Surgical Dynamometer to Simultaneously Measure the Tension Forces and the Distance between Wound Edges during the Closure of a Laparotomy

Biomechanical Parameters of Mesh Reinforcement and Analysis of a Novel Device for Incisional Hernia Prevention

BACKGROUND

Prophylactic mesh augmentation (PMA) is an effective technique utilized to reduce the risk of incisional hernia. This study analyzes the biomechanical characteristics of a mesh-reinforced closure and evaluates a novel prophylactic mesh implantation device (SafeClose Roller System; SRS).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of eight senior-level general surgery trainees (≥4 years of training) from the University of Pennsylvania Health System participated in the study. Biomechanical strength, mesh stiffness, mesh uniformity, and time efficiency for fixation were compared among hand-sewn mesh fixation, SRS mesh fixation and a no-mesh fixation control. Porcine abdominal wall specimens served as simulated laparotomy models.

RESULTS

Biomechanical load strength was significantly higher for mesh reinforced repairs (P = 0.009). The SRS resulted in a stronger biomechanical force than hand-sewn mesh (21.2 N stronger, P = 0.317), with more uniform mesh placement (P < 0.01), faster time of fixation (P < 0.001) and with less discrete hand-movements (P < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Mesh reinforcement for incisional reinforcement has a significant impact on the strength of the closure. The utilization of a mesh-application system has the potential to amplify the advantages of mesh reinforcement by providing efficiency and consistency to fixation methods, with similar biomechanical strength to hand-sewn mesh. Additional in vivo analysis and randomized controlled trials are needed to further assess clinical efficacy.

Quantifying fascial tension in ventral hernia repair and component separation

BACKGROUND

Excessive fascial tension is a major cause of ventral hernia recurrence. Although hernias are commonly characterized by area, the tension experienced by fascia is directly proportional to the surrounding tissue stiffness. We demonstrate an accurate and simple technique for intra-operative measurement of fascial closing tension and quantify the decrease in tension following Component Separation (CS).

METHODS

A tensiometer was created using a spring with a known recoil constant (k) and a surgical clamp. Using Hooke's law (Force = kX; X = spring displacement), fascial tension was calculated. This method was first validated on a bench-top model and then applied to the anterior fascia of 4 fresh cadavers (8 hemi-abdomens) over a range of simulated hernia defect sizes. When fascia could no longer reach midline, CS was performed and measures repeated. Tissue stiffness was calculated by plotting defect size versus resulting tension.

RESULTS

Fascial defects ranged from 1- to 18-cm wide with average midline closing tension prior to release 36.1 N (range 17-48) and 8.2 N (range 5-11) after CS, a mean 76% decrease (range 70%-85%). Mean R2 values between defect size and tension for the synthetic and cadaver models were 0.99 (p < 0.01) and 0.91 (p = 0.01; all hemi-abdomen measurements significant). Inter-rater Pearson's correlation consistently found R² values > 0.95 (p < 0.01) for each hemi-abdomen, showing high precision and reproducibility.

CONCLUSION

We have applied a cheap, simple, and precise method to sterilely assess fascial tension during herniorrhaphy and also quantified the decrease in tension following component separation. This technique may be rapidly translated into the operating room with minimal equipment to provide objective data critical for intraoperative decision-making.

Theoretic and Evidence-Based Laparotomy Closure with Sutures and Meshes

The ultimate tensile strength of newly apposed tissue is the sum of the strength of the physical construct holding the tissues and the strength of biologic healing. For successful incisional hernia repair, the total strength of the repair must remain greater than the forces applied. While much work has been done to understand the science of wound healing-the ability of an open defect to contract and close-far less has been done to understand the healing of 2 newly approximated previously nonwounded surfaces held together with sutures or other implants. In this article, the elements of ultimate tensile strength on laparotomy closure as well as their progression over time will be related to clinical studies of abdominal wall closure.

Miniaturized Sensors Registering the Long-Term Course of Suture Tension In Vivo under Varying Intra-Abdominal Pressure

BACKGROUND

Failure of laparotomy closure develops after up to 20% of abdominal operations. Suture tension has an influence on the quality of tissue regeneration. No sensors are available to register suture tension dynamics in vivo.

METHODS

In a series of animal experiments, the effect of suture tension on the ultrastructure of the healing incision was examined. Surgeons' ability to suture with target tension was tested. An implantable sensor and data logger were developed and tested experimentally in sutures closing midline laparotomies in pigs both under normal and elevated intra-abdominal pressure.

RESULTS

High suture tension has a negative influence on the regeneration of laparotomy incisions. Running sutures for laparotomy closure lose 45% of their initial tension over periods of 23 h. Intermittent elevation of intra-abdominal pressure to 30 mm Hg leads to a near total loss of suture tension after 23 h.

CONCLUSION

Surgeons are not able to control and reproduce suture tension. Suture tension dynamics can be measured in vivo by the sensor developed. Further research is needed to define a tissue-specific suture tension optimum to reduce the incidence of complications after laparotomy. Techniques for laparotomy closure need to be modified.