Tuberculosis of hip in children: A retrospective analysis

Total hip arthroplasty in active and advanced tubercular arthritis: a systematic review of the current evidence

STUDY DESIGN

Systematic review.

INTRODUCTION

Total hip arthroplasty (THA) is a well-acknowledged surgical intervention to restore a painless and mobile joint in patients with osteoarticular tubercular arthritis of the hip joint. However, there is still substantial uncertainty about the ideal management, clinical and functional outcomes following THA undertaken in patients with acute Mycobacterium tuberculosis (TB) hip infections.

AIM OF THE STUDY

To undertake a systematic review and evaluate existing literature on patients undergoing THA for acute mycobacterium tuberculosis arthritis of the hip.

METHODS

A systematic review of electronic databases of PubMed, EMBASE, Scopus, Web of Science and Cochrane Library was performed on the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines. The search focused on "arthroplasty in cases with tuberculosis of hip joint" since inception of databases until July 2023. Data on patient demographics, clinical characteristics, treatment administered, surgical interventions and outcome, as reported in the included studies, were recorded. Median (range) and mean (standard deviation) were used to summarise the data for continuous variables (as reported in the original studies); and frequency/percentage was employed for categorical variables. Available data on Harris hip scores and complications were statistically pooled using random-effects meta-analysis or fixed-effect meta-analysis, as appropriate RESULTS: Among a total of 1695 articles, 15 papers were selected for qualitative summarisation and 12 reporting relevant data were included for proportional meta-analysis. A total of 303 patients (mean age: 34 to 52 years; mean follow-up: 2.5 to 10.5 years) were included in our systematic review. In a majority of included studies, postero-lateral approach and non-cemented prosthesis were employed. Fourteen studies described a single-staged procedure in the absence of sinus, abscess and tubercular infection syndrome (TIS). All surgeries were performed under cover of prolonged course of multi-drug anti-tubercular regimen. The mean Harris hip score (HHS) at final follow-up was 91.36 [95% confidence interval (CI): 89.56-93.16; I2:90.44%; p<0.001]. There were 30 complications amongst 174 (9.9%) patients (95% CI: 0.06-0.13; p=0.14; I2=0%).

CONCLUSION

THA is a safe and effective surgical intervention in patients with active and advanced TB arthritis of hip. It is recommended that the surgery be performed under cover of multi-drug anti-tubercular regimen. In patients with active sinus tracts, abscesses and TIS, surgery may be accomplished in a multi-staged manner. The clinical (range of motion, deformity correction, walking ability and pain scores), radiological (evidence of radiological reactivation and implant incorporation) and function outcome (as assessed by HHS) significantly improve after THA in these patients.

Treatment of Stage I-III Hip Joint Tuberculosis With Open Surgical Debridement and Hip Spica in Children: A Retrospective Study

BACKGROUND

This study aimed to evaluate the outcome of surgical debridement combined with postoperative hip spica immobilization in the treatment of hip joint tuberculosis in children.

METHODS

This retrospective study enrolled 87 children with stage I to III hip joint tuberculosis treated surgically at our hospital from January 2010 to January 2016. All patients considering hip tuberculosis routinely received a 4-week conservative treatment first, including rest, protected weight-bearing, and 4-drugs antitubercular chemotherapy. Surgical debridement was indicated when there was no relief after this conservative protocol. Patients were divided into 2 groups according to the duration of hip spica immobilization after operation: group A (hip spica for 4 wk, 39 patients) and group B (hip spica for 6 wk, 48 patients). All patients were recommended partial weight-bearing for 7 days and then followed the same hip joint exercises program when spica was removed. Postoperative radiographs, hip dislocation or subluxation, and modified Harris hip score (MHHS) were assessed. All patients were followed up at least 5 years.

RESULTS

There were 87 patients enrolled in our study, including 34 females and 53 males, with a mean age of 7.2±2.8 years old (range: 2 to 14 y). No significant difference was observed between these 2 groups in baseline data. In group A, the mean MHHS improved from 52.1±14.7 before surgery to 87.8±8.3 at the final follow-up ( P <0.000). In group B, there was also a significant difference between the preoperative MHHS (52.7±9.4) and the final MHHS (88.6±6.5) ( P <0.000). Although there was no significant difference between these 2 groups in the final MHHS ( P =0.593), there were also no significant differences between these 2 groups in wound healing delay (3 in group A and 6 in group B, P =0.705) and pathologic subluxation (3 in group A and 1 in group B, P =0.467). The only difference between group A (79.2±8.5) and group B (75.5±7.5) was the early functional outcome assessed by using MHHS after 1 month of hip joint exercises ( P =0.032).

CONCLUSIONS

Surgical debridement combined with antitubercular chemotherapy is an effective treatment for stage I to III hip tuberculosis in children when there is no improvement after conservative treatment. Prolonged hip spica immobilization may not reduce the risk of hip subluxation after open surgical debridement but could lead to a delay in early functional recovery. Time of spica immobilization should be individualized and based on the surgeon's evaluation and the patient's condition.

Septic sequelae of hip in children: long-term clinicoradiological outcome study

The presented retrospective study is a report of 18 patients (23 hips) with infantile post sepsis hip sequelae. There were two groups of patients. The observation group comprised of 6 patients (8 hips). The intervention group included 12 patients (15 hips) of which 12 hips had been surgically intervened for the sequelae and 3 contralateral hips which were again serially observed. The sequelae hips were classified by Choi's radiological types. The clinical evaluation was done by modified Moon's criteria. The average patient age at follow-up was 9.3 years. There were 3 type I (13%), 10 type II (43%), 2 type III (8%), and 8 Choi type IV (35%) at presentation. The Choi radiological type showed propensity to change over time/following intervention. At follow-up, there 3 type I (13%), 17 type II (74%), and 3 type IV (13%) hips. At follow-up, there were seven excellent, seven good, and four fair results. The observation group had mostly type I or II and intervention group IIIB or IV Choi types. Findings common to both groups: same Choi radiological type fared different clinically, multiple joint involvement contributed to deterioration of function and late changes in acetabulum or proximal femur lead to deterioration of clinical function. The sequelae of septic hips likely to be kept under supervised observation were Choi type I or II. In select types, intervention changed the natural history of septic sequelae significantly.

Management of post septic sequelae of hips with dislocation in children

BACKGROUND

Limited literature guide management of post septic sequelae of hips with dislocation in children. We studied the functional and radiological outcome of open reduction of such sequelae in 11 children. Special emphasis was given to determine the influence of surgical correction and relocation of these hips.

METHODS

Preoperative acetabular index (AI) on both sides was compared to quantify acetabular dysplasia. Radiological parameters like AI, centre edge angle (CEA), Reimer's index, centre head distance discrepancy (CHDD) and neck shaft angle (NSA) were calculated and compared with the unintervened side at follow-up. Outcome was assessed radiologically by modified Severin classification and clinically by Moon's criterion.

RESULTS

Average age at open reduction was 20.6 months and further follow-up was 48.8 months. The mean pre-operative AI on intervened side (35 degrees) differed significantly from unintervened side (22.5 degrees). The follow-up AI on intervened side (26.5 degrees) improved significantly from the pre-operative values but residual dysplasia persisted. Mean values for other radiological parameters on intervened side at follow-up were CEA 16.1 degrees, Reimer's index 31.5%, CHDD 18.6% and NSA 119 degrees. Mean shortening of 2.3 cm was documented in ten patients at final follow-up. Triradiate cartilage fused in four out of 11 hips at follow-up. Radiological outcome according to modified Severin classification was good to fair in seven patients (types II and III) whereas poor in four patients (types IV and V). Functional outcome as per Moon's criterion was excellent to good in nine patients, fair and poor in one patient each.

CONCLUSIONS

Open reduction potentially alters the natural history of post septic sequelae of hips with dislocation and contributes to better hip mechanics and function.

Bacille Calmette-Guérin Vaccine-Induced Tuberculous Hip Osteomyelitis in an Infant: Case report

To this day, tuberculosis (TB) continues to pose a significant global health burden. The World Health Organization's Expanded Programme on Immunization (EPI) recommends the bacille Calmette-Guérin (BCG) vaccine for infants to protect against the haematogenous spread of primary TB and other more severe types of TB infection. We report an eight-month-old boy who presented to the Armed Forces Hospital, Muscat, Oman, in 2015 with a one-month history of intermittent fever associated with a limited range of motion in the right hip area. He was up-to-date with his EPI vaccinations and had no history of exposure to individuals with TB infections. He was initially treated for bacterial septic arthritis; however, a GeneXpert TB assay revealed the presence of Mycobacterium tuberculosis, BCG strain. To the best of the authors' knowledge, this is the first documented case from Oman of a child with TB hip osteomyelitis due to a BCG vaccination.

Coexistence of a Ghon Complex, Pott's Disease, and Hip Arthritis in a Child

Introduction

Tuberculosis remains a major public health problem in developing countries. Diagnosing extrapulmonary tuberculosis can be difficult, as it requires a higher index of suspicion than primary tuberculosis. Extrapulmonary tuberculosis may mimic malignancies and many other diseases, so it should be included in the differential diagnosis. Here, we present a case of extrapulmonary tuberculosis associated with Pott’s disease and hip arthritis in a patient who recovered after 12 months of antituberculosis therapy.

Case Presentation

A 16-year-old girl presented to the outpatient otolaryngology clinic with painless swelling of the neck, and to the physical medicine and rehabilitation clinic with complaints of hip and low back pain that mimicked spondyloarthropathy. She was eventually referred to the outpatient pediatric clinic. Her acute-phase reactants were high, and hilar lymphadenopathy was evident on chest x-ray. On computerized tomography, a Pott’s abscess involving the T8, T9, and T10 vertebrae was suspected. Magnetic resonance imaging of the dorsal vertebrae and hip was performed, and a Pott’s abscess and hip tuberculous arthritis were confirmed. The patient had been exposed to tuberculosis 10 years earlier, and her purified protein derivative (PPD) test was 16 mm. After antituberculosis treatment, our patient recovered and the Pott’s disease and hip tuberculous arthritis regressed.

Conclusions

Extrapulmonary tuberculosis may mimic many other diseases, so it should be kept in mind in the differential diagnosis. It is essential to diagnose osteoarticular tuberculosis early, as late diagnosis or inadequate treatment may cause permanent disability.

Functional improvement after hip arthroscopy in cases of active paediatric hip joint tuberculosis: a retrospective comparative study vis-à-vis conservative management

PURPOSE

Tuberculosis of the hip joint is a significant cause of preventable disability, especially in children. The aim of our study was to evaluate the functional results of hip arthroscopy done in a cohort of patients with hip joint tuberculosis and to compare them with the outcome of conservatively managed cases.

METHODS

This was a retrospective cohort study in which we evaluated the records of 22 hip arthroscopies performed in known cases of tuberculosis of the hip joint in children less than 12 years of age. A note of the demographic and clinical parameters like age, duration of symptoms, stage of the disease, time period of follow-up, any complications during surgery, and pre- and post-operative modified Harris hip score (MHHS) was made in all cases. We compared the results with an age-matched cohort of 44 children with hip joint tuberculosis who were treated non-operatively with anti-tuberculosis therapy and traction in the same tertiary care institute.

RESULTS

The arthroscopic findings in our series included synovitis, chondral erosions of the femoral head and/or acetabulum, pannus formation over the femoral head and/or acetabulum, and labral tears. The various arthroscopic procedures which were done included joint lavage, synovectomy, labral debridement and cheilectomy. The mean follow-up was 45 months, with the minimum being 36 months. There was a statistically significant change in the mean MHHS after hip arthroscopic procedures (p < 0.001); the difference in the mean post- and pre-operative MHHS was independent of age, stage or duration of follow-up. There was a statistically significant difference (p < 0.05) between the magnitude of improvement in MHHS after hip arthroscopy and that after conservative management.

CONCLUSIONS

Arthroscopy of the hip joint in children in cases of tuberculosis can serve as an emerging therapeutic modality. It is an effective and safe minimally invasive procedure, and helps in improving the functional outcome in early disease.

Tuberculosis of hip: A current concept review

Tuberculosis (TB) of the hip is second to spine only hence a good number of cases are visiting the medical facilities every year. Many present in the advanced stage of the disease due to delayed diagnosis. In early stages of TB of hip, there is a diagnostic dilemma when plain X-rays are negative. In the present time, diagnostic modalities have improved from the days when diagnosis was based essentially on clinicoradiological presentation alone. By the time definite radiological changes appear on plain X-ray, the disease has moderately advanced. The modern diagnostic facilities like ultrasonography (USG) or magnetic resonance imaging of the hip joint, USG guided aspiration of synovial fluid and obtaining the material for polymerase chain reaction and tissue diagnosis must be utilized. In the treatment, current emphasis is more on mobility with stability at hip. Joint debridement, skeletal traction, and mobilization exercises may give more satisfying results as compared to the immobilization by hip spica. Adults with advanced arthritis and healed infection should be informed and discussed the various treatment modalities including the joint replacement. More and more surgeons are taking up the challenge of putting the total hip replacement in the active stage of the disease. Until the long term results in active disease are well established, we recommend it for the healed disease only in selected cases.

Tuberculosis of the trochanteric bursa: a case report

Tuberculous trochanteric bursitis is rare. We report on a 48-year-old man with a huge gravitational abscess in the thigh secondary to tuberculosis of the trochanteric bursa.

Tuberculosis of the hip in children: A retrospective analysis of 27 patients

BACKGROUND

We retrospectively evaluated the pretreatment radiological presentation and the clinicoradiological outcome at the completion of 1 year chemotherapy in osteoarticular tuberculosis of hip in children to prognosticate correlation between them.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We retrospectively analyzed the clinical and plain radiographic findings in 27 patients with an age of 12 years or younger in whom hip tuberculosis was diagnosed and treated between 2006 and 2010. The diagnosis was based on histopathology in 14 and clinicoradiological basis in 13 patients. The pre and post treatment plain radiographs were evaluated according to Shanmugasundaram radiological classification and our observations regarding unclassified cases which were not fit in this classification were suggested. The functional outcome at the completion of chemotherapy was assessed using modified Moon's criteria.

RESULTS

The male female ratio was 11:16. The left hip was involved more frequently than the right (17:10). The average age was 7.37 years (range, 2-12 years). In the pretreatment radiographs, 9 hips were normal, 6 traveling, 4 dislocating, 1 protrusio acetabuli, 3 atrophic and 4 unclassified types (3 triradiate; 1 pseudarthrosis coxae). There were no Perthes and mortar pestle at the initial presentation. Posttreatment, the types changed to 9 normal, 3 Perthes, 1 protrusio acetabuli, 1 atrophic, 4 mortar pestle and 9 unclassified types (3 triradiate, 3 pseudarthrosis coxae and 3 ankylosed). There were 37% excellent, 18.5% good, 26% fair and 18.5% poor results. The prognosis was best with initial "triradiate" and normal types and worst with posttreatment atrophic and "ankylosed" types.

CONCLUSIONS

The Shanmugasundaram radiological types accurately predict prognosis only in normal types and "triradiate" pattern. The functional outcome is independent of radiological morphology of the hip in smaller children.