An Audit for Radiotherapy Planning and Treatment Errors From a Low-Middle-Income Country Centre

AIMS

To report the findings of an audit for radiotherapy errors from a low-middle-income country (LMICs) centre. This would serve as baseline data for radiotherapy error rates, their severity and causes, in such centres where modern error reporting and learning processes still do not exist.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A planned cross-sectional weekly audit of electronic radiotherapy charts at the radiotherapy planning and delivery step for all patients treated with curative intent was conducted. Detailed analysis was carried out to determine the step of origin of error, time and contributing factors. They were graded as per indigenous institutional (TMC) radiotherapy error grading (TREG) system and the contributing factors identified were prioritised using the product of frequency, severity and ease of detection.

RESULTS

In total, 1005 consecutive radically treated patients' charts were audited, 67 radiotherapy errors affecting 60 patients, including 42 incidents and 25 near-misses were identified. Transcriptional errors (29%) were the most common type. Most errors occurred at the time of treatment planning (59.7%), with "plan information transfer to the radiation oncology information system" being the most frequently affected sub-step of the radiotherapy process (47.8%). More errors were noted at cobalt units (52/67; 77.6%) than at linear accelerators. Trend analysis showed an increased number of radiotherapy incidents on Fridays and near-misses on Mondays. Trend for increased radiotherapy errors noted in the evening over other shifts. On severity grading, most of the errors (54/60; 90%) were clinically insignificant (grade I/II). Inadequacies and non-adherence towards standard operating procedures, poor documentation and lack of continuing education were the three most prominent causes.

CONCLUSION

Preliminary data suggest a vulnerability of LMIC set-up to radiotherapy errors and emphasises the need for the development of longitudinal prospective processes, such as voluntary reporting and a continued education system, to ensure robust and comprehensive safe practises on par with centres in developed countries.

Monte Carlo Investigation of Photon Beam Characteristics and its Variation with Incident Electron Beam Parameters for Indigenous Medical Linear Accelerator

Purpose

A Monte Carlo model of a 6 MV medical linear accelerator (linac) unit built indigenously was developed using the BEAMnrc user code of the EGSnrc code system. The model was benchmarked against the measurements. Monte Carlo simulations were carried out for different incident electron beam parameters in the study.

Materials and Methods

Simulation of indigenously developed linac unit has been carried out using the Monte Carlo based BEAMnrc user-code of the EGSnrc code system. Using the model, percentage depth dose (PDD), and lateral dose profiles were studied using the DOSXYZnrc user code. To identify appropriate electron parameters, three different distributions of electron beam intensity were investigated. For each case, the kinetic energy of the incident electron was varied from 6 to 6.5 MeV (0.1 MeV increment). The calculated dose data were compared against the measurements using the PTW, Germany make RFA dosimetric system (water tank MP3-M and 0.125 cm³ ion chamber).

Results

The best fit of incident electron beam parameter was found for the combination of beam energy of 6.2 MeV and circular Gaussian distributed source in X and Y with FWHM of 1.0 mm. PDD and beam profiles (along both X and Y directions) were calculated for the field sizes from 5 cm × 5 cm to 25 cm × 25 cm. The dose difference between the calculated and measured PDD and profile values were under 1%, except for the penumbra region where the maximum deviation was found to be around 2%.

Conclusions

A Monte Carlo model of indigenous linac (6 MV) has been developed and benchmarked against the measured data.

Acceptance criteria for flattening filter-free photon beam from standard medical electron linear accelerator: AERB task group recommendations

Medical electron linear accelerators with the capability of generating unflat photon (flattening filter-free, FFF) beams are also available commercially for clinical applications in radiotherapy. However, the beam characteristics evaluation criteria and parameters are not yet available for such photon beams. Atomic Energy Regulatory Board (AERB) of India constituted a Task Group comprising experts from regulatory agency, advisory body/research and technical institutions, and clinical radiotherapy centers in the country to evolve and recommend the acceptance criteria for the flattening filter-free (FFF) photon beams. The Task Group thoroughly reviewed the literature and inputs of the manufactures/suppliers of the FFF linac and recommended a set of dosimetry parameters for evaluating the characteristics of the unflat photon beam. The recommendations included the evaluation of quality index, degree of unflatness, difference in percentage surface dose between flat and unflat photon beams, percentage depth dose at 10 cm depth, off-axis-ratios and radiation beam penumbra. The recommended parameters were evaluated for FFF photon beams generated by three different models of the linac, and it was observed that recommended evaluation methods are simple and easy to be implemented with the existing dosimetry and quality assurance infrastructure of the linac facilities of the radiotherapy departments. Recommendations were also made for periodic quality control check of the unflat photon beams and constancy evaluation in the beam characteristics.

Dose optimization in gynecological 3D image based interstitial brachytherapy using martinez universal perineal interstitial template (MUPIT) -an institutional experience

The aim of this study was to evaluate the dose optimization in 3D image based gynecological interstitial brachytherapy using Martinez Universal Perineal Interstitial Template (MUPIT). Axial CT image data set of 20 patients of gynecological cancer who underwent external radiotherapy and high dose rate (HDR) interstitial brachytherapy using MUPIT was employed to delineate clinical target volume (CTV) and organs at risk (OARs). Geometrical and graphical optimization were done for optimum CTV coverage and sparing of OARs. Coverage Index (CI), dose homogeneity index (DHI), overdose index (OI), dose non-uniformity ratio (DNR), external volume index (EI), conformity index (COIN) and dose volume parameters recommended by GEC-ESTRO were evaluated. The mean CTV, bladder and rectum volume were 137 ± 47cc, 106 ± 41cc and 50 ± 25cc, respectively. Mean CI, DHI and DNR were 0.86 ± 0.03, 0.69 ± 0.11 and 0.31 ± 0.09, while the mean OI, EI, and COIN were 0.08 ± 0.03, 0.07 ± 0.05 and 0.79 ± 0.05, respectively. The estimated mean CTV D90 was 76 ± 11Gy and D100 was 63 ± 9Gy. The different dosimetric parameters of bladder D2cc, D1cc and D0.1cc were 76 ± 11Gy, 81 ± 14Gy, and 98 ± 21Gy and of rectum/recto-sigmoid were 80 ± 17Gy, 85 ± 13Gy, and 124 ± 37Gy, respectively. Dose optimization yields superior coverage with optimal values of indices. Emerging data on 3D image based brachytherapy with reporting and clinical correlation of DVH parameters outcome is enterprizing and provides definite assistance in improving the quality of brachytherapy implants. DVH parameter for urethra in gynecological implants needs to be defined further.

Investigation on the effect of sharp phantom edges on point dose measurement during patient-specific dosimetry with Rapid Arc

The objective of this work was to investigate and quantify the effect of sharp edges of the phantom on the point dose measurement during patient-specific dosimetry with Rapid Arc (RA). Ten patients with carcinoma of prostate were randomly selected for this dosimetric study. Rapid Arc plans were generated with 6 MV X-rays in the Eclipse (v 8.6.14) with single arc (clockwise). Dosimetry verification plans were generated for two phantoms (cylindrical and rectangular). The cylindrical phantom was solid water (diameter 34 cm) and the rectangular phantom was a water phantom (25 cm × 25 cm × 10 cm). These phantoms were pre-scanned in computed tomography (CT) machine with cylindrical ionization chamber (FC65) in place. The plans were delivered with Novalis Tx linear accelerator with 6 MV X-rays for both the phantoms separately. The measured dose was compared with the planned dose for both the phantoms. Mean percentage deviation between measured and planned doses was found to be 4.19 (SD 0.82) and 3.63 (SD 0.89) for cylindrical and rectangular phantoms, respectively. No significant dosimetric variation was found due to the geometry (sharp edges) of the phantom. The sharp edges of the phantom do not perturb the patient specific Rapid Arc dosimetry significantly.

Dosimetric comparison of inverse optimization with geometric optimization in combination with graphical optimization for HDR prostate implants

The purpose of this study is to compare geometric optimization (GO) with anatomy based inverse optimization (ABIO). Five patients of carcinoma prostate treated with HDR interstitial brachytherapy had been studied. Post implant CT scans of 5 mm slice thickness were obtained; target volume and other critical structures rectum, bladder and urethra were drawn by the clinician. Plans were obtained with geometric optimization and anatomy based inversed optimization. Anatomy based inverse planning implemented currently in PLATO BPS version 14.2, is based on geometric and dose point optimization and designed to account for the critical structures. Graphical optimization (GrO) is used to fine-tune the distribution ie to reduce the dose to critical structures and to improve the target coverage in both geometric optimization and anatomy based inverse optimization plans. DVH of target, rectum, bladder and urethra were evaluated and compared, dose homogeneity index and conformity index were also evaluated for all the plans. The mean target coverage was 93.9±7%, 90.3±4%, 82±13%, 91.6±3 for different optimization techniques GO, GO_gr, ABIO and ABIO_gr respectively. The target coverage in ABIO is not clinically acceptable. Maximum dose, dose to 2% of the volume of urethra D(2%,U) was 137±12%, 123.2±2%, 111.5±9, 122.7±4 for GO, GO_gr, ABIO and ABIO_gr respectively. The mean conformity index values were 0.71, 0.76, 0.65, 0.82 for GO, GO_gr, ABIO, ABIO_gr respectively. ABIO_gr has a good conformity over all other optimization techniques. However the difference is not very significant between GO and GO_gr. The mean values of DHI are 0.81, 0.77, 0.65 and 0.75 for GO, GO_gr, ABIO and ABIO_gr respectively. Geometric optimization is highly homogenous compared to all other optimization techniques.To conclude, target coverage in ABIO is not clinically acceptable. However ABIO followed by graphical optimization is much superior in sparing of critical structures and conformity compared to geometrical optimization. Target coverage is marginally better in GO compared to ABIO_gr. Homogeneity is superior in GO compared to ABIO_gr. However ABIO_gr plans were clinically acceptable with respect to homogeneity. Further, dose escalation to the target is possible with ABIO, without exceeding the tolerance dose to urethra. Clinical correlation of genitourinary toxicity has to be studied.

Dosimetric evaluation of rectum and bladder using image-based CT planning and orthogonal radiographs with ICRU 38 recommendations in intracavitary brachytherapy

The purpose is to compare CT-based dosimetry with International Commission on Radiation Units and Measurements (ICRU 38) bladder and rectum reference points in patients of carcinoma of uterine cervix treated with intracavitary brachytherapy (ICA). Twenty-two consecutive patients were evaluated. Orthogonal radiographs and CT images were acquired and transferred to PLATO planning system. Bladder and rectal reference points were identified according to ICRU 38 recommendations. Dosimetry was carried out based on Manchester system. Patient treatment was done using ¹⁹²Iridium high dose rate (HDR) remote after-loading machine based on the conventional radiograph-based dosimetry. ICRU rectal and bladder point doses from the radiograph plans were compared with D₂, dose received by 2 cm³ of the organ receiving maximum dose from CT plan. V₂, volume of organ receiving dose more than the ICRU reference point, was evaluated. The mean (±standard deviation) volume of rectum and bladder was 60 (±28) cm³ and 138 (±41) cm³ respectively. The mean reference volume in radiograph and CT plan was 105 (±7) cm³ and 107 (±7) cm³ respectively. It was found that 6 (±4) cm³ of rectum and 16 (±10) cm³ of bladder received dose more than the prescription dose. V₂ of rectum and bladder was 7 (±1.7) cm³ and 20.8 (±6) cm³ respectively. Mean D₂ of rectum and bladder was found to be 1.11 (±0.2) and 1.56 (±0.6) times the mean ICRU reference points respectively. This dosimteric study suggests that comparison of orthogonal X-ray-based and CT-based HDR ICA planning is feasible. ICRU rectal point dose correlates well with maximum rectal dose, while ICRU bladder point underestimates the maximum bladder dose.

Electron arc therapy for bilateral chest wall irradiation: treatment planning and dosimetric study

AIMS

The treatment of patients with synchronous bilateral breast cancer is a challenge. We present a report of dosimetric data of patients with bilateral chest walls as the target treated with electron arc therapy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Ten consecutive patients who had undergone electron arc therapy to the bilateral chest wall for breast cancer were analysed. After positioning and immobilisation, patients underwent computed tomography scans from the neck to the upper abdomen. Electron arc plans were generated using the PLATO RTS (V1.8.2 Nucletron) treatment planning system. Electron energy was chosen depending upon the depth and thickness of the planning target volume (PTV). For all patients, the arc angle ranged between 80 and 280° (start angle 80°, stop angle 280°). The homogeneity index, coverage index and doses to organs at risk were evaluated. The patient-specific output factor and thermoluminescence dosimetry (TLD) measurements were carried out for all patients. The total planned dose to the PTV was 50Gy/25 fractions/5 weeks.

RESULTS

The mean PTV (± standard deviation) was 568.9 (±116)cm(3). The mean PTV coverage was 89 (±5.8)% of the prescribed dose. For the right lung, the mean values of D(1) and D(10) were 46 (±7.6) and 30 (±9)Gy, respectively. For the left lung, the mean values of D(1) and D(10) were 45 (±7) and 27 (±8)Gy, respectively. For the heart, the mean values of D(1), D(5) and D(10) were 21 (±15), 13.5 (±12) and 9 (±9)Gy, respectively. The mean values of TLD at various pre-specified locations on the chest wall surface were 1.84, 1.82, 1.82, 1.89 and 1.78Gy, respectively

CONCLUSION

The electron arc technique for treating the bilateral chest wall is a feasible and pragmatic technique. This technique has the twin advantages of adequate coverage of the target volume and sparing of adjacent normal structures. However, compared with other techniques, it needs a firm quality assurance protocol for dosimetry and treatment delivery.

Cosmesis, Late Sequelae and Local Control after Breast-Conserving Therapy: Influence of Type of Tumour Bed Boost and Adjuvant Chemotherapy

AIMS

To study the influence of various factors affecting cosmetic outcome and late sequelae in a large cohort of women treated with breast-conserving therapy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Between 1980 and 2000, 1022 pathological stage I/II breast cancer patients underwent breast-conserving therapy. On the basis of the type of tumour bed boost they received after whole breast radiotherapy, these women were assigned to three groups: (A) low dose rate (LDR) brachytherapy of 15-20 Gy (n=383); (B) high dose rate (HDR) brachytherapy of 10 Gy (optimised) in a single fraction (n=153); (C) electron beam 15 Gy/six fractions (n=460). Systemic adjuvant therapy was given to 757 women, of whom 570 received adjuvant chemotherapy.

RESULTS

Cosmesis at the last follow-up was good or excellent in 77% of women. Post-radiation worsening of cosmesis was observed in 11.5% of women and was similar in the three boost groups. Moderate to severe late breast sequelae were observed in 22% of women in group B, which was significantly higher than the 12% in group A (P=0.002) and 9% in group C (P=0.0001). The actuarial 5-year local control rate was 91% and was 90, 92 and 93% in groups A, B and C, respectively. Tumour size (P=0.049) and adjuvant chemotherapy (P=0.04) were the significant factors affecting cosmetic outcome on univariate analysis. On multivariate analysis, adjuvant chemotherapy was the only factor leading to worsening in the cosmetic outcome, with P=0.03 (hazard ratio 1.65 [95% confidence interval 1.05-2.59]).

CONCLUSION

The type of tumour bed boost did not have a significant effect on the worsening of cosmetic outcome. However, there were significantly more late breast sequelae in women treated with single fraction HDR implants. Chemotherapy had an adverse effect on the cosmetic outcome, but the late breast sequelae and local control rates were comparable.

Commissioning of motorized wedge for the first equinox-80 telecobalt unit and implementation in the Eclipse 3D treatment planning system

A new model of the telecobalt unit (TCU), Theratron Equinox-80, (MDS Nordion, Canada) equipped with a single 60 degree motorized wedge (MW), four universal wedges (UW) for 15 degrees, 30 degrees, 45 degrees and 60 degrees have been evaluated. MW was commissioned in Eclipse (Varian, Palo Alto, USA) 3D treatment planning system (TPS). The profiles and central axis depth doses (CADD) were measured with Wellhofer blue water phantom for MW and the measured data was commissioned in Eclipse. These profiles and CADD for MW were compared with UW in a homogeneous phantom generated in Eclipse for various field sizes. The dose was also calculated in the same phantom at 10 cm depth. For the particular MW angle and the respective open and MW beam weights, the dose was measured for a field size of 10 cm x 10 cm in a MEDTEC water phantom at 10 cm depth with a 0.13 cc thimble ion chamber (Scanditronix Wellhofer, Uppsala, Sweden) and a NE electrometer (Nuclear Enterprises, UK). Measured dose with ion chamber was compared with the TPS calculated dose. MW angle verification was also done on the Equinox for four angles (15 degrees, 30 degrees, 45 degrees and 60 degrees). The variation in measured and calculated dose at 10 cm depth was within 2%. The measured and the calculated wedge angles were in good agreement within 2 degrees. The motorized wedges were successfully commissioned in Eclipse for four wedge angles.

Intensity modulated radiotherapy dosimetry with ion chambers, TLD, MOSFET and EDR2 film

Purpose of this study was to report in a together our experience of using ion chambers, TLD, MOSFET and EDR2 film for dosimetric verification of IMRT plans delivered with dynamic multileaf collimator (DMLC). Two ion chambers (0.6 and 0.13 CC) were used. All measurements were performed with a 6MV photon beam on a Varian Clinac 6EX LINAC equipped with a Millennium MLC. All measurements were additionally carried out with (LiF:Mg,TI) TLD chips. Five MOSFET detectors were also irradiated. EDR2 films were used to measure coronal planar dose for 10 patients. Measurements were carried out simultaneously for cumulative fields at central axis and at off-axis at isocenter plane (+/- 1, and +/- 2 cm). The mean percentage variation between measured cumulative central axis dose with 0.6 cc ion chamber and calculated dose with TPS was -1.4% (SD 3.2). The mean percentage variation between measured cumulative absolute central axis dose with 0.13 cc ion chamber and calculated dose with TPS was -0.6% (SD 1.9). The mean percentage variation between measured central axis dose with TLD and calculated dose with TPS was -1.8% (SD 2.9). A variation of less than 5% was found between measured off-axis doses with TLD and calculated dose with TPS. For all the cases, MOSFET agreed within +/- 5%. A good agreement was found between measured and calculated isodoses. Both ion chambers (0.6 CC and 0.13 CC) were found in good agreement with calculated dose with TPS.

Evaluation of radiograph-based interstitial implant dosimetry on computed tomography images using dose volume indices for head and neck cancer

Conventional radiograph-based implant dosimetry fails to correlate the spatial dose distribution on patient anatomy with lack in dosimetry quality. Though these limitations are overcome in computed tomography (CT)-based dosimetry, it requires an algorithm which can reconstruct catheters on the multi-planner CT images. In the absence of such algorithm, we proposed a technique in which the implanted geometry and dose distribution generated from orthogonal radiograph were mapped onto the CT data using coordinate transformation method.

Radiograph-based implant dosimetry was generated for five head and neck cancer patients on Plato Sunrise treatment planning system. Dosimetry was geometrically optimized on volume, and dose was prescribed according to the natural prescription dose. The final dose distribution was retrospectively mapped onto the CT data set of the same patients using coordinate transformation method, which was verified in a phantom prior to patient study. Dosimetric outcomes were evaluated qualitatively by visualizing isodose distribution on CT images and quantitatively using the dose volume indices, which includes coverage index (CI), external volume index (EI), relative dose homogeneity index (HI), overdose volume index (OI) and conformal index (COIN).

The accuracy of coordinate transformation was within ±1 mm in phantom and ±2 mm in patients. Qualitative evaluation of dosimetry on the CT images shows reasonably good coverage of target at the expense of excessive normal tissue irradiation. The mean (SD) values of CI, EI and HI were estimated to be 0.81 (0.039), 0.55 (0.174) and 0.65 (0.074) respectively. The maximum OI estimated was 0.06 (mean 0.04, SD = 0.015). Finally, the COIN computed for each patient ranged from 0.4 to 0.61 (mean 0.52, SD = 0.078).

The proposed technique is feasible and accurate to implement even for the most complicated implant geometry. It allows the physicist and physician to evaluate the plan both qualitatively and quantitatively. Dose volume indices derived from CT data set are useful for evaluating the implant and comparing different brachytherapy plans. COIN index is an important tool to assess the target coverage and sparing of normal tissues in brachytherapy.

Peripheral dose from uniform dynamic multileaf collimation fields: implications for sliding window intensity-modulated radiotherapy

The increase in the number of monitor units in sliding window intensity-modulated radiotherapy, compared with conventional techniques for the same target dose, may lead to an increase in peripheral dose (PD). PD from a linear accelerator was measured for 6 MV X-ray using 0.6 cm3 ionization chamber inserted at 5 cm depth into a 35 cm x 35 cm x 105 cm plastic water phantom. Measurements were made for field sizes of 6 cm x 6 cm, 10 cm x 10 cm and 14 cm x 14 cm, shaped in both static and dynamic multileaf collimation (DMLC) mode, employing strip fields of fixed width 0.5 cm, 1.0 cm, 1.5 cm, and 2.0 cm, respectively. The effect of collimator rotation and depth of measurement on peripheral dose was investigated for 10 cm x 10 cm field. Dynamic fields require 2 to 14 times the number of monitor units than does a static open field for the same dose at the isocentre, depending on strip field width and field size. Peripheral dose resulting from dynamic fields manifests two distinct regions showing a crest and trough within 30 cm from the field edge and a steady exponential fall beyond 30 cm. All dynamic fields were found to deliver a higher PD compared with the corresponding static open fields, being highest for smallest strip field width and largest field size; also, the percentage increase observed was highest at the largest out-of-field distance. For 6 cm x 6 cm field, dynamic fields with 0.5 cm and 2 cm strip field width deliver PDs 8 and 2 times higher than that of the static open field. The corresponding factors for 14 cm x 14 cm field were 15 and 6, respectively. The factors by which PD for DMLC fields increase, relative to jaws-shaped static fields for out-of-field distance beyond 30 cm, are almost the same as the corresponding increases in the number of monitor units. Reductions of 20% and 40% in PD were observed when the measurements were done at a depth of 10 cm and 15 cm, respectively. When the multileaf collimator executes in-plane (collimator 90 degrees) motion, peripheral dose decreases by as much as a factor of 3 compared with cross-plane data. The knowledge of PD from DMLC field is necessary to estimate the increase in whole-body dose and the likelihood of radiation induced secondary malignancy.

Performance evaluation of a dedicated computed tomography scanner used for virtual simulation using in-house fabricated CT phantoms

Comprehensive tests on single slice CT scanner was carried out using in-house fabricated phantoms/test tools following AAPM recommended methods to independently validate the auto-performance test (APT) results. Test results of all the electromechanical parameters were found within the specified limits. Radiation and sensitivity profile widths were within ± 0.05 cm of the set slice thickness. Effective energy corresponding to nominal kVp of 80, 110 and 130 were 49.99, 55.08 and 59.48 keV, respectively. Percentage noise obtained by APT was 1.32% while the independently measured value was 0.38%. Observed contrast resolutions by independent method at 0.78% and 12% contrast difference were 4 mm and 1.25 mm (= 4 lp/cm) respectively. However, high contrast resolution (limiting spatial resolution) by APT at 50, 10 and 2% MTF levels were 9, 12.5 and 14.1 lp/cm respectively. Difference in calculated and measured CT numbers of water, air, teflon, acrylic, polystyrene and polypropylene were in the range of 0 to 24 HU, while this difference was 46 and 94 HU in case of nylon and bakelite respectively. The contrast scale determined using CT linearity phantom was 1.998×10⁻⁴ cm⁻¹/CT number. CT dose index (CTDI) and weighted CTDI (CTDI_w) measured at different kVp for standard head and body phantoms were smaller than manufacturer-specified and system-calculated values and were found within the manufacturer-specified limit of ± 20%. Measured CTDIs on surface (head: 3.6 cGy and body: 2.6 cGy) and at the center (3.3 cGy, head; and 1.2 cGy, body) were comparable to reported values of other similar CT scanners and were also within the industry-quoted CTDI range. Comprehensive QA and independent validation of APT results are necessary to obtain baseline data for CT virtual simulation.

Transperineal low-dose rate iridium-192 interstitial brachytherapy in cervical carcinoma stage IIB

PURPOSE

To assess local control, survival and complications in patients with cervical carcinoma Stage IIB treated radically with transperineal Iridium-192 low-dose rate interstitial brachytherapy following external beam radiotherapy.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

65 women (age 25-70 years, mean 47 years) with cervical carcinoma Stage IIB were initially treated with external beam radiotherapy on a telecobalt or 6 MV linear accelerator to a dose of 50 Gy delivered in 5-6 weeks. After 2-3 weeks of completing external radiation, patients received interstitial brachytherapy with Iridium-192 (activity 0.5-1 mCi/cm) using a Syed-Neblett perineal template. The median dose delivered to the implant volume was 24 Gy (range 20-32 Gy) delivered at an average dose rate of 0.70 Gy/h (range 0.40-1.20 Gy/h). A point defined at 1.5 cm lateral to the central uterine tandem at the level of os was taken as a representative for assessing the dose to the cervix. Mean doses delivered by interstitial brachytherapy to point A, cervix, point B and rectum were 38 Gy, 34 Gy, 16 Gy and 16 Gy, respectively.

RESULTS

At a median follow-up of 53 months, the actuarial disease free survival and overall survival for 65 patients at both 5 and 10 years was 64% and 44%, respectively. Response to radiotherapy was a strong predictor of local control with 82% of patients continuing to have pelvic control after initial complete response. Overall, nine (14%) patients had persistent disease, ten (15%) developed a central recurrence after initial control and three patients developed distant metastasis on follow-up. No patient had any immediate treatment-related complication. Late toxicity included grade I-II rectal reactions in five patients and grade IV bladder complication (vesico-vaginal fistula) in two patients. 5 years after treatment, one patient developed intestinal obstruction, which was relieved after conservative management. Two patients developed vaginal stenosis. The 5- and 10-year disease free survival was 48% in patients aged less than 45 years as compared to 80% in patients of more than 45 years (p = 0.009). Dose to the cervical point was a prognostic indicator with 5- and 10-year disease free survival of 47% in patients who received < 35 Gy in comparison to 80% in patients who had > 35 Gy (p = 0.03). There was no difference in local control and survival in patients with minimal and moderate parametrial involvement. Bulky disease (> 4 cm) at presentation and a longer gap between external radiation and brachytherapy showed a trend towards inferior local control.

CONCLUSIONS

Interstitial brachytherapy after external beam irradiation in patients with cervical carcinoma Stage IIB results in acceptable local control, survival and complication rates. Increased dose to the cervical disease results in improved local control and survival and should therefore be considered while optimizing brachytherapy treatment plans. Comparison of the results with those of standard intracavitary therapy remains to be proven in a randomized trial.

Primary carcinoma of the vagina: Tata Memorial Hospital experience

PURPOSE

Carcinoma of the vagina is a rare gynecological malignancy comprising approximately 2% of all the gynecological malignancies. We have analyzed the treatment outcome of the patients treated at the Tata Memorial Hospital from January 1984 to December 1993.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

In this 10-year period, 134 patients of primary vaginal cancers were registered at our hospital. Of these, 75 patients received complete treatment and are analyzed.

RESULTS

Disease-free survival (DFS) for the whole group is 50%, and overall survival (OAS) is 60%. Most locoregional recurrences and distant failures are noted in the 2 years following treatment. DFS at 5 years is as follows: Stage I (5 patients), Stage IIA (37 patients), Stage IIB (15 patients), Stage III (14 patients), and Stage IV (4 patients); are 40%, 55%, 60%, 50%, and 25%, respectively. The DFS for patients with complete response (42 patients) to external radiation at 5 years is 68%, with partial response (25 patients) is 35%, and with poor or no response (6 patients) is 18% (p = 0.0000). We observed that brachytherapy was an important part of the treatment, and patients who received brachytherapy (59 patients), either with a vaginal intracavitary applicator (30 patients) or interstitial implant (29 patients) had a DFS of 53% and 56%, respectively, while 15 patients who received external radiation alone had a DFS of 30%. Patients receiving brachytherapy within 4 weeks of external radiation had a DFS of 60% as compared to 30% when the interval was more than 4 weeks.

CONCLUSION

The factors indicating prognosis are: site and extent of involvement, presence of lymph nodes at presentation, technique of brachytherapy, and interval between external radiation and brachytherapy.

Dosimetry of intracavitary applications in carcinoma of the cervix: rectal dose analysis

The International Commission on Radiation Units and Measurements (ICRU), in its Report-38, has given certain recommendations regarding the specifications of bladder and rectal reference points in the intracavitary treatment of carcinoma of the cervix. Conforming to this report, 182 intracavitary applications performed in stage I and II cervix cases were analyzed. In 113 applications, the maximum rectal dose was found to be in a point on the anteroposterior line drawn through the centre of colpostat sources. However, for our type of applications, the point on the anteroposterior line drawn through the lower end of the uterine tube seldom gets maximum dose. In addition, it was observed that there are other dose points than the ICRU reference point receiving doses close to maximum dose. It was concluded that doses to multiple rectal reference points should be recorded, in addition to the ICRU-defined rectal reference point.

Design and comparison of wedge shaped midline block with rectangular block used in early stage cervical cancers

PURPOSE

Design of an universal wedge shaped midline block for early stage cervical cancers to get uniform dose distribution around the target volume.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

The method of fabrication of wedge shaped midline block is discussed for treatment of early stage cervical cancers based on the configuration of 137Cs pellets used in intracavitary applications and along with external photon beams obtained by using 60Co teletherapy machine and 6 and 10 MV linear accelerators.

RESULTS

The dosimetric measurements are carried out to confirm the adequacy of thickness and shape of the block using radiation field analyzer for all the 3 energies.

DISCUSSION

The dose distribution comparison has been made with wedge shaped midline block and conventional rectangular shields to show its superiority in getting homogeneous dose distribution around target volume. The shift in 184 intracavitary applications is analyzed in actual clinical applications with respect to central axis of external beams and its comparison is made with both types of blocks. With the shift of 1 cm towards lateral from midline an overdose can occur upto 12 Gy at certain points with rectangular block compared to wedge shaped midline block.

CONCLUSION

Since the preparation of individual wedge shaped midline block for every application will be a difficult process for busy centers, the single wedge shaped midline block for each energy is more convenient to handle for busy centers instead of individualized compensating blocks for every intracavitary application.

Geometrical considerations in dose volume analysis in intracavitary treatment

PURPOSE

The present work was aimed at to study the relationship between the volume enclosed by reference isodose surface and various geometrical parameters of the intracavitary applicator in treatment of carcinoma of cervix.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Pearshape volume of the reference isodose derived from the Total Reference Air Kerma (TRAK) and the product of its dimensions, height H, width W and thickness T which is dependent on the applicator geometry, were estimated for 100 intracavitary applications treated by Selectron LDR machine. Orthogonal radiographs taken for each patient were used for measurement of actual geometric dimensions of the applicator and carrying out the dosimetry on TP-11 treatment planning system. The dimensions H, W and T of reference isodose surface (60 Gy) were also noted.

RESULTS

Ratio of the product HWT and the pearshape volume was found mainly to be a function of colpostat separation and not of other geometrical parameters like maximum vertical and anterio-posterior dimension of the applicator. The ratio remained almost constant for a particular combination of uterine tandem and colpostat. Variation in the ratios were attributed to the non-standard geometry.

CONCLUSION

The ratio of the volume of reference isodose surface to the product of its dimensions in the applicator depends upon the colpostat separation.

Treatment volume from total reference air kerma (TRAK) in intracavitory applications and its comparison with ICRU reference volume

PURPOSE

A systematic dosimetry study conforming to International Commission on Radiation Units and Measurements Report Number 38, was carried out for, cancer of Cervix Stage I and II cases at Tata Memorial Hospital.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

The reference Volume dimension were noted for each applicator. Also 3-D dosimetry was performed for selected cases, and actual geometric volume enclosed by various isodose surfaces were obtained. A relation was derived, which gave the volume enclosed by any isodose surface as a function of total reference air kerma of the sources in the applicator. The volume enclosed by reference isodose surface was compared with the product of its dimensions height, width, and thickness.

RESULTS

The volume enclosed by any isodose surface of an intracavitary application can be easily derived from total reference air kerma of the sources within the applicator.

CONCLUSION

Ratio of the volume enclosed by reference isodose surface with the product of its dimensions (HWT) could be a predictive parameter for clinical outcome, besides the reference volume specified by the report.

CT assisted computation of collimator angle and importance of off-axis planning of inclined lesions

In the radiation treatment of inclined lesions the longitudinal axis of beam should be always parallel to the longitudinal axis of lesion in the treatment plane. Hence the choice of correct collimator angle is of prime importance in the oblique field off-axis treatment planning of inclined lesions. In this paper a graphical method is discussed to determine the collimator angles from the CT scans taken at different off-axis planes. A phantom was constructed which can simulate conditions like inclined lesion in the patient and CT scans were taken at different levels. The collimator angles estimated from CT scans are found to match with the collimator angles obtained from simulator within +/- 1 degree for various gantry angles. The method is applied to plan a case of cancer of the oesophagus (upper third), which is a typical example of inclined lesion.

Endobronchial brachytherapy: a preliminary experience

Fourteen patients with malignant airway obstruction were treated with a placement of a flexible nylon catheter for low dose rate manual afterloading Iridium 192 endobronchial brachytherapy using a flexible fibreoptic bronchoscope. Eight patients had obstructive pneumonitis at initial presentation, while 6 cases were recurrences after previous external irradiation. Six evaluable patients of the former group had complete or partial reinflation of lung and were followed by external radiotherapy. Of the latter group, 3 were evaluable and had moderate to good palliation of their symptoms. No complication was observed. The technique is simple and safe with good patient compliance. Further evaluation is indicated to assess its role in the locoregional management of lung cancer.

Heat capacities at constant volume, free volumes, and rotational freedom in some liquids

This paper presents the experimental results on the velocity of sound, densities, and heat capacities of eight organic liquids at 25�, 35�, and 45�C. Using Eyring's equation, the free volumes have been calculated from the sound velocity data. For pure liquids, a quantity Cv* = (Cv)L- (Cv)g- Cstr called the residual heat capacity is found to be linearly dependent on free volume. Analysis of the data for 34 liquids shows that a plot of residual heat capacity against the free volume gives a series of straight lines differing in slopes for different groups of liquids such as hydrocarbons, halogen-substituted hydrocarbons, alcohols, etc. This behaviour is ascribed as being due to different degrees of rotational freedom of molecules in these liquids.