Transplanted hNT Cells (“LBS Neurons”) in a Rat Model of Huntington's Disease: Good Survival, Incomplete Differentiation, and Limited Functional Recovery

Bringing Neural Cell Therapies to the Clinic: Past and Future Strategies

Cell replacement therapy in the nervous system has a rich history, with ∼40 years of research and ∼30 years of clinical experience. There is compelling evidence that appropriate cells can integrate and function in the dysfunctioning human nervous system, but the clinical results are mixed in practice. A number of factors conspire to vary patient outcome: the indication, cell source, patient selection, and team performing transplantation are all variables that can affect efficacy. Most early clinical trials have used fetal cells, a limited cell source that resists scale and standardization. Direct fetal cell transplantation creates significant challenges to commercialization that is the ultimate goal of an effective cell therapy. One approach to help scale and standardize fetal cell preparations is the expansion of neural cells in vitro. Expansion is achieved by transformation or through the application of mitogens before cryopreservation. Recently, neural cells derived from pluripotent stem cells have provided a scalable alternative. Pluripotent stem cells are desirable for manufacturing but present alternative concerns and manufacturing obstacles. All cell sources require robust and reproducible manufacturing to make nervous system cell replacement therapy an option for patients. Here, we discuss the challenges and opportunities for cell replacement in the nervous system. In this review, we give an overview of completed and ongoing neural cell transplantation clinical trials, and we discuss the challenges and opportunities for future cell replacement trials with a particular focus on pluripotent stem cell-derived therapies.

Transplantation of GABAergic cells derived from bioreactor-expanded human neural precursor cells restores motor and cognitive behavioral deficits in a rodent model of Huntington's disease

Huntington's disease (HD) is a neurodegenerative disorder that is characterized by progressive dementia, choreiform involuntary movements, and emotional deterioration. Neuropathological features include the progressive degeneration of striatal γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA) neurons. New therapeutic approaches, such as the transplantation of human neural precursor cells (hNPCs) to replace damaged or degenerated cells, are currently being investigated. The aim of this study was to investigate the potential for utilizing telencephalic hNPCs expanded in suspension bioreactors for cell restorative therapy in a rodent model of HD. hNPCs were expanded in a hydrodynamically controlled and homogeneous environment under serum-free conditions. In vitro analysis revealed that the bioreactor-expanded telencephalic (BET)-hNPCs could be differentiated into a highly enriched population of GABAergic neurons. Behavioral assessments of unilateral striatal quinolinic acid-lesioned rodents revealed a significant improvement in motor and memory deficits following transplantation with GABAergic cells differentiated from BET-hNPCs. Immunohistochemical analysis revealed that transplanted BET-hNPCs retained a GABAergic neuronal phenotype without aberrant transdifferentiation or tumor formation, indicating that BET-hNPCs are a safe source of cells for transplantation. This preclinical study has important implications as the transplantation of GABAergic cells derived from predifferentiated BET-hNPCs may be a safe and feasible cell replacement strategy to promote behavioral recovery in HD.

Implantation of undifferentiated and pre-differentiated human neural stem cells in the R6/2 transgenic mouse model of Huntington's disease

Background

Cell therapy is a potential therapeutic approach for several neurodegenetative disease, including Huntington Disease (HD). To evaluate the putative efficacy of cell therapy in HD, most studies have used excitotoxic animal models with only a few studies having been conducted in genetic animal models. Genetically modified animals should provide a more accurate representation of human HD, as they emulate the genetic basis of its etiology.

Results

In this study, we aimed to assess the therapeutic potential of a human striatal neural stem cell line (STROC05) implanted in the R6/2 transgenic mouse model of HD. As DARPP-32 GABAergic output neurons are predominately lost in HD, STROC05 cells were also pre-differentiated using purmorphamine, a hedgehog agonist, to yield a greater number of DARPP-32 cells. A bilateral injection of 4.5x10⁵ cells of either undifferentiated or pre-differentiated DARPP-32 cells, however, did not affect outcome compared to a vehicle control injection. Both survival and neuronal differentiation remained poor with a mean of only 161 and 81 cells surviving in the undifferentiated and differentiated conditions respectively. Only a few cells expressed the neuronal marker Fox3.

Conclusions

Although the rapid brain atrophy and short life-span of the R6/2 model constitute adverse conditions to detect potentially delayed treatment effects, significant technical hurdles, such as poor cell survival and differentiation, were also sub-optimal. Further consideration of these aspects is therefore needed in more enduring transgenic HD models to provide a definite assessment of this cell line’s therapeutic relevance. However, a combination of treatments is likely needed to affect outcome in transgenic models of HD.

Cell therapy in Huntington disease

Huntington disease (HD), caused by polyglutamate expansions in the huntingtin protein, is a progressive neurodegenerative disease resulting in cognitive and motor impairments and death. Neuronal dysfunction and degeneration contribute to progressive physiological, motor, cognitive, and emotional disturbances characteristic of HD. A major impetus for research into the treatment of HD has centered on cell therapy strategies to protect vulnerable neuronal cell populations or to replace dysfunctional or dying cells. The work underlying 3 approaches to HD cell therapy includes the potential for self-repair through the manipulation of endogenous stem cells and/or neurogenesis, the use of fetal or stem cell transplantation as a cell replacement strategy, and the administration of neurotrophic factors to protect susceptible neuronal populations. These approaches have shown some promising results in animal models of HD. Although striatal transplantation of fetal-derived cells has undergone clinical assessment since the 1990s, many cell therapy strategies have yet to be applied in the clinic environment. A more thorough understanding of the pathophysiologies underlying HD as well as the response of both endogenous and exogenous cells to the degenerating brain will inform their merit as potential therapeutic agents and enhance the framework by which the success of such strategies are determined.

A comparison of dopaminergic cells from the human NTera2/D1 cell line transplanted into the hemiparkinsonian rat

Human NT cells derived from the NTera2/D1 cell line express a dopaminergic phenotype making them an attractive vehicle to supply dopamine to the depleted striatum of the Parkinsonian patient. In vitro, hNT neurons express tyrosine hydroxylase (TH), depending on the length of time they are exposed to retinoic acid. This study compared two populations of hNT neurons that exhibit a high yield of TH+ cells, MI-hNT and DA-hNT. The MI-hNT and DA-hNT neurons were intrastriatally transplanted into the 6-OHDA hemiparkinsonian rat. Amelioration in rotational behavior was measured and immunohistochemistry was performed to identify surviving hNT and TH+ hNT neurons. Results indicated that both MI-hNT and DA-hNT neurons can survive in the striatum, however, neither maintained their dopaminergic phenotype in vivo. Other strategies used in conjunction with hNT cell replacement are likely needed to enhance and maintain the dopamine expression in the grafted cells.

Stem cell transplantation for Huntington's disease

By way of commentary on a recent report that transplanted adult neural progenitor cells can alleviate functional deficits in a rat lesion model of Huntington's disease [Vazey, E.M., Chen, K., Hughes, S.M., Connor, B., 2006. Transplanted adult neural progenitor cells survive, differentiate and reduce motor function impairment in a rodent model of Huntington's disease. Exp. Neurol. 199, 384-396], we review the current status of the field exploring the use of stem cells, progenitor cells and immortalised cell lines to repair the lesioned striatum in animal models of the human disease. A remarkably rich range of alternative cell types have been used in various animal models, several of which exhibit cell survival and incorporation in the host brain, leading to subsequent functional recovery. In comparing the alternatives with the 'gold standard' currently offered by primary tissue grafts, key issues turn out to be: cell survival, differentiation prior to and following implantation into striatal-like phenotypes, integration and connectivity with the host brain, the nature of the electrophysiological, motor and cognitive tests used to assess functional repair, and the mechanisms by which the grafts exert their function. Although none of the alternatives yet has the capacity to match primary fetal tissues for functional repair, that standard is itself limited, and the long term goal must be not just to match but to surpass present capabilities in order to achieve fully functional reconstruction reliably, flexibly, and on demand.

Time of transplantation and cell preparation determine neural stem cell survival in a mouse model of Huntington’s disease

Cell replacement therapies for neurodegenerative diseases, using multipotent neural stem cells (NSCs), require above all, a good survival of the graft. In this study, we unilaterally injected quinolinic acid (QA) into the striatum of adult mice and transplanted syngeneic NSCs of enhanced green fluorescent protein-transgenic mice into the lesioned striatum. The injection of QA leads to an excitotoxic lesion with selective cell death of the medium sized spiny neurons, the same cells that are affected in Huntington's disease. In order to investigate the best timing of transplantation for the survival of donor cells, we transplanted the stem cells at 2, 7 and 14 days after injury. In addition, the influence of graft preparation prior to transplantation, i.e., intact neurospheres versus dissociated cell suspension on graft survival was investigated. By far the best survival was found with the combination of early transplantation (i.e., 2 days after QA-lesion) with the use of neurospheres instead of dissociated cell suspension. This might be due to the different states of host's astrocytic and microglia activation which we found to be moderate at 2, but pronounced at 7 and 14 days after QA-lesion. We also investigated brain derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF)-expression in the striatum after QA-lesion and found no significant change in BDNF protein-level. We conclude that already the method of graft preparation of NSCs for transplantation, as well as the timing of the transplantation procedure strongly affects the survival of the donor cells when grafted into the QA-lesioned striatum of adult mice.

GABAergic lineage differentiation of AF5 neural progenitor cells in vitro

We have previously described an immortal rat central-nervous-system progenitor cell line, AF5, which is able to exit the cell cycle and assume a differentiated state with neuronal properties. The phenotypic specification of differentiated AF5 cells, however, is not known. In the present study, when induced to differentiate by serum starvation in Neurobasal medium, AF5 cells down-regulate glial fibrillary acidic protein and up-regulate expression of beta-III-tubulin, medium-molecular-weight neurofilament protein, and neuronal growth-associated protein 43. Expression of the gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) lineage marker, glutamic acid decarboxylase 67 (GAD67), increases during differentiation, suggesting that AF5 cells adopt a GABAergic lineage. Time-course analysis of the GABAergic neuron specification transcription factor, Pitx2, by reverse transcription/polymerase chain reaction, has shown an increase in the Pitx2 transcript 48 h after initiation of differentiation. In differentiated AF5 cells, expression of the Pitx2 target gene products GAD65 and GABA transporter-1 increases. Cellular GABA levels in differentiated AF5 cells increase by about 26-fold, and GABA release into the medium is 150-fold higher compared with that of undifferentiated cells. Therefore, AF5 cells can be induced to differentiate to a neuronal phenotype with a GABAergic lineage.

Preservation of striatal tissue and behavioral function after neural stem cell transplantation in a rat model of Huntington’s disease

Cell replacement has the potential to become a frontline therapy to remedy behavioral impairments in Huntington's disease. To determine the efficacy of stem cell transplantation, behavioral assessment and in vivo monitoring of the lesion environment are paramount. We here demonstrate that neural stem cells from the MHP36 cell line prevented the development of a deficit on the beam walk test while providing partial recovery of learning in the water maze. However, no beneficial effect on rats' impairment in the staircase test was observed. By quantification of the lesion from serial magnetic resonance images, no effect of neural stem cells on lesion volume was observed. Instead, a preservation of striatal volume over time and its correlation with performance on the beam walk test suggested that sparing of behavioral function was associated with a stagnation of ongoing tissue loss rather than a reduction in lesion size. Serial imaging therefore warrants further implementation in clinical trials of neural grafts to monitor in vivo changes in the damaged brain due to transplantation.

Transplantation of hNT neurons into the ischemic cortex: Cell survival and effect on sensorimotor behavior

Cell transplantation offers a potential new treatment for stroke. Animal studies using models that produce ischemic damage in both the striatum and the frontal cortex have shown beneficial effects when hNT cells (postmitotic immature neurons) were transplanted into the ischemic striatum. In this study, we investigated the effect of hNT cells in a model of stroke in which the striatum remains intact and damage is restricted to the cortex. hNT cells were transplanted into the ischemic cortex 1 week after stroke induced by distal middle cerebral artery occlusion (dMCAo). The cells exhibited robust survival at 4 weeks posttransplant even at the lesion border. hNT cells did not migrate, but they did extend long neurites into the surrounding parenchyma mainly through the white matter. Neurite extension was predominantly toward the lesion in ischemic animals but was bidirectional in uninjured animals. Extension of neurites through the cortex toward the lesion was also seen when there was some surviving cortical tissue between the graft and the infarct. Prolonged deficits were obtained in four tests of sensory-motor function. hNT-transplanted animals showed a significant improvement in functional recovery on one motor test, but there was no effect on the other three tests relative to control animals. Thus, despite clear evidence of graft survival and neurite extension, the functional benefit of hNT cells after ischemia is not guaranteed. Functional benefit could depend on other variables, such as infarct location, whether the cells mature, the behavioral tests employed, rehabilitation training, or as yet unidentified factors.

Tumorigenicity issues of embryonic carcinoma-derived stem cells: relevance to surgical trials using NT2 and hNT neural cells

Cell therapy is a rapidly moving field with new cells, cell lines, and tissue-engineered constructs being developed globally. As these novel cells are further developed for transplantation studies, it is important to understand their safety profiles both prior to and posttransplantation in animals and humans. Embryonic carcinoma-derived cells are considered an important alternative to stem cells. The NTera2/D1 teratocarcinoma cell-line (or NT2-N cells) gives rise to neuron-like cells called hNT neurons after exposure to retinoic acid. NT2 cells form tumors upon transplantation into the rodent. However, when the NT2 cells are treated with retinoic acid to produce hNT cells, they terminally differentiate into post-mitotic neurons with no sign of tumorigenicity. Preliminary human transplantation studies in the brain of stroke patients also demonstrated a lack of tumorigenicity of these cells. This review focuses on the use of hNT neurons in cell transplantation for the treatment in central nervous system (CNS) diseases, disorders, or injuries and on the mechanism involved in retinoic acid exposure, final differentiation state, and subsequent tumorigenicity issues that must be considered prior to widespread clinical use.

Long distance selective fiber outgrowth of transplanted hNT neurons in white matter tracts of the adult rat brain

Terminally differentiated neurons derived from a human teratocarcinoma cell line (NT2N or hNT neurons) are promising as a cell source for transplantation, as they have been shown to be safe for transplantation in humans. We have shown previously that hNT neurons can express a catecholaminergic phenotype in a rat Parkinson model. In this study, we investigated the long-term survival and ability of hNT neurons to express tyrosine hydroxylase and reconstruct the dopamine-denervated nigrostriatal pathway. Hemiparkinsonian rats received grafts of 400,000 viable hNT neurons into each of the denervated striatum and substantia nigra. Robust hNT grafts were detected up to 24 weeks posttransplantation, although few cells expressed tyrosine hydroxylase. Many hNT fibers were often associated with ipsilateral and contralateral white matter tracts--corpus callosum, rostral migratory stream, optic tract, and external capsule. Fewer fibers were associated with the superior cerebellar peduncle, medial lemniscus, and nigrostriatal pathway. Axons also projected into the frontal cortex and extended parallel to the surface of the brain in the superficial cortical layers. These pathways were seen in all grafted animals, suggesting that specific guidance cues exist in the adult brain governing hNT fiber outgrowth. Injured adult axons and transplanted embryonic neuronal axons rarely extend for such distances in the adult nervous system. We propose that elucidating the factors promoting and guiding hNT axonal outgrowth could provide important clues to enhancing regeneration and target reinnervation in the adult brain, two factors of critical importance for cell restoration strategies aimed at brain repair.