The relationship between keratan sulfate glycosaminoglycan density and mechanical stiffening of CXL treatment

The corneal stroma is primarily composed of collagen fibrils, proteoglycans, and glycosaminoglycans (GAGs). It is known that corneal crosslinking (CXL) treatment improves mechanical properties of the cornea. However, the influence of stromal composition on the strengthening effect of CXL procedure has not been thoroughly investigated. The primary objective of the present research was to characterize the effect of keratan sulfate (KS) GAGs on the efficacy of CXL therapy. To this end, the CXL method was used to crosslink porcine corneal samples from which KS GAGs were enzymatically removed by keratanase II enzyme. Alcian blue staining was done to confirm the successful digestion of GAGs and uniaxial tensile experiments were performed for characterizing corneal mechanical properties. The influence of GAG removal and CXL treatment on resistance of corneal samples against enzymatic pepsin degradation was also quantified. It was found that removal of KS GAGs significantly softened corneal tensile properties (P < 0.05). Moreover, the CXL therapy significantly increased the tensile stiffness of GAG-depleted strips (P < 0.05). GAG-depleted corneal buttons were dissolved in the pepsin digestion solution significantly faster than control samples (P < 0.05). The CXL treatment significantly increased the time needed for complete pepsin digestion of GAG-depleted disks (P < 0.05). Based on these observations, we concluded that KS GAGs play a significant role in defining tensile properties and structural integrity of porcine cornea. Furthermore, the stiffening influence of the CXL treatment does not significantly depend on the density of corneal KS GAGs. The findings of the present study provided new information on the relation between corneal composition and CXL procedure mechanical effects.

The role of KS GAGs in the microstructure of CXL-treated corneal stroma; a transmission electron microscopy study

The mechanical and physical properties of the cornea originate from the microstructure and composition of its extracellular matrix. It is known that collagen fibrils, with a relatively uniform diameter, are organized in a pseudo-hexagonal array. It has been suggested that proteoglycans and the interaction of their glycosaminoglycan (GAG) side chains with themselves and collagen fibrils are important for collagen fibril organization inside the cornea. There are several diseases such as keratoconus in which the regular collagen fibrillar packing becomes distorted causing corneal optical and mechanical properties to be compromised. The primary purpose of the present work was to investigate the role of GAGs on the microstructure of corneal extracellular matrix before and after corneal crosslinking (CXL) treatment. For this purpose, keratan sulphates (KS) were removed from corneal samples using the keratanase enzyme and the CXL procedure was used to crosslink the specimens. The transmission electron microscopy was then used to characterize the diameter of collagen fibrils and their interfibrillar spacing. It was found that KS GAG depletion increased the collagen interfibrillar spacing while the CXL treatment significantly decreased the interfibrillar spacing. The enzyme and CXL treatments had an insignificant effect on the diameter of collagen fibrils. The underlying mechanisms responsible for these observations were discussed in terms of the assumption that GAG chains form duplexes that behave as tiny ropes holding collagen fibrils in place.

Effect of corneal collagen crosslinking on viscoelastic shear properties of the cornea

The cornea is responsible for most of the refractive power in the eye and acts as a protective layer for internal contents of the eye. The cornea requires mechanical strength for maintaining its precise shape and for withstanding external and internal forces. Corneal collagen crosslinking (CXL) is a treatment option to improve corneal mechanical properties. The primary objective of this study was to characterize CXL effects on viscoelastic shear properties of the porcine cornea as a function of compressive strain. For this purpose, corneal buttons were prepared and divided into three groups: control group (n = 5), pseudo-crosslinked group (n = 5), and crosslinked group (n = 5). A rheometer was used to perform dynamics torsional shear experiments on corneal disks at different levels of compressive strain (0%-40%). Specifically, strain sweep experiments and frequency sweep tests were done in order to determine the range of linear viscoelasticity and frequency dependent shear properties, respectively. It was found that the shear properties of all samples were dependent on the shear strain magnitude, loading frequency, and compressive strain. With increasing the applied shear strain, all samples showed a nonlinear viscoelastic response. Furthermore, the shear modulus of samples increased with increasing the frequency of the applied shear strain and/or increasing the compressive strain. Finally, the CXL treatment significantly increased the shear storage and loss moduli when the compressive strain was varied from 0% to 30% (p < 0.05); larger shear moduli were observed at compressive 40% strain but the difference was not significant (P = 0.12).

Mechanical behaviour of healthy versus alkali-lesioned corneas by a porcine organ culture model

BACKGROUND

Cornea is a composite tissue exhibiting nonlinear and time-dependent mechanical properties. Corneal ulcers are one of the main pathologies that affect this tissue, disrupting its structural integrity and leading to impaired functions. In this study, uniaxial tensile and stress-relaxation tests are developed to evaluate stress-strain and time-dependent mechanical behaviour of porcine corneas.

RESULTS

The samples are split in two groups: some corneas are analysed in an unaltered state (healthy samples), while others are injured with alkaline solution to create an experimental ulcer (lesioned samples). Furthermore, within each group, corneas are examined in two conditions: few hours after the enucleation (fresh samples) or after 7 days in a specific culture medium for the tissue (cultured samples). Finally, another condition is added: corneas from all the groups undergo or not a cross-linking treatment. In both stress-strain and stress-relaxation tests, a weakening of the tissue is observed due to the imposed conditions (lesion, culture and treatment), represented by a lower stiffness and increased stress-relaxation.

CONCLUSIONS

Alkali-induced corneal stromal melting determines changes in the mechanical response that can be related to a damage at microstructural level. The results of the present study represent the basis for the investigation of traditional and innovative corneal therapies.

Brillouin microscopic depth-dependent analysis of corneal crosslinking performed over or under the LASIK flap

PURPOSE

To determine the impact of corneal crosslinking (CXL) performed over the laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) flap using the Standard CXL (S-CXL) protocol or under the flap after flap lift (flap-CXL) on regional corneal stiffness using Brillouin microscopy.

SETTING

University of Southern California Keck School of Medicine, Los Angeles, California, and Cole Eye Institute, Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, Ohio, USA.

DESIGN

Laboratory ex vivo experiment.

METHODS

After epithelium debridement, LASIK flaps were created on intact fresh porcine eyes with a mechanical microkeratome. Then, S-CXL (riboflavin applied to the corneal surface followed by 3 mW/cm ultraviolet exposure with the flap in place for 30 minutes) or flap-CXL (riboflavin applied to the stromal bed after reflecting the flap followed by the same ultraviolet A exposure with the flap replaced) was performed. Depth profile of stiffness variation and averaged elastic modulus of anterior, middle, and posterior stroma were determined by analyzing Brillouin maps. Each eye served as its own control.

RESULTS

The study was performed on 24 fresh porcine eyes. S-CXL had maximal stiffening impact in the anterior most corneal stroma within the LASIK flap (8.40 ± 0.04 GHz), whereas flap-CXL had lower maximal stiffening impact (8.22 ± 0.03 GHz) (P < .001) that occurred 249 ± 34 μm under the corneal surface. S-CXL increased longitudinal modulus by 6.69% (anterior), 0.48% (middle), and -0.91% (posterior) as compared with flap-CXL, which increased longitudinal modulus by 3.43% (anterior, P < .001), 1.23% (middle, P < .1), and -0.78% (posterior, P = .68).

CONCLUSIONS

The S-CXL technique generated significantly greater stiffening effect in the anterior cornea than a modified protocol with riboflavin administration under the flap (flap-CXL). Minimal stiffening occurred in the middle or posterior cornea with either protocol.

The biology of corneal cross-linking derived from ultraviolet light and riboflavin

Over the past 20 years, corneal crosslinking (CXL) has been used by surgeons to halt progression in eyes with keratoconus. We reviewed the literature regarding the mechanism of action of CXL, the role of each of its components the strong biologic reaction, and their effects on cell interaction, proteins involved, wound healing, and cytotoxic reaction. CXL surgery involves a photochemical response in which ultraviolet light at a given wavelength and riboflavin participate. The combination of irradiation with UVA light and riboflavin leads to an intense process of apoptosis of keratocytes in the anterior stroma. Differences in light irradiation, as well as the importance of riboflavin and its vehicle, were also detailed. The surgery creates additional chemical bonds between the amino terminals of the collagen side chains and the proteoglycans of the extracellular matrix. A photosensitization reaction catalyzed by riboflavin classically involves the production of singlet oxygen. Microstructure studies show changes in the size of the fibril and potentially in the interfibrillar space, that the most significant changes related to the stiffening effect of CXL occur in the anterior third of the cornea and that short irradiation times, especially below 5 min, may not have the same biological effect. Changes in the riboflavin vehicle, with the incorporation of Hydroxypropyl methylcellulose as a carrier, can lead to faster diffusion and a more intense photochemical reaction. These are findings that can impact the optimal adjustment of irradiation time according to the riboflavin (and its carrier) used. Many studies have suggested that CXL is safe and effective in the standard and accelerated protocols that have been used by surgeons. After the initial depletion of anterior keratocytes, keratocyte density seems to return to average 6-12 months after surgery when corneas are examined with the confocal microscope.

Changes and quantitative characterization of hyper-viscoelastic biomechanical properties for young corneal stroma after standard corneal cross-linking treatment with different ultraviolet-A energies

Corneal collagen cross-linking (CXL) treatment can restore vision in patients suffering from keratoconus and corneal injury, by improving the mechanical properties of the cornea. The correlation between ultraviolet-A (UVA) irradiant energies of standard CXL (SCXL) and corneal visco-hyperelastic mechanical behavior remains unknown. In this study, SCXL with four different UVA irradiant energy doses (0-5.4 J/cm²) were administered as part of quantitative treatments of corneal stromal lenticules extracted from young myopic patients via small incision lenticule extraction (SMILE) corneal refractive surgery. Double-strip samples with symmetric geometries were cut simultaneously for SCXL treatment and non-treated control. First, 40 pairs of strips were loaded to failure to assess the mechanical parameters of the material. Then, another 40 pairs were tested using a special uniaxial tensile test including quasi-static loading-unloading, instantaneous loading, and stress relaxation, to determine the visco-hyperelastic mechanical behavior. Upon combining the collagen fibril crimping constitutive model with the quasi-linear viscoelastic model, it was observed that with increasing UVA energy dose, the corneal strength and hyperelastic stiffness were significantly enhanced, while the maximum stretch and viscosity of the cornea were significantly reduced. Considering the quantitative analysis of SCXL and the rehabilitation prediction of keratoconus treatment, the results clarify the biomechanical behavior of human corneal stroma in SCXL clinical surgery. STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE: This study quantitatively analyzes the improvement in the biomechanical properties of young central corneal stroma, due to SCXL treatment with different energies. Furthermore, the correlation between the hyper-viscoelastic mechanical parameters and UVA irradiant energy doses of SCXL are clarified. The contribution of this study fills the knowledge gap of the CXL on corneal biomechanics. It can not only clarify this mechanism better but also assist with guiding SCXL surgery for individualized patient corneas.

Depth-Dependent Reduction of Biomechanical Efficacy of Contact Lens-Assisted Corneal Cross-linking Analyzed by Brillouin Microscopy

PURPOSE

To determine the relative impact of contact lens- assisted corneal cross-linking (CACXL) and standard protocol CXL (CXL) on regional corneal stiffness using Brillouin microscopy.

METHODS

CXL and CACXL were performed on 30 intact fresh porcine eyes (15 per group). Depth profile of stiffness variation and averaged elastic modulus of anterior, middle, and posterior stroma were determined by Brillouin maps. Corneas were cut into strips to conduct mechanical stress-strain tests after Brillouin microscopy to evaluate stiffness difference between CXL and CACXL. Each eye served as its own control.

RESULTS

CXL had a greater impact on corneal stiffness, with a maximum increase of 5.74% compared to 3.99% for CACXL (P < .001). CXL increased longitudinal modulus by 7.8% in the anterior, 1.7% in the middle, and -0.7% in the posterior regions compared to CACXL, which increased longitudinal modulus by 5.5% in the anterior (P < .001), 1.2% in the middle (P = .15), and -0.4% in the posterior regions (P = .60). Mechanical stress-strain tests showed that at 10% strain averaged Young's modulus was 5 MPa for CXL and 2.97 MPa for CACXL (P < .001).

CONCLUSIONS

Both CACXL and standard protocol CXL induced significant corneal stiffening primarily concentrated in the anterior cornea. CACXL leads to less stiffening compared with CXL. An attenuated but continuous stiffening effect can be observed through the whole cornea for both CACXL and CXL, although CACXL has a smaller stiffness gradient. [J Refract Surg. 2019;35(11):721-728.].