Comprehensive assessment of determinant specificity, frequency, and cytokine signature of the primed CD8 cell repertoire induced by a minor transplantation antigen

Comprehensive Evaluation of the Expressed CD8+ T Cell Epitope Space Using High-Throughput Epitope Mapping

T cell immunity is traditionally assessed through functional recall assays, which detect the consequences of the T cells' antigen encounter, or via fluorescently labeled multimers that selectively bind peptide-specific T cell receptors. Using either approach, if the wrong antigen or peptide of a complex antigenic system, such as a virus, is used for immune monitoring, either false negative data will be obtained, or the magnitude of the antigen-specific T cell compartment will go largely underestimated. In this work, we show how selection of the “right” antigen or antigenic peptides is critical for successful T cell immune monitoring against human cytomegalovirus (HCMV). Specifically, we demonstrate that individual HCMV antigens, along with previously reported epitopes, frequently failed to detect CD8+ T cell immunity in test subjects. Through systematic assessment of T cell reactivity against individual nonamer peptides derived from the HCMVpp65 protein, our data clearly establish that (i) systematic testing against all potential epitopes encoded by the genome of the antigen of interest is required to reliably detect CD8+ T cell immunity, and (ii) genome-wide, large scale systematic testing of peptides has become feasible through high-throughput ELISPOT-based “brute force” epitope mapping.

How frequently are predicted peptides actually recognized by CD8 cells?

Detection of antigen-specific CD8 cells frequently relies on the use of peptides that are predicted to bind to HLA Class I molecules or have been shown to induce immune responses. There is extensive knowledge on individual HLA alleles’ peptide-binding requirements, and immunogenic peptides for many antigens have been defined. The 32 individual peptides that comprise the CEF peptide pool represent such well-defined peptide determinants for Cytomegalo-, Epstein–barr-, and Influenza virus. We tested the accuracy of these peptide recognition predictions on 42 healthy human donors that have been high-resolution HLA-typed. According to the predictions, 241 recall responses should have been detected in these donors. Actual testing showed that 36 (15 %) of the predicted CD8 cell responses occurred in the high frequency range, 41 (17 %) in mid-frequencies, and 45 (19 %) were at the detection limit. In 119 instances (49 %), the predicted peptides were not targeted by CD8 cells detectably. The individual CEF peptides were recognized in an unpredicted fashion in 57 test cases. Moreover, the frequency of CD8 cells responding to a single peptide did not reflect on the number of CD8 cells targeting other determinants on the same antigen. Thus, reliance on one or a few predicted peptides provides a rather inaccurate assessment of antigen-specific CD8 cell immunity, strongly arguing for the use of peptide pools for immune monitoring.

Multiparameter Flow Cytometric Assays to Quantify Effector and Regulatory T-Cell Function in Multiple Sclerosis

The immune system plays a major pathological and regulatory role in multiple sclerosis (MS) and, therefore, is a focus of extensive research. Animal models of MS have been crucial in understanding the pathological processes in MS and developing certain treatments, however, all crucial aspects of the human disease may not be appropriately modeled. With the exception of detecting oligoclonal bands and IgG synthesis in cerebrospinal fluids of MS patients, there has not been major progress in the development of immunologic tests that can be used for diagnosis of MS. Further, due to the lack of validated immune assays, routine monitoring of the immune system following therapy initiation is not a part of standard patient care in MS. This is critical since immunomodulatory therapies used for MS treatment are not benign and, more importantly, there is a considerable variation in clinical responses in MS patients initiating such therapies. Flow cytometry is a powerful tool that can be used for studying both the phenotype and function of immune cells. The studies described here will demonstrate how flow cytometry can be used to apply current knowledge about the MS immune system to develop a diagnostic laboratory test for the immunologic monitoring of this disease. Importantly, we will also show that the multiparameter flow cytometry based assay developed by us can also be implemented for the immunologic evaluation of therapeutic success in MS patients.

Effects of preexisting autoimmunity on heart graft prolongation after donor-specific transfusion and anti-CD154

BACKGROUND

Alloreactive memory T cells prevent costimulatory blockade-induced heart graft survival in mice, but whether and how preexisting autoreactive T cells affect solid-organ transplants under these conditions is unknown.

METHODS

We tested the impact of preexisting cardiac myosin (CM)-specific immunity on murine heart transplant recipients treated with donor-specific transfusion (DST) plus anti-CD154 monoclonal antibody MR1.

RESULTS

Preimmunization with CM but not control ovalbumin abrogated the graft prolonging effects of DST/MR1, whether administered 2 weeks or more than 6 weeks before transplantation. Adoptive transfer of spleen cells from CM-immunized mice into naïve recipients had similar effects. CM-specific immunity did not cross-react with donor antigens and preimmunization with CM had no impact on the survival or histology of DST/MR1-treated syngeneic heart grafts, the latter indicating that persistent autoimmunity is insufficient to cause rejection in the context of costimulatory blockade. We observed that the CM preimmunized mice produced higher frequencies of donor-reactive T cells with higher ratios of CD8/CD4Foxp3 cells, suggesting that the autoreactive memory T cells provide help for activation of alloreactive T cells despite the costimulatory blockade.

CONCLUSIONS

These mechanistic insights linking autoimmunity and alloimmunity in a model of murine heart transplantation have clinical relevance to the known association between autoimmunity and an elevated risk of acute and chronic heart transplant injury in humans.

Quality of the transgene-specific CD8+ T cell response induced by adenoviral vector immunization is critically influenced by virus dose and route of vaccination

Adenoviral vectors have been widely used for experimental gene therapy and vaccination, yet there is a surprising lack of knowledge connecting the route and dose of adenovirus administration to the induced transgene-specific immune response. We have recently demonstrated polyfunctional CD8(+) T cells and protective memory responses using adenoviral vectors, which seem to contrast with recent reports suggesting that an exhausted CD8(+) T cell phenotype is induced by inoculation with adenoviral vectors. Accordingly, we investigated the route and dose interrelationship for transgene-specific CD8(+) T cells using adenoviral vectors encoding beta-galactosidase applied either s.c. or i.v. Irrespective of the route of inoculation, most of the adenoviral inoculum was found to disseminate systemically as the dose was raised beyond 10(9) particles. The number of transgene-specific CD8(+) T cells correlated positively with dissemination, whereas the functional capacity of the generated T cells correlated inversely with vector dissemination. A comparison of the immune response to s.c. or i.v. administration at moderate doses revealed that inoculation by both routes induced a transient peak of IFN-gamma-producing CD8(+) T cells 2 to 3 wk postinfection, but following i.v. administration, these cells were only detected in the liver. Two to four months after systemic, but not peripheral, immunization, dysfunctional transgene-specific CD8(+) T cells impaired in both cytokine production and important in vivo effector functions, accumulated in the spleen. These findings indicate that the localization of the adenoviral inoculum and not the total Ag load determines the quality of the CD8(+) T cell response induced with adenoviral vaccines.

Captopril, an Angiotensin-Converting Enzyme Inhibitor, Promotes Growth of Immunogenic Tumors in Mice

PURPOSE

Antitumor potential of angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibitors has been shown in different preclinical settings, which always involved immunocompromised organisms or nonimmunogenic tumor models. In our study, we wanted to evaluate the effect of captopril on growth of immunogenic tumors in immunocompetent animals.

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN

We used different murine tumor models to evaluate the effect of captopril on tumor take and survival of tumor-bearing immunocompetent and immunocompromised mice. We used an orthotopic renal cell cancer model and highly immunogenic tumor model, which were based on kidney subcapsular injection of RenCa cells or s.c. injection of MethA cells, respectively. To show the influence of captopril on antigen-specific immune responses, we have used two model antigens (green fluorescent protein and beta-galactosidase).

RESULTS

Captopril decreased survival of RenCa-bearing, immunocompetent mice in a dose-dependent manner and in adjuvant setting. In nephrectomized mice, captopril shortened their survival. Captopril promoted formation of immunogenic MethA sarcoma tumors but had no effect on nonimmunogenic melanoma cells (B78-H1). Treatment of immunocompromised mice bearing MethA tumors or RenCa kidney tumors with captopril did not affect tumor formation nor survival, respectively. Captopril-treated mice immunized with AdLacZ or AdGFP vectors did not generate or generated decreased numbers of antigen-specific CD8+ T cells, respectively. However, they showed B-cell responses represented by infiltration of MethA tumors with activated B cells and dramatically increased serum level of beta-galactosidase-specific antibodies.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results show a novel role of captopril in tumor biology and the tumor-promoting properties of captopril seem to be associated with its immunomodulatory potential.

CD8 T Cells Specific for a Donor-Derived, Self-Restricted Transplant Antigen Are Nonpathogenic Bystanders after Vascularized Heart Transplantation in Mice

CD8 T cell cross-priming, an established mechanism of protective antiviral immunity, was originally discovered during studies involving minor transplantation Ags. It is unclear whether or how cross-primed CD8 T cells, reactive to donor-derived, but recipient class I MHC-restricted epitopes, could injure a fully MHC-disparate, vascularized transplant. To address this question we studied host class I MHC-restricted, male transplantation Ag-reactive T cell responses in female recipients of fully MHC-disparate, male heart transplants. Cross-priming to the immune-dominant determinant HYUtyp occurred at low frequency after heart transplantation. CD8 T cell preactivation through immunization with HYUtyp mixed in CFA did not alter the kinetics of acute rejection. Furthermore, neither HYUtyp immunization nor adoptive transfer of HYUtyp-specific TCR-transgenic T cells affected outcome in 1) a model of chronic rejection in the absence of immunosuppression or 2) a model of allograft acceptance induced by costimulatory blockade. The results support the contention that CD8 T cells reactive to host-restricted, but donor-derived, Ags are highly specific and are nonpathogenic bystanders during rejection of MHC-disparate cardiac allografts.

Memory T cells in transplantation: generation, function, and potential role in rejection

The adaptive immune system is endowed with long-lived memory to recall previous antigen encounters and respond more effectively to them. Memory immune responses are mediated by antigen-specific memory T lymphocytes that exhibit enhanced function compared with naïve T cells that have never encountered antigen. While the generation of memory T cells specific for pathogens is beneficial in providing protective immunity, memory T cells specific for alloantigens can be deleterious to the recipient of a transplanted organ. In graft rejection, memory T cells mediate accelerated, "second-set" rejection and their presence has been associated with increased propensity for early rejection. Recent findings have demonstrated that alloreactive memory T cells can be generated via exposure to alloantigens, as well as stimuli that are cross-reactive with alloantigens, and are therefore likely present in "naïve" individuals. This review focuses on the characteristics of memory T cells which make them of special interest to the transplant community, including differential activation requirements, broad homing properties, and resistance to tolerance induction. The multiple ways in which memory T cells can contribute to early and late graft rejection are discussed, as well as potential targets for combating alloreactive memory to be considered in the future design of tolerance induction strategies.

Effects of T cell frequency and graft size on transplant outcome in mice

The features that determine whether graft-reactive T lymphocytes develop into effector cells capable of mediating organ destruction are not well understood. To investigate potential factors involved in this process, we first confirmed that female recipient mice acutely rejected minor Ag-disparate male skin, but not heart transplants. Despite this difference in outcome, heart and skin transplantation induced antidonor T cell responses of similar magnitude, specificity, and cytokine profile. The heart-graft-primed T cells transiently infiltrated the graft and ultimately induced the development of chronic transplant vasculopathy. Increasing the frequency of donor-reactive T cells by presensitization or by using TCR (CD8+ antimale)-transgenic recipients did not mediate acute rejection but accelerated the pace and severity of the vasculopathy. Surprisingly, decreasing the tissue mass of the donor heart by 50% resulted in acute rejection of these smaller grafts without increasing the frequency of antidonor effector T cells in the recipients. In complementary studies, placement of one or two male skin grafts on a single recipient did not affect the frequency or cytokine profile of the induced antimale T cell repertoire. Nonetheless, the recipients of single grafts acutely rejected the transplanted skin while the recipients of two skin grafts did not. These results provide new insight into the pathogenesis of transplant vasculopathy and provide an explanation for the difference in outcome between murine skin and heart transplants by highlighting the novel concept that the efficiency of transplant-reactive T cell immunity is heavily influenced by the tissue burden it encounters at the effector stage.

CD4+ and CD8+ cells in cryopreserved human PBMC maintain full functionality in cytokine ELISPOT assays

The frequency and the cytokine signature of antigen-specific T cells in the blood reflect the magnitude and the quality of T cell immunity in vivo. Recently, cytokine enzyme-linked immunospot (ELISPOT) assays performed on freshly isolated peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC) emerged as a promising tool for monitoring these key parameters, providing direct feedback information on the efficacy of vaccinations and immune therapies. However, performing ELISPOT assays with freshly isolated cells is not readily feasible in the context of clinical trials. The ability to obtain valid ELISPOT data on cryopreserved samples would greatly enhance ex vivo immune monitoring capabilities. We have therefore systematically studied antigen-specific T cell responses in freshly isolated PBMC and after cryopreservation. Four healthy donors were selected that displayed T cell responses to six recall antigens. The antigen reactive T cells were defined as CD4 or CD8 cells, and their cytokine effector class was established measuring interferon (IFN)-gamma, interleukin (IL)-2, IL-4 and IL-5. The donors were bled at three different time points, and their PBMC were tested fresh and after freeze-thawing. The results showed that the frequencies and type 1/type 2 cytokine signatures of recall antigen-specific CD4 and CD8 cells are unaffected after cryopreservation. In contrast to these data obtained on human PBMC, cryopreservation of murine spleen cells causes a decrease in cytokine secretion.

T cells primed by Leishmania major infection cross-react with alloantigens and alter the course of allograft rejection

Alloreactive T lymphocytes can be primed through direct presentation of donor MHC:peptide complexes on graft cells and through indirect presentation of donor-derived determinants expressed by recipient APCs. The large numbers of determinants on an allograft and the high frequency of the alloreactive repertoire has further led to speculation that exposure to environmental Ags may prime T cells that cross-react with alloantigens. We sought to develop a model in which to test this hypothesis. We found that CD4(+) T cells obtained from C57BL/6 (B6) mice that clinically resolved Leishmania major infection exhibited statistically significant cross-reactivity toward P/J (H-2(p)) Ags compared with the response to other haplotypes. B6 animals that were previously infected with L. major specifically rejected P/J skin grafts with second set kinetics compared with naive animals. Although donor-specific transfusion combined with costimulatory blockade (anti-CD40 ligand Ab) induced prolonged graft survival in naive animals, the same treatment was ineffective in mice previously infected with L. major. The studies demonstrate that cross-reactive priming of alloreactive T cells can occur and provide direct evidence that such T cells can have a significant impact on the outcome of an allograft. The results have important implications for human transplant recipients whose immune repertoires may contain cross-reactively primed allospecific T cells.

Evolution of the enzyme-linked immunosorbent spot assay for post-transplant alloreactivity as a potentially useful immune monitoring tool

Post-transplant monitoring of cellular immunity has the potential to guide alterations in medical therapy. To this end, our laboratory has developed an enzyme-linked immunosorbent spot (ELISPOT) assay for detection of peripheral blood alloimmunity. Peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBLs) from normal volunteers and from renal allograft recipients were tested against donor stimulator cells for their ability to respond in 'one-way' cytokine ELISPOT assays. T cell depletion of donor spleen or PBLs eliminated donor cell cytokine secretion while preserving the ability of these cells to present allo-antigen to responding T cells. Alloreactive IFN-gamma-producing PBLs derive from the memory T cell pool and are readily detectable in recipients of renal allografts taking immunosuppressant medications. A significant expansion of IFN-gamma-producing donor-reactive memory PBLs was detectable at 4-6 months post-transplant in those who had experienced an acute rejection episode compared with those with a stable post-transplant course. The data demonstrate the feasibility of repeated post-transplant monitoring of allograft recipients, and provide the foundation for improving the care of human transplant recipients through rational clinical decision-making based on measures of immune function.

Cross-primed CD8(+) T cells mediate graft rejection via a distinct effector pathway

To prevent bystander destruction of healthy host tissues, cytotoxic CD8(+) T lymphocytes are fitted with specific receptors that direct their destructive forces specifically against chosen targets. We show here, however, that anti-H-Y monospecific, H-2(b-restricted MataHari CD8(+) T cells reject H-2(k) male skin grafts, with which they cannot directly interact. Such rejection is interferon-gamma-dependent and only occurs if the recipient endothelium expresses H-2(b). The findings suggest an alternate indirect effector pathway that requires processing and presentation of the donor H-Y antigen by recipient endothelium and have implications for both transplantation and autoimmune disease.

Primed allospecific T cells prevent the effects of costimulatory blockade on prolonged cardiac allograft survival in mice

Costimulatory blockade can induce long-term allograft survival in naive animals, but may not be as effective in animals with previously primed immune repertoires. We attempted to induce long-term graft survival in B10.D2 recipients of B10.A cardiac allografts using donor-specific transfusion (DST) plus anti-CD40 ligand antibody (alphaCD40L). Recipients were either naive mice, or mice previously primed to B10.A or third party alloantigens through engraftment and rejection of skin transplants. Untreated naïve mice rejected cardiac transplants by day 15 and contained a high frequency of primed, donor-reactive T cells. Donor-specific transfusion/alphaCD4OL treatment of naïve animals induced long-term graft survival associated with low frequencies of donor-reactive T cells. Previous priming of donor-specific T cells through rejection of B10.A, but not third party, skin grafts prevented the effects of DST/alphaCD40L on prolonging survival of B10.A hearts. Moreover, adoptive transfer of CD3+, CD4+ or CD8+ T cells from B10.A skin-graft-primed animals prevented the effects of DST/alphaCD40L. The data demonstrate that animals with immune repertoires containing previously primed, donor-reactive T cells are resistant to the effects of costimulatory blockade. The findings have important implications for ongoing, costimulatory blockade-based trials in humans, whose T-cell repertoires are known to contain memory alloreactive T cells.

Differentiation of human alloreactive CD8(+) T cells in vitro

Expansion and differentiation of alloantigen-reactive CD8(+) T cells in mixed lymphocyte cultures was followed by measurement of the loss of carboxyfluorescein diacetate succinimidyl ester (CFSE) fluorescence of responder cells. Proliferation of CD8(+) T cells became detectable on day 4 of culture and, 2 days later, > 60% of the CD8(+) T cells in culture were dividing alloreactive lymphocytes. In parallel with expansion, CD8(+) T-cell differentiation was initiated, as evidenced by an increase in the number of CD45RA(-) and CD27(-) T cells and acquisition of the ability to produce interferon-gamma after restimulation with the specific alloantigen. Finally, although short-term stimulation and measurement of intracellular cytokine production allowed visualization of alloreactive CD8(+) T cells expanded in vitro, this procedure did not detect circulating alloreactive CD8(+) T cells activated in vivo in recipients of allogeneic kidney grafts.

In vivo blockade of macrophage migration inhibitory factor prevents skin graft destruction after indirect allorecognition

BACKGROUND

The effector mechanisms that ultimately destroy transplanted tissues are poorly understood. In particular, it is not clear how CD4+ T cells primed to donor-derived determinants expressed on recipient MHC molecules (the indirect pathway) can mediate graft destruction in the absence of cognate recognition of peptide: MHC on the graft cells themselves. Macrophage migration inhibitory factor (MIF) inhibits macrophage movement and is a proinflammatory and regulatory cytokine known to be essential for development of delayed-type hypersensitivity reactions.

METHODS

To test whether MIF participates in graft destruction following indirect recognition, we studied rejection of MHC-II-deficient skin grafts placed on allogeneic SCID recipients adoptively transferred with naïve CD4+ T cells, and the recipients were treated with neutralizing anti-MIF monoclonal antibody or isotype control IgG. In this model graft rejection can only occur indirectly as the graft cells lack MHC II for recognition by the recipient CD4+ T cells.

RESULTS

We found that in vivo blockade of MIF inhibited indirect CD4+ cell-mediated skin graft destruction, and markedly reduced detectable macrophages within the grafts. The neutralizing anti-MIF antibody significantly inhibited alloreactive DTH but did not prevent T cell priming or interferon-gamma release by primed T cells.

CONCLUSIONS

The results strongly implicate MIF as an active participant in skin graft destruction after indirect recognition and suggest that this effect is mediated through an inhibition of macrophage migration and/or function.

Failure of memory (CD44 high) CD4 T cells to recognize their target antigen in retina

Activated T cells recognize Ag in the retina, an immune privileged tissue, and may mediate autoimmune disease. In contrast, this report asks if resting, Ag-specific CD4(+) CD44(+) T cells can recognize Ag expressed in the retina. As a probe for Ag, 3E9 T cells specific for an immunodominant epitope of beta-galactosidase (beta-gal) were transferred to transgenic (Tg) mice expressing beta-gal in retinal photoreceptor cells, or to ROSA26 mice which express beta-gal widely. The survival, phenotype, and responsiveness of transferred 3E9 T cells were unaffected by the presence of retinal beta-gal, but altered by recognition of beta-gal in the ROSA26 mice. Inoculation or induction of activated T cells with specificity for this epitope produced autoimmune uveoretinitis, showing that the retinal beta-gal is expressed at immunologically significant levels. We conclude that sequestration provides a substantial barrier to recognition of Ag in quiet retina, and that insufficient Ag leaves the retina for detectable immune recognition outside of the retina.

A role for TGFbeta and B cells in immunologic tolerance after intravenous injection of soluble antigen

BACKGROUND

Intravenous injection of soluble antigen has been reported to induce immunologic tolerance through a variety of mechanisms including T-cell deletion, anergy, and suppression. To clarify the reported discrepancies, we studied mechanisms of intravenous tolerance to a defined transgenic minor transplantation antigen in mice.

METHODS

Wild-type C57BL/6 (B6) mice or congenic B6 B-cell knockout mice were made tolerant to beta-galactosidase (beta-gal). Clinical tolerance was assessed by placement of B6 beta-gal transgenic (tg) and third-party skin grafts. In vitro analysis of T- and B-cell immunity and in vivo treatment with anti-TGFbeta antibodies were used to define mechanisms of induced tolerance.

RESULTS

Intravenous injection of beta-gal induced true immunologic tolerance to beta-gal tg skin in wild-type but not in B-cell-deficient recipients, suggesting that antigen presentation by B cells was required for the effect. The tolerogenic manipulation primed a population of CD4+, beta-gal-specific, TGFbeta-producing T cells. Although evidence for both anergy and suppression were observed, subsequent data demonstrated that TGFbeta was a critical immunoregulatory mediator of the tolerant state: neutralizing anti-TGFbeta antibodies fully prevented the induction of tolerance to B6 beta-gal tg skin grafts. Second male beta-gal tg grafts placed onto female recipients that were previously made tolerant to female beta-gal tg skin were rapidly rejected, however, suggesting that this TGFbeta-induced tolerance could not be linked to additional antigenic determinants.

CONCLUSIONS

The studies demonstrate a critical role for TGFbeta in mediating tolerance after intravenous injection of antigen but additionally raise concerns about the stability of this tolerant state.

Granzyme B ELISPOT assay for ex vivo measurements of T cell immunity

A major goal in immunodiagnostics has been the development of assay systems that can measure CD8(+) T cell immunity in humans, directly ex vivo, at high resolution, and with high throughput. We established granzyme B (grB) enzyme-linked immunospot assay (ELISPOT) in conjunction with image analysis to this end. Using grB transfected and untransfected Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells and T cell lines, we show that the antibody pair utilized was grB-specific and that only activated T cells secrete grB. GrB release began within 4 h after antigen stimulation and stopped within 40 h. Side-by-side comparison showed grB ELISPOT assays to have a higher resolution than classic chromium-release assays in terms of signal-to-noise ratio. The linearity of the relation of the number of CD8(+) effector T cells plated to grB spots detected suggests that grB ELISPOT assays measure the frequencies of grB-secreting cells directly. Reactivity to HIV peptides was seen in grB ELISPOT assays of freshly isolated PBMC from HIV patients, consistent with the detection of peptide-specific memory cells. The higher resolution and lower labor and material investment should make grB ELISPOT assays an attractive alternative to chromium-release assays in monitoring the clonal sizes of specific CD8 memory cells in vivo.