Health inequities and socioeconomic factors predicting the access to treatment for unruptured intracranial aneurysms in the USA in the last 20 years: interaction effect of race, gender, and insurance

BACKGROUND

The literature suggests that minority racial and ethnic groups have lower treatment rates for unruptured intracranial aneurysms (UIA). It is uncertain how these disparities have changed over time.

METHODS

A cross-sectional study using the National Inpatient Sample database covering 97% of the USA population was carried out.

RESULTS

A total of 213 350 treated patients with UIA were included in the final analysis and compared with 173 375 treated patients with aneurysmal subarachnoid hemorrhage (aSAH) over the years 2000-2019. The mean (SD) age of the UIA and aSAH groups was 56.8 (12.6) years and 54.3 (14.1) years, respectively. In the UIA group, 60.7% were white patients, 10.2% were black patients, 8.6% were Hispanic, 2% were Asian or Pacific Islander, 0.5% were Native Americans, and 2.8% were others. The aSAH group comprised 48.5% white patients, 13.6% black patients, 11.2% Hispanics, 3.6% Asian or Pacific Islanders, 0.4% Native Americans, and 3.7% others. After adjusting for covariates, black patients (OR 0.637, 95% CI 0.625 to 0.648) and Hispanic patients (OR 0.654, 95% CI 0.641 to 0.667) had lower odds of treatment compared with white patients. Medicare patients had higher odds of treatment than private patients, while Medicaid and uninsured patients had lower odds. Interaction analysis showed that non-white/Hispanic patients with any insurance/no insurance had lower treatment odds than white patients. Multivariable regression analysis showed that the treatment odds of black patients has improved slightly over time, while the odds for Hispanic patients and other minorities have remained the same over time.

CONCLUSION

This study from 2000 to 2019 shows that disparities in the treatment of UIA have persisted but have slightly improved over time for black patients while remaining constant for Hispanic patients and other minority groups.

Ingrown Toenail Management

Ingrown toenails account for approximately 20% of foot problems in primary care. The great toe is most often affected. Ingrown toenails occur most commonly in young men, and nail care habits and footwear are most often contributory factors. No consensus has been reached for the best treatment approach, but ingrown nails may be nonsurgically or surgically treated. Nonsurgical treatments are typically used for mild to moderate ingrown nails, whereas surgical approaches are used in moderate and severe cases. Simple nonsurgical palliative measures include correcting inappropriate footwear, managing hyperhidrosis and onychomycosis, soaking the affected toe followed by applying a mid- to high-potency topical steroid, and placing wisps of cotton or dental floss under the ingrown lateral nail edge. Application of a gutter splint to the ingrown nail edge to separate it from the lateral fold provides immediate pain relief. A cotton nail cast made from cotton and cyanoacrylate adhesive, taping the lateral nail fold, or orthonyxia may also alleviate mild to moderate ingrown toenail. Surgical approaches seek to remove the interaction between the nail plate and the nail fold to eliminate local trauma and inflammatory reaction. These approaches are superior to nonsurgical ones for preventing recurrence. The most common surgical approach is partial avulsion of the lateral edge of the nail plate. Matrixectomy further prevents recurrence and can be performed through surgical, chemical, or electrosurgical means.

Use of primary high-risk human papillomavirus testing for cervical cancer screening: interim clinical guidance

In 2011, the American Cancer Society, the American Society for Colposcopy and Cervical Pathology, and the American Society for Clinical Pathology updated screening guidelines for the early detection of cervical cancer and its precursors. Recommended screening strategies were cytology or cotesting (cytology in combination with high-risk HPV (hrHPV) testing). These guidelines also addressed the use of hrHPV testing alone as a primary screening approach, which was not recommended for use at that time. There is now a growing body of evidence for screening with primary hrHPV testing, including a prospective US-based registration study. Thirteen experts including representatives from the Society of Gynecologic Oncology, American Society for Colposcopy and Cervical Pathology, American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, American Cancer Society, American Society of Cytopathology, College of American Pathologists, and the American Society for Clinical Pathology, convened to provide interim guidance for primary hrHPV screening. This guidance panel was specifically triggered by an application to the FDA for a currently marketed HPV test to be labeled for the additional indication of primary cervical cancer screening. Guidance was based on literature review and review of data from the FDA registration study, supplemented by expert opinion. This document aims to provide information for health care providers who are interested in primary hrHPV testing and an overview of the potential advantages and disadvantages of this strategy for screening as well as to highlight areas in need of further investigation.

A common clinical dilemma: Management of abnormal vaginal cytology and human papillomavirus test results

OBJECTIVE

Vaginal cancer is an uncommon cancer of the lower genital tract, and standardized screening is not recommended. Risk factors for vaginal cancer include a history of other lower genital tract neoplasia or cancer, smoking, immunosuppression, and exposure to diethylstilbestrol in utero. Although cervical cancer screening after total hysterectomy for benign disease is not recommended, many women inappropriately undergo vaginal cytology and/or human papillomavirus (hrHPV) tests, and clinicians are faced with managing their abnormal results. Our objective is to review the literature on vaginal cytology and hrHPV testing and to develop guidance for the management of abnormal vaginal screening tests.

METHODS

An electronic search of the PubMed database through 2015 was performed. Articles describing vaginal cytology or vaginal hrHPV testing were reviewed, and diagnostic accuracy of these tests when available was noted.

RESULTS

The available literature was too limited to develop evidence-based recommendations for managing abnormal vaginal cytology and hrHPV screening tests. However, the data did show that 1) the risk of vaginal cancer in women after hysterectomy is extremely low, justifying the recommendation against routine screening, and 2) in women for whom surveillance is recommended, e.g. women post-treatment for cervical precancer or cancer, hrHPV testing may be useful in identification of vaginal cancer precursors.

CONCLUSION

Vaginal cancer is rare, and asymptomatic low-risk women should not be screened. An algorithm based on expert opinion is proposed for managing women with abnormal vaginal test results.

Photographic art in exam rooms may reduce white coat hypertension

INTRODUCTION

Blood pressure (BP) elevation in medical office settings in patients who are normotensive in nonmedical settings is an effect known as 'white coat hypertension'. This phenomenon is thought to be due to situational anxiety caused by the experience of visiting a doctor and the anxiety-inducing nature of the medical office. Our study was designed to determine if carefully selected photographic art could counter the anxiety that causes white coat hypertension and lead to lower BP recordings in some patients.

METHODS

117 adults, non-pregnant patients from the Louisiana State University Health Sciences Center Family Medicine Resident Clinic participated in this study. After the triage nurse measured the BP, the patients were randomly placed in either an exam room with standard medical posters (control room) or in an exam room with photographic art (photo room). The BP was measured in the exam room. After the medical visit, the patients switched rooms and the BP was measured a third time. The patients were asked to fill out a questionnaire to identify room preference.

RESULTS

On average, the BP obtained in the control rooms was higher than that obtained in the photo rooms. There was a statistically significant difference between the mean arterial pressure, systolic BP and diastolic BP between the control room and the photo room.

CONCLUSIONS

Landscape photographic art may have the beneficial effect of reducing BP in medical office examination rooms.

Oral lesions you can't afford to miss

Being able to promptly recognize and diagnose oral lesions is critical to heading off several potentially serious conditions. This article and photo guide can help.

Unexpected skin necrosis of the thighs

The patient was initially told she had cellulitis and sent home with a combination antibiotic. Three weeks later, she returned with necrotic lesions.

Hurricanes Katrina and Rita: evacuee healthcare efforts remote from hurricane affected areas

Hurricanes Katrina and Rita produced the largest evacuation due to a natural disaster in United States history. Many people were evacuated or rescued from New Orleans and the Gulf Coast, resulting in a need for mass disaster shelters and medical care for months following the storms. The shelter healthcare system that was successfully developed in the Shreveport-Bossier City, Louisiana area was accomplished with little support from customary sources. This report is written after much discussion and introspection of community leaders involved "on the ground," who organized and provided medical services to evacuees of south Louisiana. Its purpose is to compile "lessons learned" in preparation for the next disaster recovery effort that might affect this or any other region of our country.

Harnessing the power of prevention: human papillomavirus vaccines

Human papillomavirus (HPV) infection and HPV-associated diseases pose a considerable health care burden in the United States. The morbidity and mortality associated with HPV infection and HPV-associated diseases, ranging from genital warts to cervical cancer, have prompted both the use of screening measures to monitor HPV infection and the development of numerous treatment modalities to address its clinical sequelae. Although screening programs have dramatically reduced the incidence of cervical cancer through early detection and treatment, this devastating illness, which frequently affects women of reproductive age, remains a major public health concern. Prophylactic vaccines that prevent HPV infection have proved to be safe, well tolerated, highly efficacious, and induce long-lasting immunity to HPV. Multivalent vaccines that protect against the most common disease-causing HPV types should significantly reduce the morbidity and mortality associated with HPV.

The natural history of cervical cryosurgical healing. The minimal effect of debridement of the cervical eschar [see comment]

BACKGROUND

Cryosurgery is a favored treatment method for cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) among family physicians, in part because it is inexpensive and requires the least technical training and skill. Although cervical cryosurgery has been used for more than 30 years, the natural history of the postprocedure process has never been described. The primary purpose of our study was to describe the natural history of the healing process after cervical cryosurgery. A secondary purpose was to determine the effect of mechanical debridement of the cervical eschar on the symptoms of healing.

METHODS

We conducted a prospective multicentered trial in which women who had a histologic ally documented CIN lesion underwent cervical cryosurgery. Forty-six women were randomized to undergo eschar debridement at 48 hours after cryosurgey, and 38 women received standard care. All women were followed up and given preweighed sanitary pads for hydrorrhea (watery discharge) collection and a diary to record the severity and number of days of odor, pain, cramping, and hydrorrhea that were experienced.

RESULTS

The average total amount of hydrorrhea or discharge was 288 g, which required using an average of 41 sanitary pads during a period of 12.4 days. The duration of odor was 8.9 days, and the pain and cramping experienced after cryosurgery lasted 4.7 days. Women who were obese had greater hydrorrhea and pad usage than nonobese women. Debridement of the cervical eschar did not significantly change the signs and symptoms of healing after cryosurgery.

CONCLUSIONS

There are significant symptoms patients experience after cryosurgery that are not ameliorated by debridement. The expectations of the cryosurgical healing process should be disclosed to women before the procedure.

Healing experiences after cervical cryosurgery

BACKGROUND

Treatment for cervical intraepithelial neoplasia with cryosurgery is uncomfortable for many women. The subsequent healing process is also thought to bring discomfort. The purpose of our study was to describe women's experiences after cryosurgery, and how obesity, age, and gravidity affected, the healing process.

METHODS

We developed a survey from focus group results to measure the unpleasantness of hydrorrhea (watery discharge) from cryosurgery, the pad protection required, and the odor associated with the hydrorrhea. The cryosurgical experiences were compared with normal menses for the use and frequency of pad protection, medications used, and any activity restrictions.

RESULTS

Cryosurgical experiences were unpleasant for 78.3% of the women because of the pain and cramping of the procedure and the resulting hydrorrhea, odor, and necessity of wearing pads for protection. These experiences after cryosurgery caused 38.6% to restrict their activities and 67.1% to take medications, a significantly greater proportion than the 16.9% whose activities were restricted normal menses and the 26.8% who took medications for normal menses (P=-.004, P <.001, respectively). In addition to these experiences, obese, multigravid, and older women were more bothered by the duration of wearing pads than their counterparts (P=.0246, =.0061, and P=.0159, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

Our study showed that the cryosurgical healing process was not pleasant, and was least tolerable for obese, multigravid, and older women. As many as 50% of women undergoing cryosurgery will perceive the hydrorrhea, its odor, and the wearing of pads to be worse than normal menses, especially if their menses are usually light.

Placebo-controlled trial of indole-3-carbinol in the treatment of CIN

OBJECTIVE

Most precancerous lesions of the cervix are treated with surgery or ablative therapy. Chemoprevention, using natural and synthetic compounds, may intervene in the early precancerous stages of carcinogenesis and prevent the development of invasive disease. Our trial used indole-3-carbinol (I-3-C) administered orally to treat women with CIN as a therapeutic for cervical CIN.

METHODS

Thirty patients with biopsy proven CIN II-III were randomized to receive placebo or 200, or 400 mg/day I-3-C administered orally for 12 weeks. If persistent CIN was diagnosed by cervical biopsy at the end of the trial, loop electrocautery excision procedure of the transformation zone was performed. HPV status was assessed in all patients.

RESULTS

None (0 of 10) of the patients in the placebo group had complete regression of CIN. In contrast 4 of 8 patients in the 200 mg/day arm and 4 of 9 patients in the 400 mg/day arm had complete regression based on their 12-week biopsy. This protective effect of I-3-C is shown by a relative risk (RR) of 0.50 ((95% CI, 0. 25 to 0.99) P = 0.023) for the 200 mg/day group and a RR of 0.55 ((95% CI, 0.31 to 0.99) P = 0.032) for the 400 mg/day group. HPV was detected in 7 of 10 placebo patients, in 7 of 8 in the 200 mg/day group, and in 8 of 9 in the 400 mg/day group.

CONCLUSIONS

There was a statistically significant regression of CIN in patients treated with I-3-C orally compared with placebo. The 2/16 alpha-hydroxyestrone ratio changed in a dose-dependent fashion.

Nail disorders

Nail lesions can be related to a number of disease states. These may be intrinsic to the nail, caused by infection, or reflect systemic disease. Careful history and examination often is necessary for accurate diagnosis. Anatomy and gross changes of the nail are reviewed. The diagnosis and treatment of disease process such as psoriasis, lichen planus, paronychia, onychomycosis, myxoid cysts, and pincer nails are reviewed.

Cryotherapy of the uterine cervix

Cryotherapy is a time-proven ablative method of treating lower grades of dysplasia of the uterine cervix. Women who need cryotherapy typically have had an abnormal Papanicolaou smear tha has led to colposcopy, biopsy, and a diagnosis of cervical dysplasia. The basic procedure, indications, and outcomes of cryotherapy are reviewed. The procedure is easy to learn and perform, and can easily be applied in outpatients settings.

Colonoscopy experience at a family practice residency: a comparison to gastroenterology and general surgery services

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Colonoscopy training is receiving greater emphasis in family practice residencies. However, no standards have been established to measure the adequacy of this training. This study assessed the colonoscopy experience of family practice residents at Louisiana State University Medical Center at Shreveport (LSUMC-S).

METHODS

We included all colonoscopies performed by the family practice service between August 1992 and December 1994 and matched them by gender and age with cases from the gastroenterology (GI) and general surgery (GS) services performed during the same time period. Family practice and GI were compared using 143 cases from each service; 166 cases were used to compare family practice to GS.

RESULTS

The cecum was intubated in 87% of patients on all services. The average time to complete the procedure was 35 minutes by the family practice service, 44 minutes by GI, and 25 minutes by GS. No significant differences were found between family practice and GI in the number of patients with polyp, normal colon, or biopsy performed. In comparison to GS, there were significantly fewer patients on the family practice service with normal colon and more with multiple polyps and biopsy performed. Significantly more cancers were found by the family practice service than by either GI or GS. There were no complications reported for any of the services. Results compared favorably with data in the current literature.

CONCLUSIONS

The colonoscopy experience available to family practice residents at LSUMC-S is acceptable within the parameters studied.

Current concepts in postmenopausal hormone replacement therapy

As more women are living longer, there is an increasing need for women to discuss hormone replacement therapy (HRT) with their physicians. This task is complicated by areas of scientific uncertainty and evolving data concerning the risks and benefits of HRT. Benefits of HRT that are supported by strong scientific evidence include relief from menopausal symptoms such as hot flashes, prevention of osteoporosis, cardioprotective effects, relief of urogenital atrophy, and decreased urinary incontinence. Benefits supported by observational evidence include improvement of emotional lability and depression, improved sense of well-being in patients with rheumatoid arthritis, increased dermal and total skin thickness, improved verbal memory skills, and decreased risk of colon cancer. Risks to consider include a possible increase in the incidence of breast cancer and an increase in endometrial cancer in women who have an intact uterus and do not receive a progestin. Women in various risk groups, such as those at risk for coronary artery disease, osteoporosis, or breast cancer, must consider the risk-to-benefit ratio for their own individual circumstances.

Parent comprehension of polio vaccine information pamphlets

BACKGROUND

Medical information pamphlets often are written using language that requires a reading level higher than parents of many pediatric patients have achieved. Anecdotal reports suggest that many parents may not readily understand the federally mandated Public Health Service vaccine information pamphlets prepared by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) in 1991. The level at which the pamphlets need to be written for low-reading-level parents is undetermined, as is whether parents reading at higher levels will accept low-reading-level materials.

METHODS

To determine whether a simple pamphlet prepared at a low reading level using qualitative and adult education techniques would be preferable to the available CDC polio vaccine information pamphlet, we conducted an integrated qualitative-quantitative study. We compared the parent reading time and comprehension of a simplified pamphlet (Louisiana State University, LSU) comprising 4 pages, 322 words, 7 instructional graphics, and a text requiring a 6th grade reading ability with the equivalent 1991 CDC vaccine information pamphlet comprising 16 pages, 18,177 words, no graphics, and a text requiring a 10th grade reading level. We measured the reading ability of 522 parents of pediatric patients from northwest Louisiana seen at public clinics (81%) and in a private office (19%). Of the entire group, 39% were white, 60% African-American, and 1% Hispanic; the mean age was 29 years; the mean highest grade completed was 12th grade 3 months; and the reading level was less than 9th grade in 47% of parents and less than 7th grade in 20%. After parents were given one of the pamphlets to read, their reading time, comprehension, and attitude toward the pamphlet were measured.

RESULTS

Mean comprehension was 15% lower for CDC than for LSU (56% vs 72% correct; P < .001) and reading time was three times longer for CDC than for LSU (13 minutes 47 seconds vs 4 minutes 20 seconds; P < .0001). These trends were significant for parents reading at all but the lowest levels. Mean comprehension and reading time did not differ among parents reading at the third grade level or less. However, mean comprehension was greater and reading time lower for LSU among parents at all reading abilities greater than the third grade. Parents in the private practice setting took the longest time to read the CDC (20 minutes 59 seconds vs 5 minutes 46 seconds, LSU), yet their comprehension on the LSU was significantly higher than on the CDC (94% vs 71%; P < .0001). Two focus groups of high-income parents were unanimous in preferring the LSU.

CONCLUSIONS

A short, simply written pamphlet with instructional graphics was preferred by high- and low-income parents seen in private and public clinics. The sixth grade reading level appears to be too high for many parents in public clinics; new materials aimed at third to fourth grade levels may be required. The new 1994 CDC immunization materials, written at the eighth grade level, may still be inappropriately high. The American medical community should adopt available techniques for the development of more effective patient-parent education materials.

Improving patient education for patients with low literacy skills

Patients who misunderstand their diagnosis and treatment plans usually exhibit poor compliance. The 90 million adult Americans with low literacy skills struggle to understand such essential health information as discharge instructions, consent forms, oral instructions and drug labels. The Joint Commission on Accreditation of Health Organizations (JCAHO) now requires that instructions be given on a level understandable to the patient. Most physicians tend to give too much information on too high a level for many patients to understand. Physicians who speak in simpler language, repeat their instructions and demonstrate key points, while avoiding too many directives, enhance their patients' understanding. Combining easy-to-read written patient education materials with oral instructions has been shown to greatly enhance patient understanding. To be effective with patients whose literacy skills are low, patient education materials should be short and simple, contain culturally sensitive graphics and encourage desired behavior. Compliance with therapy also may be improved by including family members in the patient education process.

Literacy and self-reported educational levels in relation to Mini-mental State Examination scores

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Because of its brevity and ease of use, the Mini-mental State Examination (MMSE) is commonly used to screen and follow patients with cognitive impairment. This pilot study attempted to determine the relationships between literacy, age, and self-reported educational level and the total MMSE score.

METHODS

Cross-sectional analysis of all patients was followed by a family practice group at five local nursing homes. The associations between the patients' MMSE scores; literacy, as measured by the Rapid Estimate of Adult Literacy in Medicine (REALM); self-reported educational level; and age were determined using Pearson's correlation coefficient and stepwise multivariate linear regression.

RESULTS

A total of 105 patients completed the study. Linear regression analysis showed that MMSE scores were significantly predicted by REALM score (P < .001) and the patient's age (P < .02). However, after accounting for REALM score and age, the self-reported educational level was not related to the MMSE score (P < .8). A significant relationship was seen between the REALM score and the subjects' self-reported educational levels (r = .44, P < .001) but not the subjects' ages (r = -.17, P < 0.09). A significant linear correlation was found between the MMSE and REALM scores (r = .71, P < .0001) and a significant inverse correlation was seen between MMSE scores and the patients' ages (r = -.28, P < .004). The correlation coefficient between the patients' MMSE scores and the self-reported educational levels was .33 (P < .0007).

CONCLUSIONS

Practitioners who rely on the MMSE should be aware that patients may score in the demented range because they cannot read well enough to accurately complete the test. Literacy testing with REALM or other instruments may help identify such patients.

Noncervical human papillomavirus genital infections

The incidence of human papillomavirus infection is increasing. More than 60 types of human papillomavirus have been isolated; some types are known to have malignant potential. Differential diagnosis of the lesions includes condyloma latum, seborrheic keratoses, nevi, pearly penile papules and neoplasms. The goal in treating noncervical human papillomavirus infection is the elimination of lesions; eradication of the virus is not yet possible. Current forms of treatment include cryotherapy, podophyllum resin, podophilox, trichloroacetic acid, laser ablation, loop electrosurgical excision procedure (LEEP), fluorouracil and alpha interferon. Success in treating condyloma may be increased if the area is first soaked with 5 percent acetic acid to more clearly show the extent of the local infection. Recurrence is a problem no matter what form of therapy is used.

Effectiveness and safety of esophagogastroduodenoscopy in family practice: experience at a university medical center

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

As the use of esophagogastroduodenoscopy (EGD) by family physicians increases, a need exists to further demonstrate the procedure's clinical effectiveness and safety and the general experience of family physicians performing the procedure. This study examines the general experience of a group of family physicians performing EGDs in the university setting.

METHODS

An analysis was done of all patients undergoing EGDs performed by family physicians at a university hospital during a consecutive 27-month period. Demographics, indications, findings, diagnoses, therapy, complications, and biopsies were analyzed. Clinical effectiveness was measured by recording whether an EGD resulted in changes in diagnosis, medical therapy, or clinical management. Endoscopic diagnoses also were correlated with biopsy pathological diagnoses.

RESULTS

During the study period, 188 EGDs were performed. Clinical management of patients was changed in 88.6% of cases. The diagnosis was changed in 81.8% of cases, and drug therapy was changed in 55.7% of cases. Endoscopic impressions were confirmed by biopsy in 93.2% of cases. Procedures were completed in 98.3% of cases with no complications.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates the clinical effectiveness of EGDs performed by family physicians. The feasibility of family practice endoscopy in the university medical center setting has been demonstrated, and continued benefits from this practice are anticipated.

Procedural training in family practice residencies: current status and impact on resident recruitment

BACKGROUND

Although procedural training in family practice has recently received greater emphasis, the current status of this training in residency programs has not been reported. Considerable variation in procedural training among family practice residencies is allowed by the American Board of Family Practice and accreditation requirements. This study was performed to report the current status of procedural training in family practice residencies and to determine whether a correlation exists between the number of procedures taught in family practice residencies and successful resident recruitment.

METHODS

A one-page questionnaire was developed to determine availability of teaching and type of instructor for 24 selected procedures. This questionnaire was mailed to all 398 family practice residency directors in the United States. Data from the survey were compared with the published residency match results in 1993 and 1994.

RESULTS

Questionnaires were received from 363 programs, for a response rate of 91 percent. The current status of training in these procedures, presented by program type and geographic region, reflects considerable regional variation. Training in colposcopy and in cardiac stress testing was reported to be available in a greater percentage of programs than in previous studies. A significant positive correlation was found between the number of procedures taught by family physicians and residency match results.

CONCLUSIONS

The 91 percent response rate lends credibility to this status report and indicates that family practice program directors recognize procedural training as an important issue. The trend toward greater availability of procedural training in family practice residencies is confirmed for selected procedures. Emphasis on procedural training by family physicians has a positive correlation with successful resident recruiting. The impact on medical student interest in family practice deserves further study.

A comparison of the reliability of repeat cervical smears and colposcopy in patients with abnormal cervical cytology

BACKGROUND

To determine the reliability of repeat cervical smears (Papanicolaou smears) in patients who have had an abnormal initial smear, prospective data were collected on patients being followed up for a previously abnormal cervical smear.

METHODS

All 428 patients who were referred for colposcopy because of abnormal cervical smears underwent simultaneous cervical smears and coloposcopy with directed biopsy. Patients with colposcopic evidence of invasive carcinoma or a history of prior colposcopy were excluded. Cervical smear results were compared with the histologic findings on colposcopically directed biopsy. The ability of cervical smears to identify cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN) and high-grade lesions (CIN 2 and 3) were also calculated for the repeat cervical smear.

RESULTS

The sensitivity of repeat Papanicolau screening for CIN was 48%. When differentiating high-grade lesions from low-grade and benign biopsies, the sensitivity of the repeat cervical smear was only 25%. Of 110 patients with biopsy-proven high-grade lesions, 68% had low-grade initial cervical smears and 73% had low-grade or benign repeat cervical smear cytology.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates that repeated Pap smears often fail to identify high-grade lesions and that the sensitivity of a repeat cervical smear is very low in patients with low-grade abnormalities found on routine screening examinations. Using follow-up cervical smears to monitor patients who have low-grade squamous intraepithelial lesions (LGSIL) carries unacceptable risks. A more reliable diagnostic test such as colposcopy is indicated.

Reading ability of parents compared with reading level of pediatric patient education materials

OBJECTIVES

To test the reading ability of parents of pediatric outpatients and to compare their reading ability with the ability necessary to read commonly used educational materials; to compare individual reading grade levels with the levels of the last grade completed in school; and to further validate a new literacy screening test designed specifically for medical settings.

DESIGN

Prospective survey.

SETTING

Pediatrics outpatient clinic in a large, public university, teaching hospital.

PARTICIPANTS

Three hundred ninety-six parents or other caretakers accompanying pediatric outpatients.

MEASUREMENTS

Demographics and educational status were assessed using a structured interview. Reading ability was tested using the Rapid Estimate of Adult Literacy in Medicine (REALM) and the Wide Range Achievement Test-Revised. Written educational materials were assessed for readability levels with a computer program (Grammatik IV).

RESULTS

The mean score on the REALM for all parents placed them in the seventh to eighth grade reading range, despite the mean self-reported last grade completed in school being 11th grade 5th month. Wide Range Achievement Test-Revised scores correlated well with REALM scores (0.82). Eighty percent of 129 written materials from the American Academy of Pediatrics, the Centers for Disease Control, the March of Dimes, pharmaceutical companies, and commercially available baby books required at least a 10th grade reading level. Only 25% of 60 American Academy of Pediatrics items and 19% of all materials tested were written at less than a ninth grade level, and only 2% of all materials were written at less than a seventh grade level.

CONCLUSION

This study demonstrates that parents' self-reported education level will not accurately indicate their reading ability. Testing is needed to screen at-risk parents for low reading levels. In a public health setting, a significant amount of available parent education materials and instructions require a higher reading level than most parents have achieved. In such settings, all materials probably should be written at less than a high school level if most parents are to be expected to read them. The REALM can easily be used in busy public health clinics to screen parents for reading ability.

Rapid estimate of adult literacy in medicine: a shortened screening instrument

BACKGROUND

This study was conducted to validate a shortened version of the Rapid Estimate of Adult Literacy in Medicine (REALM). This screening instrument is designed to be used in public health and primary care settings to identify patients with low reading levels. It provides reading grade estimates for patients who read below a ninth-grade level. The REALM can be administered in one to two minutes by personnel with minimal training.

METHODS

Two hundred and three patients in four university hospital clinics (internal medicine, family practice, ambulatory care, and obstetrics/gynecology) were given the REALM and three other standardized reading tests: the reading recognition section of the Peabody Individual Achievement Test-Revised (PIAT-R), the Wide Range Achievement Test-Revised (WRAT-R), and the Slosson Oral Reading Test-Revised (SORT-R). One hundred inmates at a state prison were also given the REALM twice, one week apart, to determine test-retest reliability.

RESULTS

The REALM correlated well with the three other tests. (Correlation coefficients were 0.97 [PIAT-R], 0.96 [SORT-R], and 0.88 [WRAT-R].) All correlations were significant at P < .0001. Test-retest reliability was 0.99 (P < .001).

CONCLUSIONS

The REALM provides an estimate of patient reading ability, displays excellent concurrent validity with standardized reading tests, and is a practical instrument for busy primary care settings.

Reading ability in patients in substance misuse treatment centers

Adult inpatients in state-supported (public) and private substance misuse treatment settings were tested for reading ability. Patient education materials and consent forms were assessed for readability levels. Public patients' mean reading levels were significantly lower than those of private patients, and were 4 to 5 years below the level needed to read and understand standard treatment materials. More than half of the public and almost one-third of the private patients tested were reading below a 9th grade level. Standard treatment materials were written on 11th to 12th grade reading levels; admission and consent forms were written on 12th to 18th grade levels. Patients in substance misuse settings should be tested for literacy levels upon admission and provided with materials commensurate with their reading ability.

Why first-year family practice residents choose their residency programs

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

This study identifies some of the factors that influenced program selection by first-year family practice residents.

METHODS

In a national survey, 660 new first-year residents from 159 family practice programs responded to a questionnaire that asked them to cite the most important factors in choosing their program and rejecting other programs.

RESULTS

The most important factors in selecting a program were location, reputation, faculty, and residents. The most important factors in deciding against other programs were location, reputation, residents, and curriculum.

CONCLUSION

Our findings suggest that recruiters of first-year family practice residents need to address these factors in their recruiting efforts.

Loop electrosurgical excisional procedure

Loop electrosurgical excisional procedure, or LEEP, also known as loop diathermy treatment, loop excision of the transformation zone (LETZ), and large loop excision of the transformation zone (LLETZ), is a new technique for outpatient diagnosis and treatment of dysplastic cervical lesions. This procedure produces good specimens for cytologic evaluation, carries a low risk of affecting childbearing ability, and is likely to replace cryotherapy or laser treatment for cervical neoplasias. LEEP uses low-current, high-frequency electrical generators and thin stainless steel or tungsten loops to excise either lesions or the entire transformation zone. Complication rates are comparable to cryotherapy or laser treatment methods and include bleeding, incomplete removal of the lesion, and cervical stenosis. Compared with other methods, the advantages of LEEP include: removal of abnormal tissue in a manner permitting cytologic study, low cost, ease of acquiring necessary skills, and the ability to treat lesions with fewer visits. Patient acceptance of the procedure is high. Widespread use of LEEP by family physicians can be expected.