Synthesis and herbicidal activities of aryloxyacetic acid derivatives as HPPD inhibitors

4-Hydroxyphenylpyruvate Dioxygenase Inhibitors: From Molecular Design to Synthesis

Weed resistance is a critical issue in crop production. Among the known herbicides, 4-hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase (HPPD) inhibitors are crucial for addressing weed resistance. HPPD inhibitors constitute a pivotal aspect of contemporary crop protection strategies. The advantages of these herbicides are their broad weed spectrum, flexible application, and excellent compatibility with other herbicides. They also exhibit satisfactory crop selectivity and low toxicity and are environmentally friendly. An increasing number of new HPPD inhibitors have been designed by combining computer-aided drug design with conventional design approaches. Herein, the molecular design and structural features of innovative HPPD inhibitors are reviewed to guide the development of new HPPD inhibitors possessing an enhanced biological efficacy.

Design, synthesis and herbicidal activity of novel cyclohexanedione derivations containing pyrazole and pyridine groups as potential HPPD inhibitors

4-Hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase (EC 1.13.11.27; HPPD) is one of the important target enzymes in the development of herbicides. To discover novel HPPD inhibitors with unique molecular, 39 cyclohexanedione derivations containing pyrazole and pyridine groups were designed and synthesized. The preliminary herbicidal activity test results showed that some compounds had obvious inhibitory effects on monocotyledon and dicotyledonous weeds. The herbicidal spectrums of the highly active compounds were further determined, and the compound G31 exhibited the best inhibitory rate over 90% against Plantago depressa Willd and Capsella bursa-pastoris at the dosages of 75.0 and 37.5 g ai/ha, which is comparable to the control herbicide mesotrione. Moreover, compound G31 showed excellent crop safety, with less than or equal to 10% injury rates to corn, sorghum, soybean and cotton at a dosage of 225 g ai/ha. Molecular docking and molecular dynamics simulation analysis revealed that the compound G31 could stably bind to Arabidopsis thaliana HPPD (AtHPPD). This study indicated that the compound G31 could be used as a lead molecular structure for the development of novel HPPD inhibitors, which provided an idea for the design of new herbicides with unique molecular scaffold.

A comprehensive study demonstrating the influence of the solvent composition on the phytotoxicity of compounds, as exemplified by 2,4-D-based ILs with a choline-type cation

BACKGROUND

Growing concern for the protection of the environment and existing ecosystems has resulted in increasing consideration of phytotoxicity tests as valid ecotoxicological indicators of the potential hazards of the use of ionic liquids (ILs) or any other chemical. The objective of this study was to gain a detailed understanding of the influence of the solvent composition of spray solutions on the phytotoxic effect of foliar application of ionic pairs with weak (choline 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetate, [Chol][2,4-D]), medium (N-hexylcholine 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetate, [C6 Chol][2,4-D]) and good (N-dodecylcholine 2,4-dichlorophenoxyacetate, [C12 Chol][2,4-D]) surface-active properties.

RESULTS

Experimental results unambiguously demonstrated that the biological activity of the test salt solutions, particularly [Chol][2,4-D] and [C6 Chol][2,4-D], can be strongly affected by the addition of an organic solvent, such as methanol, ethanol, dimethylformamide (DMF) or dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO) compared to solutions in pure water. However, the observed tendency is less pronounced for the compound exhibiting good surface activity, [C12 Chol][2,4-D].

CONCLUSIONS

The collected findings show that caution is warranted in the exploitation or modification of methodologies for assessing phytotoxicity to ensure the reliable interpretation of obtained results for environmental risk assessment or building quantitative structure-activity relationship (QSAR) models. © 2023 Society of Chemical Industry.

Insights into 4-hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase-inhibitor interactions from comparative structural biology

4-Hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase (HPPD) plays a key role in tyrosine metabolism and has been identified as a promising target for herbicide and drug discovery. The structures of HPPD complexed with different types of inhibitors have been determined previously. We summarize the structures of HPPD complexed with structurally diverse molecules, including inhibitors, natural products, substrates, and catalytic intermediates; from these structures, the detailed inhibitory mechanisms of different inhibitors were analyzed and compared, and the key structural factors determining the slow-binding behavior of inhibitors were identified. Further, we propose four subpockets that accommodate different inhibitor substructures. We believe that these analyses will facilitate in-depth understanding of the enzymatic reaction mechanism and enable the design of new inhibitors with higher potency and selectivity.

Discovery of Subnanomolar Inhibitors of 4-Hydroxyphenylpyruvate Dioxygenase via Structure-Based Rational Design

High-potency 4-hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase (HPPD) inhibitors are usually featured by time-dependent inhibition. However, the molecular mechanism underlying time-dependent inhibition by HPPD inhibitors has not been fully elucidated. Here, based on the determination of the HPPD binding mode of natural products, the π-π sandwich stacking interaction was found to be a critical element determining time-dependent inhibition. This result implied that, for the time-dependent inhibitors, strengthening the π-π sandwich stacking interaction might improve their inhibitory efficacy. Consequently, modification with one methyl group on the bicyclic ring of quinazolindione inhibitors was achieved, thereby strengthening the stacking interaction and significantly improving the inhibitory efficacy. Further introduction of bulkier hydrophobic substituents with higher flexibility resulted in a series of HPPD inhibitors with outstanding subnanomolar potency. Exploration of the time-dependent inhibition mechanism and molecular design based on the exploration results are very successful cases of structure-based rational design and provide a guiding reference for future development of HPPD inhibitors.

An efficient metal-free and catalyst-free C-S/C-O bond-formation strategy: synthesis of pyrazole-conjugated thioamides and amides

An operationally simple and metal-free approach is described for the synthesis of pyrazole-tethered thioamide and amide conjugates. The thioamides were generated by employing a three-component reaction of diverse pyrazole C-3/4/5 carbaldehydes, secondary amines, and elemental sulfur in a single synthetic operation. The advantages of this developed protocol refer to the broad substrate scope, metal-free and easy to perform reaction conditions. Moreover, the pyrazole C-3/5-linked amide conjugates were also synthesized via an oxidative amination of pyrazole carbaldehydes and 2-aminopyridines using hydrogen peroxide as an oxidant.

A Competitive Edge: Competitor Inspired Scaffold Hopping in Herbicide Lead Optimization

Over the years, scaffold hopping has proven to be a powerful tool in the agrochemical optimization process. It offers the opportunity to modify known molecular lead structures to improve a range of parameters, including biological efficacy and spectrum, physicochemical properties, toxicity, stability, and to secure new intellectual property. Very often the disclosure of a new chemical structure can spark a multitude of competitor activities, where scaffold hopping plays a crucial role in the optimization process as well as for the generation of new intellectual property. Herein, recent examples of scaffold hopping in early phase herbicide research based on competitor inspired activities will be discussed using examples of how these research campaigns can often result in the registration of new crop protection products.

Structure-Activity Relationship Study of Xanthoxyline and Related Small Methyl Ketone Herbicides

Xanthoxyline (1), a small natural methyl ketone, was previously reported as a plant growth inhibitor. In this research, related methyl ketones bearing electron-donating and electron-withdrawing groups, together with heteroaromatics, were investigated against seed germination and seedling growth of Chinese amaranth (Amaranthus tricolor L.) and barnyard grass [Echinochloa crus-galli (L.) Beauv]. The structure-activity relationships (SARs) of methyl ketone herbicides were clarified, and which types and positions of substituents were crucially important for activity were also clarified. Indole derivatives, namely, 3-acetylindole (43) and 3-acetyl-7-azaindole (44) were found to be the most active methyl ketones that highly suppressed plant growth at low concentrations. The molecular docking on the 4-hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase (HPPD) enzyme indicated that carbonyl, aromatic, and azaindole were key interactions of HPPD inhibitors. This finding would be useful for the development of small ketone herbicides.

Computer-Assisted Proposition of Promising Aryloxyacetic Acid Derivatives as HPPD Inhibitors

A series of aryloxyacetic acid derivatives have demonstrated promising herbicidal performance by inhibition of the hydroxyphenylpyruvate deoxygenase (HPPD) enzyme. We hereby applied quantitative structure-activity relationship (QSAR) and docking strategies to model and chemically understand the bioactivities of these compounds and subsequently propose unprecedented analogues aiming at improving the herbicidal and environmental properties. Bulky halogens at the 2-, 3-, 4-, and 6-positions of an aromatic ring, CF₃ in 4-position, and the 2-NO₂ group in a phenyl ring appear to favor the HPPD inhibition. At the same time, Me and OMe substituents contribute to decreasing the pK_i values. Accordingly, a few compounds were proposed and the candidate with 2,4,6-triBr substituents demonstrated an estimated pK_i similar to those of the best library compounds. This finding was corroborated by the docking scores of the ligand-enzyme interactions. In addition, the high calculated lipophilicity of some proposed agrochemicals suggests that they should have low soil mobility and, therefore, are not prone to easily leach out and reach groundwater, despite causing other ecological issues.

Novel Pyrazole Amides as Potential 4-Hydroxyphenylpyruvate Dioxygenase Inhibitors

4-Hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase (HPPD) is an important target for the development of new herbicides. HPPD inhibitors can hinder photosynthesis and induce weed death with bleaching symptoms. To explore the novel skeleton of HPPD inhibitors, a series of novel pyrazole amide derivatives were synthesized and evaluated for their inhibitory effects on Arabidopsis thaliana HPPD (AtHPPD) and herbicidal activities. Some compounds had excellent inhibitory activities against AtHPPD. Among them, compound B5 displayed top-rank inhibitory activity against AtHPPD with an IC₅₀ value of 0.04 μM, which was obviously superior to that of topramezone (IC₅₀ value of 0.11 μM). Furthermore, compounds B2 and B7 had 100% herbicidal activities in Petri dish assays against Portulaca oleracea and Amaranthus tricolor at 100 μg/mL. In particular, compound B7 not only possessed strong AtHPPD inhibitory activity but also exhibited significant preemergence herbicidal activity. However, compound B7 was completely harmless to soybean, cotton, and wheat. In addition, the molecular docking and microscale thermophoresis measurement experiment verified that compounds can bind well with AtHPPD via π-π interactions. The present work provides a new approach for the rational design of more effective HPPD inhibitors, and pyrazole amides could be used as useful substructures for the development of new HPPD inhibitors and preemergence herbicidal agents.

Survey on the Recent Advances in 4-Hydroxyphenylpyruvate Dioxygenase (HPPD) Inhibition by Diketone and Triketone Derivatives and Congeneric Compounds: Structural Analysis of HPPD/Inhibitor Complexes and Structure-Activity Relationship Considerations

The serendipitous discovery of the HPPD inhibitors from allelopathic plants opened the way for searching new and effective herbicidal agents by application of classical hit-to-lead optimization approaches. A plethora of active and selective compounds were discovered that belong to three major classes of cyclohexane-based triketones, pyrazole-based diketones, and diketonitriles. In addition, to enhance inhibitory constant and herbicidal activity, many efforts were also made to gain broader weed control, crop safety, and eventual agricultural applicability. Moreover, HPPD inhibitors emerged as therapeutic agents for inherited and metabolic human diseases as well as vector-selective insecticides in the control of hematophagous arthropods. Given the large set of experimental data available, structure-activity relationship analysis could be used to derive suggestions for next generation optimized compounds.

Synthesis, molecular docking and extensive structure activity relationship of substituted DHP derivatives: a new class of herbicides

In the present study, twenty-two derivatives of dihydropyridine (DHP) have been synthesized using the Boric acid catalyst in solventless conditions. The synthesis was confirmed by FTIR analysis, 1HNMR, and 13CNMR analysis. The quantitative structure-activity relationship for all the synthesized derivatives was performed using an artificial neural network with correlation coefficient (R²) 0.8611, mean standard error 0.19, and Comparative molecular field analysis (CoMFA) with correlation coefficient (R²) 0.713, mean standard error 0.27. The molecular docking activity of synthesized compounds was tested using "AUTODOCK VINA" against "Acetohydroxyacid synthase protein receptors (PDB code 1YHZ)" acquired from the "RCSB Protein Data Bank". Docking experiments demonstrated favorable interaction among synthesized DHP derivatives and protein receptors with significant binding energy values. These synthesized derivatives have been screened for their pre-emergence herbicidal bioassay against weed species Echinochola crus galli, and the IC50 value were calculated and activity was compared with Butachlor, significant activity was exhibited by all the derivatives. All the synthesized compounds were also screened for their post emergence herbicidal activity against Echinochola crus galli, and the activity of DHPs were compared with penoxulum. All the synthesized compounds show good to moderate activity. Thus, it is concluded that substituted DHP derivatives may be developed as potential herbicides.

Design, Synthesis, Structure-Activity Relationship, Molecular Docking, and Herbicidal Evaluation of 2-Cinnamoyl-3-Hydroxycyclohex-2-en-1-one Derivatives as Novel 4-Hydroxyphenylpyruvate Dioxygenase Inhibitors

Cinnamic acid, isolated from cinnamon bark, is a natural product with excellent bioactivity, and it effectively binds with cyclohexanedione to form novel 4-hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase (HPPD) inhibitors. According to the active sub-structure combination principle, a series of novel 3-hydroxy-2-cinnamoyl-2-en-1-one derivatives were designed and synthesized. The title compounds were characterized by infrared, ¹H NMR, ¹³C NMR, and HRMS. The in vitro inhibitory activity of AtHPPD verified that compound II-13 showed the most activity with a half-maximal inhibitory concentration (IC₅₀) value of 0.180 μM, which was superior to that of mesotrione (0.206 μM) in vitro. The preliminary herbicidal activity tests demonstrated that some compounds had good herbicidal activity especially compound II-13 at a concentration of 150 g ai/ha. The binding mode of AtHPPD through molecular docking indicated that two oxygens of compounds II-13 formed bidentate interactions with metal ions, and the benzene ring formed π-π accumulation effects with Phe-381 and Phe-424. The results of molecular dynamics simulations showed that compound II-13 exhibited a more stable binding ability with AtHPPD than mesotrione. This study provided insights into the development of natural and efficient herbicides in the future.

Discovery of novel benzofuran scaffold as 4-hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase inhibitors

BACKGROUND

4-Hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase (HPPD) plays an important role in addressing the issue of plant protection research. This study sheds new light on the differences in molecular scaffold from commercialized HPPD inhibitors.

RESULTS

The compounds A1-A18 and B1-B27 were synthesized for in vitro and greenhouse experiments. The greenhouse experiment data indicated that compounds B14 and B18 displayed excellent herbicidal activity, which was higher compared to that of mesotrione. In vitro testing indicated that the compounds were HPPD inhibitors. Moreover, molecular simulation results show that the compounds B14, B18, and mesotrione shared similar interplay with surrounding residues, which led to a perfect interaction with the active site of Arabidopsis thaliana HPPD. Based on crop selectivity results, compounds B14 and B18 were selected for maize studies (injury≤10%), indicating its potential for weed control in maize fields.

CONCLUSION

These results showed that the pyrazole-benzofuran structure could be used as possible lead compounds for the development of HPPD inhibitors. © 2020 Society of Chemical Industry.

Discovery of novel arylthioacetic acid derivatives as 4-hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase inhibitors

BACKGROUND

4-Hydroxyphenylpyruvate dioxygenase (HPPD) plays an important role in addressing the issue of plant protection research. In a continuing effort to discover novel HPPD inhibitors, we adopted a bioisosterism strategy to design a series of novel arylthioacetic acid scaffold based on the previously discovered aryloxyacetic acid scaffold. This study sheds new light on the discovery of novel HPPD inhibitors.

RESULTS

The compounds A1-A30 and B1-B39 were prepared through an efficient synthetic route for in vitro and glasshouse experiments (herbicidal activities, herbicidal activity spectrum, and crop selectivity). Preliminary bioassay results reveal that these derivatives are promising Arabidopsis thaliana HPPD inhibitors, compounds A11 (K_i = 0.021 μmol L^-1 ) and B20 (K_i = 0.022 μmol L^-1 ), which exhibit similar activities to that of mesotrione (K_i = 0.020 μmol L^-1 ). The glasshouse experiments data indicated that compounds B34 displayed excellent herbicidal activity, which was higher compared to that of mesotrione. Moreover, molecular simulation results show that the compounds B20, B34, and mesotrione shared similar interplay with surrounding residues, which led to a perfect interaction with the active site of Arabidopsis thaliana HPPD. Based on herbicidal results, compound B34 was selected for crop selectivity studies (corn injury ≤ 10%), indicating its potential for weed control in corn fields.

CONCLUSION

These bioassay results showed that the compound B34 could be used as a possible lead compound for the development of HPPD inhibitors. © 2020 Society of Chemical Industry.