Recent advances in lithotripsy technology and treatment strategies: A systematic review update

INTRODUCTION

Shock wave lithotripsy (SWL) is a well - established treatment option for urolithiasis. The technology of SWL has undergone significant changes in an attempt to better optimize the results while reducing failure rates. There are some important limitations that restrict the use of SWL. In this review, we aim to place these advantages and limitations in perspective, assess the current role of SWL, and discuss recent advances in lithotripsy technology and treatment strategies.

METHODS

A comprehensive review was conducted to identify studies reporting outcomes on ESWL. We searched for literature (PubMed, Embase, Medline) that focused on the physics of shock waves, theories of stone disintegration, and studies on optimising shock wave application. Relevant articles in English published since 1980 were selected for inclusion.

RESULTS

Efficacy has been shown to vary between lithotripters. To maximize stone fragmentation and reduce failure rates, many factors can be optimized. Factors to consider in proper patient selection include skin - to - stone distance and stone size. Careful attention to the rate of shock wave administration, proper coupling of the treatment head to the patient have important influences on the success of lithotripsy.

CONCLUSION

Proper selection of patients who are expected to respond well to SWL, as well as attention to the technical aspects of the procedure are the keys to SWL success. Studies aiming to determine the mechanisms of shock wave action in stone breakage have begun to suggest new treatment strategies to improve success rates and safety.

Renal inter-alpha-trypsin inhibitor heavy chain 3 increases in calcium oxalate stone-forming patients

Inter-alpha-trypsin inhibitor heavy-chain proteins bind to the protease inhibitor bikunin and to hyaluronan, stabilizes extracellular matrix in various tissues, and also inhibits calcium oxalate crystallization in vitro. In both normal and stone-forming patients, we found heavy chain 3 and hyaluronan in the interstitial matrix of the kidney. Osteopontin was found in the collecting duct, thin loop of Henle, and urothelial cells. In stone formers, heavy chain 3 was also present in collecting duct, thin loop, and interstitial cells. Heavy chain 3 and osteopontin colocalized in plaque matrix and urothelial cells. Within individual plaque spherules, heavy chain 3 was found in the matrix layer while osteopontin was located along the crystal-matrix interface. Bikunin was present only in the collecting duct apical membranes and the loop cell cytoplasm of stone formers colocalizing with osteopontin and heavy chain 3. Widespread heavy chain 3 was only present in stone formers, whereas osteopontin was similarly expressed in normal and stone-forming subjects except for its localization in plaques of the stone formers. This is consistent with studies linking inter-alpha-trypsin inhibitor components to human stone disease, although their role is still unclear. Heavy chain 3 may also play a role in stabilizing hyaluronan in the renal interstitial matrix.

Renal crystal deposits and histopathology in patients with cystine stones

We have biopsied the papillae of patients who have cystine stones asking if this stone type is associated with specific tissue changes. We studied seven cystine stone formers (SF) treated with percutaneous nephrolithotomy using digital video imaging of renal papillae for mapping and obtained papillary biopsies. Biopsies were analyzed by routine light and electron microscopy, infrared spectroscopy, electron diffraction, and micro-CT. Many ducts of Bellini (BD) had an enlarged ostium, and all such were plugged with cystine crystals, and had injured or absent lining cells with a surrounding interstitium that was inflamed to fibrotic. Crystal plugs often projected into the urinary space. Many inner medullary collecting ducts (IMCD) were dilated with or without crystal plugging. Apatite crystals were identified in the lumens of loops of Henle and IMCD. Abundance of interstitial Randall's plaque was equivalent in amount to that of non-SF. In the cortex, glomerular obsolescence and interstitial fibrosis exceeded normal. Cystine crystallizes in BD with the probable result of cell injury, interstitial reaction, nephron obstruction, and with the potential of inducing cortical change and loss of IMCD tubular fluid pH regulation, resulting in apatite formation. The pattern of IMCD dilation, and loss of medullary structures is most compatible with such obstruction, either from BD lumen plugs or urinary tract obstruction from stones themselves.

Lower pole I: a prospective randomized trial of extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy and percutaneous nephrostolithotomy for lower pole nephrolithiasis-initial results

PURPOSE

The efficacy of shock wave lithotripsy and percutaneous stone removal for the treatment of symptomatic lower pole renal calculi was determined.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A prospective randomized, multicenter clinical trial was performed comparing shock wave lithotripsy and percutaneous stone removal for symptomatic lower pole only renal calculi 30 mm. or less.

RESULTS

Of 128 patients enrolled in the study 60 with a mean stone size of 14.43 mm. were randomized to percutaneous stone removal (58 treated, 2 awaiting treatment) and 68 with a mean stone size of 14.03 mm. were randomized to shock wave lithotripsy (64 treated, 4 awaiting treatment). Followup at 3 months was available for 88% of treated patients. The 3-month postoperative stone-free rates overall were 95% for percutaneous removal versus 37% lithotripsy (p <0.001). Shock wave lithotripsy results varied inversely with stone burden while percutaneous stone-free rates were independent of stone burden. Stone clearance from the lower pole following shock wave lithotripsy was particularly problematic for calculi greater than 10 mm. in diameter with only 7 of 33 (21%) patients becoming stone-free. Re-treatment was necessary in 10 (16%) lithotripsy and 5 (9%) percutaneous cases. There were 9 treatment failures in the lithotripsy group and none in the percutaneous group. Ancillary treatment was necessary in 13% of lithotripsy and 2% percutaneous cases. Morbidity was low overall and did not differ significantly between the groups (percutaneous stone removal 22%, shock wave lithotripsy 11%, p =0.087). In the shock wave lithotripsy group there was no difference in lower pole anatomical measurements between kidneys in which complete stone clearance did or did not occur.

CONCLUSIONS

Stone clearance from the lower pole following shock wave lithotripsy is poor, especially for stones greater than 10 mm. in diameter. Calculi greater than 10 mm. in diameter are better managed initially with percutaneous removal due to its high degree of efficacy and acceptably low morbidity.

Effect of radiographic contrast material exposure on spiral CT attenuation of renal calculi

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

The authors performed this study to determine whether exposure of renal calculi to radiographic contrast material has an effect on the attenuation values at computed tomography (CT) performed with varying collimation widths.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Renal calculi (23 stones of various composition) were scanned with 1-, 3-, and 10-mm collimation. Stones were then exposed to a solution of radiographic contrast material for 5 minutes, washed with water, and rescanned 36 hours later. The reproducibility of the CT attenuation measurements on different days was evaluated by obtaining measurements in a subset of 16 renal stones on 4 different days.

RESULTS

There was no statistically significant change in attenuation after contrast material exposure at narrow collimation. At wider collimation, statistically significant increases were noted in both attenuation and standard deviation. A small amount of variability between readings was noted on different days, with a minimal increase in attenuation each day. Correlation between readings remained very high.

CONCLUSION

Exposure of stones to a radiographic contrast material had a statistically significant effect on CT attenuation values only at wide collimation. This may be related to technical factors including volume averaging. Absence of an effect at narrow collimation suggests that the attenuation values of renal stones do not significantly change after exposure to contrast material.

Holmium laser prostatectomy

Holmium laser prostatectomy has evolved in the last decade to reproduce the short- and long-term results of both transurethral and open prostatectomy. This article discusses our surgical approach at the Methodist Hospital of Indiana as well as offers a review of the literature of holmium prostatectomy.

Correction of helical CT attenuation values with wide beam collimation: in vitro test with urinary calculi

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES

Urinary calculi are now commonly detected with helical computed tomography (CT), and it has been proposed that stone composition can be determined from CT attenuation values. However, typical scans are made with a beam collimation of 5 mm or more, resulting in volume averaging and reduction in accuracy of attenuation measurement. The authors tested a model for correction of errors in attenuation values, even at section widths larger than the width of the object.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Human urinary stones were scanned with helical CT at different beam collimation widths. A computer model was used to predict the effect of beam width and stone size on accuracy of measured attenuation.

RESULTS

At 3-mm collimation, the model corrected the attenuation readings with an underestimation of 12% +/- 1 (compared with values at 1-mm collimation; 127 stones; diameters of 1.7-11.3 mm). With attenuation measured at 10-mm collimation, the model underestimated the true value by 34% +/- 3 (103 stones), with a significant negative correlation with stone diameter on magnitude of error (diameters of 3.0-11.3 mm). Correlation of data from patient scans with subsequent in vitro scanning of the same stones confirmed the validity of the model, but corrected in vivo scans consistently yielded lower values for the stones than in vitro.

CONCLUSION

Volume averaging effects on attenuation in helical CT are predictable in vitro for urinary calculi--and presumably for other roughly spherical structures--as long as section width does not excessively exceed the diameter of the structure.

Laparoscopic transverse hemicystectomy with ileocystoplasty in a porcine model

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

The ideal replacement for bladder tissue is yet to be described, although multiple alternatives have been studied. Currently, enterocystoplasty, despite its limitations, is considered the gold standard for bladder augmentation. This study evaluated the feasibility, safety, and morbidity of laparoscopic ileocystoplasty in a large-animal model.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In eight minipigs, laparoscopy was performed using four ports. A segment of ileum was delivered through a 3-cm umbilical incision and detubularized and refashioned using standard open surgical technique. Laparoscopic hemicystectomy was then performed, followed by laparoscopic suturing of the ileal patch to the bladder. The bladder was drained with a Foley catheter, but no pelvic drain was placed. All animals were followed for for a minimum of 3 months. Preoperative and postoperative evaluation included measurement of bladder capacity, ultrasound imaging of the kidneys, blood counts, and serum electrolyte and creatinine measurements. Two of the animals were sacrificed at 3 months and one at 6 months, and the bladders were harvested.

RESULTS

Eight animals underwent ileocystoplasty without intraoperative or postoperative complications. The average operating and anastomosis time was 250 minutes and 96 minutes, respectively. All animals had normal preoperative blood values that remained normal during follow-up. Bladder capacity decreased initially to 71% of the baseline volume and then increased to 83% and 117% at 3 and 6 months. One of three animals sacrificed was noted to have a right midureteral stricture.

CONCLUSIONS

We developed a reliable laparoscopic technique for ileocystoplasty that may extend the advantages of laparoscopy, including better cosmesis and reduced risk of postoperative adhesions, to bladder augmentation.

Holmium laser enucleation for prostate adenoma greater than 100 gm.: comparison to open prostatectomy

PURPOSE

Options for treatment of large (greater than 100 gm.) prostatic adenomas have until now been limited to open surgery or transurethral resection by skilled resectionists. Considerable blood loss, morbidity, extended hospital stay and prolonged recovery occur with open surgery for large prostatic adenomas. Endoscopic surgery for benign prostatic hyperplasia has evolved during the last decade to offer the patient and surgeon significant advantages of transurethral removal of prostatic adenomas. Holmium laser enucleation of the prostate with transurethral tissue morcellation provides significant reductions in morbidity, bleeding and hospital stay for patients with large prostate adenomas.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective review of data on 10 cases of holmium laser enucleation and 10 open prostatectomies for greater than 100 gm. prostatic adenomas was performed from 1998 to 1999 at our institution. Patient demographics, indication for surgery, preoperative and postoperative American Urological Association (AUA) symptom scores, operating time, serum hemoglobin, resected prostatic weight, pathological diagnosis, length of stay and complications were compared.

RESULTS

Patient age, indications for surgery (retention, failed medical therapy, high post-void residual, bladder calculi, bladder diverticula and azotemia) and preoperative AUA symptom scores were similar in both groups. Postoperative AUA symptom scores were significantly decreased (p <0.004) in both groups. Operating times were not significantly different. Serum sodium was unchanged by holmium laser enucleation (not significant), and postoperative hemoglobin was not significantly reduced in the holmium laser enucleation group but decreased significantly in the open prostatectomy group (mean decrease 2.9 +/- 0.7 gm., p = 0.0003). Resected weight was greater in the holmium laser enucleation group (151 versus 106 gm., p = 0.07). Length of stay was significantly shorter in the holmium laser enucleation group (2.1 versus 6.1 days, p <0.001). Complications in the holmium laser enucleation group included stress urinary incontinence in 4 cases, prostatic perforation in 1 and urinary retention in 1. No patient treated with holmium laser enucleation was discharged home with an indwelling catheter. Complications in the open prostatectomy group included bladder neck contractures in 2 cases, stress incontinence in 1 and urge incontinence in 1. All patients treated with open prostatectomy were discharged home with an indwelling catheter.

CONCLUSIONS

Holmium laser enucleation is an effective, safe procedure for large prostatic adenomas with significantly lower morbidity, catheterization duration and length of stay. Performing holmium laser enucleation for large adenomas requires experience. Stress incontinence was seen frequently with laser but was short-term and self-limited. Holmium laser enucleation is a new procedure, and as experience and expertise increase, it may become an attractive alternative to open prostatectomy for patients with large prostate adenomas.

Renal trauma and the risk of long-term complications in shock wave lithotripsy

Open surgery for removal of upper urinary tract stones has long been associated with a high morbidity and mortality. So when shock wave (SW) lithotripsy (SWL) was introduced in the early 1980s, the climate was right for acceptance of a noninvasive method for stone comminution. The growth in popularity of SWL was extremely rapid, based in part on the perception that it was entirely safe [1]. Now, after a decade of clinical SWL, experience tells us differently. SWL may be very effective at breaking kidney stones, but it can also cause severe renal trauma that can lead to irreversible long-term complications [2, 3].

Helical CT of urinary calculi: effect of stone composition, stone size, and scan collimation

OBJECTIVE

Helical CT has become the preferred methodology for identifying urinary calculi. However, the ability to predict stone composition, which influences patient treatment, depends on the accurate measurement of the radiographic attenuation of stones. We studied the effects of stone composition, stone size, and scan collimation width on the measurement of attenuation in vitro.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

One hundred twenty-seven human urinary calculi of known composition and size were scanned at 120 kVp, 240 mA, and a 1:1 pitch at different collimations. A model, based on the physics of helical CT, was used to predict the effect of scan collimation width and stone size on measured attenuation.

RESULTS

At a 1-mm collimation, stone groups could be differentiated by attenuation: the attenuation of uric acid was less than that of cystine or struvite, which overlapped; these were less than the attenuation of calcium oxalate monohydrate, which was in turn lower than that of brushite and hydroxyapatite, which overlapped and showed the highest values. At a wider collimation, attenuation was lower and the ability to differentiate stone composition was lost. Attenuation also decreased with smaller stones. At a 10-mm collimation, some uric acid stones (<approximately 6 mm) and other stones (< approximately 4 mm) had very low attenuation, so low that they could remain undetected on helical CT. The model predicted well the degree that attenuation was affected by stone size and collimation width.

CONCLUSION

Stone composition and stone size, relative to CT collimation, independently influenced CT attenuation. The effect of stone size and collimation generally conformed to the model's predictions. We determined that small stones with low attenuation can be overlooked on helical CT.

Calcium stone fragility is predicted by helical CT attenuation values

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Helical CT has become the preferred method for imaging urinary calculi, and so it would be useful if data from helical CT could also be used to predict the number of shockwaves (SWs) needed to break a given stone.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

We measured the number of SWs required to comminute calcium stones in vitro.

RESULTS

The SW requirement correlated with stone size (volume, weight, diameter) and with helical CT attenuation values when the scans were performed at 3-mm collimation. When CT scans were performed at 1-mm collimation, the number of SWs needed for comminution did not correlate with helical CT attenuation values. This result indicates that the correlation with 3-mm scans was attributable to volume-averaging effects, in which smaller stones yield smaller attenuation values. That is, attenuation values from helical CT at larger beam collimation widths contain information about stone size that can be exploited to predict the fragility of calcium stones. We observed that for calcium stones, the number of SWs to comminution was generally less than half the stone CT attenuation value in Hounsfield units. This "half-attenuation rule" predicted the number of SWs needed to complete fragmentation for 95% of calcium stones (24/24 calcium oxalate monohydrate, 13/13 hydroxyapatite, 8/10 brushite stones).

CONCLUSION

This in vitro study suggests that it may be possible to predict effective SW dose using helical CT prior to lithotripsy.

Renal disease potentiates the injury caused by SWL

PURPOSE

The present study tested the hypothesis that renal disease potentiates the structural/functional changes induced by a clinical dose of shockwaves.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Experimental pyelonephritis was induced in 6- to 8-week-old pigs before treatment with 2,000 shocks at 24 kV. These pigs were divided into two groups according to whether they were infected with a highly virulent (Group 1) or less virulent (Group 2) inoculation of E. coli. All animals were imaged by MR prior to SWL as a means of documenting the extent of pyelonephritis and immediately after SWL to examine the lesion produced by the shockwaves. The glomerular filtration rate (GFR), renal plasma flow (RPF) and para-aminohippurate (PAH) extraction were determined bilaterally on day 30 (Group 1) or day 80 (Group 2).

RESULTS

In group 2, urine flow and sodium excretion were reduced by 50% from baseline in the shocked kidneys at both 1 and 4 hours post-SWL. A sustained reduction in RPF through 4 hours post-SWL was noted in the shocked kidneys in Group 1, but RPF was significantly reduced only at the 1-hour determination in Group 2. Large, consistent reductions in GFR were evident at 1 and 4 hours post-SWL in shocked and unshocked kidneys of Group 2 and in the shocked kidneys of Group 1. No significant changes were noted in PAH extraction.

CONCLUSION

Acute pyelonephritis exaggerated the effect of a clinical dose of shockwaves on renal hemodynamics. This effect suggests that renal disease may be risk factor for SWL-induced injury.

Metabolic evaluation of stone disease patients: a practical approach

In the last three decades, minimally invasive techniques have progressed significantly, replacing traditional open surgery as the mainstay of stone disease surgical treatment. The challenge for the next millennium remains medical prevention of calcium urolithiasis, a field where less dramatic progress has been achieved during the same period of time. The purpose of this article is to provide the practicing urologist with current practical guidelines for the assessment and management of calcium urolithiasis patients. The recommendations are based on the latest available information regarding the pathogenesis, medical treatment options, and decision-making rationale when managing these challenging patients. Every urolithiasis patient should undergo a basic evaluation, which is considered the minimal essential diagnostic work-up, in order to rule out obvious, treatable systemic causes of urinary stone disease. All patients should be advised about conservative nonspecific preventive measures. High-risk stone patients should have a more extensive metabolic evaluation based on two 24-hour urine samples. Treatment protocols for each patient are tailored individually according to the metabolic evaluation findings.

Relationship between kidney size, renal injury, and renal impairment induced by shock wave lithotripsy

The relationship between kidney size and impaired renal function induced by shock-wave lithotripsy (SWL) was examined in 6- and 10-wk-old anesthetized pigs. Each pig received 2000 shock waves, 24 kV, or sham SWL to the lower pole calyx of one kidney. Bilateral GFR, renal plasma flow (RPF), and para-aminohippurate extraction was measured 1 h before and 1 and 4 h after SWL. The kidneys were then removed for morphometric analysis. Mean kidney weights were 66.1+/-2.7 g (n = 9) and 103.1+/-3.3 g (n = 8) in the SWL groups, and 60.1+/-2.6 g (n = 9) and 82.3+/-4.0 g (n = 9) in the sham-SWL groups. SWL-induced lesions occupied a significantly greater volume of the small kidneys (6.1+/-1.7 vol % versus 1.5+/-0.2 vol% in the large kidneys). RPF was significantly reduced by SWL in small and large kidneys, but to a significantly greater extent in small kidneys. RPF was also significantly reduced in the contralateral kidneys of both groups, but only at 1 h after SWL. SWL significantly reduced GFR to similar degrees in both kidneys of both groups, regardless of kidney size. Para-aminohippurate extraction was likewise reduced to similar degrees in both groups, but this effect was evident only in the SWL-treated kidneys, and only in the pole to which the shock waves had been applied. The injury induced by SWL affected a larger fraction of small kidneys than large ones, and the renal vasoconstriction induced by SWL was greatest in small kidneys.

Expanding role of flexible nephroscopy in the upper urinary tract

Flexible nephroscopy has become an important diagnostic and therapeutic modality for urologists. We have applied the flexible nephroscope in four clinical settings: as an adjunct to rigid instruments during primary percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL); in a second-look procedure to remove residual renal calculi; as the primary endoscope to treat renal calculi; and to diagnose and treat other upper urinary tract pathology. The most common application of flexible nephroscopy in our experience has been during primary PCNL after the bulk of the stone burden has been removed with the rigid nephroscope. Liberal use of the flexible endoscope in these settings may increase the stone-free rate and decrease the need for additional access tracts and procedures. In addition, patients with conduit urinary diversions may be managed using flexible nephroscopy to diagnose and treat upper tract tumors.

Alterations in predicted growth rates of pediatric kidneys treated with extracorporeal shockwave lithotripsy

The long-term effects of extracorporeal shockwave lithotripsy (SWL) on the kidneys of children treated for renal calculi are unclear. In order to determine if SWL has any negative effects on renal growth rates, we reviewed long-term (mean 9-year) follow-up data on 29 pediatric patients treated between 1984 and 1988 with an unmodified Dornier HM3 lithotripter. Changes in renal length, serum creatinine, and blood pressure were analyzed. Predicted renal growth was calculated using a formula for age-adjusted renal length. Treated kidneys were stratified into normal and abnormal groups based on a history of renal surgery, evidence of recurrent infection, and obvious anatomic abnormalities. Fifty-six upper urinary tract calculi were treated in 34 renal units. Twenty-two renal units (68%) were rendered stone free, and 65% of the patients continue to be stone free. At follow-up, one patient was classified as having new-onset hypertension, and the mean serum creatinine was 0.93 +/- 0.08 mg/dL. Both at treatment and at follow-up, no significant differences were found in the sizes of the treated and untreated kidneys. However, at treatment, the abnormal group of kidneys seemed to be smaller than expected (mean Z -1.30 +/- 1.10), whereas the group of normal kidneys was very close (mean Z 0.18 +/- 0.54) to the predicted length. At follow-up, the deviations between actual and predicted renal length were significantly more negative. Treated kidneys were an additional 1.26 +/- 0.49 SD units below their expected length (p = 0.02). Untreated kidneys were further below normal as well but possibly to a lesser degree (-0.82 +/- 0.36; p <0.04). Although there was a trend for the abnormal group to have smaller kidneys than the normal group, both groups showed the same trend toward an age-adjusted reduction in renal growth at follow-up. The alterations in renal growth patterns observed in this population are unsettling and could be secondary to either treatment effect (SWL) or, more likely, to some underlying pathology intrinsic to pediatric kidneys with urolithiasis. Until further data are available, SWL in the pediatric population should be applied with caution and at the lowest dosage sufficient to achieve stone comminution.

Lower-pole caliceal stone clearance after shockwave lithotripsy, percutaneous nephrolithotomy, and flexible ureteroscopy: impact of radiographic spatial anatomy

Spatial anatomy of the lower renal pole, as defined by the infundibulopelvic angle (LIP angle), infundibular length (IL), and infundibular width (IW), plays a significant role in the stone-free rate after shockwave lithotripsy. A wide LIP angle, a short IL, and a broad IW, individually or in combination, favor stone clearance, whereas a LIP <70 degrees, an IL >3 cm, or an IW < or =5 mm are individually unfavorable. When all three unfavorable factors or an unfavorable LIP and IL coexist, the post-SWL stone-free rate falls to 50% or less. Using these criteria, more than one fourth of our patients with a lower-pole calculus might have been better served by an initial percutaneous or perhaps ureteroscopic procedure, neither of which is significantly affected by the lower-pole spatial anatomy.

Lower-pole caliceal stone clearance after shockwave lithotripsy, percutaneous nephrolithotomy, and flexible ureteroscopy: impact of radiographic spatial anatomy

Spatial anatomy of the lower renal pole, as defined by the infundibulopelvic angle (LIP angle), infundibular length (IL), and infundibular width (IW), plays a significant role in the stone-free rate after shockwave lithotripsy. A wide LIP angle, a short IL, and a broad IW, individually or in combination, favor stone clearance, whereas a LIP <70 degrees, an IL >3 cm, or an IW < or =5 mm are individually unfavorable. When all three unfavorable factors or an unfavorable LIP and IL coexist, the post-SWL stone-free rate falls to 50% or less. Using these criteria, more than one fourth of our patients with a lower-pole calculus might have been better served by an initial percutaneous or perhaps ureteroscopic procedure, neither of which is significantly affected by the lower-pole spatial anatomy.

High-speed photographic evaluation of holmium laser

Little information has been published regarding the relative contributions and exact mechanisms involved in stone fragmentation during holmium laser lithotripsy. High-speed photography has been used to evaluate other intracorporeal lithotripsy devices, and we chose this method to evaluate the holmium laser. High-speed photographic evaluation of cavitation bubbles produced by the four fiber sizes (200, 365, 550, and 1000 microm) showed a moderate degree of correlation (n = 0.71 for 1 J pulses, r = 0.80 for 4 J pulses) between maximal bubble size and fiber diameter. Eliminating the data from the eroded 550 microm fiber strengthened the correlation to r = 0.94 for 1 J pulses and r = 0.99 for 4 J pulses. The importance of keeping fiber tips in good working condition was thereby demonstrated. Evidence of a thermal effect of the laser on stone and chalk was also obtained. In a parallel study, no correlation (r = -0.08) was found between fiber diameter and stone fragmentation efficiency using chalk as an in vitro stone model.

Simultaneous bilateral percutaneous nephrolithotomy

PURPOSE

We evaluate the results of simultaneous bilateral percutaneous nephrolithotomy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The charts of 52 patients scheduled for simultaneous bilateral percutaneous nephrolithotomy at the Methodist Hospital of Indiana were retrospectively reviewed. The results of the 48 patients who underwent the procedure were tabulated and analyzed.

RESULTS

Mean operative time was 269 minutes and mean hospital stay was 5.6 days. Of the patients 45 were rendered stone-free (96.9% of 96 renal units) and 3 had insignificant debris (fragments less than 4 mm.) unilaterally. Complications were infrequent and included hydrothorax in 5 cases, ureteral obstruction by fragment migration in 2, hematuria causing clot retention in 2, blood transfusion in 2 and ureteral perforation with a guide wire in 1.

CONCLUSIONS

Simultaneous bilateral percutaneous nephrolithotomy is a well tolerated, safe, cost-effective and expeditious approach to patients with bilateral renal calculi requiring percutaneous nephrolithotomy.

Ureteral Stones Clinical Guidelines Panel summary report on the management of ureteral calculi. The American Urological Association

PURPOSE

The American Urological Association convened the Ureteral Stones Clinical Guidelines Panel to analyze the literature regarding available methods for treating ureteral calculi and to make practice policy recommendations based on the treatment outcomes data.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The panel searched the MEDLINE data base for all articles related to ureteral calculi published from 1966 to January 1996. Outcomes data were extracted from articles accepted after panel review. The data were then meta-analyzed to produce outcome estimates for alternative treatments of ureteral calculi.

RESULTS

The data indicate that up to 98% of stones less than 0.5 cm. in diameter, especially in the distal ureter, will pass spontaneously. Shock wave lithotripsy is recommended as first line treatment for most patients with stones 1 cm. or less in the proximal ureter. Shock wave lithotripsy and ureteroscopy are acceptable treatment choices for stones 1 cm. or less in the distal ureter.

CONCLUSIONS

Most ureteral stones will pass spontaneously. Those that do not can be removed by either shock wave lithotripsy or ureteroscopy. Traditional blind basket extraction, without fluoroscopic control and guide wires, is not recommended. Open surgery is appropriate as a salvage procedure or in certain unusual circumstances.

Quantitation of shock wave lithotripsy-induced lesion in small and large pig kidneys

BACKGROUND

Shock wave lithotripsy (SWL) is known to cause injury to the kidney. However, it is not known how lesion size varies as the parameters of SWL treatment (number of shocks, kilovoltage, kidney size) are changed. This hypothesis could not be tested because there was no method available to quantitate accurately the SWL-induced renal lesion.

METHODS

A dosage of 2,000 shocks at 24 kV delivered by an unmodified Dornier HM3 lithotripter was applied to the lower pole calyx of the right kidney of small and large pig kidneys. A new method was developed to embed a whole pig kidney for serially sectioning, recording, and digitization. Automated computer color recognition made it possible to discriminate regions of hemorrhage from undamaged tissue and allowed quantitation of the lesion in single sections and in the entire kidney.

RESULTS

The new protocol resulted in an accurate identification of sites of hemorrhage and calculations of the volume fraction of injured renal tissue. Lesion size induced in small kidneys was significantly larger than that induced in the larger kidneys (7.6 +/- 1.2% and 1.6 +/- 0.7%, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

Computer segmentation of serially sectioned SWL-treated kidneys has determined that kidney size is a risk factor for enhanced renal injury.

Urologic applications of the Holmium laser

The Holmium laser has now been in clinical use in urology for several years. The indications for its use continue to expand, and now include lithotripsy and urothelial tumor ablation anywhere in the urinary tract, resection of the prostate, incision of various urinary tract strictures, and vaporization of cutaneous lesions of the external genitalia. The 2100-nm wavelength provides the Holmium laser with a unique combination of vaporization and coagulation, allowing a precise cutting action when higher energy levels are applied. A shallow depth of penetration (< 0.5 mm) in water and tissue allows precise energy application and provides a margin of safety. The machine's user-friendly setup facilitates its operation by urologists and assistance by allied health-care personnel. The multiple urologic applications make the Holmium laser an attractive instrument for everyday utilization by any medium to large urological unit.

Effects of SWL on glomerular filtration rate and renal plasma flow in uninephrectomized minipigs

This study tested the hypothesis that the effects of SWL on hemodynamics in solitary kidneys differ from those in kidneys of binephric animals. Five female miniature pigs (Pitman-Moore, 6 months of age, 30-35 kg) were anesthetized for unilateral nephrectomy. Seven pigs served as binephric controls. Two weeks later, each pig was anesthetized, prepared for unilateral or bilateral urine collections, and subjected to SWL (Dornier HM3, 2000 shocks, 24 kV). Clearances of inulin (glomerular filtration rate; GFR) and para-aminohippurate (renal plasma flow; RPF) were measured 1 hour prior to and 1, 4, and 24 hours after SWL. The GFR and RPF were higher in uninephrectomized than in intact pigs at all time points. In both groups, SWL reduced GFR and RPF. In the binephric pigs, RPF was reduced at all times post-SWL, but in the uninephrectomized pigs, RPF was returning toward baseline by 4 hours post-SWL and was not different from baseline at 24 hours. A comparison of whole-animal GFR and RPF (righ plus left clearances in binephric pigs v solitary renal clearances in uninephrectomized pigs) showed that whole-animal GFR and RPF did not differ between the groups before or after SWL. Compensatory renal hypertrophy and improved hemodynamics in solitary kidneys may acutely attenuate the renal vasoconstrictive effect of SWL. The long-term consequences of the compensatory changes are unknown.

Extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy. Development, instrumentation, and current status

In this article, the author briefly reviews the early development of the lithotriptor, provides a detailed review of lithotriptors that are currently available, and gives an overview of the present extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy indications and techniques. The author also presents a brief overview of the results that are produced by various lithotriptors.

Branching patterns of the renal artery of the pig

BACKGROUND

The pig kidney is similar in structure and function to the human kideny, thus making it a useful model in understanding the human kidney in health and disease. However, little is known about the branching pattern of the pig renal artery as compared with the human and other animals.

METHODS

The right and left kidneys from 11 juvenile pigs were injected with either Mercox compound to form a vascular cast or contrast media to obtain a renal arteriogram. Branching patterns of the renal artery were then examined to the level of the interlobar arteries.

RESULTS

Examination of all 22 kidneys showed the main stem renal artery branching into two predictable patterns, designated I and II. The renal artery in pattern I (17 of 22 kidneys) divides into upper and lower polar arteries that then form anterior and posterior segmental arteries. Pattern I has two variations. Pattern II (5 of 22 kidneys) has a variable blood flow to the upper pole. Not only do anterior and posterior segmental arteries pass to the upper pole, but additional vessels arising from the lower polar artery also supply the upper pole.

CONCLUSIONS

The most common branching pattern of the main stem renal artery is pattern I, which divides the blood flow of the entire kidney into two distinct regions. Pattern II is less frequently seen and shows more variability in number and location of branches.

Lithotripsy and surgery

Advances in surgical techniques have dramatically altered the management of patients with symptomatic urolithiasis requiring intervention. Extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy, percutaneous nephrolithotomy, and ureteroscopy allow virtually any stone to be removed from the upper urinary tract without resorting to open surgical techniques. Extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy is the preferred initial treatment for approximately 80% to 85% of calculi. Percutaneous nephrolithotomy is the preferred approach when dealing with more voluminous stone material (ie, > 2 cm). Ureteroscopy is generally reserved for distal ureteral calculi, although the recent advent of small flexible ureteroscopes have extended ureteroscopic techniques effectively into the proximal ureter and even the kidney. Staghorn stones are usually best managed initially with percutaneous nephrolithotomy followed by the addition of extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy, if necessary. The relative advantages, disadvantages, and complications of extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy, percutaneous nephrolithotomy, and ureteroscopy will be reviewed.

Value of laparoscopy in the management of calculi complicating renal malformations

A minimally invasive approach for urolithiasis patients with complex anatomic abnormalities occasionally necessitates the use of laparoscopic techniques, either alone or in combination with endourologic techniques. The management of these patients is best accomplished in centers with the facilities to provide a spectrum of endourologic and laparoscopic techniques. Two illustrative cases are described.

Use of extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy for treatment of nephrolithiasis and ureterolithiasis in five dogs

The safety and efficacy of extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy in 5 dogs with nephrolithiasis and ureterolithiasis was assessed. Three dogs had bilateral nephrolithiasis, 1 had bilateral nephrolithiasis and unilateral ureterolithiasis, and 1 had unilateral nephrolithiasis and unilateral ureterolithiasis. A first-generation lithotriptor was used for all treatments. None of the dogs developed clinically important complications during or after treatment, except for 1 dog treated for bilateral nephrolithiasis that developed transient ureterolithiasis. Renal function was unchanged in all dogs following treatment. Clinical signs resolved in all dogs. Extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy appears to be a safe and effective means of treating nephrolithiasis and ureterolithiasis in dogs and appears to cause less renal parenchymal damage and renal function loss than does nephrotomy.

Endoscopic management of total ureteral occlusion and ureterovaginal fistula

Between August 1991 and June 1994, endoureterotomy was performed in nine patients for total ureteral occlusion. Four of these patients had an associated ureterovaginal fistula. The total ureteral occlusions were iatrogenic in eight patients and the result of trauma in one. The prone split leg position was used to facilitate simultaneous antegrade and retrograde ureteroscopy in all nine patients. The "cut-to-the-light" technique was utilized in six patients and a new technique employing a fascial incising needle was used in five patients. Five patients developed ureteral strictures within 5 months of the primary procedure that were corrected endoscopically. With a mean follow-up of 22 months, all nine patients have a successful outcome. Endoscopic management of difficult urteral disease such as total urteral occlusion and ureterovaginal fistula is a useful alternative to open surgery.

Shock wave lithotripsy with the Dornier MFL 5000 lithotriptor using an external fixed rate signal

PURPOSE

We examine the effects of fixed rate shock wave administration on the cardiac rhythm and treatment efficacy of a tubless lithotriptor (Dornier MFL 5000*). A secondary goal was to examine the treatment efficacy of fixed shock wave administration compared to R wave triggered lithotripsy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In this prospective study Holter monitoring was used before, during and after nonR wave triggered shock wave lithotripsy.

RESULTS

An increase in premature ventricular contractions was noted during shock wave lithotripsy. However, there were no episodes of significant ventricular ectopia, ventricular tachycardia, asystole or heart block as a result of nonR wave triggered shock wave administration. NonR wave gated shock wave lithotripsy expedited patient treatment and (mean treatment time 46 +/- 21 minutes)., minimized the use of sedation during treatment and produced results similar to R wave gated shock wave lithotripsy with the MFL 5000 lithotriptor.

CONCLUSIONS

With adequate precautions, fixed rate shock wave administration would appear to be a reasonable option to treat urolithiasis with the MFL 5000 lithotriptor as with other newer lithotriptors.

Metabolic evaluation of infected renal lithiasis: clinical relevance

Complete metabolic evaluation was performed in 21 patients with infected renal lithiasis. Patients with pure struvite stones (struvite +/- carbonate apatite) were significantly less likely to have metabolic abnormalities than patients who had struvite +/- carbonate apatite+calcium oxalate (2 of 14 v 7 of 7, P = 0.0003). Urine calcium excretion was markedly higher in the mixed stone group than the pure struvite group (342 +/- 98 mg/24 h v 136 +/- 82 mg/24 h; P < 0.0001). The differing opinions among researchers regarding the likelihood of finding metabolic abnormalities in patients with urolithiasis and infection probably reflect differences in the definitions of the populations studied. If patients with calculi containing only struvite +/- carbonate apatite are evaluated, we believe that few significant metabolic abnormalities will be identified.

Percutaneous nephrolithotomy directly through an angiomyolipoma

We present a patient with tuberous sclerosis and bilateral angiomyolipomas with a right partial staghorn calculi in which the calculi was managed with a percutaneous nephrolithotomy. Despite the inherent risk of hemorrhage with a percutaneous approach compounded by the fact that this was done directly through a tumor, we were able to render the patient stone free with no intraoperative bleeding, complications, or the need for postoperative blood transfusion. To our knowledge, this is the first reported case of percutaneous nephrolithotomy directly through a renal angiomyolipoma.

Laparoscopic retroperitoneal needle suspension urethropexy

Recent advances in laparoscopic surgery have allowed urologists to perform laparoscopic bladder suspension; however, laparoscopic suturing techniques have a steep learning curve and make the procedure more difficult and time consuming. We describe a new technique that combines extraperitoneal laparoscopic bladder neck mobilization through a single port with the ease of a needle suspension urethropexy in order to avoid the need for vaginal incisions and the use of laparoscopic suturing techniques. The procedure has been performed in four patients, all of whom are continent and voiding with complete bladder emptying. Postoperative pain was minimal, allowing most patients to be discharged the day after surgery. In the future, the procedure may be performed on an outpatient basis.

Nephrolithiasis Clinical Guidelines Panel summary report on the management of staghorn calculi. The American Urological Association Nephrolithiasis Clinical Guidelines Panel

The American Urological Association Nephrolithiasis Clinical Guidelines Panel recommendations for managing struvite staghorn calculi are based on a comprehensive review of the treatment literature and meta-analysis of outcome data from the 110 pertinent articles containing viable, unduplicated data. The panel concluded that the 3 most significant outcome probabilities are those of being stone-free, undergoing secondary unplanned procedures and having associated complications. Panel guideline recommendations for most standard patients are that neither shock wave lithotripsy monotherapy nor open surgery should be a first-line treatment choice but that a combination of percutaneous stone removal and shock wave lithotripsy should be used.

Biocompatibility of small-intestinal submucosa in urinary tract as augmentation cystoplasty graft and injectable suspension

We explored the biocompatibility of fluidized canine small-intestinal submucosa (SIS) for periureteral injection and as a patch graft for bladder augmentation in pigs. Gross evaluation 8 weeks after submucosal injection showed persistence of the nodule. Histologic examination showed thickened submucosa with spindle cells embedded in poorly organized fibrous material. There was no evidence of inflammatory reaction or granuloma formation. Subserosal nodules likewise persisted and demonstrated capillary ingrowth. Grafts of SIS became epithelialized within 3 weeks with maintenance of bladder capacity. Ingrowth of capillaries and smooth muscle could be seen in later specimens. Although further studies with longer follow-up are needed, SIS appears to be a promising graft material in the urinary tract.

Management of lower pole nephrolithiasis: a critical analysis

The results of extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy (ESWL*) and percutaneous nephrostolithotomy for the treatment of lower pole nephrolithiasis were examined in 32 consecutive patients undergoing percutaneous nephrostolithotomy at the Methodist Hospital of Indiana and through meta-analysis of publications providing adequate stratification of treatment results. Of 101 cases managed with percutaneous nephrostolithotomy 91 (90%) were stone-free, a result significantly better than that achieved with ESWL (1,733 of 2,927 stone-free, 59%). Stone-free rates with percutaneous nephrostolithotomy were independent of stone burden, whereas stone-free rates with ESWL were inversely correlated to the stone burden treated. The morbidity of patients undergoing percutaneous nephrostolithotomy at our hospital was minimal, with a mean hospital stay of 4.7 +/- 2.8 days. No blood transfusions were required. All patients became stone-free. The percentage of urolithiasis patients with lower pole calculi is increasing. Because of the significantly greater efficacy of percutaneous nephrostolithotomy for lower pole calculi, particularly stones larger than 10 mm. in diameter, further consideration should be given to an initial approach with percutaneous nephrostolithotomy.

Indomethacin suppositories versus intravenously titrated morphine for the treatment of ureteral colic

STUDY OBJECTIVES

To develop a protocol for the blinded IV titration of morphine and to compare the analgesic efficacy and side effect profile of indomethacin suppositories versus IV morphine in the treatment of acute ureteral colic.

DESIGN

Randomized, double-blind, double-dummy, two-period crossover study.

SETTING

Emergency department of a central-city, teaching hospital.

PARTICIPANTS

Patients 18 to 75 years of age with pain suggestive of ureteral colic. Exclusions included pregnancy, adverse reactions to the study drugs, chronic nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID) therapy, or any pain medicine taken within four hours of ED admission.

INTERVENTIONS

Patients were randomized to one of two groups: indomethacin 100-mg rectal suppository or morphine by IV titration (5-mg loading dose and up to two additional 2.5-mg doses if needed). At the end of 30 minutes, if adequate pain relief had not been obtained, treatment was crossed over.

MEASUREMENTS

Verbal analog scale (initial pain) and visual analog pain relief scale.

MAIN RESULTS

Seventy-five patients were entered into the study. Only data from those patients with stone presence confirmed by IV pyelogram or stone passage were analyzed. Twenty-four could not be evaluated (23 who did not meet criteria for stone presence and one whose pain resolved spontaneously before study medications could be administered). Of the remaining 51 patients, 31 received indomethacin first and 20 received morphine first. Morphine recipients reported more pain relief at ten minutes (P = .02), but at 20 and 30 minutes, no significant difference (P = .17 and .74, respectively) existed between the two groups.

CONCLUSION

IV morphine produced more rapid analgesia than rectally administered indomethacin. There were no significant differences in vital sign changes or number of side effects between the two treatment groups. This study is the first to compare an NSAID with morphine administered by IV titration, considered by many to be the "gold standard" for relief of acute, severe pain. Future studies could evaluate the simultaneous administration of an opioid combined with an NSAID or compare an IV titrated opioid with an IV NSAID.

Percutaneous transilial access for stone removal in crossed fused renal ectopia

A case of crossed fused renal ectopia with urosepsis due to multiple struvite calculi in the left lower pole of the orthotopic renal unit is presented. The patient had a neurogenic bladder secondary to myelodysplasia, bilateral ureteral reflux, and had undergone multiple orthopedic operations previously, including posterior iliopsoas transplantation through the iliac bone (Sharrard procedure). After controlling the infection, nephrostolithotomy was performed. Three percutaneous accesses including one through the opening in the left iliac bone were required to gain access to all the stones. The patient was rendered stone free and subsequently underwent bladder augmentation and ureteral reimplantation. The management of complicated renal units is reviewed with respect to crossed renal fusion.

Evolution of the technique of combination therapy for staghorn calculi: a decreasing role for extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy

Percutaneous nephrostolithotomy with or without extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy (ESWL) has been extensively used in the management of staghorn calculi, with stone-free rates varying from 23 to 86%. Explanations for the variability of such results include differences in stone burden, differences in percutaneous techniques and an overreliance on ESWL. The results and changing trends in the relative roles of percutaneous nephrostolithotomy and ESWL in the management of staghorn calculi at the Methodist Hospital of Indiana were examined. We reviewed 343 cases of staghorn calculi (partial and complete) with adequate followup data, which were managed with initial percutaneous nephrostolithotomy. Cases were divided into 2 groups: group 1 (252 cases) from 1984 to 1987 when access was performed by a radiologist and group 2 (91 cases) from 1988 to 1990 when access was performed by a urologist. Although stones in group 2 tended to be larger, a decreasing dependence on ESWL was noted (64.7% in group 1 compared to 35.2% in group 2, p less than 0.001). Despite the larger stone size in group 2, stone-free rates were similar (83.3% in group 1, 86.8% in group 2). In groups 1 and 2 percutaneous nephrostolithotomy alone achieved stone-free rates of 91% and 91.5%, respectively. The stone-free rate with the combination approach was 79.1% and 78.1% in groups 1 and 2, respectively. Technical refinements with percutaneous nephrostolithotomy in group 2 include accurate and carefully selected accesses (superior pole in 36.3%) for best approach to the stone, multiple accesses (13.3%) and improved skills in flexible nephroscopy. Blood transfusion has not been required in group 2 compared with 11.1% in group 1. Mean hospital stay was 12.4 days in group 1 and 10.3 days in group 2 (percutaneous nephrostolithotomy alone, 7.2 days). With careful attention to percutaneous nephrostolithotomy techniques, complex renal stones can be successfully managed endourologically, reducing the need for combination ESWL. Complications previously associated with percutaneous nephrostolithotomy have decreased.

Stone surface area determination techniques: a unifying concept of staghorn stone burden assessment

The use of stone surface area measurements obtained from standard radiographs provides a more accurate and reproducible assessment of stone burden when reporting results and treatment recommendations for staghorn calculi. Techniques for determining stone surface area include use of graph paper, planimeter or computerized image analysis. The use of graph paper is inefficient while planimeters suffer from significant variation for areas less than 500 mm.2 (more than 5%). Computer image analysis is accurate, rapid and easiest to perform. Software programs compatible with microcomputers are readily available making assessment of stone surface area practical and inexpensive. Stone surface area showed close correlation to stone volume as measured by 3-dimensional computerized tomography (correlation coefficient 0.84, p = 0.005). Stone surface area determination enables more accurate reporting of treatment results and, thus, recommendations based upon stone burden. Comparison of data between institutions becomes more meaningful if stone surface area is used. Stone surface area also provides a useful basis to study and compare trends of treatment within a single institution.

Staghorn calculi: analysis of treatment results between initial percutaneous nephrostolithotomy and extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy monotherapy with reference to surface area

Treatment recommendations and results reported for the management of staghorn calculi are highly variable. In an attempt to provide a more objective means to compare treatment results for staghorn renal calculi, stone burden as measured by stone surface area was used. Stone surface area was determined by computer analysis. A total of 380 cases of staghorn calculi treated at the same institution was evaluated. Treatment consisted of initial percutaneous nephrostolithotomy with or without extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy (ESWL*) in 298 cases and ESWL monotherapy in 82. When considered as a group, the overall stone-free rate for initial percutaneous nephrostolithotomy (mean surface area 1,378.3 mm.2) was 84.2% compared to 51.2% (p less than 0.0001) for ESWL monotherapy (mean surface area 693.4 mm.2). For staghorn calculi smaller than 500 mm.2 a stone-free rate of 94.4% was achieved in the percutaneous nephrostolithotomy with or without ESWL group compared to 63.2% for ESWL monotherapy (p = 0.0214). For calculi of 501 to 1,000 mm.2 the stone-free rates were 86% and 45.7%, respectively (p less than 0.0001). When stone surface area exceeded 1,000 mm.2 the stone-free rate for percutaneous nephrostolithotomy with or without ESWL was 82.4% but it was only 22.2% for ESWL monotherapy (p = 0.0002). Overall, when adjusted for stone surface area the odds of being stone-free were more than 8 times higher for initial percutaneous nephrostolithotomy versus ESWL monotherapy (odds ratio = 8.36, p less than 0.0001). While percutaneous nephrostolithotomy with or without ESWL appears to be the procedure of choice for most staghorn stones, ESWL monotherapy may have a role for some stones smaller than 500 mm.2. In 12 such cases associated with a nondilated renal collecting system (mean surface area 380.5 mm.2) a stone-free rate of 91.7% was achieved. The number of procedures required to complete therapy was higher in the initial percutaneous nephrostolithotomy group (2.8 versus 2.1, p less than 0.0001). Although complications were more common in the ESWL monotherapy group (manifested as obstruction in 30.5%), bleeding requiring blood transfusion was more frequent in the initial percutaneous nephrostolithotomy group (9.4%).

New alternatives in gallstone treatment

Within the past few years, a number of new treatment modalities for gallbladder stones have become available. Laparoscopic cholecystectomy has proved as safe as traditional surgical cholecystectomy, without the discomfort and lengthy recuperation associated with a large abdominal incision. Several other new treatments also have been investigated, including percutaneous cholecystolithotomy, peroral drug chemolysis, extracorporeal shock wave lithotripsy, and methyl-tert-butyl ether lavage. The relative merits and disadvantages of these treatments, compared to each other and to standard cholecystectomy, are described herein.