Reproductive and treatment outcomes in chronic intervillositis of unknown etiology: A systematic review and meta-analysis

Chronic Intervillositis of Unknown Etiology (CIUE) is a rare idiopathic inflammatory disorder of the placenta. The evidence suggests an increased risk for poor obstetrical outcomes and a risk of recurrence as high as 100 %. This meta-analysis examined CIUE prevalence, recurrence, association with autoimmune disorders, reproductive outcomes, pregnancy complications, and the benefits of medical treatments. A systematic review, following PRISMA guidelines, involved a thorough search across multiple databases including Medline, Embase, Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature (CINAHL), Evidence Based Medical Reviews, and Scopus. Out of 590 initially identified studies, 19 studies were included for both qualitative synthesis and meta-analysis after full-text review. Risk of bias was assessed using appropriate tools: The Risk Of Bias In Non-randomized Studies of Interventions tool was applied to twelve studies, while the Joanna Briggs Institute case series critical appraisal tool was used for seven studies. Our findings confirm that CIUE is a rare condition (0.7 %). CIUE is associated with decreased live birth rates (53 %), increased recurrent pregnancy loss (23 %), fetal loss beyond 22 weeks gestation (25 %), a higher prevalence of autoimmune diseases (14 %), and a recurrence rate of 30 % in subsequent pregnancies. Moreover, individuals with CIUE had higher rates of pregnancy complications, including gestational hypertension (19 %), intrauterine growth restriction (45 %), and preterm births (43 %). No significant improvement in live birth rate was observed among treated CIUE patients; however, caution is warranted when interpreting these findings due to the limited sample size. Future research in CIUE is crucial given its rarity and complexity.

Characterizing Histopathologic Features in Pregnancies With Chronic Histiocytic Intervillositis Using Computerized Image Analysis

CONTEXT.—

Chronic histiocytic intervillositis (CHI) is a rare condition characterized by maternal immune cell infiltration into the human placenta. CHI is strongly associated with fetal growth restriction, miscarriage, and stillbirth, and knowledge of its etiology, and consequently effective treatment, is limited. Currently, diagnosis is largely subjective and varies between centers, making comparison between studies challenging.

OBJECTIVE.—

To objectively quantify and interrelate inflammatory cells and fibrin in placentas with CHI compared with controls and determine how pathology may be altered in subsequent pregnancies following diagnosis. Macrophage phenotype was also investigated in untreated cases of CHI.

DESIGN.—

Computerized analysis was applied to immunohistochemically stained untreated (index) cases of CHI, subsequent pregnancies, and controls. Index placentas were additionally stained by immunofluorescence for M1 (CD80 and CD86) and M2 macrophage markers (CD163 and CD206).

RESULTS.—

Quantification revealed a median 32-fold increase in macrophage infiltration in index cases versus controls, with CHI recurring in 2 of 11 (18.2%) subsequent pregnancies. A total of 4 of 14 placentas (28.6%) with a diagnosis of CHI did not exhibit infiltration above controls. Macrophages in index pregnancies strongly expressed CD163. There was no significant difference in fibrin deposition between index cases and controls, although subsequent pregnancies displayed a 2-fold decrease compared with index pregnancies. CD3+ T cells were significantly elevated in index pregnancies; however, they returned to normal levels in subsequent pregnancies.

CONCLUSIONS.—

In CHI, intervillous macrophages expressed CD163, possibly representing an attempt to resolve inflammation. Computerized analysis of inflammation in CHI may be useful in determining how treatment affects recurrence, and alongside pathologist expertise in grading lesion severity.

Evaluation of Histopathologic Alterations in First-trimester COVID-19-positive Pregnancies Ending in Abortion

This study aims to evaluate histopathologic alterations and the presence of chronic histiocytic intervillositis in first-trimester coronavirus-2019 (COVID-19)-positive pregnancies ending in abortion, compared with those at a similar gestational week and undergoing curettage before the pandemic. This retrospective case-control study consisted of 9 patients who were infected with COVID-19 and undergoing curettage for abortion between April 2020 and January 2021. The control group consisted of 34 patients with a similar gestational age who underwent curettage for abortion before August 2019. Demographic and clinical data were recorded. A histopathologic examination of the placental specimens was performed. The CD68 immunostaining was performed to detect intravillous and intervillous histiocytes. At the time of diagnosis of COVID 19, 7 patients (77.8%) of COVID-19-positive women had symptoms with the most common symptoms of fatigue (66.7%) and cough (55.6%). Histopathologic examination revealed that the rate of intravillous and intervillous calcification, intervillous fibrinoid deposition, hydropic villi and acute lymphocytic villitis, and fetal and maternal thrombi was significantly higher in the COVID-19-positive patients than the control group ( P =0.049, 0.002, 0.049, 0.014, 0.008, 0.001, and 0.014, respectively). There was a significant difference in the CD68 staining of the intravillous and intervillous histiocytes between the groups ( P =0.001). This study showed a significant increase in the intervillous fibrinoid deposition, thrombi formation in the maternal and fetal vascular structures, acute lymphocytic villitis, and an increase of CD68 + stained histiocytes in the intravillous and intervillous spaces in women infected with COVID-19 during the first trimester of pregnancy.

Chronic Inflammatory Placental Disorders Associated With Recurrent Adverse Pregnancy Outcome

Chronic inflammatory placental disorders are a group of rare but devastating gestational syndromes associated with adverse pregnancy outcome. This review focuses on three related conditions: villitis of unknown etiology (VUE), chronic histiocytic intervillositis (CHI) and massive perivillous fibrin deposition (MPFD). The hallmark of these disorders is infiltration of the placental architecture by maternal immune cells and disruption of the intervillous space, where gas exchange between the mother and fetus occurs. Currently, they can only be detected through histopathological examination of the placenta after a pregnancy has ended. All three are associated with a significant risk of recurrence in subsequent pregnancies. Villitis of unknown etiology is characterised by a destructive infiltrate of maternal CD8+ T lymphocytes invading into the chorionic villi, combined with activation of fetal villous macrophages. The diagnosis can only be made when an infectious aetiology has been excluded. VUE becomes more common as pregnancy progresses and is frequently seen with normal pregnancy outcome. However, severe early-onset villitis is usually associated with fetal growth restriction and recurrent pregnancy loss. Chronic histiocytic intervillositis is characterised by excessive accumulation of maternal CD68+ histiocytes in the intervillous space. It is associated with a wide spectrum of adverse pregnancy outcomes including high rates of first-trimester miscarriage, severe fetal growth restriction and late intrauterine fetal death. Intervillous histiocytes can also accumulate due to infection, including SARS-CoV-2, although this infection-induced intervillositis does not appear to recur. As with VUE, the diagnosis of CHI requires exclusion of an infectious cause. Women with recurrent CHI and their families are predisposed to autoimmune diseases, suggesting CHI may have an alloimmune pathology. This observation has driven attempts to prevent CHI with a wide range of maternal immunosuppression. Massive perivillous fibrin deposition is diagnosed when >25% of the intervillous space is occupied by fibrin, and is associated with fetal growth restriction and late intrauterine fetal death. Although not an inflammatory disorder per se, MPFD is frequently seen in association with both VUE and CHI. This review summarises current understanding of the prevalence, diagnostic features, clinical consequences, immune pathology and potential prophylaxis against recurrence in these three chronic inflammatory placental syndromes.

Inflammatory lesions in placental pathology

Placental inflammatory lesions are important findings that lead fetal and neonatal morbidity and mortality, and can be divided into two broad subcategories, acute inflammation caused by microorganisms and chronic inflammation caused by host immune responses. Recently, a diagnostic framework for these lesions has been established, and uniform diagnostic criteria have been recommended by the Amsterdam International Consensus Group. Chorioamnionitis is representative of the acute inflammatory lesion, and is the most frequent pathological diagnosis in placental pathology. The hallmark of chorioamnionitis is neutrophil infiltration in the membrane/chorioamnionic plate and fetal vessels. The inflammatory response can be both maternal (inflammation in the membrane or chorioamnionic plate) and fetal (inflammation in the fetal vessels-umbilical vessels or chorionic vessel). Recent studies have shown that the fetal inflammatory response is associated with neonatal mortality and morbidity. Furthermore, chronic inflammatory lesions, such as villitis of unknown etiology and chronic histiocytic intervillositis, are also important. Although their etiology remains unknown, the maternal immune response against paternal antigens has been considered a possible factor. These inflammatory lesions are associated with fetal demise and fetal growth restriction. Inflammatory lesions in the placenta are useful for understanding intrauterine conditions, guiding treatment, and predicting complications.

Chronic histiocytic intervillositis (CHI): an under-recognised condition with potential serious sequelae in pregnancy

Chronic histiocytic intervillositis (CHI) is a rare placental disorder associated with adverse pregnancy outcomes and high recurrence rates in subsequent pregnancies. We discuss a case of CHI diagnosed incidentally in a young primigravida who presented with a first trimester miscarriage. CHI is usually diagnosed after an adverse pregnancy outcome by microscopic placental histopathology. Currently, CHI is a poorly understood condition by clinicians in many aspects, including its aetiology and subsequent management of patients in their future pregnancies. This is due to the lack of awareness and underdiagnosis of CHI among general pathologists and obstetricians. The authors would like to highlight this interesting case to encourage more research on CHI to understand its pathophysiology and optimal management better. Clinicians should also focus on providing holistic care to this group of patients by considering the impact of adverse pregnancy outcomes on their emotional well-being.

Chronic Intervillositis of Unknown Etiology: Development of a Grading and Scoring System That Is Strongly Associated With Poor Perinatal Outcomes

Chronic intervillositis of unknown etiology (CIUE) is a rare placental disease characterized by intervillous infiltration of maternal macrophages and associated with poor pregnancy outcomes and a high risk of recurrence in subsequent pregnancies. Its pathophysiology remains unclear and prognostic factors have not yet been established. In addition, clear relationships between the histologic extent of lesions and the severity of perinatal outcomes have not been demonstrated. Our objectives were to validate a CIUE classification system based on the gradation of macrophagic infiltration of the intervillous space, and to attempt to correlate these results with perinatal outcomes. For this multicenter retrospective study, 3 pathologists reviewed all cases diagnosed with "intervillositis" between 1997 and 2018. Confirmed CIUE cases were semiquantitatively graded based on the percentage of macrophagic infiltrate in the intervillous space: grade 1 (5% to 10%), grade 2 (10% to 50%), and grade 3 (>50%). Multiple pregnancies and pregnancies with medical follow-up completed outside of the study centers were excluded. In total, 122 cases of CIUE in 102 patients were included in the study. Microscopic classification based on one criterion was easy to perform, and interobserver correlation was good. Grade 3 infiltration was strongly associated with poor perinatal outcomes and fetal growth restriction (P<0.0001). After delivery, only 16.1% of newborns from the grade 3 CIUE group were alive, compared with 59% from the grade 2 and 86.5% from the grade 1 group (P=0.0002). Recurrence risk was associated with CIUE gradation of the index case (P=0.004), with 95% of recurrent CIUE cases being from patients with grades 2 and 3 CIUE. In this study, conducted with the largest CIUE cohort to date, a classification based only on the degree of macrophagic infiltration of the intervillous space was validated, and this classification was shown to be strongly associated with poor perinatal outcomes and risk of recurrence.

CD39 downregulation in chronic intervillositis of unknown etiology

Chronic intervillositis of unknown etiology (CIUE) is a rare placental lesion associated with infiltration of mononuclear inflammatory cells into the intervillous space, poor perinatal outcomes (intrauterine fetal demise or fetal growth restriction), and high rates of recurrence. CD39 is the ectonucleotidase that protects tissues from inflammatory stress and cell injury, which is localized on the surface of villi in normal placentas; however, its expression and role in CIUE are unknown. The aims of this retrospective study were to determine the expression of CD39 in CIUE and its significance in pregnancy outcomes. We compared the number of CD68- and CD3-positive cells, CD39 expression, and complement 4d (C4d) and fibrin deposition in placental tissues from patients with CIUE (n = 22) and gestational age-matched controls (n = 20), and between CIUE pregnancies with poor and good outcomes. The numbers of CD68- or CD3-positive cells were significantly higher (P < 0.0001), whereas CD39 expression on the surface of villi and endothelial cells of the stem villi was significantly lower in the CIUE group than that in controls (45% vs. 95%, P < 0.0001 and 77% vs. 96%, P < 0.001, respectively). C4d and fibrin deposition were also significantly increased in CIUE compared with those of controls. Furthermore, CD39 downregulation and the number of CD68 cells were strongly associated with poor pregnancy outcomes (P < 0.01 and P < 0.05, respectively), but other histological parameters (CD3, C4d, and fibrin) did not show this association. Our study suggests that CD39 downregulation is a useful marker of CIUE and is associated with poor pregnancy outcomes in patients with CIUE.

Placental pathologic lesions with a significant recurrence risk - what not to miss!

Here, we review three important placental pathologies with significant clinical implications and recurrence risks. They are, in order of most to least frequently seen, villitis of unknown etiology, chronic histiocytic intervillositis, and massive perivillous fibrin deposition (also known as maternal floor infarction). These entities occur in both preterm and term gestations and are observed more frequently with maternal and obstetric disorders including prior pregnancy loss, hypertension/preeclampsia, and autoimmune disease. They are associated with, and probably the cause of, significant perinatal morbidity and mortality including intrauterine growth restriction, fetal and neonatal demise, and fetal/neonatal neurocompromise (seizures and cerebral palsy). All three entities have high recurrence risks, with recurrence rates ranging from 34 to 100%. The histologic features of villitis of unknown etiology, chronic histiocytic intervillositis, and massive perivillous fibrin deposition are described herein. We discuss the clinical associations and suggest the subsequent clinical and pathological evaluation. Hypotheses as to the biology of these lesions are reviewed.

Towards standardized criteria for diagnosing chronic intervillositis of unknown etiology: A systematic review

Chronic intervillositis of unknown etiology (CIUE) is a poorly understood, relatively rare condition characterized histologically by the intervillous infiltration of mononuclear cells in the placenta. Clinically, CIUE is associated with poor pregnancy outcome (e.g., impaired fetal growth, preterm birth, fetal death) and high risk of recurrence in subsequent pregnancies. Because CIUE is not defined consistently, it is essential to clearly define this condition. We therefore review the published definitions of CIUE. In addition, we provide an overview of the reviewed histopathological and maternal characteristics, obstetric features, and pregnancy outcomes. Medical publication databases were searched for articles published through February 2017. Eighteen studies were included in our systematic review. The sole inclusion criterion used in all studies was the presence of intervillous infiltrates. Overall, CIUE was characterized by adverse pregnancy outcome. Miscarriage occurred in 24% of cases, with approximately half of these miscarriages defined as late. Impaired growth was commonly observed, 32.4% of pregnancies reached term, and the live birth rate was 54.9%. The high recurrence rate (25.1%) of the intervillous infiltrates in subsequent pregnancies underscores the clinical relevance of CIUE, the need for increased awareness among pathologists and clinicians, and the need for further research. Criteria for the diagnosis of CIUE are proposed and a Delphi study could be used to resolve any controversy regarding these criteria. Future studies should be designed to characterize the full clinical spectrum of CIUE.

Significance of C4d Immunostaining in Placental Chronic Intervillositis

Deposition of the complement split product C4d is a phenomenon studied extensively as a marker for complement activation in antibody-mediated transplant rejection. C4d also is observed in placental disease processes including spontaneous abortion, infarct, and villitis of unknown origins. Massive chronic intervillositis is a rare placental abnormality associated with increased risk of growth restriction, fetal death, and recurrent fetal loss. In this study, we evaluated C4d immunostaining in placentas with accumulation of intervillous monocytes with and without villitis. Archived placentas from Kosair Children's Hospital (Louisville, KY) and Seattle Children's Hospital (Seattle, WA) were selected and divided into 4 groups, 16 cases of intervillositis with complicated pregnancy, 15 cases of uncomplicated intervillositis, 20 cases of complicated villitis, and 13 cases of uncomplicated villitis, all with varying degrees of monocytic cells in the intervillous space. Representative specimen blocks were immunohistochemically stained for C4d. The percentage of positive staining of the microvillous surface of the syncytiotrophoblast was scored by five pathologists, and the following consensus score was determined: 0  =  0% to 5%; 1  =  5% to 25%; 2  =  25% to 75%; and 3 ≥ 75%. C4d immunostain localized to the microvillous border of syncytiotrophoblast in many of the placentas. C4d staining was more strongly associated with intervillositis than with villitis (odds ratio: 6.3; confidence interval: 2.1-18.7; P  =  0.001).

Assessment of the number and function of macrophages in the placenta of gestational diabetes mellitus patients

In order to assess the number and function of macrophages in the placenta of pregnancy complicated with gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM) as well as those of normal pregnancies, placenta samples were collected from 15 GDM patients (GDM group) and 10 normal pregnant women (control group). The expression levels of macrophage markers (CD68/CD14) and inflammatory cytokines (IL-6/TNF-α) in placenta were detected using immunohistochemistry and PCR. The results showed that the number of CD68+ or CD14+ cells in the GMD group was remarkably higher than that in the control group (P<0.05), indicating that the number of macrophages in the GDM group was significantly greater than that in the control group. The mRNA expression levels of CD68+, IL-6 and TNF-α were higher in the GMD group than in the control group. In conclusion, more macrophages accumulate in placenta of pregnancy complicated with GDM, and the expression levels of pro-inflammation factors are also increased in GDM pregnancies, suggesting that macrophages and inflammatory mediators (IL-6 and TNF-α) may play an important role in GDM.

An immunological basis for chronic histiocytic intervillositis in recurrent fetal loss

PROBLEM

Chronic histiocytic intervillositis (CHIV) is a rare type of placental pathology that is associated with reproductive loss at all gestational ages. The aim of the study was to investigate the relationship between the severity of CHIV and the outcome of pregnancy and to compare the immune response between CHIV patients and controls to explore an immunological origin of CHIV.

METHOD OF STUDY

Microscopic slides were reviewed and scored according to a previously published grading system in 30 pregnancies of 22 CHIV patients. Partner-specific mixed lymphocyte reactions, cytotoxic T-lymphocyte precursor frequencies (CTLpf), and anti-HLA antibodies were determined in four patients and seven controls.

RESULTS

Higher CHIV scores are associated with worse pregnancy outcome. CHIV patients demonstrated a higher CTLpf against their partner compared to non-complicated pregnancies (P = 0.03). The CTLpf was extremely high in 75% of the patients. Antipaternal HLA antibodies were only present in 75% of the CHIV patients compared to none of the controls (P = 0.02).

CONCLUSION

CHIV scores seem to be associated with the severity of adverse pregnancy outcome. High antipaternal cellular (T-cell) and humoral (B-cell) response to partner-specific CTLpf and the presence of anti-HLA antibodies directed to the partner suggest an immunologic origin of CHIV.