Using force or EMG envelope as feedback signal for motor control system

PURPOSE

This work studied muscle neuro-mechanics during symmetrical up-going ramp (UGR) and down-going ramp (DGR).

AIM

to evaluate during the modulation of muscular action the outcome of force feedback (FF) or neural feedback (NF) on the behavior of the trailing signals - i.e. the EMG envelope (eEMG) for FF or force signal for NF.

METHOD

Subjects: 20. Investigated muscles: dorsal interosseous (FDI) and tibialis anterior (TA). Detected signals: force and EMG. Visual feedback: force (FF), eEMG (NF). Effort triangles: ramps duration 7.5 s, vertex at 50 and 100 % of the maximal voluntary action. Eventually, each subject performed FF50%, FF100%, NF50% and NF100% per each muscle. In each condition the areas beneath the force and eEMG signals were computed to calculate the ratios between the DGR and UGR values during the different tasks (force area DGR / force area UGR; eEMG area DGR / eEMG area UGR). Electro-mechanical coupling efficiency (EMCE) was estimated through the eEMG area / force area ratio for both UGR and DGR in each condition.

RESULTS

a) FF. FDI: eEMG area ratio was 0.84 ± 0.15 and 0.73 ± 0.17 for FF50% and FF100%, respectively. TA: eEMG area ratio was 0.88 ± 0.11 and 0.91 ± 0.17 for FF50% and FF100%, respectively. b) NF: FDI: force area ratio was 1.18 ± 0.13 and 1.17 ± 0.13 for NF50% and NF100%, respectively. TA: force area ratio was 1.17 ± 0.21 and 1.07 ± 0.19 for NF50% and NF100%, respectively. c) DGR EMCE was greater than UGR EMCE in all four tasks.

CONCLUSION

The influence of UGR on deployed EMCE in the following force decrement phase underpins the changes of trailing signals area during DGR. This underlines the necessity of a careful evaluation of the features of FF or NF for experimental studies or rehabilitation purposes involving the motor control system.

Influence of age on force and re-lengthening dynamics after tetanic stimulation withdrawal in the tibialis anterior muscle

PURPOSE

During alternate movements across a joint, the changeover from one direction of rotation to the opposite may be influenced by the delay and rate of tension reduction and the compliance to re-lengthening of the previously active muscle group. Given the aging process may affect the above-mentioned factors, this work aimed to compare the dynamics of both the ankle torque decline and muscle re-lengthening, mirrored by mechanomyogram (MMG), in the tibialis anterior because of its important role in gait.

METHODS

During the relaxation phase, after a supramaximal 35 Hz stimulation applied at the superficial motor point, in 20 young (Y) and 20 old (O) subjects, the torque (T) and MMG dynamics characteristics were measured.

RESULTS

The T and MMG analysis provided: (I) the beginning of the decay after cessation of stimulation (T: 22.51 ± 5.92 ms [Y] and 51.35 ± 15.21 ms [O]; MMG: 27.38 ± 6.93 ms [Y] and 61.41 ± 18.42 ms [O]); (II) the maximum rate of reduction (T: - 110.4 ± 45.56 Nm/s [Y] and - 52.72 ± 32.12 Nm/s [O]; MMG: - 24.47 ± 10.95 mm/s [Y] and - 13.76 ± 6.54 mm/s [O]); (III) the muscle compliance, measuring the MMG reduction of every 10% reduction of torque (bin 20-10%: 15.69 ± 7.5[Y] and 10.8 ± 3.3 [O]; bin 10-0%: 22.12 ± 10.3 [Y] and 17.58 ± 5.6 [O]).

CONCLUSION

Muscle relaxation results are different in Y and O and can be monitored by a non-invasive method measuring physiological variables of torque and re-lengthening dynamics at the end of the electromechanical coupling previously induced by the neuromuscular stimulation.

Normalized maximal rate of torque development during voluntary and stimulated static contraction in human tibialis anterior: Influence of age

The risk of falling in older adults has been related, among other factors, to the reduction of the rate of torque development (RTD) with age. It is well known that both structural/peripheral and neural factors can influence the RTD. The purpose of this study was to compare the normalized RTD in young and older participants obtained during a) rapid voluntary tension production and b) neuromuscular electrical stimulation. The tibialis anterior of 19 young subjects (10 males and 9 females; age 21-33 years old) and 19 older participants (10 males and 9 females; age 65-80 years old) was studied. The subjects performed a series of maximal isometric explosive dorsiflexions and underwent trains of supra-maximal electrical stimulations (35 Hz) on the tibialis anterior motor point. Muscle shortening was indirectly measured using a laser (surface mechanomyogram, MMG). Both torque and MMG were normalized to their maximum value. Using a 20 ms sliding window on the normalized torque signal, the normalized maximum RTD was calculated for both voluntary and stimulated contractions. Active stiffness of the muscle- tendon unit was calculated as the area of the normalized torque with respect to the normalized MMG. Normalized maximum RTD was found significantly lower in older adults during voluntary activity (young: 751.9 ± 216.3%/s and old: 513.9 ± 173.9%/s; P < .001), and higher during stimulated contractions (young: 753.1 ± 225.9%/s and old: 890.1 ± 221.3%/s; P = .009). Interestingly, active stiffness was also higher in older adults (young: 3524.6 ± 984.6‰ and old 4144.6 ± 816.6‰; P = .041) and significantly correlated to the normalized maximum RTD during stimulated contractions. This dichotomy suggests that modifications in the structural/peripheral muscle properties are not sufficient to counteract the age-related decrease in neural drive to the muscle during voluntary isometric contractions in aged participants.