Evidence for Highly Variable, Region-Specific Patterns of T-Cell Epitope Mutations Accumulating in Mycobacterium tuberculosis Strains

Attenuated but immunostimulatory Mycobacterium tuberculosis variant bovis strain Ravenel shows variation in T cell epitopes

Tuberculosis, caused by Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex (MTBC) organisms, affects a range of humans and animals globally. Mycobacterial pathogenesis involves manipulation of the host immune system, partially through antigen presentation. Epitope sequences across the MTBC are evolutionarily hyperconserved, suggesting their recognition is advantageous for the bacterium. Mycobacterium tuberculosis var. bovis (MBO) strain Ravenel is an isolate known to provoke a robust immune response in cattle, but typically fails to produce lesions and persist. Unlike attenuated MBO BCG strains that lack the critical RD1 genomic region, Ravenel is classic-type MBO structurally, suggesting genetic variation is responsible for defective pathogenesis. This work explores variation in epitope sequences in MBO Ravenel by whole genome sequencing, and contrasts such variation against a fully virulent clinical isolate, MBO strain 10-7428. Validated MTBC epitopes (n = 4818) from the Immune Epitope Database were compared to their sequences in MBO Ravenel and MBO 10-7428. Ravenel yielded 3 modified T cell epitopes, in genes rpfB, argC, and rpoA. These modifications were predicted to have little effect on protein stability. In contrast, T cells epitopes in 10-7428 were all WT. Considering T cell epitope hyperconservation across MTBC variants, these altered MBO Ravenel epitopes support their potential contribution to overall strain attenuation. The affected genes may provide clues on basic pathogenesis, and if so, be feasible targets for reverse vaccinology.

A Low-Prevalence Single-Nucleotide Polymorphism in the Sensor Kinase PhoR in Mycobacterium tuberculosis Suppresses Its Autophosphatase Activity and Reduces Pathogenic Fitness: Implications in Evolutionary Selection

The genome sequencing of Mycobacterium tuberculosis, the causative organism of tuberculosis, has significantly improved our understanding of the mechanisms that drive the establishment of infection and disease progression. Several clinical strains of M. tuberculosis exhibit single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs), the implications of which are only beginning to be understood. Here, we examined the impact of a specific polymorphism in PhoR, the sensor kinase of the PhoPR two-component system. Biochemical analysis revealed reduced autophosphatase/ATPase activity, which led to enhanced downstream gene expression. We complemented M. tuberculosis H37Ra with the wild-type and mutant phoPR genes and characterized the strains in a cell line infection model. We provide an explanation for the low prevalence of the SNP in clinical strains (∼1%), as the mutation causes a survival disadvantage in the host cells. The study provides a rare example of selection of a signaling node under competing evolutionary forces, wherein a biochemically superior mutation aids bacterial adaptation within-host but has low fitness for infection and hence is not selected. Our study highlights the importance of accounting for such SNPs to test therapeutic and co-therapeutic methods to combat TB.

Evolutionary Genetics of Mycobacterium tuberculosis and HIV-1: "The Tortoise and the Hare"

The already enormous burden caused by Mycobacterium tuberculosis and Human Immunodeficiency Virus type 1 (HIV-1) alone is aggravated by co-infection. Despite obvious differences in the rate of evolution comparing these two human pathogens, genetic diversity plays an important role in the success of both. The extreme evolutionary dynamics of HIV-1 is in the basis of a robust capacity to evade immune responses, to generate drug-resistance and to diversify the population-level reservoir of M group viral subtypes. Compared to HIV-1 and other retroviruses, M. tuberculosis generates minute levels of genetic diversity within the host. However, emerging whole-genome sequencing data show that the M. tuberculosis complex contains at least nine human-adapted phylogenetic lineages. This level of genetic diversity results in differences in M. tuberculosis interactions with the host immune system, virulence and drug resistance propensity. In co-infected individuals, HIV-1 and M. tuberculosis are likely to co-colonize host cells. However, the evolutionary impact of the interaction between the host, the slowly evolving M. tuberculosis bacteria and the HIV-1 viral "mutant cloud" is poorly understood. These evolutionary dynamics, at the cellular niche of monocytes/macrophages, are also discussed and proposed as a relevant future research topic in the context of single-cell sequencing.

Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex and human coadaptation: a two-way street complicating host susceptibility to TB

For centuries, the Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex (MTBC) has infected numerous populations, both human and non-human, causing symptomatic tuberculosis (TB) in some hosts. Research investigating the MTBC and how it has evolved with its host over time is sparse and has not resulted in many significant findings. There are even fewer studies investigating adaptation of the human host susceptibility to TB and these have largely focused on genome-wide association and candidate gene association studies. However, results emanating from these association studies are rarely replicated and appear to be population specific. It is, therefore, necessary to relook at the approach taken to investigate the relationship between the MTBC and the human host. Understanding that the evolution of the pathogen is coupled to the evolution of the host might be the missing link needed to effectively investigate their relationship. We hypothesize that this knowledge will bolster future efforts in combating the disease.