Comparative Studies of Bone Graft and Orthobiologics for Foot Ankle Arthrodesis: A Critical Review

Locally obtained autologous bone grafts are effective for achieving arthrodesis while managing foot and ankle charcot's neuroarthropathy: short to mid-term results from a specialized north African foot and ankle surgery unit

PURPOSE

We aimed to report the union rate after only utilizing a locally obtained autologous bone graft while correcting the deformity and performing joint arthrodesis in patients with foot and ankle Charcot neuropathy (CN) and to report on the radiographic, functional, complications incidence outcomes at a minimum of two years of follow up.

METHODS

We included 24 patients having a mean age of 55.4 ± 10.1 years diagnosed with CN of the foot, ankle, or both. Seven (29.2%) cases were classified as Brodsky type 1, 11 (45.8%) as type 3 A, and six (25%) were type 4. Hindfoot and Midfoot bi-columnar arthrodesis was performed in 70.8% and 29.2% of the patients, respectively. Eight (33.3%) cases had preoperative ulcers. Functional outcomes were evaluated using a modified AOFAS score. Arthrodesis site union was assessed clinically and radiographically. All patients were available for a mean follow up of 35.7 ± 9.5 (24-54) months.

RESULTS

Arthrodesis site union was achieved in 23 (95.8%) cases after a mean of 4 ± 1.7 (2-7.5) months. The mean modified AOFAS score was 72.4 ± 10.41 (46-83) points; 79.2% achieved excellent and good scores. Ulcers healed in 87.5% of the patients. Twenty-two (91.7%) patients were satisfied with their functional results. Infection incidence was 12.5%, and no patients required revision or amputation.

CONCLUSION

Foot and ankle Charcot neuroarthropathy deformity correction by arthrodesis of the affected joint as a salvage management option resulted in acceptable clinical and radiological outcomes. To enhance the local environment for arthrodesis consolidation, locally obtained autografts led to higher union rates and avoided the drawbacks of using other graft types.