Electrical Signaling of Plants under Abiotic Stressors: Transmission of Stimulus-Specific Information

Bioelectronic tools for understanding the universal language of electrical signaling across species and kingdoms

Modern bioelectronic tools are rapidly advancing to detect electric potentials within networks of electrogenic cells, such as cardiomyocytes, neurons, and pancreatic beta cells. However, it is becoming evident that electrical signaling is not limited to the animal kingdom but may be a universal form of cell-cell communication. In this review, we discuss the existing evidence of, and tools used to collect, subcellular, single-cell and network-level electrical signals across kingdoms, including bacteria, plants, fungi, and even viruses. We discuss how cellular networks employ altered electrical "circuitry" and intercellular mechanisms across kingdoms, and we assess the functionality and scalability of cutting-edge nanobioelectronics to collect electrical signatures regardless of cell size, shape, or function. Researchers today aim to design micro- and nano-topographic structures which harness mechanosensitive membrane and cytoskeletal pathways that enable tight electrical coupling to subcellular compartments within high-throughput recording systems. Finally, we identify gaps in current knowledge of inter-species and inter-kingdom electrical signaling and propose critical milestones needed to create a central theory of electrical signaling across kingdoms. Our discussion demonstrates the need for high resolution, high throughput tools which can probe multiple, diverse cell types at once in their native or experimentally-modeled environments. These advancements will not only reveal the underlying biophysical laws governing the universal language of electrical communication, but can enable bidirectional electrical communication and manipulation of biological systems.

Analysis of the Mechanisms Underlying the Specificity of the Variation Potential Induced by Different Stimuli

Plants are able to perceive diverse environmental factors and form an appropriate systemic functional response. Systemic responses are induced by stimulus-specific long-distance signals that carry information about the stimulus. Variation potential is proposed as a candidate for the role of such a signal. Here, we focus on the mechanisms that determine the specificity of the variation potential under the action of different local stimuli. Local stimuli such as heating, burning and wounding cause variation potential, the parameters of which differ depending on the type of stimulus. It was found that the stimulus-specific features of the hydraulic signal monitored by changes in leaf thickness and variation potential, such as a greater amplitude upon heating and burning and a significant amplitude decrement upon burning and wounding, were similar. The main features of these signals are the greater amplitude upon heating and burning, and a significant amplitude decrement upon burning and wounding. Together with the temporal correspondence of signal propagation, this evidence indicates a role for the hydraulic signal in the induction of stimulus-specific variation potential. Experiments using mechanosensitive channel inhibitors have demonstrated that the hydraulic signal contributes more to the induction of the variation potential in the case of rapidly growing stimuli, such as burning and wounding, than in the case of gradual heating. For thermal stimuli (gradual heating and burning), a greater contribution, compared to wounding, of the chemical signal related to reactive oxygen species to the induction of the variation potential was demonstrated. Thus, the specificity of the parameters of the variation potential is determined by the different contributions of hydraulic and chemical signals.

Electrical Signaling Beyond Neurons

Neural action potentials (APs) are difficult to interpret as signal encoders and/or computational primitives. Their relationships with stimuli and behaviors are obscured by the staggering complexity of nervous systems themselves. We can reduce this complexity by observing that "simpler" neuron-less organisms also transduce stimuli into transient electrical pulses that affect their behaviors. Without a complicated nervous system, APs are often easier to understand as signal/response mechanisms. We review examples of nonneural stimulus transductions in domains of life largely neglected by theoretical neuroscience: bacteria, protozoans, plants, fungi, and neuron-less animals. We report properties of those electrical signals-for example, amplitudes, durations, ionic bases, refractory periods, and particularly their ecological purposes. We compare those properties with those of neurons to infer the tasks and selection pressures that neurons satisfy. Throughout the tree of life, nonneural stimulus transductions time behavioral responses to environmental changes. Nonneural organisms represent the presence or absence of a stimulus with the presence or absence of an electrical signal. Their transductions usually exhibit high sensitivity and specificity to a stimulus, but are often slow compared to neurons. Neurons appear to be sacrificing the specificity of their stimulus transductions for sensitivity and speed. We interpret cellular stimulus transductions as a cell's assertion that it detected something important at that moment in time. In particular, we consider neural APs as fast but noisy detection assertions. We infer that a principal goal of nervous systems is to detect extremely weak signals from noisy sensory spikes under enormous time pressure. We discuss neural computation proposals that address this goal by casting neurons as devices that implement online, analog, probabilistic computations with their membrane potentials. Those proposals imply a measurable relationship between afferent neural spiking statistics and efferent neural membrane electrophysiology.

Rediscovering Chara as a model organism for molecular and evo-devo studies

Chara has been used as a model for decades in the field of plant physiology, enabling the investigation of fundamental physiological processes. In electrophysiological studies, Chara has been utilized thanks to its large internodal cells that can be easily manipulated. Additionally, Chara played a pioneering role in elucidating the presence and function of the cytoskeleton in cytoplasmic streaming, predating similar findings in terrestrial plants. Its representation considerably declined following the establishment and routine application of genetic transformation techniques in Arabidopsis. Nevertheless, the recent surge in evo-devo studies can be attributed to the whole genome sequencing of the Chara braunii, which has shed light on ancestral traits prevalent in land plants. Surprisingly, the Chara braunii genome encompasses numerous genes that were previously regarded as exclusive to land plants, suggesting their acquisition prior to the colonization of terrestrial habitats. This review summarizes the established methods used to study Chara, while incorporating recent molecular data, to showcase its renewed importance as a model organism in advancing plant evolutionary developmental biology.

Electrical signalling and plant response to herbivory: A short review

For a long time, electrical signaling was neglected at the expense of signaling studies in plants being concentrated with chemical and hydraulic signals. Studies conducted in recent years have revealed that plants are capable of emitting, processing, and transmitting bioelectrical signals to regulate a wide variety of physiological functions. Many important biological and physiological phenomena are accompanied by these cellular electrical manifestations, which supports the hypothesis about the importance of bioelectricity as a fundamental 'model' for response the stresses environmental and for activities regeneration of these organisms. Electrical signals have also been characterized and discriminated against in genetically modified plants under stress mediated by sucking insects and/or by the application of systemic insecticides. Such results can guide future studies that aim to elucidate the factors involved in the processes of resistance to stress and plant defense, thus aiding in the development of successful strategies in integrated pest management. Therefore, this mini review includes the results of studies aimed at electrical signaling in response to biotic stress. We also demonstrated how the generation and propagation of electrical signals takes place and included a description of how these electrical potentials are measured.

Ion Channels in Electrical Signaling in Higher Plants

Electrical signals (ESs) appearing in plants under the action of various external factors play an important role in adaptation to changing environmental conditions. Generation of ES in higher plant cells is associated with activation of Ca2+, K+, and anion fluxes, as well as with changes in the activity of plasma membrane H+-ATPase. In the present review, molecular nature of the ion channels contributing to ESs transmission in higher plants is analyzed based on comparison of the data from molecular-genetic and electrophysiological studies. Based on such characteristics of ion channels as selectivity, activation mechanism, and intracellular and tissue localization, those ion channels that meet the requirements for potential participation in ES generation were selected from a wide variety of ion channels in higher plants. Analysis of the data of experimental studies performed on mutants with suppressed or enhanced expression of a certain channel gene revealed those channels whose activation contributes to ESs formation. The channels responsible for Ca2+ flux during generation of ESs include channels of the GLR family, for K+ flux - GORK, for anions - MSL. Consideration of the prospects of further studies suggests the need to combine electrophysiological and genetic approaches along with analysis of ion concentrations in intact plants within a single study.

Effect of low-dose ionizing radiation on spatiotemporal parameters of functional responses induced by electrical signals in tobacco plants

Plants growing under an increased radiation background may be exposed to additional stressors. Plant acclimatization is formed with the participation of stress signals that cause systemic responses-a change in the activity of physiological processes. In this work, we studied the mechanisms of the effect of ionizing radiation (IR) on the systemic functional responses induced by electrical signals. Chronic β-irradiation (31.3 μGy/h) have a positive effect on the morphometric parameters and photosynthetic activity of tobacco plants (Nicotiana tabacum L.) at rest. An additional stressor causes an electrical signal, which, when propagated, causes a temporary change in chlorophyll fluorescence parameters, reflecting a decrease in photosynthesis activity. Irradiation did not significantly affect the electrical signals. At the same time, more pronounced photosynthesis responses are observed in irradiated plants: both the amplitude and the leaf area covered by the reaction increase. The formation of such responses is associated with changes in pH and stomatal conductance, the role of which was analyzed under IR. Using tobacco plants expressing the fluorescent pH-sensitive protein Pt-GFP, it was shown that IR enhances signal-induced cytoplasmic acidification. It was noted that irradiation also disrupts the correlation between the amplitudes of the electrical signal, pH shifts, changes in chlorophyll fluorescence parameters. Also stronger inhibition of stomatal conductance by the signal was shown in irradiated plants. It was concluded that the effect of IR on the systemic response induced by the electrical signal is mainly due to its effect on the stage of signal transformation into the response.

Relative Membrane Potential Measurements Using DISBAC2(3) Fluorescence in Arabidopsis thaliana Primary Roots

In vivo microscopy of plants with high-frequency imaging allows observation and characterization of the dynamic responses of plants to stimuli. It provides access to responses that could not be observed by imaging at a given time point. Such methods are particularly suitable for the observation of fast cellular events such as membrane potential changes. Classical measurement of membrane potential by probe impaling gives quantitative and precise measurements. However, it is invasive, requires specialized equipment, and only allows measurement of one cell at a time. To circumvent some of these limitations, we developed a method to relatively quantify membrane potential variations in Arabidopsis thaliana roots using the fluorescence of the voltage reporter DISBAC₂(3). In this protocol, we describe how to prepare experiments for agar media and microfluidics, and we detail the image analysis. We take an example of the rapid plasma membrane depolarization induced by the phytohormone auxin to illustrate the method. Relative membrane potential measurements using DISBAC₂(3) fluorescence increase the spatio-temporal resolution of the measurements and are non-invasive and suitable for live imaging of growing roots. Studying membrane potential with a more flexible method allows to efficiently combine mature electrophysiology literature and new molecular knowledge to achieve a better understanding of plant behaviors. Key features Non-invasive method to relatively quantify membrane potential in plant roots. Method suitable for imaging seedlings root in agar or liquid medium. Straightforward quantification.

Systemic Signals Induced by Single and Combined Abiotic Stimuli in Common Bean Plants

To survive in a dynamic environment growing fixed to the ground, plants have developed mechanisms for monitoring and perceiving the environment. When a stimulus is perceived, a series of signals are induced and can propagate away from the stimulated site. Three distinct types of systemic signaling exist, i.e., (i) electrical, (ii) hydraulic, and (iii) chemical, which differ not only in their nature but also in their propagation speed. Naturally, plants suffer influences from two or more stimuli (biotic and/or abiotic). Stimuli combination can promote the activation of new signaling mechanisms that are explicitly activated, as well as the emergence of a new response. This study evaluated the behavior of electrical (electrome) and hydraulic signals after applying simple and combined stimuli in common bean plants. We used simple and mixed stimuli applications to identify biochemical responses and extract information from the electrical and hydraulic patterns. Time series analysis, comparing the conditions before and after the stimuli and the oxidative responses at local and systemic levels, detected changes in electrome and hydraulic signal profiles. Changes in electrome are different between types of stimulation, including their combination, and systemic changes in hydraulic and oxidative dynamics accompany these electrical signals.

Integration of Electrical Signals and Phytohormones in the Control of Systemic Response

Plants are constantly exposed to environmental stresses. Local stimuli sensed by one part of a plant are translated into long-distance signals that can influence the activities in distant tissues. Changes in levels of phytohormones in distant parts of the plant occur in response to various local stimuli. The regulation of hormone levels can be mediated by long-distance electrical signals, which are also induced by local stimulation. We consider the crosstalk between electrical signals and phytohormones and identify interaction points, as well as provide insights into the integration nodes that involve changes in pH, Ca²⁺ and ROS levels. This review also provides an overview of our current knowledge of how electrical signals and hormones work together to induce a systemic response.

Effect of extremely low-frequency magnetic fields on light-induced electric reactions in wheat

Magnetic field oscillations resulting from atmospheric events could have an effect on growth and development of plants and on the responsive reactions of plants to other environmental factors. In the current work, extremely low-frequency magnetic field (14.3 Hz) was shown to modulate light-induced electric reactions of wheat (Triticum aestivum L.). Blue light-induced electric reaction in wheat leaf comprises depolarization and two waves of hyperpolarization resulting in an increase of the potential to a higher level compared to the dark one. Fluorescent and inhibitory analysis demonstrate a key role of calcium ions and calcium-dependent H⁺-ATPase of the plasma membrane in the development of the reaction. Activation of H⁺-ATPase by the increased calcium influx is suggested as a mechanism of the influence of magnetic field on light-induced electric reaction.

ROS and redox regulation of cell-to-cell and systemic signaling in plants during stress

Stress results in the enhanced accumulation of reactive oxygen species (ROS) in plants, altering the redox state of cells and triggering the activation of multiple defense and acclimation mechanisms. In addition to activating ROS and redox responses in tissues that are directly subjected to stress (termed 'local' tissues), the sensing of stress in plants triggers different systemic signals that travel to other parts of the plant (termed 'systemic' tissues) and activate acclimation and defense mechanisms in them; even before they are subjected to stress. Among the different systemic signals triggered by stress in plants are electric, calcium, ROS, and redox waves that are mobilized in a cell-to-cell fashion from local to systemic tissues over long distances, sometimes at speeds of up to several millimeters per second. Here, we discuss new studies that identified various molecular mechanisms and proteins involved in mediating systemic signals in plants. In addition, we highlight recent studies that are beginning to unravel the mode of integration and hierarchy of the different systemic signals and underline open questions that require further attention. Unraveling the role of ROS and redox in plant stress responses is highly important for the development of climate resilient crops.

In vivo Imaging Enables Understanding of Seamless Plant Defense Responses to Wounding and Pathogen Attack

Plants are exposed to varied biotic stresses, including sequential or simultaneous attack by insects and pathogens. To overcome these complex stresses, plants must perceive each of the stresses, then integrate and relay the information throughout the plant body and eventually activate local and systemic resistance responses. Previous molecular genetic studies identified jasmonic acid and salicylic acid as key plant hormones of wound and immune responses. These hormones, combined with their antagonistic interaction, play critical roles in the initiation and regulation of defense responses against insects and pathogens. Aside from molecular and genetic information, the latest in vivo imaging technology has revealed that plant defense responses are regulated spatially and temporally. In this review, we summarize the current knowledge of local and systemic defense responses against wounding and diseases with a focus on past and recent advances in imaging technologies. We discuss how imaging-based multiparametric analysis has improved our understanding of the spatiotemporal regulation of dynamic plant stress responses. We also emphasize the importance of compiling the knowledge generated from individual studies on plant wounding and immune responses for a more seamless understanding of plant defense responses in the natural environment.

Integration of long-range signals in plants: A model for wound-induced Ca2+, electrical, ROS, and glutamate waves

Plants show long-range cytosolic Ca²⁺ signal transduction in response to wounding. Recent advances in in vivo imaging techniques have helped visualize spatiotemporal dynamics of the systemic Ca²⁺ signals and provided new insights into underlying molecular mechanisms, in which ion channels of the GLUTAMATE RECEPTOR-LIKE (GLR) family are critical for the sensory system. These, along with MECHANOSENSITIVE CHANNEL OF SMALL CONDUCTANCE-LIKE 10 (MSL10) and Arabidopsis H⁺-ATPase (AHA1) regulate the propagation system. In addition, membrane potential, reactive oxygen species (ROS), and glutamate waves operate in parallel to long-range signal transduction. We summarize these findings and introduce a model that integrates long-range Ca²⁺, electrical, ROS, and glutamate signals in systemic wound responses.

Encoding, transmission, decoding, and specificity of calcium signals in plants

Calcium acts as a signal and transmits information in all eukaryotes. Encoding machinery consisting of calcium channels, stores, buffers, and pumps can generate a variety of calcium transients in response to external stimuli, thus shaping the calcium signature. Mechanisms for the transmission of calcium signals have been described, and a large repertoire of calcium binding proteins exist that can decode calcium signatures into specific responses. Whilst straightforward as a concept, mysteries remain as to exactly how such information processing is biochemically implemented. Novel developments in imaging technology and genetically encoded sensors (such as calcium indicators), in particular for multi-signal detection, are delivering exciting new insights into intra- and intercellular calcium signaling. Here, we review recent advances in characterizing the encoding, transmission, and decoding mechanisms, with a focus on long-distance calcium signaling. We present technological advances and computational frameworks for studying the specificity of calcium signaling, highlight current gaps in our understanding and propose techniques and approaches for unravelling the underlying mechanisms.

Wound-Induced Systemic Responses and Their Coordination by Electrical Signals

Wounding not only induces the expression of damage-responsive genes, but also initiates physiological changes, such as tissue repair, vascular reconnection, and de novo organogenesis in locally damaged tissues. Wound-induced signals also propagate from the site of wounding to distal organs to elicit a systemic response. Electrical signaling, which is the most conserved type of systemic signaling in eukaryotes, is triggered by wound-induced membrane potential changes. Changes in membrane potential spread toward systemic tissues in synergy with chemical and hydraulic signals. Here, we review current knowledge on wound-induced local and systemic responses in plants. We focus particularly on how wound-activated plasma membrane-localized ion channels and pumps propagate systemic information about wounding to induce downstream molecular responses in distal tissues. Finally, we propose future studies that could lead to a better understanding of plant electrical signals and their role in physiological responses to wounding.

Effect of Photoconversion Coatings for Greenhouses on Electrical Signal-Induced Resistance to Heat Stress of Tomato Plants

The use of photoconversion coatings is a promising approach to improving the quality of light when growing plants in greenhouses in low light conditions. In this work, we studied the effect of fluoropolymer coatings, which produce photoconversion of UV-A radiation and violet light into blue and red light, on the growth and resistance to heat stress of tomato plants (Solanum lycopersicum L.). The stimulating effect of the spectrum obtained as a result of photoconversion on plant growth and the activity of the photosynthesis process are shown. At the same time, the ability to withstand heat stress is reduced in plants grown under a photoconversion coating. Stress electrical signals, which normally increase resistance, in such plants have a much weaker protective effect on the photosynthetic apparatus. The observed effects are apparently explained by a decrease in the concentration of H₂O₂ in plants grown using photoconversion technologies, which leads to a shift in the development program towards increased productivity to the detriment of the protective function. Thus, when using photoconversion technologies in agricultural practice, it is necessary to pay increased attention to maintaining stable conditions during plant cultivation.