Mechanisms of TTNtv-Related Dilated Cardiomyopathy: Insights from Zebrafish Models

In Vivo Approaches to Understand Arrhythmogenic Cardiomyopathy: Perspectives on Animal Models

Arrhythmogenic cardiomyopathy (AC) is a hereditary cardiac disorder characterized by the gradual replacement of cardiomyocytes with fibrous and adipose tissue, leading to ventricular wall thinning, chamber dilation, arrhythmias, and sudden cardiac death. Despite advances in treatment, disease management remains challenging. Animal models, particularly mice and zebrafish, have become invaluable tools for understanding AC's pathophysiology and testing potential therapies. Mice models, although useful for scientific research, cannot fully replicate the complexity of the human AC. However, they have provided valuable insights into gene involvement, signalling pathways, and disease progression. Zebrafish offer a promising alternative to mammalian models, despite the phylogenetic distance, due to their economic and genetic advantages. By combining animal models with in vitro studies, researchers can comprehensively understand AC, paving the way for more effective treatments and interventions for patients and improving their quality of life and prognosis.

The TTN p. Tyr4418Ter mutation causes cardiomyopathy in human and mice

OBJECTIVE

To generate a mouse model carrying TTNtv Y4370* simulating the newly discovered human heterozygous nonsense TTNtv c.13254T>G (p.Tyr4418Ter) to supplement and improve the functional evidence of pathogenic mutation TTNtv c.13254T>G on the pathogenic type of dilated cardiomyopathy.

METHODS

We generated 4 mice carrying TTNtv p. Y4370* through CRISPR/Cas-mediated genome engineering. Monthly serological detection, bimonthly echocardiography, and histology evaluation were carried out to observe and compare alterations of cardiac structure and function between 4 TTN+/- mice and 4 wild-type (WT) mice.

RESULTS

For the two-month-old TTN+/- mice, serum glutamic-oxalacetic transaminase (AST), lactic dehydrogenase (LDH), and creatine kinase (CK) were significantly increased, the diastolic Left Ventricular Systolic Anterior Wall (LVAW), and the LV mass markedly rose, with the left ventricular volume displaying an increasing trend and Ejection Fraction (EF) and Fractional Shortening (FS) showing a decreasing trend. Besides, the histological evaluation showed that cardiac fibrosis level and positive rate of cardiac mast cell of TTN+/- mice were obviously increased compared with WT mice.

CONCLUSIONS

TTNtv Y4370* could lead to cardiac structure and function alterations in mice, supplementing the evidence of TTNtv c.13254T>G pathogenicity in human.

Sarcomere level mechanics of the fast skeletal muscle of the medaka fish larva

The medaka fish (Oryzias latipes) is a vertebrate model used in developmental biology and genetics. Here we explore its suitability as a model for investigating the molecular mechanisms of human myopathies caused by mutations in sarcomeric proteins. To this end, the relevant mechanical parameters of the intact skeletal muscle of wild-type medaka are determined using the transparent tail at larval stage 40. Tails were mounted at sarcomere length of 2.1 μm in a thermoregulated trough containing physiological solution. Tetanic contractions were elicited at physiological temperature (10°C-30°C) by electrical stimulation, and sarcomere length changes were recorded with nanometer-microsecond resolution during both isometric and isotonic contractions with a striation follower. The force output has been normalized for the actual fraction of the cross section of the tail occupied by the myofilament lattice, as established with transmission electron microscopy (TEM), and then for the actual density of myofilaments, as established with X-ray diffraction. Under these conditions, the mechanical performance of the contracting muscle of the wild-type larva can be defined at the level of the half-thick filament, where ∼300 myosin motors work in parallel as a collective motor, allowing a detailed comparison with the established performance of the skeletal muscle of different vertebrates. The results of this study point out that the medaka fish larva is a suitable model for the investigation of the genotype/phenotype correlations and therapeutic possibilities in skeletal muscle diseases caused by mutations in sarcomeric proteins.NEW & NOTEWORTHY The suitability of the medaka fish as a model for investigating the molecular mechanisms of human myopathies caused by mutations of sarcomeric proteins is tested by combining structural analysis and sarcomere-level mechanics of the skeletal muscle of the tail of medaka larva. The mechanical performance of the medaka muscle, scaled at the level of the myosin-containing thick filament, together with its reduced genome duplication makes this model unique for investigations of the genotype/phenotype correlations in human myopathies.

Truncated titin is structurally integrated into the human dilated cardiomyopathic sarcomere

Heterozygous (HET) truncating variant mutations in the TTN gene (TTNtvs), encoding the giant titin protein, are the most common genetic cause of dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM). However, the molecular mechanisms by which TTNtv mutations induce DCM are controversial. Here, we studied 127 clinically identified DCM human cardiac samples with next-generation sequencing (NGS), high-resolution gel electrophoresis, Western blot analysis, and super-resolution microscopy in order to dissect the structural and functional consequences of TTNtv mutations. The occurrence of TTNtv was found to be 15% in the DCM cohort. Truncated titin proteins matching, by molecular weight, the gene sequence predictions were detected in the majority of the TTNtv+ samples. Full-length titin was reduced in TTNtv+ compared with TTNtv- samples. Proteomics analysis of washed myofibrils and stimulated emission depletion (STED) super-resolution microscopy of myocardial sarcomeres labeled with sequence-specific anti-titin antibodies revealed that truncated titin was structurally integrated into the sarcomere. Sarcomere length-dependent anti-titin epitope position, shape, and intensity analyses pointed at possible structural defects in the I/A junction and the M-band of TTNtv+ sarcomeres, which probably contribute, possibly via faulty mechanosensor function, to the development of manifest DCM.

Transcriptome studies of inherited dilated cardiomyopathies

Dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) is a group of heart muscle diseases that often lead to heart failure, with more than 50 causative genes have being linked to DCM. The heterogenous nature of the inherited DCMs suggest the need of precision medicine. Consistent with this emerging concept, transcriptome studies in human patients with DCM indicated distinct molecular signature for DCMs of different genetic etiology. To facilitate this line of research, we reviewed the status of transcriptome studies of inherited DCMs by focusing on three predominant DCM causative genes, TTN, LMNA, and BAG3. Besides studies in human patients, we summarized transcriptomic analysis of these inherited DCMs in a variety of model systems ranging from iPSCs to rodents and zebrafish. We concluded that the RNA-seq technology is a powerful genomic tool that has already led to the discovery of new modifying genes, signaling pathways, and related therapeutic avenues. We also pointed out that both temporal (different pathological stages) and spatial (different cell types) information need to be considered for future transcriptome studies. While an important bottle neck is the low throughput in experimentally testing differentially expressed genes, new technologies in efficient animal models such as zebrafish starts to be developed. It is anticipated that the RNA-seq technology will continue to uncover both unique and common pathological events, aiding the development of precision medicine for inherited DCMs.

[Recent studies on dilated cardiomyopathy caused by TTN mutations in children]

The mutations of TTN gene that encodes titin are the most common mutation type among the genetic causes of dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM). This article reviews the worldwide studies on potential molecular pathogenesis (transcription, post-translational modification, etc.), clinical phenotypes, and gene therapies of pediatric DCM caused by TTN mutations, with the hope of providing a reference for the precision treatment of pediatric DCM caused by TTN mutations.

A spectrum of clinical severity of recessive titinopathies in prenatal

Variants in TTN are associated with a broad range of clinical phenotypes, from dominant adult-onset dilated cardiomyopathy to recessive infantile-onset myopathy. However, few foetal cases have been reported for multiple reasons. Next-generation sequencing has facilitated the prenatal identification of a growing number of suspected titinopathy variants. We investigated six affected foetuses from three families, completed the intrauterine course of the serial phenotypic spectrum of TTN, and discussed the genotype-phenotype correlations from a broader perspective. The recognizable prenatal feature onset at the second trimester was started with reduced movement, then contracture 3-6 weeks later, followed with/without hydrops, finally at late pregnancy was accompanied with polyhydramnio (major) or oligohydramnios. Two cases with typical arthrogryposis-hydrops sequences identified a meta-only transcript variant c.36203-1G>T. Deleterious transcriptional consequences of the substitution were verified by minigene splicing analysis. Case 3 identified a homozygous splicing variant in the constitutively expressed Z-disc. It presented a milder phenotype than expected, which was presumably saved by the isoform of corons. A summary of the foetal-onset titinopathy cases implied that variants in TTN present with a series of signs and a spectrum of clinical severity, which followed the dosage/positional effect; the meta-only transcript allele involvement may be a prerequisite for the development of fatal hydrops.

Enrichment of titin-truncating variants in exon 327 in dilated cardiomyopathy and its relevance to reduced nonsense-mediated mRNA decay efficiency

Titin truncating variants (TTNtvs) are the most common genetic cause of dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM). Among four regions of titin, A-band enrichment of DCM-causing TTNtvs is widely accepted but the underlying mechanism is still unknown. Meanwhile, few reports have identified exon 327 as a highly mutated A-band exon but the degree of exon 327 enrichment has not been quantitatively investigated. To find the real hotspot of DCM-causing TTNtvs, we aimed to reassess the degree of TTNtv enrichment in known titin regions and in exon 327, separately. In addition, we tried to explain exon 327 clustering in terms of nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) efficiency and a dominant negative mechanism recently proposed. Research papers focusing on TTNtvs found in patients with DCM were collected. A total of 612 patients with TTNtv-realated DCM were obtained from 10 studies. In the four regions of TTN and exon 327, the degree of TTNtvs enrichment was calculated in a way that the effect of distribution of highly expressed exons was normalized. As a result, exon 327 was the only region that showed significant enrichment for DCM-related TTNtv (p < .001). On the other hand, other A-band exons had almost the same number of TTNtv of random distribution. A review of RNAseq data revealed that the median allelic imbalance deviation of exon 327 TTNtvs was .04, indicating almost zero NMD. From these findings, we propose that the widely accepted A-band enrichment of DCM-related TTNtv is mostly attributable to exon 327 enrichment. In addition, based on the recently demonstrated dominant negative mechanism, the extremely low NMD efficiency seems to contribute to exon 327 enrichment.

A novel likely pathogenic variant in the FBXO32 gene associated with dilated cardiomyopathy according to whole‑exome sequencing

Background

Familial dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) is a genetic heart disorder characterized by progressive heart failure and sudden cardiac death. Over 250 genes have been reported in association with DCM; nonetheless, the genetic cause of most DCM patients has been unknown. The goal of the present study was to determine the genetic etiology of familial DCM in an Iranian family.

Methods

Whole-exome sequencing was performed to identify the underlying variants in an Iranian consanguineous family with DCM. The presence of the candidate variant was confirmed and screened in available relatives by PCR and Sanger sequencing. The pathogenic effect of the candidate variant was assessed by bioinformatics analysis, homology modeling, and docking.

Results

One novel likely pathogenic deletion, c.884_886del: p.Lys295del, in F-box only protein 32 (muscle-specific ubiquitin-E3 ligase protein; FBXO32) was identified. Based on bioinformatics and modeling analysis, c.884_886del was the most probable cause of DCM in the studied family.

Conclusions

Our findings indicate that variants in FBXO32 play a role in recessive DCM. Variants in FBXO32 may disturb the degradation of target proteins in the ubiquitin–proteasome system and lead to severe DCM. We suggest considering this gene variants in patients with recessively inherited DCM.

Use of animal models to understand titin physiology and pathology

In recent years, increasing attention has been paid to titin (TTN) and its mutations. Heterozygous TTN truncating variants (TTNtv) increase the risk of a cardiomyopathy. At the same time, TTNtv and few missense variants have been identified in patients with mainly recessive skeletal muscle diseases. The pathogenic mechanisms underlying titin‐related diseases are still partly unknown. Similarly, the titin mechanical and functional role in the muscle contraction are far from being exhaustively clarified. In the last few years, several animal models carrying variants in the titin gene have been developed and characterized to study the structural and mechanical properties of specific titin domains or to mimic patients' mutations. This review describes the main animal models so far characterized, including eight mice models and three fish models (Medaka and Zebrafish) and discusses the useful insights provided by a thorough characterization of the cell‐, tissue‐ and organism‐phenotypes in these models.

Protein tyrosine phosphatase receptor zeta 1 deletion triggers defective heart morphogenesis in mice and zebrafish

Protein tyrosine phosphatase receptor-ζ1 (PTPRZ1) is a transmembrane tyrosine phosphatase receptor highly expressed in embryonic stem cells. In the present work, gene expression analyses of Ptprz1^−/− and Ptprz1^+/+ mice endothelial cells and hearts pointed to an unidentified role of PTPRZ1 in heart development through the regulation of heart-specific transcription factor genes. Echocardiography analysis in mice identified that both systolic and diastolic functions are affected in Ptprz1^−/− compared with Ptprz1^+/+ hearts, based on a dilated left ventricular (LV) cavity, decreased ejection fraction and fraction shortening, and increased angiogenesis in Ptprz1^−/− hearts, with no signs of cardiac hypertrophy. A zebrafish ptprz1^−/− knockout was also generated and exhibited misregulated expression of developmental cardiac markers, bradycardia, and defective heart morphogenesis characterized by enlarged ventricles and defected contractility. A selective PTPRZ1 tyrosine phosphatase inhibitor affected zebrafish heart development and function in a way like what is observed in the ptprz1^−/− zebrafish. The same inhibitor had no effect in the function of the adult zebrafish heart, suggesting that PTPRZ1 is not important for the adult heart function, in line with data from the human cell atlas showing very low to negligible PTPRZ1 expression in the adult human heart. However, in line with the animal models, Ptprz1 was expressed in many different cell types in the human fetal heart, such as valvar, fibroblast-like, cardiomyocytes, and endothelial cells. Collectively, these data suggest that PTPRZ1 regulates cardiac morphogenesis in a way that subsequently affects heart function and warrant further studies for the involvement of PTPRZ1 in idiopathic congenital cardiac pathologies.

NEW & NOTEWORTHY Protein tyrosine phosphatase receptor ζ1 (PTPRZ1) is expressed in fetal but not adult heart and seems to affect heart development. In both mouse and zebrafish animal models, loss of PTPRZ1 results in dilated left ventricle cavity, decreased ejection fraction, and fraction shortening, with no signs of cardiac hypertrophy. PTPRZ1 also seems to be involved in atrioventricular canal specification, outflow tract morphogenesis, and heart angiogenesis. These results suggest that PTPRZ1 plays a role in heart development and support the hypothesis that it may be involved in congenital cardiac pathologies.