Preservation of hearing in patients undergoing excision of acoustic neuromas and other cerebellopontine angle tumors

Hearing recovery after surgical resection of non-vestibular schwannoma cerebellopontine angle tumors

PURPOSE

Post-operative outcomes for hearing after resection surgery to remove cerebellopontine angle (CPA) tumors other than vestibular schwannomas (VS) are not well understood. This study presents a series of patients with significant post-operative hearing recovery, trying to define the incidence among all patients operated on for removal of non-VS CPA tumors.

METHODS

This is a retrospective observational case series of 8 patients among 69 operated on for removal of non-VS CPA tumors between 2012 and 2020. All patients had pre- and post-operative hearing measurement with pure-tone average (PTA) and speech discrimination score (SDS), according to the American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery recommendations, auditory brainstem response (ABR) measurements and imaging.

RESULTS

Six meningiomas and two lower cranial nerve schwannomas operated on with a retrosigmoid approach were included for analysis. The mean pre-operative PTA and SDS were 58 ± 20.7 dB and 13 ± 17.5%, respectively. All patients had pre-operative class D hearing and asynchronous ABRs. They all showed significant hearing recovery, with an improvement of 36 ± 22.2 dB (p = 0.0025) and 85 ± 16.9% (p = 0.0001) in PTA and SDS, respectively, with mean follow-up of 21 ± 23.5 months. Seven patients recovered to a class A hearing level and one patient to class B. The ABRs became synchronous for three patients. The incidence of auditory recovery was 13% for patients operated on with a conservative approach (n = 60).

CONCLUSION

A significant post-operative improvement in hearing could be a reasonable expectation in non-VS tumors extending into the CPA and a retrosigmoid approach should always be considered regardless of pre-operative hearing status.

Flexible endoscopic assistance in the surgical management of vestibular schwannomas

Endoscopic-assisted techniques have extensively been applied to vestibular schwannoma (VS) surgery allowing to increase the extent of resection, minimize complications, and preserve facial nerve and auditory functions. In this paper, we retrospectively analyze the effectiveness of flexible endoscope in the endoscopic-assisted retrosigmoid approach for the surgical management of VS of various sizes. The authors conducted a retrospective analysis on 32 patients who underwent combined microscopic and flexible endoscopic resection of VS of various sizes over a period of 16 months. Flexible endoscopic-assisted retrosigmoid approach was performed in all cases, and in 6 cases, flexible and rigid endoscopic control were used in combination to evaluate the differences between the two surgical instruments. The surgical results were additionally compared with a previous case series of 141 patients operated for VS of various sizes without endoscopic assistance. Gross-total resection was achieved in 84% of the cases and near-total resection was accomplished in the rest of them. Excellent or good facial nerve function was observed in all except one case with a preoperative severe facial palsy. Hearing preservation surgery (HPS) was attempted in 11 cases and accomplished in 9 (81.8%). A tumor remnant was endoscopically identified in the fundus of the IAC in all cases (100%). Endoscopic assistance increased the rate of total removal and no intrameatal residual tumor was seen at radiological follow-up. Comparative analysis with a surgical cohort of patients operated with the sole microsurgical technique showed a significative association between endoscopic assistance and intracanalicular extent of resection. Combined microsurgical and flexible endoscopic assistance provides remarkable advantages in the pursuit of maximal safe resection of VS and preservation of facial nerve and auditory functions, minimizing the risk of post-operative complications.

Angular and metric analysis of the neural structures in the cerebellopontine angle

INTRODUCTION

The cerebellopontine angle (CPA) is a subarachnoid space in the lateral aspect of the posterior fossa. In this study, we propose a complementary analysis of the CPA from the cerebellopontine fissure.

METHODS

We studied 50 hemi-cerebelli in the laboratory of neuroanatomy and included a description of the CPA anatomy from the cerebellopontine fissure and its relationship with the flocculus and the 5th, 6th, 7th, and 8th cranial nerves (CN) origins.

RESULTS

The average distance from the 5th CN to the mid-line (ML) was 19.2 mm, 6th CN to ML was 4.4 mm, 7-8 complex to ML was 15.8 mm, flocculus to ML was 20.5 mm, and flocculus to 5th CN was 11.5 mm, additionally, and the diameter of the flocculus was 9.0 mm. The angle between the vertex in the flocculus and the V CN and the medullary-pontine line was 64.8 degrees.

DISCUSSION

The most common access to the CPA is through the retrosigmoid-suboccipital region and this approach can be done with the help of an endoscope. The anatomy of origins of neural structures tends to be preserved in cases of CPA lesions.

CONCLUSION

Knowledge of the average distances between the neural structures in the cerebellar-pontine fissure and the angular relationships between these structures facilitates the use of surgical approaches such as microsurgery and endoscopy.

Factors influencing hearing preservation in acoustic tumor surgery

In patients who underwent neurosurgery for excision of acoustic tumors, we used correlation and multivariate logistic regression analysis to study relationships among nine variables thought to have value in predicting hearing preservation. These variables included auditory perceptual, auditory neurophysiologic, and imaging-related characteristics of acoustic tumor dimensions. The univariate correlations showed two general trends. The first trend demonstrated relationships among imaging-related acoustic tumor dimensions (size or porus acousticus widening) with either postoperative hearing or brainstem auditory evoked potential (BAEP) abnormalities (tumor size and postoperative hearing; porus acousticus widening and postoperative hearing; tumor size and preoperative BAEP abnormalities). The second trend reflected interrelationships among preoperative audiometric variables that were not related to postoperative hearing outcome. Logistic regression analysis of eight independent variables on the presence or absence of postoperative hearing found that porus acousticus widening was the best prognostic indicator for hearing outcome. When the porus acousticus was widened, the odds ratio was 11:1 that hearing would be lost postoperatively. Viewed as a whole, the literature on prognostic variables related to hearing preservation has been limited, almost entirely, to univariate relationships. To determine more accurately which preoperative variables have unique prognostic value, more complex multivariate, analysis procedures will be required. Additionally, standardized criteria for assessment and reporting of auditory test results are also needed.

Hearing preservation in surgery for large vestibular schwannomas

OBJECT

Hearing preservation remains a challenging problem in vestibular schwannoma (VS) surgery. The ability to preserve hearing in patients with large tumors is subject to particular difficulty. In this study, the authors focus on hearing preservation in patients harboring large VSs.

METHODS

A total of 344 consecutive patients underwent surgical removal of VSs over the past 9 years. Of these 344 cases, 195 VSs were > 20 mm in maximum cisternal diameter. Of the 195 cases, hearing preservation surgery was attempted for 54 patients who had a Class A, B, C, or D preoperative hearing level; that is, a pure tone average <or= 60 dB and speech discrimination score >or= 50% according to the Sanna/Fukushima classification. The tumors were classified as moderately large (21-30 mm based on the largest extrameatal diameter), large (31-40 mm), and giant (>or= 41 mm) according to the international criteria. The authors categorized patients with Class A, B, C, D, or E hearing (pure tone average <or= 80 dB and speech discrimination score >or= 40%) as having preserved hearing postoperatively.

RESULTS

Forty-one tumors (75.9%) were totally removed and 13 (24.1%) had near-total removal. Of the 54 patients, 29 maintained their hearing postoperatively; the overall hearing preservation rate was 53.7%. Analysis based on the preoperative hearing level showed that hearing was preserved in 14 (77.8%) of 18 cases for Class A; in 8 (47.1%) of 17 cases for Class B; in 4 (57.1%) of 7 cases for Class C; and in 3 (25.0%) of 12 cases for Class D. In addition, according to the analysis based on the tumor size, 20 (52.6%) of 38 patients with moderately large tumors retained their hearing, as did 5 (50.0%) of 10 patients with large tumors and 4 (66.7%) of 6 patients with giant tumors. Complications included 2 cases of bacterial meningitis that were cured by intravenous injection of antibiotics, 3 cases of subcutaneous CSF leakage that resolved without any surgical repair, and 1 case of temporary abducent nerve palsy. There were no deaths in this series.

CONCLUSIONS

The results indicate that successful hearing preservation surgery in large VSs is possible with meticulous technique and attention to adhesions between the tumor and the cochlear nerves.

Facial nerve function and hearing preservation after retrosigmoid excision of vestibular schwannoma: Christchurch Hospital experience with 97 patients

BACKGROUND

Between January 1988 and December 2002, 97 patients underwent surgery for excision of vestibular schwannoma via the retrosigmoid approach at Christchurch Hospital.

METHODS

A retrospective review was undertaken of the clinical notes with emphasis on facial nerve function and hearing preservation postoperatively.

RESULTS

Of patients with small and medium-sized tumours, 81% had good facial nerve function at 1 year (House-Brackmann grade 1 and grade 2), 16% had moderate function (grade 3 and grade 4) and 3% had poor function (grade 5). Of patients with large tumours, 22% had good facial function (grade 1 and grade 2), 37% had moderate function (grade 3 and grade 4) and 41% had poor function (grade 5 and grade 6). Useful postoperative hearing was preserved in 21% of the 47 patients with tumours <3 cm and useful preoperative hearing. In the last 5 years the authors have been operating in conjunction with an ear, nose and throat surgeon (PAB) trained in base-of-skull surgery. Over this period, useful hearing was preserved in 32% of patients with small and medium-sized tumours and useful preoperative hearing.

CONCLUSIONS

Tumour size was an important predictor of the postoperative facial and cochlear nerve function. The multidisciplinary approach to these tumours offers better results. These results compare well with other published series.

Intraoperative cranial nerve monitoring

The purpose of intraoperative monitoring is to preserve function and prevent injury to the nervous system at a time when clinical examination is not possible. Cranial nerves are delicate structures and are susceptible to damage by mechanical trauma or ischemia during intracranial and extracranial surgery. A number of reliable electrodiagnostic techniques, including nerve conduction studies, electromyography, and the recording of evoked potentials have been adapted to the study of cranial nerve function during surgery. A growing body of evidence supports the utility of intraoperative monitoring of cranial nerve nerves during selected surgical procedures.

Facial nerve electromyography and other cranial nerve monitoring

Cranial nerves can be damaged during a variety of surgical procedures. The function of the cranial nerves can be monitored during surgery with electromyography (EMG), compound nerve and muscle action potentials (MAP), and auditory evoked potentials (AEP). We report important technical considerations that allow reliable recordings of these modalities during surgery, the criteria for determining a significant change in these electrophysiologic measures of function, the application of these techniques to specific surgical procedures, and the data that support the utility of cranial nerve monitoring.

Neurotopographic considerations in the microsurgical treatment of small acoustic neurinomas

OBJECT

The authors studied the relationships between tumor size, location, and topographic position relative to the intact facial nerve bundles in acoustic neurinomas to determine the influence of these factors on hearing preservation postoperatively. Consistent topographic relationships were found.

METHODS

Four hundred fifty-two patients with acoustic neurinoma treated via a retrosigmoid approach were analyzed with respect to hearing preservation and facial nerve function. One hundred fifteen tumors were identified as small and were categorized as Grades I and II. Patients with Grade I tumors, that is, purely intracanalicular lesions, all had good hearing preoperatively, defined by a less than 50-dB pure tone average and 50% speech discrimination score. All 14 Grade I tumors were removed, resulting in preservation of the patient's hearing by these criteria. There were no particular topographic anatomical relationships associated with these tumors that affected hearing preservation. Grade II tumors, defined as those protruding into the cerebellopontine angle without contacting the brainstem, were found in 101 patients and were divided by size into two grades: IIA (< 1 cm) and IIB (1-1.8 cm). In 90 patients with Grade IIA tumors, 72 (89%) of 81 who had preserved hearing preoperatively maintained it postoperatively, and in the 11 patients with Grade IIB tumors, six of whom had good hearing preoperatively, four (67%) had preserved hearing postoperatively. Six morphological types were identified based on their neurotopographic relationships to the elements of the vestibulocochlear nerve.

CONCLUSIONS

Hearing preservation postsurgery by tumor type was as follows: 1A, 92%; 1B, 88%; 1C, 100%; 2A, 83%; 2B, 92%; and 3, 57%. Combined, this represents a hearing preservation rate of 87% after surgical treatment of Grade II acoustic neurinomas. Full nerve function was maintained in 88% of patients with anatomically preserved facial nerves in both Grade I and II tumors. The remaining 12% of patients retained partial function of the facial nerve. Two patients in the series lost anatomical integrity of the nerve due to surgery.

Management of 1000 vestibular schwannomas (acoustic neuromas): hearing function in 1000 tumor resections

OBJECTIVE

The realistic chances of hearing preservation and the comparability of international results on hearing preservation in complete microsurgical vestibular schwannoma resections were the focus of this study in a large patient population treated by uniform principles.

METHODS

One thousand vestibular schwannomas were operated on at Nordstadt Neurosurgical Department, from 1978 to 1993, by the senior surgeon (MS). There were 1000 tumors in 962 patients, i.e., 880 patients with unilateral tumors and 82 patients operated on for bilateral tumors in neurofibromatosis-2 (120 cases). Preservation of the cochlear nerve was attempted whenever possible. The audiometric data were analyzed by the Nordstadt classification system and graded in steps of 30 dB by audiometry and in steps of 10 to 30% by speech discrimination; for comparability, the data were also evaluated by the criteria of Gardner, Shelton, and House, and they were assessed in relation to the Hannover tumor extension grading system.

RESULTS

Anatomic cochlear nerve preservation was achieved in 682 of 1000 cases (68%), as well as in some preoperatively deaf patients, a very few of whom regained some hearing. Of a total of 732 cases with some preoperative hearing, anatomic cochlear nerve preservation was achieved in 580 cases (79%) and functional cochlear nerve preservation in 289 (39.5%); analysis over time revealed an actual preservation rate of 47% in the most recent 200 cases. Specific factors, such as gender, tumor extension, preoperative hearing quality, and symptom duration, were investigated for their predictive value for hearing preservation. Male gender, small to medium tumor size (mainly extending within the cerebellopontine cistern; Classes T2 and T3), good to moderate hearing (up to 40-dB loss), and short duration of hypoacusis (< 1.5 yr) or of vestibular disturbances (< 0.7 yr) were advantageous factors, with chances of hearing preservation between 47 and 88%.

CONCLUSION

Functional cochlear nerve preservation in complete microsurgical resection should belong to the contemporary standard of treatment goals.

The retrosigmoid approach to acoustic neurinomas: technical, strategic, and future concepts

The retrosigmoid approach continues to be the most widely employed strategy for the surgical resection of acoustic neuromas. The results with respect to facial nerve function are uniformly reported to be quite high. The great emphasis currently is upon improving results with regard to the conservation of useful hearing. This paper focuses on the anatomical and strategic surgical factors that we currently consider to be important to maximizing our current results. The future aspects of this trend toward improved success in conserving hearing in these patients is also discussed.

Hearing preservation in vestibular schwannoma surgery: what factors influence outcome?

The goals in the management of patients with vestibular schwannomas have changed drastically over the past few decades, with preservation of useful hearing representing the newest challenge. The true incidence of preserved useful hearing, however, has become clouded by a lack of uniformity in reporting results. The authors have analyzed 56 consecutive cases, in which directed attempts were made to preserve hearing on the involved side, to understand what factors play a major role in postoperative hearing preservation. Of the 56 cases reviewed, there were 46 patients who had "good" preoperative hearing (pure tone average < 50 dB; speech discrimination score > 50%). We found that, in this group of patients, if the tumor was less than 2 cm in diameter from pons to petrous, there was a 52% (16 of 31 patients) chance of preserving good hearing and if the tumor was 1 cm or less, the chances increased to 83%. Factors such as preoperative hearing status, tumor size and location, tumor consistency, and preoperative and intraoperative brainstem auditory evoked potentials are discussed in detail as they relate to postoperative outcome.

Patterns of evoked otoacoustic emissions associated with acoustic neuromas

Evoked otoacoustic emissions (OAEs) are assumed to reflect healthy outer hair cell function. Over the past few years, evoked OAEs have been shown to be useful as indicators of cochlear hearing loss. Because basic studies have shown that OAEs are extremely sensitive to cochlear anoxia and hypoxia, as well as to the adverse effects of many inner ear diseases, it is possible that these objective tests can provide some insight into the fundamental basis of the hearing loss exhibited by patients with acoustic neuromas. The primary aim of the present study was to examine the effects of acoustic neuromas on the amplitudes of evoked OAEs and to compare these findings with tumor-induced hearing levels. To this end, tests of behavioral audiometry, distortion-product otoacoustic emissions and transiently evoked otoacoustic emissions were performed on 44 patients with verified acoustic neuromas. The results demonstrated that the majority of ears with acoustic neuromas displayed one of two distinct patterns of evoked OAEs: a cochlear pattern or a noncochlear pattern. Although behavioral hearing thresholds were higher with larger tumors, OAE levels exhibited no clear relationship to tumor size. The present findings support the notion that acoustic neuromas may cause hearing impairment according to two types of influence that act at different levels of the peripheral auditory system. The tumor's cochlear effect on evoked OAE activity is most likely caused by an indirectly mediated compromise of the organ of Corti's vascular supply. It is probable that the direct pressure of the tumor on the eighth cranial nerve is responsible for the observed noncochlear effects.

Hearing preservation in vestibular schwannoma surgery: fact or fantasy?

This study reviews 57 papers dealing with the issue of hearing preservation in vestibular schwannoma surgery published in otolaryngologic and neurosurgical literature between the years 1977 and 1994. The authors', in this review, have made an attempt to verify whether the claims of hearing preservation are real, whether there is a price to be paid in terms of morbidity and whether there are univocal criteria for reporting results. The review shows that there is a wide disarray in reporting hearing results and the claims of hearing preservation are often unreal and misleading. On retabulating the results of a few series according to the minimal prerequisites for normal hearing (PTA < or = 30 dB and SDS > or = 70 per cent) and according to other various commonly reported criteria, it became evident that rates of hearing preservation differed a lot depending upon criteria. While any measurable hearing could be preserved in many cases, only a few had normal hearing preserved.

Preoperative and Postoperative Auditory and Facial Nerve Function in Cerebellopontine Angle Meningiomas

Preoperative and postoperative facial nerve and auditory function were reviewed retrospectively in 13 cases of cerebellopontine angle meningiomas. According to their location within the posterior fossa and with special reference to the internal auditory canal, they were classified into a premeatal and a retromeatal group. All the tumors were removed by an otoneurosurgical team by use of a retrosigmoid approach. Postoperative results (1 year after operation) were compared within the two groups with respect to preservation of hearing (normal hearing in 31% and preservation of preoperative hearing in 69% of the cases) and facial nerve function (no or mild postoperative impairment in 69% of the cases). Both preoperative and postoperative impairment of facial nerve and auditory function prevailed in the premeatal group. For preservation of vital vascular and central nervous structures, subtotal resection with consecutive fractionated radiation therapy had to be performed in 30% of the cases. Our results provide substantial evidence that in cerebellopontine angle meningiomas a precise preoperative study of tumor location will assist in improving individual operative strategy and thus postoperative functional results.

Hearing preservation in acoustic tumour surgery

900 acoustic neurinomas were removed by the suboccipital approach at Nordstadt Neurosurgical Department from 1978 to 1992 by the same surgeon (M. S.). While 247 patients were deaf on the involved side before surgery, there were 653 patients ears with some preoperative hearing. Preservation of the cochlear nerve was always attempted, and the overall-rate of hearing preservation was 38% (249 of 653), regardless of pre- and postoperative quality of hearing or of tumour sizes. In small tumour sizes below 3 cm of diameter preservation rate was 51%, in large tumours above 3 cm of diameter it was 22%. A classification system of hearing quality was made up considering pure tone audiometric hearing losses (PTA HL) at 1 to 3 kHz, and individual maximum speech discrimination scores. The usefulness of the preserved hearing is further evaluated considering the quality of hearing in the contralateral ear, and by application of other classification schemes. Presentation of the surgical strategies and their refinements by personal experience provide the base for discussion questioning whether and how further progress may still be anticipated.

Hearing preservation in acoustic neuroma surgery: value of monitoring cochlear nerve action potentials

This study reviews the hearing results in 80 consecutive patients who underwent complete removal of histologically proven acoustic neuromas by use of the suboccipital approach. Of these, 56 patients had successful monitoring of cochlear compound action potentials; 20 were not monitored because their surgery predated monitoring; and 4 had unsuccessful monitoring. A significant difference was found in hearing preservation rates between the group in whom compound action potential monitoring was performed and those in whom monitoring was either unavailable or failed (p = 0.02). Overall, 38% (30 of 80) had preserved hearing. There were 51 patients in whom the click threshold for the cochlear compound action potential was measured during surgery. Twenty-one patients had a threshold shift of 20 dB or less, 15 (71%) of these retained serviceable hearing (speech reception threshold < or = 50 dB; speech discrimination score > or = 60%). Of 12 patients in whom the threshold shift was 30 to 60 dB, none had serviceable hearing after surgery. The click threshold shift was predictive of a significant postoperative hearing change (p < 0.001).

Full recovery from deafness after removal of a large acoustic neurinoma associated with neurofibromatosis 2: case report

The first case of full recovery from deafness after radical intracapsular removal of a large acoustic neurinoma, more than 4 cm in diameter, is reported. The patient, a 17-year-old woman, had multiple intracranial and intraspinal tumors in addition to bilateral acoustic neurinomas. Radical intracapsular removal is a useful technique to preserve nerves in patients with large acoustic neurinoma. When identifiable evoked potentials are preserved in brain stem auditory evoked potential, hearing preservation should be tried despite preoperative hearing level.

Preservation of hearing in surgery for acoustic neuromas

Preservation of hearing was attempted in 161 cases of histologically confirmed acoustic neuroma removed by the senior author between January 1, 1970, and September 30, 1991. There were 136 patients with unilateral tumors; 22 patients had bilateral tumors (neurofibromatosis 2) and underwent a total of 25 procedures. Hearing was initially preserved in 35% of patients with unilateral tumors and in 44% of those with bilateral tumors. Results are reported in terms of pre- and postoperative pure tone average and speech discrimination scores. Surgical access to the tumor was obtained via middle cranial fossa and suboccipital approaches. The latter has been used more often over the past 5 years because of a lower associated incidence of transient facial paresis. Persistent postoperative headaches have been the most common complication following the suboccipital approach. The results of preoperative brain-stem auditory evoked response (BAER) studies were useful in predicting the outcome of hearing preservation attempts. Patients with intact BAER waveform morphology and normal or delayed latencies had a higher probability of hearing preservation in comparison to those with abnormal preoperative BAER morphology.

Preservation of cochlear nerve function in acoustic neurinoma surgery

A total of 55 cases with unilateral acoustic neurinoma which were operated on by the lateral suboccipital approach was studied to elucidate factors which influence postoperative hearing acuity. We analyzed several factors: preoperative hearing level, tumour size, tumour consistency (cystic or solid), and anatomical location of the cochlear nerve. The size of the tumours ranged from 1.2 to 5.8 cm in diameter. Thirty of 55 cases (55%) preoperatively had remaining cochlear function. The smaller the size of tumour, the higher was the preoperative hearing level excepting those tumours with a diameter of 5 cm or greater, which had relatively good hearing and often contained large cysts. As to the consistency of the tumours, 41 were solid and 14 were cystic, where 19 (46%) and 11 (79%) cases had had preoperative hearing, respectively. Anatomical continuity of the cochlear nerve was maintained at surgery in 15 of 30 cases with preoperatively remaining hearing; cochlear function was preserved after surgery in 9 of the 15 cases. It was located counter-clockwise (caudally) to the facial nerve at an angle of 50 degrees on average when they were projected on the right side. The distance or interrelation between the two nerves had no bearing on postoperative hearing preservation. Postoperatively, hearing acuity was improved in 6 cases (20%) with a mean value of 5.6 dB, unchanged in 3 (10%), and deteriorated in 21 (70%) among the 30 cases with remaining preoperative-hearing. When the tumour was less than 2 cm or cystic, better hearing preservation was expected.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Late course of preserved hearing and tinnitus after acoustic neurilemoma surgery

The late course of preserved hearing and tinnitus following retrosigmoid transmeatal surgery for acoustic neurilemoma is reported. Over a period of 5 years, useful hearing was preserved in 15 patients after preservation was attempted in 42 patients. In five patients the hearing was better than the preoperative level; in three it was worse. Three patients developed delayed worsening and fluctuations of hearing in the surgically treated ear during a median follow-up period of 2 1/2 years. While the exact reason for such worsening was not clear in two patients, in one patient it appeared that the muscle graft placed in the internal auditory canal after tumor resection resulted in fibrosis and compromise of the cochlear nerve. The causes of delayed worsening of hearing in the absence of tumor recurrence are analyzed, and possible treatment and methods of prevention of worsening are suggested. In six patients, tinnitus persisted after surgery in the ear with successful preservation of hearing, but hearing was not worsened and the tinnitus was not bothersome to the patient. In one patient with preoperative tinnitus, hearing was not preserved and tinnitus persisted sufficiently to necessitate reexploration and cochlear nerve section.

Hearing preservation in acoustic neurinoma surgery

The authors have reviewed hearing results obtained in 99 patients operated on via the suboccipital approach for acoustic neurinoma, who were not deaf prior to surgery (pure tone average less than 70 dB). Tumor size was less than 10 mm in four cases, 10 to 19 mm in 26 cases, 20 to 29 mm in 39 cases, and 30 mm or greater in 30 cases. Removal was macroscopically complete in 92 cases and incomplete in seven, including four cases with bilateral acoustic neurofibromatosis. Hearing was preserved in 29 patients (29.3%), of whom 23 had neurinomas smaller than 30 mm and six had tumors exceeding 30 mm in size. Postoperative hearing was good in eight cases (four with neurinomas less than 20 mm and four with neurinomas greater than 20 mm), serviceable in four cases (three with neurinomas less than 20 mm and one with a tumor greater than 30 mm), and poor in 17 cases (eight with neurinomas less than 20 mm and nine with tumors greater than 20 mm). Fifty-seven patients underwent intraoperative brain-stem auditory evoked potential monitoring: the rate of hearing preservation was found to be higher in this group than in the 42 without monitoring (p less than 0.05). A statistical study using stepwise regression analysis showed that the two preoperative factors most significantly associated with postoperative hearing preservation are a good auditory level for low frequencies measured by pure tone audiometry and a small-sized tumor. Overall results indicate that, even if hearing is more easily preserved when the neurinoma is small and the preoperative auditory condition is good, the surgeon should try to save hearing in all patients who have preserved hearing before surgery.

The fate of tumour rests following removal of acoustic neuromas: an MRI Gd-DTPA study

The fate of capsular fragments left attached to vital structures at the time of otherwise total tumour removal was studied in 14 of 21 such patients who underwent acoustic neuroma surgery. Imaging using magnetic resonance Gd-DTPA at post-operative intervals of 6 months-12 years (mean 70 months) showed evidence of persistent tumour in half the patients. None of the patients had developed new symptoms and computed tomography had failed to demonstrate tumour recurrence. Persistence of the tumour was more likely if the residual fragments were not cauterized at the time of operation. Four of the seven persisting tumour rests showed evidence of gradual enlargement. The implications for patient management, particularly if an attempt is made to preserve hearing, are discussed.

Preoperative findings and hearing preservation in acoustic neuroma surgery

For the purpose of clarifying whether or not the possibility of hearing preservation can be predicted preoperatively, we compared clinical characteristics and preoperative test results between hearing preserved and hearing unpreserved patients. Based on an analysis of this study, we conclude that duration of symptoms, ABR findings and caloric test results, in addition to hearing level, speech discrimination score and tumor size should be considered as prognostic signs of hearing preservation. Although all factors do not suggest a definite possibility of hearing preservation, candidates for hearing preservation surgery should be selected according to these prognostic factors.

Hearing improvement after acoustic tumor removal

Hearing improvement after removal of an acoustic tumor is an uncommon occurrence. Hearing improvement was observed in 8.5% of acoustic tumor removals performed using the middle fossa approach in an attempt to preserve hearing. Improvement in speech discrimination occurred most frequently and was of greatest magnitude compared with changes in the speech reception threshold or pure-tone average. No preoperative factors were predictive of postoperative hearing improvement. Findings support the conclusion that candidates for hearing preservation surgery should be chosen on the merits of their existing preoperative hearing and not on the basis of anticipated improvement.

Petrous meningiomas: a review of seventeen cases

Seventeen patients with petrous meningiomas managed at St. Michael's Hospital, during the years 1973-1987, were retrospectively reviewed. There were 15 females and 2 males; their ages ranged from 42 to 68 years (mean age: 53 years). The clinical presentation most commonly included headache and eighth cranial nerve dysfunction; the average duration of symptoms was 6 years (3 month-27 years). Computed tomography was performed in 15 cases. The mean tumour size was 2.5 centimeters (0.5-4 cm). The most common site of tumour origin was at or medial to the porus acousticus. Meningioma was suspected preoperatively in 10 of the 15 patients who had preoperative CT scans. Complete excision was obtained in 12 cases. There were no operative deaths after initial resections. Postoperative morbidity included worsening of pre-existing hearing loss in six patients, transient facial nerve palsies in six, permanent facial nerve palsies in four and new facial or corneal hypesthesia in three. Two patients developed cerebrospinal fluid fistulae. Tumour recurrence occurred into two patients in whom a complete resection was anticipated. Also, in two patients with incompletely resected tumours second operations were required. Fourteen patients are alive, 13 of whom care for themselves independently. The average follow-up was 5 years (6 months-9 years). It seems appropriate to recommend initial radical surgical excision of these benign tumours, where possible, in order to prevent tumour recurrence.

Preservation of hearing in neurofibromatosis 2

Preservation of hearing in the neurofibromatosis 2 (central neurofibromatosis) patient has been infrequently documented. This goal can be attained in selected patients and should be more frequently accomplished in the future with improved diagnostic capabilities and improved surgical techniques. We report three patients in whom this elusive goal has been accomplished.

Comparisons of the clinical and radiological features and surgical management of posterior fossa meningiomas and acoustic neuromas

Next to acoustic neuromas, meningiomas are the most common benign tumour of the posterior fossa. This paper reviews the personal experience of one of the authors with the management of 26 posterior fossa meningiomas and 212 acoustic neuromas. The aim was to compare the clinical and radiological features of these two types of posterior fossa tumours to determine whether they can be differentiated preoperatively. The study also aimed at analysing the surgical treatment of posterior fossa meningiomas. The results showed that posterior fossa meningiomas can usually be differentiated from acoustic neuromas on the basis of clinical and radiological features. Preoperative differentiation aids surgical management, especially for selection of surgical approach. In most instances, posterior fossa meningiomas can be totally resected with minimal morbidity and mortality.

Surgery for acoustic neurinoma. An analysis of 100 translabyrinthine operations

A consecutive series of 100 translabyrinthine operations for removal of acoustic neurinoma is reported. Complete tumor removal was achieved in 97% of cases. There were three perioperative deaths, and the postoperative morbidity rate was low. The facial nerve was preserved anatomically in 82% of patients. Preoperative facial weakness and tumor size larger than 2.5 cm were predictive of poor facial recovery. In patients with an intact nerve but complete facial palsy 1 week after surgery, electroneuronography was a good predictor of the final facial outcome and may influence the timing of rehabilitative procedures. With the exception of patients who have small tumors and good speech discrimination (where a suboccipital approach may preserve hearing acuity), the translabyrinthine operation is the procedure of choice for removal of acoustic neurinomas in patients who have normal hearing in the contralateral ear.

Neurophysiologic monitoring in posterior fossa surgery. II. BAEP-waves I and V and preservation of hearing

Of 135 cases operated upon for posterior fossa lesions 103 showed preoperative hearing. In 34 acoustic neurinomas 14 had postoperative initially preserved hearing, in 20 microvascular decompressions 19 had preserved postoperative hearing and in 49 other lesions 5 lost hearing. The relationship between preservation of hearing and the preservation or loss of brainstem auditory evoked potentials (BAEP) waves I and V in the three groups of namely: acoustic neurinomas, microvascular decompressions and other lesions are presented. It is noteworthy that only patients with preserved waves I or V are suitable candidates for intraoperative monitoring. The loss of wave V is usually associated with hearing loss (10 out of 13 cases). But hearing loss is also possible despite preservation of wave I (3 out of 60) or despite preservation of wave V (2 out of 68). The predictive value of the preservation of waves I and V is not an absolute one, but it strongly suggests preserved hearing postoperatively. The dilemma remains that once waves I or V are lost during surgery there is no certainty as to postoperative hearing. If wave V recovers after an initial loss, hearing is usually preserved but not in all cases. In wave I amplitude changes alone were more frequent than in wave V, where latency changes alone were more frequently observed. Particular surgical manoeuvres could be found to be often associated with a wave deterioration. Hearing preservation could never be achieved in patients who already preoperatively had no BAEP. It is concluded that BAEP monitoring is of great value in surgery for microvascular decompression and cerebello-pontine-angle (CPA) tumours with preserved hearing.

Facial nerve recovery following acoustic neuroma surgery

A series of 76 consecutive patients undergoing unilateral acoustic neuroma excision is reported. Preoperative facial weaknesses and a tumour larger than 2.5 cm were predictive factors of poor facial nerve recovery, re-emphasising the need to detect and remove these tumours at an early stage. Electroneuronography performed around one week after surgery appears to be a good indicator of the likelihood of recovery in facial nerves which are anatomically intact, but which show no function at that stage. Multiple rehabilitative procedures are often required when inadequate function or poor cosmetic results are obtained. Primary nerve repair or facial-hypoglossal anastomosis provide better rehabilitative results than dynamic and static procedures.

Preservation of hearing in acoustic tumor surgery: audiologic indicators

Preservation of hearing in patients with acoustic nerve tumors can be a goal when tumor size is small and residual hearing is intact. Overall success rates for preservation have been reported to be 20% to 40%. The overall success rate in this series is 30.7%. However, indicators of intact auditory brain stem response (waves I-III-V), good speech discrimination score, and intact acoustic (stapedial) reflex were associated with a 68.2% rate of success. Thus, a comprehensive audiologic evaluation is a guideline for selecting and counselling patients with acoustic tumors before hearing preservation procedures.

Audiological findings after stereotactic radiosurgery in acoustic neurinomas

Stereotactic radiosurgery was used in the treatment of 126 patients with acoustic neurinomas up to 30 mm in diameter from 1969 to 1984. Adequate follow-up data (mean follow-up period 4.7 years) were available for 111 (116 ears) of these 126 patients; of these 111 patients, 64 (65 ears) had a pure-tone threshold of less than 90 dB before the treatment and were followed up audiologically. Preserved hearing was found in 26% of the ears one year postoperatively. Shrinkage of the tumour was obtained in 44% and arrest of its growth in 42%. There was no mortality related to the radiosurgical treatment. Transitory facial weakness was noted in 15% of the patients (3% in 1983-84). Eighteen per cent of the patients had some, usually transitory, trigeminal dysfunction. The stapedius reflex threshold was improved in 13 ears (20%). In one patient the audiological tests became pathological in the contralateral ear during growth of a new tumour. Initially the stapedius reflex threshold was elevated, and 11 months later the BRA pattern also became abnormal.

Electrophysiological monitoring during acoustic neuroma and other posterior fossa surgery

Techniques used to monitor the function of the seventh and eighth cranial nerves during acoustic neuroma and other posterior fossa surgery are reviewed. The auditory brainstem response (ABR), electrocochleogram (ECochG) and direct recording from the auditory nerve (CNAP) were compared. The best technique is the ECochG, although in many cases, the CNAP should be used as a back-up technique. The CNAP is especially useful for the identification of the auditory nerve. Both can provide real-time feedback on the physiological integrity of the auditory nerve. The ABR may be helpful in monitoring brainstem function. For some procedures, optimal monitoring requires the combined recording of all three techniques. Monopolar constant-voltage intracranial stimulation of the facial nerve is helpful for the identification and preservation of the facial nerve. Audio monitoring of spontaneous electromyographic activity provides real-time feedback on the effect of surgical manipulation of the nerve. Monitoring of ephaptic transmission in the facial nerve during microvascular decompression for hemifacial spasm aids in the identification of the offending vessel.

Intra-operative electrocochleography to monitor cochlear potentials during acoustic neuroma excision

Intra-operative electrocochleography (ECochG) was used in an attempt to monitor the action potential of the cochlear nerve during acoustic neuroma surgery in 14 patients with useful pre-operative hearing. Five patients had ECochG potentials preserved and yet only three could hear when tested audiometrically later. Of those losing the potentials intra-operatively all were subsequently deaf and the pattern of waveform loss allowed determination of the probable cause of hearing loss. Complete excision of the tumour was achieved in each case regardless of the ultimate effect on the AP as it was not felt justified to risk subsequent recurrence. In common with other studies one of the best prognostic factors for these preservation of hearing was found to be the size of the tumour.

The state of tinnitus after inner ear surgery

A retrospective study of several procedures--for either treatment of vertigo or resection of acoustic neuromas--was performed to determine their effect on tinnitus. Subjective ratings of the state of tinnitus (resolution, improvement, maintenance, or deterioration) were obtained by questionnaire. Surgical procedures performed for correction of vertigo frequently alter tinnitus. In general, procedures that conserve hearing--namely, retrolabyrinthine vestibular neurectomy (RVN), middle fossa vestibular neurectomy (MFVN), and endolymphatic shunt procedures (ELS)--have a 50% to 65% chance of helping relieve tinnitus and up to a 22% chance of worsening tinnitus. When there is no serviceable hearing, cochleovestibular neurectomy (CVN) offers the best cure rate for tinnitus (76%) and the least chance of worsening tinnitus (3%). When hearing is minimal and the patient complains of tinnitus, a CVN--rather than a labyrinthectomy--should be recommended. However, when useful hearing is present, a CVN is not usually recommended for relief of tinnitus, since the actual cure rates are only 35%. When vertigo is not a complaint, there is currently no surgical procedure known that can be recommended for the treatment of tinnitus.

Hearing preservation after acoustic neuroma surgery with intraoperative direct eighth cranial nerve monitoring: Part II. A classification of results

Since the advent of brainstem auditory evoked response audiometry and computerized tomography, small acoustic neuromas are more frequently found. Often the patient has serviceable hearing, which we would like to preserve during complete tumor removal. Since 1978, sixteen patients with acoustic neuromas have been operated upon through the retrosigmoid suboccipital approach, with the goal of hearing preservation. In 1983, we began using intraoperative direct eighth nerve monitoring, which produced a rapid assessment of cochlear nerve function during the excision of small acoustic neuromas. The tumors varied in size from intracanalicular lesions to one lesion with a 3.0 cm protrusion medial to the porus acousticus. In eight of sixteen cases, intraoperative monitoring was used, and in four of the patients hearing was preserved. In eight cases, intraoperative monitoring was not used, and hearing was preserved in only two patients. The overall success rate--in total tumor removal with hearing preservation--was 37%. Hearing was preserved in six of eight patients who had tumors which measured less than 1.5 cm. In this group of cases, two of the patients had a Class I good hearing result (PTA 0 to 30 dB and 70 to 100% discrimination), one patient had Class III nonserviceable hearing, (PTA 65 to 75 dB and 25 to 45% discrimination), and three patients had Class IV poor hearing, (PTA 80 to 100 dB and 0 to 20% discrimination). We found that continuous monitoring of direct eighth-nerve-evoked action potentials were extremely valuable and rapidly indicated reversible cochlear nerve trauma.

Acoustic neuromas: management of 204 cases

This paper reviews the author's personal experience with the management of 204 patients with the clinical diagnosis of acoustic neuroma. Craniotomy was performed in 181 of these cases, all of whom were proven to have acoustic neuromas. The remaining 23 cases with the clinical diagnosis of acoustic neuroma did not have tumour surgery, mainly because of advanced age or concurrent disease, although some required shunts for hydrocephalus. The management of acoustic neuromas including the selection of surgical approach depends upon the patient's age and general health, the size and growth direction of the tumour, previous surgical attempts at removal, and the presence of hydrocephalus, a contralateral tumour, and serviceable hearing. Twenty-nine other cases with the clinical diagnosis of acoustic neuroma underwent craniotomy: 20 had petrous or tentorial meningiomas encroaching on the porus acousticus or growing in the internal auditory canal, six had neuromas of the seventh cranial nerve and three had arachnoiditis occluding the internal auditory canal.