Validating an Evaporative Calibrator for Gaseous Oxidized Mercury

Measurement of Atmospheric Mercury: Current Limitations and Suggestions for Paths Forward

Mercury (Hg) researchers have made progress in understanding atmospheric Hg, especially with respect to oxidized Hg (HgII) that can represent 2 to 20% of Hg in the atmosphere. Knowledge developed over the past ∼10 years has pointed to existing challenges with current methods for measuring atmospheric Hg concentrations and the chemical composition of HgII compounds. Because of these challenges, atmospheric Hg experts met to discuss limitations of current methods and paths to overcome them considering ongoing research. Major conclusions included that current methods to measure gaseous oxidized and particulate-bound Hg have limitations, and new methods need to be developed to make these measurements more accurate. Developing analytical methods for measurement of HgII chemistry is challenging. While the ultimate goal is the development of ultrasensitive methods for online detection of HgII directly from ambient air, in the meantime, new surfaces are needed on which HgII can be quantitatively collected and from which it can be reversibly desorbed to determine HgII chemistry. Discussion and identification of current limitations, described here, provide a basis for paths forward. Since the atmosphere is the means by which Hg is globally distributed, accurately calibrated measurements are critical to understanding the Hg biogeochemical cycle.

Application of traceable calibration for gaseous oxidized mercury in air

BACKGROUND

The current speciation methods for mercury (Hg) measurements are fraught with considerable uncertainty, from sample collection to calibration. High reactivity of gaseous oxidized Hg (GOM) species and their ultra-trace level presence makes them difficult to sample and calibrate. Given that improper calibration may lead to measurement biases, reliable and metrologically traceable calibration methods are required for accurately quantifying GOM in air. In the present study, we applied the recently developed calibration method based on non-thermal plasma oxidation of elemental Hg, to a commercially available Hg air speciation system for actual environmental measurements of GOM for the first time.

RESULTS

Hg species such as HgO, HgCl2, and HgBr2 were produced with trace amounts of reactant gases (oxygen and electrolytically produced chlorine and bromine) and the production was driven by plasma-assisted oxidation. The plasma oxidation efficiency of elemental Hg with oxygen was 98.5 ± 7.5 % (k = 2), while that for chlorine and bromine was 96.8 ± 6.9 % (k = 2) and 97.4 ± 9.6 % (k = 2), respectively. The calibration method was tested against the internal permeation (Hg0) source of the Tekran 2537B Hg analyzer on-field by loading HgO to different KCl-coated denuders using the plasma. GOM concentrations were measured using the Tekran speciation system. With internal calibration, concentrations were up to 9.1 % lower than those in plasma calibration, thereby emphasizing the importance of the calibration strategy. Measurement uncertainty (k = 2) further emphasizes this distinction. Internal calibration measurement uncertainty was 36.8 %, while plasma calibration boasted lower uncertainty at 13.8 %.

SIGNIFICANCE

The non-thermal plasma calibration strategy, as a unique and discrete calibration method traceable to the NIST SRM 3133 for ambient air GOM measurements, provide a higher level of confidence in the accuracy of GOM measurements with several advantages over other methods. Calibrations at extreme low concentrations (<100 pg) are possible with this method relevant to ambient air GOM concentrations.

Optimization of a pre-concentration method for the analysis of mercury isotopes in low-concentration foliar samples

Hg isotope analysis in samples from background regions is constrained by the presence of low Hg concentration and therefore requires a pre-concentration method. Existing Hg pre-concentration methods are constrained by long sample processing time and limited sample loading capacity. Using foliar samples as a test case, an optimized Hg pre-concentration method is presented that involves the microwave-assisted digestion of samples for Hg isotope analysis with the addition of a pre-digestion step. Microwave-digested foliar samples and CRMs were transferred to an impinger, reduced with SnCl2, and collected in a 2.25 mL concentrated inverse aqua regia (3:1 HNO3:HCl, v/v). This resulted in an optimal acid concentration in the solution ideal for analysis on MC-ICP-MS. The time for purging with Hg-free N2 was optimized to 30 min and the efficiency of the pre-concentration method was tested using a combination of approaches. Tests performed on pure reagents and matrix of foliar samples spiked with 197Hg radiotracer showed recoveries averaging 99 ± 1.7% and 100 ± 3.0%, respectively. Mercury at concentrations as low as 1.83 ng g-1 was pre-concentrated by digesting aliquots of foliage samples in individual digestion vessels. Recoveries following their pre-concentration averaged 99 ± 6.0%, whereas recoveries of 95 ± 4.7% and 95 ± 2.5% were achieved for NIST SRM 1575a (pine needle) and reagents spiked with NIST SRM 3133, respectively. Analysis using multicollector-ICP-MS showed low fractionation of δ202Hg during sample pre-concentration with no significant mass-independent fractionation. The proposed method is a relatively simple and robust way to prepare Hg samples for Hg isotopic analysis and is suitable even for complex biological matrices.

Comparison and calibration of methods for ambient reactive mercury quantification

Gaseous oxidized mercury (GOM) is the dominant form of atmospheric mercury (Hg) deposited and sequestered within ecosystems. Thus, accurate, calibrated measurements of GOM are needed. Here, two active membrane-based collection systems (RMAS) were used to determine GOM and particulate-bound Hg (PBM), as well as reactive Hg (RM = GOM + PBM), and compared with two dual-channel systems (DCS) and a Tekran 2537/1130 speciation system. The DCS measured operationally defined GOM by difference, using concentrations of gaseous elemental Hg (GEM) and total gaseous Hg. One DCS was linked to a custom-built, automated calibration system that permeated GEM, HgBr₂, or HgCl₂. The five systems were co-located for one-year to develop a dataset that would allow for understanding limitations of each system, and assessing measurement accuracy and long-term precision of the calibrator. The Tekran system measured ~14.5 % of the GOM measured by the other systems. The USU and UNR DCS and RMAS were significantly correlated, but the DCS was 50 and 30 % higher, respectively, than the RMAS. The calibrator performed consistently in the field and lab, and the DCS fully recovered GOM injected by the calibrator. Since the uncalibrated DCS measured the same concentrations as the calibrated DCS, they are both accurate methods for measuring RM and/or GOM. Some loss occurred from the RMAS membranes. SYNOPSIS: Accurate and calibrated measurements of atmospheric reactive mercury using membranes and two dual-channel systems.

Calibration Sources for Gaseous Oxidized Mercury: A Review of Source Design, Performance, and Operational Parameters

Mercury is a neurotoxin that, unlike many localized industrial pollutants, spreads globally through atmospheric transport. Mercury in the atmosphere is operationally partitioned into gaseous elemental mercury (GEM), gaseous oxidized mercury (GOM), and particulate-bound mercury (TPM). Although GOM makes up only a small fraction of Hg in the free troposphere under normal conditions, its role in the dry and wet deposition of mercury makes GOM a significant species for understanding the transport and fate of mercury in the atmosphere. Although instruments for atmospheric mercury speciation are commercially available, significant uncertainty is associated with the current speciation methods, from sample collection to calibration, for GOM measurements. This paper examines the custom-made calibration sources that have been developed for GOM measuring instruments, evaluates the factors influencing the source performance, and synthesizes recommendations for the design and operation of GOM calibration sources in the future.

Calibration Approach for Gaseous Oxidized Mercury Based on Nonthermal Plasma Oxidation of Elemental Mercury

Atmospheric mercury measurements carried out in the recent decades have been a subject of bias largely due to insufficient consideration of metrological traceability and associated measurement uncertainty, which are ultimately needed for the demonstration of comparability of the measurement results. This is particularly challenging for gaseous Hg^II species, which are reactive and their ambient concentrations are very low, causing difficulties in proper sampling and calibration. Calibration for atmospheric Hg^II exists, but barriers to reliable calibration are most evident at ambient Hg^II concentration levels. We present a calibration of Hg^II species based on nonthermal plasma oxidation of Hg⁰ to Hg^II. Hg⁰ was produced by quantitative reduction of Hg^II in aqueous solution by SnCl₂ and aeration. The generated Hg⁰ in a stream of He and traces of reaction gas (O₂, Cl₂, or Br₂) was then oxidized to different Hg^II species by nonthermal plasma. A highly sensitive ¹⁹⁷Hg radiotracer was used to evaluate the oxidation efficiency. Nonthermal plasma oxidation efficiencies with corresponding expanded standard uncertainty values were 100.5 ± 4.7% (k = 2) for 100 pg of HgO, 96.8 ± 7.3% (k = 2) for 250 pg of HgCl₂, and 77.3 ± 9.4% (k = 2) for 250 pg of HgBr₂. The presence of HgO, HgCl₂, and HgBr₂ was confirmed by temperature-programmed desorption quadrupole mass spectrometry (TPD-QMS). This work demonstrates the potential for nonthermal plasma oxidation to generate reliable and repeatable amounts of Hg^II compounds for routine calibration of ambient air measurement instrumentation.