Heat Acclimation-Mediated Cross-Tolerance: Origins in within-Life Epigenetics?

Embryonic manipulations shape life-long, heritable stress responses through complex epigenetic mechanisms: a review

Enhancing an organism's likelihood of survival hinges on fostering a balanced and adaptable development of robust stress response systems. This critical process is significantly influenced by the embryonic environment, which plays a pivotal role in shaping neural circuits that define the stress response set-point. While certain embryonic conditions offer advantageous outcomes, others can lead to maladaptive responses. The establishment of this response set-point during embryonic development can exert life-long and inheritable effects on an organism's physiology and behavior. This review highlights the significance of multilevel epigenetic regulation and the intricate cross-talk among these layers in response to heat stress during the embryonic period, with a particular focus on insights gained from the avian model.

Climate change and pregnancy complications: From hormones to the immune response

Pregnant women are highly vulnerable to adverse environments. Accumulating evidence highlights that increasing temperatures associated with the ongoing climate change pose a threat to successful reproduction. Heat stress caused by an increased ambient temperature can result in adverse pregnancy outcomes, e.g., preterm birth, stillbirth and low fetal weight. The pathomechanisms through which heat stress interferes with pregnancy maintenance still remain vague, but emerging evidence underscores that the endocrine system is severely affected. It is well known that the endocrine system pivotally contributes to the physiological progression of pregnancy. We review – sometimes speculate - how heat stress can offset hormonal dysregulations and subsequently derail other systems which interact with hormones, such as the immune response. This may account for the heat-stress related threat to successful pregnancy progression, fetal development and long-term children’s health.

Vascular compliance and left ventricular compliance cross talk: Implications for using long-term heat acclimation in cardiac care

1) The first evidence of the beneficial impact of Long-Term-Heat-Acclimation (LTHA) on cardio-vascular compliance was the positive inotropic response and improved left ventricular (LV) compliance noted when isolated hearts from LTHA rats were studied. Human echo study demonstrates that passive HA affects the right ventricle and the atria as well. 2) There is a cross-talk between vascular and cardiac compliance. Vascular compliance per se is defined by central venous pressure-Blood volume relationship-Global Vascular Compliance (GVC). It is determined by the sum of the vascular compliance of the vessels in every organ in any physiological state, varies with LTHA and thus influences cardiac performance. LTHA improves endothelial function, increases NO (nitric oxide) production, in-turn stimulating alterations in ECM (extracellular matrix) via the TGF β1-SMAD pathway. 3) LTHA is associated with transformation from fast to slow myosin, heat acclimation ischemic/hypoxic cross-tolerance and alterations in the extracellular matrix. 4) A human translational study demonstrated improved LV compliance following bypass surgery in LTHA subjects compared to controls. 5) Diastolic dysfunction and the impact of comorbidities with vascular and non- vascular origins are major contributors to the syndrome of heart failure with preserved ejection function (HFPEF). Unfortunately, there is a paucity of treatment modalities that improve diastolic dysfunction. 6) In the current mini-review we suggest that LTHA may be beneficial to HFPEF patients by remodeling cardiac compliance and vascular response.

Epigenetic responses to heat: From adaptation to maladaptation

NEW FINDINGS

What is the topic of this review? This review outlines the history of research on epigenetic adaptations to heat exposure. The perspective taken is that adaptations reflect properties of hormesis, whereby low, repeated doses of heat induce adaptation (acclimation/acclimatization); whereas brief, life-threatening exposures can induce maladaptive responses. What advances does it highlight? The epigenetic mechanisms underlying acclimation/acclimatization comprise specific molecular programmes on histones that regulate heat shock proteins transcriptionally and protect the organism from subsequent heat exposures, even after long delays. The epigenetic signalling underlying maladaptive responses might rely, in part, on extensive changes in DNA methylation that are sustained over time and might contribute to later health challenges.

ABSTRACT

Epigenetics plays a strong role in molecular adaptations to heat by producing a molecular memory of past environmental exposures. Moderate heat, over long periods of time, induces an 'adaptive' epigenetic memory, resulting in a condition of 'resilience' to future heat exposures or cross-tolerance to other forms of toxic stress. In contrast, intense, life-threatening heat exposures, such as severe heat stroke, can result in a 'maladaptive' epigenetic memory that can place an organism at risk of later health complications. These cellular memories are coded by post-translational modifications of histones on the nucleosomes and/or by changes in DNA methylation. They operate by inducing changes in the level of gene transcription and therefore phenotype. The adaptive response to heat acclimation functions, in part, by facilitating transcription of essential heat shock proteins and exhibits a biphasic short programme (maintaining DNA integrity, followed by a long-term consolidation). The latter accelerates acclimation responses after de-acclimation. Although less studied, the maladaptive responses to heat stroke appear to be coded in long-lasting changes in DNA methylation near the promoter region of genes involved with basic cell function. Whether these memories are also encoded in histone modifications is not yet known. There is considerable evidence that both adaptive and maladaptive epigenetic responses to heat can be inherited, although most evidence comes from lower organisms. Future challenges include understanding the signalling mechanisms responsible and discovering new ways to promote adaptive responses while suppressing maladaptive responses to heat, as all life forms adapt to life on a warming planet.

Cardiovascular Adjustments After Acute Heat Exposure

In this review, we highlight recent studies from our group and others that have characterized the cardiovascular adjustments that occur after acute heat exposure. Special emphasis will be placed on underlying mechanisms and clinical implications. Finally, we postulate that these acute cardiovascular adjustments may predict the long-term adaptive response to chronic heat therapy.

Early-life thermal stress mediates long-term alterations in hypothalamic microglia

Stressful environmental events in early life have long-lasting consequences on later stress responses. We previously showed that heat conditioning of 3-day-old chicks during the critical period of heat-response development leads to heat vulnerability later in life. Here we assessed the role of early-life heat stress on the inflammatory response in the chick anterior hypothalamus (AH), focusing on hypothalamic microglia. We identified the microglial cell population in the chick AH using anti-KUL01 and anti-CD45 antibodies. Specific microglial features were also confirmed by expression of their signature genes. Under normal environmental conditions, hypothalamic microglia isolated from lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-injected chicks displayed a classical activated proinflammatory profile accompanied by a decreased homeostatic signature, demonstrating similarity of immune response with mammalian microglial cells. In accordance with our previous observations, conditioning of 3-day-old chicks under high ambient temperature decreased the number of newborn cells in the AH, among them microglial precursors. Although heat exposure did not affect microglial cell viability, it had a long-term impact on LPS-induced inflammatory response. Exposure to harsh heat led to heat vulnerability, and attenuated recruitment of peripheral monocytes and T cells into the AH following LPS challenge. Moreover, heat conditioning altered microglial reactivity, manifested as suppressed microglial activation in response to LPS. Innate immune memory developed by heat conditioning might underlie suppression of the microglial response to LPS challenge. We describe alterations in genome-wide CpG methylation profile of hypothalamic microglia, demonstrating probable epigenetic involvement in the reprogramming of microglial function, leading to heat-induced inflammatory cross-tolerance.

Human total fertility rate affected by ambient temperatures in both the present and previous generations

Elevated temperatures negatively affect human reproduction through several processes that regulate nutrient uptake and resource allocation in pregnant women. These can interfere with foetal development, resulting in low birth weight neonates with altered development trajectories. Temperatures that affect the current generation could, therefore, also have an impact on the following generation. We asked whether heat stress affected offspring fertility by asking if current and past ambient temperatures influenced total fertility rates (TFR) in human populations distributed across the world. We analysed time series data in 65 countries using simple regression analyses based on maximum temperatures and temperature amplitudes over 55 years. Supplemental longer time series (up to 100 years) provided information on response patterns in Northern Europe and Greenland's colder climates. There were clear and strong effects of temperatures on the TFR in the concurrent and the previous generation. Our temperature-based models account for 71-95% of the variation in TRF in European countries and Greenland, and 56-99% of the variation in 65 countries worldwide. Our findings are consistent with studies of seasonal variation in fertility and suggest that increased temperatures will negatively influence populations subjected to monthly maximum temperatures above 15-20 °C, while fertility in colder climates benefits from elevated temperatures. Our results provide strong evidence that ambient temperatures have important effects on human fertility, and that these effects persist into the following generation.

The involvement of microglial CX3CR1 in heat acclimation-induced amelioration of adult hippocampal neurogenesis impairment in EMF-exposed mice

Microglial CX3C chemokine receptor 1 (CX3CR1) has been implicated in numerous cellular mechanisms, including signalling pathways that regulate brain homoeostasis and adult hippocampal neurogenesis. Specific environmental conditions can impair hippocampal neurogenesis-related cognition, learning and memory. However, the role of CX3CR1 in the neurogenic alterations resulting from the cross-tolerance protection conferred by heat acclimation (HA) against the effects of electromagnetic field (EMF) exposure is less well understood. Here, we investigated the role of microglial CX3CR1 signalling in adult hippocampal neurogenesis induced by HA in EMF-exposed mice. We found that EMF exposure significantly decreased the number of proliferating and differentiating cells in the dentate gyrus (DG) of the hippocampus, resulting in a reduced neurogenesis rate. Moreover, alterations in the phenotypes of activated microglia and decreased expression levels of CX3CR1, but not sirtuin 1 (SIRT1), were observed in the brains of EMF-exposed mice. Remarkably, HA treatment improved microglial phenotypes, restored the expression of CX3CR1, and ameliorated the decrease in the adult hippocampal neurogenesis rate following EMF exposure. Moreover, pharmacological inhibition of CX3CR1 and SIRT1 failed to restore CX3CR1 expression and ameliorate hippocampal neurogenesis impairment following HA plus EMF stimulation. These results indicate that microglial CX3CR1 is involved in the cross-tolerance protective effect of HA on adult hippocampal neurogenesis upon EMF exposure.

Heat acclimation mediated cardioprotection is controlled by mitochondrial metabolic remodeling involving HIF-1α

Heat acclimation (HA) induces metabolic plasticity to resist the effects of environmental heat with cross-tolerance to novel stressors such as oxygen supply perturbations, exercise, and alike. Our previous results indicated that hypoxia inducible transcription factor (HIF-1α) contributes to this adaptive process. In the present study, we link functional studies in isolated cardiomyocytes, with molecular and biochemical studies of cardiac mitochondria and demonstrate that HA remodels mitochondrial metabolism and performance. We observed the significant role that HIF-1α plays in the HA heart, as HA reduces oxidative stress during ischemia by shifting mitochondrial substrate preference towards pyruvate, with elevated level and activity of mitochondrial LDH (LDHb), acting a pivotal role. Increased antioxidative capacity to encounter hazards is implicated. These results deepen our understanding of heat acclimation-mediated cross tolerance (HACT), in which adaptive bioenergetic-mechanisms counteract the hazards of oxidative stress.

Embryonic Heat Conditioning Induces TET-Dependent Cross-Tolerance to Hypothalamic Inflammation Later in Life

Early life encounters with stress can lead to long-lasting beneficial alterations in the response to various stressors, known as cross-tolerance. Embryonic heat conditioning (EHC) of chicks was previously shown to mediate resilience to heat stress later in life. Here we demonstrate that EHC can induce cross-tolerance with the immune system, attenuating hypothalamic inflammation. Inflammation in EHC chicks was manifested, following lipopolysaccharide (LPS) challenge on day 10 post-hatch, by reduced febrile response and reduced expression of LITAF and NFκB compared to controls, as well as nuclear localization and activation of NFκB in the hypothalamus. Since the cross-tolerance effect was long-lasting, we assumed that epigenetic mechanisms are involved. We focused on the role of ten-eleven translocation (TET) family enzymes, which are the mediators of active CpG demethylation. Here, TET transcription during early life stress was found to be necessary for stress resilience later in life. The expression of the TET family enzymes in the midbrain during conditioning increased in parallel to an elevation in concentration of their cofactor α-ketoglutarate. In-ovo inhibition of TET activity during EHC, by the α-ketoglutarate inhibitor bis-2-(5-phenylacetamido-1,3,4-thiadiazol-2-yl) ethyl sulfide (BPTES), resulted in reduced total and locus specific CpG demethylation in 10-day-old chicks and reversed both thermal and inflammatory resilience. In addition, EHC attenuated the elevation in expression of the stress markers HSP70, CRHR1, and CRHR2, during heat challenge on day 10 post-hatch. This reduction in expression was reversed by BPTES. Similarly, the EHC-dependent reduction of inflammatory gene expression during LPS challenge was eliminated in BPTES-treated chicks. Thus, TET family enzymes and CpG demethylation are essential for the embryonic induction of stress cross-tolerance in the hypothalamus.

Cross-tolerance: embryonic heat conditioning induces inflammatory resilience by affecting different layers of epigenetic mechanisms regulating IL6 expression later in life

A stressor can induce resilience in another, different stressor, a phenomenon known as cross-tolerance. To learn if cross-tolerance is governed by epigenetic regulation, we used embryonic heat conditioning (EHC) in chicks, during the development of the hypothalamus, to increase the immunization response. Indeed, EHC induced a lifelong systemic antibody response to immunization, in addition to reduced hypothalamic IL6 inflammatory expression following LPS challenge. Since the outcome of EHC was long-term cross-tolerance with the immune system, we studied possible epigenetic mechanisms. We first analysed the methylation and hydroxymethylation patterns of IL6. We found reduced hydroxymethylation on IL6 intron 1 in the EHC group, a segment enriched with CpGs and NFkB-binding sites. Luciferase assay in cell lines expressing NFkB showed that IL6 intron 1 is indeed an enhancer. ChiP in the same segment against NFkB in the hypothalamus presented reduced binding to IL6 intron 1 in the EHC group, before and during LPS challenge. In parallel, EHC chicks' IL6 intron 1 presented increased H3K27me3, a repressive translational modification mediated by EZH2. This histone modification occurred during embryonic conditioning and persisted later in life. Moreover, we showed reduced expression of miR-26a, which inhibits EZH2 transcription, during conditioning along with increased EZH2 expression. We demonstrate that stress cross-tolerance, which was indicated by EHC-induced inflammatory resilience and displayed by attenuated inflammatory expression of IL6, is regulated by different epigenetic layers.

Cross-talk between energy metabolism and epigenetics during temperature stress response in C2C12 myoblasts

Objective: Environmental stress induces disturbances in cell energy metabolism and may cause epigenetic modifications. This study aimed to understand the possible impact of temperature stress (35 °C, 39 °C and 41 °C, compared to control 37 °C) on energy metabolism and epigenetic modifications, such as DNA methylation and histone H4 acetylation, as well as its effects on the expression of genes responsible for epigenetic changes, in mouse skeletal myoblasts (C2C12 cells). Methods: The results showed significantly reduced maximal respiration and spare respiratory capacity under heat stress (39 °C and 41 °C), suggesting that mitochondrial functions were compromised under these conditions. The glycolytic capacity and glycolysis markedly increased following low-temperature stress (35 °C). The results suggested that, under cold stress, cells prefer glycolysis as a rapid compensatory mechanism to meet energy requirements for adaptive thermogenic response. Results: Epigenetic changes (histone H4 acetylation and global DNA methylation) were observed under both heat and cold stress. Among the genes coding for DNA methyltransferases, the Dnmt3a was significantly increased under high-temperature conditions (39 °C and 41 °C), while Dnmt1 expression was significantly increased at low temperature (35 °C), indicating that under these conditions the cells preferred maintenance of methylation to de novo methylation activity. An expression pattern similar to Dnmt3a was observed for Gcn5, encoding for a histone acetyltransferase. The study revealed that temperature stress induced changes in the metabolic profiles, as well as epigenetic modifications, including the dynamics of the key enzymes. Conclusion: The results indicated the existence of crosstalk mechanisms between energy metabolism and epigenetics during cell stress response.

TREM2 Regulates Heat Acclimation-Induced Microglial M2 Polarization Involving the PI3K-Akt Pathway Following EMF Exposure

The function of triggering receptor expressed on myeloid cells-2 (TREM2) has been described within microglia with a beneficial activated phenotype. However, the role of TREM2 underlying microglial phenotypic alterations in the cross-tolerance protection of heat acclimation (HA) against the inflammatory stimuli electromagnetic field (EMF) exposure is less well known. Here, we investigated the TREM2-related signaling mechanism induced by HA in EMF-stimulated N9 microglial cells (N9 cells). We found that EMF exposure significantly increased the production of pro-inflammatory cytokines tumor necrosis factor-α (TNF-α, IL-1β, and IL-6), and the expression of M1 markers (CD11b and CD86); meanwhile, decreased the levels of anti-inflammatory cytokines (IL-4 and IL-10) and the expression of M2 markers (CD206 and Arg1) in N9 cells. Clearly, HA treatment decreased the secretion of TNF-α, IL-1β and IL-6 and the expression of CD11b and CD86, and enhanced the production of IL-4 and IL-10 and the expression of CD206 and Arg1. Moreover, TREM2 esiRNA and selective inhibitor of PI3K clearly decreased anti-inflammatory cytokines production, M2 markers expression, and phosphorylation of PI3K and Akt following HA plus EMF stimulation. These results indicate that TREM2 and PI3K-Akt pathway are involved in the cross-tolerance protective effect of HA in microglial polarization towards the EMF exposure. This finding inspires future studies that aim to explore the non-drug approaches underlying EMF stimulation and other central nervous system (CNS) inflammatory diseases.

Thermal Manipulation During Embryogenesis Impacts H3K4me3 and H3K27me3 Histone Marks in Chicken Hypothalamus

Changes in gene activity through epigenetic alterations induced by early environmental challenges during embryogenesis are known to impact the phenotype, health, and disease risk of animals. Learning how environmental cues translate into persisting epigenetic memory may open new doors to improve robustness and resilience of developing animals. It has previously been shown that the heat tolerance of male broiler chickens was improved by cyclically elevating egg incubation temperature. The embryonic thermal manipulation enhanced gene expression response in muscle (P. major) when animals were heat challenged at slaughter age, 35 days post-hatch. However, the molecular mechanisms underlying this phenomenon remain unknown. Here, we investigated the genome-wide distribution, in hypothalamus and muscle tissues, of two histone post-translational modifications, H3K4me3 and H3K27me3, known to contribute to environmental memory in eukaryotes. We found 785 H3K4me3 and 148 H3K27me3 differential peaks in the hypothalamus, encompassing genes involved in neurodevelopmental, metabolic, and gene regulation functions. Interestingly, few differences were identified in the muscle tissue for which differential gene expression was previously described. These results demonstrate that the response to embryonic thermal manipulation (TM) in chicken is mediated, at least in part, by epigenetic changes in the hypothalamus that may contribute to the later-life thermal acclimation.

Coordination of ABA and Chaperone Signaling in Plant Stress Responses

The abscisic acid (ABA) and chaperone signaling pathways are the central regulators of plant stress defense. Despite their significance and potential overlap, these systems have been described separately. In this review, we summarize information about mechanisms by which the ABA and chaperone signaling pathways might be coregulated. The central factors that join the ABA and chaperone signaling systems are the SWI/SNF chromatin-remodeling proteins, which are involved in stress memory. A benefit from coordination is that the signals sensed through both the ABA and chaperone signaling systems are perceived and stored via chromatin-remodeling factors. For improving plant stress resistance, we propose new bioengineering strategies, which we term 'bioengineering memory'.

Impact of environmental stressors on tolerance to hemorrhage in humans

Hemorrhage is a leading cause of death in military and civilian settings, and ~85% of potentially survivable battlefield deaths are hemorrhage-related. Soldiers and civilians are exposed to a number of environmental and physiological conditions that have the potential to alter tolerance to a hemorrhagic insult. The objective of this review is to summarize the known impact of commonly encountered environmental and physiological conditions on tolerance to hemorrhagic insult, primarily in humans. The majority of the studies used lower body negative pressure (LBNP) to simulate a hemorrhagic insult, although some studies employed incremental blood withdrawal. This review addresses, first, the use of LBNP as a model of hemorrhage-induced central hypovolemia and, then, the effects of the following conditions on tolerance to LBNP: passive and exercise-induced heat stress with and without hypohydration/dehydration, exposure to hypothermia, and exposure to altitude/hypoxia. An understanding of the effects of these environmental and physiological conditions on responses to a hemorrhagic challenge, including tolerance, can enable development and implementation of targeted strategies and interventions to reduce the impact of such conditions on tolerance to a hemorrhagic insult and, ultimately, improve survival from blood loss injuries.

Application of evidence-based recommendations for heat acclimation: Individual and team sport perspectives

Heat acclimation or acclimatization (HA) occurs with repeated exposure to heat inducing adaptations that enhance thermoregulatory mechanisms and heat tolerance leading to improved exercise performance in warm-to-hot conditions. HA is an essential heat safety and performance enhancement strategy in preparation for competitions in warm-to-hot conditions for both individual and team sports. Yet, some data indicate HA is an underutilized pre-competition intervention in athletes despite the well-known benefits; possibly due to a lack of practical information provided to athletes and coaches. Therefore, the aim of this review is to provide actionable evidence-based implementation strategies and protocols to induce and sustain HA. We propose the following suggestions to circumvent potential implementation barriers: 1) incorporate multiple induction methods during the initial acclimation period, 2) complete HA 1-3 weeks before competition in the heat to avoid training and logistical conflicts during the taper period, and 3) minimize adaptation decay through intermittent exercise-heat exposure or re-acclimating immediately prior to competition with 2-4 consecutive days of exercise-heat training. Use of these strategies may be desirable or necessary to optimize HA induction and retention around existing training or logistical requirements.