Comparison of targeted metagenomics and IS-Pro methods for analysing the lung microbiome

Background

Targeted metagenomics and IS-Pro method are two of the many methods that have been used to study the microbiome. The two methods target different regions of the 16 S rRNA gene. The aim of this study was to compare targeted metagenomics and IS-Pro methods for the ability to discern the microbial composition of the lung microbiome of COPD patients.

Methods

Spontaneously expectorated sputum specimens were collected from COPD patients. Bacterial DNA was extracted and used for targeted metagenomics and IS-Pro method. The analysis was performed using QIIME2 (targeted metagenomics) and IS-Pro software (IS-Pro method). Additionally, a laboratory cost per isolate and time analysis was performed for each method.

Results

Statistically significant differences were observed in alpha diversity when targeted metagenomics and IS-Pro methods’ data were compared using the Shannon diversity measure (p-value = 0.0006) but not with the Simpson diversity measure (p-value = 0.84). Distinct clusters with no overlap between the two technologies were observed for beta diversity. Targeted metagenomics had a lower relative abundance of phyla, such as the Proteobacteria, and higher relative abundance of phyla, such as Firmicutes when compared to the IS-Pro method. Haemophilus, Prevotella and Streptococcus were most prevalent genera across both methods. Targeted metagenomics classified 23 % (144/631) of OTUs to a species level, whereas IS-Pro method classified 86 % (55/64) of OTUs to a species level. However, unclassified OTUs accounted for a higher relative abundance when using the IS-Pro method (35 %) compared to targeted metagenomics (5 %). The two methods performed comparably in terms of cost and time; however, the IS-Pro method was more user-friendly.

Conclusions

It is essential to understand the value of different methods for characterisation of the microbiome. Targeted metagenomics and IS-Pro methods showed differences in ability in identifying and characterising OTUs, diversity and microbial composition of the lung microbiome. The IS-Pro method might miss relevant species and could inflate the abundance of Proteobacteria. However, the IS-Pro kit identified most of the important lung pathogens, such as Burkholderia and Pseudomonas and may work in a more diagnostics-orientated setting. Both methods were comparable in terms of cost and time; however, the IS-Pro method was easier to use.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s12866-021-02288-x.

Screening for gynecologic cancer

Screening for cancer of the uterus, cervix, and ovary allows earlier detection of disease in some asymptomatic women. The screening tests commonly used have low false-negative rates and, with the exception of endometrial biopsy and endometrial washings in detection of uterine cancer, they have high false-positive rates. Conclusions concerning effectiveness of screening tests in improving the likelihood of a favorable outcome are difficult because there are no randomized trials. Without randomized trials, cost-benefit analysis of screening for gynecologic malignancies is imprecise.

The clinical pathology of heartwater. III. Changes in blood clotting, blood calcium, blood protein, haematocrit and white-cell counts in sheep with experimentally induced heartwater

Studies to evaluate changes in blood clotting, blood calcium and protein, the haematocrit and white-cell counts were undertaken in seven sheep with experimentally induced heartwater. A marked decline in thrombocyte count was recorded during the acute stage of the disease. This was associated with increases in both prothrombin time (PT) and activated partial thromboplastin time (APTT); fibrinogen increased while there was no detectable increase in fibrinogen degradation products (FDP). At the same time total serum protein (TSP), albumin and globulin dropped very sharply; total calcium showed a progressive drop but ionized calcium rose initially and was followed by a terminal decline. The total leucocyte count showed a terminal increase while the haematocrit dropped progressively.

Second-look procedures in ovarian cancer patients receiving six vs. nine courses of platinum, adriamycin, cytoxan (PAC) chemotherapy: the SCPMG experience 1982-1985

From July 1, 1982, through December 31, 1985, 100 patients with Stage I, II, or III ovarian cancer, who were clinically NED following primary chemotherapy, underwent second look laparotomy. A prospective, nonrandomized study was set up among the various institutions within the Southern California Kaiser Permanente Medical Group. Those patients being treated at the Tertiary Oncology center received six courses of PAC while patients treated at other centers received nine courses of PAC. There was no selection as to severity of disease. Patients with Stage IV disease were not subjected to second-look procedures. Twenty patients with Stage I disease received other than PAC chemotherapy. Eighty patients with Stage II and III disease received PAC chemotherapy; 39 had six courses and 41, nine courses or more of PAC. Standard second-look procedure was performed and the status of the second-look procedure was the determining factor of response. Eighteen of the 39 patients (46%) who received six courses and 26 of 41 patients (63%) who received nine courses of chemotherapy had negative second-look procedures. Sixty-five patients had Stage III ovarian cancer, 34 with six courses of therapy and 31 with nine courses of therapy. There was no statistical difference in the incidence of positive or negative second-look procedures between the groups. The therapeutic index of six courses of PAC chemotherapy was in our hands, higher than with nine courses, since there was no observed difference in the status of the second-look and there was significantly more toxicity with the nine courses of therapy.

One-way nonstimulation of mixed leukocyte culture in dog families

Fifteen dog families were studied in mixed leukocyte culture. In eight families of seven different breeds, one-way nonstimulation in mixed leukocyte culture was observed. This could be explained by lymphocyte-defined (LD) homozygosity in most instances. In one family, an inclusion phenomenon was postulated, and in another, a deletion. LD homozygotes can serve as reference for LD typing and can also help elucidate the relative role of the LD locus for transplantation of organs.