A novel susceptibility locus on chromosome 2 in the (New Zealand Black x New Zealand White)F1 hybrid mouse model of systemic lupus erythematosus

Immune Relevant and Immune Deficient Mice: Options and Opportunities in Translational Research

In 1989 ILAR published a list and description of immunodeficient rodents used in research. Since then, advances in understanding of molecular mechanisms; recognition of genetic, epigenetic microbial, and other influences on immunity; and capabilities in manipulating genomes and microbiomes have increased options and opportunities for selecting mice and designing studies to answer important mechanistic and therapeutic questions. Despite numerous scientific breakthroughs that have benefitted from research in mice, there is debate about the relevance and predictive or translational value of research in mice. Reproducibility of results obtained from mice and other research models also is a well-publicized concern. This review summarizes resources to inform the selection and use of immune relevant mouse strains and stocks, aiming to improve the utility, validity, and reproducibility of research in mice. Immune sufficient genetic variations, immune relevant spontaneous mutations, immunodeficient and autoimmune phenotypes, and selected induced conditions are emphasized.

Anti-TNF-alpha therapies in systemic lupus erythematosus

Tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-α is not just a proinflammatory cytokine. It has also been proposed to be an immunoregulatory molecule that can alter the balance of T regulatory cells. Anti-TNF-α therapies have been provided clinical benefit to many patients and introduced for treating moderate to severe rheumatoid arthritis, Crohn's disease, and other chronic inflammatory disorders. However, their use also is accompanied by new or aggravated forms of autoimmunity, such as formation of autoantibodies, including antinuclear antibodies (ANAs), antidouble-stranded DNA (dsDNA) antibodies, and anticardiolipin antibodies (ACL). Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is a disease with autoimmune disturbance and inflammatory damage. The role of TNF-α in human SLE is controversial. Here we review the role of TNF-α in the pathophysiological processes of SLE and the likely effects of blocking TNF-α in treatment of SLE.

A novel CD93 polymorphism in non-obese diabetic (NOD) and NZB/W F1 mice is linked to a CD4+ iNKT cell deficient state

In the present study, we characterize a polymorphism in the CD93 molecule, originally identified as the receptor for the C1q complement component (i.e., C1qRp, or AA4.1) in non-obese diabetic (NOD) mice. This allele carries a coding polymorphism in the first epidermal growth factor-like domain of CD93, which results in an amino acid substitution from Asn→His at position 264. This polymorphism does not appear to influence protein translation or ecto-domain cleavage, as CD93 is detectable in bone-marrow-derived macrophage and B-cell precursor lysates and in soluble form in the serum. The NOD CD93 isoform causes a phenotypic aberrancy in the early B-cell developmental stages (i.e., pro-, pre-, immature, and transitional), likely related to a conformational variation. Interestingly, the NZB/W F1 strain, which serves as a murine model of Lupus, also expresses an identical CD93 sequence polymorphism. Cd93 is located within the NOD Idd13 locus and is also tightly linked to the NZB/W F1 Wbw1 and Nkt2 disease susceptibility loci, which are thought to regulate natural killer T (NKT) cell homeostasis. Consistent with this genetic linkage, we found B6 CD93^−/− and B6.NOD^Idd13 mice to be susceptible to a profound CD4⁺ NKT cell deficient state. These data suggest that Cd93 may be an autoimmune susceptibility gene residing within the Idd13 locus, which plays a role in regulating absolute numbers of CD4⁺ NKT cells.

Integrating human and rodent data to identify the genetic factors involved in chronic kidney disease

The increasing numbers of patients with chronic kidney disease combined with no satisfying interventions for preventing or curing the disease emphasize the need to better understand the genes involved in the initiation and progression of complex renal diseases, their interactions with other host genes, and the environment. Linkage and association studies in human, rat, and mouse have been successful in identifying genetic loci for various disease-related phenotypes but have thus far not been very successful identifying underlying genes. The purpose of this review is to summarize the progress in human, rat, and mouse genetic studies to show the concordance between the loci among the different species. The collective utilization of human and nonhuman mammalian datasets and resources can lead to a more rapid narrowing of disease loci and the subsequent identification of candidate genes. In addition, genes identified through these methods can be further characterized and investigated for interactions using animal models, which is not possible in humans.

Genetic analysis of albuminuria in aging mice and concordance with loci for human diabetic nephropathy found in a genome-wide association scan

Aging in the kidney can cause albuminuria, and discovering molecular mechanisms responsible for this might offer a new perspective on the etiology of this abnormality. Haplotype association mapping in the mouse is a novel approach which uses the haplotypes of the relatively closely related mouse inbred strains and the phenotypic variation among these strains to find associations between haplotypes and phenotype. The albumin-to-creatinine ratios, a measure of urinary albumin excretion, were determined in 30 inbred mouse strains at 12, 18, and 24 months of age. Mapping was performed for males and females separately at all three time points using a high density set of 63,222 single-nucleotide polymorphisms to determine genetic loci involved in albuminuria. One significant and eight suggestive loci were found, some of which map to previously identified loci for traits associated with kidney damage in the mouse, but with a much higher resolution thus narrowing their chromosomal location. These nine loci were then compared with genome-wide association scans for diabetic nephropathy (DN) in human type I diabetes. Our study found that two of the nine mouse loci for age-related albuminuria were significantly associated with DN and consistent across male and female strata. This suggests common underlying genes predispose to kidney disease in mice and humans.

Role of distinct immune components in the radiation-induced abrogation of systemic lupus erythematosus development in mice

The New Zealand Black x New Zealand White F1 [(NZB/NZW) F1] mouse develops an autoimmune condition resembling aspects of human systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE). We investigated the effects of a novel prophylactic thoraco-abdominal gamma irradiation protocol on the onset and evolution of lupus in these animals. Survival of irradiated mice was higher when compared with nonirradiated mice. Kidney lesions were milder and autoantibody levels were lower in irradiated mice. To identify possible mechanisms involved in the radiation-induced improvement of disease, distinct components of humoral and cellular immune responses were evaluated. Because B-1 cells are known to be involved in various autoimmune diseases, we investigated the participation of these cells in SLE progression. Unexpectedly, B-1 cells were not depleted in (NZB/NZW) F1, even after several rounds of irradiation. No alterations were found in viability and physiology of B-1 cells in SLE animals with the exception of constitutive overexpression of the anti-apoptotic molecule Bcl-2, which may account for the observed radioresistance. Thus, a role for B-1 cells in murine SLE cannot be excluded, since the irradiation protocol did not effectively eliminate these cells. Additionally, we demonstrate a marked delay in the ability of splenocytes to repopulate the spleen after irradiation in (NZB/NZW) F1, in contrast to leucocytes in other cellular compartments. The implications of these findings for the fate of SLE in this model are discussed.

Genetic basis of murine lupus nephritis

Systemic lupus erythematosus is a generalized autoimmune disease affecting multiple end-organs including the kidneys. Glomerulonephritis is a leading cause of death in lupus, both in patients and murine models that develop disease spontaneously. Genetic mapping studies have uncovered several genetic intervals that confer susceptibility to nephritis both in human beings and in mice. This review surveys the genomic positions of these nephritis susceptibility loci in murine lupus. Currently we know very little about the molecular identities of the culprit genes within these mapped loci and whether these genetic elements contribute to nephritis directly in a renal-intrinsic fashion or indirectly by augmenting the formation of pathogenic autoantibodies. The next decade is likely to witness a significant broadening of our understanding of how different genes and molecules might facilitate end-organ damage in lupus.

Genetic susceptibility to type 2 diabetic nephropathy in human and animal models

Diabetic nephropathy is the most common cause of end-stage renal disease (ESRD) in Japan, Western Europe, and the United States. Mega studies such as Diabetes Control and Complication Trial (DCCT), Epidemiology of Diabetes Interventions and Complications (EDIC), and the United Kingdom Prospective Diabetes Study (UKPDS) clarified that poor glycemic and blood pressure control are undoubtedly involved in the development of nephropathy. However, these factors are not sufficient to predict which diabetic patients will develop renal disease, because not all patients with poor glycemic and blood pressure control develop renal disease. Since ethnic variations and familial clustering of diabetic nephropathy have been observed, genetic factors might contribute to susceptibility to this disease. Several methods such as (genome wide) association studies, sib-pair analysis, and quantitative trait loci (QTLs) analysis are available to examine polygenic diseases. However, no mutations that could explain the majority of nephropathy cases have been identified so far. The development of most diabetic nephropathy might be explained by the polygenic effect (i.e. many minor gene-gene interactions might be very important in the development of nephropathy). Identification of candidate genes of nephropathy enables targeting of therapy in patients at risk and development of novel therapeutic agents.

Mouse protein arrays from a TH1 cell cDNA library for antibody screening and serum profiling

The mouse is the premier genetic model organism for the study of disease and development. We describe the establishment of a mouse T helper cell type 1 (T(H)1) protein expression library that provides direct access to thousands of recombinant mouse proteins, in particular those associated with immune responses. The advantage of a system based on the combination of large cDNA expression libraries with microarray technology is the direct connection of the DNA sequence information from a particular clone to its recombinant, expressed protein. We have generated a mouse T(H)1 expression cDNA library and used protein arrays of this library to characterize the specificity and cross-reactivity of antibodies. Additionally, we have profiled the autoantibody repertoire in serum of a mouse model for systemic lupus erythematosus on these protein arrays and validated the putative autoantigens on highly sensitive protein microarrays.

Genetics of lupus nephritis

Susceptibility to lupus nephritis is the end-result of complex interactions between polymorphic genetic factors involved in the regulation of immune responses. In humans, genome-wide screens and candidate-gene analyses led to the identification of several loci containing potential targets (FcgammaRIIa, PTPN22, PD-1, IL-10) for physiopathological research and therapeutic interventions. In mice, the generation of congenic mice, bearing in a normal genetic background one single disease-associated locus, greatly improved our understanding of the mechanisms mediating the genetic contribution to the disease. In the future, the identification of disease-associated genes will open new perspectives for the development of more targeted therapies of lupus nephritis.

Genetic segregation of spontaneous erosive arthritis and generalized autoimmune disease in the BXD2 recombinant inbred strain of mice

The BXD2 strain of mice is one of approximately 80 BXD recombinant inbred (RI) mouse strains derived from an intercross between C57BL/6J (B6) and DBA/2J (D2) strains. We have discovered that adult BXD2 mice spontaneously develop generalized autoimmune disease, including glomerulonephritis (GN), increased serum titres of rheumatoid factor (RF) and anti-DNA antibody, and a spontaneous erosive arthritis characterized by mononuclear cell infiltration, synovial hyperplasia, and bone and cartilage erosion. The features of lupus and arthritis developed by the BXD2 mice segregate in F2 mice generated by crossing BXD2 mice with the parental B6 and D2 strains. Genetic linkage analysis of the serum levels of anti-DNA and RF by using the BXD RI strains shows that the serum titers of anti-DNA and RF were influenced by a genetic locus on mouse chromosome (Chr) 2 near the marker D2Mit412 (78 cm, 163 Mb) and on Chr 4 near D4Mit146 (53.6 cm, 109 Mb), respectively. Both loci are close to the B-cell hyperactivity, lupus or GN susceptibility loci that have been identified previously. The results of our study suggest that the BXD2 strain of mice is a novel model for complex autoimmune disease that will be useful in identifying the mechanisms critical for the immunopathogenesis and genetic segregation of lupus and erosive arthritis.

New insights into disease pathogenesis from mouse lupus genetics

Full manifestation of mouse lupus, similar to the human disease in its severe form, is characterized by elevated antinuclear autoantibody levels and the development of kidney disease. Considerable evidence supports a genetic basis for lupus. The functional dissection of susceptibility loci in multigenic mouse models of lupus has provided insight into the immune abnormalities associated with autoantibody production and other processes critical for inflammation and damage in the kidney. The elucidation of models with single-gene manipulations has also identified immune mechanisms in the pathway to lupus. Recent advances have challenged previously accepted truths and new layers of complexity have become apparent.

Genetic basis of murine lupus

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is an autoimmune disorder characterized by the formation of a variety of autoantibodies and subsequent development of severe glomerulonephritis. Etiology of SLE remains unknown even if it is now well established that SLE is under polygenic control as well as the contribution of hormonal and environmental factors. The availability of several murine strains that spontaneously develop an autoimmune syndrome resembling human SLE, such as New Zealand, MRL and BXSB mice has provided useful tools for the genetic dissection of susceptibility to SLE. Moreover, development of various transgenic and mutant mice has made it possible to identify a number of susceptibility genes such as those involved in the regulation of apoptosis or B cell receptor signaling that can trigger lupus-like phenotypes. Obviously, further identification of the genetic defects present in lupus-prone mice is of paramount importance for understanding the immunopathogenesis of SLE.

Modifier genes and protective alleles in humans and mice

Interest in modifier genes is growing rapidly because of their ability to modulate the phenotype of individuals with monogenic and multigenic traits and diseases. A neglected class of modifiers is protective alleles that can suppress disease in otherwise susceptible individuals. Together these modifier genes and protective alleles provide important glimpses into the molecular and cellular basis for the functional networks that provide robustness and homeostasis in complex biological systems.

Role of TNF/TNFR in autoimmunity: specific TNF receptor blockade may be advantageous to anti-TNF treatments

Deregulated TNF production, be it low or high, characterizes many autoimmune diseases. Recent evidence supports a dualistic, pro-inflammatory and immune- or disease-suppressive role for TNF in these conditions. Blocking TNF in autoimmune-prone chronic inflammatory diseases may, therefore, lead to unpredictable outcomes, depending on timing and duration of treatment. Indeed, blockade of TNF in human rheumatoid arthritis or inflammatory bowel disease patients, although so far impressively beneficial for the majority of patients, it has also led to a significant incidence of drug induced anti-dsDNA production or even in manifestations of lupus and neuro-inflammatory disease. Notably, anti-TNF treatment of multiple sclerosis patients has led almost exclusively to immune activation and disease exacerbation. We discuss here recent evidence in murine disease models, indicating an heterogeneity of TNF receptor usage in autoimmune suppression versus inflammatory tissue damage, and put forward a rationale for a predictably beneficial effect of 'anti-TNFR' instead of 'anti-TNF' treatment in human chronic inflammatory and autoimmune conditions.

Susceptibility genes in the pathogenesis of murine lupus

Systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) is the paradigm of a multisystem autoimmune disease in which genetic factors strongly influence susceptibility. Through genome scans and congenic dissection, numerous loci associated with lupus susceptibility have been defined and the complexity of the inheritance of this disease has been revealed. In this review, we provide a brief description of animal models of SLE, both spontaneous models and synthetic models, with an emphasis on the B6 congenic model derived from analyses of the NZM2410 strain. A hypothetical model of disease progression that organizes many of the identified SLE susceptibility loci in three distinct biological pathways that interact to mediate disease pathogenesis is also described. We finally discuss our recent fine mapping analysis, which revealed a cluster of loci that actually comprise the Sle1 locus.