Advanced Imaging for Quantitative Evaluation of Aphanomyces Root Rot Resistance in Lentil

Suitable Methods of Inoculation and Quantification of Fusarium Root Rot in Lentil

Lentil (Lens culinaris L. subsp. culinaris) is an important grain legume grown worldwide. As its popularity grows among consumers and more acres are produced, new root rot complexes have become more prevalent. This work sought to develop methods for studying root rot caused by Fusarium avenaceum in lentil using controlled environments. The objectives were to (i) find an effective and seed-safe sterilization technique, (ii) optimize the inoculation technique and lentil growing environment, and (iii) develop visual and automated disease scoring systems. Results showed the use of detergent and a low concentration (0.1%) of NaClO (the active ingredient in bleach) maintained germinability and effectively eliminated bacterial and fungal contamination on seeds. Other treatments, such as ethanol, reduced seed germination or failed to kill pathogenic fungi such as Fusarium spp. Placing inoculum at a moderate rate of 1 × 10⁶ spores both directly on the seed and on top of the media covering the seed improved severity scores and reduced escapes compared with placement on top of the media only. Visual severity scoring systems and diagrammatic scales were developed for scoring the cotyledon region and roots. A computer vision algorithm was designed to improve the efficiency of scoring the cotyledon region and roots for disease severity using a simple RGB camera and lightbox. Visual and computer scores were best correlated when images were visually scored on a monitor, and multiple images were averaged. The scores generated from the computer vision algorithm had better correlations with visual scores for cotyledon rot (r = 0.92 and β₁ = 0.96) than root rot (r = 0.62 and β₁ = 0.67).

Remote sensing for field pea yield estimation: A study of multi-scale data fusion approaches in phenomics

Introduction

Remote sensing using unmanned aerial systems (UAS) are prevalent for phenomics and precision agricultural applications. The high-resolution data for these applications can provide useful spectral characteristics of crops associated with performance traits such as seed yield. With the recent availability of high-resolution satellite imagery, there has been growing interest in using this technology for plot-scale remote sensing applications, particularly those related to breeding programs. This study compared the features extracted from high-resolution satellite and UAS multispectral imagery (visible and near-infrared) to predict the seed yield from two diverse plot-scale field pea yield trials (advanced breeding and variety testing) using the random forest model.

Methods

The multi-modal (spectral and textural features) and multi-scale (satellite and UAS) data fusion approaches were evaluated to improve seed yield prediction accuracy across trials and time points. These approaches included both image fusion, such as pan-sharpening of satellite imagery with UAS imagery using intensity-hue-saturation transformation and additive wavelet luminance proportional approaches, and feature fusion, which involved integrating extracted spectral features. In addition, we also compared the image fusion approach to high-definition satellite data with a resolution of 0.15 m/pixel. The effectiveness of each approach was evaluated with data at both individual and combined time points.

Results and discussion

The major findings can be summarized as follows: (1) the inclusion of the texture features did not improve the model performance, (2) the performance of the model using spectral features from satellite imagery at its original resolution can provide similar results as UAS imagery, with variation depending on the field pea yield trial under study and the growth stage, (3) the model performance improved after applying multi-scale, multiple time point feature fusion, (4) the features extracted from the pan-sharpened satellite imagery using intensity-hue-saturation transformation (image fusion) showed better model performance than those with original satellite imagery or high definition imagery, and (5) the green normalized difference vegetation index and transformed triangular vegetation index were identified as key features contributing to high model performance across trials and time points. These findings demonstrate the potential of high-resolution satellite imagery and data fusion approaches for plot-scale phenomics applications.

Evaluation of Effective Class-Balancing Techniques for CNN-Based Assessment of Aphanomyces Root Rot Resistance in Pea (Pisum sativum L.)

Aphanomyces root rot (ARR) is a devastating disease that affects the production of pea. The plants are prone to infection at any growth stage, and there are no chemical or cultural controls. Thus, the development of resistant pea cultivars is important. Phenomics technologies to support the selection of resistant cultivars through phenotyping can be valuable. One such approach is to couple imaging technologies with deep learning algorithms that are considered efficient for the assessment of disease resistance across a large number of plant genotypes. In this study, the resistance to ARR was evaluated through a CNN-based assessment of pea root images. The proposed model, DeepARRNet, was designed to classify the pea root images into three classes based on ARR severity scores, namely, resistant, intermediate, and susceptible classes. The dataset consisted of 1581 pea root images with a skewed distribution. Hence, three effective data-balancing techniques were identified to solve the prevalent problem of unbalanced datasets. Random oversampling with image transformations, generative adversarial network (GAN)-based image synthesis, and loss function with class-weighted ratio were implemented during the training process. The result indicated that the classification F1-score was 0.92 ± 0.03 when GAN-synthesized images were added, 0.91 ± 0.04 for random resampling, and 0.88 ± 0.05 when class-weighted loss function was implemented, which was higher than when an unbalanced dataset without these techniques were used (0.83 ± 0.03). The systematic approaches evaluated in this study can be applied to other image-based phenotyping datasets, which can aid the development of deep-learning models with improved performance.

Phenotypic and Genetic Characterization of the Lentil Single Plant-Derived Core Collection for Resistance to Root Rot Caused by Fusarium avenaceum

Lentil (Lens culinaris) is a pulse crop grown for its amino acid profile, moderate drought tolerance, and ability to fix nitrogen. As the global demand for lentils expands and new production regions emerge so too have the complement of diseases that reduce yield, including the root rot complex. Although the predominant causal pathogen varies based on growing region, Fusarium avenaceum is often found to be an important contributor to disease. This study screened part of the lentil single plant-derived core collection for resistance to F. avenaceum in a greenhouse. Plants were phenotyped for disease severity using three scoring scales and the differences in biomass traits due to pathogen presence were measured. Lentil accessions varied in disease severity and differences in biomass traits were found to be correlated with each visual severity estimate (r = -0.37 to -0.63, P < 0.001), however, heritability estimates were low to moderate among traits (H² = 0.12 to 0.43). Results of a genome-wide association study (GWAS) using single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) markers derived from genotyping-by-sequencing revealed 11 quantitative trait loci (QTL) across four chromosomes. Two pairs of QTL colocated for two traits and were found near putative orthologs that have been previously associated with plant disease resistance. The identification of lentil accessions that did not exhibit a difference in biomass traits may serve as parental material in breeding or in the development of biparental mapping populations to further validate and dissect the genetic control of resistance to root rot caused by F. avenaceum.

Analysis of RGB Plant Images to Identify Root Rot Disease in Korean Ginseng Plants Using Deep Learning

Ginseng is an important medicinal plant in Korea. The roots of the ginseng plant have medicinal properties; thus, it is very important to maintain the quality of ginseng roots. Root rot disease is a major disease that affects the quality of ginseng roots. It is important to predict this disease before it causes severe damage to the plants. Hence, there is a need for a non-destructive method to identify root rot disease in ginseng plants. In this paper, a method to identify the root rot disease by analyzing the RGB plant images using image processing and deep learning is proposed. Initially, plant segmentation is performed, and then the noise regions are removed in the plant images. These images are given as input to the proposed linear deep learning model to identify root rot disease in ginseng plants. Transfer learning models are also applied to these images. The performance of the proposed method is promising in identifying root rot disease.

A Novel Computational Framework for Precision Diagnosis and Subtype Discovery of Plant With Lesion

Plants are often attacked by various pathogens during their growth, which may cause environmental pollution, food shortages, or economic losses in a certain area. Integration of high throughput phenomics data and computer vision (CV) provides a great opportunity to realize plant disease diagnosis in the early stage and uncover the subtype or stage patterns in the disease progression. In this study, we proposed a novel computational framework for plant disease identification and subtype discovery through a deep-embedding image-clustering strategy, Weighted Distance Metric and the t-stochastic neighbor embedding algorithm (WDM-tSNE). To verify the effectiveness, we applied our method on four public datasets of images. The results demonstrated that the newly developed tool is capable of identifying the plant disease and further uncover the underlying subtypes associated with pathogenic resistance. In summary, the current framework provides great clustering performance for the root or leave images of diseased plants with pronounced disease spots or symptoms.

Omics Path to Increasing Productivity in Less-Studied Crops Under Changing Climate-Lentil a Case Study

Conventional breeding techniques for crop improvement have reached their full potential, and hence, alternative routes are required to ensure a sustained genetic gain in lentils. Although high-throughput omics technologies have been effectively employed in major crops, less-studied crops such as lentils have primarily relied on conventional breeding. Application of genomics and transcriptomics in lentils has resulted in linkage maps and identification of QTLs and candidate genes related to agronomically relevant traits and biotic and abiotic stress tolerance. Next-generation sequencing (NGS) complemented with high-throughput phenotyping (HTP) technologies is shown to provide new opportunities to identify genomic regions and marker-trait associations to increase lentil breeding efficiency. Recent introduction of image-based phenotyping has facilitated to discern lentil responses undergoing biotic and abiotic stresses. In lentil, proteomics has been performed using conventional methods such as 2-D gel electrophoresis, leading to the identification of seed-specific proteome. Metabolomic studies have led to identifying key metabolites that help differentiate genotypic responses to drought and salinity stresses. Independent analysis of differentially expressed genes from publicly available transcriptomic studies in lentils identified 329 common transcripts between heat and biotic stresses. Similarly, 19 metabolites were common across legumes, while 31 were common in genotypes exposed to drought and salinity stress. These common but differentially expressed genes/proteins/metabolites provide the starting point for developing high-yielding multi-stress-tolerant lentils. Finally, the review summarizes the current findings from omic studies in lentils and provides directions for integrating these findings into a systems approach to increase lentil productivity and enhance resilience to biotic and abiotic stresses under changing climate.

High-Throughput Extraction of Seed Traits Using Image Acquisition and Analysis

Seed traits can easily be assessed using image processing tools to evaluate differences in crop variety performances in response to environment and stress. In this chapter, we describe a protocol to measure seed traits that can be applied to crops with small grains, including legume grains with little modification. The imaging processing tool can be applied to process a batch of images without human intervention. The method allows evaluation of geometric and color features, and currently extracts 11 seed traits that include number of seeds, seed area, major axis, minor axis, eccentricity, and mean and standard deviation of reflectance in red, green, and blue channels from seed images. Protocols or methods, including the one described in this chapter, facilitate phenotyping seed traits in a high-throughput and automated manner, which can be applied in plant breeding programs and food processing industry to evaluate seed quality.

Resources for image-based high-throughput phenotyping in crops and data sharing challenges

High-throughput phenotyping (HTP) platforms are capable of monitoring the phenotypic variation of plants through multiple types of sensors, such as red green and blue (RGB) cameras, hyperspectral sensors, and computed tomography, which can be associated with environmental and genotypic data. Because of the wide range of information provided, HTP datasets represent a valuable asset to characterize crop phenotypes. As HTP becomes widely employed with more tools and data being released, it is important that researchers are aware of these resources and how they can be applied to accelerate crop improvement. Researchers may exploit these datasets either for phenotype comparison or employ them as a benchmark to assess tool performance and to support the development of tools that are better at generalizing between different crops and environments. In this review, we describe the use of image-based HTP for yield prediction, root phenotyping, development of climate-resilient crops, detecting pathogen and pest infestation, and quantitative trait measurement. We emphasize the need for researchers to share phenotypic data, and offer a comprehensive list of available datasets to assist crop breeders and tool developers to leverage these resources in order to accelerate crop breeding.

Crop Performance Evaluation of Chickpea and Dry Pea Breeding Lines Across Seasons and Locations Using Phenomics Data

The Pacific Northwest is an important pulse production region in the United States. Currently, pulse crop (chickpea, lentil, and dry pea) breeders rely on traditional phenotyping approaches to collect performance and agronomic data to support decision making. Traditional phenotyping poses constraints on data availability (e.g., number of locations and frequency of data acquisition) and throughput. In this study, phenomics technologies were applied to evaluate the performance and agronomic traits in two pulse (chickpea and dry pea) breeding programs using data acquired over multiple seasons and locations. An unmanned aerial vehicle-based multispectral imaging system was employed to acquire image data of chickpea and dry pea advanced yield trials from three locations during 2017-2019. The images were analyzed semi-automatically with custom image processing algorithm and features were extracted, such as canopy area and summary statistics associated with vegetation indices. The study demonstrated significant correlations (P < 0.05) between image-based features (e.g., canopy area and sum normalized difference vegetation index) with yield (r up to 0.93 and 0.85 for chickpea and dry pea, respectively), days to 50% flowering (r up to 0.76 and 0.85, respectively), and days to physiological maturity (r up to 0.58 and 0.84, respectively). Using image-based features as predictors, seed yield was estimated using least absolute shrinkage and selection operator regression models, during which, coefficients of determination as high as 0.91 and 0.80 during model testing for chickpea and dry pea, respectively, were achieved. The study demonstrated the feasibility to monitor agronomic traits and predict seed yield in chickpea and dry pea breeding trials across multiple locations and seasons using phenomics tools. Phenomics technologies can assist plant breeders to evaluate the performance of breeding materials more efficiently and accelerate breeding programs.

Dissecting the Genetic Architecture of Aphanomyces Root Rot Resistance in Lentil by QTL Mapping and Genome-Wide Association Study

Lentil (Lens culinaris Medikus) is an important source of protein for people in developing countries. Aphanomyces root rot (ARR) has emerged as one of the most devastating diseases affecting lentil production. In this study, we applied two complementary quantitative trait loci (QTL) analysis approaches to unravel the genetic architecture underlying this complex trait. A recombinant inbred line (RIL) population and an association mapping population were genotyped using genotyping by sequencing (GBS) to discover novel single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). QTL mapping identified 19 QTL associated with ARR resistance, while association mapping detected 38 QTL and highlighted accumulation of favorable haplotypes in most of the resistant accessions. Seven QTL clusters were discovered on six chromosomes, and 15 putative genes were identified within the QTL clusters. To validate QTL mapping and genome-wide association study (GWAS) results, expression analysis of five selected genes was conducted on partially resistant and susceptible accessions. Three of the genes were differentially expressed at early stages of infection, two of which may be associated with ARR resistance. Our findings provide valuable insight into the genetic control of ARR, and genetic and genomic resources developed here can be used to accelerate development of lentil cultivars with high levels of partial resistance to ARR.

Generalized Linear Model with Elastic Net Regularization and Convolutional Neural Network for Evaluating Aphanomyces Root Rot Severity in Lentil

Phenomics technologies allow quantitative assessment of phenotypes across a larger number of plant genotypes compared to traditional phenotyping approaches. The utilization of such technologies has enabled the generation of multidimensional plant traits creating big datasets. However, to harness the power of phenomics technologies, more sophisticated data analysis methods are required. In this study, Aphanomyces root rot (ARR) resistance in 547 lentil accessions and lines was evaluated using Red-Green-Blue (RGB) images of roots. We created a dataset of 6,460 root images that were annotated by a plant breeder based on the disease severity. Two approaches, generalized linear model with elastic net regularization (EN) and convolutional neural network (CNN), were developed to classify disease resistance categories into three classes: resistant, partially resistant, and susceptible. The results indicated that the selected image features using EN models were able to classify three disease categories with an accuracy of up to 0.91 ± 0.004 (0.96 ± 0.005 resistant, 0.82 ± 0.009 partially resistant, and 0.92 ± 0.007 susceptible) compared to CNN with an accuracy of about 0.84 ± 0.009 (0.96 ± 0.008 resistant, 0.68 ± 0.026 partially resistant, and 0.83 ± 0.015 susceptible). The resistant class was accurately detected using both classification methods. However, partially resistant class was challenging to detect as the features (data) of the partially resistant class often overlapped with those of resistant and susceptible classes. Collectively, the findings provided insights on the use of phenomics techniques and machine learning approaches to provide quantitative measures of ARR resistance in lentil.