Expert-based medication reviews to reduce polypharmacy in older patients in primary care: a northern-Italian cluster-randomised controlled trial

BACKGROUND

Evidence regarding clinically relevant effects of interventions aiming at reducing polypharmacy is weak, especially for the primary care setting. This study was initiated with the objective to achieve clinical benefits for older patients (aged 75+) by means of evidence-based reduction of polypharmacy (defined as ≥8 prescribed drugs) and inappropriate prescribing in general practice.

METHODS

The cluster-randomised controlled trial involved general practitioners and patients in a northern-Italian region. The intervention consisted of a review of patient's medication regimens by three experts who gave specific recommendations for drug discontinuation. Main outcome measures were non-elective hospital admissions or death within 24 months (composite primary endpoint). Secondary outcomes were drug numbers, hospital admissions, mortality, falls, fractures, quality of life, affective status, cognitive function.

RESULTS

Twenty-two GPs/307 patients participated in the intervention group, 21 GPs/272 patients in the control group. One hundred twenty-five patients (40.7%) experienced the primary outcome in the intervention group, 87 patients (32.0%) in the control group. The adjusted rates of occurrence of the primary outcome did not differ significantly between the study groups (intention-to-treat analysis: adjusted odds ratio 1.46, 95%CI 0.99-2.18, p = 0.06; per-protocol analysis: adjusted OR 1.33, 95%CI 0.87-2.04, p = 0.2). Hospitalisations as single endpoint occurred more frequently in the intervention group according to the unadjusted analysis (OR 1.61, 95%CI 1.03-2.51, p = 0.04) but not in the adjusted analysis (OR 1.39, 95%CI 0.95-2.03, p = 0.09). Falls occurred less frequently in the intervention group (adjusted OR 0.55, 95%CI 0.31-0.98; p = 0.04). No significant differences were found regarding the other outcomes. Definitive discontinuation was obtained for 67 (16.0%) of 419 drugs rated as inappropriate. About 6% of the prescribed drugs were PIMs.

CONCLUSIONS

No conclusive effects were found regarding mortality and non-elective hospitalisations as composite respectively single endpoints. Falls were significantly reduced in the intervention group, although definitive discontinuation was achieved for only one out of six inappropriate drugs. These results indicate that (1) even a modest reduction of inappropriate medications may entail positive clinical effects, and that (2) focusing on evidence-based new drug prescriptions and prevention of polypharmacy may be more effective than deprescribing.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

Current Controlled Trials (ID ISRCTN: 38449870), date: 11/09/2013.

Quality improvement in chronic care by self-audit, benchmarking and networking in general practices in South Tyrol, Italy: results from an interventional study

BACKGROUND

Systematic strategies promoting quality of care in general practice are yet under-represented in several European countries.

OBJECTIVE

This interventional study assessed whether a combined intervention (self-audit, benchmarking, quality circles) improved quality of care in Salzburg, Austria and South Tyrol, Italy. The present publication reports the Italian results.

METHODS

We developed quality indicators for general practice in a consensus process based on pre-existing quality programmes. The indicators addressed diagnosis and treatment regarding eight common chronic conditions. A quality score comprising 91 indicators was calculated (0-5 points per indicator depending on fulfilment, maximum 455 points). We collected anonymous data from the electronic health records of the participating physicians in 2012, 2013 and 2014. Wilcoxon signed-rank tests were used for pre-post analysis.

RESULTS

Thirty-six GPs participated in the study. The median quality score increased significantly from 177.0 points at baseline to 272.0 points at the second follow-up (P = 0.000). Improvements concerned process and intermediate outcome indicators particularly between baseline and the first follow-up.

CONCLUSION

Performance was relatively low at baseline and improved considerably, mainly in the first study period. The intervention investigated in this study can serve as a model for future quality programmes. A customized electronic health record for the implementation of this intervention as well as standardized and consistent documentation by GPs is a prerequisite. Use of a limited set of quality indicators (QIs) and regular QI modification is probably advisable to increase the benefits. Long-term prospective studies should investigate the impact of QI-based interventions on end-result outcomes.

Anti-gastric parietal cell antibodies for autoimmune gastritis screening in juvenile autoimmune thyroid disease

OBJECTIVE

Patients with autoimmune thyroid disease (ATD) have a higher prevalence of autoimmune gastritis (AIG) compared with the general population. The association between ATD and AIG is poorly characterized in the pediatric age. We reviewed the prevalence of anti-gastric parietal cell antibodies (PCA) in young patients with ATD to evaluate its usefulness as a marker for AIG screening.

METHODS

We evaluated 220 children and adolescents (11.28 ± 6.37 years) with ATD (186 with autoimmune thyroiditis (AT) and 34 with Graves' disease (GD). At ATD diagnosis and annually thereafter, blood counts and PCA levels were measured. In patients positive for PCA, plasma gastrin, chromogranin A, vitamin B₁₂, iron and ferritin levels and H. pylori antigen were measured. PCA-positive patients > 18 years were invited to undergo a gastroscopic exam.

RESULTS

PCA positivity was detected in ten (4.5%) subjects (5F/5M; 12.6 ± 3.4 years). The prevalence of PCA positivity was not significantly different in the comparison of GD and AT patients (p = 0.9). PCA positivity was detected after 2.7 ± 2.7 years of follow-up in AT and 4.4 ± 4.0 years in GD (p = 0.4). Autoantibody positivity was more prevalent in female patients, in both AT and GD (p = 0.02 and p = 0.03, respectively). At detection of PCA positivity, five out of ten PCA-positive patients had iron deficiency, four vitamin B₁₂ deficiency, two anemia, three hypergastrinemia and two elevated chromogranin values. Two patients had H. pylori infection. Gastroscopy was performed in the five ATD patients and in all patients, AIG was confirmed.

CONCLUSION

In the juvenile population, ATD and AIG may also be associated. PCA screening is useful to detect subjects at risk for this condition. Due to the longer life expectancy of the pediatric population and considering the relatively high risk of malignant transformation, early surveillance monitoring is mandatory for children and adolescents with ATD.

Psychological distress is associated with altered cognitive functioning in family caregivers of patients with disorders of consciousness

OBJECTIVES

To analyse the possible presence of reduced cognitive efficiency in family caregivers of patients with prolonged disorders of consciousness (DOC).

SUBJECTS

The participants were 27 caregivers of 25 patients with DOC admitted to the severe brain injury units of the ICS Maugeri, Institutes of Telese Terme and Sciacca, Italy.

METHODS

We examined cognitive functions such as short- and long-term memory, executive functions and attention by means of standardized tests. We also assessed features of psychological distress such as anxiety, depression, psychophysiological symptoms, prolonged grief disorder, psychological burden and quality of life. All scores on neuropsychological tests were compared with those of the 15 matched control subjects.

RESULTS

Enrolled family caregivers showed high frequency of clinically relevant depressive symptoms and anxiety; half of them met the criteria for prolonged grief disorder. Caregivers achieved scores lower than the matched controls on tests for selective attention, verbal fluency and long-term spatial memory.

CONCLUSIONS

Family caregivers' burden is associated with a reduced efficiency of selected executive measures and visuospatial learning. These results emphasize the need for appropriate psychological and cognitive supporting therapies for family caregivers of patients with DOC, also considering their delicate involvement in clinical decision-making and in providing care.

Automatic identification of type 2 diabetes, hypertension, ischaemic heart disease, heart failure and their levels of severity from Italian General Practitioners' electronic medical records: a validation study

OBJECTIVES

The Italian project MATRICE aimed to assess how well cases of type 2 diabetes (T2DM), hypertension, ischaemic heart disease (IHD) and heart failure (HF) and their levels of severity can be automatically extracted from the Health Search/CSD Longitudinal Patient Database (HSD). From the medical records of the general practitioners (GP) who volunteered to participate, cases were extracted by algorithms based on diagnosis codes, keywords, drug prescriptions and results of diagnostic tests. A random sample of identified cases was validated by interviewing their GPs.

SETTING

HSD is a database of primary care medical records. A panel of 12 GPs participated in this validation study.

PARTICIPANTS

300 patients were sampled for each disease, except for HF, where 243 patients were assessed.

OUTCOME MEASURES

The positive predictive value (PPV) was assessed for the presence/absence of each condition against the GP's response to the questionnaire, and Cohen's κ was calculated for agreement on the severity level.

RESULTS

The PPV was 100% (99% to 100%) for T2DM and hypertension, 98% (96% to 100%) for IHD and 55% (49% to 61%) for HF. Cohen's kappa for agreement on the severity level was 0.70 for T2DM and 0.69 for hypertension and IHD.

CONCLUSIONS

This study shows that individuals with T2DM, hypertension or IHD can be validly identified in HSD by automated identification algorithms. Automatic queries for levels of severity of the same diseases compare well with the corresponding clinical definitions, but some misclassification occurs. For HF, further research is needed to refine the current algorithm.