Molecular and clinical studies of Dent's disease in Japan: biochemical examination and renal ultrasonography do not predict carrier state

Proteinuria in Dent disease: a review of the literature

BACKGROUND

Dent disease is a rare X-linked recessive proximal tubulopathy caused by mutations in CLCN5 (Dent-1) or OCRL (Dent-2). As a rule, total protein excretion (TPE) is low in tubular proteinuria compared with glomerular disease. Several authors have reported nephrotic-range proteinuria (NP) and glomerulosclerosis in Dent disease. Therefore, we aimed to analyze protein excretion in patients with documented CLCN5 or OCRL mutations in a systematic literature review.

DESIGN

PubMed and Embase were searched for cases with documented CLCN5 or OCRL mutations and (semi-)quantitative data on protein excretion. The most reliable data (i.e., TPE > protein-creatinine ratio > Albustix) was used for NP classification.

RESULTS

Data were available on 148 patients from 47 reports: 126 had a CLCN5 and 22 an OCRLmutation. TPE was not significantly different between both forms (p = 0.11). Fifty-five of 126 (43.7 %) Dent-1 vs 13/22 (59.1 %) Dent-2 patients met the definition of NP (p = 0.25). Serum albumin was normal in all reported cases (24/148). Glomerulosclerosis was noted in 20/32 kidney biopsies and was strongly related to tubulointerstitial fibrosis, but not to kidney function or proteinuria.

CONCLUSION

More than half of the patients with both forms of Dent disease have NP, and the presence of low molecular weight proteinuria in a patient with NP in the absence of edema and hypoalbuminemia should prompt genetic testing. Even with normal renal function, glomerulosclerosis and tubulointerstitial fibrosis are present in Dent disease. The role of proteinuria in the course of the disease needs to be examined further in longitudinal studies.

Dent-2 disease: a mild variant of Lowe syndrome

OBJECTIVE

To compare the renal and extra-renal phenotypes of patients classified as having Dent disease, Dent-2 disease, or Lowe syndrome.

STUDY DESIGN

Chart review of data from 93 patients with identified voltage-gated chloride channel and chloride/proton antiporter 5 gene and oculo-cerebro-renal syndrome of Lowe gene mutations observed by the authors, complemented with published data.

RESULTS

There was a wide overlap of renal symptoms. Nephrocalcinosis was more prevalent in Dent-1 disease, and renal tubular acidosis, aminoaciduria, and renal failure was more prevalent in patients with Lowe syndrome. Patients with Lowe syndrome were shorter than patients with Dent-1 disease, and patients with Dent-2 disease showed an intermediate phenotype. Three patients with Dent-2 disease had mild peripheral cataract, and 9 patients were noted to have some degree of mental retardation.

CONCLUSION

There is a phenotypic continuum within patients with Dent-2 disease and Lowe syndrome, suggesting that there are individual differences in the ability to compensate for loss of oculo-cerebro-renal syndrome of Lowe gene function.

Hypercalciuria in patients with CLCN5 mutations

Hypercalciuria is regarded as a characteristic symptom of Dent disease, an X-linked recessive tubulopathy characterized by low molecular weight (LMW) proteinuria, nephrocalcinosis/nephrolithiasis, and progressive renal failure due to mutations in the CLCN5 gene. As the presence of hypercalciuria may affect the decision to consider a CLCN5 mutation in the differential diagnosis, the phenotypic spectrum and the relative frequency of hypercalciuria in patients with CLCN5 mutations was determined. We assessed renal calcium excretion in 34 male patients with proven CLCN5 mutations, who had been referred because of LMW proteinuria and at least one additional symptom of Dent disease. Hypercalciuria was defined as renal calcium excretion exceeding 0.1 mmol/kg per day. Data obtained were compared with all series of CLCN5-positive patients identified by a systematic literature survey. In 7 of our 19 families, at least 1 affected male had normal calcium excretion. Hypercalciuria was observed in 22 of 31 patients tested (71%) compared to 85 of 90 (94.4%) in series from Europe and North America and 74.4% from Japan. LMW proteinuria was present in all CLCN5-positive patients; 25% of the patients in European and North American series, 45% of the Japanese, and 41% in the present series had only two of the four principal symptoms of Dent disease. Therefore, a CLCN5 mutation should be considered irrespective of the presence of hypercalciuria in a patient with LMW proteinuria and one additional symptom of Dent disease.