Confirmation of Paternity despite Three Genetic Incompatibilities at Chromosome 2

Case reports on uniparental disomy of chromosomes 6 and 3 in paternity testing

In paternity testing, when there are Mendelian errors in the alleles between the child and the parents, a slippage mutation, or silent allele may not fully explain the phenomenon. Sometimes, it is attributed to chromosomal abnormalities, such as uniparental disomy (UPD). Here, we present the investigation of two cases of suspected UPD in paternity testing based on short tandem repeat (STR) detection (capillary electrophoresis platform). Case 1 involves a trio, where all genotypes detected on chromosome 6 in the child are homozygous and found in the father. Case 2 is a duo (mother and child), where all genotypes on chromosome 3 in the child are homozygous and not always found in the mother. At the same time, Mendelian error alleles were also observed at specific loci in these two chromosomes. Furthermore, we used the MGIEasy Signature Identification Library Prep Kit for sequencing on the massively parallel sequencing platform, which included common autosomal, X and Y chromosomes, and mitochondrial genetic markers used in forensic practice. The results showed that the genotypes of shared STRs on the two platforms were consistent, and STRs and single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) on these two chromosomes were homozygous. All other genetic markers followed the laws of inheritance. A comprehensive analysis supported the parent-child relationship between the child and the alleged parent, and the observed genetic anomalies can be attributed to UPD. UPD occurrences are rare, and ignoring its presence can lead to erroneous exclusions in paternity testing, particularly when multiple loci on a chromosome exhibit homozygosity.

Analysis of homozygous allele mismatches in paternity tests with massively parallel sequencing

In paternity testing, short tandem repeats (STRs) allele mismatches are often detected. Nowadays, polymerase chain reaction- and capillary electrophoresis (CE)-based STR genotyping is the most commonly used method to distinguish alleles based on their length. However, it could not detect alleles of the same size with sequence differences. Massively parallel sequencing (MPS) can determine not only allele sizes but also sequences, which could explain the causes of allele mismatches. Additionally, more types of genetic markers can be detected in a single assay, which increases the discriminatory power and facilitates the analysis of paternity tests. In this study, we analyzed 11 cases with homozygous allele mismatches from routine DNA trio paternity tests using the CE platform. Samples were sequenced using the ForenSeq DNA Signature Prep Kit and the MiSeq FGx Sequencing System. The results show that of the eight father-child mismatch cases and three mother-child mismatch cases, five cases with D5S818 and D8S1179 and one case at D13S317 were classified as non-amplification. The other three cases and two cases could be defined as mutations. This study suggests that MPS-based STR genotyping can provide additional information that allows more accurate interpretation of allelic mismatches in paternity testing.

Effect of uniparental disomy in parentage testing

Uniparental disomy (UPD) is a rare type of chromosomal aberration that may hinder the analysis of kinship during forensic identification. Here, we investigated these genetic findings to avoid false exclusions during parentage testing. Thirty-nine fluorescently labeled, autosomal short tandem repeats (STR) were amplified in three cases, to detect parent-child relationships. Twenty-three fluorescently labeled Y-chromosome STRs were also employed. These were subjected to capillary electrophoresis. The parentage index was calculated by the bipartite or tripartite model. Single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) microarrays were performed to further investigate the genetic mechanisms. The conclusions supported the biological mother-child relationship in three cases. However, in all cases, the alleged father and child had three autosomal STR markers, constrained to a single chromosome, which did not conform to Mendelian inheritance rules. The genotyping of 23 Y-chromosome STRs did not reveal any violations of Mendelian law. The combination of STR profiling and SNP microarrays suggested that two children had maternal UPD of chromosome 7, whilst one had UPD of chromosome 2. After excluding the three incompatible loci, the conclusions supported the biological father-child relationship in all cases. The same results were obtained when parentage testing of trios was used. Uniparental disomy may complicate the judgment of kinship in parentage testing. The possibility of UPD should be considered when incompatible STR loci are found on the same chromosome. Genetic evidence obtained through additional molecular techniques can provide better interpretation of kinship in the presence of UPD and avoid false exclusions of biological relationships.

Analysis of aborted fetal material using autosomal STR markers in forensic cases of sexual assault

Sexual violence represents a widespread social problem associated with serious lifelong consequences. In many cases, an outcome of sexual violence is the victim's unwanted pregnancy, usually ended in an abortion. The objective of this paper is to report five rape cases, including rapes of a minor and young woman, two incest cases and a case of human trafficking for sexual exploitation, where every case resulted in the victim's pregnancy. In each case, pregnancy was terminated in the first trimester or at the beginning of the second trimester in the relevant medical center or clinic. Fresh fetal blood or aborted tissue samples were delivered to our laboratory in order to perform paternity testing for the purpose of proving the crime. DNA extraction using Qiagen Dneasy™ Tissue Kit was optimized according to the sample type. Amplification of autosomal STR (Short Tandem Repeat) markers was performed using the PowerPlex®16 System. In two cases, mixtures of maternal and fetal DNA in the aborted fetal material were found. Using the LRmix Studio v.2.1.5 Software for interpreting DNA mixtures based on a probabilistic model, the likelihoods of maternal contribution and presence of fetal allelic variants inherited from the alleged father/suspect were calculated. Based on these results, we confirmed the presence of assumed fetal fractions (determined before software analysis) in the mixtures. In all cases, positive paternity proved the crime (probabilities of paternity >99.9999%). This cases report once again pointed out the importance of DNA analysis in the process of clarifying and solving forensic cases and demonstrated that the LRmix Studio v.2.1.5 Software can deal with complex cases such as sexual assaults.