Quantitative EEG (QEEG) Measures Differentiate Parkinson's Disease (PD) Patients from Healthy Controls (HC)

Parkinson's disease detection and classification using EEG based on deep CNN-LSTM model

The progressive loss of motor function in the brain is a hallmark of Parkinson's disease (PD). Electroencephalogram (EEG) signals are commonly used for early diagnosis since they are associated with a brain disorder. This work aims to find a better way to represent electroencephalography (EEG) signals and enhance the classification accuracy of individuals with Parkinson's disease using EEG signals. In this paper, we present two hybrid deep neural networks (DNN) that combine convolutional neural networks with long short-term memory to diagnose Parkinson's disease using EEG signals, that is, through the establishment of parallel and series combined models. The deep CNN network is utilized to acquire the structural features of ECG signals and extract meaningful information from them, after which the signals are sent via a long short-term memory network to extract the features' context dependency. The proposed architecture was able to achieve 97.6% specificity, 97.1% sensitivity, and 98.6% accuracy for a parallel model and 99.1% specificity, 98.5% sensitivity, and 99.7% accuracy for a series model, both in 3-class classification (PD patients with medication, PD patients without medication and healthy).

An interpretable model based on graph learning for diagnosis of Parkinson's disease with voice-related EEG

Parkinson's disease (PD) exhibits significant clinical heterogeneity, presenting challenges in the identification of reliable electroencephalogram (EEG) biomarkers. Machine learning techniques have been integrated with resting-state EEG for PD diagnosis, but their practicality is constrained by the interpretable features and the stochastic nature of resting-state EEG. The present study proposes a novel and interpretable deep learning model, graph signal processing-graph convolutional networks (GSP-GCNs), using event-related EEG data obtained from a specific task involving vocal pitch regulation for PD diagnosis. By incorporating both local and global information from single-hop and multi-hop networks, our proposed GSP-GCNs models achieved an averaged classification accuracy of 90.2%, exhibiting a significant improvement of 9.5% over other deep learning models. Moreover, the interpretability analysis revealed discriminative distributions of large-scale EEG networks and topographic map of microstate MS5 learned by our models, primarily located in the left ventral premotor cortex, superior temporal gyrus, and Broca's area that are implicated in PD-related speech disorders, reflecting our GSP-GCN models' ability to provide interpretable insights identifying distinctive EEG biomarkers from large-scale networks. These findings demonstrate the potential of interpretable deep learning models coupled with voice-related EEG signals for distinguishing PD patients from healthy controls with accuracy and elucidating the underlying neurobiological mechanisms.

EEG-Based Parkinson's Disease Recognition via Attention-Based Sparse Graph Convolutional Neural Network

Parkinson's disease (PD) is a complicated neurological ailment that affects both the physical and mental wellness of elderly individuals which makes it problematic to diagnose in its initial stages. Electroencephalogram (EEG) promises to be an efficient and cost-effective method for promptly detecting cognitive impairment in PD. Nevertheless, prevailing diagnostic practices utilizing EEG features have failed to examine the functional connectivity among EEG channels and the response of associated brain areas causing an unsatisfactory level of precision. Here, we construct an attention-based sparse graph convolutional neural network (ASGCNN) for diagnosing PD. Our ASGCNN model uses a graph structure to represent channel relationships, the attention mechanism for selecting channels, and the L1 norm to capture channel sparsity. We conduct extensive experiments on the publicly available PD auditory oddball dataset, which consists of 24 PD patients (under ON/OFF drug status) and 24 matched controls, to validate the effectiveness of our method. Our results show that the proposed method provides better results compared to the publicly available baselines. The achieved scores for Recall, Precision, F1-score, Accuracy and Kappa measures are 90.36%, 88.43%, 88.41%, 87.67%, and 75.24%, respectively. Our study reveals that the frontal and temporal lobes show significant differences between PD patients and healthy individuals. In addition, EEG features extracted by ASGCNN demonstrate significant asymmetry in the frontal lobe among PD patients. These findings can offer a basis for the establishment of a clinical system for intelligent diagnosis of PD by using auditory cognitive impairment features.

Budget-Based Classification of Parkinson's Disease From Resting State EEG

Early detection is vital for future neuroprotective treatments of Parkinson's disease (PD). Resting state electroencephalographic (EEG) recording has shown potential as a cost-effective means to aid in detection of neurological disorders such as PD. In this study, we investigated how the number and placement of electrodes affects classifying PD patients and healthy controls using machine learning based on EEG sample entropy. We used a custom budget-based search algorithm for selecting optimized sets of channels for classification, and iterated over variable channel budgets to investigate changes in classification performance. Our data consisted of 60-channel EEG collected at three different recording sites, each of which included observations collected both eyes open (total N = 178) and eyes closed (total N = 131). Our results with the data recorded eyes open demonstrated reasonable classification performance (ACC = .76; AUC = .76) with only 5 channels placed far away from each other, the selected regions including right-frontal, left-temporal and midline-occipital sites. Comparison to randomly selected subsets of channels indicated improved classifier performance only with relatively small channel-budgets. The results with the data recorded eyes closed demonstrated consistently worse classification performance (when compared to eyes open data), and classifier performance improved more steadily as a function of number of channels. In summary, our results suggest that a small subset of electrodes of an EEG recording can suffice for detecting PD with a classification performance on par with a full set of electrodes. Furthermore our results demonstrate that separately collected EEG data sets can be used for pooled machine learning based PD detection with reasonable classification performance.

An extended clinical EEG dataset with 15,300 automatically labelled recordings for pathology decoding

Automated clinical EEG analysis using machine learning (ML) methods is a growing EEG research area. Previous studies on binary EEG pathology decoding have mainly used the Temple University Hospital (TUH) Abnormal EEG Corpus (TUAB) which contains approximately 3,000 manually labelled EEG recordings. To evaluate and eventually even improve the generalisation performance of machine learning methods for EEG pathology, decoding larger, publicly available datasets is required. A number of studies addressed the automatic labelling of large open-source datasets as an approach to create new datasets for EEG pathology decoding, but little is known about the extent to which training on larger, automatically labelled dataset affects decoding performances of established deep neural networks. In this study, we automatically created additional pathology labels for the Temple University Hospital (TUH) EEG Corpus (TUEG) based on the medical reports using a rule-based text classifier. We generated a dataset of 15,300 newly labelled recordings, which we call the TUH Abnormal Expansion EEG Corpus (TUABEX), and which is five times larger than the TUAB. Since the TUABEX contains more pathological (75%) than non-pathological (25%) recordings, we then selected a balanced subset of 8,879 recordings, the TUH Abnormal Expansion Balanced EEG Corpus (TUABEXB). To investigate how training on a larger, automatically labelled dataset affects the decoding performance of deep neural networks, we applied four established deep convolutional neural networks (ConvNets) to the task of pathological versus non-pathological classification and compared the performance of each architecture after training on different datasets. The results show that training on the automatically labelled TUABEXB dataset rather than training on the manually labelled TUAB dataset increases accuracies on TUABEXB and even for TUAB itself for some architectures. We argue that automatically labelling of large open-source datasets can be used to efficiently utilise the massive amount of EEG data stored in clinical archives. We make the proposed TUABEXB available open source and thus offer a new dataset for EEG machine learning research.

Magnetoencephalography-based approaches to epilepsy classification

Epilepsy is a chronic central nervous system disorder characterized by recurrent seizures. Not only does epilepsy severely affect the daily life of the patient, but the risk of premature death in patients with epilepsy is three times higher than that of the normal population. Magnetoencephalography (MEG) is a non-invasive, high temporal and spatial resolution electrophysiological data that provides a valid basis for epilepsy diagnosis, and used in clinical practice to locate epileptic foci in patients with epilepsy. It has been shown that MEG helps to identify MRI-negative epilepsy, contributes to clinical decision-making in recurrent seizures after previous epilepsy surgery, that interictal MEG can provide additional localization information than scalp EEG, and complete excision of the stimulation area defined by the MEG has prognostic significance for postoperative seizure control. However, due to the complexity of the MEG signal, it is often difficult to identify subtle but critical changes in MEG through visual inspection, opening up an important area of research for biomedical engineers to investigate and implement intelligent algorithms for epilepsy recognition. At the same time, the use of manual markers requires significant time and labor costs, necessitating the development and use of computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) systems that use classifiers to automatically identify abnormal activity. In this review, we discuss in detail the results of applying various different feature extraction methods on MEG signals with different classifiers for epilepsy detection, subtype determination, and laterality classification. Finally, we also briefly look at the prospects of using MEG for epilepsy-assisted localization (spike detection, high-frequency oscillation detection) due to the unique advantages of MEG for functional area localization in epilepsy, and discuss the limitation of current research status and suggestions for future research. Overall, it is hoped that our review will facilitate the reader to quickly gain a general understanding of the problem of MEG-based epilepsy classification and provide ideas and directions for subsequent research.

Two-channel EEG based diagnosis of panic disorder and major depressive disorder using machine learning and non-linear dynamical methods

The current study aimed to investigate the possibility of rapid and accurate diagnoses of Panic disorder (PD) and Major depressive disorder (MDD) using machine learning. The support vector machine method was applied to 2-channel EEG signals from the frontal lobes (Fp1 and Fp2) of 149 participants to classify PD and MDD patients from healthy individuals using non-linear measures as features. We found significantly lower correlation dimension and Lempel-Ziv complexity in PD patients and MDD patients in the left hemisphere compared to healthy subjects at rest. Most importantly, we obtained a 90% accuracy in classifying MDD patients vs. healthy individuals, a 68% accuracy in classifying PD patients vs. controls, and a 59% classification accuracy between PD and MDD patients. In addition to demonstrating classification performance in a simplified setting, the observed differences in EEG complexity between subject groups suggest altered cortical processing present in the frontal lobes of PD patients that can be captured through non-linear measures. Overall, this study suggests that machine learning and non-linear measures using only 2-channel frontal EEGs are useful for aiding the rapid diagnosis of panic disorder and major depressive disorder.

Evaluating methods of oversampling and averaging resting-state electroencephalography data in classifying Parkinson's disease. ANNUAL INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE OF THE IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY SOCIETY. IEEE ENGINEERING IN MEDICINE AND BIOLOGY SOCIETY. ANNUAL INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE 2023;2023:1-5. [PMID: 38082678 DOI: 10.1109/embc40787.2023.10340819] [Citation(s) in RCA: 0] [Impact Index Per Article: 0]

Collecting resting-state electroencephalography (RSEEG) data is time-consuming and data sets are therefore often small. Because many machine learning (ML) algorithms work better with ample data, researchers looking to use RSEEG and ML to develop diagnostic models have used oversampling methods that may seem to contradict averaging methods used in conventional electroencephalography (EEG) research to improve the signal-to-noise ratio. Using eyes open (EO) and eyes closed (EC) recordings from 3 different research groups, we investigated the effect of different averaging and oversampling methods on classification metrics when classifying people with Parkinson's disease (PD) and controls. Both EC and EO recordings were used due to differences found between these methods. Our results indicated that grouping 58 electrodes into regions-of-interest (ROI) based on anatomical location is preferable to using single electrodes. Furthermore, although recording EO data led to slightly better classification, the number of data points for each participant was reduced and recordings for three participants entirely lost during pre-processing due to a higher level of artefacts than in the EC data.Clinical relevance- RSEEG is a potential biomarker for the diagnosis and prognostication of PD, but for RSEEG to have clinical relevance, it is necessary to establish which averaging and oversampling of data most reliably segregates the classes for people with PD and controls. We found that using of ROIs and EC data performed the best, as EO data was often contaminated with artefacts.

Machine Learning-Based Detection of Parkinson's Disease From Resting-State EEG: A Multi-Center Study

Resting-state EEG (rs-EEG) has been demonstrated to aid in Parkinson's disease (PD) diagnosis. In particular, the power spectral density (PSD) of low-frequency bands (δ and θ) and high-frequency bands (α and β) has been shown to be significantly different in patients with PD as compared to subjects without PD (non-PD). However, rs-EEG feature extraction and the interpretation thereof can be time-intensive and prone to examiner variability. Machine learning (ML) has the potential to automatize the analysis of rs-EEG recordings and provides a supportive tool for clinicians to ease their workload. In this work, we use rs-EEG recordings of 84 PD and 85 non-PD subjects pooled from four datasets obtained at different centers. We propose an end-to-end pipeline consisting of preprocessing, extraction of PSD features from clinically-validated frequency bands, and feature selection. Following, we assess the classification ability of the features via ML algorithms to stratify between PD and non-PD subjects. Further, we evaluate the effect of feature harmonization, given the multi-center nature of the datasets. Our validation results show, on average, an improvement in PD detection ability (69.6% vs. 75.5% accuracy) by logistic regression when harmonizing the features and performing univariate feature selection (k = 202 features). Our final results show an average global accuracy of 72.2% with balanced accuracy results for all the centers included in the study: 60.6%, 68.7%, 77.7%, and 82.2%, respectively.Clinical relevance- We present an end-to-end pipeline to extract clinically relevant features from rs-EEG recordings that can facilitate the analysis and detection of PD. Further, we provide an ML system that shows a good performance in detecting PD, even in the presence of centers with different acquisition protocols. Our results show the relevance of harmonizing features and provide a good starting point for future studies focusing on rs-EEG analysis and multi-center data.

Distinguishing Parkinson's Disease with GLCM Features from the Hankelization of EEG Signals

This study proposes a novel method that uses electroencephalography (EEG) signals to classify Parkinson's Disease (PD) and demographically matched healthy control groups. The method utilizes the reduced beta activity and amplitude decrease in EEG signals that are associated with PD. The study involved 61 PD patients and 61 demographically matched controls groups, and EEG signals were recorded in various conditions (eyes closed, eyes open, eyes both open and closed, on-drug, off-drug) from three publicly available EEG data sources (New Mexico, Iowa, and Turku). The preprocessed EEG signals were classified using features obtained from gray-level co-occurrence matrix (GLCM) features through the Hankelization of EEG signals. The performance of classifiers with these novel features was evaluated using extensive cross-validations (CV) and leave-one-out cross-validation (LOOCV) schemes. This method under 10 × 10 fold CV, the method was able to differentiate PD groups from healthy control groups using a support vector machine (SVM) with an accuracy of 92.4 ± 0.01, 85.7 ± 0.02, and 77.1 ± 0.06 for New Mexico, Iowa, and Turku datasets, respectively. After a head-to-head comparison with state-of-the-art methods, this study showed an increase in the classification of PD and controls.

Diagnosis and classification of Parkinson's disease using ensemble learning and 1D-PDCovNN

In this paper, we proposed a novel approach to diagnose and classify Parkinson's Disease (PD) using ensemble learning and 1D-PDCovNN, a novel deep learning technique. PD is a neurodegenerative disorder; early detection and correct classification are essential for better disease management. The primary aim of this study is to develop a robust approach to diagnosing and classifying PD using EEG signals. As the dataset, we have used the San Diego Resting State EEG dataset to evaluate our proposed method. The proposed method mainly consists of three stages. In the first stage, the Independent Component Analysis (ICA) method has been used as the pre-processing method to filter out the blink noises from the EEG signals. Also, the effect of the band showing motor cortex activity in the 7-30 Hz frequency band of EEG signals in diagnosing and classifying Parkinson's disease from EEG signals has been investigated. In the second stage, the Common Spatial Pattern (CSP) method has been used as the feature extraction to extract useful information from EEG signals. Finally, an ensemble learning approach, Dynamic Classifier Selection (DCS) in Modified Local Accuracy (MLA), has been employed in the third stage, consisting of seven different classifiers. As the classifier method, DCS in MLA, XGBoost, and 1D-PDCovNN classifier has been used to classify the EEG signals as the PD and healthy control (HC). We first used dynamic classifier selection to diagnose and classify Parkinson's disease (PD) from EEG signals, and promising results have been obtained. The performance of the proposed approach has been evaluated using the classification accuracy, F-1 score, kappa score, Jaccard score, ROC curve, recall, and precision values in the classification of PD with the proposed models. In the classification of PD, the combination of DCS in MLA achieved an accuracy of 99,31%. The results of this study demonstrate that the proposed approach can be used as a reliable tool for early diagnosis and classification of PD.

Parkinson’s disease detection based on multi-pattern analysis and multi-scale convolutional neural networks

Parkinson’s disease (PD) is a complex neurodegenerative disease. At present, the early diagnosis of PD is still extremely challenging, and there is still a lack of consensus on the brain characterization of PD, and a more efficient and robust PD detection method is urgently needed. In order to further explore the features of PD based on brain activity and achieve effective detection of PD patients (including OFF and ON medications), in this study, a multi-pattern analysis based on brain activation and brain functional connectivity was performed on the brain functional activity of PD patients, and a novel PD detection model based on multi-scale convolutional neural network (MCNN) was proposed. Based on the analysis of power spectral density (PSD) and phase-locked value (PLV) features of multiple frequency bands of two independent resting-state electroencephalography (EEG) datasets, we found that there were significant differences in PSD and PLV between HCs and PD patients (including OFF and ON medications), especially in the β and γ bands, which were very effective for PD detection. Moreover, the combined use of brain activation represented by PSD and functional connectivity patterns represented by PLV can effectively improve the performance of PD detection. Furthermore, our proposed MCNN model shows great potential for automatic PD detection, with cross-validation accuracy, sensitivity, specificity, and area under the receiver operating characteristic curve all above 99%. Our study may help to further understand the characteristics of PD and provide new ideas for future PD diagnosis based on spontaneous EEG activity.

Survey of Machine Learning Techniques in the Analysis of EEG Signals for Parkinson’s Disease: A Systematic Review

Background: Parkinson’s disease (PD) affects 7–10 million people worldwide. Its diagnosis is clinical and can be supported by image-based tests, which are expensive and not always accessible. Electroencephalograms (EEG) are non-invasive, widely accessible, low-cost tests. However, the signals obtained are difficult to analyze visually, so advanced techniques, such as Machine Learning (ML), need to be used. In this article, we review those studies that consider ML techniques to study the EEG of patients with PD. Methods: The review process was conducted following the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines, which are used to provide quality standards for the objective evaluation of various studies. All publications before February 2022 were included, and their main characteristics and results were evaluated and documented through three key points associated with the development of ML techniques: dataset quality, data preprocessing, and model evaluation. Results: 59 studies were included. The predominating models were Support Vector Machine (SVM) and Artificial Neural Networks (ANNs). In total, 31 articles diagnosed PD with a mean accuracy of 97.35 ± 3.46%. There was no standard cleaning protocol for EEG and a great heterogeneity in EEG characteristics was shown, although spectral features predominated by 88.37%. Conclusions: Neither the cleaning protocol nor the number of EEG channels influenced the classification results. A baseline value was provided for the PD diagnostic problem, although recent studies focus on the identification of cognitive impairment.

Betweenness Centrality in Resting-State Functional Networks Distinguishes Parkinson's Disease

The goal of this paper is to use graph theory network measures derived from non-invasive electroencephalography (EEG) to develop neural decoders that can differentiate Parkinson's disease (PD) patients from healthy controls (HC). EEG signals from 27 patients and 27 demographically matched controls from New Mexico were analyzed by estimating their functional networks. Data recorded from the patients during ON and OFF levodopa sessions were included in the analysis for comparison. We used betweenness centrality of estimated functional networks to classify the HC and PD groups. The classifiers were evaluated using leave-one-out cross-validation. We observed that the PD patients (on and off medication) could be distinguished from healthy controls with 89% accuracy - approximately 4% higher than the state-of-the-art on the same dataset. This work shows that brain network analysis using extracranial resting-state EEG can discover patterns of interactions indicative of PD. This approach can also be extended to other neurological disorders.

Parkinson’s Disease Detection from Resting-State EEG Signals Using Common Spatial Pattern, Entropy, and Machine Learning Techniques

Parkinson’s disease (PD) is a very common brain abnormality that affects people all over the world. Early detection of such abnormality is critical in clinical diagnosis in order to prevent disease progression. Electroencephalography (EEG) is one of the most important PD diagnostic tools since this disease is linked to the brain. In this study, novel efficient common spatial pattern-based approaches for detecting Parkinson’s disease in two cases, off–medication and on–medication, are proposed. First, the EEG signals are preprocessed to remove major artifacts before spatial filtering using a common spatial pattern. Several features are extracted from spatially filtered signals using different metrics, namely, variance, band power, energy, and several types of entropy. Machine learning techniques, namely, random forest, linear/quadratic discriminant analysis, support vector machine, and k-nearest neighbor, are investigated to classify the extracted features. The impacts of frequency bands, segment length, and reduction number on the results are also investigated in this work. The proposed methods are tested using two EEG datasets: the SanDiego dataset (31 participants, 93 min) and the UNM dataset (54 participants, 54 min). The results show that the proposed methods, particularly the combination of common spatial patterns and log energy entropy, provide competitive results when compared to methods in the literature. The achieved results in terms of classification accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity in the case of off-medication PD detection are around 99%. In the case of on-medication PD, the results range from 95% to 98%. The results also reveal that features extracted from the alpha and beta bands have the highest classification accuracy.

The Effects of Non-Invasive Brain Stimulation on Quantitative EEG in Patients With Parkinson's Disease: A Systematic Scoping Review

Parkinson's disease (PD) is a progressive neurodegenerative disorder characterized by motor and non-motor symptoms, aside from alterations in the electroencephalogram (EEG) already registered. Non-invasive brain stimulation (NIBS) techniques have been suggested as an alternative rehabilitative therapy, but the neurophysiological changes associated with these techniques are still unclear. We aimed to identify the nature and extent of research evidence on the effects of NIBS techniques in the cortical activity measured by EEG in patients with PD. A systematic scoping review was configured by gathering evidence on the following bases: PubMed (MEDLINE), PsycINFO, ScienceDirect, Web of Science, and cumulative index to nursing & allied health (CINAHL). We included clinical trials with patients with PD treated with NIBS and evaluated by EEG pre-intervention and post-intervention. We used the criteria of Downs and Black to evaluate the quality of the studies. Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS), transcranial electrical stimulation (tES), electrical vestibular stimulation, and binaural beats (BBs) are non-invasive stimulation techniques used to treat cognitive and motor impairment in PD. This systematic scoping review found that the current evidence suggests that NIBS could change quantitative EEG in patients with PD. However, considering that the quality of the studies varied from poor to excellent, the low number of studies, variability in NIBS intervention, and quantitative EEG measures, we are not yet able to use the EEG outcomes to predict the cognitive and motor treatment response after brain stimulation. Based on our findings, we recommend additional research efforts to validate EEG as a biomarker in non-invasive brain stimulation trials in PD.

Quantitative Electroencephalography as a Biomarker for Cognitive Dysfunction in Parkinson's Disease

Background: Quantitative electroencephalography (qEEG) has been suggested as a biomarker for cognitive decline in Parkinson's disease (PD). Objective: Determine if applying a wavelet-based qEEG algorithm to 21-electrode, resting-state EEG recordings obtained in a routine clinical setting has utility for predicting cognitive impairment in PD. Methods: PD subjects, evaluated by disease stage and motor score, were compared to healthy controls (N = 20 each). PD subjects with normal (PDN, MoCA 26-30, N = 6) and impaired (PDD, MoCA ≤ 25, N = 14) cognition were compared. The wavelet-transform based time-frequency algorithm assessed the instantaneous predominant frequency (IPF) at 60 ms intervals throughout entire recordings. We then determined the relative time spent by the IPF in the four standard EEG frequency bands (RTF) at each scalp location. The resting occipital rhythm (ROR) was assessed using standard power spectral analysis. Results: Comparing PD subjects to healthy controls, mean values are decreased for ROR and RTF-Beta, greater for RTF-Theta and similar for RTF-Delta and RTF-Alpha. In logistic regression models, arithmetic combinations of RTF values [e.g., (RTF-Alpha) + (RTF-Beta)/(RTF-Delta + RTF-Theta)] and RTF-Alpha values at occipital or parietal locations are most able to discriminate between PD and controls. A principal component (PC) from principal component analysis (PCA) using RTF-band values in all subjects is associated with PD status (p = 0.004, β = 0.31, AUC = 0.780). Its loadings show positive contribution from RTF-Theta at all scalp locations, and negative contributions from RTF-Beta at occipital, parietal, central, and temporal locations. Compared to cognitively normal PD subjects, cognitively impaired PD subjects have lower median RTF-Alpha and RTF-Beta values, greater RTF-Theta values and similar RTF-Delta values. A PC from PCA using RTF-band values in PD subjects is associated with cognitive status (p = 0.002, β = 0.922, AUC = 0.89). Its loadings show positive contributions from RTF-Theta at all scalp locations, negative contributions from RTF-Beta at central locations, and negative contributions from RTF-Delta at central, frontal and temporal locations. Age, disease duration and/or sex are not significant covariates. No PC was associated with motor score or disease stage. Significance: Analyzing standard EEG recordings obtained in a community practice setting using a wavelet-based qEEG algorithm shows promise as a PD biomarker and for predicting cognitive impairment in PD.

Predicting Parkinson's disease using gradient boosting decision tree models with electroencephalography signals

INTRODUCTION

Parkinson's disease (PD) is a neurodegenerative disorder with only symptomatic treatments currently available. Although correct, early diagnoses of PD are important, the existing diagnostic method based on pathologic examinations only has an accuracy of approximately 80.6%. Although electroencephalography (EEG)-based assistive technology has been introduced, it has been difficult to implement in practice due to the high computational complexity and low accuracy of the analysis methods. This study proposed a fast, accurate PD prediction method using the Hjorth parameter and the gradient boosting decision tree (GBDT) algorithm.

METHOD

We used an open EEG dataset with 41 PD patients and 41 healthy controls (HCs); EEG signals were recorded from participants at the University of New Mexico (PD: 27 vs. HC: 27) and University of Iowa (PD: 14 vs. HC: 14). We explored the analytic time segment and frequency range in which the Hjorth parameter best represents the EEG characteristics of PD patients.

RESULTS

Our best model (CatBoost-based) distinguished PD patients from controls with an accuracy of 89.3%, an area under the receiver operating characteristics curve (AUC) of 0.912, an F-score of 0.903, and an odds ratio of 115.5. These results showed that our models outperformed those of all other previous works and were even superior to previously known pathologic examination-based diagnoses with long-term follow-up (accuracy = 83.9%).

CONCLUSION

The proposed methods are expected to be utilized as an effective method for improving the diagnosis of PD.

Novel automated PD detection system using aspirin pattern with EEG signals

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Parkinson's disease (PD) is one of the most common diseases worldwide which reduces quality of life of patients and their family members. The electroencephalogram (EEG) signals coupled with various advanced machine-learning algorithms have been widely used to detect PD automatically. In this paper, we propose a novel aspirin pattern to detect PD accurately using EEG signals.

METHOD

In this research, the feature generation ability of a chemical graph is investigated. Therefore, this work presents a new graph-based aspirin model for automated PD detection using EEG signals. The proposed method consists of (i) multilevel feature generation phase involving new aspirin pattern, statistical moments, and maximum absolute pooling (MAP), (ii) selection of most discriminative features using neighborhood component analysis (NCA), and (iii) classification using k nearest neighbor (kNN) for automated detection of PD and (iv) iterative majority voting.

RESULTS

A public dataset has been used to develop the proposed model. Two cases are created, and these cases consisted of two classes. Leave one subject out (LOSO) validation have been used to calculate robust results. Our proposal achieved 93.57% and 95.48% classification accuracies for Case 1 and Case 2 respectively.

CONCLUSION

Our developed automated PD model is accurate and equipped to be tested with more diverse EEG datasets.

Machine Learning Approaches for Detecting Parkinson’s Disease from EEG Analysis: A Systematic Review

Background: Diagnosis of Parkinson’s disease (PD) is mainly based on motor symptoms and can be supported by imaging techniques such as the single photon emission computed tomography (SPECT) or M-iodobenzyl-guanidine cardiac scintiscan (MIBG), which are expensive and not always available. In this review, we analyzed studies that used machine learning (ML) techniques to diagnose PD through resting state or motor activation electroencephalography (EEG) tests. Methods: The review process was performed following Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. All publications previous to May 2020 were included, and their main characteristics and results were assessed and documented. Results: Nine studies were included. Seven used resting state EEG and two motor activation EEG. Subsymbolic models were used in 83.3% of studies. The accuracy for PD classification was 62–99.62%. There was no standard cleaning protocol for the EEG and a great heterogeneity in the characteristics that were extracted from the EEG. However, spectral characteristics predominated. Conclusions: Both the features introduced into the model and its architecture were essential for a good performance in predicting the classification. On the contrary, the cleaning protocol of the EEG, is highly heterogeneous among the different studies and did not influence the results. The use of ML techniques in EEG for neurodegenerative disorders classification is a recent and growing field.

Alpha Power and Functional Connectivity in Cognitive Decline: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Background:

Mild cognitive impairment (MCI) is a stage between expected age-related cognitive decline and dementia. Dementias have been associated with changes in neural oscillations across the frequency spectrum, including the alpha range. Alpha is the most prominent rhythm in human EEG and is best detected during awake resting state (RS). Though several studies measured alpha power and synchronization in MCI, findings have not yet been integrated.

Objective:

To consolidate findings on power and synchronization of alpha oscillations across stages of cognitive decline.

Methods:

We included studies published until January 2020 that compared power or functional connectivity between 1) people with MCI and cognitively healthy older adults (OA) or people with a neurodegenerative dementia, and 2) people with progressive and stable MCI. Random-effects meta-analyses were performed when enough data was available.

Results:

Sixty-eight studies were included in the review. Global RS alpha power was lower in AD than in MCI (ES = –0.30; 95% CI = –0.51, –0.10; k = 6), and in MCI than in OA (ES = –1.49; 95% CI = –2.69, –0.29; k = 5). However, the latter meta-analysis should be interpreted cautiously due to high heterogeneity. The review showed lower RS alpha power in progressive than in stable MCI, and lower task-related alpha reactivity in MCI than in OA. People with MCI had both lower and higher functional connectivity than OA. Publications lacked consistency in MCI diagnosis and EEG measures.

Conclusion:

Research indicates that RS alpha power decreases with increasing impairment, and could—combined with measures from other frequency bands—become a biomarker of early cognitive decline.

Linear predictive coding distinguishes spectral EEG features of Parkinson's disease

OBJECTIVE

We have developed and validated a novel EEG-based signal processing approach to distinguish PD and control patients: Linear-predictive-coding EEG Algorithm for PD (LEAPD). This method efficiently encodes EEG time series into features that can detect PD in a computationally fast manner amenable to real time applications.

METHODS

We included a total of 41 PD patients and 41 demographically-matched controls from New Mexico and Iowa. Data for all participants from New Mexico (27 PD patients and 27 controls) were used to evaluate in-sample LEAPD performance, with extensive cross-validation. Participants from Iowa (14 PD patients and 14 controls) were used for out-of-sample tests. Our method utilized data from six EEG leads which were as little as 2 min long.

RESULTS

For the in-sample dataset, LEAPD differentiated PD patients from controls with 85.3 ± 0.1% diagnostic accuracy, 93.3 ± 0.5% area under the receiver operating characteristics curve (AUC), 87.9 ± 0.9% sensitivity, and 82.7 ± 1.1% specificity, with multiple cross-validations. After head-to-head comparison with state-of-the-art methods using our dataset, LEAPD showed a 13% increase in accuracy and a 15.5% increase in AUC. When the trained classifier was applied to a distinct out-of-sample dataset, LEAPD showed reliable performance with 85.7% diagnostic accuracy, 85.2% AUC, 85.7% sensitivity, and 85.7% specificity. No statistically significant effect of levodopa-ON and levodopa-OFF sessions were found.

CONCLUSION

We describe LEAPD, an efficient algorithm that is suitable for real time application and captures spectral EEG features using few parameters and reliably differentiates PD patients from demographically-matched controls.

Is the Random Forest Algorithm Suitable for Predicting Parkinson's Disease with Mild Cognitive Impairment out of Parkinson's Disease with Normal Cognition?

Because it is possible to delay the progression of dementia if it is detected and treated in an early stage, identifying mild cognitive impairment (MCI) is an important primary goal of dementia treatment. The objectives of this study were to develop a random forest-based Parkinson's disease with mild cognitive impairment (PD-MCI) prediction model considering health behaviors, environmental factors, medical history, physical functions, depression, and cognitive functions using the Parkinson's Dementia Clinical Epidemiology Data (a national survey conducted by the Korea Centers for Disease Control and Prevention) and to compare the prediction accuracy of our model with those of decision tree and multiple logistic regression models. We analyzed 96 subjects (PD-MCI = 45; Parkinson's disease with normal cognition (PD-NC) = 51 subjects). The prediction accuracy of the model was calculated using the overall accuracy, sensitivity, and specificity. Based on the random forest analysis, the major risk factors of PD-MCI were, in descending order of magnitude, Clinical Dementia Rating (CDR) sum of boxes, Untitled Parkinson's Disease Rating (UPDRS) motor score, the Korean Mini Mental State Examination (K-MMSE) total score, and the K- Korean Montreal Cognitive Assessment (K-MoCA) total score. The random forest method achieved a higher sensitivity than the decision tree model. Thus, it is advisable to develop a protocol to easily identify early stage PDD based on the PD-MCI prediction model developed in this study, in order to establish individualized monitoring to track high-risk groups.

Phase lag index and spectral power as QEEG features for identification of patients with mild cognitive impairment in Parkinson's disease

OBJECTIVES

To identify quantitative EEG frequency and connectivity features (Phase Lag Index) characteristic of mild cognitive impairment (MCI) in Parkinson's disease (PD) patients and to investigate if these features correlate with cognitive measures of the patients.

METHODS

We recorded EEG data for a group of PD patients with MCI (n = 27) and PD patients without cognitive impairment (n = 43) using a high-resolution recording system. The EEG files were processed and 66 frequency along with 330 connectivity (phase lag index, PLI) measures were calculated. These measures were used to classify MCI vs. MCI-free patients. We also assessed correlations of these features with cognitive tests based on comprehensive scores (domains).

RESULTS

PLI measures classified PD-MCI from non-MCI patients better than frequency measures. PLI in delta, theta band had highest importance for identifying patients with MCI. Amongst cognitive domains, we identified the most significant correlations between Memory and Theta PLI, Attention and Beta PLI.

CONCLUSION

PLI is an effective quantitative EEG measure to identify PD patients with MCI.

SIGNIFICANCE

We identified quantitative EEG measures which are important for early identification of cognitive decline in PD.

Automatic diagnosis of neurological diseases using MEG signals with a deep neural network

The application of deep learning to neuroimaging big data will help develop computer-aided diagnosis of neurological diseases. Pattern recognition using deep learning can extract features of neuroimaging signals unique to various neurological diseases, leading to better diagnoses. In this study, we developed MNet, a novel deep neural network to classify multiple neurological diseases using resting-state magnetoencephalography (MEG) signals. We used the MEG signals of 67 healthy subjects, 26 patients with spinal cord injury, and 140 patients with epilepsy to train and test the network using 10-fold cross-validation. The trained MNet succeeded in classifying the healthy subjects and those with the two neurological diseases with an accuracy of 70.7 ± 10.6%, which significantly exceeded the accuracy of 63.4 ± 12.7% calculated from relative powers of six frequency bands (δ: 1-4 Hz; θ: 4-8 Hz; low-α: 8-10 Hz; high-α: 10-13 Hz; β: 13-30 Hz; low-γ: 30-50 Hz) for each channel using a support vector machine as a classifier (p = 4.2 × 10-2). The specificity of classification for each disease ranged from 86-94%. Our results suggest that this technique would be useful for developing a classifier that will improve neurological diagnoses and allow high specificity in identifying diseases.

Detection of Microbial 16S rRNA Gene in the Blood of Patients With Parkinson's Disease

Emerging evidence suggests that the microbiota present in feces plays a role in Parkinson's disease (PD). However, the alterations of the microbiome in the blood of PD patients remain unknown. To test this hypothesis, we conducted this case-control study to explore the microbiota compositions in the blood of Chinese PD patients. Microbiota communities in the blood of 45 patients and their healthy spouses were investigated using high-throughput Illumina HiSeq sequencing targeting the V3-V4 region of 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) gene. The relationships between the microbiota in the blood and PD clinical characteristics were analyzed. No difference was detected in the structure and richness between PD patients and healthy controls. The following genera were enriched in the blood of PD patients: Isoptericola, Cloacibacterium, Enhydrobacter and Microbacterium; whereas genus Limnobacter was enriched in the healthy controls after adjusting for age, gender, body mass index (BMI) and constipation. Additionally, the findings regarding these genera were validated in another independent group of 58 PD patients and 57 healthy controls using real-time PCR targeting genus-specific 16S rRNA genes. Furthermore, not only the genera Cloacibacterium and Isoptericola (which were identified as enriched in PD patients) but also the genera Paludibacter and Saccharofermentans were positively associated with disease duration. Some specific genera in the blood were related to mood disorders. We believe this is the first report to provide direct evidence to support the hypothesis that the identified microbiota in the blood are associated with PD. Additionally, some microbiota in the blood are closely associated with the clinical characteristics of PD. Elucidating these differences in blood microbiomes will provide a foundation to improve our understanding of the role of microbiota in the pathogenesis of PD.

Alteration of the fecal microbiota in Chinese patients with Parkinson's disease

Emerging evidences suggest that gut microbiota dysbiosis plays a role in Parkinson's disease (PD). However, the alterations in fecal microbiome in Chinese PD patients remains unknown. This case-control study was conducted to explore fecal microbiota compositions in Chinese PD patients. Microbiota communities in the feces of 45 patients and their healthy spouses were investigated using high-throughput Illumina Miseq sequencing targeting the V3-V4 region of 16S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) gene. The relationships between fecal microbiota and PD clinical characteristics were analyzed. The structure and richness of the fecal microbiota differed between PD patients and healthy controls. Genera Clostridium IV, Aquabacterium, Holdemania, Sphingomonas, Clostridium XVIII, Butyricicoccus and Anaerotruncus were enriched in the feces of PD patients after adjusting for age, gender, body mass index (BMI), and constipation. Furthermore, genera Escherichia/Shigella were negatively associated with disease duration. Genera Dorea and Phascolarctobacterium were negatively associated with levodopa equivalent doses (LED). Among the non-motor symptoms (NMSs), genera Butyricicoccus and Clostridium XlVb were associated with cognitive impairment. Overall, we confirmed that gut microbiota dysbiosis occurs in Chinese patients with PD. A well-controlled population involved was beneficial for the identification of microbiota associated with diseases. Additionally, the fecal microbiota was closely related to PD clinical characteristics. Elucidating these differences in the fecal microbiome will provide a foundation to improve our understanding the pathogenesis of PD and to support the potentially therapeutic options modifying the gut microbiota.

Diminished EEG habituation to novel events effectively classifies Parkinson's patients

OBJECTIVES

We aimed to test if EEG responses to novel events reliably dissociated individuals with Parkinson's disease and controls, and if this dissociation was sensitive and specific enough to be a candidate biomarker of cognitive dysfunction in Parkinson's disease.

METHODS

Participants included N = 25 individuals with Parkinson's disease and an equal number of well-matched controls. EEG was recorded during a three-stimulus auditory oddball paradigm both ON and OFF medication.

RESULTS

While control participants showed reliable EEG habituation to novel events over time, individuals with Parkinson's did not. In the OFF condition, individual differences in habituation correlated with years since diagnosis. Pattern classifiers achieved high sensitivity and specificity in discriminating patients from controls, with a maximum accuracy of 82%. Most importantly, the confidence of the classifier was related to years since diagnosis, and this correlation increased as the time course of differential habituation increasingly distinguished the groups.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings identify systemic alteration in an obligatory neural mechanism that may contribute to higher-level cognitive dysfunction in Parkinson's disease.

SIGNIFICANCE

These findings suggest that EEG responses to novel events in this rapid, simple, and inexpensive test have tremendous promise for tracking individual trajectories of cognitive dysfunction in Parkinson's disease.

Correlations between Motor Symptoms across Different Motor Tasks, Quantified via Random Forest Feature Classification in Parkinson's Disease

Background

Objective assessments of Parkinson’s disease (PD) patients’ motor state using motion capture techniques are still rarely used in clinical practice, even though they may improve clinical management. One major obstacle relates to the large dimensionality of motor abnormalities in PD. We aimed to extract global motor performance measures covering different everyday motor tasks, as a function of a clinical intervention, i.e., deep brain stimulation (DBS) of the subthalamic nucleus.

Methods

We followed a data-driven, machine-learning approach and propose performance measures that employ Random Forests with probability distributions. We applied this method to 14 PD patients with DBS switched-off or -on, and 26 healthy control subjects performing the Timed Up and Go Test (TUG), the Functional Reach Test (FRT), a hand coordination task, walking 10-m straight, and a 90° curve.

Results

For each motor task, a Random Forest identified a specific set of metrics that optimally separated PD off DBS from healthy subjects. We noted the highest accuracy (94.6%) for standing up. This corresponded to a sensitivity of 91.5% to detect a PD patient off DBS, and a specificity of 97.2% representing the rate of correctly identified healthy subjects. We then calculated performance measures based on these sets of metrics and applied those results to characterize symptom severity in different motor tasks. Task-specific symptom severity measures correlated significantly with each other and with the Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale (UPDRS, part III, correlation of r² = 0.79). Agreement rates between different measures ranged from 79.8 to 89.3%.

Conclusion

The close correlation of PD patients’ various motor abnormalities quantified by different, task-specific severity measures suggests that these abnormalities are only facets of the underlying one-dimensional severity of motor deficits. The identification and characterization of this underlying motor deficit may help to optimize therapeutic interventions, e.g., to “automatically” adapt DBS settings in PD patients.

Among Early Appearing Non-Motor Signs of Parkinson's Disease, Alteration of Olfaction but Not Electroencephalographic Spectrum Correlates with Motor Function

Olfactory decline is a frequent and early non-motor symptom in Parkinson’s disease (PD), which is increasingly used for diagnostic purposes. Another early appearing sign of PD consists in electroencephalographic (EEG) alterations. The combination of olfactory and EEG assessment may improve the identification of patients with early stages of PD. We hypothesized that olfactory capacity would be correlated with EEG alterations and motor and cognitive impairment in PD patients. To the best of our knowledge, the mutual influence of both markers of PD—olfactory decrease and EEG changes—was not studied before. We assessed the function of odor identification using olfactory “Screening 12 Test” (“Sniffin’ Sticks^®”), between two samples: patients with PD and healthy controls (HC). We analyzed correlations between the olfactory function and demographical parameters, Unified Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale (UPDRS-III), cognitive task performance, and spectral alpha/theta ratio (α/θ). In addition, we used receiver operating characteristic-curve analysis to check the classification capacity (PD vs HC) of olfactory function, α/θ, and a combined marker (olfaction and α/θ). Olfactory capacity was significantly decreased in PD patients, and correlated with age, disease duration, UPDRS-III, and with items of UPDRS-III related to gait and axial rigidity. In HC, olfaction correlated with age only. No correlation with α/θ was identified in both samples. Combined marker showed the largest area under the curve. In addition to EEG, the assessment of olfactory function may be a useful tool in the early characterization and follow-up of PD.