Effects of Deep Brain Stimulation in the Subthalamic Nucleus on Neurocognitive Function in Patients With Parkinson's Disease Compared With Medical Therapy: A Meta-Analysis

Monitoring Cognitive Functions During Deep Brain Stimulation Interventions by Real Time Neuropsychological Testing

OBJECTIVE

We monitored cognition in 14 Parkinson's disease (PD) patients during deep brain stimulation (DBS) surgery when the electrode was positioned at the target subthalamic nucleus (STN) (i.e., the STN motor area).

METHODS

We present the DBS-real-time neuropsychological testing (DBS-RTNT) protocol and our preliminary experience with it; we also compared the intraoperative patient performance with the baseline data.

RESULTS

Compared with the baseline data, patients undergoing DBS-RTNT in the target area demonstrated a significantly decreased performance on some tasks belonging to the memory and executive function domains. Patients undergoing right hemisphere DBS-RTNT had significantly lower short-term memory and sequencing scores than did patients undergoing left hemisphere DBS-RTNT.

CONCLUSION

PD patient cognitive performance should be monitored during DBS surgery, as STN-DBS may induce changes. These preliminary data contribute to improving our understanding of the anatomo-functional topography of the STN during DBS surgery, which will enable the identification of the best site for producing positive motor effects without causing negative cognitive and/or emotional changes in individual patients in the future. In principle, medications (i.e., patients who underwent surgery in a levodopa-off state) could have influenced our results; therefore, future studies are needed to address the possible confounding effects of levodopa use.

Differential Cognitive Effects of Unilateral Subthalamic Nucleus Deep Brain Stimulation for Parkinson's Disease

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to investigate the cognitive effects of unilateral directional versus ring subthalamic nucleus deep brain stimulation (STN DBS) in patients with advanced Parkinson's disease.

METHODS

We examined 31 participants who underwent unilateral STN DBS (left n = 17; right n = 14) as part of an National Institutes of Health (NIH)-sponsored randomized, double-blind, crossover study contrasting directional versus ring stimulation. All participants received unilateral DBS implants in the hemisphere more severely affected by motor parkinsonism. Measures of cognition included verbal fluency, auditory-verbal memory, and response inhibition. We used mixed linear models to contrast the effects of directional versus ring stimulation and implant hemisphere on longitudinal cognitive function.

RESULTS

Crossover analyses showed no evidence for group-level changes in cognitive performance related to directional versus ring stimulation. Implant hemisphere, however, impacted cognition in several ways. Left STN participants had lower baseline verbal fluency than patients with right implants (t [20.66 = -2.50, p = 0.02]). Verbal fluency declined after left (p = 0.013) but increased after right STN DBS (p < 0.001), and response inhibition was faster following right STN DBS (p = 0.031). Regardless of hemisphere, delayed recall declined modestly over time versus baseline (p = 0.001), and immediate recall was unchanged.

INTERPRETATION

Directional versus ring STN DBS did not differentially affect cognition. Similar to prior bilateral DBS studies, unilateral left stimulation worsened verbal fluency performance. In contrast, unilateral right STN surgery increased performance on verbal fluency and response inhibition tasks. Our findings raise the hypothesis that unilateral right STN DBS in selected patients with predominant right brain motor parkinsonism could mitigate declines in verbal fluency associated with the bilateral intervention. ANN NEUROL 2024;95:1205-1219.

Bidirectional Interplay between Deep Brain Stimulation and Cognition in Parkinson's Disease: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

Deep brain stimulation (DBS) is efficacious for treating motor symptoms in Parkinson's disease (PD).

OBJECTIVES

The aim is to evaluate the evidence regarding DBS effectiveness after postoperative cognitive deterioration, the impact of preoperative cognition on DBS effectiveness, and the impact of DBS on cognition.

METHODS

Literature searches were performed on MEDLINE, EMBASE, and CENTRAL (Cochrane library). Primary outcomes were OFF-drug Unified Parkinson Disease Rating Scale Part III score and cognitive test scores.

RESULTS

DBS effectiveness did not differ in patients with postoperative declining compared to stable cognition (n = 5 studies). Preoperative cognition did not influence DBS effectiveness (n = 1 study). DBS moderately decreased verbal fluency compared to the best medical treatment (n = 24 studies), which may be transient.

CONCLUSION

DBS motor effectiveness in PD does not appear to be influenced by cognition. DBS in PD seems cognitively safe, except for a moderate decline in verbal fluency. Further research is warranted. © 2024 The Authors. Movement Disorders published by Wiley Periodicals LLC on behalf of International Parkinson and Movement Disorder Society.

Differential cognitive effects of unilateral left and right subthalamic nucleus deep brain stimulation for Parkinson disease

Objective

To investigate hemispheric effects of directional versus ring subthalamic nucleus (STN) deep brain stimulation (DBS) surgery on cognitive function in patients with advanced Parkinson's disease (PD).

Methods

We examined 31 PD patients (Left STN n = 17; Right STN n = 14) who underwent unilateral subthalamic nucleus (STN) DBS as part of a NIH-sponsored randomized, cross-over, double-blind (ring vs directional) clinical trial. Outcome measures were tests of verbal fluency, auditory-verbal memory, and response inhibition. First, all participants were pooled together to study the effects of directional versus ring stimulation. Then, we stratified the groups by surgery hemisphere and studied the longitudinal changes in cognition post-unilateral STN DBS.

Results

Relative to pre-DBS cognitive baseline performances, there were no group changes in cognition following unilateral DBS for either directional or ring stimulation. However, assessment of unilateral DBS by hemisphere revealed a different pattern. The left STN DBS group had lower verbal fluency than the right STN group (t(20.66 = -2.50, p = 0.02). Over a period of eight months post-DBS, verbal fluency declined in the left STN DBS group (p = 0.013) and improved in the right STN DBS group over time (p < .001). Similarly, response inhibition improved following right STN DBS (p = 0.031). Immediate recall did not significantly differ over time, nor was it affected by implant hemisphere, but delayed recall equivalently declined over time for both left and right STN DBS groups (left STN DBS p = 0.001, right STN DBS differ from left STN DBS p = 0.794).

Conclusions

Directional and ring DBS did not differentially or adversely affect cognition over time. Regarding hemisphere effects, verbal fluency decline was observed in those who received left STN DBS, along with the left and right STN DBS declines in delayed memory. The left STN DBS verbal fluency decrement is consistent with prior bilateral DBS research, likely reflecting disruption of the basal-ganglia-thalamocortical network connecting STN and inferior frontal gyrus. Interestingly, we found an improvement in verbal fluency and response inhibition following right STN DBS. It is possible that unilateral STN DBS, particularly in the right hemisphere, may mitigate cognitive decline.

Cognitive Impact of Deep Brain Stimulation in Parkinson’s Disease Patients: A Systematic Review

Introduction

Parkinson’s disease (PD) patients have a significantly higher risk of developing dementia in later disease stages, leading to severe impairments in quality of life and self-functioning. Questions remain on how deep brain stimulation (DBS) affects cognition, and whether we can individualize therapy and reduce the risk for adverse cognitive effects. Our aim in this systematic review is to assess the current knowledge in the field and determine if the findings could influence clinical practice.

Methods

We have conducted a systematic review according to PRISMA guidelines through MEDLINE and Embase databases, with studies being selected for inclusion via a set inclusion and exclusion criteria.

Results

Sixty-seven studies were included in this systematic review according to the selected criteria. This includes 6 meta-analyses, 18 randomized controlled trials, 17 controlled clinical trials, and 26 observational studies with no control arms. The total number of PD patients encompassed in the studies cited in this review is 3677, not including the meta-analyses.

Conclusion

Cognitive function in PD patients can deteriorate, in most cases mildly, but still impactful to the quality of life. The strongest evidence is present for deterioration in verbal fluency, while inconclusive evidence is still present for executive function, memory, attention and processing speed. Global cognition does not appear to be significantly impacted by DBS, especially if cognitive screening is performed prior to the procedure, as lower baseline cognitive function is connected to poor outcomes. Further randomized controlled studies are required to increase the level of evidence, especially in the case of globus pallidus internus DBS, pedunculopontine nucleus DBS, and the ventral intermediate nucleus of thalamus DBS, and more long-term studies are required for all respective targets.

Short and Long-Term Cognitive Effects of Subthalamic Deep Brain Stimulation in Parkinson's Disease and Identification of Relevant Factors

BACKGROUND

Subthalamic nucleus deep brain stimulation (STN-DBS) successfully controls the motor symptoms of Parkinson's disease (PD) but has associated cognitive side-effects.

OBJECTIVE

Establish the short- and long-term cognitive effects of STN-DBS in PD.

METHODS

Both the short-term and long-term effects of STN-DBS on cognition were examined through evaluation of the controlled studies that compared patients with STN-DBS to unoperated PD patients, thus controlling for illness progression. We also reviewed the literature to identify the factors that influence cognitive outcome of STN-DBS in PD.

RESULTS

The meta-analysis of the short-term cognitive effects of STN-DBS revealed moderate effect sizes for semantic and phonemic verbal fluency and small effect sizes for psychomotor speed and language, indicating greater decline in the STN-DBS operated than the unoperated patients in these cognitive domains. The longer-term STN-DBS results from controlled studies indicated rates of cognitive decline/dementia up to 32%; which are no different from the rates from the natural progression of PD. Greater executive dysfunction and poorer memory pre-operatively, older age, higher pre-operative doses of levodopa, and greater axial involvement are some of the factors associated with worse cognition after STN-DBS in PD.

CONCLUSION

This evidence can be used to inform patients and their families about the short-term and long-term risks of cognitive decline following STN-DBS surgery and aid the team in selection of suitable candidates for surgery.