Overlapping network meta-analyses on psoriasis systemic treatments: an overview, quantity does not make quality

BACKGROUND

Network Meta-analyses (NMAs) have become successful in addressing gaps in the comparative effectiveness of systemic treatments in moderate-to-severe psoriasis. However, their increasing number carries both a risk of overlap and reproducibility issues that can hamper clinical decision-making. In this overview, we aimed to assess redundancy across these NMAs and to describe their characteristics.

METHODS

We considered all systematic reviews with NMAs of randomized controlled trials that included adult patients with moderate-to-severe psoriasis and that evaluated the efficacy and/or safety of systemic treatments compared with placebo or with an active comparator. PubMed/MEDLINE, Epistemonikos, PROSPERO and the Evidence Update of the Centre of Evidence-Based Dermatology of the University of Nottingham were searched up to 25 February 2021. Our main outcome was the number per year of redundant NMAs and the extent of their overlap. We also described their features, especially, the confidence in the results of the reviews, the studies' funding and the presence of spin (a description that overstates efficacy and/or understates harm), reporting issues and methodological characteristics.

RESULTS

In total, 47 redundant NMAs were included. Only 2/47 (4%) included all available treatments. Both efficacy and safety were evaluated in 14/47 (30%) NMAs and both short and long-term evaluations were assessed in 5/47 (11 %). Confidence in the results was critically low for 39/47 (83%) NMAs and only 10/47 (23 %) registered a protocol. 26/47 NMAs (55%) received pharmaceutical funding. CROs were involved in 19/47 (40%) NMAs. Reporting was poor across most of the NMAs' abstracts and spin was present in all of the abstracts. Almost half of the NMA failed to consider important limitations such as heterogeneity (32%) or consistency (66%).

DISCUSSION

In addition to a duplication of efforts, our overview showed heterogeneous methods and poor confidence in the results in a majority of the included NMAs, further distorted by reporting issues and spin. Clinicians need to interpret NMAs with caution when looking for the most reliable and comprehensive evidence.

International multicentre observational study to assess the efficacy and safety of a 0·5 mg kg-1 per day starting dose of oral corticosteroids to treat bullous pemphigoid

BACKGROUND

European guidelines propose a 0·5 mg kg^-1 per day dose of oral prednisone as initial treatment for bullous pemphigoid (BP). We assessed the safety and efficacy of this regimen depending on BP extent and general condition of the patients.

METHODS

In a prospective international study, we consecutively included all patients diagnosed with BP. Patients received a 0·5 mg kg^-1 per day dose of prednisone, which was then gradually tapered 15 days after disease control, with the aim of stopping prednisone or maintaining minimal treatment (0·1 mg kg^-1 per day) within 6 months after the start of treatment. The two coprimary endpoints were control of disease activity at day 21 and 1-year overall survival. Disease severity was assessed according to the Bullous Pemphigoid Disease Area Index (BPDAI) score.

RESULTS

In total, 198 patients were included between 2015 and 2017. The final analysis comprised 190 patients with a mean age of 80·9 (SD 9·1) years. Control of disease activity was achieved at day 21 in 119 patients [62·6%, 95% confidence interval (CI) 55·3-69.5]; 18 of 24 patients (75%, 95% CI 53·3-90·2), 75 of 110 patients (68·8%, 95% CI 59·2-77·3) and 26 of 56 patients (46.4%, 95% CI 33·0-60·3) had mild, moderate and severe BP, respectively (P = 0·0218). A total of 30 patients died during the study. The overall Kaplan-Meier 1-year survival was 82·6% (95% CI 76·3-87·4) corresponding to 90·9%, 83·0% and 80·0% rates in patients with mild, moderate and severe BP, respectively (P = 0·5). Thresholds of 49 points for BPDAI score and 70 points for Karnofsky score yielded maximal Youden index values with respect to disease control at day 21 and 1-year survival, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

A 0·5 mg kg^-1 per day dose of prednisone is a valuable therapeutic option in patients with mild or moderate BP whose general condition allows them to be autonomous.

Evaluation of timolol maleate gel for management of hard-to-heal chronic venous leg ulcers. Phase II randomised-controlled study

BACKGROUND

Venous leg ulcers (VLUs) often take a very long time to heal. Timolol maleate has been reported as displaying efficacy in healing of VLUs.

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the efficacy of timolol maleate gel in the management of hard-to-heal VLUs and to assess its safety as a topical agent during 12 weeks of use in combination with conventional treatment.

METHODS

A prospective, phase-II randomised-controlled trial with a sample size based on Fleming's one-stage design (P0=0.25, P1=0.45, alpha=0.1, beta=0.2) was planned. Patients with VLUs present for ≥24 weeks and with ≥50% granulation tissue were included. One drop of sustained-release timolol gel (Timoptol® LP 0.5%, Santen, Tampere, Finland) per 6 cm² VLU area was applied every 2 days for 12 weeks in timolol-treated patients, as adjuvant therapy to the standard care protocol (interface dressing and multilayer venous compression). Controls received standard care alone. The primary endpoint was to obtain ≥40% reduction in ulcer area at week 12 (W12).

RESULTS

Forty-three patients were randomised to the study, with 40 receiving at least one treatment and included in the analysis: 21 timolol-treated patients and 19 controls (females: 70%; median age: 72.5 [range 35-93] years). At W12, ≥40% ulcer-area reduction was achieved in 14/21 (67%) timolol-treated patients vs. 6/19 (32%) controls. No serious adverse events occurred. Local wound infections not requiring systemic antibiotics occurred in 5 cases in the timolol group and in one case in the controls.

CONCLUSIONS

These results support the benefit and safety of using timolol maleate to manage hard-to-heal VLUs, but confirmation is required in a larger multicentre randomised phase-III study.

Severe erosive gingivostomatitis in a patient treated by vedolizumab

Vedolizumab is a humanized monoclonal antibody that binds to the human a4β7 integrin and is approved for use in inflammatory bowel diseases. We describe a patient with severe, refractory erosive gingivostomatitis, which appeared a few days after the first dose of vedolizumab and resolved after discontinuation of the drug. We believe the gingivostomatitis to be a direct side effect of vedolizumab, rather than an extraintestinal manifestation of the underlying inflammatory bowel diseases. The clinicians need to be aware of this adverse event, which could be mistakenly considered as an extraintestinal manifestation of inflammatory bowel diseases.

[Cytopenia under topical imiquimod in two patients treated with oral hydroxyurea]

BACKGROUND

Aldara^® is a topical immunomodulatory treatment. The risks of systemic passage are minimal. There have been rare reports of systemic adverse effects.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Case 1. Five sachets weekly of imiquimod were prescribed for Bowen's disease on the forearm in a patient known to have essential thrombocytosis under Hydrea^®. His CBC was normal (6000 leukocytes/mm³, 2200 PMN/mm, 230,000 platelets/mm³). Imiquimod was given in 15 sachets weekly. Fifteen day later, the patient presented bicytopenia (3000 leukocytes/mm³, 1400 PMN/mm³, 119,000 platelets/mm³). Hydroxyurea and imiquimod were suspended until normalization of CBC. Hydroxyurea was resumed without recurrence of the bicytopenia. The patient's history included an identical episode following application of imiquimod. Case 2. Five sachets weekly of imiquimod were prescribed for actinic keratosis on the scalp in a patient known to have primary polycythemia under hydroxyurea. Her CBC was normal except for anemia (Hb 11.5g/L, 160,000 platelets/mm³, 1100 lymphocytes/mm³). Imiquimod was given in 12 sachets weekly. Ten days later, anemia increased (Hb 10g/dL) with lymphopenia (800/mm³) and thrombocytopenia (115,000/mm³). Suspension of imiquimod resulted in normalization of the previous CBC values.

DISCUSSION

. The literature review identified reports of dose-dependent lymphopenia under oral imiquimod but not under Aldara^®. The National Pharmacovigilance Database listed 10 cases of hematological disorders most likely caused by Aldara^®. Hydroxyurea may induce cytopenia, and while it was not considered the sole causative agent in this case, it is likely to have had a triggering role in these patients with blood dyscrasias. Our findings show that misuse of imiquimod carries a potential risk of hematologic abnormality in patients receiving concomitant hydroxyurea, a commonly combined drug.

Severe cutaneous adverse reactions due to inappropriate medication use

BACKGROUND

The proportion of severe cutaneous adverse reactions (SCARs) that could be avoided if medication use was consistent with good medical practice is unknown.

OBJECTIVES

To estimate the proportion of SCARs related to inappropriate medication use.

METHODS

We carried out a retrospective study of all validated SCARs collected in a French registry between 2003 and 2016. For each case, all plausible drugs suspected of inducing SCARs (i.e. not just the drug regarded as 'the most probable') were considered with regard to (i) prescription for an inappropriate indication, (ii) unintentional rechallenge despite a previous allergy to the drug or (iii) self-medication with prescription medicines.

RESULTS

In total, 602 cases were included in the analyses. Antibiotics, anticonvulsants and allopurinol were the drugs most frequently involved, accounting for more than 50% of all cases. All suspected medications were considered to have been appropriately used for 417 of the 602 individuals included in the study population [69·3%, 95% confidence interval (CI) 65·6-73·0] and inappropriately used for 144 individuals (23·9%, 95% CI 20·5-27·3). These inappropriate uses were due mainly to prescriptions for an inappropriate indication (65·8%, 95% CI 58·4-73·2) or unintentional rechallenge (20·9%, 95% CI 14·6-27·2). Allopurinol and co-trimoxazole were the drugs most frequently involved in inappropriate indications. Antibiotics were the largest group involved in unintentional rechallenge. Nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs, available on prescription, were most frequently involved in inappropriate self-medication.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results underline the need for respecting the appropriate indication for drugs in order to reduce the incidence of SCARs. Reducing unintentional rechallenge also seems to be a necessary preventive measure.

[Misdiagnosis of hidradenitis suppurativa continues to be a major issue. The R-ENS Verneuil study]

OBJECTIVE

To provide physicians with an understanding of the factors behind significant delays in the diagnosis of hidradenitis suppurativa (HS) in France.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

This prospective multicentre national study conducted from October 2015 to March 2016 included all patients consulting for HS. Patient data were collected by means of a standardized questionnaire. Univariate and multivariate analyses were conducted to collect factors associated with a significant time to diagnosis of at least 5.5years, defined as the period between the onset of initial clinical signs and the time of formal diagnosis.

RESULTS

The 16 participating centres enrolled 312 patients (62% women), of average age 35years. The average age at onset of HS was 22years. Before formal diagnosis by a dermatologist (64% of cases), 170 (54%), 114 (37%) and 45 (15%) patients had previously consulted at least 3, 5 and 10 general physicians, respectively. The average time between the initial clinical signs of HS, the first dermatology visit and the definitive diagnosis was 6.2 and 8.4 years, respectively. Active smoking (OR adjusted 1.85; P=0.027) and disease onset at a younger age (adjusted OR 0.92; P<0.001) were both associated with significant delays in diagnosis.

CONCLUSION

These results emphasized misdiagnosis among HS patients but did not evidence any association between either sociodemographic or economic characteristics and the existence of significant times to diagnosis.

Trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole-induced linear IgA bullous disease presenting as toxic epidermal necrolysis

BACKGROUND

Linear IgA bullous dermatosis (LABD) is an autoimmune blistering skin disorder characterized by linear IgA deposits along the dermoepidermal junction. Usually idiopathic, LABD can be drug-induced.

OBJECTIVE

To report the atypical characteristics of a case of trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole-induced LABD presenting as toxic epidermal necrolysis (TEN).

METHODS

A 63-year-old woman treated with trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole for Pneumocystis jirovecii infection developed a generalized maculopapular rash with herpetiform lesions, rosette-like lesions, and tense bullae with Nikolsky sign.

RESULTS

Anti-basement membrane zone antibodies were negative, but immunoblot revealed a 160 kDa band corresponding to subepidermal class IgA desmoglein 1. Skin biopsy specimens revealed a subepidermal bulla and direct immunofluorescence showed linear IgA deposition along the basement membrane zone. A diagnosis of toxic epidermal necrolysis was excluded and replaced by trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole-induced LABD.

CONCLUSION

We report a case of trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole-induced LABD with a 160 kDa IgA desmoglein 1 found by immunoblotting analysis, probably by epitope spreading.