Skin dose estimation for various beam modifiers and source-to-surface distances for 6MV photons

A Study to Analyze Impact of Treatment Couch and Immobilization Devices on Surface Dose for Megavoltage Photon Beams

PURPOSE/OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study is to investigate the effect of treatment couch and immobilization devices on surface dose for megavoltage photon beams.

MATERIAL/METHODS

Percentage surface dose (PSD) measurement was carried out in Elekta Synergy™ Linear accelerator using PTW Markus® Parallel plate ionization chamber of volume 0.05cm3 with water equivalent RW3 Slab phantom (PTW, Germany). The measurement depth was considered at 0.07mm. The reference PSD was measured at 0° gantry angle with 10×10cm2, 20×20cm2 and 30×30cm2 field sizes and 100cm SSD for 4MV, 6MV and 15MV photon beams. For comparison, PSD measurement was carried out at 180° gantry angle inclusion of treatment couch (TC), All in One positioning system (AIO - PS) and Vac lok Cushions (VLC).

RESULTS

Beam angle at 0°, for field sizes 10×10cm2, 20×20cm2 and 30×30cm2, the PSD was observed as 30.9%, 40.5%, 48.7% for 4MV; 23.7%, 33.8%, 42.2% for 6MV; and 17.0%, 29.6%, 38.6% for 15MV respectively. Beam angle at 180° with TC, an increase in PSD by maximum of 65.0% for 4MV, 64.9% for 6MV and 55.9% for 15MV as compared to 0° angle. The PSD increased when beam angle was 180° with TC and AIO - PS were 65.0% for 4MV, 67.4% for 6MV, and 60.9% for 15MV than 0° angle. Similarly, increased PSD for beam angle at 180° with TC and VLC were 66.8% for 4MV, 66.8% for 6MV and 61.3% for 15MV as compared to 0° angle.

CONCLUSION

For all three-photon energies, at 180° gantry angle, the PSD increased significantly in case of TC, VLC, and AIO - PS for all the field sizes as compared to gantry angle at 0°. It is necessary to consider TC, AIO - PS and VLC during dose calculation to ensure accuracy of patient treatment delivery.

Assessment of Surface and Build-up Doses for a 6 MV Photon Beam using Parallel Plate Chamber, EBT3 Gafchromic Films, and PRIMO Monte Carlo Simulation Code

Background:

Accurate assessment of surface and build-up doses has a key role in radiotherapy, especially for the superficial lesions with uncertainties involved while performing measurements in the build-up region.

Objective:

This study aimed to assess surface and build-up doses for 6 MV photon beam from linear accelerator using parallel plate ionization chamber, EBT3 Gafchromic films, and PRIMO Monte Carlo (MC) simulation code.

Material and Methods:

In this experimental study, parallel plate chamber (PPC05) and EBT3 Gafchromic films were used to measure doses in a build-up region for 6 MV beam from the linear accelerator for different field sizes at various depths ranging from 0 to 2 cm from the surface with 100 cm source to surface distance (SSD) in a solid water phantom. Measured results were compared with Monte Carlo simulated results using PENELOPE-based PRIMO simulation code for the same setup conditions. Effect of gantry angle incidence and SSD were also analyzed for depth doses at the surface and build-up regions using PPC05 ion chamber and EBT3 Gafchromic films.

Results:

Doses measured at the surface were 14.78%, 19.87%, 25.83%, and 31.54% for field sizes of 5×5, 10×10, 15×15, and 20×20 cm², respectively for a 6 MV photon beam with a parallel plate chamber and 14.20%, 19.14%, 25.149%, and 30.90%, respectively for EBT3 Gafchromic films. Both measurement sets were in good agreement with corresponding simulated results from the PRIMO MC simulation code; doses increase with the increase in field sizes.

Conclusion:

Good agreement was observed between the measured depth doses using parallel plate ionization chamber, EBT3 Gafchromic films, and the simulated depth doses using PRIMO Monte Carlo simulation code.

Out-of-field dose assessment for a 1.5 T MR-Linac with optically stimulated luminescence dosimeters

PURPOSE

To assess the out-of-field surface and internal dose of the 1.5 T MR-Linac compared to the conventional external beam linac using optically stimulated luminescence dosimeters (OSLDs), and evaluate the out-of-field dose calculation accuracy of the Monaco treatment planning system (TPS) of the 1.5T MR-Linac.

METHODS

A cubic solid water phantom, with OSLDs on the surface, was vertically irradiated by MR-Linac square fields with different sizes. In addition, OSLDs were arranged out of the beam edges in four directions. An anthropomorphic adult phantom, with 125 cm³ simulated volume, was irradiated in four orthogonal directions by both MR-Linac and conventional linac at the head, thoracic, and pelvic sites. Out-of-field doses were measured by OSLDs on both the surface and internal emulational organs at risk (OARs). The results were compared to the simulated dose from Monaco TPS.

RESULTS

At different field sizes (5 × 5 to 20 × 20 cm² ) and distances (1 to 10 cm) to beam edge, the out-of-field surface dose measured on MR-Linac varied from 0.16 % (10 cm to 5 × 5 cm² edge) to 7.02 % (1 cm to 20 × 20 cm² edge) of the maximum dose laterally and from 0.14 % (10 cm to 5 × 5 cm² edge) to 8.56 % (1 cm to 20 × 20 cm² edge) of the maximum dose longitudinally. Compared to the OSLDs measured data, the Monaco TPS presented an overestimate of the out-of-field dose of OARs at 0-2 % isodose area on both surface and internal check points, and the overestimation gets greater as the distance increases. The underestimation was found to be 0-35% at 2-5% isodose area on both surface and internal check points. Compared to the conventional linac, MR-Linac delivered higher average values of out-of-field dose on surface check points (20%, 19%, 21%) and internal simulated OARs (42%, 37%, 9%) of the anthropomorphic phantom at head, thoracic, and pelvic irradiations, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Compared to the conventional linac, MR-Linac has the same out-of-field dose distribution. However, considering the absolute dose values, MR-Linac delivered relatively higher out-of-field doses on both surface and internal OARs. Additional radiation shielding to patients undergoing MR-Linac may provide protection from out-of-field exposure.

Estimation of Skin doses for Retrofit Prototype Multileaf Collimators Designed for Telecobalt Therapy Machine

Aim

The objective of this study was to evaluate skin dose based on retrofit prototype multileaf collimators (MLCs), designed for cobalt-60 teletherapy machine. Since patient's skin is sensitive to radiation, evaluation of skin dose is of utmost importance for investigating the risk of late effects.

Materials and Methods

Measurements were performed with a Phoenix cobalt-60 teletherapy machine and the detector used was EBT3 radiochromic film. The experiments were performed in a solid water phantom with two prototype MLCs mounted to the machine. Dose readings were taken by placing the films at source-to-surface distance (SSD) of 60 cm, 65 cm, 70 cm, 75 cm, 80 cm, 85 cm, and 90 cm for various MLC-generated field sizes starting from 2 cm × 2 cm to 14 cm × 14 cm. The films were analyzed using custom made programs. The measured doses were normalized to the dose at dmax for that particular measurement of SSD.

Results

The skin dose is expressed as a percentage of dose at dose maximum. In general, the skin dose increases with field size and decreases with SSD. The measurements indicate surface doses within 20%-60% for the investigated SSD range. Furthermore, there is no significant difference between the surface doses of two prototype MLCs studied.

Conclusions

From the measurements, it can be concluded that there is good skin sparing even at close distance to the MLCs. The skin dose is <50% for SSDs >65 cm. A minimum gap of 5 cm is required to produce acceptable skin dose.

Quantitative Effect of Bolus on Skin Dose in Postmastectomy Radiation Therapy

BACKGROUND

In postmastectomy radiation therapy (PMRT), some centres prescribe the use of a tissue-equivalent bolus to the skin to reduce the risk of chest wall recurrence. The addition of bolus causes an increase in the skin dose, which may lead to increased risk of radiodermatitis. Radiodermatitis can decrease patients' overall quality of life, bringing into question the benefit of using the bolus. The purpose of this retrospective chart review was to quantify the increase in skin dose associated with the use of bolus in the PMRT setting.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We evaluated 70 patients who underwent PMRT at our institution during 2012-2018. Two similar treatment plans were generated for each patient: one with bolus and one without. Skin dose-volume histogram values were evaluated, and statistical analysis was performed using MATLAB R2015b.

RESULTS

There was no significant difference in the maximum skin dose within a depth of 5 mm for bolus versus nonbolus plans (P = 0.4). However, within a depth of 3 mm, bolus plans had a maximum skin dose 7% ± 2.5% higher than the nonbolus plans (P < .00001). Mean skin dose within depths of 3 and 5 mm were both significantly higher (P < .00001) for bolus plans. The photon beam energy and chest wall separation showed minimal or no effect on skin dose.

CONCLUSION

Given the differing opinions in the literature regarding the role for bolus in PMRT, there is still uncertainty of the optimal treatment method. This retrospective study demonstrates a 20%-30% reduction in mean skin dose when bolus is not used.

Absorption ratio of treatment couch and effect on surface and build-up region doses

Aim

In this study, at different fields, energies and gantry angles, treatment couch and rails dose absorption ratio and treatment couch effect on surface and build-up region doses were examined.

Background

It is assumed that radiation attenuation is minimal because the carbon fiber couches have low density and it is not generally accounted for during treatment planning. Consequently, it leads to a major dosimetric mistake.

Materials and methods

Solid water phantom was used for relative dose measurement. The measurements were done using a Farmer ion chamber with 0.6 cc volume and a parallel plane ion chamber starting from surface with 1 mm depth intervals at 10 × 10 cm² field, SSD 100 cm. Measurements were taken for situations where the beams intersect the couch and couch rails.

Results

Dose absorption ratio of carbon fiber couch obtained at gantry angle of 180° was 1.52%, 0.69%, 0.33% and 0.25% at different field sizes for 6 MV. For 15 MV, this ratio was 0.95%, 0.27%, 0.20% and 0.05%. The absorption ratio is between 3.4% and 1.22% when the beams intersect with couch rails. The couch effect increased surface dose from 14% to 70% for 6 MV and from 11.34% to 53.03% for 15 MV.

Conclusions

The results showed that the carbon fiber couch increased surface dose during posterior irradiation. Therefore, the skin-sparing effect of the high energy beams was decreased. If the effect of couch is not considered, it may cause significant differences at dose which reaches the patient and may cause tissue problems such as erythema.

Characterization of a new transmission detector for patient individualized online plan verification and its influence on 6MV X-ray beam characteristics

PURPOSE

Online verification and 3D dose reconstruction on daily patient anatomy have the potential to improve treatment delivery, accuracy and safety. One possible implementation is to recalculate dose based on online fluence measurements with a transmission detector (TD) attached to the linac. This study provides a detailed analysis of the influence of a new TD on treatment beam characteristics.

METHODS

The influence of the new TD on surface dose was evaluated by measurements with an Advanced Markus Chamber (Adv-MC) in the build-up region. Based on Monte Carlo simulations, correction factors were determined to scale down the over-response of the Adv-MC close to the surface. To analyze the effects beyond dmax percentage depth dose (PDD), lateral profiles and transmission measurements were performed. All measurements were carried out for various field sizes and different SSDs. Additionally, 5 IMRT-plans (head & neck, prostate, thorax) and 2 manually created test cases (3×3cm(2) fields with different dose levels, sweeping gap) were measured to investigate the influence of the TD on clinical treatment plans. To investigate the performance of the TD, dose linearity as well as dose rate dependency measurements were performed.

RESULTS

With the TD inside the beam an increase in surface dose was observed depending on SSD and field size (maximum of +11%, SSD = 80cm, field size = 30×30cm(2)). Beyond dmax the influence of the TD on PDDs was below 1%. The measurements showed that the transmission factor depends slightly on the field size (0.893-0.921 for 5×5cm(2) to 30×30cm(2)). However, the evaluation of clinical IMRT-plans measured with and without the TD showed good agreement after using a single transmission factor (γ(2%/2mm) > 97%, δ±3% >95%). Furthermore, the response of TD was found to be linear and dose rate independent (maximum difference <0.5% compared to reference measurements).

CONCLUSIONS

When placed in the path of the beam, the TD introduced a slight, clinically acceptable increase of the skin dose even for larger field sizes and smaller SSDs and the influence of the detector on the dose beyond dmax as well as on clinical IMRT-plans was negligible. Since there was no dose rate dependency and the response was linear, the device is therefore suitable for clinical use. Only its absorption has to be compensated during treatment planning, either by the use of a single transmission factor or by including the TD in the incident beam model.

Characterization of MOSkin detector for in vivo skin dose measurement during megavoltage radiotherapy

In vivo dosimetry is important during radiotherapy to ensure the accuracy of the dose delivered to the treatment volume. A dosimeter should be characterized based on its application before it is used for in vivo dosimetry. In this study, we characterize a new MOSFET‐based detector, the MOSkin detector, on surface for in vivo skin dosimetry. The advantages of the MOSkin detector are its water equivalent depth of measurement of 0.07 mm, small physical size with submicron dosimetric volume, and the ability to provide real‐time readout. A MOSkin detector was calibrated and the reproducibility, linearity, and response over a large dose range to different threshold voltages were determined. Surface dose on solid water phantom was measured using MOSkin detector and compared with Markus ionization chamber and GAFCHROMIC EBT2 film measurements. Dependence in the response of the MOSkin detector on the surface of solid water phantom was also tested for different (i) source to surface distances (SSDs); (ii) field sizes; (iii) surface dose; (iv) radiation incident angles; and (v) wedges. The MOSkin detector showed excellent reproducibility and linearity for dose range of 50 cGy to 300 cGy. The MOSkin detector showed reliable response to different SSDs, field sizes, surface, radiation incident angles, and wedges. The MOSkin detector is suitable for in vivo skin dosimetry.

PACS number: 87.55.Qr

Superficial dosimetry imaging based on Čerenkov emission for external beam radiotherapy with megavoltage x-ray beam

PURPOSE

Čerenkov radiation emission occurs in all tissue, when charged particles (either primary or secondary) travel at velocity above the threshold for the Čerenkov effect (about 220 KeV in tissue for electrons). This study presents the first examination of optical Čerenkov emission as a surrogate for the absorbed superficial dose for MV x-ray beams.

METHODS

In this study, Monte Carlo simulations of flat and curved surfaces were studied to analyze the energy spectra of charged particles produced in different regions near the surfaces when irradiated by MV x-ray beams. Čerenkov emission intensity and radiation dose were directly simulated in voxelized flat and cylindrical phantoms. The sampling region of superficial dosimetry based on Čerenkov radiation was simulated in layered skin models. Angular distributions of optical emission from the surfaces were investigated. Tissue mimicking phantoms with flat and curved surfaces were imaged with a time domain gating system. The beam field sizes (50 × 50-200 × 200 mm(2)), incident angles (0°-70°) and imaging regions were all varied.

RESULTS

The entrance or exit region of the tissue has nearly homogeneous energy spectra across the beam, such that their Čerenkov emission is proportional to dose. Directly simulated local intensity of Čerenkov and radiation dose in voxelized flat and cylindrical phantoms further validate that this signal is proportional to radiation dose with absolute average discrepancy within 2%, and the largest within 5% typically at the beam edges. The effective sampling depth could be tuned from near 0 up to 6 mm by spectral filtering. The angular profiles near the theoretical Lambertian emission distribution for a perfect diffusive medium, suggesting that angular correction of Čerenkov images may not be required even for curved surface. The acquisition speed and signal to noise ratio of the time domain gating system were investigated for different acquisition procedures, and the results show there is good potential for real-time superficial dose monitoring. Dose imaging under normal ambient room lighting was validated, using gated detection and a breast phantom.

CONCLUSIONS

This study indicates that Čerenkov emission imaging might provide a valuable way to superficial dosimetry imaging in real time for external beam radiotherapy with megavoltage x-ray beams.

Superficial dosimetry imaging of Čerenkov emission in electron beam radiotherapy of phantoms

Čerenkov emission is generated from ionizing radiation in tissue above 264 keV energy. This study presents the first examination of this optical emission as a surrogate for the absorbed superficial dose. Čerenkov emission was imaged from the surface of flat tissue phantoms irradiated with electrons, using a range of field sizes from 6 cm × 6 cm to 20 cm × 20 cm, incident angles from 0° to 50°, and energies from 6 to 18 MeV. The Čerenkov images were compared with the estimated superficial dose in phantoms from direct diode measurements, as well as calculations by Monte Carlo and the treatment planning system. Intensity images showed outstanding linear agreement (R(2) = 0.97) with reference data of the known dose for energies from 6 to 18 MeV. When orthogonal delivery was carried out, the in-plane and cross-plane dose distribution comparisons indicated very little difference (± 2-4% differences) between the different methods of estimation as compared to Čerenkov light imaging. For an incident angle 50°, the Čerenkov images and Monte Carlo simulation show excellent agreement with the diode data, but the treatment planning system had a larger error (OPT = ± 1~2%, diode = ± 2~3%, TPS = ± 6-8% differences) as would be expected. The sampling depth of superficial dosimetry based on Čerenkov radiation has been simulated in a layered skin model, showing the potential of sampling depth tuning by spectral filtering. Taken together, these measurements and simulations indicate that Čerenkov emission imaging might provide a valuable method of superficial dosimetry imaging from incident radiotherapy beams of electrons.