Cognitive-behavioural therapy compared with standardised medical care for adults with dissociative non-epileptic seizures: the CODES RCT

BACKGROUND

Dissociative (non-epileptic) seizures are potentially treatable by psychotherapeutic interventions; however, the evidence for this is limited.

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of dissociative seizure-specific cognitive-behavioural therapy for adults with dissociative seizures.

DESIGN

This was a pragmatic, multicentre, parallel-arm, mixed-methods randomised controlled trial.

SETTING

This took place in 27 UK-based neurology/epilepsy services, 17 liaison psychiatry/neuropsychiatry services and 18 cognitive-behavioural therapy services.

PARTICIPANTS

Adults with dissociative seizures in the previous 8 weeks and no epileptic seizures in the previous year and meeting other eligibility criteria were recruited to a screening phase from neurology/epilepsy services between October 2014 and February 2017. After psychiatric assessment around 3 months later, eligible and interested participants were randomised between January 2015 and May 2017.

INTERVENTIONS

Standardised medical care consisted of input from neurologists and psychiatrists who were given guidance regarding diagnosis delivery and management; they provided patients with information booklets. The intervention consisted of 12 dissociative seizure-specific cognitive-behavioural therapy 1-hour sessions (plus one booster session) that were delivered by trained therapists, in addition to standardised medical care.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The primary outcome was monthly seizure frequency at 12 months post randomisation. The secondary outcomes were aspects of seizure occurrence, quality of life, mood, anxiety, distress, symptoms, psychosocial functioning, clinical global change, satisfaction with treatment, quality-adjusted life-years, costs and cost-effectiveness.

RESULTS

In total, 698 patients were screened and 368 were randomised (standardised medical care alone, n = 182; and cognitive-behavioural therapy plus standardised medical care, n = 186). Primary outcome data were obtained for 85% of participants. An intention-to-treat analysis with multivariate imputation by chained equations revealed no significant between-group difference in dissociative seizure frequency at 12 months [standardised medical care: median of seven dissociative seizures (interquartile range 1-35 dissociative seizures); cognitive-behavioural therapy and standardised medical care: median of four dissociative seizures (interquartile range 0-20 dissociative seizures); incidence rate ratio 0.78, 95% confidence interval 0.56 to 1.09; p = 0.144]. Of the 16 secondary outcomes analysed, nine were significantly better in the arm receiving cognitive-behavioural therapy at a p-value < 0.05, including the following at a p-value ≤ 0.001: the longest dissociative seizure-free period in months 7-12 inclusive post randomisation (incidence rate ratio 1.64, 95% confidence interval 1.22 to 2.20; p = 0.001); better psychosocial functioning (Work and Social Adjustment Scale, standardised treatment effect -0.39, 95% confidence interval -0.61 to -0.18; p < 0.001); greater self-rated and clinician-rated clinical improvement (self-rated: standardised treatment effect 0.39, 95% confidence interval 0.16 to 0.62; p = 0.001; clinician rated: standardised treatment effect 0.37, 95% confidence interval 0.17 to 0.57; p < 0.001); and satisfaction with treatment (standardised treatment effect 0.50, 95% confidence interval 0.27 to 0.73; p < 0.001). Rates of adverse events were similar across arms. Cognitive-behavioural therapy plus standardised medical care produced 0.0152 more quality-adjusted life-years (95% confidence interval -0.0106 to 0.0392 quality-adjusted life-years) than standardised medical care alone. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (cost per quality-adjusted life-year) for cognitive-behavioural therapy plus standardised medical care versus standardised medical care alone based on the EuroQol-5 Dimensions, five-level version, and imputed data was £120,658. In sensitivity analyses, incremental cost-effectiveness ratios ranged between £85,724 and £206,067. Qualitative and quantitative process evaluations highlighted useful study components, the importance of clinical experience in treating patients with dissociative seizures and potential benefits of our multidisciplinary care pathway.

LIMITATIONS

Unlike outcome assessors, participants and clinicians were not blinded to the interventions.

CONCLUSIONS

There was no significant additional benefit of dissociative seizure-specific cognitive-behavioural therapy in reducing dissociative seizure frequency, and cost-effectiveness over standardised medical care was low. However, this large, adequately powered, multicentre randomised controlled trial highlights benefits of adjunctive dissociative seizure-specific cognitive-behavioural therapy for several clinical outcomes, with no evidence of greater harm from dissociative seizure-specific cognitive-behavioural therapy.

FUTURE WORK

Examination of moderators and mediators of outcome.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

Current Controlled Trials ISRCTN05681227 and ClinicalTrials.gov NCT02325544.

FUNDING

This project was funded by the National Institute for Health Research (NIHR) Health Technology Assessment programme and will be published in full in Health Technology Assessment; Vol. 25, No. 43. See the NIHR Journals Library website for further project information.

Can computers improve the health of the nation?

In this paper the authors consider whether the use of computers can be demonstrated to have a positive impact upon the effectiveness of health screening, in accordance with the Health of the Nationdocument. The paper is based on a study of 1.1 million patients registered with 283 general practices in the north-west region of the UK.

Outcome for infants at high risk of major handicap

Perinatal intensive care had been introduced in University College Hospital, London, by 1966. In the succeeding 10 years, 28-day mortality rates fell among infants of birth weight 1500 g or less. Among the survivors, the incidence of major handicap was 10% or less and the mean IQ increased to within the range expected for a normal population. Of the children aged 8 years or more 76% had no handicaps and were attending normal schools; 18% had minor handicaps or problems for which they were receiving extra help in normal schools; and only 6% were attending special schools. Throughout the 10 years of the study, the overall prognosis for these infants of very low birth weight improved significantly. Results among other high-risk groups were equally encouraging. Analysis of variance of the data from the infants who weighed 1500 g or less at birth indicated that perinatal complications, particularly illnesses associated with abnormal neurological signs or acidaemia in the infants around the time of birth, were the principal factors determining the condition of the survivors at follow-up. Thus, it is likely that additional refinements in the management of the perinatal period may result in further improvements in the prognosis of these and other high-risk newborns.

Outcome in breast cancer managed without an initial axillary lymph node dissection

PURPOSE

The role of an elective axillary lymph node dissection (AxLND) in the initial management of patients with early stage breast cancer has recently become controversial. The objective of this current study is to review the reasons as to why patients from a single institution were managed without an initial AxLND and their outcome in terms of survival and recurrence rates.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective analysis was conducted on 126 women referred to the Princess Margaret Hospital with the diagnosis of breast cancer who did not undergo an initial AxLND.

RESULTS

The median age of this population was 69 years, with the vast majority (93%) being post-menopausal. Fifty-seven patients had T1 tumors and the remainder had T2-3 tumors. Adjuvant radiation therapy to the breast was administered to 65 patients and systemic adjuvant treatment was administered to 24 patients. In approximately one-third of these cases, the reasons cited for not performing an AxLND were related to the patient's age, a medical contraindication, or the patient's choice. The 5-year actuarial cause-specific survival was 92%; the local breast relapse-free rate (RFR) was 85% and the axillary RFR was 86%. No patients in this study experienced debilitating symptoms from their axillary disease. Only 16 patients underwent a subsequent AxLND, with the lymph nodes being pathologically uninvolved in six of these patients.

CONCLUSION

This study supports the concept that. in selected patients, adopting an approach of a delayed AxLND does not appear to compromise the patients' outcome, with only 13% of patients requiring a subsequent AxLND.

Phylloides tumor of the breast: a report of 14 cases

The objective of this retrospective study is to determine the role of radiation therapy in the management of benign phylloides tumors. Fourteen patients with a diagnosis of benign phylloides tumor (PT) and registered at the Princess Margaret Hospital are included in the study. Definitive surgery consisted of either lumpectomy in seven patients or mastectomy in the other seven patients. One patient died of her disease, and the remaining patients had no evidence of disease at last follow-up (median 38.4 months). Among these 13 patients, 4 had at least one recurrence and the recurrence rate was higher for the group who underwent lumpectomy (43% compared with 28%). One patient was treated by lumpectomy and adjuvant radiation therapy, and had no subsequent recurrence (follow-up time 35.5 months). The role for radiation therapy in the management of this disease remains unclear.

Long-term results of concurrent radiation and chemotherapy for carcinoma of the cervix recurrent after surgery

Between 1981 and 1991, 41 patients with carcinoma of the cervix recurrent only in the pelvis, or pelvis and para-aortic nodes after initial surgery, were treated with concurrent chemo-radiation (CT-RT). The total dose of radiation was tailored to the disease extent. Radiation was delivered to the pelvis and/or pelvis plus para-aortic nodes. Concurrent infusional 5-fluorouracil 1.5 g m-2 day-1 was delivered with bid radiation for one to three courses of 3 or 4 days. In addition, 10 patients received one or two courses of intravenous mitomycin C (Mit C) 6 mg m-2. Twenty-three of 40 evaluable (58%) had a complete response to CT-RT. Five have subsequently relapsed, two in pelvis alone, one in pelvis and distant sites and two with distant metastases only. Eighteen of 40 (45%) remain alive without disease from 3 to 113 months (median 57 months) after CT-RT. Sustained complete remissions and apparent cure have occured even in poor pronosis patients with pelvic side wall or common iliac nodal diease and those recurrent at short intervals from surgery. Using logistic regression the following varibles were examined for their prognostic significance for pelvic control and survival: Mit C, extent of pelvic diseases number of course of 5-FU, nodal status at original surgery and radiation dose. On multivariate analysis only the number of courses of 5-FU used was predictive of pelvic control and survival. Concurrent 5-FU and radiation is recommended as salvage therapy for patients wth recurrent locoregional cervical cancer.

Concurrent chemoradiation in advanced cervical cancer

The pelvis is the predominant site of failure following radical radiotherapy (RT) for locally advanced cervical cancer. We report the results of phase I-II studies on 200 patients with bulky (greater than or equal to 5 cm) carcinoma of the cervix. Patients were treated between 1981 and 1988 on sequential protocols of concurrent chemoradiation to establish an acceptable treatment regimen. RT with daily or partially hyperfractionated pelvic (n = 154) or pelvic plus paraaortic (n = 46) fields was given by continuous (n = 154) or split course (n = 46) regimens. Infusional fluorouracil (5-FU) in a dose of 1 g/m2/day was given on the first and last 4 days of a 5-week course of continuous RT, or with both halves of split course RT. Seventy-eight patients received bolus mitomycin C (Mit-C), 6 mg/m2, once or twice with the start of the 5-FU infusion. The median external RT dose was 46 Gy (range 40 to 65 Gy) followed in 90% (n = 181) by a single intracavitary application of 40 Gy using a linear source of cesium-137. Median follow up is 2.5 years (range 0.6 to 6.9 years) and is sufficient to reliably estimate late toxicities. Acute toxicities were transient oral mucositis (13), RT interruption for enteritis (7), febrile neutropenia (3), and thrombocytopenic tumor bleed (1). Serious late toxicities resulted in death in 3 patients and occurred in bladder in 6 and in bowel in 25, including 8 patients with tumor recurrence. The incidence of late bowel toxicity correlated with the specific therapy given and decreased with each successive protocol. On logistic regression the only treatment variable showing a statistically significant effect on complications was the use of Mit-C (P = 0.0053). Pelvic RT and 5-FU alone produced fewer complications, only 4/105, than historically seen with standard pelvic RT alone. Three-year pelvic control and survival rates were 85 and 71% respectively in stage Ib/II (n = 100) and 50 and 42% in stage III/IV (n = 100). Encouraged by these results and decreased toxicity, we have begun a phase III study to determine whether the addition of concurrent 5-FU to continuous partially hyperfractionated pelvic RT improves local control and survival.

Concurrent radiation and chemotherapy for carcinoma of the cervix recurrent after radical surgery

Results of salvage therapy in patients with carcinoma of the cervix, recurrent after primary surgery, have been dismal even when disease was apparently confined to the pelvis. Further surgery or radiation therapy cured only some with central pelvic disease alone who had recurred at intervals longer than 6 months after primary therapy. To try to improve the results of salvage therapy, we used a combination of concurrent chemotherapy, 5-Fluorouracil with or without Mitomycin-C, and radiation therapy. Seventeen patients were treated. Recurrent disease was present in the pelvis or pelvis and paraaortic nodes after radical surgery for Stage IB carcinoma of the cervix. Eight of seventeen (47%) are alive, disease-free, 21 to 58 months after therapy. Seven of the eight had biopsy proven recurrence. Five of eight had recurred within 9 months of primary surgery and 7/8 had a component of pelvic side wall disease. Thus the survivors had unfavorable prognostic features. Nevertheless, the use of concurrent radiation and chemotherapy produced an exceptionally high proportion of sustained complete remissions and possible cures.

Concurrent radiation, mitomycin C and 5-fluorouracil in poor prognosis carcinoma of cervix: preliminary results of a phase I-II study

Between July 1981 and June 1983, 27 patients with advanced primary squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) of cervix (FIGO Stages IIIB, IVA or extensive nodal involvement) and 8 with recurrent disease were treated using a pilot regimen of combination chemotherapy (CT): Mitomycin C (MIT), 5 Fluorouracil (5 FU), and radiation therapy (RT). CT and RT doses on this Phase I-II Study were escalated to the current regimen. A split course of RT was used, either pelvic RT alone (4560 Gy in 28 fractions) or the same pelvic RT plus para-aortic RT (3600 Gy in 24 fractions). CT was given: MIT 6 mg/M2 IV push day 1, and 5 FU 1.0 g/M2 (maximum daily 1.5 g) by continuous IV infusion days 1 through 4 of each half-course of RT. This was followed by one application of intrauterine 137Cs when possible. Three of the 8 patients with recurrence in the pelvis or para-aortic nodes had a complete response (CR) to CT-RT and are alive without disease at 19, 19 and 22 months after treatment, respectively. Twenty of the 27 (74%) primary patients had a CR. With a median duration of follow-up of 6 months 4/20 have relapsed, 1 in RT field, 2 at distant sites, and 1 in both. Pelvic disease remains controlled in 19/27 (70%) including one patient salvaged with surgery. The acute toxicity of this regimen was tolerable: 2/35 developed transient leukopenia with one febrile episode, 9/35 developed transient thrombocytopenia without bleeding. Symptomatic sigmoid strictures developed in two patients, one requiring surgical intervention. Sigmoid perforation occurred in one patient and contributed to death. Typically, near complete regression of tumor is noted on completion of the external RT, reproducing the dramatic responses that have been observed in SCC of the anal canal, esophagus and head and neck, with this CT-RT regimen. A Phase III Study is required to establish whether the enhanced response rates to CT-RT will result in increased pelvic control and cure rates compared to those after RT alone.

Prognosis for infants weighing 1000 g or less at birth

During the 10 years 1966-1975, 148 infants weighing less than or equal to 1000 g were admitted to the Neonatal Unit of University College Hospital. 48 (32%) survived the neonatal period. The neonatal survival rate for infants weighing less than or equal to 750 g was 8% and for infants weighing 751-1000 g, 41% 9 infants died later, leaving 39 (26%) long-term survivors, all of whom are being followed-up. The progress of the 27 older children, born in 1966-74 (median birthweight 899 g, range 648-998 g; median gestational age 28 weeks, range 24-35 weeks), was assessed at ages between 15 months and 8 years (median 3 years). No abnormalities were detected in 21 infants (78%): 2 (7%) had major handicaps and 4 (15%) minor handicaps. We conclude that provided intensive care methods are available, the prognosis for infants weighing less than or equal to 1000 g is now better than in the past.