A Commentary on the Use of Bivalve Mollusks in Monitoring Metal Pollution Levels

Antioxidant defenses and metabolic responses of Mytilus coruscus exposed to various concentrations of PAEs (phthalate esters)

Phthalate esters (PAEs), as a major plasticizer with multi-biotoxicity, are frequently detected in marine environments, and potentially affecting the survival of aquatic organisms. In the study, three typical PAEs (dimethyl phthalate [DMP], dibutyl phthalate [DBP] and di(2-ethylhexyl) phthalate [DEHP]) were selected to investigate the accumulation patterns and ecotoxicological effects on Mytilus coruscus (M. coruscus). In M. coruscus, the accumulation was DEHP>DBP>DMP, and the bioaccumulation in tissues was digestive glands>gills>gonads>muscles. Meanwhile, the activities of superoxide dismutase (SOD) and catalase (CAT) showed an activation-decrease-activation trend of stress, with more pronounced concentration effects. Glutathione reductase (GSH) activity was significantly increased, and its expression was more sensitive to be induced at an early stage. The metabolic profiles of the gonads, digestive glands and muscle tissues were significantly altered, and DEHP had a greater effect on the metabolic profiles of M. coruscus, with the strongest interference. PAEs stress for 7 d significantly altered the volatile components of M. coruscus, with potential implications for their nutritional value. This study provides a biochemical, metabolomic, and nutritional analysis of DMP, DBP, and DEHP toxic effects on M. coruscus from a multidimensional perspective, which provides support for ecotoxicological studies of PAEs on marine organisms. ENVIRONMENTAL IMPLICATION: Phthalate esters (PAEs), synthetic compounds from phthalic acid, are widespread in the environment, household products, aquatic plants, animals, and crops, posing a significant threat to human health. However, the majority of toxicological studies examining the effects of PAEs on aquatic organisms primarily focus on non-economic model organisms like algae and zebrafish. Relatively fewer studies have been conducted on marine organisms, particularly economically important shellfish. So, this study is innovative and necessary. This study provides a biochemical, metabolomic, and nutritional analysis of DMP, DBP, and DEHP toxic effects on mussels, and supports the ecotoxicology of PAEs on marine organisms.

Copper and zinc isotope systematics in different bivalve mollusk species from the French coastline: Implications for biomonitoring

Zinc (Zn) and copper (Cu) stable isotopic compositions have been analyzed in various species of bivalve mollusks worldwide, but no comprehensive systematic interspecies comparison exists. Thus, we assessed isotope differences between species harvested in emblematic French coastal ecosystems to unveil biologically driven Cu and Zn isotope fractionation patterns. Inter-species isotopic variability of Cu is larger than Zn, with organisms that regulate internal concentrations displaying preferential bioaccumulation of heavy isotopes. The degree of internal isotope fractionation decreases from mussels > clams > oysters, affecting Cu more than Zn. The less pronounced Zn inter-specie variability helps preserve source information more reliably. Spatial analysis of a single oyster species denotes thus an important isotope variability of environmental Zn sources, including natural, anthropogenic and dietary components. Overall, results highlight the importance of considering systematic offset in Cu and Zn isotope values when comparing data from different bivalve species.

The French Mussel Watch Program reveals the attenuation of coastal lead contamination over four decades

The mid-20th century industrial peak caused severe global lead (Pb) marine contamination. Although Europe initiated Pb emission reduction regulations in the 1980s, the short- and long-term impacts remain unclear. This study investigates the evolution of Pb contamination on the French coast through elemental and isotope analysis in oysters and mussels from the French "Mussel Watch" Program. Observations at 114 monitoring stations over four decades have shown decreasing Pb levels in these bivalve mollusks. In 1988, 95 % exceeded the background reference values; this level had dropped to 39 % by 2021. The Pb isotope ratios in bivalves from eight target sites revealed a reduction in bioaccumulated anthropogenic Pb, albeit without complete elimination. The long residence time of legacy Pb combined with inputs from diffuse urban sources likely explains the persistent presence of anthropogenic Pb on the French coast. This study endorses the importance of continuous biomonitoring to evaluate environmental regulations and policies.

Metallic trace element contamination of the giant clam Tridacna maxima in French Polynesia

This study is a first assessment of Metallic Trace Elements (MTE) contamination of four lagoons in French Polynesia, chosen because their main anthropic uses are potential sources of MTE (military, agriculture, maritime). We used the giant clam Tridacna maxima as a biointegrator of fifteen MTE to assess the environmental footprint of human activities. The study of organotropism showed that not only the kidney but also the gonad and digestive system (GDS) are accumulator organs of interest for ETM biomonitoring. This result confirms that heterotrophic feeding is the pathway of ETM accumulation. Here, T. maxima appeared to be a super-accumulator of Ni (2700 ppm.dw), but also revealed at Tubuai (As, Fe, Mn) and Arutua (Cd, Zn) the environmental footprint of agricultural and maritime activities. The concentration of Cd recorded in Arutua (5 ppm.dw) both in KID and GDS, also underline the need for better control of effluents resulting from human activities.

A review of natural and anthropogenic radionuclide pollution in marine bivalves

Radionuclide contamination in food is a public health issue. Bivalves are known to accumulate relatively high levels of radionuclides. Despite many relevant reports, this information is poorly organized. Therefore, in this study, we conducted a comprehensive scientific review of radionuclides in marine bivalves. In general, the accumulation of radionuclides in bivalves is highly species and tissue-specific, which may be due to the different biological half-life of radionuclides in different species and tissues. The trophic pathway is the main pathway for the accumulation of most radionuclides in bivalves, with polonium-210 (210Po) and lead-210 (210Pb) potentially selectively accumulating in the digestive glands, while 134Cs and 137Cs selectively accumulating in the adductor muscle and mantle. Some other radionuclides (radium-226 (226Ra) and strontium-90 (90Sr)) are absorbed along with other minerals (e.g. Calcium) and selectively accumulate in bivalve shells. The information in this study can provide an overview of radionuclide contamination in marine bivalves.

The impact of microplastics on bivalve mollusks: A bibliometric and scientific review

Bivalves are important members of the ecosystem and their populations are declining globally, making them a concern for their role in ecosystem services and the fishing industry. Bivalves are excellent bioindicators of MPs pollution due to their widespread distribution, filtering capabilities, and close association with human health. Microplastics (MPs) have direct and indirect impacts on bivalves, affecting their physiology, habitat structure, food sources, and persistence of organic pollutants. This review provides an extensive overview of the impact of MPs on bivalves, covering various aspects such as their economic significance, ecological roles, and importance in biomonitoring environmental quality. The article presents the current state of knowledge on the sources and pathways of MPs in aquatic environments and their effects on bivalves. The mechanisms underlying the effects of MPs on bivalves, including ingestion, filtration activity, feeding inhibition, accumulation, bioaccumulation, and reproduction, are also discussed. Additionally, a bibliometric analysis of research on MPs in bivalves is presented, highlighting the number of papers, geographical distribution, and keyword clusters relating to MPs. Finally, the review emphasizes the importance of ongoing research and the development of mitigation strategies to reduce the negative effects of MPs pollution on bivalves and their habitats in oceans and coastal waters.

Quantitative determination of heavy metal contaminants in edible soft tissue of clams, mussels, and oysters

Aquatic environments are important sources of healthy and nutritious foods; however, clams, mussels, and oysters (the bivalves most consumed by humans) can pose considerable health risks to consumers if contaminated by heavy metals in polluted areas. These organisms can accumulate dangerously high concentrations of heavy metals (e.g., Cd, Hg, Pb) in their soft tissues that can then be transferred to humans following ingestion. Monitoring contaminants in clams, mussels and oysters and their environments is critically important for global human health and food security, which requires reliable measurement of heavy-metal concentrations in the soft tissues. The aim of our present paper is to provide a review of how heavy metals are quantified in clams, mussels, and oysters. We do this by evaluating sample-preparation methods (i.e., tissue digestion / extraction and analyte preconcentration) and instrumental techniques (i.e., atomic, fluorescence and mass spectrometric methods, chromatography, neutron activation analysis and electrochemical sensors) that have been applied for this purpose to date. Application of these methods, their advantages, limitations, challenges and expected future directions are discussed.

Efficient, Green, and Low-Cost Conversion of Bivalve-Shell Wastes to Value-Added Calcium Lactate

This work presents the efficient, green, and low-cost preparation of calcium lactate by using bivalve-shell wastes (cockle, mussel, and oyster shells) as raw materials. Three bivalve shells, a cockle, mussel, and oyster, were used separately as an alternative calcium-source material for the preparation of calcium lactate. The bivalve-shell waste was cleaned and milled, obtaining calcium carbonate (CaCO3) powder, which reacted to the lactic acid, forming calcium lactate. The effects of different calcium sources (cockle, mussel, and oyster) and different lactic acid concentrations (6, 8, and 10 mol/L) on the physicochemical properties of the synthesized calcium lactates were then investigated. The results pointed out that the highest solubility of the product was observed when 6 mol/L lactic acid and cockle-shell derived CaCO3 were employed for the calcium lactate preparation. The thermal decompositions of all calcium lactates occurred in three processes: dehydration, ethyl-lactate elimination, and decarbonization, respectively. The results, obtained from an infrared spectrometer, X-ray diffractometer, thermogravimetric analyzer, and scanning electron microscope, confirmed the formation of calcium lactate pentahydrate (Ca(CH3CHOHCOO)2·5H2O). The diffractograms also indicated the presence of two enantiomers of Ca(CH3CHOHCOO)2·5H2O, namely, of dl- and l-enantiomers, which depended on the lactic acid concentration used in the preparation process. The morphologies of calcium lactates show the firewood-like crystals in different microsizes, together with smaller irregular crystals. In summary, this work reports an effective process to prepare the valuable calcium lactates by using the cheap bivalve-shell-derived CaCO3 as a renewable calcium source.

Histopathological alterations in the gonads of wild white clams Dosinia ponderosa inhabiting a former copper mine locality in the Gulf of California

OBJECTIVE

Prolonged exposure to heavy metals, such as Pb, Hg, or Cu, has multiple adverse effects on marine organisms at the cellular, physiological, and population levels. Bivalves' histopathology provides a sensitive biomarker of pollutant-induced stress and environmental health. Gonad tissue deterioration is of particular concern, as it affects the reproductive success of a species. This study aimed to examine the histopathological alterations caused by metal exposure in the gonad of the white clam Dosinia ponderosa.

METHODS

Organisms were sampled from three locations in the Gulf of California: Santa Rosalia (SR), a former Cu mining town; San Lucas beach (SL), a nearby site influenced by pollution; and Escondida beach (EB), which served as a control site. Histological and histochemical stains were used, and the prevalence and intensity level of each alteration were calculated.

RESULT

The prevalence of alterations was higher in the ovaries of SR clams (92% compared to 60% in SL clams and 32.7% in EB clams), during spawning (91.4% compared to 20% in SL clams and 4.7% in EB clams), and in winter (93.5% compared to 30% in SL clams and 17.4% in EB clams).

CONCLUSION

These findings suggest a significant deterioration in the gonads of white clams from SR, probably linked to the chronic exposure to high concentrations of Cu and possibly other heavy metals; hence, the reproductive health of the clams is likely compromised.

Impact of Pb Toxicity on the Freshwater Pearl Mussel, Lamellidens marginalis: Growth Metrics, Hemocyto-Immunology, and Histological Alterations in Gill, Kidney, and Muscle Tissue

Pb is one of the most extensively used harmful heavy metals in Bangladesh, and its occurrence in waters affects aquatic organisms significantly. The tropical pearl mussel, Lamellidens marginalis, was exposed to different concentrations (T₁ 21.93 mgL^-1, T₂ 43.86 mgL^-1, and T₃ 87.72 mgL^-1) of Pb(NO₃)₂ and was evaluated against a control C 0 mgL^-1 of Pb(NO₃)₂, followed by a 96 h acute toxicity test. The LC₅₀ value was recorded as 219.32 mgL^-1. The physicochemical parameters were documented regularly for each treatment unit. The values of % SGR, shell weight, soft tissue wet weight, and weight gain remained statistically higher for the control group in comparison with the treatment. No mortality was noted for control units, while a gradually decreased survival rate was recorded for the different treatment groups. Fulton's condition factor was recorded as highest in the control and lowest in the T₃ unit, while the condition indices did not vary between the control and treatment groups. The hemocyte was accounted as maximum in the control and T₁, while minimum in T₂ and T₃. The serum lysosomal parameters also followed a similar pattern, and a significantly low level of lysosomal membrane stability, and serum lysosome activity was noted for T₃ and T₂ units in comparison to the control group. The histology of the gill, kidney, and muscle was well structured in the control group, while distinct pathologies were observed in the gill, kidney, and muscle tissue of different treatment groups. The quantitative comparison revealed that the intensity of pathological alteration increased as the dosage of Pb increased. The current study, therefore, indicated that intrusion of Pb(NO₃)₂ in the living medium significantly alters growth performance and hemocyte counts, and chronic toxicity induces histomorphological abnormalities in vital organs.

Biomonitoring of potentially toxic elements through oysters (Saccostrea palmula and Crassostrea corteziensis) from coastal lagoons of Southeast Gulf of California, Mexico: health risk assessment

The coastal lagoons of the Gulf of California support important traditional fisheries and mollusc cultures (generally oysters) and receive important volumes of agricultural, industrial and urban effluents, consumption of the oysters could pose risk to human health. The concentrations of arsenic (As), cadmium (Cd), copper (Cu), iron (Fe), lead (Pb), and zinc (Zn) in the oysters Saccostrea palmula and Crassostrea corteziensis, from four coastal lagoons (Altata, AL; Macapule, ML; Navachiste, NL; El Colorado, ECL) in the Southeast Gulf of California, were seasonally evaluated (summer 2019-spring 2020). The order of magnitude of potentially toxic elements concentrations in the soft tissue in both oyster species and at all sites was Zn > Fe > Cu > As > Cd > Pb. Cadmium, Cu, Pb, and Zn exceeded the maximum permissible limits in more than one sampling site. The highest concentrations (mg kg^-1, wet weight) of As (4.2 ± 1.1, spring) and Cd (3.3 ± 0.7, autumn) were registered in S. palmula et al. and NL sampling sites, respectively. Crassostrea corteziensis presented higher levels of Cu (40.5 ± 6.7, spring), Pb (2.0 ± 0.4, spring), and Zn (96.9 ± 20.4, spring) in ECL and Fe (62.2 ± 25.4, autumn) in ML. The hazard quotient (HQ) values exceeded the safe level of 1 for Cd in S. palmula and C. corteziensis in NL for children (~ 16 kg weight). In addition, in children, the hazard index (HI) values in both species of oysters ranged from 0.7 to 2.1 and 0.6 to 1.9, respectively. On the other hand, the intake of the studied elements through the consumption of oysters would not induce adverse effects to human health (men and women weighing 70 and 60 kg, respectively); HQ and HI values were < 1.

Byssus of Green-Lipped Mussel Perna viridis as a Biomonitoring Biopolymer for Zinc Pollution in Coastal Waters

The present study aimed to confirm the use of the byssus (BYS) of the green-lipped mussel Perna viridis as a biomonitoring biopolymer for zinc (Zn) by comparing it to copper (Cu) and cadmium (Cd) pollution in coastal waters under experimental field conditions, based on the transplantation of caged mussels between polluted and unpolluted sites in the Straits of Johore (SOJ). Four important evidential points were found in the present study. First, the 34 field-collected populations with BYS/total soft tissue (TST) ratios > 1 indicated that the BYS was a more sensitive, concentrative, and accumulative biopolymer for the three metals than TST. Significant (p < 0.05) and positive correlations between BYS and TST in terms of the levels of the three metals were observed. Second, the data obtained in the present study were well-supported by the interspecific comparison, which indicated that the BYS of P. viridis was a significantly better biomonitoring biopolymer for the identification of coastal areas exposed to Zn, Cd, and Cu pollution and played the role of an excretion route of metal wastes. Third, the higher positive correlation coefficients for the metals between the BYS sedimentary geochemical fractions than the TST sedimentary geochemical fractions indicated that the BYS was more reflective of metal bioavailability and contamination in coastal waters. Fourth, and most importantly, the field-based cage transplantation study clearly indicated the accumulation and elimination of the three metals by the BYS in both polluted and unpolluted sites in the Straits of Johore. In sum, the BYS of P. viridis was confirmed as a better biopolymer than TST for Zn, as well as Cd and Cu, bioavailability and contamination in tropical coastal waters.

Remediation plan of nano/microplastic toxicity in food

Microplastic pollution is causing a stir globally due to its persistent and ubiquitous nature. The scientific collaboration is diligently working on improved, effective, sustainable, and cleaner measures to control the nano/microplastic load in the environment especially wrecking the aquatic habitat. This chapter discusses the challenges encountered in nano/microplastic control and improved technologies like density separation, continuous flow centrifugation, oil extraction protocol, electrostatic separation to extract and quantify the same. Although it is still in the early stages of research, biobased control measures, like meal worms and microbes to degrade microplastics in the environment have been proven effective. Besides the control measures, practical alternatives to microplastics can be developed like core-shell powder, mineral powder, and biobased food packaging systems like edible films and coatings developed using various nanotechnological tools. Lastly, the existing and ideal stage of global regulations is compared, and key research areas are pinpointed. This holistic coverage would enable manufacturers and consumers to reconsider their production and purchase decisions for sustainable development goals.

Meta-analysis reveals the species-, dose- and duration-dependent effects of cadmium toxicities in marine bivalves

Cadmium (Cd) is a typical pollutant in marine environment. Increasing studies have focused on the toxicological effects of Cd in marine bivalves. However, there were many conflicting findings of toxicological effects of Cd in marine bivalves. An integrated analysis performed on the published data of Cd toxicity in marine bivalves is still absent. In this study, a meta-analysis was performed on the toxic endpoints in bivalves exposed to aqueous-phase Cd from 87 studies screened from 1519 papers. Subgroup analyses were conducted according to the categories of species, tissue, exposure dose and duration. The results showed significant species-, duration- and dose-dependent responses in bivalves to aqueous-phase Cd exposure. In details, clams were more sensitive to Cd than oysters, mussels and scallops, indicated by the largest effect size in clams. Gill, hepatopancreas and hemolymph were top three tissues used to indicate Cd-induced toxicity and did not present a significant tissue-specific manner among them. With regard to toxicological effect subgroups, oxidative stress and detoxification were top two subgroups indicating Cd toxicities. Detoxification and genotoxicity subgroups presented higher response magnitudes. What is more, toxicological effect subgroups presented multiple dose- and duration-dependent curves. Oxidative stress and genotoxicity related endpoints presented significant increase trends with Cd exposure dose and were preferable biomarkers to marine Cd pollution. Detoxification and energy metabolism related endpoints showed inverted U-shaped and U-shaped dose-response curves, both of which could be explained by hormesis. The linear decrease in oxidative stress and energy metabolism related endpoints over time suggested their involvement into the adaptive mechanism in bivalves. Overall, this study provided not only a better understanding the responsive mechanisms of marine bivalves to Cd stress, but also a selection reference for biomarkers to aqueous-phase Cd pollution in marine environment.

Comparative study of immunological biomarkers in the carpet shell clams (Ruditapes decussatus) from metal-contaminated sites in the South Lagoon of Tunis (Tunisia)

The South Lagoon of Tunis (Tunisia) is a Mediterranean lagoon adversely affected by industrial contaminants, harbour activity and untreated urban sewage. In this lagoon, the clam Ruditapes decussatus has been widely used as a biomonitor of seawater pollution through measurements of parameters related to oxidative stress and neurotoxicity. However, few studies have considered parameters of the immune system of this species in the South Lagoon of Tunis. Therefore, the aim of the present work was to evaluate several immune-related parameters in the cell-free haemolymph of carpet shell clams sampled during August and February from three polluted sites in the South Lagoon of Tunis (S1, S2 and S3) and one less polluted site as a reference site (RS) in order to identify suitable biomarkers for environmental quality assessments of this ecosystem. Concerning the immune-related parameters, seasonal factors modulated phenoloxidase, lysozyme, protease and esterase activity, with lower values measured for samples collected in August than for samples collected in February. In fact, bactericidal activity against two of the pathogenic bacteria tested and the activity of most immune-related enzymes were reduced in the cell-free haemolymph of clams collected from the most sampling sites in August compared to February one. In addition, values of abiotic parameters (temperature, salinity and pH) and metal (cadmium, copper, iron, lead and zinc) concentrations in the clams' soft tissues, previously obtained and published by the authors, as well as the values of immune-related parameters were integrated using principal component analyses. Results indicated that the values of all measured immune-related parameters were negatively correlated with the temperature values and the variations most of these parameters highlighted that the chemical industrial area (S3) was the most impacted location within the South Lagoon of Tunis. The present study illustrates that the immune-related parameters measured in carpet shell clam cell-free haemolymph represent suitable biomarkers for environmental quality assessments because they provide effective seasonal and spatial discrimination.

Seagrass and green macroalgae Halimeda as biomonitoring tools for metal contamination in Chuuk, Micronesia: Pollution assessment and bioaccumulation

In this study, we evaluated metal accumulation in different species and tissues of seagrasses and green macroalgae Halimeda and assessed metal pollution levels in Chuuk, Micronesia. In seagrass, the concentrations of Ni, Cu, Zn, Cd, Pb, and Hg were higher in leaves than in roots, whereas Cr and As concentrations were higher in roots. Halimeda had higher concentrations of Ni than of the other metals, and the mean Ni concentration was approximately 2.1 times higher in Halimeda than in seagrass leaves. The concentrations of Cr, As, Cu, Pb, and Hg in Halimeda were similar to those in seagrasses, whereas the Zn and Cd concentrations in Halimeda were very low. Significant correlations in metal concentrations between sediment and both seagrasses and Halimeda were observed for Cr, Ni, Cu, Zn, and Pb. This study suggests that seagrasses and Halimeda are useful indicators for monitoring metal pollution in coastal environments.

Effect of the Elemental Content of Shells of the Bivalve Mollusks (Mytilus galloprovincialis) from Saldanha Bay (South Africa) on Their Crystallographic Texture

Simple Summary

The aim was to study the question of whether the texture of mollusk shells changes with alteration in their elemental composition. Even though significant differences between concentrations of elements among the stations were found, the crystallographic textures of mussel shells from the studied bays showed insignificant dissimilarities. The observed differences in the maximum values in the pole figures fell within the range of variability identified for the genus Mytilus. Nevertheless, they appeared to correlate with the concentrations of Br, Mg, and Sr, which merits further investigation using larger sample sizes and higher variabilities of the ecological state of mussels.

Abstract

A both wild and farmed mussels in natural conditions, anthropogenic inputs are usually reflected in the increase of the content of specific elements. To determine the possible effect of the elemental patterns of farmed and wild mussels (Mytilus galloprovincialis) collected in the Saldanha Bay area (South Africa) on the crystallographic texture of the shells, the content of 20 elements in shells and 24 in the soft tissue of mussels was determined by neutron activation analysis. The crystallographic texture of mussel shells was analyzed using time-of-flight neutron diffraction. The wild mussels from open ocean site live in stressful natural conditions and contain higher amounts of the majority of determined elements in comparison with mussels farmed in closed water areas with anthropogenic loadings. The changes between the maximums of the same pole figures of the three samples are in the range of variability identified for the genus Mytilus. The content of Cl, Sr, and I was the highest in mussels from the open ocean site, which is reflected by the lowest mass/length ratio. The determined crystallographic textures of mussels are relatively stable as shown in the analyzed pole figures despite the concentrations of Na, Mg, Cl, Br, Sr, and I in shells, which significantly differ for wild and farmed mussels. The stability of the crystallographic texture that we observed suggests that it can be used as a reference model, where if a very different texture is determined, increased attention to the ecological situation should be paid.

Trace Elements and Omega-3 Fatty Acids of Wild and Farmed Mussels (Mytilus galloprovincialis) Consumed in Bulgaria: Human Health Risks

The unique, closed ecosystem of the Black Sea is of significant global importance. The levels and health risk of some trace elements (As, Cd, Cr, Cu, Fe, Ni, Pb and Zn) in wild and farmed mussels (Mytilus galloprovincialis) collected from the Bulgarian part of the Black Sea were determined and using different approaches such as Estimated Daily Intake (EDI), Target Hazard Quotient (THQ), Hazard Index (HI), Target risk (TR), human health risk levels were assessed. The mean maximum concentrations of the elements Cd, Cr, Cu, Fe, Ni, Pb and Zn in all mussel samples were below the maximum permissible limits (MPLs) except that which exceeded the limit of 2.00 mg/kg ww. Eicosapentaenoic (EPA, 20:5n-3) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA, 22:6n-3) were the major polyunsaturated fatty acids. The fatty acids profile studied mussels showed that the farmed mussels had higher PUFA/SFA ratios, DHA and EPA + DHA content and lower SFA, AI and TI values. The target risk (TR) values for Pb, Cr, Ni and As were calculated, evaluated and showed acceptable or negligible levels. Target hazard quotients (THQs) and hazard index (HI) from elemental intake were below 1 indicated no hazard from consumption. The benefit-risk ratio indicated that wild and cultured M. galloprovincialis are safe for human consumption.