Are We Ready for NGS HIV Drug Resistance Testing? The Second "Winnipeg Consensus" Symposium

Performance of the Applied Biosystems HIV-1 Genotyping Kit with Integrase

HIV genotyping is used to assess HIV susceptibility to antiretroviral drugs. The Applied Biosystems HIV-1 Genotyping Kit with Integrase (AB kit, Thermo Fisher Scientific) detects resistance-associated mutations (RAMs) in HIV protease (PR), reverse transcriptase (RT), and integrase (IN). We compared results from the AB kit with results obtained previously with the ViroSeq HIV-1 Genotyping System. DNA amplicons from the AB kit were also analyzed using next-generation sequencing (NGS). HIV RNA was extracted using the MagNA Pure 24 instrument (Roche Diagnostics; 96 plasma samples, HIV subtype B, viral load range: 530-737,741 copies/mL). FASTA files were generated from AB kit data using Exatype (Hyrax Biosciences). DNA amplicons from the AB kit were also analyzed by NGS using the Nextera XT kit (Illumina). Drug resistance was predicted using the Stanford HIV Drug Resistance Database. The mean genetic distance for sequences from ViroSeq and the AB kit was 0.02% for PR/RT and 0.04% for IN; 103 major RAMs were detected by both methods. Four additional major RAMs were detected by the AB kit only. These four major RAMs were also detected by NGS (detected in 18.1%-38.2% of NGS reads). NGS detected 27 major RAMs that were not detected with either of the Sanger sequencing-based kits. All major RAMs detected with ViroSeq were detected with the AB kit; additional RAMs were detected with the AB kit only. DNA amplicons from the AB kit can be used for NGS for more sensitive detection of RAMs.

Portable Nanopore sequencing solution for next-generation HIV drug resistance testing

BACKGROUND

Tackling HIV drug resistance is one of major challenges for ending AIDS epidemic, but the elevated expense of cutting-edge genomics hampers the advancement of HIV genotype testing for clinical care.

METHODS

We developed a HIV genotype testing pipeline that centers on a cost-efficient portable Nanopore sequencer. Accuracy verification was conducted through comparison with parallel data obtained via fixed-site Pacbio sequencing. Our complete pol-gene sequencing strategy coupled with portable high-throughput sequencing was applied to identify drug resistance mutations across 58 samples sourced from the ART-treated Los Angeles General Medical Center Rand Schrader Clinic (LARSC) cohort (7 samples from 7 individuals) and the ART-naïve Center for HIV/AIDS Vaccine Immunology (CHAVI) cohort (51 samples from 38 individuals).

RESULTS

A total of 472 HIV consensus sequences, each tagged with a unique molecular identifier, were produced from over 1.4 million bases acquired through portable Nanopore sequencing, which matched those obtained independently via Pacbio sequencing. With this desirable accuracy, we first documented the linkage of multidrug cross-resistance mutations across Integrase Strand Transfer inhibitors (INSTIs) and Non-Nucleoside Reverse Transcriptase Inhibitors (NNRTIs) from an individual failing a second-generation INSTI regimen. By producing more than 500 full-length HIV pol gene sequences in a single portable sequencing run, we detected Protease Inhibitor (PI), Nucleoside Reverse Transcriptase Inhibitor (NRTI), NNRTI and INSTI resistance mutations. All drug resistance mutations identified through portable sequencing were cross-validated using fixed-site Pacbio sequencing.

CONCLUSIONS

Our accurate and affordable HIV drug resistance testing solution is adaptable for both individual patient care and large-scale surveillance initiatives.

Advancing HIV Drug Resistance Technologies and Strategies: Insights from South Africa's Experience and Future Directions for Resource-Limited Settings

Monitoring of HIV drug resistance (HIVDR) remains critical for ensuring countries attain and sustain the global goals for ending HIV as a public health threat by 2030. On an individual patient level, drug resistance results assist in ensuring unnecessary treatment switches are avoided and subsequent regimens are tailored on a case-by-case basis, should resistance be detected. Although there is a disparity in access to HIVDR testing in high-income countries compared to low- and middle-income countries (LMICS), more LMICs have now included HIVDR testing for individual patient management in some groups of patients. In this review, we describe different strategies for surveillance as well as where HIVDR testing can be implemented for individual patient management. In addition, we briefly review available technologies for HIVDR testing in LMICs, including Sanger sequencing, next-generation sequencing, and some point-of-care options. Finally, we describe how South Africa has implemented HIVDR testing in the public sector.

Laboratory diagnosis of HIV: a contemporary overview in the Australian context

Over the past decade there have been technical advances in human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) assays and updates to testing regulations that have substantially changed the landscape of laboratory testing for HIV. In addition, there have been significant changes in the epidemiology of HIV in Australia in the context of highly effective contemporary biomedical treatment and prevention strategies. Here, we provide an update on contemporary issues for the laboratory detection and confirmation of HIV in Australia. These include (1) the impact of early treatment and biological prevention strategies on the serological and virological detection of HIV; (2) the updated national HIV laboratory case definition and its interaction with testing regulations, public health and clinical guidelines; and (3) novel strategies for the laboratory detection of HIV, including the incorporation of HIV nucleic acid amplification tests (NAATs) into testing algorithms. These developments present an opportunity to develop a nationally consistent contemporary HIV testing algorithm that would result in optimisation and standardisation of HIV testing in Australia.

QuasiFlow: a Nextflow pipeline for analysis of NGS-based HIV-1 drug resistance data

Summary

Next-generation sequencing (NGS) enables reliable detection of resistance mutations in minority variants of human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1). There is paucity of evidence for the association of minority resistance to treatment failure, and this requires evaluation. However, the tools for analyzing HIV-1 drug resistance (HIVDR) testing data are mostly web-based which requires uploading data to webservers. This is a challenge for laboratories with internet connectivity issues and instances with restricted data transfer across networks. We present QuasiFlow, a pipeline for reproducible analysis of NGS-based HIVDR testing data across different computing environments. Since QuasiFlow entirely depends on command-line tools and a local copy of the reference database, it eliminates challenges associated with uploading HIV-1 NGS data onto webservers. The pipeline takes raw sequence reads in FASTQ format as input and generates a user-friendly report in PDF/HTML format. The drug resistance scores obtained using QuasiFlow were 100% and 99.12% identical to those obtained using web-based HIVdb program and HyDRA web respectively at a mutation detection threshold of 20%.

Availability and implementation

QuasiFlow and corresponding documentation are publicly available at https://github.com/AlfredUg/QuasiFlow. The pipeline is implemented in Nextflow and requires regular updating of the Stanford HIV drug resistance interpretation algorithm.

Supplementary information

Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics Advances online.

Low-frequency pre-treatment HIV drug resistance: effects on 2-year outcome of first-line efavirenz-based antiretroviral therapy

OBJECTIVES

Assess the impact of pre-treatment high-frequency and low-frequency drug-resistant HIV variants on long-term outcomes of first-line efavirenz-based antiretroviral therapy (ART).

DESIGN

Prospective observational study.

METHODS

Participants' pre-treatment plasma RNA had two sections of HIV pol encoding reverse transcriptase sequenced (Illumina, MiSeq) using unique molecular identifiers to detect wild-type (pre-treatment drug-resistant variants less than 1% of viral quasispecies), low-frequency (1-9%) or high-frequency drug-resistant variants (10-100%). Associations between pre-treatment drug resistance and virologic outcomes over 24 months of efavirenz-based ART were assessed for the number and frequency of mutations by drug class and other resistance parameters.

RESULTS

Virologic failure was detected in 30 of 352 (9%) and pre-treatment drug-resistant variants were detected in the viral quasispecies of 31 of 352 (9%) participants prescribed efavirenz-based ART. Survival analyses revealed statistically significant associations between pre-treatment drug resistance at low (P < 0.0001) and high (P < 0.001) frequencies, at oligonucleotide ligation assay (OLA) (P < 0.00001) and non-OLA (P < 0.01) codons, to a single-antiretroviral class (P < 0.00001), and a shorter time to virologic failure of efavirenz-based ART. Regression analyses detected independent effects across resistance categories, including both low-frequency (P < 0.01) and high-frequency (P < 0.001) drug-resistant variants.

CONCLUSION

We observed that pre-treatment HIV drug resistance detected at low frequencies increased the risk of virologic failure over 24 months of efavirenz-based ART, but that most failures, regardless of drug-resistant variants' frequencies, were detected within a year of ART initiation. These observations suggest that when efavirenz-based ART is prescribed, screening for pre-treatment drug resistance by an assay capable of detecting low-frequency variants, including OLA, may guide clinicians to prescribe more effective ART.

Establishment and application of a method of tagged-amplicon deep sequencing for low-abundance drug resistance in HIV-1

In the latest HIV-1 global drug resistance report released by WHO, countries are advised to strengthen pre-treatment monitoring of drug resistance in AIDS patients. In this study, we established an NGS-based segmented amplification HIV-1 drug resistance mutation detection method. The pol region of HIV-1 was divided into three short fragments for NGS. The entire amplification and sequencing panel were more cost-effective and batched by using the barcode sequence corresponding to the sample. Each parameter was evaluated using samples with known resistance variants frequencies. The nucleotide sequence error rate, amino acid error rate, and noise value of the NGS-based segmented amplification method were both less than 1%. When the threshold was 2%, the consensus sequences of the HIV-1 NL4-3 strain were completely consistent with the Sanger sequences. This method can detect the minimum viral load of the sample at 10² copies/ml, and the input frequency and detection frequency of HIV-1 resistance mutations within the range of 1%–100% had good conformity (R² = 0.9963; R² = 0.9955). This method had no non-specific amplification for Hepatitis B and C. Under the 2% threshold, the incidence of surveillance drug resistance mutations in ART-naive HIV-infected patients was 20.69%, among which NRTIs class resistance mutations were mainly.

Protease and gag diversity and drug resistance mutations among treatment-naive Mexican people living with HIV

Introduction

In Mexico, HIV genotyping is performed in people living with HIV (PLWH) failing their first-line antiretroviral (ARV) regimen; it is not routinely done for all treatment-naive PLWH before ARV initiation. The first nationally representative survey published in 2016 reported that the prevalence of pretreatment drug mutations in treatment-naive Mexican PLWH was 15.5% to any antiretroviral drug and 10.6% to non-nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitors (NNRTIs) using conventional Sanger sequencing. Most reports in Mexico focus on HIV pol gene and nucleoside and non-nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor (NRTI and NNRTI) drug resistance mutations (DRMs) prevalence, using Sanger sequencing, next-generation sequencing (NGS) or both. To our knowledge, NGS has not be used to detect pretreatment drug resistance mutations (DRMs) in the HIV protease (PR) gene and its substrate the Gag polyprotein.

Methods

Treatment-naive adult Mexican PLWH were recruited between 2016 and 2019. HIV Gag and protease sequences were obtained by NGS and DRMs were identified using the WHO surveillance drug resistance mutation (SDRM) list.

Results

One hundred PLWH attending a public national reference hospital were included. The median age was 28 years-old, and most were male. The median HIV viral load was 4.99 [4.39–5.40] log copies/mL and median CD4 cell count was 150 [68.0–355.78] cells/mm³. As expected, most sequences clustered with HIV-1 subtype B (97.9%). Major PI resistance mutations were detected: 8 (8.3%) of 96 patients at a detection threshold of 1% and 3 (3.1%) at a detection threshold of 20%. A total of 1184 mutations in Gag were detected, of which 51 have been associated with resistance to PI, most of them were detected at a threshold of 20%. Follow-up clinical data was available for 79 PLWH at 6 months post-ART initiation, seven PLWH failed their first ART regimen; however no major PI mutations were identified in these individuals at baseline.

Conclusions

The frequency of DRM in the HIV protease was 7.3% at a detection threshold of 1% and 3.1% at a detection threshold of 20%. NGS-based HIV drug resistance genotyping provide improved detection of DRMs. Viral load was used to monitor ARV response and treatment failure was 8.9%.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12879-022-07446-8.

Analytical Assessment of the Vela Diagnostics NGS Assay for HIV Genotyping and Resistance Testing: The Apulian Experience

Drug-resistance monitoring is one of the hardest challenges in HIV management. Next-generation sequencing (NGS) technologies speed up the detection of drug resistance, allowing the adjustment of antiretroviral therapy and enhancing the quality of life of people living with HIV. Recently, the NGS Sentosa^® SQ HIV Genotyping Assay (Vela Diagnostics) received approval for in vitro diagnostics use. This work is the first Italian evaluation of the performance of the Vela Diagnostics NGS platform, assessed with 420 HIV-1 clinical samples. A comparison with Sanger sequencing performance is also reported, highlighting the advantages and disadvantages of the Sentosa^® NGS assay. The precision of the technology was studied with reference specimens, while intra- and inter-assay reproducibility were evaluated for selected clinical samples. Vela Diagnostics’ NGS assay reached an 87% success rate through 30 runs of analysis in a real-world clinical context. The concordance with Sanger sequencing outcomes was equal to 97.2%. Several detected mismatches were due to NGS’s superior sensitivity to low-frequency variants. A high accuracy was observed in testing reference samples. Repeatability and reproducibility assays highlighted the good performance of the NGS platform. Beyond a few technical issues that call for further optimization, the key improvement will be a better balance between costs and processing speed. Once these issues have been solved, the Sentosa^® SQ HIV Genotyping Assay will be the way forward for HIV resistance testing.

Strengths and caveats of identifying resistance genes from whole genome sequencing data

INTRODUCTION

Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) continues to present major challenges to modern healthcare. Recent advances in whole-genome sequencing (WGS) have made the rapid molecular characterization of AMR a realistic possibility for diagnostic laboratories; yet major barriers to clinical implementation exist.

AREAS COVERED

We describe and compare short- and long-read sequencing platforms, typical components of bioinformatics pipelines, tools for AMR gene detection and the relative merits of read- or assembly-based approaches. The challenges of characterizing mobile genetic elements from genomic data are outlined, as well as the complexities inherent to the prediction of phenotypic resistance from WGS. Practical obstacles to implementation in diagnostic laboratories, the critical role of quality control and external quality assurance, as well as standardized reporting standards are also discussed. Future directions, such as the application of machine-learning and artificial intelligence algorithms, linked to clinically meaningful outcomes, may offer a new paradigm for the clinical application of AMR prediction.

EXPERT OPINION

AMR prediction from WGS data presents an exciting opportunity to advance our capacity to comprehensively characterize infectious pathogens in a rapid manner, ultimately aiming to improve patient outcomes. Collaborative efforts between clinicians, scientists, regulatory bodies and healthcare administrators will be critical to achieve the full promise of this approach.

Viral resistance burden and APOBEC editing correlate with virological response in heavily treatment-experienced people living with multi-drug resistant HIV

BACKGROUND

The impact of drug resistance mutational load and APOBEC editing in heavily treatment-experienced (HTE) people living with multidrug-resistant HIV has not been investigated.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

This study explored the HIV-DNA and HIV-RNA mutational load of drug resistance and APOBEC-related mutations through next-generation sequencing (NGS, Illumina MiSeq) in 20 failing HTE participants enrolled in the PRESTIGIO registry.

RESULTS

The patients showed high levels of both HIV-DNA (4.5 [4.0-5.2] log₁₀ copies/10⁶ T-CD4+ cell) and HIV-RNA (4.5 [4.1-5.0] log₁₀ copies/mL) with complex resistance patterns in both compartments. Among the 255 drug-resistant mutations found, 66.3% were concordantly detected in both HIV-DNA and HIV-RNA; 71.3% of mutations were already present in historical Sanger genotypes. At an intra-patient frequency > 5%, a considerable proportion of mutations detected through DNA-NGS were found in historical genotypes but not through RNA-NGS, and few patients had APOBEC-related mutations. Of 14 patients who switched therapy, the five who failed treatment had DNA resistance with higher intra-patient frequency and higher DNA/RNA mutational load in a context of tendentially less pronounced APOBEC editing compared with those who responded.

CONCLUSIONS

Using NGS in HIV-DNA and HIV-RNA together with APOBEC editing evaluation might help to identify HTE individuals with MDR who are more prone to experience virological failure.

Screening of anti-HIV activities in ethanol extract and fractions from Ficus fistulosa leaves

OBJECTIVES

Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection is considered as a major immunosuppressive disease linked to malignancies and other opportunistic infections. Recently, the high prevalence of HIV drug-resistant strains required a high demand for novel antiviral drug development, especially in herbal medicine approaches. The objective of this study was to evaluate the possibility of Ficus fistulosa leaves can inhibit HIV replication in ethanol extract form as well as its fractions using chloroform, ethyl acetate, and butanol solvents.

METHODS

F. fistulosa leaves were extracted using ethanol as a solvent and further gradually fractionated in chloroform, ethyl acetate, and butanol solvents. The targeted persistently infected virus (MT4/HIV) cell lines were cocultured with ethanol extract and fractions at different time points. The syncytium formation and cytotoxicity assays were performed to evaluate the potential antiviral activity of F. fistulosa leaves.

RESULTS

One of the four tested extract/fractions showed antiviral activity against HIV. The ethanol extract showed weak inhibition with a high level of toxicity (IC₅₀ = 8.96 μg/mL, CC₅₀ ≥50 μg/mL, and SI = 5.58). Meanwhile, chloroform fraction effectively inhibited the MT4/HIV cell proliferation while keeping the toxicity to a minimal level (IC₅₀ = 3.27 μg/mL, CC₅₀ = 29.30 μg/mL, and SI = 8.96). In contrast of ethyl acetate fraction and butanol fraction showed no anti HIV activity with a high level of toxicity (CC₅₀ ≥50 μg/mL) and low SI value (>2.17 μg/mL and >0.97 μg/mL).

CONCLUSIONS

Chloroform fraction of F. fistulosa leaves showed effectively as anti-viral activity against MT4/HIV cells.

HIV-1 Drug Resistance Genotyping in Resource Limited Settings: Current and Future Perspectives in Sequencing Technologies

Affordable, sensitive, and scalable technologies are needed for monitoring antiretroviral treatment (ART) success with the goal of eradicating HIV-1 infection. This review discusses use of Sanger sequencing and next generation sequencing (NGS) methods for HIV-1 drug resistance (HIVDR) genotyping, focusing on their use in resource limited settings (RLS). Sanger sequencing remains the gold-standard method for detecting HIVDR mutations of clinical relevance but is mainly limited by high sequencing costs and low-throughput. NGS is becoming a more common sequencing method, with the ability to detect low-abundance drug-resistant variants and reduce per sample costs through sample pooling and massive parallel sequencing. However, use of NGS in RLS is mainly limited by infrastructure costs. Given these shortcomings, our review discusses sequencing technologies for HIVDR genotyping, focusing on common in-house and commercial assays, challenges with Sanger sequencing in keeping up with changes in HIV-1 treatment programs, as well as challenges with NGS that limit its implementation in RLS and in clinical diagnostics. We further discuss knowledge gaps and offer recommendations on how to overcome existing barriers for implementing HIVDR genotyping in RLS, to make informed clinical decisions that improve quality of life for people living with HIV.

Next Generation Sequencing for HIV-1 Drug Resistance Testing-A Special Issue Walkthrough

Drug resistance remains a global challenge in the fight against the HIV pandemic [...].

Development and Application of Performance Assessment Criteria for Next-Generation Sequencing-Based HIV Drug Resistance Assays

Next-generation sequencing (NGS)-based HIV drug resistance (HIVDR) assays outperform conventional Sanger sequencing in scalability, sensitivity, and quantitative detection of minority resistance variants. Thus far, HIVDR assays have been applied primarily in research but rarely in clinical settings. One main obstacle is the lack of standardized validation and performance evaluation systems that allow regulatory agencies to benchmark and accredit new assays for clinical use. By revisiting the existing principles for molecular assay validation, here we propose a new validation and performance evaluation system that helps to both qualitatively and quantitatively assess the performance of an NGS-based HIVDR assay. To accomplish this, we constructed a 70-specimen proficiency test panel that includes plasmid mixtures at known ratios, viral RNA from infectious clones, and anonymized clinical specimens. We developed assessment criteria and benchmarks for NGS-based HIVDR assays and used these to assess data from five separate MiSeq runs performed in two experienced HIVDR laboratories. This proposed platform may help to pave the way for the standardization of NGS HIVDR assay validation and performance evaluation strategies for accreditation and quality assurance purposes in both research and clinical settings.