All Patients With Common Variable Immunodeficiency Disorders (CVID) Should Be Routinely Offered Diagnostic Genetic Testing

The autoimmune rheumatological presentation of Common Variable Immunodeficiency Disorders with an overview of genetic testing

Primary immunodeficiency Disorders (PIDS) are rare, mostly monogenetic conditions which can present to a number of specialties. Although infections predominate in most PIDs, some individuals can manifest autoimmune or inflammatory sequelae as their initial clinical presentation. Identifying patients with PIDs can be challenging, as some can present later in life. This is often seen in patients with Common Variable Immunodeficiency Disorders (CVID), where symptoms can begin in the sixth or even seventh decades of life. Some patients with PIDs including CVID can initially present to rheumatologists with autoimmune musculoskeletal manifestations. It is imperative for these patients to be identified promptly as immunosuppression could lead to life-threatening opportunistic infections in these immunocompromised individuals. These risks could be mitigated by prior treatment with subcutaneous or intravenous (SCIG/IVIG) immunoglobulin replacement or prophylactic antibiotics. Importantly, many of these disorders have an underlying genetic defect. Individualized treatments may be available for the specific mutation, which may obviate or mitigate the need for hazardous broad-spectrum immunosuppression. Identification of the genetic defect has profound implications not only for the patient but also for affected family members, who may be at risk of symptomatic disease following an environmental trigger such as a viral infection. Finally, there may be clinical clues to the underlying PID, such as recurrent infections, the early presentation of severe or multiple autoimmune disorders, as well as a relevant family history. Early referral to a clinical immunologist will facilitate appropriate diagnostic evaluation and institution of treatment such as SCIG/IVIG immunoglobulin replacement. This review comprises three sections; an overview of PIDs, focusing on CVID, secondly genetic testing of PIDs and finally the clinical presentation of these disorders to rheumatologists.

Common Variable Immunodeficiency

Common variable immunodeficiency (CVID) is the most common primary immune deficiency characterized by impaired production of specific immunoglobulin. The clinical manifestations are heterogeneous including acquisition of recurrent bacterial infections after a period of wellness, lymphoproliferation, autoimmunity, pulmonary disease, liver disease, enteropathy, granulomas, and an increased risk of malignancy. The etiology of CVID is largely unknown, with a considerable number of patients having an underlying genetic defect causing immune dysregulation. The antibody deficiency found in CVID is treated with lifelong immunoglobulin therapy, which is preventative of the majority of infections when given regularly.

Challenges for gene editing in common variable immunodeficiency disorders: Current and future prospects

The original CRISPR Cas9 gene editing system and subsequent innovations offers unprecedented opportunities to correct severe genetic defects including those causing Primary Immunodeficiencies (PIDs). Common Variable Immunodeficiency Disorders (CVID) are the most frequent symptomatic PID in adults and children. Unlike many other PIDs, patients meeting CVID criteria do not have a definable genetic defect and cannot be considered to have an inborn error of immunity (IEI). Patients with a CVID phenotype carrying a causative mutation are deemed to have a CVID-like disorder consequent to an IEI. Patients from consanguineous families often have highly penetrant early-onset autosomal recessive forms of CVID-like disorders. Individuals from non-consanguineous families may have autosomal dominant CVID-like disorders with variable penetrance and expressivity. This essay explores the potential clinical utility as well as the current limitations and risks of gene editing including collateral genotoxicity. In the immediate future the main application of this technology is likely to be the in vitro investigation of epigenetic and polygenic mechanisms, which are likely to underlie many cases of CVID and CVID-like disorders. In the longer-term, the CRISPR Cas9 system and other gene-based therapies could be utilized to treat CVID-like disorders, where the underlying IEI is known.

The Rapidly Expanding Genetic Spectrum of Common Variable Immunodeficiency-Like Disorders

The understanding of common variable immunodeficiency disorders (CVID) is in evolution. CVID was previously a diagnosis of exclusion. New diagnostic criteria have allowed the disorder to be identified with greater precision. With the advent of next-generation sequencing (NGS), it has become apparent that an increasing number of patients with a CVID phenotype have a causative genetic variant. If a pathogenic variant is identified, these patients are removed from the overarching diagnosis of CVID and are deemed to have a CVID-like disorder. In populations where consanguinity is more prevalent, the majority of patients with severe primary hypogammaglobulinemia will have an underlying inborn error of immunity, usually an early-onset autosomal recessive disorder. In nonconsanguineous societies, pathogenic variants are identified in approximately 20% to 30% of patients. These are often autosomal dominant mutations with variable penetrance and expressivity. To add to the complexity of CVID and CVID-like disorders, some genetic variants such as those in TNFSF13B (transmembrane activator calcium modulator cyclophilin ligand interactor) predispose to, or enhance, disease severity. These variants are not causative but can have epistatic (synergistic) interactions with more deleterious mutations to worsen disease severity. This review is a description of the current understanding of genes associated with CVID and CVID-like disorders. This information will assist clinicians in interpreting NGS reports when investigating the genetic basis of disease in patients with a CVID phenotype.

Selective IgA Deficiency May Be an Underrecognized Risk Factor for Severe COVID-19

SARS-CoV-2, the agent responsible for COVID-19, has wreaked havoc around the globe. Hundreds of millions of individuals have been infected and well over six million have died from COVID-19. Many COVID-19 survivors have ongoing physical and psychiatric morbidity, which will remain for the rest of their lives. Early in the pandemic, it became apparent that older individuals and those with comorbidities including obesity, diabetes mellitus, coronary artery disease, hypertension, and renal and pulmonary disease were at increased risk of adverse outcomes. It is also clear that some immunodeficient patients, such as those with innate or T cell-immune defects, are at greater risk from COVID-19. Selective IgA deficiency (sIgAD) is generally regarded as a mild disorder in which most patients are asymptomatic because of redundancy in protective immune mechanisms. Recent data indicate that patients with sIgAD may be at high risk of severe COVID-19. SARS-CoV-2 gains entry primarily through the upper respiratory tract mucosa, where IgA has a critical protective role. This may underlie the vulnerability of sIgAD patients to adverse outcomes from COVID-19. This perspective highlights the need for ongoing research into mucosal immunity to improve COVID-19 treatments for patients with sIgAD.

"Common variable immunodeficiency: Challenges for diagnosis"

Common variable immunodeficiency is a heterogeneous condition characterized by B cell dysfunction with reduced serum immunoglobulin levels and a highly variable spectrum of clinical manifestations ranging from recurrent infections to autoimmune disease. The diagnosis of CVID is often challenging due to the diverse clinical presentation of patients and the existence of multiple diagnostic criteria without a universally adopted consensus. Laboratory evaluation to assist with diagnosis currently includes serum immunoglobulin testing, immunophenotyping, assessment of vaccine response, and genetic testing. Additional emerging techniques include investigation of the B cell repertoire and the use of machine learning algorithms. Advances in our understanding of common variable immunodeficiency will ultimately contribute to earlier diagnosis and novel interventions with the goal of improving prognosis for these patients.

The pediatric common variable immunodeficiency - from genetics to therapy: a review

Common variable immunodeficiency (CVID) is the most prevalent antibody deficiency, characterized by remarkable genetic, immunological, and clinical heterogeneity. The diagnosis of pediatric CVID is challenging due to the immaturity of the immune response and sustained actively developing antibody affinity to antigens and immunological memory that may overlap with the inborn error of immunity. Significant progress has been recently done in the field of immunogenetics, yet a paucity of experimental and clinical studies on different systemic manifestations and immunological features of CVID in children may contribute to a delayed diagnosis and therapy. In this review, we aimed at defining the variable epidemiological, etiological, and clinical aspects of pediatric CVID with special emphasis on predominating infectious and non-infectious phenotypes in affected children.

CONCLUSION

While pediatric CVID is a multifaceted and notorious disease, increasing the pediatricians' awareness of this disease entity and preventing the diagnostic and therapeutic delay are needed, thereby improving the prognosis and survival of pediatric CVID patients.

WHAT IS KNOWN

• CVID is an umbrella diagnosis characterized by complex pathophysiology with an antibody deficiency as a common denominator. • It is a multifaceted disease characterized by marked genetic, immunological, and clinical heterogeneity..

WHAT IS NEW

• The diagnosis of pediatric CVID is challenging due to the immaturity of innate and adaptive immune response. • Increasing the pediatricians' awareness of CVID for the early disease recognition, timely therapeutic intervention, and improving the prognosis is needed.

Comparison of Diagnostic Criteria for Common Variable Immunodeficiency Disorders (CVID) in the New Zealand CVID Cohort Study

Common variable immunodeficiency disorders (CVID) are the most frequent symptomatic primary immune deficiencies in adults and children. In addition to recurrent and severe infections, patients with CVID are susceptible to autoimmune and inflammatory complications. The aetiologies of these uncommon conditions are, by definition, unknown. When the causes of complex disorders are uncertain, diagnostic criteria may offer valuable guidance to the management of patients. Over the last two decades, there have been four sets of diagnostic criteria for CVID in use. The original 1999 European Society for Immunodeficiencies and Pan-American Society for Immunodeficiency (ESID/PAGID) criteria are less commonly used than the three newer criteria: Ameratunga et al (Clin Exp Immunol 174:203-211, 2013), ESID (J Allergy Clin Immunol Pract, 2019) and ICON (J Allergy Clin Immunol Pract 4:38-59, 2016) criteria. The primary aim of the present study was to compare the utility of diagnostic criteria in a well-characterised cohort of CVID patients. The New Zealand CVID cohort study (NZCS) commenced in 2006 and currently comprises one hundred and thirteen patients, which represents approximately 70% of all known CVID patients in NZ. Many patients have been on subcutaneous or intravenous (SCIG/IVIG) immunoglobulin treatment for decades. Patients were given a clinical diagnosis of CVID as most were diagnosed before the advent of newer diagnostic criteria. Application of the three commonly used CVID diagnostic criteria to the NZCS showed relative sensitivities as follows: Ameratunga et al (Clin Exp Immunol 174:203-211, 2013), possible and probable CVID, 88.7%; ESID (J Allergy Clin Immunol Pract, 2019), 48.3%; and ICON (J Allergy Clin Immunol Pract 4:38-59, 2016), 47.1%. These differences were mostly due to the low rates of diagnostic vaccination challenges in patients prior to commencing SCIG/IVIG treatment and mirror similar findings in CVID cohorts from Denmark and Finland. Application of the Ameratunga et al (Clin Exp Immunol 174:203-211, 2013) CVID diagnostic criteria to patients on SCIG/IVIG may obviate the need to stop treatment for vaccine studies, to confirm the diagnosis.

Bronchiectasis is associated with delayed diagnosis and adverse outcomes in the New Zealand Common Variable Immunodeficiency Disorders cohort study

Common variable immunodeficiency disorders (CVID) are multi-system disorders where target organ damage is mediated by infective, autoimmune and inflammatory processes. Bronchiectasis is probably the most common disabling complication of CVID. The risk factors for bronchiectasis in CVID patients are incompletely understood. The New Zealand CVID study (NZCS) is a nationwide longitudinal observational study of adults, which commenced in 2006. In this analysis, the prevalence and risk factors for bronchiectasis were examined in the NZCS. After informed consent, clinical and demographic data were obtained with an interviewer-assisted questionnaire. Linked electronic clinical records and laboratory results were also reviewed. Statistical methods were applied to determine if variables such as early-onset disease, delay in diagnosis and increased numbers of infections were associated with greater risk of bronchiectasis. One hundred and seven adult patients with a diagnosis of CVID are currently enrolled in the NZCS, comprising approximately 70% of patients known to have CVID in New Zealand. Fifty patients (46·7%) had radiologically proven bronchiectasis. This study has shown that patients with compared to those without bronchiectasis have an increased mortality at a younger age. CVID patients with bronchiectasis had a greater number of severe infections consequent to early-onset disease and delayed diagnosis. Indigenous Māori have a high prevalence of CVID and a much greater burden of bronchiectasis compared to New Zealand Europeans. Diagnostic latency has not improved during the study period. Exposure to large numbers of infections because of early-onset disease and delayed diagnosis was associated with an increased risk of bronchiectasis. Earlier diagnosis and treatment of CVID may reduce the risk of bronchiectasis and premature death in some patients.

Perspective: Application of the American College of Medical Genetics Variant Interpretation Criteria to Common Variable Immunodeficiency Disorders

Common variable immunodeficiency disorders (CVIDs) are rare primary immunodeficiency diseases (PIDs) mostly associated with late onset antibody failure leading to immune system failure. Patients with CVID are predisposed to disabling complications such as bronchiectasis and systemic autoimmunity. In recent years a large number of genetic defects have become associated with these disorders. Patients with a causative mutation are deemed to have CVID-like disorders, while those with mutations predisposing to or modifying disease severity remain within the spectrum of CVID as defined by current diagnostic criteria. Next-generation sequencing (NGS) allows simultaneous analysis of multiple genes. Potential mutations identified from NGS are commonly evaluated with the American College of Medical Genetics (ACMG) variant interpretation criteria to determine their pathogenicity (causality). Patients with CVID and CVID-like disorders have marked genetic, allelic, and phenotypic heterogeneity. Although all patients with a CVID phenotype should undergo genetic testing, the complexity of the genetics associated with these disorders is challenging. Variants of unknown significance (VUS) remain a significant barrier to realising the full potential of NGS in CVID and CVID-like disorders. Here we explore the nuances of applying the ACMG criteria to patients with CVID and CVID-like disorders. Close collaboration between the clinician, bioinformatics, and genetics professionals will improve the diagnostic yield from genetic testing and reduce the frequency of VUS.

Case Report: Hyper IgM Syndrome Identified by Whole Genome Sequencing in a Young Syrian Man Presenting With Atypical, Severe and Recurrent Mucosal Leishmaniasis

A previously healthy 19-year-old Syrian man presented with atypical and severe mucosal leishmaniasis caused by Leishmania tropica. During a 2-year period, he had three severe relapses despite various treatment strategies, including liposomal amphotericin B and Miltefosine. Because of the unusual clinical presentation, potential underlying immunodeficiency was investigated. Normal T and NK cell counts were found. The B cell count was slightly elevated at 0.7 × 109 cells/L (0.09 × 109 to 0.57 × 109 cells/L), but the proportions of memory and isotype switched memory B cells were severely diminished IgG levels were low, at 309 mg/dL (610-1490 mg/dL). The initial IgM and IgA levels were within normal range, but the IgA levels decreased to 57 mg/dL (70-430 mg/dL) during follow up. Common variable immunodeficiency (CVID) was initially suspected, because the immunological results of low IgG and IgA, low switched memory B cells, no profound T cell deficiency found and absence of secondary cause of hypogammaglobulinemia were compatible with this diagnosis (ESID 2019). However, the highly unusual and severe clinical presentation of L. tropica is not suggestive of B-cell deficiency or CVID. Eventually a pathogenic nonsense variant in the CD40 ligand gene [p.(Arg11∗)] was identified by whole genome sequencing, thus enabling the diagnosis of X-linked hyper IgM syndrome. This case illustrates and supports the potential for the use of whole genome sequencing in accurate diagnosis of primary immunodeficiencies.

Targeted pharmacologic immunomodulation for inborn errors of immunity

Inborn errors of immunity consist of over 400 known single gene disorders that may manifest with infection susceptibility, autoimmunity, autoinflammation, hypersensitivity and cancer predisposition. Most patients are treated symptomatically with immunoglobulin replacement, prophylactic antimicrobials or broad immunosuppression pertaining to their disease phenotype. Other than haematopoietic stem cell transplantation, the aforementioned treatments do little to alter disease morbidity or mortality. Further, many patients may not be transplant candidates. In this review, we describe monogenic disorders affecting leucocyte migration, disorders of immune synapse formation and dysregulation of immune cell signal transduction. We highlight the use of off-label small molecules and biologics mechanistically targeted to altered disease pathophysiology of such diseases.

Comprehensive assessment of respiratory complications in patients with common variable immunodeficiency

BACKGROUND

Common variable immunodeficiency (CVID) is a heterogeneous group of disorders, characterized by recurrent upper and lower respiratory tract infections and some noninfectious clinical complications.

OBJECTIVE

To provide a detailed evaluation of respiratory presentations and complications in a cohort of Iranian patients with CVID.

METHODS

A retrospective cohort study was conducted on 245 CVID patients who were recorded in the Iranian primary immunodeficiency disorders registry network. Respiratory manifestations were evaluated by reviewing clinical hospital records, immunologic findings, pulmonary function tests (PFT), and high-resolution computed tomography (HRCT) scans.

RESULTS

Most of the patients (n = 208, 85.2%) had experienced at least 1 episode of acute respiratory manifestation, and pneumonia was observed in 31.6 % (n = 77) of cases as a first disease manifestation. During the follow-up, pneumonia, sinusitis, and otitis media were documented in 166 (68.6%), 125 (51.2%), and 103 (42.6%) cases, respectively. Abnormal PFT measurements were documented in 53.8% of patients. Among these patients, 21.5% showed restrictive changes, whereas 18.4% of patients showed an obstructive pattern. Bronchiectasis was the most frequent radiological finding, confirmed in 27.2% of patients. Patients with bronchiectasis were older at the time of immunodeficiency diagnosis (P < .001) and had longer diagnosis delay (P < .001) when compared with patients without bronchiectasis.

CONCLUSION

This study highlights the importance of monitoring the respiratory tract system even in asymptomatic patients. Pulmonary function tests and CT scans are the most commonly used techniques aiming to identify these patients early, aiming to reduce the rate of long-term respiratory complications.