Consequences and Resolution of Transcription-Replication Conflicts

A rewiring of DNA replication mediated by MRE11 exonuclease underlies primed-to-naive cell de-differentiation

Mouse embryonic stem cells (mESCs) in the primed pluripotency state, which resembles the post-implantation epiblast, can be de-differentiated in culture to a naive state that resembles the pre-implantation inner cell mass. We report that primed-to-naive mESC transition entails a significant slowdown of DNA replication forks and the compensatory activation of dormant origins. Using isolation of proteins on nascent DNA coupled to mass spectrometry, we identify key changes in replisome composition that are responsible for these effects. Naive mESC forks are enriched in MRE11 nuclease and other DNA repair proteins. MRE11 is recruited to newly synthesized DNA in response to transcription-replication conflicts, and its inhibition or genetic downregulation in naive mESCs is sufficient to restore the fork rate of primed cells. Transcriptomic analyses indicate that MRE11 exonuclease activity is required for the complete primed-to-naive mESC transition, demonstrating a direct link between DNA replication dynamics and the mESC de-differentiation process.

Telomere-specific regulation of TERRA and its impact on telomere stability

TERRA is a class of telomeric repeat-containing RNAs that are expressed from telomeres in multiple organisms. TERRA transcripts play key roles in telomere maintenance and their physiological levels are essential to maintain the integrity of telomeric DNA. Indeed, deregulated TERRA expression or its altered localization can impact telomere stability by multiple mechanisms including fueling transcription-replication conflicts, promoting resection of chromosome ends, altering the telomeric chromatin, and supporting homologous recombination. Therefore, a fine-tuned control of TERRA is important to maintain the integrity of the genome. Several studies have reported that different cell lines express substantially different levels of TERRA. Most importantly, TERRA levels markedly vary among telomeres of a given cell type, indicating the existence of telomere-specific regulatory mechanisms which may help coordinate TERRA functions. TERRA molecules contain distinct subtelomeric sequences, depending on their telomere of origin, which may instruct specific post-transcriptional modifications or mediate distinct functions. In addition, all TERRA transcripts share a repetitive G-rich sequence at their 3' end which can form DNA:RNA hybrids and fold into G-quadruplex structures. Both structures are involved in TERRA functions and can critically affect telomere stability. In this review, we examine the mechanisms controlling TERRA levels and the impact of their telomere-specific regulation on telomere stability. We compare evidence obtained in different model organisms, discussing recent advances as well as controversies in the field. Furthermore, we discuss the importance of DNA:RNA hybrids and G-quadruplex structures in the context of TERRA biology and telomere maintenance.

Looping out of control: R-loops in transcription-replication conflict

Transcription-replication conflict is a major cause of replication stress that arises when replication forks collide with the transcription machinery. Replication fork stalling at sites of transcription compromises chromosome replication fidelity and can induce DNA damage with potentially deleterious consequences for genome stability and organismal health. The block to DNA replication by the transcription machinery is complex and can involve stalled or elongating RNA polymerases, promoter-bound transcription factor complexes, or DNA topology constraints. In addition, studies over the past two decades have identified co-transcriptional R-loops as a major source for impairment of DNA replication forks at active genes. However, how R-loops impede DNA replication at the molecular level is incompletely understood. Current evidence suggests that RNA:DNA hybrids, DNA secondary structures, stalled RNA polymerases, and condensed chromatin states associated with R-loops contribute to the of fork progression. Moreover, since both R-loops and replication forks are intrinsically asymmetric structures, the outcome of R-loop-replisome collisions is influenced by collision orientation. Collectively, the data suggest that the impact of R-loops on DNA replication is highly dependent on their specific structural composition. Here, we will summarize our current understanding of the molecular basis for R-loop-induced replication fork progression defects.

Transcription-Replication Conflicts as a Source of Genome Instability

Transcription and replication both require large macromolecular complexes to act on a DNA template, yet these machineries cannot simultaneously act on the same DNA sequence. Conflicts between the replication and transcription machineries (transcription-replication conflicts, or TRCs) are widespread in both prokaryotes and eukaryotes and have the capacity to both cause DNA damage and compromise complete, faithful replication of the genome. This review will highlight recent studies investigating the genomic locations of TRCs and the mechanisms by which they may be prevented, mitigated, or resolved. We address work from both model organisms and mammalian systems but predominantly focus on multicellular eukaryotes owing to the additional complexities inherent in the coordination of replication and transcription in the context of cell type-specific gene expression and higher-order chromatin organization.

Protein crotonylation: An emerging regulator in DNA damage response

DNA damage caused by internal or external factors lead to increased genomic instability and various diseases. The DNA damage response (DDR) is a crucial mechanism that maintaining genomic stability through detecting and repairing DNA damage timely. Post-translational modifications (PTMs) play significant roles in regulation of DDR. Among the present PTMs, crotonylation has emerged as a novel identified modification that is involved in a wide range of biological processes including gene expression, spermatogenesis, cell cycle, and the development of diverse diseases. In the past decade, numerous crotonylation sites have been identified in histone and non-histone proteins, leading to a more comprehensive and deep understanding of the function and mechanisms in protein crotonylation. This review provides a comprehensive overview of the regulatory mechanisms of protein crotonylation and the effect of crotonylation in DDR. Furthermore, the effect of protein crotonylation in tumor development and progression is presented, to inspire and explore the novel strategies for tumor therapy.

Go along to get along: Integrator at active replication forks defuses co-directional transcription-replication conflicts

There has been growing appreciation that transcription is an endogenous source of replication stress and must be coordinated with replication. In this issue, Bhowmick et al.¹ uncover a protective mechanism that prevents co-directional transcription-replication conflicts (TRCs) from becoming genotoxic.

An automated image analysis pipeline to quantify the coordination and overlap of transcription and replication activity in mammalian genomes

Transcription-replication conflicts (TRCs) represent a potent endogenous source of replication stress. Besides the spatial and temporal coordination of replication and transcription programs, cells employ many additional mechanisms to resolve TRCs in a timely manner, thereby avoiding replication fork stalling and genomic instability. Proximity ligation assays (PLA) using antibodies against actively elongating RNA Polymerase II (RNAPIIpS2) and PCNA to detect proximity (<40nm) between transcribing RNA polymerases and replication forks can be used to assess and quantify TRC levels in cells. A complementary fluorescence microscopy approach to assess the spatial coordination of transcription and replication activities in the nucleus is to quantify the colocalization (200-400nm) between active transcription and ongoing replication using immunofluorescence staining with an antibody against elongating RNA Polymerase II (RNAPIIpS2) and EdU-Click-it pulse-labelling, respectively. Despite significant efforts to automate image analysis, the need for manual verification, correction, and complementation of automated processes creates a bottleneck for efficient, high-throughput and large-scale imaging. Here, we describe an automated Fiji image analysis macro that allows the user to automate the measurement of RNAPIIpS2 and EdU levels and extract the key parameters such as transcription-replication (TR) colocalization and TRC-PLA foci count from single cells in a high throughput manner. While we showcase the usability of this analysis pipeline for quantifying TR colocalization and TRC-PLA in mouse embryonic stem cells (mESCs), the analysis pipeline is designed as a generally applicable tool allowing the quantification of nuclear signals, colocalization and foci count in various model systems and cell types.

The SETD2 Methyltransferase Supports Productive HPV31 Replication through the LEDGF/CtIP/Rad51 Pathway

The human papillomavirus (HPV) life cycle takes place in the stratified epithelium, with the productive phase being activated by epithelial differentiation. The HPV genome is histone-associated, and the life cycle is epigenetically regulated, in part, by histone tail modifications that facilitate the recruitment of DNA repair factors that are required for viral replication. We previously showed that the SETD2 methyltransferase facilitates the productive replication of HPV31 through the trimethylation of H3K36 on viral chromatin. SETD2 regulates numerous cellular processes, including DNA repair via homologous recombination (HR) and alternative splicing, through the recruitment of various effectors to histone H3 lysine 36 trimethylation (H3K36me3). We previously demonstrated that the HR factor Rad51 is recruited to HPV31 genomes and is required for productive replication; however, the mechanism of Rad51 recruitment has not been defined. SET domain containing 2 (SETD2) promotes the HR repair of double-strand breaks (DSBs) in actively transcribed genes through the recruitment of carboxy-terminal binding protein (CtBP)-interacting protein (CtIP) to lens epithelium-derived growth factor (LEDGF)-bound H3K36me3, which promotes DNA end resection and thereby allows for the recruitment of Rad51 to damaged sites. In this study, we found that reducing H3K36me3 through the depletion of SETD2 or the overexpression of an H3.3K36M mutant leads to an increase in γH2AX, which is a marker of damage, on viral DNA upon epithelial differentiation. This is coincident with decreased Rad51 binding. Additionally, LEDGF and CtIP are bound to HPV DNA in a SETD2-dependent and H3K36me3-dependent manner, and they are required for productive replication. Furthermore, CtIP depletion increases DNA damage on viral DNA and blocks Rad51 recruitment upon differentiation. Overall, these studies indicate that H3K36me3 enrichment on transcriptionally active viral genes promotes the rapid repair of viral DNA upon differentiation through the LEDGF-CtIP-Rad51 axis. IMPORTANCE The productive phase of the HPV life cycle is restricted to the differentiating cells of the stratified epithelium. The HPV genome is histone-associated and subject to epigenetic regulation, though the manner in which epigenetic modifications contribute to productive replication is largely undefined. In this study, we demonstrate that SETD2-mediated H3K36me3 on HPV31 chromatin promotes productive replication through the repair of damaged DNA. We show that SETD2 facilitates the recruitment of the homologous recombination repair factors CtIP and Rad51 to viral DNA through LEDGF binding to H3K36me3. CtIP is recruited to damaged viral DNA upon differentiation, and, in turn, recruits Rad51. This likely occurs through the end resection of double-strand breaks. SETD2 trimethylates H3K36me3 during transcription, and active transcription is necessary for Rad51 recruitment to viral DNA. We propose that the enrichment of SETD2-mediated H3K36me3 on transcriptionally active viral genes upon differentiation facilitates the repair of damaged viral DNA during the productive phase of the viral life cycle.

FANCD2 promotes mitotic rescue from transcription-mediated replication stress in SETX-deficient cancer cells

Replication stress (RS) is a leading cause of genome instability and cancer development. A substantial source of endogenous RS originates from the encounter between the transcription and replication machineries operating on the same DNA template. This occurs predominantly under specific contexts, such as oncogene activation, metabolic stress, or a deficiency in proteins that specifically act to prevent or resolve those transcription-replication conflicts (TRCs). One such protein is Senataxin (SETX), an RNA:DNA helicase involved in resolution of TRCs and R-loops. Here we identify a synthetic lethal interaction between SETX and proteins of the Fanconi anemia (FA) pathway. Depletion of SETX induces spontaneous under-replication and chromosome fragility due to active transcription and R-loops that persist in mitosis. These fragile loci are targeted by the Fanconi anemia protein, FANCD2, to facilitate the resolution of under-replicated DNA, thus preventing chromosome mis-segregation and allowing cells to proliferate. Mechanistically, we show that FANCD2 promotes mitotic DNA synthesis that is dependent on XPF and MUS81 endonucleases. Importantly, co-depleting FANCD2 together with SETX impairs cancer cell proliferation, without significantly affecting non-cancerous cells. Therefore, we uncovered a synthetic lethality between SETX and FA proteins for tolerance of transcription-mediated RS that may be exploited for cancer therapy.

Biochemical and single-molecule techniques to study accessory helicase resolution of R-loop proteins at stalled replication forks

R-loop proteins present a stable and robust blockade to the progression of a DNA replication fork during S-phase. The consequences of this block can include mutagenesis and other irreversible chromosomal catastrophes, causing genomic instability and disease. As such, further investigation into the molecular mechanisms underlying R-loop protein resolution is warranted. The critical role of non-replicative accessory helicases in R-loop protein resolution has increasingly come into light in recent years. Such helicases include the Pif1-family, monomeric helicases that have been studied in many different contexts and that have been ascribed to a multitude of separable protective functions in the cell. In this chapter, we present protocols to study R-loop protein resolution by Pif1 helicase at stalled replication forks using purified proteins, both at the biochemical and single-molecule level. Our system uses recombinant proteins expressed in Saccharomyces cerevisiae but could apply to practically any organism of interest due to the high interspecies homology of the proteins involved in DNA replication. The methods we outline are extensible to many systems and should be applicable to studying R-loop clearance by any Superfamily (SF) 1B helicase. These techniques will further enable mechanistic research on these critical but understudied components of the genomic maintenance program.

Treacle Sticks the Nucleolar Responses to DNA Damage Together

The importance of chromatin environment for DNA repair has gained increasing recognition in recent years. The nucleolus is the largest sub-compartment within the nucleus: it has distinct biophysical properties, selective protein retention, and houses the specialized ribosomal RNA genes (collectively referred to as rDNA) with a unique chromatin composition. These genes have high transcriptional activity and a repetitive nature, making them susceptible to DNA damage and resulting in the highest frequency of rearrangements across the genome. A distinct DNA damage response (DDR) secures the fidelity of this genomic region, the so-called nucleolar DDR (n-DDR). The composition of the n-DDR reflects the characteristics of nucleolar chromatin with the nucleolar protein Treacle (also referred to as TCOF1) as a central coordinator retaining several well-characterized DDR proteins in the nucleolus. In this review, we bring together data on the structure of Treacle, its known functions in ribosome biogenesis, and its involvement in multiple branches of the n-DDR to discuss their interconnection. Furthermore, we discuss how the functions of Treacle in ribosome biogenesis and in the n-DDR may contribute to Treacher Collins Syndrome, a disease caused by mutations in Treacle. Finally, we outline outstanding questions that need to be addressed for a more comprehensive understanding of Treacle, the n-DDR, and the coordination of ribosome biogenesis and DNA repair.

The role of chromatin at transcription-replication conflicts as a genome safeguard

DNA replication ensures the correct copying of the genome and the faithful transfer of the genetic information to the offspring. However, obstacles to replication fork (RF) progression cause RF stalling and compromise efficient genome duplication. Since replication uses the same DNA template as transcription, both transcription and replication must be coordinated to prevent Transcription-Replication Conflicts (TRCs) that could stall RF progression. Several factors contribute to limit the occurrence of such conflicts and their harmful impact on genome integrity. Increasing evidence indicates that chromatin homeostasis plays a key role in the cellular response to TRCs as well as in the preservation of genome integrity. Indeed, chromatin regulating enzymes are frequently mutated in cancer cells, a common characteristic of which is genome instability. Therefore, understanding the role of chromatin in TRC occurrence and resolution may help identify the molecular mechanism by which chromatin protects genome integrity, and the causes and physiological relevance of the high mutation rates of chromatin regulating factors in cancer. Here we review the current knowledge in the field, as well as the perspectives and future applications.