Evaluation of Reproducibility of Brain Volumetry between Commercial Software, Inbrain and Established Research Purpose Method, FreeSurfer

Volume and Permeability of White Matter Hyperintensity on Cognition: A DCE Imaging Study of an Older Cohort With and Without Cognitive Impairment

BACKGROUND

The impact of blood-brain barrier (BBB) leakage on white matter hyperintensity (WMH) subtypes (location) and its association with clinical factors and cognition remains unclear.

PURPOSE

To investigate the relationship between WMH volume, permeability, clinical factors, and cognition in older individuals across the cognitive spectrum.

STUDY TYPE

Prospective, cross-sectional.

SUBJECTS

A total of 193 older adults with/without cognitive impairment; 128 females; mean age 70.1 years (standard deviation 6.8).

FIELD STRENGTH/SEQUENCE

3 T, GE Dynamic contrast-enhanced, three-dimensional (3D) Magnetization-prepared rapid gradient-echo (MPRAGE T1WI), 3D fluid-attenuated inversion recovery (FLAIR).

ASSESSMENT

Periventricular WMH (PWMH), deep WMH (DWMH), and normal-appearing white matter (NAWM) were segmented using FMRIB automatic segmentation tool algorithms on 3D FLAIR. Hippocampal volume and cortex volume were segmented on 3D T1WI. BBB permeability (Ktrans) and blood plasma volume (Vp) were determined using the Patlak model. Vascular risk factors and cognition were assessed.

STATISTICAL TESTS

Univariate and multivariate analyses were performed to identify factors associated with WMH permeability. Logistic regression analysis assessed the association between WMH imaging features and cognition, adjusting for age, sex, apolipoprotein E4 status, education, and brain volumes. A P-value <0.05 was considered significant.

RESULTS

PWMH exhibited higher Ktrans (0.598 ± 0.509 × 10-3 minute-1) compared to DWMH (0.496 ± 0.478 × 10-3 minute-1) and NAWM (0.476 ± 0.398 × 10-3 minute-1). Smaller PWMH volume and cardiovascular disease (CVD) history were significantly associated with higher Ktrans in PWMH. In DWMH, higher Ktrans were associated with CVD history and cortical volume. In NAWM, it was linked to CVD history and dyslipidemia. Larger PWMH volume (odds ratio [OR] 1.106, confidence interval [CI]: 1.021-1.197) and smaller hippocampal volume (OR 0.069; CI: 0.019-0.253) were independently linked to worse global cognition after covariate adjustment.

DATA CONCLUSION

Elevated BBB leakage in PWMH was associated with lower PWMH volume and prior CVD history. Notably, PWMH volume, rather than permeability, was correlated with cognitive decline, suggesting that BBB leakage in WMH may be a consequence of CVD rather than indicate disease progression.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

2 TECHNICAL EFFICACY: Stage 3.

Automated brain segmentation and volumetry in dementia diagnostics: a narrative review with emphasis on FreeSurfer

Background

Dementia can be caused by numerous different diseases that present variable clinical courses and reveal multiple patterns of brain atrophy, making its accurate early diagnosis by conventional examinative means challenging. Although highly accurate and powerful, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) currently plays only a supportive role in dementia diagnosis, largely due to the enormous volume and diversity of data it generates. AI-based software solutions/algorithms that can perform automated segmentation and volumetry analyses of MRI data are being increasingly used to address this issue. Numerous commercial and non-commercial software solutions for automated brain segmentation and volumetry exist, with FreeSurfer being the most frequently used.

Objectives

This Review is an account of the current situation regarding the application of automated brain segmentation and volumetry to dementia diagnosis.

Methods

We performed a PubMed search for “FreeSurfer AND Dementia” and obtained 493 results. Based on these search results, we conducted an in-depth source analysis to identify additional publications, software tools, and methods. Studies were analyzed for design, patient collective, and for statistical evaluation (mathematical methods, correlations).

Results

In the studies identified, the main diseases and cohorts represented were Alzheimer’s disease (n = 276), mild cognitive impairment (n = 157), frontotemporal dementia (n = 34), Parkinson’s disease (n = 29), dementia with Lewy bodies (n = 20), and healthy controls (n = 356). The findings and methods of a selection of the studies identified were summarized and discussed.

Conclusion

Our evaluation showed that, while a large number of studies and software solutions are available, many diseases are underrepresented in terms of their incidence. There is therefore plenty of scope for targeted research.

Comparison of Inter-Method Agreement and Reliability for Automatic Brain Volumetry Using Three Different Clinically Available Software Packages

Background and Objectives: No comparative study has evaluated the inter-method agreement and reliability between Heuron AD and other clinically available brain volumetric software packages. Hence, we aimed to investigate the inter-method agreement and reliability of three clinically available brain volumetric software packages: FreeSurfer (FS), NeuroQuant® (NQ), and Heuron AD (HAD). Materials and Methods: In this study, we retrospectively included 78 patients who underwent conventional three-dimensional (3D) T1-weighed imaging (T1WI) to evaluate their memory impairment, including 21 with normal objective cognitive function, 24 with mild cognitive impairment, and 33 with Alzheimer's disease (AD). All 3D T1WI scans were analyzed using three different volumetric software packages. Repeated-measures analysis of variance, intraclass correlation coefficient, effect size measurements, and Bland-Altman analysis were used to evaluate the inter-method agreement and reliability. Results: The measured volumes demonstrated substantial to almost perfect agreement for most brain regions bilaterally, except for the bilateral globi pallidi. However, the volumes measured using the three software packages showed significant mean differences for most brain regions, with consistent systematic biases and wide limits of agreement in the Bland-Altman analyses. The pallidum showed the largest effect size in the comparisons between NQ and FS (5.20-6.93) and between NQ and HAD (2.01-6.17), while the cortical gray matter showed the largest effect size in the comparisons between FS and HAD (0.79-1.91). These differences and variations between the software packages were also observed in the subset analyses of 45 patients without AD and 33 patients with AD. Conclusions: Despite their favorable reliability, the software-based brain volume measurements showed significant differences and systematic biases in most regions. Thus, these volumetric measurements should be interpreted based on the type of volumetric software used, particularly for smaller structures. Moreover, users should consider the replaceability-related limitations when using these packages in real-world practice.

Development and validation of a deep learning-based automatic segmentation model for assessing intracranial volume: comparison with NeuroQuant, FreeSurfer, and SynthSeg

Background and purpose

To develop and validate a deep learning-based automatic segmentation model for assessing intracranial volume (ICV) and to compare the accuracy determined by NeuroQuant (NQ), FreeSurfer (FS), and SynthSeg.

Materials and methods

This retrospective study included 60 subjects [30 Alzheimer's disease (AD), 21 mild cognitive impairment (MCI), 9 cognitively normal (CN)] from a single tertiary hospital for the training and validation group (50:10). The test group included 40 subjects (20 AD, 10 MCI, 10 CN) from the ADNI dataset. We propose a robust ICV segmentation model based on the foundational 2D UNet architecture trained with four types of input images (both single and multimodality using scaled or unscaled T1-weighted and T2-FLAIR MR images). To compare with our model, NQ, FS, and SynthSeg were also utilized in the test group. We evaluated the model performance by measuring the Dice similarity coefficient (DSC) and average volume difference.

Results

The single-modality model trained with scaled T1-weighted images showed excellent performance with a DSC of 0.989 ± 0.002 and an average volume difference of 0.46% ± 0.38%. Our multimodality model trained with both unscaled T1-weighted and T2-FLAIR images showed similar performance with a DSC of 0.988 ± 0.002 and an average volume difference of 0.47% ± 0.35%. The overall average volume difference with our model showed relatively higher accuracy than NQ (2.15% ± 1.72%), FS (3.69% ± 2.93%), and SynthSeg (1.88% ± 1.18%). Furthermore, our model outperformed the three others in each subgroup of patients with AD, MCI, and CN subjects.

Conclusion

Our deep learning-based automatic ICV segmentation model showed excellent performance for the automatic evaluation of ICV.

Comparison of Normative Percentiles of Brain Volume Obtained from NeuroQuant® vs. DeepBrain® in the Korean Population: Correlation with Cranial Shape

Purpose

This study aimed to compare the volume and normative percentiles of brain volumetry in the Korean population using quantitative brain volumetric MRI analysis tools NeuroQuant® (NQ) and DeepBrain® (DB), and to evaluate whether the differences in the normative percentiles of brain volumetry between the two tools is related to cranial shape.

Materials and Methods

In this retrospective study, we analyzed the brain volume reports obtained from NQ and DB in 163 participants without gross structural brain abnormalities. We measured three-dimensional diameters to evaluate the cranial shape on T1-weighted images. Statistical analyses were performed using intra-class correlation coefficients and linear correlations.

Results

The mean normative percentiles of the thalamus (90.8 vs. 63.3 percentile), putamen (90.0 vs. 60.0 percentile), and parietal lobe (80.1 vs. 74.1 percentile) were larger in the NQ group than in the DB group, whereas that of the occipital lobe (18.4 vs. 68.5 percentile) was smaller in the NQ group than in the DB group. We found a significant correlation between the mean normative percentiles obtained from the NQ and cranial shape: the mean normative percentile of the occipital lobe increased with the anteroposterior diameter and decreased with the craniocaudal diameter.

Conclusion

The mean normative percentiles obtained from NQ and DB differed significantly for many brain regions, and these differences may be related to cranial shape.

Choroid Plexus Volume and Permeability at Brain MRI within the Alzheimer Disease Clinical Spectrum

Background Mounting evidence suggests that the choroid plexus (CP) plays an important role in the pathophysiology of Alzheimer disease (AD), but its imaging profile in cognitive impairment remains unclear. Purpose To evaluate CP volume, permeability, and susceptibility by using MRI in patients at various stages of cognitive impairment. Materials and Methods This retrospective study evaluated patients with cognitive symptoms who underwent 3.0-T MRI of the brain, including dynamic contrast-enhanced (DCE) imaging and quantitative susceptibility mapping (QSM), between January 2013 and May 2020. CP volume was automatically segmented using three-dimensional T1-weighted sequences; the volume transfer constant (ie, K^trans) and fractional plasma volume (ie, V_p) were determined using DCE MRI, and susceptibility was assessed using QSM. The effects of CP volume, expressed as the ratio to intracranial volume, on cognition were evaluated using multivariable linear regression adjusted for age, sex, education, apolipoprotein E ε4 allele status, and volumetric measures. Results A total of 532 patients with cognitive symptoms (mean age, 72 years ± 9 [SD]; 388 women) were included: 78 with subjective cognitive impairment (SCI), 158 with early mild cognitive impairment (MCI), 149 with late MCI, and 147 with AD. Among these, 132 patients underwent DCE MRI and QSM. CP volume was greater in patients at more severe stages (ratio of intracranial volume × 10³: 0.9 ± 0.3 for SCI, 1.0 ± 0.3 for early MCI, 1.1 ± 0.3 for late MCI, and 1.3 ± 0.4 for AD; P < .001). Lower K^trans (r = -0.19; P = .03) and V_p (r = -0.20; P = .02) were negatively associated with CP volume; susceptibility was not (r = 0.15; P = .10). CP volume was negatively associated with memory (B = -0.67; standard error of the mean [SEM], 0.21; P = .01), executive function (B = -0.90; SEM, 0.31; P = .01), and global cognition (B = -0.82; SEM, 0.32; P = .01). Conclusion Among patients with cognitive symptoms, larger choroid plexus volume was associated with severity of cognitive impairment in the Alzheimer disease spectrum. Published under a CC BY 4.0 license. Online supplemental material is available for this article. See also the editorial by Chiang in this issue.

[Brain MRI-Based Artificial Intelligence Software in Patients with Neurodegenerative Diseases: Current Status]

The incidence of neurodegenerative diseases in the older population has increased in recent years. A considerable number of studies have been performed to characterize these diseases. Imaging analysis is an important biomarker for the diagnosis of neurodegenerative disease. Objective and reliable assessment and precise detection are important for the early diagnosis of neurodegenerative diseases. Artificial intelligence (AI) using brain MRI applied to the study of neurodegenerative diseases could promote early diagnosis and optimal decisions for treatment plans. MRI-based AI software have been developed and studied worldwide. Representatively, there are MRI-based volumetry and segmentation software. In this review, we present the development process of brain volumetry analysis software in neurodegenerative diseases, currently used and developed AI software for neurodegenerative disease in the Republic of Korea, probable uses of AI in the future, and AI software limitations.

Expert Opinions and Recommendations for the Clinical Use of Quantitative Analysis Software for MRI-Based Brain Volumetry

치매를 비롯한 퇴행성 신경 질환의 초기 진단에 자기공명영상을 이용한 뇌 위축 평가와 정량적 용적 분석이 중요하다. 뇌 위축의 시각적 평가는 주관적으로 평가자에 따라 다른 결과를 보여주기 때문에, 객관적인 결과를 제공하면서 임상 적용도 가능한 소프트웨어의 수요와 개발이 늘어나고 있다. 이러한 임상용 소프트웨어의 실제 임상 적용은 영상 검사의 표준화가 선행되어야 하고, 개발된 소프트웨어의 검증이 반드시 필요하다. 따라서 대한신경두경부영상의학회는 뇌용적 분석 임상용 소프트웨어의 임상적 활용에 대한 의견을 제시하기 위해 전문위원회를 구성하고 현재까지 발표된 연구를 정리하였다. 그리고, 정량화 분석을 위한 영상 검사의 표준화 및 소프트웨어의 임상 적용에 대한 전문가 의견을 제시하기 위하여 공동 작업을 수행하였다. 본 종설에서는 뇌 자기공명영상의 정량화 분석의 필요성 및 배경, 정량화 분석을 위한 임상용 소프트웨어의 소개 및 기존의 표준품(reference standard)과의 진단능 비교, 영상 획득의 표준화, 분석 및 평가의 표준화, 소프트웨어의 임상 적용에 대한 전문가 의견, 제한점 및 대처 방법 등 대한신경두경부영상의학회의 전문가 권고안을 소개하는 것이 목적이다.