Personal DNA Testing Increases Pharmacy Students' Confidence and Competence in Pharmacogenomics

Pharmacogenomics education strategies in the United States pharmacy school curricula

BACKGROUND

Clinical pharmacogenomics is an expanding area in healthcare that relies heavily on pharmacists for advocacy and implementation. To support pharmacists' significant roles in clinical pharmacogenomics, pharmacy schools and colleges in the United States (US) have strived to incorporate pharmacogenomics education into their curricula, and various teaching strategies have been employed in recent years to meet pharmacogenomics educational outcomes. The six major strategies reported in the literature are described and compared in this review, which culminates in a proposed longitudinal curriculum design for pharmacogenomics education.

METHODS

Publications focused on pharmacogenomics education to pharmacy students within the US in the past decade were evaluated and summarized.

RESULTS

The major education strategies that have been studied are didactic lecture, personal genotyping or personal genomic testing, simulation laboratory activity, interprofessional education, practice-based activity such as clinical rotation, and combinational courses. Strengths and limitations of each teaching strategy are summarized and discussed.

IMPLICATIONS

Based upon each education strategy's strengths and weaknesses, the authors propose a longitudinal curriculum design to ensure that pharmacogenomics is taught multiple times to pharmacy students with diverse formats and teaching objectives conducive to long-term knowledge retention and practice readiness. Through this longitudinal curriculum design, pharmacy graduates will be well equipped to lead clinical pharmacogenomics in practice.

A Scoping Review of Pharmacogenomic Educational Interventions to Improve Knowledge and Confidence

OBJECTIVES

Poor knowledge and confidence in pharmacogenomics are key barriers to implementation. Education of future health care professionals is required to enhance appropriate use of pharmacogenomics; however, the optimal education approach is unclear. This systematic scoping review evaluates pharmacogenomic educational interventions to improve knowledge and confidence.

FINDINGS

A total of 24 studies were included. Most (90%) studies delivered pharmacogenomic education to pharmacy students and consisted of didactic lectures and workshops with case studies. To supplement case studies, self or class aggregated (52%, 12 of 23), mock (43%, 10 of 23) or faculty member provided (4%, 1 of 23) pharmacogenomic data were used in the case scenarios. All studies used quantitative methods, including student assessments and scaled surveys to assess the impact of the educational intervention on knowledge and/or confidence in pharmacogenomics. On average, the educational interventions improved knowledge acquisition by 21%, confidence in pharmacogenomic data interpretation by 37%, confidence in communication of pharmacogenomic information to patients by 41% and to health care professionals by 44%. Improvement in communication with other health care professionals was greater in students involved in interprofessional learning compared to self-pharmacogenomic testing.

SUMMARY

The measures used to determine the effect of educational interventions on student knowledge and confidence varied. Innovative pedagogy, specifically interactive case-based learning and simulation such as interprofessional learning, enhances the knowledge and confidence of students in pharmacogenomics. Course-embedded self-pharmacogenomic testing may offer a supplementary, interactive component to case-based learning by using real-life reports as the foundation of knowledge and confidence acquisition.

Effectiveness of pharmacogenomics educational interventions on healthcare professionals and health professions students: A systematic review

BACKGROUND

The field of pharmacogenomics is rapidly advancing, but its adoption and implementation remain slow and lacking. Lack of pharmacogenomics knowledge among healthcare professionals is the most frequently cited barrier to adopting and implementing pharmacogenomics in clinical settings.

OBJECTIVES

This study aimed to critically evaluate and determine the effectiveness of educational interventions in improving pharmacogenomics knowledge and practice.

METHODS

Four electronic databases were searched: MEDLINE, EMBASE, CENTRAL, and PsycINFO. Studies on pharmacogenomics educational interventions for health care professionals and students with pre- and post-intervention assessments and results were included. No restrictions were placed on time, language, or educational contexts. The educational outcomes measured include both objective and subjective outcomes. The pharmacogenomics competency domains used to judge educational interventions are based on the competency domains listed by the American Association of Colleges of Pharmacies (AACP). The National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute of the National Institutes of Health was used for the quality assessment of pre-post studies with no control group and the controlled intervention studies. No meta-analysis was conducted; the data were synthesized qualitatively. The systematic review was reported in accordance with the PRISMA statement.

RESULTS

Fifty studies were included in this review. All included studies integrated the AACP pharmacogenomics competency domains into their educational interventions. Most of the studies had educational interventions that integrated clinical cases (n = 44; 88%). Knowledge was the most frequently evaluated outcome (n = 34; 68%) and demonstrated significant improvement after the educational intervention that integrated AACP pharmacogenomics competency domains and employed active learning with clinical case inclusion.

CONCLUSION

This review provided evidence of the effectiveness of educational interventions in improving pharmacogenomics knowledge and practice. Incorporating pharmacogenomics competency domains into education and training, with patient cases for healthcare professionals and students, dramatically improved their pharmacogenomics knowledge, attitudes, and confidence in practice.

The Critical Role of Pharmacists in the Clinical Delivery of Pharmacogenetics in the U.S

Since the rebirth of pharmacogenomics (PGx) in the 1990s and 2000s, with new discoveries of genetic variation underlying adverse drug response and new analytical technologies such as sequencing and microarrays, there has been much interest in the clinical application of PGx testing. The early involvement of pharmacists in clinical studies and the establishment of organizations to support the dissemination of information about PGx variants have naturally resulted in leaders in clinical implementation. This paper presents an overview of the evolving role of pharmacists, and discusses potential challenges and future paths, primarily focused in the U.S. Pharmacists have positioned themselves as leaders in clinical PGx testing, and will prepare the next generation to utilize PGx testing in their scope of practice.

Knowledge and attitudes of medical and pharmacy students about pharmacogenomics: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Pharmacogenomics (PGx) is rapidly growing branch of molecular genetics with high potentials to influence therapeutics. This review evaluates knowledge and attitudes of medical and pharmacy students about PGx. A literature search was conducted in electronic databases and studies were selected by following precise eligibility criteria. After quality assessment, studies were reviewed systematically, and meta-analyses of proportions were performed to estimate response rates of students. Fifteen studies (5509 students; 69% [95% confidence interval (CI): 60%, 77%] females) were included. Among students, 28% [95%CI: 12, 46] had adequate PGx knowledge; 65% [95%CI: 55, 75] were willing to have PGx test for their own risk assessment; 78% [95%CI: 71, 84] had intention to incorporate PGx in future practice; and 32% [95%CI: 21, 43] were satisfied with current PGx component of curriculum. Age, advanced year of educational program, and more time spent in PGx education were positively associated with PGx knowledge and positive attitudes.

Pharmacogenomics elective focused on advanced lab techniques, game-based learning, and business plan development

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Many medications contain labeling information related to pharmacogenomics. Effective education in this area is critical to ensure that future healthcare professionals are equipped with the skills needed to optimize patient therapy based on genetic testing results. This study focused on a novel elective course designed to educate students in pharmacogenomics.

EDUCATIONAL ACTIVITY AND SETTING

We developed a one credit hour pharmacogenomics elective course divided into three main content areas. The first section incorporated traditional lecture to review and cover new content not otherwise covered in the curriculum. The second section applied foundational content from the first session through an educational review game and simulated business plan. The third section of the course provided students an overview of laboratory techniques and sample collection procedures. To evaluate the effectiveness of these activities, students provided feedback through course evaluations and completed pre- and posttests on basic pharmacogenomics content.

FINDINGS

Overall, the course improved knowledge among students, and students provided positive feedback. Students averaged 9% higher on the posttest compared to the pretest (P = .03). Course evaluations trended positive with ratings close to "strongly agree." The most frequent comments stated an appreciation for the interactive components of the course and recommended increasing the elective to two credit hours.

SUMMARY

Through incorporation of novel lab techniques, game-based learning, and an innovative business plan process, the course increased student knowledge and received positive feedback. These new techniques could serve as a model for other pharmacogenomics training programs.

Development and Validation of the Minnesota Assessment of Pharmacogenomic Literacy (MAPL)

Ensuring that patients have an adequate understanding of pharmacogenomic (PGx) test results is a critical component of implementing precision medicine into clinical care. However, no PGx-specific validated literacy assessment has yet been developed. To address this need, we developed and validated the Minnesota Assessment of Pharmacogenomic Literacy (MAPLTM). Foundational work included a scoping review of patient and general public attitudes and experiences with pharmacogenomic testing, three focus groups, readability assessments, and review by experts and members of the general public. This resulted in a 15-item assessment designed to assess knowledge in four domains: underlying concepts, limitations, benefits, and privacy. For validation, 646 participants completed the MAPL as a part of a larger survey about pharmacogenomic research and statewide PGx implementation. Two items were deemed to be “too easy” and dropped. The remaining 13 items were retained in the final MAPL with good internal reliability (Cronbach’s alpha = 0.75). Confirmatory factor analysis validated the four-domain construct of MAPL and suggested good model performance and high internal validity. The estimated coefficient loadings across 13 questions on the corresponding domains are all positive and statistically significant (p < 0.05). The MAPL covers multiple knowledge domains of specific relevance to PGx and is a useful tool for clinical and research settings where quantitative assessment of PGx literacy is of value.

Pharmacy Student Perceptions of a Virtual Pharmacogenomics Activity

Pharmacogenomics (PGx) utilizes a patient’s genome to guide drug treatment and dosing. The Accreditation Council for Pharmacy Education (ACPE) included PGx as a critical content area. Pharmacists are increasingly involved in providing this service, which necessitates training. Second-year pharmacy students at Samford University McWhorter School of Pharmacy have didactic training in the principles of PGx and managing drug therapy using PGx data. A clinical skills lab activity was developed to reinforce these principles and allow students to navigate resources to develop and communicate recommendations for drug therapy. The activity was initially planned as synchronous, but transitioned to asynchronous when students began remote learning in the spring of 2020 due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The investigators sought students’ perceptions of the PGx lab activity and the delivery of its content via a virtual format. This study gathered data from an anonymous, voluntary student survey through Samford University’s course management system, Canvas, in the spring of 2020 soon after completion of the virtual PGx learning activity. The investigators’ goal is to obtain the information and insights obtained from the students who participated in the PGx lab activity to provide guidance for the improvement of their PGx lab activity and for other schools of pharmacy to deliver a PGx lab activities using nontraditional teaching methodologies.

Development of the pharmacogenomics and genomics literacy framework for pharmacists

BACKGROUND

Pharmacists play a unique role in integrating genomic medicine and pharmacogenomics into the clinical practice and to translate pharmacogenomics from bench to bedside. However, the literature suggests that the knowledge gap in pharmacogenomics is a major challenge; therefore, developing pharmacists' skills and literacy to achieve this anticipated role is highly important. We aim to conceptualize a personalized literacy framework for the adoption of genomic medicine and pharmacogenomics by pharmacists in the United Arab Emirates with possible regional and global relevance.

RESULTS

A qualitative approach using focus groups was used to design and to guide the development of a pharmacogenomics literacy framework. The Health Literacy Skills framework was used as a guide to conceptualize the pharmacogenomics literacy for pharmacists. The framework included six major components with specific suggested factors to improve pharmacists' pharmacogenomics literacy. Major components include individual inputs, demand, skills, knowledge, attitude and sociocultural factors.

CONCLUSION

This framework confirms a holistic bottom-up approach toward the implementation of pharmacogenomics. Personalized medicine entails personalized efforts and frameworks. Similar framework can be created for other healthcare providers, patients and stakeholders.