Chiroptical switches: applications in sensing and catalysis

Longitudinal Extension of Double π-Helix Enables Near-Infrared Amplified Dissymmetry and Chiroptical Response

Near-infrared (NIR) circularly polarized light absorbing or emitting holds great promise for highly sensitive and precise bioimaging, biosensing, and photodetectors. Aiming at designing NIR chiral molecular systems with amplified dissymmetry and robust chiroptical response, herein, we present a series of double π-helical dimers with longitudinally extended π-entwined substructures via Ullmann or Yamamoto homocoupling reactions. Circular dichroism (CD) spectra revealed an approximate linear bathochromic shift with the rising number of naphthalene subunits, indicating a red to NIR chiroptical response. Particularly, the terrylene diimide-entwined dimers exhibited the strongest CD intensities, with the maximal |Δε| reaching up to 393 M-1 cm-1 at 666 nm for th-TDI[2]; and a record-high chiroptical response (|ΔΔε|) between the neutral and dianionic species of 520 M-1 cm-1 at 833 nm for th-TDI[2]Cl was achieved upon further reduction to its dianionic state. Time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) calculations suggested that the pronounced intensification of the CD spectra originated from a simultaneous enhancement of both electric (μ) and magnetic (m) transition dipole moments, ultimately leading to an overall increase in the rotatory strength (R). Notably, the circularly polarized luminescence (CPL) brightness (BCPL) reached 77 M-1 cm-1 for th-TDI[2]Cl, among the highest values reported for NIR-CPL emitters. Furthermore, all chiral dianions exhibited excellent air stability under ambient conditions with half-life times of up to 10 days in N-methylpyrrolidone (NMP), which is significant for future biological applications and chiroptic switches.

Chiroptical Strain Sensors from Electrospun Cadmium Sulfide Quantum-Dot Fibers

Controllable synthesis of homochiral nano/micromaterials has been a constant challenge for fabricating various stimuli-responsive chiral sensors. To provide an avenue to this goal, we report electrospinning as a simple and economical strategy to form continuous homochiral microfibers with strain-sensitive chiroptical properties. First, electrospun homochiral microfibers from self-assembled cadmium sulfide (CdS) quantum dot magic-sized clusters (MSCs) are produced. Highly sensitive and reversible strain sensors are then fabricated by embedding these chiroptically active fibers into elastomeric films. The chiroptical response on stretching is indicated quantitatively as reversible changes in magnitude, spectral position (wavelength), and sign in circular dichroism (CD) and linear dichroism (LD) signals and qualitatively as a prominent change in the birefringence features under cross-polarizers. The observed periodic twisted helical fibrils at the surface of fibers provide insights into the origin of the fibers' chirality. The measurable shifts in CD and LD are caused by elastic deformations of these helical fibrillar structures of the fiber. To elucidate the origin of these chiroptical properties, we used field emission-electron microscopy (FE-SEM), atomic force microscopy (AFM), synchrotron X-ray analysis, polarized optical microscopy, as well as measurements to isolate the true CD, and contributions from photoelastic modulators (PEM) and LD. Our findings thus offer a promising strategy to fabricate chiroptical strain-sensing devices with multiple measurables/observables using electric-field-assisted spinning of homochiral nano/microfibers.

Near-Infrared, Organic Chiroptic Switch with High Dissymmetry Factors

Here we unveil a chiral molecular redox switch derived from PDI-based twistacenes─chPDI[2] that has the remarkable attributes of high-intensity and a broadband chiral response. This material exhibits facile, stable, and reversible multistate chiroptical switching behavior over a broad active wavelength range close to 700 nm, encompassing ultraviolet, visible, and near-infrared regions. Upon reduction, chPDI[2] exhibits a substantial increase in the amplitude of its circular dichroic response, with an outstanding |ΔΔε| > 300 M-1 cm-1 and a high dissymmetry factor of 3 × 10-2 at 960 nm. DFT calculations suggest that the long wavelength CD signal for doubly reduced chPDI[2] originates from excitation of the PDI backbone to the π* orbital of the bridging alkene. Importantly, the dimer's molecular contortion facilitates ionic diffusion, enabling chiral switching in solid state films. The high dissymmetry factors and near-infrared response establish chPDI[2] as a unique chiroptic switch.

Mechanochemical Scholl Reaction on Phenylated Cyclopentadiene Core: One-Step Synthesis of Fluoreno[5]helicenes

In this study, we explore feasibility of the mechanochemical approach in the synthesis of tetrabenzofluorenes (fluoreno[5]helicenes). For this, commercially available phenylated cyclopentadiene precursors are subjected to the Scholl reaction in the solid state using FeCl3 as an oxidant and sodium chloride as the solid reaction medium. This ball milling process gave access to the 5-membered ring containing-helicenes in one synthetic step in high (95-96 %) isolated yields. The solution-phase reactions, however, were found to be moderate to low yielding in this regard (10-40 %).

Acid/Base-Triggered Photophysical and Chiroptical Switching in a Series of Helicenoid Compounds

A series of molecules that possess two quinolines, benzoquinolines, or phenanthrolines connected in a chiral fashion by a biaryl junction along with their water-soluble derivatives was developed and characterized. The influence of the structure on the basicity of the nitrogen atoms in two heterocycles was examined and the photophysical and chiroptical switching activity of the compounds upon protonation was studied both experimentally and computationally. The results demonstrated that changes in the electronic structure of the protonated vs. neutral species, promoting a bathochromic shift of dominant electronic transitions and alternation of their character from π-to-π* to charge-transfer-type, when additionally accompanied by the high structural flexibility of a system, leading to changes in conformational preferences upon proton binding, produce particularly pronounced modifications of the spectral properties in acidic medium. The latter combined with reversibility of the read-out make some of the molecules in this series very promising multifunctional pH probes.

Inversion of Molecular Chirality Associated with Ferroelectric Switching in a High-Temperature Two-Dimensional Perovskite Ferroelectric

Controlling molecular chirality by external stimuli is of great significance in both fundamental research and technological applications. Herein, we report a high-temperature (384 K) molecular ferroelectric of a Cu(II) complex whose spontaneous polarization can be switched associated with flipping of molecular chirality. In this two-dimensional perovskite structure, the inorganic layer is separated by (NH₃(CH₂)₂SS(CH₂)₂NH₃)²⁺ organic cations skewed in a chiral conformation (P- or M-helicity in an individual crystal). As the stereodynamic disulfide bridge determines the molecular dipole moment along the polar axis, the chiral organic cation can be converted to its enantiomer as a consequence of an electric field-induced shift of the S-S moiety relative to its screw axis during the ferroelectric switching. The variation of the molecular chirality is examined with single-crystal X-ray diffraction and circular dichroism spectra. The simultaneous switching of molecular chirality and spontaneous polarization in this perovskite ferroelectric may lead to novel chiral electronic phenomena.

Inducing a pH-dependent conformational response by competitive binding to Zn2+ of a series of chiral ligands of disparate basicity

Molecules that change shape in response to environmental conditions are central to biological molecular communication devices and their synthetic chemical analogues. Here we report a molecular system in which a series of chiral anionic ligands of differing basicity are selectively protonated according to the pH of the medium. A cationic circular dichroism (CD) reporter complex responds to anion binding by selecting one of two alternative enantiomeric conformations. Exploiting the principle that less basic anions have, in general, weaker electrostatic interactions than more basic anions, a set of three chiral acids with large (>5 unit) pK_a differences and differing configurations were sequentially deprotonated in acetonitrile by addition of base, allowing the most basic anion in the mixture at any time to bind to the reporter complex. A characteristic CD output resulted, which changed in sign as the next-most basic anion was revealed by the next deprotonation in the series. Four cycles of switching between three ligand-bound states were achieved with minimal changes in signal magnitude, by alternating addition of base and acid. The pH-dependent conformational response was used to transduce a signal by appending to the binding site a 2-aminoisobutyric acid (Aib) oligomer, whose M or P helical conformation depended on the chirality of the bound ligand, and was reported by a remote ¹³C-labelled NMR reporter group. The multicomponent system thus converts a pH signal into a programmable conformational response which induces a remote spectroscopic effect.

A chemical system comprising a series of chiral acids of differing pK_a, a metal, and a conformationally labile chromophore responds to pH with a CD spectrum that reports the absolute stereochemistry of the most basic anion in the mixture.

Induced axial chirality by a tight belt: naphthalene chromophores fixed in a 2,5-substituted cofacial para-phenylene-ethynylene framework

We report the design of a synthetically easy accessible axial chirality-inducing framework for a chromophore of choice. The scaffold consists of two basic para-phenylene-ethynylene backbones separated by laterally placed corner units. Substitution with an inherently achiral chromophore at the 2 and 5 positions of the central phenylene excitonically couples the chromophore associated transition and thereby results in chiroptical properties. Using 6-methoxynaphthalene as a model chromophore, we present the synthesis, structural analysis and spectroscopic investigation of the framework. The chiral framework was synthesized in three straightforward synthetic steps and fully characterized. The obtained racemic compounds were resolved using HPLC and assignment of the absolute configuration was performed using the exciton chirality method, crystallography and DFT calculations. This simple yet potent framework might prove useful to enrich the structural diversity of chiral materials.

Stimuli-Responsive Chiroptical Switching

"Chirality" governs many fundamental properties in chemistry and biochemistry. While early investigations on stereochemistry are primarily dedicated to static chirality, there is an increasing interest in the field of dynamic chirality (chiral switches). These chiral switches are essential in controlling the directionality in molecular motors. Dynamic chiralities are equally crucial in switchable stereoselectivity, switchable asymmetric catalysis and enantioselective separation. Herein, we limit our discussion to recent advances on stimuli-induced chiroptical switching of axial, helical, and planar chirality in response to external stimuli. We also discuss a few examples of applications of the switchable chirality.

A Family of Superhelicenes: Easily Tunable, Chiral Nanographenes by Merging Helicity with Planar π Systems

We designed a straightforward synthetic route towards a full-fledged family of π-extended helicenes: superhelicenes. They have two hexa-peri-hexabenzocoronenes (HBCs) in common that are connected via a central five-membered ring. By means of structurally altering this 5-membered ring, we realized a versatile library of molecular building blocks. Not only the superhelicene structure, but also their features are tuned with ease. In-depth physico-chemical characterizations served as a proof of concept thereof. The superhelicene enantiomers were separated, their circular dichroism was measured in preliminary studies and concluded with an enantiomeric assignment. Our work was rounded-off by crystal structure analyses. Mixed stacks of M- and P-isomers led to twisted molecular wires. Using such stacks, charge-carrier mobilities were calculated, giving reason to expect outstanding hole transporting properties.

Chirality induction to achiral molecules by silica-coated chiral molecular assemblies

Hybrid silica-organic nanohelices are used to organize a large variety of nonchiral small organic molecules or inorganic anions to nanometer-sized assemblies. Such chiral organization of achiral molecules induces chiroptical properties as detected by vibrational or electronic circular dichroism (CD), as well as from circularly polarized luminescence (CPL).

Interconversion between Möbius chiroptical states sustained by hexaphyrin dynamic coordination

Harnessing the chiroptical properties of molecular Möbius rings is motivated by fundamental aspects while challenged by synthetic difficulties. Focusing on Möbius aromatic Zn(ii) hexaphyrin complexes, interconversion between two chiral states was achieved through binding and release of an amino ligand (forward/backward stimuli), leading to different chiroptical switching phenomena (amplification, on-off, inversion). The amine either supplies the chirality or behaves as an achiral effector regulating the Zn(ii)-binding of a second (chiral) carboxylato ligand. These results highlight the Möbius [28]hexaphyrin scaffold as an attractive chiral switchable unit.

A Multiple Chirality Switching Device for Spatial Light Modulators

A new and simple strategy towards electric-field-driven multiple chirality switching device has been designed and fabricated by combining a newly synthesized base-responsive chiroptical polymer switch (R-FLMA) and p-benzoquinone (p-BQ) via proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) mechanism. Clear and stable triple chirality states (silence, positive, negative) of this device in visible band can be regulated reversibly (>1000 cycles) by adjusting voltage programs. Furthermore, such chiral switching phenomena are also accompanied by apparent changes of color and fluorescence. More importantly, the potential application of this device for a spatial light modulator has also been demonstrated.

Light-mediated chiroptical switching of an achiral foldamer host in presence of a carbohydrate guest

A photoresponsive diarylethene was incorporated in an achiral helical foldamer container. A carbohydrate guest was found to induce opposite handedness upon binding to the open and closed forms of the diarylethene-containing foldamer, thus enabling chiroptical switching of an achiral host mediated by a chiral guest.

A ferrocene-based pseudopeptide chiroptical switch

A ferrocene pseudopeptide chiroptical switch sensitive to solvent exchange and acid addition with a response in the visible region of CD spectra.

Histidine Proton Shuttle-Initiated Switchable Inversion of Circularly Polarized Luminescence

Switchable inversion of the sign of circularly polarized luminescence (CPL) in chiral supramolecular systems has gained remarkable interest because of its role in understanding the chirality-switching phenomena in biological systems and developing smart chiral luminescent materials. Herein, inspired by the histidine proton shuttle in natural enzymes, we synthesized a histidine π-gel (PyC₃H) and realized reversible inversion of supramolecular chirality and CPL by receiving and then transferring a proton. It was found that in the course of histidine protonation by adding an external proton source, the transcription of intrinsic molecular chirality of PyC₃H to the supramolecular level biased, achieving dynamic control over the PyC₃H gel with left-handed CPL inversed into the right-handed one. The mechanism study revealed that the supramolecular chirality and CPL inversion are mainly affected by the cooperation adjustment of hydrogen bonds and π-π stacking upon histidine protonation and deprotonation, which causes the re-orientations of pyrene chromophores. This work sets up an alternative effective method to fabricate tunable CPL-active materials while using the same chiral small molecules, which provides a new insight into developing bio-inspired switchable supramolecular materials.

Supramolecular chiroptical switches

Recent progress in chiroptical switches including on/off, amplification, and inversion of the chiral signals such as ECD and CPL in supramolecular assemblies is shown.

Off-off-on chiroptical property switching of a pyrene luminophore by stepwise helicate formation

Pyrene-based chiral ligands (LR and LS) consisting of two chiral imidazole sidearms at the 1,8-positions first form pyrene-bridged oligomers [(L(R or S))3(Zn2+)n], which are chiroptically inactive, with a low concentration of zinc ions (Zn2+). Upon addition of more Zn2+, chiroptically active coordination helicates ([(L(R or S))3(Zn2+)2]) are formed. The stepwise assembly process successfully facilitated an "off-off-on" chiroptical switching process of a pyrene luminophore controlled by the concentration of Zn2+. The resulting pyrene-bridged helicates exhibit high performance in terms of a dissymmetry factor of circular dichroism (|gCD| = 0.006) and circularly polarized luminescence (|gCPL| = 0.01).

Combined reversible switching of ECD and quenching of CPL with chiral fluorescent macrocycles

A series of chiral fluorescent macrocycles display a remarkable combination of both +/– ECD and strong on/off CPL reversible switching upon cation binding and displacement.

Straightforward synthesis and resolution of a series of chiral fluorescent macrocycles are presented, together with their electronic circular dichroism (ECD), strong excimer fluorescence (EF, λ 300 to 650 nm) and allied highly circularly polarized luminescence (CPL, g_lum up to 1.7 × 10^–2). The ECD, EF and CPL responses are strongly affected by the presence of metal ions (Na⁺, Ba²⁺) thanks to deep conformational changes. While ECD signals can be almost completely reversibly inverted upon the complexation/decomplexation of metal ions in a typical binary response, CPL signals are reversibly quenched concomitantly. The designed macrocycles display thus a remarkable combination of both +/– ECD and on/off CPL reversible switching.

Reconfigurable, graphene-coated, chalcogenide nanowires with a sub-10-nm enantioselective sorting capability

Chiral surface plasmon polaritons (SPPs) produced by plasmonic nanowires can be used to enhance molecular spectroscopy for biosensing applications. Nevertheless, the switchable stereoselectivity and detection of various analytes are limited by a lack of switchable, chiral SPPs. Using both finite-element method simulations and analytic calculations, we present a graphene-coated chalcogenide (GCC) nanowire that produces mid-infrared, chiral SPPs. The chiral SPPs can be reversibly switched between "on" (transparent) and "off" (opaque) by non-volatile structural state transitions in the dielectric constants of the chalcogenide glass Ge2Sb2Te5. Furthermore, by controlling the Fermi energy of the graphene-coating layer, the nanowire can output either non-chiral or chiral SPPs. A thermal-electric model was built to illustrate the possibility of ultrafast on/off switching of the SPPs at the terminus of the nanowire. Finally, we show that a selective, lateral sorting of sub-10-nm enantiomers can be achieved via the GCC nanowire. Chiral nanoparticles with opposite handedness experience transverse forces that differ in both their sign and magnitude. Our design may pave the way for plasmonic nanowire networks and tunable nanophotonic devices, which require the ultrafast switching of SPPs, and provide a possible approach for a compact, enantiopure synthesis.

Intense redox-driven chiroptical switching with a 580 mV hysteresis actuated through reversible dimerization of an azoniahelicene

Electrochemical reduction of an azoniahelicene affords a dimer, accompanied by a strong change in the electronic circular dichroism. The fast dimerisation event leads to a >500 mV shift of the oxidation potential, affording a large area of bistability, where the chiroptical signal only depends on the redox history.

Induced circular dichroism of monoatomic anions: silica-assisted the transfer of chiral environment from molecular assembled nanohelices to halide ions

Induced CD of monoatomic anions was detected using silica-coated molecular assembled nanohelices and multi-step chirality induction was achieved through an in situ chemical reaction via chiralized monoatomic anions.

Guest-regulated chirality switching of planar chiral pseudo[1]catenanes

Pillar[5]arene-derived pseudo[1]catenanes in dichloromethane exist in an equilibrium between a self-included conformational state and a de-threading one.

Supramolecular chiroptical switching of helical-sense preferences through the two-way intramolecular transmission of a single chiral source

Complexation-induced reversal of helical-sense preferences is demonstrated with a simple molecule with a pair of exciton-coupled chromophores.

Steric and Stereochemical Modulation in Pyridyl- and Quinolyl-Containing Ligands

Nitrogen-containing pyridine and quinoline are outstanding platforms on which excellent ionophores and sensors for metal ions can be built. Steric and stereochemical effects can be used to modulate the affinity and selectivity of such ligands toward different metal ions on the coordination chemistry front. On the signal transduction front, such effects can also be used to modulate optical responses of these ligands in metal sensing systems. In this review, steric modulation of achiral ligands and stereochemical modulation in chiral ligands, especially ionophores and sensors for zinc, copper, silver, and mercury, are examined using published structural and spectral data. Although it might be more challenging to construct chiral ligands than achiral ones, isotropic and anisotropic absorption signals from a single chiroptical fluorescent sensor provide not only detection but also differentiation of multiple analytes with high selectivity.

Conformational changes and chiroptical switching of enantiopure bis-helicenic terpyridine upon Zn(2+) binding

The molecular conformation of a bis-helicenic terpyridine system is strongly modified upon binding to Zn(ii) ion, a process that is accompanied by large changes in the optical and chiroptical properties. This system affords a new type of helicene-based chiroptical switching.

Multimetallic Architectures from the Self-assembly of Amino Acids and Tris(2-pyridylmethyl)amine Zinc(II) Complexes: Circular Dichroism Enhancement by Chromophores Organization

Stereodynamic optical probes are becoming very popular for their capability to act as molecular sensors for the determination of the enantiomeric excess (ee) of chiral compounds. Herein, we describe a new molecular architecture formed by the self-assembly of three zinc metal ions, two modified tris(2-pyridylmethyl)amine ligands, and two amino acids. This system is the structural and functional serendipitous evolution of our previous probe for the determination of amino acids ee. In the new system, one of the metals templates in close proximity two chromophores enhancing their exciton coupling.

Novel redox responsive chiral cyclometalated platinum(ii) complexes with pinene functionalized C^N^N ligands

A couple of unprecedented platinum(iv) complexes have been facilely prepared, and distinct chiroptical performances are exhibited.

Zwitterionic [4]helicene: a water-soluble and reversible pH-triggered ECD/CPL chiroptical switch in the UV and red spectral regions

The chiroptical switching properties of a readily accessible and water-soluble diaza [4]helicene are disclosed.

Functional helquats: helical cationic dyes with marked, switchable chiroptical properties in the visible region

Helquat dyes are the first helicene-like cationic styryl dyes obtained as separate enantiomers. Their remarkable chiroptical properties are due to the unique combination of a cationic hemicyanine chromophore and a helicene-like motif. The magnitude of the ECD response and the pH switching along with their positioning in the visible region are unprecedented among helicenoids.

Artificial switchable catalysts

Catalysis is key to the effective and efficient transformation of readily available building blocks into high value functional molecules and materials. For many years research in this field has largely focussed on the invention of new catalysts and the optimization of their performance to achieve high conversions and/or selectivities. However, inspired by Nature, chemists are beginning to turn their attention to the development of catalysts whose activity in different chemical processes can be switched by an external stimulus. Potential applications include using the states of multiple switchable catalysts to control sequences of transformations, producing different products from a pool of building blocks according to the order and type of stimuli applied. Here we outline the state-of-art in artificial switchable catalysis, classifying systems according to the trigger used to achieve control over the catalytic activity and stereochemical or other structural outcomes of the reaction.

A cyclic azobenzenophane-based smart polymer for chiroptical switches

Polymers based on cyclic azobenzenophanes as pendants with different methylene spacers (n = 2, 6, 11) have been synthesized. And the one with a six-methylene spacer is a good candidate for a chiroptical switch.

C₅-symmetric chiral corannulenes: desymmetrization of bowl inversion equilibrium via "intramolecular" hydrogen-bonding network

Because of a rapid conformational inversion, bowl-shaped C5-symmetric corannulenes, though geometrically chiral, have not been directly resolved into their enantiomers. However, if this inversion equilibrium can be desymmetrized, chiral corannulenes enriched in either enantiomer can be obtained. We demonstrated this possibility using pentasubstituted corannulenes 4 and 5 carrying amide-appended thioalkyl side chains. Compound 4 displays chiroptical activity in a chiral hydrocarbon such as limonene. Because compound 5 carries a chiral center in the side chains, its enantiomers 5R and 5S show chiroptical activity even in achiral solvents such as CHCl3 and methylcyclohexane. In sharp contrast, when the side chains bear no amide functionality (1 and 2R), no chiroptical activity emerges even in limonene or with a chiral center in the side chains. Detailed investigations revealed that the peripheral amide units in 4 and 5 are hydrogen-bonded only "intramolecularly" along the corannulene periphery, affording cyclic amide networks with clockwise and anticlockwise geometries. Although this networking gives rise to four stereoisomers, only two, which are enantiomeric to one another, are suggested computationally to exist in the equilibrated system. In a chiral environment (chiral solvent or side chain), their thermodynamic stabilities are certainly unequal, so the bowl-inversion equilibrium can be desymmetrized. However, this is not the case when the system contains a protic solvent that can deteriorate the hydrogen-bonding network. When the enantiomeric purity of limonene as the solvent is varied, the chiroptical activity of the corannulene core changes nonlinearly with its enantiomeric excess (majority rule).

Chiroptical spectroscopic techniques based on fluorescence

Among the various chiroptical spectroscopic methods circular dichroism (CD), optical rotatory dispersion (ORD), Raman optical activity (ROA), the methods based on fluorescence have so far played a marginal role. Fluorescence detected circular dichroism and circularly polarized luminescence (CPL) were both introduced many years ago with important, but not so frequent, applications. In particular, CPL, which requires specialist hardware, has been restricted by the limited number of users. Recent interest, which has increased in the field of material science particularly, where the emission properties are more attractive and important than the absorption ones, has motivated new application fields and may change the situation in the future.