Normothermic Regional Perfusion is an Emerging Cost-Effective Alternative in Donation After Circulatory Death (DCD) in Heart Transplantation

Neither Ethical nor Prudent: Why Not to Choose Normothermic Regional Perfusion

In transplant medicine, the use of normothermic regional perfusion (NRP) in donation after circulatory determination of death raises ethical difficulties. NRP is objectionable because it restores the donor's circulation, thus invalidating a death declaration based on the permanent cessation of circulation. NRP's defenders respond with arguments that are tortuous and factually inaccurate and depend on introducing extraneous concepts into the law. However, results comparable to NRP's-more and higher-quality organs and more efficient allocation-can be achieved by removing organs from deceased donors and using normothermic machine perfusion (NMP) to support the organs outside the body, without jeopardizing confidence in transplantation's legal and ethical foundations. Given the controversy that NRP generates and the convoluted justifications made for it, we recommend a prudential approach we call "ethical parsimony," which holds that, in the choice between competing means of achieving a result, the ethically simpler one is to be preferred. This approach makes clear that policy-makers should favor NMP over NRP.

Novel portable hypothermic machine perfusion preservation device enhances cardiac viability of donated human hearts

Introduction

Heart transplant remains the gold standard treatment for patients with advanced heart failure. However, the list of patients waiting for a heart transplant continues to increase. We have developed a portable hypothermic oxygenated machine perfusion device, the VP.S ENCORE®, to extend the allowable preservation time. The purpose of this study was to test the efficacy of the VP.S. ENCORE® using deceased donors derived hearts.

Methods

Hearts from brain-dead donors not utilized for transplant (n = 11) were offered for research from the Texas Organ Sharing Alliance (TOSA), South and Central Texas' Organ Procurement Organization (OPO) and were preserved in the VP.S ENCORE® for 4 (n = 2), 6 (n = 3), and 8 (n = 3) hours or were kept in static cold storage (SCS) (n = 3). After preservation, the hearts were placed in an isolated heart Langendorff model for reperfusion and evaluated for cardiac function.

Results

The mean donor age was 37.82 ± 12.67 with the youngest donor being 19 and the oldest donor being 58 years old. SCS hearts mean weight gain (%) was -1.4 ± 2.77, while perfused at 4 h was 5.6 ± 6.04, perfused at 6 h 2.1 ± 6.04, and 8 h was 7.2 ± 10.76. Venous and arterial lactate concentrations were less than 2.0 mmol/L across all perfused hearts. Left ventricular contractility (+dPdT, mmHg/s) for 4 h (1,214 ± 1,064), 6 (1,565 ± 141.3), and 8 h (1,331 ± 403.6) were within the range of healthy human heart function. Thus, not significant as compared to the SCS group (1,597 ± 342.2). However, the left ventricular relaxation (mmHg/s) was significant in 6-hour perfused heart (p < 0.05) as compared to SCS. Gene expression analysis of inflammation markers (IL-6, IL-1β) showed no significant differences between SCS and perfused hearts, but a 6-hour perfusion led to a downregulated expression of these markers.

Discussion

The results demonstrate that the VP.S ENCORE® device enhances cardiac viability and exhibits comparable cardiac function to a healthy heart. The implications of these findings suggest that the VP.S ENCORE® could introduce a new paradigm in the field of organ preservation, especially for marginal hearts.

Single center utilization and post-transplant outcomes of thoracoabdominal normothermic regional perfusion deceased cardiac donor organs

INTRODUCTION

Thoracoabdominal normothermic regional perfusion (TA-NRP) following cardiac death is an emerging multivisceral organ procurement technique. Recent national studies on outcomes of presumptive TA-NRP-procured organs are limited by potential misclassification since TA-NRP is not differentiated from donation after cardiac death (DCD) in registry data.

METHODS

We studied 22 donors whose designees consented to TA-NRP and organ procurement performed at our institution between January 20, 2020 and July 3, 2022. We identified these donors in SRTR to describe organ utilization and recipient outcomes and compared them to recipients of traditional DCD (tDCD) and donation after brain death (DBD) organs during the same timeframe.

RESULTS

All 22 donors progressed to cardiac arrest and underwent TA-NRP followed by heart, lung, kidney, and/or liver procurement. Median donor age was 41 years, 55% had anoxic brain injury, 45% were hypertensive, 0% were diabetic, and median kidney donor profile index was 40%. TA-NRP utilization was high across all organ types (88%-100%), with a higher percentage of kidneys procured via TA-NRP compared to tDCD (88% vs. 72%, p = .02). Recipient and graft survival ranged from 89% to 100% and were comparable to tDCD and DBD recipients (p ≥ .2). Delayed graft function was lower for kidneys procured from TA-NRP compared to tDCD donors (27% vs. 44%, p = .045).

CONCLUSION

Procurement from TA-NRP donors yielded high organ utilization, with outcomes comparable to tDCD and DBD recipients across organ types. Further large-scale study of TA-NRP donors, facilitated by its capture in the national registry, will be critical to fully understand its impact as an organ procurement technique.

Donor and recipient risk factors for the development of primary graft dysfunction following lung transplantation

Primary Graft Dysfunction (PGD) is a major cause of both short-term and long-term morbidity and mortality following lung transplantation. Various donor, recipient, and technical risk factors have been previously identified as being associated with the development of PGD. Here, we present a comprehensive review of the current literature as it pertains to PGD following lung transplantation, as well as discussing current strategies to mitigate PGD and future directions. We will pay special attention to recent advances in lung transplantation such as ex-vivo lung perfusion, thoracoabdominal normothermic regional perfusion, and up-to-date literature published in the interim since the 2016 ISHLT consensus statement on PGD and the COVID-19 pandemic.

On the ethical permissibility of in situ reperfusion in cardiac transplantation after the declaration of circulatory death

Transplant surgeons in the USA have begun performing a novel organ procurement protocol in the setting of circulatory death. Unlike traditional donation after circulatory death (DCD) protocols, in situ normothermic perfusion DCD involves reperfusing organs, including the heart, while still contained in the donor body. Some commentators, including the American College of Physicians, have claimed that in situ reperfusion after circulatory death violates the widely accepted Dead Donor Rule (DDR) and conclude that in situ reperfusion is ethically impermissible. In this paper I argue that, in terms of respecting the DDR, in situ reperfusion cardiac transplantation does not differ from traditional DCD cardiac transplantation. I do this by introducing and defending a refined conception of circulatory death, namely vegetative state function permanentism I also argue against the controversial brain occlusion feature of the in situ reperfusion DCD protocol, on the basis that it is ethically unnecessary and generates the problematic appearance of ethical dubiousness.

Dilemmas concerning heart procurement in controlled donation after circulatory death

With an expanding population at risk for heart failure and the resulting increase in patients admitted to the waiting list for heart transplantation, the demand of viable organs exceeds the supply of suitable donor hearts. Use of hearts after circulatory death has reduced this deficit. Two primary techniques for heart procurement in circulatory death donors have been described: direct procurement and perfusion and thoraco-abdominal normothermic regional perfusion. While the former has been accepted as an option for heart procurement in circulatory death donors, the latter technique has raised some ethical questions in relation to the dead donor rule. In this paper we discuss the current dilemmas regarding these heart procurement protocols in circulatory death donors.

Thoracic organ machine perfusion: A review of concepts with a focus on reconditioning therapies

Thoracic organ transplantation, including lung, heart, and heart-lung transplants are highly regarded as gold standard treatments for patients suffering from heart failure or chronic end stage lung conditions. The relatively high prevalence of conditions necessitating thoracic organ transplants combined with the lack of available organs has resulted in many either dying or becoming too ill to receive a transplant while on the waiting list. There is a dire need to increase both the number of organs available and the utilization of such organs. Improved preservation techniques beyond static storage have shown great potential to lengthen the current period of viability of thoracic organs while outside the body, promising better utilization rates, increased donation distance, and improved matching of donors to recipients. Ex-situ organ perfusion (ESOP) can also make some novel therapeutic strategies viable, and the combination of the ESOP platform with such reconditioning therapies endeavors to better improve functional preservation of organs in addition to making more organs viable for transplantation. Given the abundance of clinical and pre-clinical studies surrounding reconditioning of thoracic organs in combination with ESOP, we summarize in this review important concepts and research regarding thoracic organ machine perfusion in combination with reconditioning therapies.