The clinical diagnosis of chronic acalculous cholecystitis

BACKGROUND

Chronic acalculous cholecystitis (CAC), a diagnosis of exclusion, appears to be more common than was previously thought. We correlated the pathology with test results and response to treatment in a prospective study to obtain data for evidence-based management.

METHODS

The study subjects were patients with chronic biliary symptoms but had normal sonogram results. They were further investigated with esophagogastroduodenoscopy, multidiscipline evaluations, and cholecystokinin-stimulated scintigraphy (CCK-HIDA). They were offered laparoscopic cholecystectomy (LC) when the symptoms were intransigent, and the main abnormality was a low ejection fraction (EF) as determined by CCK-HIDA. We analyzed the histologic findings of the gallbladder, CCK-HIDA EF, and clinical outcomes during the control period with a concurrent series of LC for calculus from the same surgeons.

RESULTS

Of 176 cholecystectomies for biliary pain without stones, 152 had pathologically verified CAC. EF by CCK-HIDA was low in patients with CAC (18%) and low in normal gallbladders (26%). In the same period, 497 patients had cholecystectomies for cholelithiasis. Lasting symptom relief for CAC after LC was not different from that for calculous disease (85% vs 90%).

CONCLUSIONS

The syndrome consisting of chronic biliary symptoms, stone-free sonograms, low EF in CCK-HIDA, and absence of other pain sources is highly predictive for CAC, which is well treated with LC, with results similar to those for calculous disease.

When it's not appendicitis

Other pathology besides appendicitis may be found in patients with right lower quadrant pain. This has led some to advocate diagnostic laparoscopy/laparoscopic appendectomy for all such cases. This policy would substantially raise the costs of care without a priori proof of its efficacy. However, a selective approach on when to proceed with diagnostic laparoscopy will depend on the frequency of finding unexpected, nonappendiceal pathology. To determine this, we reviewed our experience with 202 appendectomies. For females < 50 years old, 33 per cent had normal appendices, 12 per cent had periappendicitis, 47 per cent had acute appendicitis, 12 per cent had perforated appendicitis, and 26 per cent had other nonappendiceal pathology. For males < 50 years old, 13 per cent had normal appendices, 8 per cent had periappendicitis, 67 per cent had acute appendicitis, 15 per cent had perforated appendicitis, and 5 per cent had other pathology. For patients > 50 years old, 7 per cent had normal appendices, 13 per cent had periappendicitis, 33 per cent had acute appendicitis, 60 per cent had perforated appendicitis, and 20 per cent other pathology. Other nonappendiceal pathology was found in 42 per cent of females < 50 with normal appendices, 57 per cent with periappendicitis, and 14 per cent with acute/perforated appendicitis. In males < 50 years, 50 per cent of those with normal appendices, 10 per cent of those with periappendicitis, and 0.7 per cent of those with acute appendicitis had nonappendiceal pathology. In conclusion, women of childbearing age and patients > 50 years old have a significant incidence of nonappendiceal pathology. In this group of patients, a diagnostic laparoscopy appears justifiable to identify the cause of the abdominal pain.

Quality of life scale for gastroesophageal reflux disease

BACKGROUND

Treatment of uncomplicated gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) is primarily to improve the symptoms of the patient. However, measurement of symptomatic outcome is difficult because it is as the patient perceives it to be and not "objective." This creates a need to develop a simple and understandable instrument to measure symptomatic outcome.

STUDY DESIGN

All patients referred for evaluation of GERD were eligible for this prospective study. During the initial visit, patients were asked to complete the Gastroesophageal Reflux Data Sheet. This ten-item questionnaire included an overall assessment of satisfaction; the best possible score was 0, and the worst was 45. The evaluation included history, physical examination, and additional studies, including upper gastrointestinal series, esophagogastroduodenoscopy, esophageal manometry, and 24-hour esophageal pH monitoring as indicated. Initial treatment was medical with histamine2-blockers, omeprazole, cisapride, or both. If a patient was dissatisfied with medical treatment and had both a hypotensive lower esophageal sphincter and abnormal results of the 24-hour pH monitoring, then operative treatment with either laparoscopic or open Nissen or Toupet fundoplication was offered. After approximately three months of medical treatment or one month after operative treatment, patients were asked to complete the questionnaire again. Data were analyzed using nonparametric tests and linear regression analysis.

RESULTS

A total of 72 patients were assessed, and 100 percent of them completed the questionnaire. Patients who were satisfied with their condition had a median health-related quality of life (HRQL) score of five, and those who were dissatisfied had a median score of 26 (p < 0.000001). Patients who ultimately chose surgical therapy had a median preoperative score of 28, compared with 15 for patients who chose to continue medical therapy (p = 0.0001). The change in HRQL score from before treatment to after treatment for surgical patients was 27 compared with 11 for medically treated patients (p < 0.002). Items 1 through 6 of the questionnaire were individually sensitive to the effects of treatment. However, there was no correlation between HRQL and the composite pH score or with the lower esophageal sphincter pressure.

CONCLUSIONS

This HRQL score has advantages over standard health status instruments for GERD including simplicity for patients (and therefore a high compliance rate), ease of understanding for physicians, and sensitivity to the effects of treatment. In addition, it may help determine, early in the course of treatment, patients who may ultimately require surgical therapy, thereby avoiding prolonged, but futile, medical therapy.

A giant renal artery aneurysm diagnosed post partum

We report a case of a 5.8 cm. right renal artery aneurysm diagnosed intact 8 weeks post partum. Rupture of a renal arterial aneurysm during pregnancy is a rare but well described catastrophic event. There are no previous reports of an intact renal artery aneurysm diagnosed either ante partum or post partum. To our knowledge, this also represents the largest reported renal artery aneurysm. The aneurysm was repaired successfully with kidney salvage and closure of the fistulous connection to the renal vein.