The mucosal adjuvant effects of cholera toxin and immune-stimulating complexes differ in their requirement for IL-12, indicating different pathways of action

Adjuvants that can improve mucosal vaccine efficacy are much warranted. In this comparative study between cholera toxin (CT) and immune-stimulating complexes (ISCOM) we found that, contrary to CT, ovalbumin (OVA)-ISCOM were poor inducers of mucosal anti-OVA IgA responses, but induced similar or better systemic immunity following oral immunizations. The addition of CT to the oral OVA-ISCOM protocol did not stimulate local anti-OVA IgA immunity, nor did it change the quality or magnitude of the systemic responses. Both vectors recruited strong innate immunity, but only OVA-ISCOM could directly induce IL-12, demonstrable at the protein and mRNA levels. CT had no inhibitory effects on lipopolysaccharide/IFN-gamma-induced IL-12 mRNA expression or IL-12 production. Furthermore, adjuvanticity of CT was unaffected in IL-12-deficient mice, while OVA-ISCOM showed partly impaired adjuvant effects by the lack of IL-12. CT abrogated the induction of oral tolerance stimulated by antigen feeding in these mice. In addition, CT did not alter TGF-beta levels, suggesting that the immunomodulating effect of CT was independent of IL-12 as well as TGF-beta production. Taken together, these findings indicate that mucosal adjuvanticity of CT and ISCOM are differently dependent on IL-12, suggesting that separate and distinct antigen-processing pathways are involved.

Lack of local suppression in orally tolerant CD8-deficient mice reveals a critical regulatory role of CD8+ T cells in the normal gut mucosa

We found that feeding keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) to CD8-deficient (CD8-/-) mice induced oral tolerance that was comparable in both magnitude and quality to that induced in wild-type (wt) mice. The tolerance was dose dependent, and only higher doses of KLH caused significant reduction in specific Ab and T cell responses. Both Th1 and Th2 CD4+ T cell functions were affected. Feeding KLH together with cholera toxin (CT) adjuvant, however, abrogated the induction of oral tolerance equally well in CD8-/- and wt mice. On the contrary, CT adjuvant was unable to abrogate already established oral tolerance in both CD8-/- and wt mice. Most importantly, whereas Ag feeding induced hyporesponsiveness in systemic as well as in local gut IgA responses in wt mice, a lack of local suppression was evident in orally tolerant CD8-/- mice following oral immunizations. Thus, contrary to the situation in wt mice, Ag feeding induces systemic, but not local, gut IgA hyporesponsiveness in CD8-/- mice, suggesting that CD8+ T cells in the normal gut mucosa exert an important down-regulatory function. In wt mice the local suppression extended to an unrelated Ag, OVA, given together with KLH and CT adjuvant, i.e., bystander suppression. Based on these results we propose that tolerance induced by feeding Ag is highly compartmentalized, requiring CD8+ T cells for local suppression of IgA responses, whereas systemic tolerance may affect CD4+ T cells of both Th1 and Th2 types independently of CD8+ T cells. Finally, the adjuvant effect of CT abrogates induction, but not established, oral tolerance through a mechanism that does not require CD8+ T cells.

The influence of costimulation and regulatory CD4+ T cells on intestinal IgA immune responses

It is thought that IgA B-cell differentiation is highly dependent on activated CD4+ T cells. In particular, cell-cell interactions in the Peyer's patches involving CD40 and/or CD80/CD86 have been implicated in germinal-center formation and IgA B-cell development. Also soluble factors, such as IL-4, IL-5, IL-6, and TGF beta may be critical for IgA B-cell differentiation in vivo. Here we report on some paradoxical findings with regard to IgA B-cell differentiation and specific mucosal immune responses that we have recently made using gene knockout mice. More specifically, we have investigated to what extent absence of CD4+ T cells, relevant cytokines, or T-cell-B-cell interactions would influence IgA B-cell differentiation in vivo. Using CD4- or IL-4-gene knockout mice or mice made transgenic for CTLA4Ig, we found that, although specific responses were impaired, total IgA production and IgA B-cell differentiation appeared to proceed normally. However, a poor correlation was found between, on the one hand, GC formation and IgA differentiation and, on the other hand, the ability to respond to T-cell-dependent soluble protein antigens in these mice. Thus, despite the various deficiencies in CD4+ T-cell functions seemingly intact IgA B-cell development was observed.

CD8-deficient mice exhibit augmented mucosal immune responses and intact adjuvant effects to cholera toxin

We used normal, CD4 and CD8 gene-targeted mice to investigate the role of CD4+ and CD8+ T cells in the regulation of gut mucosal immune responses following oral immunizations with cholera toxin (CT) adjuvant. Phenotypic analysis of mucosa-associated tissues revealed normal CD3+ T-cell frequencies in CD4-/- and CD8-/- mice such that in CD4-/- mice the CD8+ and double-negative (DN) T cells were increased. In CD8-/- mice the CD4+ T cells were increased, with the exception that in the intraepithelial compartment the CD3+ T cells were predominantly DN gamma delta T-cell receptor (TCR)+ T cells. All mice, normal and deficient, failed to respond to oral immunization with the antigen, keyhole limpet haemocyanin (KLH), alone. In the presence of CT adjuvant, however, CD8-/- mice consistently exhibited three- to fivefold stronger gut mucosal responses compared to normal C57B1/6 mice. By contrast, no difference was observed for systemic responses between CD8-/- and normal mice. Thus the up-regulation selectively affected mucosal responses, suggesting that, contrary to the CD8-/- mouse gut, the normal gut mucosa may host CD8+ T cells that exert a local suppressive effect on T- and B-cell responses. The magnitude of the enhancing effect of CT was comparable in CD8-/- and normal mice, clearly demonstrating that the adjuvant mechanism of CT does not require CD8+ T cells. On the other hand, the adjuvant effect of CT required CD4+ T cells, because no or poor anti-KLH responses were observed in CD4-/- mice. In both normal and CD8-/- mice CT adjuvant promoted KLH-specific CD4+ T-cell printing without any selective effect on the differentiation towards a T-helper type-1 (Th1) or Th2 dominance. Furthermore, CT adjuvant increased the frequency of CD4+ T cells expressing a memory phenotype, i.e. CD44high, LECAM-1low and CD45RBlow. We have shown, using gene-targeted mice, that CD8+ T cells are not required for the adjuvant effect of CT, and that CD8+ T cells may exert local mucosal down-regulation of intestinal immune responses.

Cholera toxin adjuvant greatly promotes antigen priming of T cells

Cholera toxin (CT) given perorally is a powerful mucosal immunogen and adjuvant. Information that explains the adjuvant effect of CT may be used for the development of more effective oral vaccines and might also contribute to our understanding of the mechanisms involved in regulating mucosal immunity. The present study was undertaken to investigate if CT administered together with keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH) would act to promote or inhibit priming of KLH-specific T cells and whether the adjuvant effect of CT is restricted to mucosal immune responses or is a generalized phenomenon due to direct immunomodulating effects of CT. We found that CT adjuvant greatly augmented the effectiveness of a single oral priming immunization with KLH: re-challenge with KLH in vitro 1 week following immunization gave several-fold stronger proliferation in KLH-specific spleen, mesenteric lymph node, Peyer's patch and gut lamina propria T cells from KLH + CT adjuvant as opposed to KLH only-treated mice. Moreover, several-fold stronger cytokine production, i.e. interleukin (IL)-2, IL-4, IL-5, IL-6, IL-10 and interferon-gamma accompanied the enhanced proliferative response of T cells from CT adjuvant-treated mice. The adjuvant effect of CT was not restricted to mucosal immune responses but was evident also following a single parenteral immunization with KLH + CT. Limiting dilution analysis revealed that CT adjuvant promoted a 20- to 40-fold increase in the frequency of primed KLH-specific T cells. Phenotypic and functional analyses clearly demonstrated that CT adjuvant primarily enhanced priming of CD4+ rather than CD8+ T cells and the pattern of lymphokine secretion disclosed that CT most probably promoted antigen priming of both Th1 and Th2 type of CD4+ T precursor cells.