The NICE Evidence Standards Framework for digital health and care technologies - Developing and maintaining an innovative evidence framework with global impact

Objective

In 2018, the UK National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE), in partnership with Public Health England, NHS England, NHS Improvement and others, developed an evidence standards framework (ESF) for digital health and care technologies (DHTs). The ESF was designed to provide a standardised approach to guide developers and commissioners on the levels of evidence needed for the clinical and economic evaluation of DHTs by health and care systems.

Methods

The framework was developed using an agile and iterative methodology that included a literature review of existing initiatives and comparison of these against the requirements set by NHS England; iterative consultation with stakeholders through an expert working group and workshops; and questionnaire-based stakeholder input on a publicly available draft document.

Results

The evidence standards framework has been well-received and to date the ESF has been viewed online over 55,000 times and downloaded over 19,000 times.

Conclusions

In April 2021 we published an update to the ESF. Here, we summarise the process through which the ESF was developed, reflect on its global impact to date, and describe NICE’s ongoing work to maintain and improve the framework in the context for a fast moving, innovative field.

Characterization of the secreted form of endothelial-cell-specific molecule 1 by specific monoclonal antibodies

Endothelial-cell-specific molecule 1 (ESM-1) is a recently identified endothelial cell molecule. As ESM-1 mRNA is preferentially expressed in human lung and kidney tissues, and as ESM-1 mRNA expression is regulated by inflammatory cytokines, ESM-1 is thought to play a role in the vascular contribution to organ-specific inflammation. In order to define its behavior, mouse anti-ESM-1 monoclonal antibodies were developed, and three distinct epitopes were mapped, which allowed development of a specific ELISA assay, immunohistological staining and immunoblot analysis. Here, we demonstrate that ESM-1 is present in cell lysates of human endothelial cells (human umbilical vein endothelial cells) with an apparent molecular weight of 20 kD. In contrast, the secreted form of ESM-1 is shifted to an apparent molecular weight of 50 kD, indicating that the secreted form of ESM-1 is posttranslationally modified. By ELISA, we show that the secretion of ESM-1 is significantly enhanced in the presence of TNFalpha. In contrast, the spontaneous as well as TNFalpha-induced secretion of ESM-1 is strongly inhibited by IFNgamma. Moreover, ESM-1 was detected in the serum of healthy subjects at an average concentration of 1.08 ng/ml, and we demonstrated that the serum level of ESM-1 is dramatically increased in patients presenting a septic shock. Analysis of ESM-1 expression in normal human tissues by immunohistochemistry showed that ESM-1 is localized in the vascular network, but also in the bronchial and renal epithelia. Our results demonstrate that ESM-1 is mainly expressed in the vascular endothelium both in vitro and in vivo, but also by different epithelia. ESM-1 may represent a new marker of endothelial cell activation, and may have a functional role in endothelium-dependent pathological disorders.