Mastoid Obliteration with Synthetic Materials: A Review of the Literature

A Comparison of the Sticky Bone Obliteration Technique and Obliteration Using S53P4 Bioactive Glass After Canal Wall Down Ear Surgery: A Preliminary Study

Background: The aim of this study was to analyse the results of the mastoid obliteration technique with sticky bone (SB) and compare them with those obtained using bioactive glass S53P4 (BAG). Methods: This prospective preliminary study comprised 28 adults who underwent canal wall down (CWD) surgery using two mastoid obliterative techniques: SB (n = 21) or BAG (n = 7). The SB group was treated with the patients' own bone dust and injectable platelet rich fibrin (IPRF) (n = 13%) or bone dust, IPRF, and additionally allogenic lyophilised demineralised bone (n = 9%). Results: Nine months after the surgery, in the SB group, retroauricular depression was observed in three (14%) patients, temporary retroauricular fistula in one (5%), and a conical and smooth external auditory canal (EAC) was achieved in 15 (71%). Mean EAC capacity was 0.6 mL higher than in the contralateral ear. In the SB group, the tympanic membrane (TM) of nineteen (91%) patients was fully healed, one (5%) had TM perforation, and one (5%) developed a retraction pocket. In the BAG group, retroauricular depression was observed in four (57%) patients, temporary retroauricular fistula was present in one (14%), and a conical and smooth EAC was achieved in five (71%). Mean EAC capacity was 0.3 mL higher than on the opposite side. In the BAG group, we stated six (86%) patients with fully healed TM and one (14%) with a retraction pocket. One cholesteatoma was found in the BAG group and two in SB, (14% vs. 10%). After 9 months, all patients in both groups achieved a dry and self-cleaning cavity. Conclusions: Mastoid obliteration in CWD surgery using SB or BAG allows for reconstruction of the conical shape of the EAC with a volume similar to that of a healthy ear. Both techniques seem to have a minimal risk of complications and result in a dry, self-cleaning cavity. Further studies concerning a larger series of cases are necessary to confirm the findings of this preliminary analysis.

Comparison of Post-auricular Soft Tissue and Post-auricular Soft Tissue With Autologous Bone Pate in Obliteration of the Canal Wall Down Mastoidectomy Cavity

Background The surgical management of chronic otitis media (COM) with squamous disease is canal wall down mastoidectomy (CWDM). Canal wall down procedures require the obliteration of the newly formed cavity to mitigate complications. Soft tissue flaps, including Rambo flap, Hong Kong flap, Palva flap, and inferior-based fascio-periosteal flap, as well as autologous bone pâté, have been the most successful and commonly used materials for obliteration over the past two decades. Although each flap has its advantages, the Palva flap is considered superior, primarily because of its ease of use and the simplicity of its design. In this study, we intend to evaluate the effectiveness of mastoid obliteration using autologous bone pate with Palva flap compared to Palva flap (post-auricular fibro-periosteal soft tissue) in patients who underwent CWDM. Methods Sixty-two patients with COM with squamous disease were included in the study. The patients underwent CWDM with tympanoplasty and meatoplasty, followed by cavity obliteration using two different methods: group A - obliteration with Palva flap (post-auricular fibro-periosteal soft tissue) and group B - obliteration with Palva flap and bone pate. The patients were evaluated for cavity problems on post-operative days 21, 30, 60, 90, and 180, based on a 10-point scale compiled from the literature. Results Our study found that the majority of patients had right-sided disease and were between 41 and 60 years of age. Five out of sixty-two (8.1%) patients developed cavity problems, three in group A (9.7%) and two in group B (6.5%). The incidence of cavity problems was almost the same in both groups. The cavity problems were as follows: vertigo (1/62, 1.6%), surgical site infection (2/62, 3.2%), and graft failure (2/62, 3.2%). However, there were no statistically significant differences (p-value: 0.62) between either of the obliteration methods in terms of mitigating cavity problems. Conclusion Post-auricular soft tissue and post-auricular soft tissue with autologous bone pate in the obliteration of the CWDM cavity provided similar results in terms of mitigating cavity problems.

Antibiofilm Effects of Novel Compounds in Otitis Media Treatment: Systematic Review

Otitis media (OM) is a frequent disease with incidence rate of 5300 cases per 100,000 people. Recent studies showed that polymicrobial biofilm formation represents a significant pathogenic mechanism in recurrent and chronic forms of OM. Biofilm enables bacteria to resist antibiotics that would typically be recommended in guidelines, contributing to the ineffectiveness of current antimicrobial strategies. Given the challenges of successfully treating bacterial biofilms, there is an growing interest in identifying novel and effective compounds to overcome antibacterial resistance. The objective of this review was to provide an overview of the novel compounds with antibiofilm effects on bacterial biofilm formed by clinical isolates of OM. The systematic review included studies that evaluated antibiofilm effect of novel natural or synthetic compounds on bacterial biofilm formed from clinical isolates obtained from patients with OM. The eligibility criteria were defined using the PICOS system: (P) Population: all human patients with bacterial OM; (I) Intervention: novel natural or synthetic compound with biofilm effect; (C) Control standard therapeutic antimicrobial agents or untreated biofilms, (O) Outcome: antibiofilm effect (biofilm inhibition, biofilm eradication), (S) Study design. The PRISMA protocol for systematic reviews and meta-analysis was followed. From 3564 potentially eligible studies, 1817 duplicates were removed, and 1705 were excluded according to defined exclusion criteria. A total of 41 studies with available full texts were retrieved by two independent authors. Fifteen articles were selected for inclusion in the systematic review which included 125 patients with OM. A total of 17 different novel compounds were examined, including N-acetyl-L-cysteine (NAC), tea tree oil, xylitol, eugenol, Aloe barbadensis, Zingiber officinale, Curcuma longa, Acacia arabica, antisense peptide nucleic acids, probiotics Streptococcus salivarius and Streptococcus oralis, Sodium 2-mercaptoethanesulfonate (MESNA), bioactive glass, green synthesized copper oxide nanoparticles, radish, silver nanoparticles and acetic acid. Staphylococcus aureus was the most commonly studied pathogen, followed by Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Haemophilus influenzae. Biofilm inhibition only by an examined compound was assessed in six studies; biofilm eradication in four studies, and both biofilm inhibition and biofilm eradication were examined in five studies. This systematic review indicates that some compounds like NAC, prebiotics, nanoparticles and MESNA that have significant effects on biofilm are safe and could be researched more extensively for further clinical use. However, a lack of data about reliable and efficient compounds used in therapy of different types of otitis media still remains in the literature.

Mastoid Obliteration With Freeze-Dried Bone Allograft in Canal Wall Down Tympanoplasty: Description of a Novel Technique and Case Report

Mastoid obliteration can be performed after canal wall down (CWD) mastoidectomy with various materials. Homologous bone tissue harvested from cadaver donor represents a feasible option with advantages. The purpose of the study is to describe the case of a patient diagnosed with middle ear cholesteatoma treated with mastoidectomy of the CWD and mastoid obliteration with homologous freeze-dried corticocancellous bone particulate in the Cittadella Hospital Ear, Nose, Throat (ENT) unit. The preoperative characteristics of the patients, the procurement and processing of bone allografts, the surgical technique, and postsurgical outcomes are described. No perioperative and postoperative complications were observed, and no rejection or foreign body reactions occurred. The patient then underwent a seriated follow-up. Audiometric tests showed an improvement in hearing levels. The volume of the neoexternal ear canal was 2.01 cm3. The case demonstrated clinical stability, substantial hearing recovery, and no need for specialist cleaning of the reformed external ear canal (EEC). The freeze-dried bone tissue allograft, in the technical way we used, appears to be a viable option in mastoid obliteration because homologous bone is not affected by material shortage, has fast assimilation, and ensures a useful radiological examination scan, at a low cost.

Heterologous Materials Are Really Better than Autologous in Tympanoplasty Mastoid Obliteration? A Systematic Review with Meta-Analysis

The aim is to analyze Literature concerning mastoid obliteration in adults with either autologous or heterologous grafts in the last 10 years. Data Source: Databases such as NIH PubMed, Bookshelf, NLM Catalog, Cochrane Library, and Embase were consulted. Thirty-seven studies were selected (22 concerning autologous materials, 15 about heterologous ones). Only studies with more than 12 months of follow-up were considered. A statistical analysis with random-effects models was performed to allow the true effect sizes to differ from study to study. The present literature review and meta-analysis does not allow to establish the supremacy of one technique over the other, but underlines the advantages of each reconstructive choice and the importance of mastoid obliteration in cholesteatoma surgery. The total number of obliterated ears was 2882. Overall otorrhea rate was 5% (5.2% for heterologous grafts; 4.9% for autologous materials; P < .05). Recurrent and residual cholesteatoma rate was 4.5% (3.4% in heterologous materials; 5.2% in autologous grafts; P < .05). Recurrent cholesteatoma rate was 1.8% (1.6% when using heterologous grafts, 1.9% with autologous; P < .05). Residual cholesteatoma rate was 1.5% (1.6% with heterologous materials, 1.5% with autologous; P < .05). TM (tympanic membrane) retraction pockets rate was 5.3% (3.6% with heterologous materials; P >.05; 7% with autologous materials; P < .05). TM perforations rate was 2.9% (4.3% with heterologous materials, 2.5% with autologous; P < .05). Infection rate was 2.3% (2.3% with heterologous materials, 2.2% with autologous; P < .05). Heterologous materials are associated with significantly lower rates of recurrent and residual cholesteatoma and retraction pockets development, although they are associated with higher rates of otorrhea and TM perforation.

Safety and Effectiveness of Bone Allografts for Mastoid Obliteration After Mastoidectomy: A Pilot Study

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Various materials are used to perform post-mastoidectomy mastoid obliteration (MO) to reduce the risk of recurrent infections, stasis of secretions, or caloric dizziness. Autologous materials used as fillers for MO tend to be insufficient owing to shrinkage over time or inadequate volume of these substances. Synthetic materials are unsatisfactory for MO because of the risk of rejection and extrusion. We investigated the safety and effectiveness of bone allografts for post-mastoidectomy MO.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

We reviewed the medical records of patients who underwent mastoidectomy with MO between January 2013 and January 2021. In the MO group, bone allografts were additionally used to fill the residual mastoid cavity. In the canal wall down (CWD) group, all patients underwent CWD mastoidectomy with use of additional inferiorly based mucoperiosteal flaps.

RESULTS

The study included the MO group (23 ears) and the CWD group (53 ears). In the MO group, compared with the preoperative status, we observed a decrease in the tendency of the air-bone gap postoperatively. Compared with the CWD group, the total complication rate showed a decreasing tendency in the MO group.

CONCLUSIONS

No patient showed post-MO shrinkage of the grafted bone allograft or otorrhea. Further large-scale studies are warranted to confirm the advantages of bone allografts for MO, including maintenance with time and sufficient amount.

Allograft bone vs. bioactive glass in rehabilitation of canal wall-down surgery

Canal wall-down (CWD) mastoidectomy creates a radical cavity that modifies the anatomy and physiology of the middle ear, thus preventing it from being self-cleaning and causing epidermal stagnation in the posterior cavities. Canal wall-down tympanomastoidectomy with reconstruction (CWDTwR) can obliterate such radical cavities. The main objective of this study was to compare postoperative results after CWDTwR by using either bone allografts or 45S5 bioactive glass as a filling tissue with an 18-month follow-up. This was a single-center observational trial including all patients undergoing CWDTwR. Patients were divided into two groups according to the filling material used: allograft bone (AB group) or 45S5 bioactive glass (BG group). Clinical monitoring was performed regularly, with control imaging performed at 18 months (CT scan and DW MRI). The two groups were compared with the t test for quantitative variables and the chi square test for qualitative variables (no revision surgery, audiometric results, complications, mastoid obliteration volume). Thirty-two patients underwent CWDTwR between October 2015 and 2018. The mean age was 48 years, and 71.9% (23/32) were men. A total of 46.9% (15/32) of the patients had undergone at least 3 middle-ear surgeries prior to CWDTwR. The most frequent preoperative symptom was otorrhea (100.0%, 32/32), and only 12.5% (4/32) experienced dizziness. Fifteen and 17 patients underwent surgery with bone allografts and 45S5 bioactive glass, respectively. At 18 months post-operation, 53.3% of the patients (8/15) in the AB group presented with recurrent otorrhea versus 5.9% (1/17) of patients in the BG group (p = 0.005). Seventy-eight percent (7/9) of symptomatic patients had undergone revision surgery at 18 months postoperation: 40.0% (6/15) in the AB group and 5.9% (1/17) in the BG group (p = 0.033). One patient's surgery was cancelled due to the COVID-19 pandemic, and one patient refused surgery. The effects of CWDTwR with bone allografts are disappointing in early follow-up, with significant resorption leading to a 40.0% revision surgery rate. 45S5 BG is a simple solution, with preliminary results that are superior to those of AB. However, prospective controlled studies with longer follow-up times are needed to evaluate the value of BG versus other synthetic materials (such as hydroxyapatite) in surgical management of CWDTwR.Trial registration: retrospectively registered.

Efficacy of S53P4 Bioactive Glass for the Secondary Obliteration of Chronically Discharging Radical Cavities

Objective

Present the results of the secondary obliteration of chronically discharging radical cavities using S53P4 bioactive glass (BAG).

Study Design

Retrospective cohort study.

Setting

Single-center study.

Methods

A single-center retrospective cohort study was conducted of all patients that underwent secondary obliteration of persistently draining radical cavities using S53P4 BAG between 2011 and 2022. Patients with middle ear cholesteatoma were excluded. The main outcome was postoperative otorrhea, as indicated by Merchant grading.

Results

In total, 97 patients were included. The median postoperative follow-up time was 3.9 years (range 0.5-10.4). Average time between the original canal wall down surgery and the secondary obliteration was 25.3 years (SD 11.7, range 2-66). At the most recent follow-up visit, a Merchant grade of 0 to 1 was observed in 95% of the cases. There were no cases of sensorineural hearing loss or facial palsy, one case developed a retro auricular skin defect and 1 patient developed CSF leakage. Minor complications were seen in 10 patients (10%). Ossicular chain reconstruction with a titanium prosthesis was performed in 42 cases, resulting in a median improvement of 11.2 dB in air conduction thresholds. In 9/42 cases (21%), closure of the postoperative air-bone gap to ≤20 dB was achieved. Twenty-five percent of cases could be discharged from out-patient visits.

Conclusion

Revision of persistently draining radical cavities with BAG obliteration is feasible and results in a dry and safe ear in 95% of the patients, thereby enabling wearing of a conventional hearing aid. Out-patient visits could be ceased in 25% of the cases.

The effect of bony obliteration on quality of life after tympano-mastoidectomy surgery: A prospective observational controlled cohort study

Objectives

The study's primary objective was to compare the quality of life (QoL) and external auditory canal (EAC) hygiene among patients who underwent bony mastoid obliteration or meatoplasty after canal wall down (CWD) mastoidectomy.

Methods

A prospective, observational, controlled cohort study was conducted at our tertiary referral university hospital. Twenty-eight patients older than 16 years of age with chronic otitis media who underwent CWD mastoidectomy were included. Two cohorts were followed: CWD mastoidectomy followed by mastoid obliteration (Group 1, n = 14) and CWD mastoidectomy followed by meatoplasty (Group 2, n = 14). The main outcome measures of total COMBI score (postoperative 6-month QoL) and EAC hygiene were compared between the groups.

Results

The average age of the patients was 36.14 (12. 22) years; 15 (53.6%) were female and 13 (46.4%) were male. There were no differences in demographic variables, preoperative findings, or COMQ-12 (preoperative QoL) scores between groups. The average COMBI score of Group 1 (49.0 [8.66]) was not significantly different from Group 2 (46.79 [7.76]) (p = .482). Poor EAC hygiene was observed in eight (57.1%) patients in Group 2 and three (21.4%) patients in Group 1 (p = .06). In Group 1, no resorption of graft material was observed in 10 (71.4%) patients, minor resorption was observed in three (21.4%) patients, and significant resorption was observed in one (7.1%) patient. There were no significant differences in audiological findings between groups (p > .05).

Conclusion

There were no significant differences regarding short-term postoperative QoL, EAC hygiene, or hearing outcomes between patients who underwent bony mastoid obliteration or meatoplasty after CWD mastoidectomy.

Level of Evidence

1b (individual prospective cohort study).

Mastoid obliteration with hydroxyapatite vs. bone pâté in mastoidectomy surgery performed on patients with cholesteatoma and chronic suppurative otitis media: a retrospective analysis

PURPOSE

To compare the efficacy and safety of hydroxyapatite vs. bone pâté as obliteration material in mastoidectomy surgery for patients with chronic suppurative otitis media and cholesteatoma.

METHODS

This is a retrospective, multi-center, cohort study. All patients were followed up with micro-otoscopy, audiometry, and, if indicated, MRI with diffusion-weighted imaging. The following outcome parameters were analyzed: procedure safety (wound infections and complications), cholesteatoma recidivism rates (residual/recurrent), control of infection (Merchant's scale), and hearing results (pure-tone averages at 500/1000/2000/4000 Hz).

RESULTS

Eighty-three cases were included: 45 obliterated with hydroxyapatite and 38 with bone pâté, with a mean follow-up time of, respectively, 25 and 24 months. Wound infections were only detected in the bone pâté group (4.8%) and successfully treated with oral or intravenous antibiotics and surgical drainage (p = 0.026). No other major surgical complications were observed in both groups. Cholesteatoma recidivism was observed in 15% using hydroxyapatite and 12% using bone pâté (p = 0.471). Complete control of infection (Merchant 0) was achieved in 76.2% using bone pâté and 86.8% using hydroxyapatite at 12 months postoperatively (p = 0.223). All patients showed good postoperative healing without complete failure to manage infection (Merchant 3). Pre- and postoperative audiometry showed significant improvement in hearing results in both groups. No significant difference between the obliteration materials was observed.

CONCLUSIONS

Evaluation of mastoid obliteration reveals that hydroxyapatite and bone pâté are safe and effective obliteration materials, with high success rates in achieving a dry ear, low recidivism rates, and good hearing outcome, respecting the short-term limitation. In addition, our study shows that hydroxyapatite results in fewer postoperative wound infections compared to bone pâté.

Use of bonalive in obliterative mastoidectomy: anatomical results and clinical outcome

PURPOSE

To investigate safety and efficacy of mastoid obliteration in canal-wall-down tympanoplasty performed for cholesteatoma using bioactive glass (BAG). The authors routinely adopt CWD tympanoplasty in case of massive cholesteatoma or revision surgery, performing obliteration with BAG to reduce the mastoid cavity and related disadvantages. We assessed anatomical results, infection control and cholesteatoma recurrence in obliterative mastoidectomy using BAG.

METHODS

The authors evaluated 66 patients treated with obliterative mastoidectomy using BAG during the period 2010-2021. 48.5% of the cases had first diagnosis of cholesteatoma, 48.5% had cholesteatoma recidivisms, and two patients underwent obliteration to improve clinical outcome. BAG granules were always moistened with venous blood to enhance their adhesion and reduce the risk of dispersion. Anatomical results were evaluated in otomicroscopy and infection control was assessed during follow-up visits. Periodical otomicroscopy was performed to check recurrent cholesteatoma. MRI-DWI was indicated only in case of clinical suspect of cholesteatoma.

RESULTS

Authors followed 66 patients during a mean of 23 months. No post-operative wound infections occured. The mean re-epithelialization time was 45 days. At the last visit, control of infection was achieved in 97% of patients and a clinical stable anatomical cavity in all patients. No clinical suspect for recurrent cholesteatoma was found.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of bioactive glass is safe and effective as obliteration material in cholesteatoma surgery. Authors pay a particular attention to obliterate only patients without suspect of epithelial residual, to correctly calibrate the ear canal and to completely cover the granules with graft.

Mastoid obliteration versus canal wall down or canal wall up mastoidectomy for cholesteatoma: Systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

There is ongoing debate over the optimal surgical approach for cholesteatoma treatment^1-5. The aim of this review was to determine whether canal-wall down with mastoid obliteration is associated with favourable outcomes compared to either canal-wall down without obliteration or canal-wall up. The primary outcome was cholesteatoma reoccurrence with secondary outcomes including otorrhoea, reoperation and patient-reported outcome measures.

METHODS

Medline, Embase, Cochrane databases and clinicaltrials.gov were searched for studies reporting outcomes of patients undergoing primary CWD-MO for cholesteatoma and directly compared with CWD and CWU mastoidectomies. Data were collated and meta-analysis performed.

RESULTS

2379 patients were included from 12 studies that met the inclusion criteria. CWD-MO was found to be associated with significantly less risk of recurrence when compared to CWU (OR = 0.330 (95 % CI 0.191-0.570, p < 0.001). When compared to CWD, CWD-MO was associate with significantly lower incidence of persistent otorrhoea (OR 0.405 (95 % CI 0.232-0.706, p < 0.001) while the rates of recurrence were comparable (OR: 1.231 [95 % CI: 0.550-2.757] p = 0.613). Otorrhoea rates between CWD-MO and CWU were equivalent as was reoperation. Quality of life and hearing outcomes were variably reported.

CONCLUSIONS

This systematic review demonstrates that CWD-MO technique achieves lower recurrence rates comparable to CWD approaches and superior to CWU, while offering improved long-term control of otorrhoea. The final procedural choice should be decided based on surgeon experience, skill set and individual patient factors. To address the risk of selection bias, a randomised controlled trial is needed to answer this important research question.

Bioactive glass (S53P4) as obliteration material in subtotal petrosectomy: initial experience

BACKGROUND

Subtotal petrosectomy for chronic suppurative otitis media requires obliteration of the mastoid cavity and middle ear. Usually, abdominal fat is used for this purpose. However, infection is a risk of using fat, which might require revision surgery. The use of S53P4 bioactive glass with antibacterial properties seems an attractive alternative.

METHODS

Two patients with a history of chronic suppurative otitis media, complicated by profound perceptive hearing loss, had already been surgically treated, and were thereafter extensively treated conservatively. Because of recurrent chronic otorrhoea and pain, subtotal petrosectomy with obliteration of the cavity with S53P4 bioactive glass was performed.

RESULTS

Follow-up duration was 84 months and 18 months, respectively. No complications occurred peri-operatively. A dry ear was obtained and no late adverse events were observed.

CONCLUSION

S53P4 bioactive glass is feasible to use for obliteration after subtotal petrosectomy. Elimination of chronic suppurative otitis media can be achieved with this technique. The bioactive glass granules might be an attractive alternative to abdominal fat, which has a risk of infection.

Mastoid Obliteration Using S53P4 Bioactive Glass in Cholesteatoma Surgery: A 10-Year Single-Center Experience in 173 Adult Patients with Long-Term Magnetic Resonance Imaging Controlled Follow-up

OBJECTIVE

To present the long-term outcomes of mastoid obliteration in cholesteatoma surgery using S53P4 bioactive glass (BAG) in an adult population.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study.

SETTING

Single-center study.

PATIENTS

All 173 adult patients who underwent primary or revision surgery for cholesteatoma with mastoid obliteration using S53P4 BAG with at least 1 year of follow-up including nonecho planar diffusion-weighted magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) (non-EP DWI MRI) and/or second-look surgery to evaluate recidivism. Both canal wall up (CWU) and canal wall down (CWD) procedures were included.

INTERVENTIONS

Patients underwent CWU or CWD mastoidectomy using S53P4 BAG.

MAIN OUTCOME AND MEASURES

Cholesteatoma recidivism, postoperative complications, Merchant grade, hearing outcome.

RESULTS

Cholesteatoma recidivism was assessed by MRI in 97% of all cases and second-look surgery look surgery in 3% of cases. After a mean follow-up period of 53 months, cholesteatoma recidivism was seen in 10% of the cases (n = 18). Using the Kaplan-Meier curve to extrapolate, a 5-year recidivism rate of 12% was estimated. Only minor complications occurred, all resolving spontaneously or after minor treatment. Merchant grade of 0 to 1 was achieved 95% of the patients, no persistently wet ears were observed. Closure of the air-bone gap within 20 dB was possible in 32%.

CONCLUSION

In this long-term (up to 10 yr) follow-up study, we demonstrated the safety of S53P4 BAG. Minimal and only minor postoperative complications were observed. The effectiveness of BAG was indicated by the low rate of recidivism, even when using non-EP DWI MRI, a sensitive and specific noninvasive technique to detect cholesteatoma recidivism.

An Effect of Cyclosporin A in a Treatment of Temporal Bone Defect Using hBM-MSCs

Background. The treatment of middle ear cholesteatoma requires surgical treatment and the reconstruction of the temporal bone, which represents an ongoing problem. Otologists have focused on the research of materials allowing an airy middle ear and the preservation of hearing function to reconstruct the temporal bone. Methods. This study evaluated the effect of cyclosporin A (CsA) and a combined biomaterial in the healing process of postoperative temporal bone defects in an animal model. Cultured human Bone Marrow Mesenchymal Stromal Cells (hBM-MSCs) were mixed with hydroxyapatite (Cem-Ostetic^®), and subsequently applied as a bone substitute after middle ear surgery, showing that the therapeutic potential of hBM-MSCs associated with bone regeneration and replacement is directly influenced by CsA, confirming that it promotes the survival of MSCs in vivo. Results. The therapeutic efficacy of the combination of MSCs with CsA is greater than the sole application of MSCs in a hydroxyapatite carrier. Conclusion. The reconstruction of a temporal bone defect using hBM-MSCs requires an immunosuppressant to improve the results of treatment.

Mastoid obliteration and external auditory canal reconstruction using 3D printed bioactive glass S53P4 /polycaprolactone scaffold loaded with bone morphogenetic protein-2: A simulation clinical study in rabbits

INTRODUCTION

The lack of good prosthetic materials and objective standards has limited the promotion of mastoid obliteration and external auditory canal reconstruction, and the quality of the surgery varies. In this study, bioactive glass S53P4 (S53P4), the most popular artificial prosthetic material, was modified and combined with polycaprolactone (PCL) and bone morphogenetic protein-2 (BMP-2) to produce an individualized biological scaffold using 3D printing technology to explore a better material and method for mastoid obliteration and external auditory canal reconstruction.

METHODS

3D-printed S53P4/PCL scaffolds were fabricated from 3D reconstruction data of bone defect areas in New Zealand rabbits simulating "Canal Wall Down Mastoidectomy". The water absorption, swelling rate, porosity, and Young's modulus of the scaffold were measured, and the morphology and pore size of the scaffold were observed using scanning electron microscopy. The cytotoxicity of the S53P4/PCL scaffolds was detected using the CCK8 assay, and the in vitro antibacterial activity of the S53P4/PCL scaffolds was detected using the inhibition circle method. The BMP-2-loaded S53P4/PCL scaffolds were prepared using the drop-in lyophilization method and implanted into animal models. The biocompatibility, osteogenic activity, and external auditory canal repair of the scaffolds were observed using endoscopy, micro-CT, and histological examination.

RESULTS

The S53P4/PCL scaffold was highly compatible with the defective area of the animal model, and its physicochemical properties met the requirements of bone tissue engineering. In vitro experiments showed that the S53P4/PCL scaffold was non-cytotoxic and exhibited better antibacterial activity than the same volume of the S53P4 powder. In vivo experiments showed that the S53P4/PCL scaffold had good biocompatibility and osteogenic activity, and could effectively repair bone defects and reconstruct the normal morphology of the external auditory canal in animal models. Furthermore, its osteogenic activity and repair ability were significantly improved after loading with BMP-2.

CONCLUSIONS

The 3D printed S53P4/PCL scaffold has great potential for clinical mastoid obliteration and external auditory canal reconstruction.

Antibiotics in mastoid and epitympanic obliteration with S53P4 bioactive glass: A retrospective study

Objective

The role of antibiotics in ear surgery is still controversial. The aim of this study was to assess their need in cholesteatoma surgery when performing obliteration with S53P4 bioactive glass, a biocompatible material with antibacterial properties.

Methods

This retrospective cohort study was conducted in a tertiary referral center between January 2017 and May 2019. Sixty-nine consecutive patients, who underwent surgery for cholesteatoma removal and/or rehabilitation of canal-wall-down mastoidectomy with mastoid and epitympanic obliteration using S53P4 granules were included. Before 2019, antibiotics were routinely used (group "w/AB"). Patients received intravenous antibiotics during surgery, oral treatment was continued for 7 days and topical antibiotics for 1 month. After 2019, no antibiotics were administered (group "w/oAB"). The primary outcome was the occurrence of early surgical site infection. Secondary outcomes were late infection, anatomic and functional results at 3 and 12 months.

Results

Twenty-three patients were included in group "w/oAB" and 46 in group "w/AB", with no significant differences in demographics, medical history or follow-up. Five ears (22%) in group "w/oAB" developed an early infection compared with 2 (4%) in group "w/AB" (p = .03). The relative risk was 6.11, 95CI%[1.09;31.96]. Infections were successfully treated with antibiotics, and no patient underwent surgical removal of the granules. No late infections or complications were observed. There was no difference in graft failure or air-bone gap closure at 1 year.

Conclusion

Peri-/post-operative antibiotics prevent early infection in obliteration surgery with S53P4 granules. Infections can be treated medically without complications or require removal of the implanted material.

Level of evidence

4.

Mastoid Obliteration Decreases the Recurrent and Residual Disease: Systematic Review and Meta-analysis

OBJECTIVE

Our study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of mastoid obliteration compared to the canal wall up (CWU) technique in cholesteatoma surgery based on the systematic review of the literature and the meta-analysis of the data.

METHODS

The systematic search was performed in four major databases (MEDLINE, Web of Science, Embase, and CENTRAL) on October 14, 2021. Studies comparing the CWU technique and mastoid obliteration were included. The exclusion criteria were less than 12 months follow-up, congenital cholesteatoma, indefinite description of the surgical method, and animal studies. The protocol was registered on Prospero (registration number: CRD42021282485). The risk of bias was evaluated with the ROBINS-I tool. Residual and recurrent disease proportions as primary outcomes, quality of life, ear discharge, infection rates, hearing results, and operation time as secondary outcomes were analyzed. In the quantitative synthesis, the random effect model was used, and heterogeneity was identified.

RESULTS

A total of 11 articles with 2077 operations' data were found eligible. All the identified studies were retrospective cohorts. The odds of pooled residual and recurrent disease proportion were significantly lower in the obliteration group compared to CWU (OR = 0.45, CI:0.28;0.80, p = 0.014). However, when separated, the proportion of ears with recurrent (OR = 0.41, CI:0.11;1.57, p = 0.140) or residual (OR = 0.59, CI:0.23, 1.50, p = 0.207) disease did not show a significant difference, even though the odds were quite similar. The qualitative synthesis identified no significant difference in the secondary outcomes, but obliteration elongated the operation time.

CONCLUSION

Mastoid obliteration significantly decreased the proportion of residual and recurrent cholesteatoma in pooled analyses compared to the CWU technique with low-quality of data.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

NA Laryngoscope, 2022.

Mid-term outcomes of mastoid obliteration with biological hydroxyapatite versus bioglass: a radiological and clinical study

PURPOSE

Radiological assessment of osseointegration of mastoid grafts: biological hydroxyapatite (Bio-Oss®) (BHA) versus bioglass S53P4 (Bonalive®) (BG).

METHODS

Retrospective (10 ± 4 months post-surgery) monocentric high resolution computed tomography (CT) scan assessment (November 2018 and October 2020) by two independent radiologists (R1, R2), blinded to patient allocation. All patients who had undergone a total mastoid obliteration were eligible. Excluded: complications namely otological acute or chronic infections, unbalanced metabolic disease, long-term cortico-steroid therapy, auto-immune disease, history of allergy to grafting materials and post-surgery CT scan in other centers (n = 8).

PRIMARY OUTCOMES

the ratio between two regions of interests (ROI) (graft to otic capsule).

SECONDARY OUTCOMES

resorption of mastoid grafts and assessment of clinical tolerance.

RESULTS

Included 21 patients (mean age: 29 ± 21 years; 5 females, 16 males). Significantly higher osseointegration for BHA vs. BG (R1 p = 0.043; R2 p = 0.004); almost perfect inter-reader agreement k = 0.922). The ROI ratios for BHA and BG to that of the otic capsule were 0.57 ± 0.11 (R1) and 0.59 ± 0.14 (R2); 0.43 ± 0.11 (R1) and 0.43 ± 0.08 (R2), respectively. Density increased significantly by 399 ± 261 Hounsfield units (HU) (p = 0.008) and decreased by 464 ± 161 HU (p < 0.001) for BHA vs. BG. Resorption rates were 24.1 ± 21.0% and 66.7 ± 15.1% (p = 0.076), respectively. No significant difference in clinical tolerance was observed.

CONCLUSION

Post-operative CT scan of mastoid obliteration seems reliable in assessment of biomaterial graft's mid-term feasibility and stability: BHA seems to provide a more optimal osseointegration versus BG with no significant differences in graft resorption and clinical tolerance.

A randomized trial of topical mitomycin-C in the immediate post-operative period for the short and long-term prevention of granulation tissue in mastoid cavities

BACKGROUND

Granulation tissue is a primary source of otorrhea in the ear, particularly after surgery, and may develop complications in patients. Hence, discovering an efficient treatment is crucial for this disorder.

PURPOSE

This study aimed to evaluate the mitomycin drops efficacy for germination prevention during the recovery process after mastoidectomy. Our purpose was to introduce novel treatment options in some conditions in which we could not reconstitute the cavity to prevent the possible germination.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This clinical trial was performed on 52 patients undergoing mastoidectomy. Patients were randomly divided into two groups (26 patients in the mitomycin group and 26 patients in the placebo group). After drug administration, the granulation tissue and complications were recorded. All statistical analysis was performed using SPSS version 21.

RESULTS

The results of our study showed that mitomycin administration in patients undergoing mastoidectomy significantly reduced the formation of the granulation tissue in the first and third months after surgery (P < 0.05), which is associated with increased patient satisfaction (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

The germ formation after mastoidectomy is so common. Since mitomycin administration decreased the incidence of germ formation, it can be proposed as a suggestive treatment in all patients to increase surgical quality and decrease complications include granulation formation.

Materials used for mastoid obliteration and its complications: a systematic review

OBJECTIVE

The objectives of this review are to identify the types of materials with their associated complications and respective considerations when used to obliterate the mastoid cavity.

METHODS

A systematic search was performed across PubMed, Embase, Medline and Cochrane databases from January 2009 to January 2020 for randomized controlled trials and observational studies of patients that underwent mastoid obliteration. Studies that fulfilled the inclusion criteria were screened and scored according to the MINORS and relevance scores to determine final inclusion. Types of complications were grouped into minor and major complications based on the Clavien-Dindo classification.

RESULTS

Two thousand five hundred and seventy-eight ears were evaluated. There were a total of 165 (7.9%) minor and 142 (6.8%) major complications in the autologous group. Overall complication rate is 14.8%. The major complications were largely recurrent and residual disease requiring revision surgery. There were 10 (18.5%) minor complications and three (5.6%) major complications in the allogenic group. The cumulative complications risk is 24%. For the synthetic group, there were 39 (8.0%) minor and 34 (7.6%) major complications. The cumulative complication rate is 16.6%.

CONCLUSION

Current evidence on materials for mastoid obliteration has been evolving. Each material has its strengths and limitations. The trend over the last decade favours the use of autologous materials. The principle of using a material remains being cautious of not reimplanting skin that can lead to the development of a cholesteatoma. The choice of materials is dependent on patient factors as well as the surgeons' preference and experience.

Long-term follow-up of applying autologous bone grafts for reconstructing tympanomastoid defects in functional cholesteatoma surgery

Objectives

This study investigated the long-term surgical outcomes of functional cholesteatoma surgery with canal wall reconstruction using autologous bone grafts as the primary material in patients with acquired cholesteatoma.

Subjects and Methods

Medical charts were retrospectively reviewed for all patients admitted to one institution for surgical intervention between 2010 and 2018. We analyzed 66 patients (66 ears) who underwent functional tympanomastoidectomy involving the use of autologous bone grafts for canal wall defect reconstruction. Surgical outcomes were evaluated by comparing preoperative audiometric results with follow-up data (at least 36 months after surgery). Logistic regression analyses were performed to determine prognostic factors related to long-term hearing success. These factors included classification and stage of cholesteatoma, stapes condition, ossicular chain damage, active infection of the middle ear, state of the contralateral ear, preoperative hearing thresholds, gender, and age.

Results

The mean follow-up period was 49.2 months. The recidivism rate was 6% (four of 66 ears). The pure-tone average significantly improved from 50.78 ± 19.98 to 40.81 ± 21.22 dB hearing level (HL; p < 0.001). Air–bone gaps significantly improved from 26.26 ± 10.53 to 17.58 ± 8.21 dB HL (p < 0.001). In multivariate logistic regression analysis, early-stage disease (p = 0.021) and pars flaccida cholesteatoma (p = 0.036) exhibited statistically significant correlations with successful hearing preservation.

Conclusion

Functional cholesteatoma surgery with autologous bone grafts reconstruction is an effective approach to significantly improve hearing with low recidivism rates. Localized disease and pars flaccida cholesteatoma were two independent predictors of successful hearing preservation.

[Advances in the surgical treatment of cholesteatoma of the middle ear]

Middle ear cholesteatoma, as a common ear disease, has been further understood in terms of its molecular mechanism, classification and staging, and it is generally believed that surgical treatment is the first choice, but there is no final conclusion on its surgical choice. Microscopic surgery includes complete or open radical mastoidectomy with or without reconstruction of the middle ear cavity, and their pros and cons have been debated for decades. In the past decade, a variety of surgical methods have been developed, including various improvements and combined operations that combine the advantages of traditional open radical mastoidectomy and complete mastoidectomy. On the other hand, the emergence of ear endoscopic surgery has opened up new surgical methods, as well as the use of laser and other new technologies to improve the surgical effect and prognosis, but also can not avoid their limitations and shortcomings. The purpose of this paper is to summarize the advantages and disadvantages of various surgical treatments for middle ear cholesteatoma in order to provide guidance and help for otologists in the treatment of middle ear cholesteatoma.

Bioactive glass in canal wall reconstruction tympanoplasty

The purpose of this Technical Note is to describe the surgical technique to transform canal wall down tympanoplasty into canal wall up tympanoplasty, that is, to rehabilitate a recess cavity by filling the mastoid and epitympanic cavities with synthetic tissue (bioactive glass) and recreating a normal-caliber external auditory canal. Mastoid cavity obliteration leads to a clinically significant improvement in health-related quality of life without increasing risk of recurrent or residual cholesteatoma, conditional upon technically impeccable surgery.

[Obliteration of the middle ear cavity in children: the current state of the problem and our first experience]

Chronic otitis media is one of the most common ear pathologies among children. This article provides a short overview of publications on surgical techniques. Currently, the most effective treatment is the surgical sanitation of the middle ear cavities. There are two fundamentally different approaches of operations in relation to the posterior wall of the external auditory canal - «open» and «closed» types. Both methods have their advantages and disadvantages, which are especially noticeable in pediatric revision otosurgery. Surgical obliteration of the sanitized middle ear cavities is an effective compromise option. However, the techniques of bone obliteration, which are actively applied among adults, are difficult if we discuss children ear. A way out of this situation may be the use of modern osteoplastic materials for filling large trepanation cavities. The article describes in detail the technique of revision sanitizing surgery on the middle ear using osteoplastic granules. Purpose of the study. The analysis of the first results of separate obliteration of paratympanic cavities in children using osteoplastic materials.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

In the period from May 2018 to November 2020, on the basis of the Federal State Autonomous Institution «National Medical Research Center of Children's Health» of the Ministry of Health of Russia, 28 children aged from 6 to 17-year-old with chronic otitis media and cholesteatoma were operated using osteoplastic obliteration, who had previously sanitizing operation on the middle ear. All children on admission to the hospital and 6-12 months after the operation underwent a complex examination. The condition of each patient was assessed using the OMO-22 quality of life questionnaire, to which the parents answered the questions twice - before and 1 year after surgery.

RESULTS

During the postoperative period none of the patients had clinical signs of recurrence of cholesteatoma, which was confirmed by CT scan. When assessing the quality of life of children using a questionnaire, the average score before the operation was 130.2±27.7, after the operation - 61.5±21.1. The indicator of the bone-air interval before surgery in patients averaged 29.8±9.7 dB, 1 year after surgery - 13.0±10.9 dB (p>0.05).

FINDINGS

The first experience of using osteoplastic materials for obliterating the paratympanic spaces in children has shown high efficiency, ease of use and safety.

Implantation of the Bonebridge BCI 602 after Mastoid Obliteration with S53P4 Bioactive Glass: A Safe Method of Treating Difficult Anatomical Conditions-Preliminary Results

This study presents the preliminary results of a new otosurgical method in patients after canal wall down (CWD) surgery; it involves the implantation of the Bonebridge BCI 602 implant after obliteration of the mastoid cavity with S53P4 bioactive glass. The study involved eight adult patients who had a history of chronic otitis media with cholesteatoma in one or both ears and who had had prior radical surgery. The mean follow-up period was 12 months, with routine follow-up visits according to the schedule. The analysis had two aspects: a surgical aspect in terms of healing, development of bacterial flora, the impact on the inner ear or labyrinth, recurrence of cholesteatoma, and possible postoperative complications (firstly, after obliteration of the mastoid cavity with S53P4 bioactive glass, then after implantation). The second was an audiological aspect which assessed audiometric results and the patient’s satisfaction based on questionnaires. During the follow-up period, we did not notice any serious postoperative complications. Studies demonstrated significantly improved hearing thresholds and speech recognition in quiet and noise using the Bonebridge BCI 602. Data collected after six months of use showed improved audiological thresholds and patient satisfaction. Based on the preliminary results, we believe that the proposed two-stage surgical method using bioactive glass S53P4 is a safe and effective way of implanting the Bonebridge BCI 602 in difficult anatomical conditions. This makes it possible to treat a larger group of patients with the device.

Mastoid obliteration with S53P4 bioactive glass after canal wall down mastoidectomy: Preliminary results

BACKGROUND

Bioactive glass (S53P4), abbreviated BG, currently seems to be the best material for reconstructing the posterior wall of the auditory canal and obliterating the postoperative cavity.

PURPOSE

The aim of the study was to report preliminary results of otosurgery involving obliteration of the mastoid cavity after canal wall down mastoidectomy.

METHODS

11 adult patients who had had a history of chronic otitis media with cholesteatoma in one or both ears and previous canal wall down mastoidectomy. The duration of the follow-up was 6 months, with routine visits after 7 days, then 1, 3, and 6 months after surgery. The patient's medical history, noting other diseases potentially affecting the healing process, was analyzed. Healing, audiometric results, reduction of the volume of the cavity after surgery, and reduction of bacterial flora growth were assessed.

RESULTS

There was not worsening in the audiological evaluation. Healing period was uneventful. There was a reduction in volume of the postoperative cavity, no development of pathological flora, and no recurrence of cholesteatoma.

CONCLUSION

Obliteration of the mastoid process with S53P4 bioactive glass is a safe and effective method of treatment. Such a procedure should be considered as a treatment for patients after canal wall down surgery (CWD).

The suitability of scanning electron microscopy in the evaluation of bone structure surfaces and selection of alloplastic materials for facial skeletal reconstruction

INTRODUCTION

Functional and aesthetic problems can arise even from small losses created in the facial skeleton. Injuries and oncological surgeries are the most frequent causes of these losses within the facial skeleton. Advances in surgical interventions have allowed for ever-increasing degrees of resections, increasing oncological radicality as well as treatment effectiveness, providing the patient with the chance for a longer life. However, this subsequently requires the use of even more advanced reconstruction techniques in order to restore quality of life and comfort to the patient, as well as enable their return to professional and social activities. The necessity of reconstructive surgery applies not only to patients with cancer, but also to patients with impaired or failing sensory and organ function as a result of inflammatory conditions, injuries, or non-oncological surgeries. There are many available reconstruction procedures, which depend on the location of the loss, the type of tissue lost, the degree of loss and patient-dependent factors. Materials used in reconstruction surgeries may include the patients' tissues when available, and artificial reconstruction materials otherwise.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The analysis involved fragments of bone tissue removed during surgery. Due to the nature of the medical procedure and the inability to replant the tissue, it was regarded as medical waste. The preparations used were observed under an optical microscope and an electron scanning microscope, and a chemical analysis was performed. The chemical composition of samples was analysed using a low vacuum detector (LVD) at an accelerating voltage of 15 kV and 10 kV and at a spot size of 4 and 3.5. The observations were performed in a secondary electron (SE) detection system.

RESULTS

Observation of parameters under an optical microscope and of images obtained using an electron scanning microscope showed the presence of typical, compact bone tissue with varied surface shapes in each case (various degrees of unevenness and porosity). Chemical composition analysis confirmed the presence of compounds from the CaO-P2O5-H20 system. The Ca/P (calcium/phosphorus) ratio obtained from the chemical analysis varied from 1.33 to 2.1, and indicated a varied morphology of calcium phosphates forming the bone structures of the facial skeleton.

CONCLUSIONS

1. Calcium phosphates are characterised by excellent biocompatibility because of their chemical affinity to bone, and are ideal for the reconstruction of bone losses within the facial skeleton. 2. Biodegradable polymers have the highest functional potential among several groups of biomaterials used in tissue engineering because of their ability to be tailored individually, in addition to their high biocompatibility.

Endoscopic Management of Primary Acquired Cholesteatoma

Endoscopic ear surgery is increasingly accepted as a primary modality for cholesteatoma surgery. A major advantage is the enhanced visualization of the middle ear in traditionally poorly accessible locations by the microscope. We discuss novel techniques for selective mastoid obliteration when a canal wall down mastoidectomy is necessary. Postoperatively, indications for non-echo planar diffusion-weighted imaging MRI versus second-look surgery are discussed. Finally, outcome data for endoscopic versus microscopic ear surgery are reviewed, which show equivalent outcomes regarding residual and recurrent disease, similar rates of complications, decreased pain, and shorter healing time.