A one-year pilot study comparing direct-infusion high resolution mass spectrometry based untargeted metabolomics to targeted diagnostic screening for inherited metabolic diseases

Background: Early diagnosis of inherited metabolic diseases (IMDs) is important because treatment may lead to reduced mortality and improved prognosis. Due to their diversity, it is a challenge to diagnose IMDs in time, effecting an emerging need for a comprehensive test to acquire an overview of metabolite status. Untargeted metabolomics has proven its clinical potential in diagnosing IMDs, but is not yet widely used in genetic metabolic laboratories. Methods: We assessed the potential role of plasma untargeted metabolomics in a clinical diagnostic setting by using direct infusion high resolution mass spectrometry (DI-HRMS) in parallel with traditional targeted metabolite assays. We compared quantitative data and qualitative performance of targeted versus untargeted metabolomics in patients suspected of an IMD (n = 793 samples) referred to our laboratory for 1 year. To compare results of both approaches, the untargeted data was limited to polar metabolites that were analyzed in targeted plasma assays. These include amino acid, (acyl)carnitine and creatine metabolites and are suitable for diagnosing IMDs across many of the disease groups described in the international classification of inherited metabolic disorders (ICIMD). Results: For the majority of metabolites, the concentrations as measured in targeted assays correlated strongly with the semi quantitative Z-scores determined with DI-HRMS. For 64/793 patients, targeted assays showed an abnormal metabolite profile possibly indicative of an IMD. In 55 of these patients, similar aberrations were found with DI-HRMS. The remaining 9 patients showed only marginally increased or decreased metabolite concentrations that, in retrospect, were most likely to be clinically irrelevant. Illustrating its potential, DI-HRMS detected additional patients with aberrant metabolites that were indicative of an IMD not detected by targeted plasma analysis, such as purine and pyrimidine disorders and a carnitine synthesis disorder. Conclusion: This one-year pilot study showed that DI-HRMS untargeted metabolomics can be used as a first-tier approach replacing targeted assays of amino acid, acylcarnitine and creatine metabolites with ample opportunities to expand. Using DI-HRMS untargeted metabolomics as a first-tier will open up possibilities to look for new biomarkers.

A second case of glutaminase hyperactivity: Expanding the phenotype with epilepsy

Glutaminase (GLS) hyperactivity was first described in 2019 in a patient with profound developmental delay and infantile cataract. Here, we describe a 4-year-old boy with GLS hyperactivity due to a de novo heterozygous missense variant in GLS, detected by trio whole exome sequencing. This boy also exhibits developmental delay without dysmorphic features, but does not have cataract. Additionally, he suffers from epilepsy with tonic clonic seizures. In line with the findings in the previously described patient with GLS hyperactivity, in vivo 3 T magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) of the brain revealed an increased glutamate/glutamine ratio. This increased ratio was also found in urine with UPLC-MS/MS, however, inconsistently. This case indicates that the phenotypic spectrum evoked by GLS hyperactivity may include epilepsy. Clarifying this phenotypic spectrum is of importance for the prognosis and identification of these patients. The combination of phenotyping, genetic testing, and metabolic diagnostics with brain MRS and in urine is essential to identify new patients with GLS hyperactivity and to further extend the phenotypic spectrum of this disease.

Evaluation of PEG-L-asparaginase in asparagine suppression and anti-drug antibody development in healthy Beagle dogs: A multi-phase preclinical study

L-asparaginase is a frequently used drug in the treatment of canine malignant lymphoma. Since production and availability of native E. coli-derived L-asparaginase are limited, PEG-L-asparaginase (PEG-ASP) is an alternative. However, recommended doses and dosing intervals are mainly empirically determined. A multi-phase clinical dose-finding study with seven healthy Beagle dogs was conducted to find the minimum effective dose and, potentially, a dosing interval for PEG-ASP in dogs. Plasma concentrations of amino acids and PEG-ASP activity were measured at various time points after administration of different doses of PEG-ASP. Anti-PEG and anti-asparaginase antibody titres were measured. Administration of 10 IU/kg PEG-ASP resulted in asparagine depletion in all dogs, albeit for various durations: for 9 days in all dogs, 15 days in five dogs, 21 days in three dogs and 29 days in one dog. Asparagine suppression occurred at PEG-ASP plasma concentrations < 25 IU/L. Subsequent administrations of a second and third dose of 20 IU/kg and 40 IU/kg PEG-ASP resulted in asparagine suppression at < 9 days in five dogs, accompanied by the development of antibodies against PEG and L-asparaginase. Two dogs with prolonged asparagine suppression after the second and third administration did not develop antibodies. Marked individual variation in the mechanism and duration of response to PEG-ASP was noted. Antibody formation against PEG-ASP was frequently observed and sometimes occurred after one injection. This study suggests that PEG-ASP doses as high as the currently used dose of 40 IU/kg might not be needed in treatment of canine malignant lymphoma.

Monitoring phenylalanine concentrations in the follow-up of phenylketonuria patients: An inventory of pre-analytical and analytical variation

BACKGROUND

Reliable measurement of phenylalanine (Phe) is a prerequisite for adequate follow-up of phenylketonuria (PKU) patients. However, previous studies have raised concerns on the intercomparability of plasma and dried blood spot (DBS) Phe results. In this study, we made an inventory of differences in (pre-)analytical methodology used for Phe determination across Dutch laboratories, and compared DBS and plasma results.

METHODS

Through an online questionnaire, we assessed (pre-)analytical Phe measurement procedures of seven Dutch metabolic laboratories. To investigate the difference between plasma and DBS Phe, participating laboratories received simultaneously collected plasma-DBS sets from 23 PKU patients. In parallel, 40 sample sets of DBS spotted from either venous blood or capillary fingerprick were analyzed.

RESULTS

Our data show that there is no consistency on standard operating procedures for Phe measurement. The association of DBS to plasma Phe concentration exhibits substantial inter-laboratory variation, ranging from a mean difference of -15.5% to +30.6% between plasma and DBS Phe concentrations. In addition, we found a mean difference of +5.8% in Phe concentration between capillary DBS and DBS prepared from venous blood.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of our study point to substantial (pre-)analytical variation in Phe measurements, implicating that bloodspot Phe results should be interpreted with caution, especially when no correction factor is applied. To minimize variation, we advocate pre-analytical standardization and analytical harmonization of Phe measurements, including consensus on application of a correction factor to adjust DBS Phe to plasma concentrations.

Cross-Omics: Integrating Genomics with Metabolomics in Clinical Diagnostics

Next-generation sequencing and next-generation metabolic screening are, independently, increasingly applied in clinical diagnostics of inborn errors of metabolism (IEM). Integrated into a single bioinformatic method, these two –omics technologies can potentially further improve the diagnostic yield for IEM. Here, we present cross-omics: a method that uses untargeted metabolomics results of patient’s dried blood spots (DBSs), indicated by Z-scores and mapped onto human metabolic pathways, to prioritize potentially affected genes. We demonstrate the optimization of three parameters: (1) maximum distance to the primary reaction of the affected protein, (2) an extension stringency threshold reflecting in how many reactions a metabolite can participate, to be able to extend the metabolite set associated with a certain gene, and (3) a biochemical stringency threshold reflecting paired Z-score thresholds for untargeted metabolomics results. Patients with known IEMs were included. We performed untargeted metabolomics on 168 DBSs of 97 patients with 46 different disease-causing genes, and we simulated their whole-exome sequencing results in silico. We showed that for accurate prioritization of disease-causing genes in IEM, it is essential to take into account not only the primary reaction of the affected protein but a larger network of potentially affected metabolites, multiple steps away from the primary reaction.

Longitudinal Analysis of Ocular Disease in Children with Mucopolysaccharidosis I after Hematopoietic Cell Transplantation

Corneal clouding, causing visual impairment, is seen in nearly all patients with mucopolysaccharidosis type 1 (MPS-1). Hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT) is able to stabilize disease in many organs. Residual disease in several tissues is being increasingly recognized, however. Data on the effect of HCT on ocular disease in patients with MPS-1 are contradictory. With this study, we aim to clarify the long-term effects of HCT on ocular disease in these patients. Best corrected visual acuity (BCVA), refraction, intraocular pressure (IOP), and slit-lamp biomicroscopic and fundoscopic examinations, including corneal clouding, were collected prospectively from 24 patients with MPS-1 who underwent HCT successfully between 2003 and 2018 (92% with >95% chimerism and normal enzyme activity after HCT). The course of corneal clouding and BCVA after HCT were analyzed using a linear mixed model. Other parameters studied were clinical phenotype, age at time of transplantation, and hematologic enzyme activity after transplantation. Outcomes of additional ophthalmologic tests were described. In addition, IDUA and α-galactosidase A (AGAL) enzyme activity and glycosaminoglycan (GAG) concentration in tear fluid were determined. Corneal clouding stabilized in the first years after HCT but increased rapidly beyond 3 years (P < .0001). BCVA and IOP also worsened over time (P = .01 and P < .0001, respectively). IDUA activity in tear fluid remained very low (P < .0001). After initial stabilization in the cornea, ongoing ocular disease and low IDUA activity in tear fluid is seen in patients with MPS-1 despite treatment with HCT, unveiling a weak spot of current standard therapy. New therapies that overcome these shortcomings are needed to improve the late outcomes of patients.

Aspartylglycosamine is a biomarker for NGLY1-CDDG, a congenital disorder of deglycosylation

BACKGROUND

NGLY1-CDDG is a congenital disorder of deglycosylation caused by a defective peptide:N-glycanase (PNG). To date, all but one of the reported patients have been diagnosed through whole-exome or whole-genome sequencing, as no biochemical marker was available to identify this disease in patients. Recently, a potential urinary biomarker was reported, but the data presented suggest that this marker may be excreted intermittently.

METHODS

In this study, we performed untargeted direct-infusion high-resolution mass spectrometry metabolomics in seven dried blood spots (DBS) from four recently diagnosed NGLY1-CDDG patients, to test for small-molecule biomarkers, in order to identify a potential diagnostic marker. Results were compared to 125 DBS of healthy controls and to 238 DBS of patients with other diseases.

RESULTS

We identified aspartylglycosamine as the only significantly increased compound with a median Z-score of 4.8 (range: 3.8-8.5) in DBS of NGLY1-CDDG patients, compared to a median Z-score of -0.1 (range: -2.1-4.0) in DBS of healthy controls and patients with other diseases.

DISCUSSION

The increase of aspartylglycosamine can be explained by lack of function of PNG. PNG catalyzes the cleavage of the proximal N-acetylglucosamine residue of an N-glycan from the asparagine residue of a protein, a step in the degradation of misfolded glycoproteins. PNG deficiency results in a single N-acetylglucosamine residue left attached to the asparagine residue which results in free aspartylglycosamine when the glycoprotein is degraded. Thus, we here identified aspartylglycosamine as the first potential small-molecule biomarker in DBS for NGLY1-CDDG, making a biochemical diagnosis for NGLY1-CDDG potentially feasible.

Direct-infusion based metabolomics unveils biochemical profiles of inborn errors of metabolism in cerebrospinal fluid

BACKGROUND

For inborn errors of metabolism (IEM), metabolomics is performed for three main purposes: 1) development of next generation metabolic screening platforms, 2) identification of new biomarkers in predefined patient cohorts and 3) for identification of new IEM. To date, plasma, urine and dried blood spots are used. We anticipate that cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) holds additional - valuable - information, especially for IEM with neurological involvement. To expand metabolomics to CSF, we here tested whether direct-infusion high-resolution mass spectrometry (DI-HRMS) based non-quantitative metabolomics could correctly capture the biochemical profile of patients with an IEM in CSF.

METHODS

Eleven patient samples, harboring eight different IEM, and thirty control samples were analyzed using DI-HRMS. First we assessed whether the biochemical profile of the control samples represented the expected profile in CSF. Next, each patient sample was assigned a 'most probable diagnosis' by an investigator blinded for the known diagnoses of the patients.

RESULTS

the biochemical profile identified using DI-HRMS in CSF samples resembled the known profile, with - among others - the highest median intensities for mass peaks annotated with glucose, lactic acid, citric acid and glutamine. Subsequent analysis of patient CSF profiles resulted in correct 'most probable diagnoses' for all eleven patients, including non-ketotic hyperglycinaemia, propionic aciduria, purine nucleoside phosphorylase deficiency, argininosuccinic aciduria, tyrosinaemia type I, hyperphenylalaninemia and hypermethioninaemia.

CONCLUSION

We here demonstrate that DI-HRMS based non-quantitative metabolomics accurately captures the biochemical profile of this set of patients in CSF, opening new ways for using metabolomics in CSF in the metabolic diagnostic laboratory.

Identification of a Loss-of-Function Mutation in the Context of Glutaminase Deficiency and Neonatal Epileptic Encephalopathy

Importance

The identification and understanding of the monogenic causes of neurodevelopmental disorders are of high importance for personalized treatment and genetic counseling.

Objective

To identify and characterize novel genes for a specific neurodevelopmental disorder characterized by refractory seizures, respiratory failure, brain abnormalities, and death in the neonatal period; describe the outcome of glutaminase deficiency in humans; and understand the underlying pathological mechanisms.

Design, Setting, and Participants

We performed exome sequencing of cases of neurodevelopmental disorders without a clear genetic diagnosis, followed by genetic and bioinformatic evaluation of candidate variants and genes. Establishing pathogenicity of the variants was achieved by measuring metabolites in dried blood spots by a hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography method coupled with tandem mass spectrometry. The participants are 2 families with a total of 4 children who each had lethal, therapy-refractory early neonatal seizures with status epilepticus and suppression bursts, respiratory insufficiency, simplified gyral structures, diffuse volume loss of the brain, and cerebral edema. Data analysis occurred from October 2017 to June 2018.

Main Outcomes and Measures

Early neonatal epileptic encephalopathy with glutaminase deficiency and lethal outcome.

Results

A total of 4 infants from 2 unrelated families, each of whom died less than 40 days after birth, were included. We identified a homozygous frameshift variant p.(Asp232Glufs*2) in GLS in the first family, as well as compound heterozygous variants p.(Gln81*) and p.(Arg272Lys) in GLS in the second family. The GLS gene encodes glutaminase (Enzyme Commission 3.5.1.2), which plays a major role in the conversion of glutamine into glutamate, the main excitatory neurotransmitter of the central nervous system. All 3 variants probably lead to a loss of function and thus glutaminase deficiency. Indeed, glutamine was increased in affected children (available z scores, 3.2 and 11.7). We theorize that the potential reduction of glutamate and the excess of glutamine were a probable cause of the described physiological and structural abnormalities of the central nervous system.

Conclusions and Relevance

We identified a novel autosomal recessive neurometabolic disorder of loss of function of glutaminase that leads to lethal early neonatal encephalopathy. This inborn error of metabolism underlines the importance of GLS for appropriate glutamine homeostasis and respiratory regulation, signal transduction, and survival.

GLS hyperactivity causes glutamate excess, infantile cataract and profound developmental delay

Loss-of-function mutations in glutaminase (GLS), the enzyme converting glutamine into glutamate, and the counteracting enzyme glutamine synthetase (GS) cause disturbed glutamate homeostasis and severe neonatal encephalopathy. We report a de novo Ser482Cys gain-of-function variant in GLS encoding GLS associated with profound developmental delay and infantile cataract. Functional analysis demonstrated that this variant causes hyperactivity and compensatory downregulation of GLS expression combined with upregulation of the counteracting enzyme GS, supporting pathogenicity. Ser482Cys-GLS likely improves the electrostatic environment of the GLS catalytic site, thereby intrinsically inducing hyperactivity. Alignment of +/−12.000 GLS protein sequences from >1000 genera revealed extreme conservation of Ser482 to the same degree as catalytic residues. Together with the hyperactivity, this indicates that Ser482 is evolutionarily preserved to achieve optimal—but submaximal—GLS activity. In line with GLS hyperactivity, increased glutamate and decreased glutamine concentrations were measured in urine and fibroblasts. In the brain (both grey and white matter), glutamate was also extremely high and glutamine was almost undetectable, demonstrated with magnetic resonance spectroscopic imaging at clinical field strength and subsequently supported at ultra-high field strength. Considering the neurotoxicity of glutamate when present in excess, the strikingly high glutamate concentrations measured in the brain provide an explanation for the developmental delay. Cataract, a known consequence of oxidative stress, was evoked in zebrafish expressing the hypermorphic Ser482Cys-GLS and could be alleviated by inhibition of GLS. The capacity to detoxify reactive oxygen species was reduced upon Ser482Cys-GLS expression, providing an explanation for cataract formation. In conclusion, we describe an inborn error of glutamate metabolism caused by a GLS hyperactivity variant, illustrating the importance of balanced GLS activity.

Beneficial Effect of BH4 Treatment in a 15-Year-Old Boy with Biallelic Mutations in DNAJC12

BACKGROUND

Biallelic mutations in DNAJC12 were recently identified as a BH₄-responsive cause of hyperphenylalaninemia (HPA). Outcome was only favorable when treatment was initiated early in life. We report on a 15-year-old boy with HPA due to a homozygous deletion in DNAJC12 in whom - despite his advanced age - treatment was initiated.

CASE

A boy with developmental delay, an extrapyramidal movement disorder, and persistently elevated plasma phenylalanine levels was diagnosed with DNAJC12 deficiency at the age of 15 years. Diagnosis was made upon exome reanalysis revealing a homozygous 6.9 kb deletion in DNAJC12 which had not been detected by the standard exome analysis pipeline. Treatment with the BH₄ analog sapropterin dihydrochloride (10 mg/kg/day) was initiated and evoked a 50% reduction of the plasma phenylalanine levels. More strikingly, a marked improvement in daily functioning and improved exercise tolerance was noted. Additionally, gait analysis before and after treatment initiation revealed a partial normalization of his movement disorder.

CONCLUSION

Patients with hyperphenylalaninemia due to DNAJC12 deficiency may benefit from treatment with a BH₄ analog - even when introduced at a later age.

Farnesoid X Receptor Activation Promotes Hepatic Amino Acid Catabolism and Ammonium Clearance in Mice

BACKGROUND & AIMS

The nuclear receptor subfamily 1 group H member 4 (NR1H4 or farnesoid X receptor [FXR]) regulates bile acid synthesis, transport, and catabolism. FXR also regulates postprandial lipid and glucose metabolism. We performed quantitative proteomic analyses of liver tissues from mice to evaluate these functions and investigate whether FXR regulates amino acid metabolism.

METHODS

To study the role of FXR in mouse liver, we used mice with a disruption of Nr1h4 (FXR-knockout mice) and compared them with floxed control mice. Mice were gavaged with the FXR agonist obeticholic acid or vehicle for 11 days. Proteome analyses, as well as targeted metabolomics and chromatin immunoprecipitation, were performed on the livers of these mice. Primary rat hepatocytes were used to validate the role of FXR in amino acid catabolism by gene expression and metabolomics studies. Finally, control mice and mice with liver-specific disruption of Nr1h4 (liver FXR-knockout mice) were re-fed with a high-protein diet after 6 hours fasting and gavaged a ¹⁵NH₄Cl tracer. Gene expression and the metabolome were studied in the livers and plasma from these mice.

RESULTS

In livers of control mice and primary rat hepatocytes, activation of FXR with obeticholic acid increased expression of proteins that regulate amino acid degradation, ureagenesis, and glutamine synthesis. We found FXR to bind to regulatory sites of genes encoding these proteins in control livers. Liver tissues from FXR-knockout mice had reduced expression of urea cycle proteins, and accumulated precursors of ureagenesis, compared with control mice. In liver FXR-knockout mice on a high-protein diet, the plasma concentration of newly formed urea was significantly decreased compared with controls. In addition, liver FXR-knockout mice had reduced hepatic expression of enzymes that regulate ammonium detoxification compared with controls. In contrast, obeticholic acid increased expression of genes encoding enzymes involved in ureagenesis compared with vehicle in C57Bl/6 mice.

CONCLUSIONS

In livers of mice, FXR regulates amino acid catabolism and detoxification of ammonium via ureagenesis and glutamine synthesis. Failure of the urea cycle and hyperammonemia are common in patients with acute and chronic liver diseases; compounds that activate FXR might promote ammonium clearance in these patients.

Rapid quantification of underivatized amino acids in plasma by hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) coupled with tandem mass-spectrometry

BACKGROUND

Amino acidopathies are a class of inborn errors of metabolism (IEM) that can be diagnosed by analysis of amino acids (AA) in plasma. Current strategies for AA analysis include cation exchange HPLC with post-column ninhydrin derivatization, GC-MS, and LC-MS/MS-related methods. Major drawbacks of the current methods are time-consuming procedures, derivative problems, problems with retention, and MS-sensitivity. The use of hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) columns is an ideal separation mode for hydrophilic compounds like AA. Here we report a HILIC-method for analysis of 36 underivatized AA in plasma to detect defects in AA metabolism that overcomes the major drawbacks of other methods.

METHODS

A rapid, sensitive, and specific method was developed for the analysis of AA in plasma without derivatization using HILIC coupled with tandem mass-spectrometry (Xevo TQ, Waters).

RESULTS

Excellent separation of 36 AA (24 quantitative/12 qualitative) in plasma was achieved on an Acquity BEH Amide column (2.1×100 mm, 1.7 μm) in a single MS run of 18 min. Plasma of patients with a known IEM in AA metabolism was analyzed and all patients were correctly identified.

CONCLUSION

The reported method analyzes 36 AA in plasma within 18 min and provides baseline separation of isomeric AA such as leucine and isoleucine. No separation was obtained for isoleucine and allo-isoleucine. The method is applicable to study defects in AA metabolism in plasma.

A New Approach for Fast Metabolic Diagnostics in CMAMMA

BACKGROUND

The presence of increased urinary concentrations of both methylmalonic acid (MMA) and malonic acid (MA) is assumed to differentiate combined malonic and methylmalonic aciduria (CMAMMA), due to mutations in the ACSF3 gene, from other causes of methylmalonic aciduria (classic MMAemia). Detection of MA in urine, however, is challenging since excretion of MA can be easily missed. The objective of the study was to develop a method for quantification of MA in plasma to allow differentiation between CMAMMA and classic MMAemia.

METHODS

Compound heterozygosity for mutations in the ACSF3 gene was detected in two female siblings using diagnostic exome sequencing. Urine (MMA and MA) was analyzed with GC/MS, while plasma was analyzed with UPLC-MS/MS. MA/MMA ratios were calculated.

RESULTS

Both patients had a severe psychiatric presentation (at the age of 6 years and 5.5 years, respectively) after a viral infection. MA excretion in the patients was only just above the highest control value in several samples. MA concentrations in plasma from the two patients were clearly above the highest value observed in control subjects. However, MA concentrations in plasma from patients with classic MMAemia were also elevated. Additional, calculation of MA/MMA ratio in plasma allowed to fully differentiate between CMAMMA and classic MMAemia.

CONCLUSIONS

Calculating the MA/MMA ratio in plasma allows differentiation between CMAMMA and classic MMAemia. The full clinical spectrum of CMAMMA remains to be delineated.

[Metabolic diseases in psychiatry]

Metabolic diseases can be associated with psychiatric symptoms. We present two case histories that demonstrate the importance of correctly diagnosing a metabolic disease as being the cause of psychiatric symptoms. We also discuss which symptoms or signals may indicate a metabolic disease.

Key features and clinical variability of COG6-CDG

The conserved oligomeric Golgi (COG) complex consists of eight subunits and plays a crucial role in Golgi trafficking and positioning of glycosylation enzymes. Mutations in all COG subunits, except subunit 3, have been detected in patients with congenital disorders of glycosylation (CDG) of variable severity. So far, 3 families with a total of 10 individuals with biallelic COG6 mutations have been described, showing a broad clinical spectrum. Here we present 7 additional patients with 4 novel COG6 mutations. In spite of clinical variability, we delineate the core features of COG6-CDG i.e. liver involvement (9/10), microcephaly (8/10), developmental disability (8/10), recurrent infections (7/10), early lethality (6/10), and hypohidrosis predisposing for hyperthermia (6/10) and hyperkeratosis (4/10) as ectodermal signs. Regarding all COG6-related disorders a genotype-phenotype correlation can be discerned ranging from deep intronic mutations found in Shaheen syndrome as the mildest form to loss-of-function mutations leading to early lethal CDG phenotypes. A comparison with other COG deficiencies suggests ectodermal changes to be a hallmark of COG6-related disorders. Our findings aid clinical differentiation of this complex group of disorders and imply subtle functional differences between the COG complex subunits.

Impaired cognitive functioning in patients with tyrosinemia type I receiving nitisinone

OBJECTIVE

To examine cognitive functioning in patients with tyrosinemia type I treated with nitisinone and a protein-restricted diet.

STUDY DESIGN

We performed a cross-sectional study to establish cognitive functioning in children with tyrosinemia type I compared with their unaffected siblings. Intelligence was measured using age-appropriate Wechsler Scales. To assess cognitive development over time, we retrieved sequential IQ scores in a single-center subset of patients. We also evaluated whether plasma phenylalanine and tyrosine levels during treatment was correlated with cognitive development.

RESULTS

Average total IQ score in 10 patients with tyrosinemia type I receiving nitisinone was significantly lower compared with their unaffected siblings (71 ± 13 vs 91 ± 13; P = .008). Both verbal and performance IQ subscores differed (77 ± 14 vs 95 ± 11; P < .05 and 70 ± 11 vs 87 ± 15; P < .05, respectively). Repeated IQ measurements in a single-center subset of 5 patients revealed a decline in average IQ score over time, from 96 ± 15 to 69 ± 11 (P < .001). No significant association was found between IQ score and either plasma tyrosine or phenylalanine concentration.

CONCLUSION

Patients with tyrosinemia type I treated with nitisinone are at risk for impaired cognitive function despite a protein-restricted diet.