A multicentre study of naevus-associated melanoma vs. de novo melanoma, tumour thickness and body site differences

BACKGROUND

Whether melanoma in histological contiguity with a naevus [naevus-associated melanoma (NAM)] is distinctly different from melanoma arising de novo remains unclear.

OBJECTIVES

To determine whether the characteristics of de novo melanoma differ from NAM and are not due to naevus obliteration in thicker tumours.

METHODS

We conducted a multicentre retrospective study of de novo melanoma and NAM in seven referral centres in Europe, Australia and the USA between 2006 and 2015.

RESULTS

In a total of 9474 localized melanomas, de novo melanoma was associated with thicker tumours and body site differences compared with NAM. In the subset of T1 melanomas (n = 5307), similar body site differences were found in multivariate analysis by body site. When compared with NAM, de novo melanoma was more likely to affect older individuals (≥ 70 years) when located on the head/neck [odds ratio (OR) 4·65, 95% confidence interval (CI) 2·55-8·46], the trunk (OR 1·82, 95% CI 1·40-2·36) or the upper extremity (OR 1·69, 95% CI 1·14-2·50), was more likely to affect female patients when located on the lower extremities (OR 1·36, 95% CI 1·03-1·80), and was more likely to be of the nodular melanoma subtype (OR 2·23, 95% CI 1·14-4·35) when located on the trunk. De novo melanoma was less likely to have regression present compared with NAM.

CONCLUSIONS

Clinicopathological and body site differences between de novo melanoma and NAM support the divergent pathway model of development. These differences were also found in thin melanomas, suggesting that de novo melanomas are different from NAM and their differences are not due to the obliteration of naevus remnants in thicker tumours.

Histopathological features of complete pathological response predict recurrence-free survival following neoadjuvant targeted therapy for metastatic melanoma

BACKGROUND

Recent clinical trials demonstrated the safety and efficacy of neoadjuvant dabrafenib and trametinib (DT) among patients with surgically resectable clinical stage III BRAFV600E/K mutant melanoma. Although patients achieving a complete pathological response (pCR) exhibited superior recurrence-free survival (RFS) versus those who did not, 30% of pCR patients relapsed. We sought to identify whether histopathological features of the pathological response further delineated risk of relapse.

METHODS

Surgical resection specimens from DT-treated patients in two phase 2 clinical trials were reviewed. Histopathological features, including relative amounts of viable tumour, necrosis, melanosis, and fibrosis (hyalinized or immature/proliferative) were assessed for associations with patient outcomes.

RESULTS

Fifty-nine patients underwent surgical resection following neoadjuvant DT. Patients achieving pCR (49%) had longer RFS compared with patients who did not (P = 0.005). Patients whose treated tumour showed any hyalinized fibrosis had longer RFS versus those without (P = 0.014), whereas necrosis (P = 0.012) and/or immature/proliferative fibrosis (P = 0.026) correlated with shorter RFS. Multivariable analyses showed absence of pCR or presence of immature fibrosis independently predicted shorter RFS. Among pCR patients, mature/hyalinized-type fibrosis correlated with improved RFS (P = 0.035).

CONCLUSIONS

The extent and composition of the pathological response following neoadjuvant DT in BRAFV600E/K mutant melanoma correlates with RFS, including pCR patients. These findings support the need for detailed histological analysis of specimens collected after neoadjuvant therapy.

Pathological assessment of resection specimens after neoadjuvant therapy for metastatic melanoma

Background

Clinical trials have recently evaluated safety and efficacy of neoadjuvant therapy among patients with surgically resectable regional melanoma metastases. To capture informative prognostic data connected to pathological response in such trials, it is critical to standardize pathologic assessment and reporting of tumor response after this treatment.

Methods

The International Neoadjuvant Melanoma Consortium meetings in 2016 and 2017 assembled pathologists from academic centers to develop consensus guidelines for pathologic examination and reporting of surgical specimens from AJCC (8th edition) stage IIIB/C/D or oligometastatic stage IV melanoma patients treated with neoadjuvant-targeted or immune therapy. Patterns of pathologic response are provided context to inform these guidelines.

Results

Based on our collective experience and guided by efforts in well-established neoadjuvant settings like breast cancer, procedures directing handling of pre- and post-neoadjuvant therapy-treated melanoma specimens are provided to facilitate comparison of findings across different trials and centers. Definitions of pathologic response are provided together with guidelines for reporting and quantifying the extent of pathologic response. Finally, the spectrum of histopathologic responses observed following neoadjuvant-targeted and immune-checkpoint therapy is described and illustrated.

Conclusions

Standardizing pathologic evaluation of resected melanoma metastases following neoadjuvant-targeted or immune-checkpoint therapy allows more robust stratification of patient outcomes. This includes recognizing the spectrum of histopathologic response patterns to neoadjuvant therapy and a standard approach to grading pathologic responses. Such an approach will facilitate comparison of results across clinical trials and inform ongoing correlative studies into the mechanisms of response and resistance to agents applied in the neoadjuvant setting.

Gut microbiome modulates response to anti-PD-1 immunotherapy in melanoma patients

Preclinical mouse models suggest that the gut microbiome modulates tumor response to checkpoint blockade immunotherapy; however, this has not been well-characterized in human cancer patients. Here we examined the oral and gut microbiome of melanoma patients undergoing anti-programmed cell death 1 protein (PD-1) immunotherapy (n = 112). Significant differences were observed in the diversity and composition of the patient gut microbiome of responders versus nonresponders. Analysis of patient fecal microbiome samples (n = 43, 30 responders, 13 nonresponders) showed significantly higher alpha diversity (P < 0.01) and relative abundance of bacteria of the Ruminococcaceae family (P < 0.01) in responding patients. Metagenomic studies revealed functional differences in gut bacteria in responders, including enrichment of anabolic pathways. Immune profiling suggested enhanced systemic and antitumor immunity in responding patients with a favorable gut microbiome as well as in germ-free mice receiving fecal transplants from responding patients. Together, these data have important implications for the treatment of melanoma patients with immune checkpoint inhibitors.

Is surviving enough? Coping and impact on activities of daily living among melanoma patients with lymphoedema

We assessed the impact of lymphoedema (defined as ≥ 10% limb volume change) on quality of life (QOL), ability to perform activities of daily living (ADLs) and coping in 277 melanoma patients. Limb volume was measured prospectively, pre-operatively and every 3-6 months for 18 months post-operatively using a perometer. Three questionnaires were administered to measure QOL, coping and impact on ADLs. Statistical analyses were conducted using longitudinal logistic regression models. At 18 months, the cumulative incidence of lymphoedema was 31% in patients with upper extremity nodal basin treatment and 40% in lower extremity nodal basin treatment patients. Patients with lower extremity lymphoedema reported lower QOL scores than those with upper extremity lymphoedema. Over 18 months, both groups with mild and moderate lymphoedema showed improvement in coping [odds ratio (OR): 6.67, 95% confidence interval (CI): 3.30-13.47] and performance of ADLs (OR: 7.46, CI: 3.38-16.47). Over the course of 18 months, men were found to have poorer coping scores than women (OR: 2.91, CI: 1.35-6.27). Lymphoedema was associated with improvement in coping over time (P = 0.08) and a higher reported interference with ADLs (OR: 2.53, CI: 1.29-4.97). Patient education about lymphoedema at the time of surgical consent may improve self-efficacy and coping ability. Effective management of lymphoedema may improve patient QOL and reduce interference with ADLs.

Multimethod imaging, staging, and spectrum of manifestations of metastatic melanoma

The incidence of melanoma has been steadily increasing. Imaging plays an important role in tumour assessment as metastatic melanoma can involve multiple organs. Computed tomography (CT) is currently the most widely used technique for tumour staging, surveillance and assessment of therapeutic response, but ultrasound, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) and positron-emission tomography (PET)-CT also play important roles in the imaging of this tumour. In this article, we review the pathways of spread, staging according to the recently updated TNM classification, pathology, typical and atypical imaging features at common and uncommon sites, and treatment of metastatic melanoma.

Effect of clinical status and previous treatment of melanoma patients on expansion of TIL for adoptive T-cell therapy

3021

Background: Adoptive cell therapy (ACT) using tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes (TIL) is a promising therapy for the treatment of metastatic melanoma. Trials at the NCI have shown a 50% response rate. However, outside of the NCI, ACT has been quite limited and little is known about how patient characteristics and prior treatment affect large-scale TIL expansion needed for treatment. Methods: As part of a phase II melanoma ACT clinical trial at M. D. Anderson Cancer Center, we evaluated how clinical characteristics such as age, gender, biopsy site, melanoma type, primary tumor location, and prior treatment of patients (N=134) affected TIL expansion rates. 159 isolated metastatic melanomas (19 patients having >1 tumor harvest) were analyzed for the ability to expand a minimum of 40 million TIL, considered a minimum number for the subsequent rapid expansion protocol (REP) needed for TIL infusion. Effects of these parameters on TIL anti-tumor reactivity and TIL/tumor fragment were also analyzed. Statistical analysis was done by either Fisher's Exact test, Wilcoxon Rank Sum test, or Kruskal-Wallis Test. Results: 54.7% of the samples evaluated generated ≥ 40 million TIL, and 70% of 70 samples tested had anti-tumor reactive TIL. There was a significant relationship between age categories (p=0.0216) and gender (p=0.0164) on TIL expansion success. Younger patients did the best and females did better than males (odds 2.19, p=0.044). The site of the primary melanoma affected success of TIL expansion (p=0.0059), while no effect of tumor biopsy site and histological type was found. Prior chemotherapy (or biochemotherapy) greatly reduced TIL growth (odds 0.32, p=0.010) when compared to no prior therapy. Multivariate linear regression analyses showed that prior chemotherapy decreased TIL/tumor fragment yield by 6.19 million (p=0.0004) while immunotherapy increased it by 3.51 million (p=0.16) compared to no prior therapy. Total TIL yield or TIL/tumor fragment did not correlate with patient overall survival. Conclusions: Parameters such as age, sex, primary melanoma site, and prior therapy significantly affect TIL expansion and should be considered in selecting patients for melanoma ACT.

No significant financial relationships to disclose.

Quantitative assessment of AKT activation in melanoma

9022

Background: Activating mutations of BRAF are highly prevalent in melanoma. However, multiple lines of evidence suggest that other pathways must also contribute to this disease. Activation of the PI3K-AKT pathway has been implicated in melanoma by mutations of NRAS and PTEN. Little direct information is known about the activation of the PI3K-AKT signaling pathway in melanoma, particularly in metastases. Methods: Proteins isolated from 99 frozen melanoma tumors were measured by reverse phase protein arrays (RRPA). A total of 53 proteins were assessed using validated antibodies. Activating mutations were assessed by mass spectroscopy-based genotyping. Activation of AKT (phospho-AKT) was compared to mutations and anatomic sites. Results: Samples from 75 regional metastases (LN or in-transit) and 24 distant metastases were analyzed. Technical replicates (same lysate) and biological replicates (same tumor, different lysates) demonstrated average Pearson correlation coefficients (r) of > 0.90, supporting the high technical quality of the analysis. A positive correlation was observed between levels of p-AKT and known AKT substrates p-GSK3 and p-TSC2 (p< 0.001 for both), and a negative correlation with PTEN (p < 0.01), supporting the maintenance of phosphorylation events during sample processing. Relative differences in p-AKT by RPPA were also confirmed by immunohistochemistry of representative tumors. Tumors with BRAF mutations had higher levels of p-AKT than tumors with NRAS mutations (p = 0.03). Indeed, tumors with NRAS mutations had p-AKT levels similar to tumors wild-type for BRAF and NRAS (p =0.73). Detailed analysis demonstrated that all tumors with elevated p-AKT had low PTEN expression. Similar results were seen in human melanoma cell lines. Analysis of distant metastases demonstrated that brain metastases had higher levels of p-AKT, p-GSK3, and p-TSC2, and lower levels of PTEN, compared to metastases to the lung or liver. Conclusions: AKT activation in melanoma correlates with PTEN expression, and does not correlate with NRAS mutation. Activation of the PI3K-AKT pathway may contribute to the aggressiveness of brain metastases. These findings have clinical implications for targeting this pathway, and demonstrate the feasibility and potential of RPPA analysis of signaling pathways in melanoma.

No significant financial relationships to disclose.

HLA class II alleles predict recurrence and pattern of failure in early-stage melanoma patients

8503

Background: Prior reports have suggested a link between specific HLA class II alleles, including HLA-DRB1*1101, and melanoma recurrence. We therefore investigated the relationship between HLA class II alleles and clinical outcome in a large population of patients who presented with localized melanoma. Methods: HLA class II alleles were determined by typing of genomic DNA from patients who presented with localized melanoma (AJCC stage IA-IIC). Patients found to have occult regional disease by sentinel node biopsy were excluded. Log-rank and Cox analysis of outcome versus standard prognostic factors and common HLA class II alleles (=5% of the population) was performed. Results: 1,241 patients underwent HLA typing. The median primary tumor thickness was 1.1 mm, 16% were ulcerated, and the median follow-up was 56 months. Tumor thickness, ulceration, and Clark level were independent predictors of recurrence. The HLA class II allele HLA-DRB1*1101 (11% of the population) independently predicted a higher risk of recurrence [hazard ratio (HR) 2.04, P=0.004] while HLA-DRB1*0401 (20% of the population) predicted a lower risk of recurrence (HR 0.42, P=0.004). HLA- DRB1*1101 was a particularly strong predictor of recurrence in stage I patients (HR 2.73, P<0.0001). Among patients who recurred, HLA- DRB1*1101 was an independent predictor of local-regional vs. distant recurrence (HR 2.7, P=0.007), and was more common in those whose first recurrence was isolated to the regional nodal basin, compared to those whose first recurrence was elsewhere or in multiple locations (24% HLA-DRB1*1101-positive vs. 14%, P<0.009). Conclusions: These results confirm that HLA-DRB1*1101 is a genetic marker of increased risk of melanoma recurrence, while HLA-DRB1*0401 is a marker of decreased risk of recurrence. HLA-DRB1*1101 is a particularly strong marker among the group of patients predicted clinically to be at the lowest overall risk for recurrence, and independently predicts pattern of recurrence (regional nodal failure). This information is of value in the development of surveillance strategies for melanoma patients, as well as the selection, stratification and randomization of early-stage melanoma patients for clinical trials.

No significant financial relationships to disclose.

Reliability and validity of the Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy-melanoma (FACT-M)

8554

Background: Our group has developed a disease-specific module for the Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy (FACT) instrument to assess quality of life (QOL) in melanoma patients. The purpose of this study was to assess the reliability and validity of the melanoma subscale (MS) and melanoma surgery subscales (MSS) as well as the total FACT-M, which includes the FACT combined with the MS and MSS. Methods: 273 melanoma patients (stages I-IV) attending an outpatient melanoma clinic completed a battery of questionnaires at baseline assessment. The scores from the MS, MSS, and total FACT-M were compared to patient performance status (ECOG and Karnofsky scales), disease stage, treatment status, and other instruments with related domains including the Profile of Mood States, Marlowe-Crowne Social Desirability Scale, and the EORTC Quality of Life Questionnaire - melanoma module. Patients were assessed 1 week after baseline to assess test-retest reliability, and 163 patients completed assessments at 3 months to evaluate the responsiveness to change in performance status. Results: Internal consistency and test-retest reliability for the MS (Cronbach's a = 0.85, r = 0.81), MSS (a = 0.85, r = 0.82), and the total FACT-M (a = 0.95, r = 0.90) were excellent. Overall, the scales correlated with other measures and correlations were in the hypothesized direction. As predicted, FACT-M, MS, and MSS scores were lower for patients with advanced (stage III/IV) melanoma, patients with poor performance status, and patients who were receiving active treatment. In addition, total FACT-M, MS, and MSS scores were highly sensitive to changes in performance status (p = 0.0012, 0.0004, and 0.0006, respectively). Conclusions: The FACT-M is a reliable and valid QOL assessment tool for patients with melanoma. This disease-specific instrument should be utilized for melanoma QOL assessment in clinical trials.

No significant financial relationships to disclose.

Microscopic tumor burden in sentinel lymph nodes (SLNs) best predicts nonsentinel lymph node (NSLN) involvement in patients with melanoma

8004

Background: Therapeutic lymph node dissection (TLND) has long been the standard of care for melanoma metastatic to the regional LNs and is commonly used for patients (pts) with microscopic disease identified by SLN biopsy. We and others have demonstrated that additional histologically positive (pos) nodes are identified in 8%-33% of completion LN dissection (CLND) specimens. The purpose of this study was to determine predictors of additional LN involvement in pts. with pos SLNs. Methods: Pts with clinically node-negative melanoma who underwent SLN biopsy at our institution between 1991 and 2003 and had pos SLNs were identified. Patient and primary tumor factors, number of pos SLNs, and extent of microscopic disease within the SLN were evaluated as potential predictors of pos NSLNs. Results: Overall, 359 (16%) of 2,203 pts had a pos SLN. Pos NSLNs were identified in 48 (14%) of the 343 pts with pos SLNs who underwent CLND. On univariate analysis, several markers of SLN microscopic tumor burden, tumor thickness >2mm, age >50 years, and Clark level >III were predictive of additional pos nodes in the TLND specimen. Primary tumor ulceration was not predictive. On multivariable logistic regression analysis, markers of microscopic tumor burden (large SLN met focus, large SLN tumor square area, presence of SLN extracapsular extension, and synchronous subcapsular and intramedullary SLN deposits) were the most powerful independent predictors of pos NSLNs; tumor thickness >2mm also predicted additional disease. A model was established using tumor thickness and SLN tumor burden to identify pts with low, intermediate, or high risk for NSLN involvement (Table). Conclusions: In melanoma pts with ≥1 pos SLN, SLN tumor burden and primary tumor thickness may be useful in identifying a group at low risk for pos NSLNs. This information is valuable in designing clinical trials in which pts may be randomly assigned to TLND versus observation alone after removal of a pos SLN.

[Table: see text]

No significant financial relationships to disclose.

[Effects of vascular endothelial growth factor D on the signaling cascade of sentinel lymphatic endothelial cells from melanoma patients undergoing sentinel lymphadenectomy]

Advances in surgical treatment, including sentinel lymphadenectomy, permit the pathologic staging of regional lymph nodes most likely to contain metastasis by identifying afferent lymphatic channels, which specifically drain the primary tumor site. Recently, a new member of the angiogenic molecule in VEGF family, VEGF-D, has been identified that induces lymphangiogenesis via high-affinity binding to VEGFR-3. VEGF-D is predominantly expressed in lymphatic endothelium. We have previously developed a novel method for the isolation of anatomically-defined lymphatic endothelial cells (LECs) from human sentinel lymphatic channel during SLN biopsy. The effect of VEGF-D on the extracellular signal-regulated kinases (Erk)-1/2 and Akt signaling pathway was examined by Western blot analysis. VEGF-D (500 ng/ml) apparently upregulated phospho-p44/phospho-p42 activity in human isolated LECs by Western blot analysis, while phospho-Akt activity was not at all changed by VEGF-D exposure without the change of total p44/p42 and Akt expression. U0126 (20 microM), the MEK1/2 inhibitor, could completely block the VEGF-D induced phospholylation of Erk1/2 signaling pathway. These data demonstrate that VEGF-D induces p44/p42 in human LECs and suggests that this signaling pathway activation may be important in LEC biology and lymphoangiogenesis, which may lead to the progression of new strategies of cancer treatment.

Epidermal hyperplasia overlying human melanoma correlates with tumour depth and angiogenesis

The aim of this study was to determine whether epidermal hyperplasia overlying cutaneous human melanoma is associated with increased tumour angiogenesis, tumour growth and the potential for metastasis. Forty-two surgical specimens of cutaneous human melanoma of different depths, each containing epidermis present in the tumour-free margin, were analysed by immunohistochemistry for the expression of the pro-angiogenic molecules basic fibroblast growth factor (bFGF), vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) and interleukin-8 (IL-8) and the anti-angiogenic molecule interferon-beta (IFN-beta). The epidermis overlying intermediate and thick (1.0-10.0 mm), but not thin (0.5-1.0 mm), melanoma specimens was hyperplastic. Although the expression level of bFGF, VEGF and IL-8 in the epidermis directly overlying the tumour was similar to that in the distant epidermis, the expression of IFN-beta was significantly decreased in keratinocytes overlying intermediate and thick, but not thin, melanomas. The microvessel density was also increased in intermediate and thick specimens. Human melanoma cells were injected subcutaneously into nude mice. The resulting tumours were used to determine the association between overlying epidermal hyperplasia and neoplastic angiogenesis. Similar to human autochthonous melanomas, epidermal hyperplasia was found only over lesions produced by metastatic cells. Although there was no change in the expression of the pro-angiogenic molecules, the expression of IFN-beta was significantly decreased in the hyperplastic epidermis. Conditioned medium collected from cultures of the metastatic cell line induced in vitro proliferation of mouse keratinocytes, whereas conditioned medium collected from cultures of the non-metastatic cell line did not. Collectively, the data demonstrate that metastatic melanoma cells induce keratinocyte proliferation, leading to decreased expression of the negative regulator of angiogenesis, IFN-beta, and hence to increased angiogenesis.

Melanoma

The presentations at the American Society of Clinical Oncology 2001 meeting reported or updated the results of phase I, II, and III randomized trials and also reported important meta-analyses and retrospective studies impacting on the management of patients with melanoma. In the treatment of early stage melanoma, the prognostic significance of pathologic status of sentinel lymph nodes was affirmed. With respect to regional nodal involvement (American Joint Committee on Cancer [AJCC] stage III), investigators presented the interim results of the United Kingdom randomized low-dose interferon (IFN) trial, and up-to-date meta-analyses of several IFN trials including a pooled analysis of the Eastern Cooperative Oncology Group trials evaluating interferon in the adjuvant setting. In the advanced disease setting (AJCC stage IV), several studies elucidated the pros and cons of biochemotherapy in patients with metastatic melanoma, with an emphasis on seeking to improve response in the central nervous system and durability of response in general. Thought provoking was new data regarding the potential for lovastatin to act as a chemopreventive agent for melanoma. Translational studies were presented, one supporting the importance of HLA-typing in developing targeted vaccine therapy. Finally, the results of a novel experimental melanoma vaccine were presented using autologous tumor-derived heat-shock protein peptide complex-96 (HSPPC-96).

Improved staging of node-negative patients with intermediate to thick melanomas (>1 mm) with the use of lymphatic mapping and sentinel lymph node biopsy

BACKGROUND

Elective lymph node dissection (ELND) may contribute to a survival benefit in certain stratified subsets of melanoma patients. We hypothesized that lymphatic mapping and sentinel lymph node (SLN) biopsy (with complete node dissection if metastases are present) may improve both staging and survival of patients with clinically negative nodes, without subjecting all patients to the morbidity associated with complete ELND.

METHODS

We reviewed the data for all 14,914 N0 patients of the AJCC Melanoma Staging Database to determine the effect of SLN biopsy and ELND on staging and survival.

RESULTS

Retrospective analysis revealed that there was an apparent statistically significant survival advantage to SLN biopsy in patients with melanomas > 1 mm (n = 9024; 68.5% and 26.2% reduction in mortality compared with patients staged to be N0 by clinical exam and ELND, respectively; P < .0001). Five-year survivals were 90.5%, 77.7%, and 69.8%, respectfully, for patients staged by SLN biopsy (n = 2552), ELND (n = 2014), and clinical examination alone (n = 5192). The survival advantage of SLN biopsy was statistically significant for each T-stage category (T2, T3, and T4) and ulceration status. There was no advantage to SLN biopsy in patients with melanomas <1 mm (n = 5890).

CONCLUSIONS

SLN biopsy provides more accurate staging and may contribute to a survival benefit in populations of patients with melanoma.

Patterns of regional and distant metastasis in patients with conjunctival melanoma: experience at a cancer center over four decades

OBJECTIVE

The regional lymph nodes generally are believed to be the most common first site of metastasis for conjunctival malignant melanoma, but the pattern of nodal metastasis in this disease has not been well established. The goal of this study was to determine the frequency, location, and timing of regional lymph node metastasis in patients with conjunctival melanoma treated at one cancer center over four decades.

DESIGN

Retrospective case series.

PARTICIPANTS

Twenty-seven patients.

METHODS

The clinical records of 27 patients with conjunctival malignant melanoma were reviewed retrospectively.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The rates of local conjunctival recurrence, regional nodal metastasis, and distant metastasis were analyzed along with overall survival. The follow-up time ranged from 2.5 to 17 years (median, 6 years).

RESULTS

Eleven patients (41%) experienced clinical regional lymph node metastasis 1.5 to 6.0 years (mean, 3.2 years) after the initial diagnosis. The involved lymphatics were the preauricular (parotid) nodes in 8 patients (73%), the submandibular nodes in 1 patient (9%), and the deeper cervical nodes in 2 patients (18%). In seven patients (26%), distant metastasis developed without evidence of prior or concurrent regional nodal disease. Patients in whom distant metastasis developed without clinical evidence of regional nodal involvement were more likely to have had local conjunctival recurrence (P = 0.03) and a higher number of local recurrences (P = 0.05) compared with patients with regional lymph nodes as the site of first metastasis. The 5- and 10-year overall survival rates were 74% and 41%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Regional lymph node metastasis occurred in a higher percentage of patients with conjunctival malignant melanoma than has been reported previously. Preauricular lymph nodes were most commonly involved. Distant metastasis without prior or concurrent lymph node involvement was not a rare event.

Sentinel lymph node biopsy for conjunctival melanoma

OBJECTIVE

To investigate the feasibility and safety of preoperative lymphoscintigraphy and sentinel lymph node (SLN) biopsy for conjunctival melanoma.

METHODS

A 49-year-old man with a biopsy-proven malignant melanoma of the conjunctiva (caruncle) underwent preoperative lymphoscintigraphy and SLN biopsy using a technique in which both isosulfan blue dye and technetium Tc 99 m sulfur colloid were injected in the subconjunctival space around the primary lesion. The conjunctival melanoma was excised just before identification and removal of the SLNs. The SLNs were excised along with concomitant dissection of their associated lymph node basins. The SLNs were evaluated histologically using serial sectioning and immunohistochemical staining with antisera against the S-100 protein and the melanoma antigen HMB-45.

RESULTS

Three SLNs were identified in the left submandibular and the left upper and middle jugular lymph node basins during the preoperative lymphoscintigraphy. The same three SLNs were successfully identified in the operating room. The SLNs were histologically negative, and the immunohistochemical staining against S-100 and HMB-45 was also negative. We did not observe any immediate adverse effects on the globe or the periocular structures from lymphatic mapping and SLN biopsy. By 24 hours after injection of blue dye, only a faint trace of blue was visible on the ocular surface.

CONCLUSIONS

Preoperative lymphoscintigraphy and SLN biopsy can be performed safely in patients with conjunctival melanoma. A larger study is planned to determine the sensitivity of this technique for the detection of occult regional nodal disease in patients with conjunctival melanoma.

Final version of the American Joint Committee on Cancer staging system for cutaneous melanoma

PURPOSE

To revise the staging system for cutaneous melanoma under the auspices of the American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The prognostic factors analysis described in the companion publication (this issue), as well as evidence from the published literature, was used to assemble the tumor-node-metastasis criteria and stage grouping for the melanoma staging system.

RESULTS

Major changes include (1) melanoma thickness and ulceration but not level of invasion to be used in the T category (except for T1 melanomas); (2) the number of metastatic lymph nodes rather than their gross dimensions and the delineation of clinically occult (ie, microscopic) versus clinically apparent (ie, macroscopic) nodal metastases to be used in the N category; (3) the site of distant metastases and the presence of elevated serum lactic dehydrogenase to be used in the M category; (4) an upstaging of all patients with stage I, II, and III disease when a primary melanoma is ulcerated; (5) a merging of satellite metastases around a primary melanoma and in-transit metastases into a single staging entity that is grouped into stage III disease; and (6) a new convention for defining clinical and pathologic staging so as to take into account the staging information gained from intraoperative lymphatic mapping and sentinel node biopsy.

CONCLUSION

This revision will become official with publication of the sixth edition of the AJCC Cancer Staging Manual in the year 2002.

Prognostic factors analysis of 17,600 melanoma patients: validation of the American Joint Committee on Cancer melanoma staging system

PURPOSE

The American Joint Committee on Cancer (AJCC) recently proposed major revisions of the tumor-node-metastases (TNM) categories and stage groupings for cutaneous melanoma. Thirteen cancer centers and cancer cooperative groups contributed staging and survival data from a total of 30,450 melanoma patients from their databases in order to validate this staging proposal.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

There were 17,600 melanoma patients with complete clinical, pathologic, and follow-up information. Factors predicting melanoma-specific survival rates were analyzed using the Cox proportional hazards regression model. Follow-up survival data for 5 years or longer were available for 73% of the patients.

RESULTS

This analysis demonstrated that (1) in the T category, tumor thickness and ulceration were the most powerful predictors of survival, and the level of invasion had a significant impact only within the subgroup of thin (< or = 1 mm) melanomas; (2) in the N category, the following three independent factors were identified: the number of metastatic nodes, whether nodal metastases were clinically occult or clinically apparent, and the presence or absence of primary tumor ulceration; and (3) in the M category, nonvisceral metastases was associated with a better survival compared with visceral metastases. A marked diversity in the natural history of pathologic stage III melanoma was demonstrated by five-fold differences in 5-year survival rates for defined subgroups. This analysis also demonstrated that large and complex data sets could be used effectively to examine prognosis and survival outcome in melanoma patients.

CONCLUSION

The results of this evidence-based methodology were incorporated into the AJCC melanoma staging as described in the companion publication.

Dominant-negative transcription factor AP-2 augments SB-2 melanoma tumor growth in vivo

We have previously demonstrated that the transition of melanoma to the metastatic phenotype is associated with a loss of expression of the transcription factor AP-2. To further investigate the role of AP-2 in the progression of human melanoma, we attempted to inactivate AP-2 in primary cutaneous SB-2 melanoma cells by using a dominant-negative AP-2, or AP-2B, gene. AP-2B is an alternatively spliced AP-2 variant capable of inhibiting AP-2 trans-activator function. Stable transfection of primary cutaneous melanoma SB-2 cells with the dominant-negative AP-2B gene was confirmed by RT--PCR and Northern blot analyses. Electromobility shift assay using nuclear extracts from these cell lines demonstrated decreased functional binding of AP-2B-transfected cells to the AP-2 consensus binding sequence compared with neo-transfected controls. In addition, CAT activity driven by a construct containing the AP-2 consensus binding sequence was downregulated in the AP-2B transfected cells, indicating AP-2 activity was quenched in the transfected cells. Orthotopic (subcutaneous) injection of the dominant-negative (AP-2B)-transfected cell lines into nude mice increased their tumorigenicity compared to control neo-transfected cells. The AP-2B-transfected cells displayed an increase in MMP-2 expression (by Northern blot) and MMP-2 activity (by zymography), which resulted in an increase in invasiveness through Matrigel-coated filters. The AP-2B-transfected tumors also displayed an increase in MMP-2 expression, microvessel density, and angiogenesis in vivo. These results demonstrate that inactivation of AP-2 contributes to the progression of melanoma, at least partially via deregulation of the MMP-2 gene.

Sentinel lymph node biopsy for melanoma: controversy despite widespread agreement

Although sentinel lymph node (SLN) biopsy for melanoma has been adopted throughout the United States and abroad as a standard method of determining the pathologic status of the regional lymph nodes, some controversy still exists regarding the validity and utility of this procedure. SLN biopsy is a minimally invasive procedure, performed on an outpatient basis at the time of wide local excision of the melanoma, with little morbidity. Numerous studies have documented the accuracy of this procedure for identifying nodal metastases. There are four major reasons to perform SLN biopsy. First, SLN biopsy improves the accuracy of staging and provides valuable prognostic information for patients and physicians to guide subsequent treatment decisions. Second, SLN biopsy facilitates early therapeutic lymph node dissection for those patients with nodal metastases. Third, SLN biopsy identifies patients who are candidates for adjuvant therapy with interferon alfa-2b. Fourth, SLN biopsy identifies homogeneous patient populations for entry onto clinical trials of novel adjuvant therapy agents. Overall, the benefit of accurate nodal staging obtained by SLN biopsy far outweighs the risks and has important implications for patient management.

Sentinel lymph node biopsy for melanoma: how many radioactive nodes should be removed?

BACKGROUND

Sentinel lymph node (SLN) biopsy has become a standard method of staging patients with cutaneous melanoma. Sentinel lymph node biopsy usually is performed by intradermal injection of a vital blue dye (isosulfan blue) plus radioactive colloid (technetium sulfur colloid) around the site of the tumor. Intraoperative gamma probe detection has been shown to improve the rate of SLN identification compared to the use of blue dye alone. However, multiple sentinel nodes often are detected using the gamma probe. It is not clear whether these additional lymph nodes represent true sentinel nodes, or second-echelon lymph nodes that have received radiocolloid particles that have passed through the true sentinel node. This analysis was performed to determine the frequency with which these less radioactive lymph nodes contain metastatic disease when the most radioactive, or "hottest," node does not.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In the Sunbelt Melanoma Trial, 1184 patients with cutaneous melanoma of Breslow thickness 1.0 mm or more had sentinel lymph nodes identified. Sentinel lymph node biopsy was performed by injection of technetium sulfur colloid plus isosulfan blue dye in 99% of cases. Intraoperative determination of the degree of radioactivity of sentinel nodes (ex vivo) was measured, as well as the degree of blue dye staining.

RESULTS

Sentinel nodes were identified in 1373 nodal basins in 1184 patients. A total of 288 of 1184 patients (24.3%) were found to have sentinel node metastases detected by histology or immunohistochemistry. Nodal metastases were detected in 306 nodal basins in these 288 patients. There were 175 nodal basins from 170 patients in which at least one positive sentinel node was found and more than one sentinel node was harvested. Blue dye staining was found in 86.3% of the histologically positive sentinel nodes and 66.4% of the negative sentinel nodes. In 40 of 306 positive nodal basins (13.1%), the most radioactive sentinel node was negative for tumor when another, less radioactive, sentinel node was positive for tumor. In 20 of 40 cases (50%), the less radioactive positive sentinel node contained 50% or less of the radioactive count of the hottest lymph node. The cervical lymph node basin was associated with an increased likelihood of finding a positive sentinel node other than the hottest node.

CONCLUSIONS

If only the most radioactive sentinel node in each basin had been removed, 13.1% of the nodal basins with positive sentinel nodes would have been missed. It is recommended that all blue lymph nodes and all nodes that measure 10% or higher of the ex vivo radioactive count of the hottest sentinel node should be harvested for optimal detection of nodal metastases.

Significance of plasma cytokine levels in melanoma patients with histologically negative sentinel lymph nodes

INTRODUCTION

Although sentinel lymph node (SLN) status is the most powerful predictor of prognosis in patients with clinically localized melanoma, a proportion of melanoma patients with histologically negative SLNs will still recur. It is hypothesized that tumor response may be altered or mediated by specific cytokines. We therefore investigated whether levels of IL-4, IL-6, IL-10, TNF-alpha, or IFN-gamma would predict disease recurrence in melanoma patients with histologically negative SLNs.

METHODS

This prospective cohort study involved 218 patients with clinically localized melanoma who underwent a histologically negative SLN biopsy. Preoperative plasma cytokine levels were determined by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay on these patients, as well as on 90 healthy controls. Kaplan-Meier life tables were constructed, and Cox proportional hazards analyses were performed to assess predictors of disease-free survival (DFS).

RESULTS

At a median follow-up of 43 months, 33 of 218 patients (15%) had suffered disease recurrence. Melanoma patients had significant elevations of IL-4, IL-6, and IL-10 compared to healthy controls; levels of IFN-gamma were less elevated in melanoma patients compared to controls. Despite this, melanoma patients with detectable IFN-gamma levels were at significantly higher risk for recurrence compared to patients with undetectable levels (5-year DFS 70% vs. 86%, P = .03). On multivariate analysis including standard melanoma prognostic factors, only tumor thickness (P = .004) and the presence of detectable IFN-gamma levels (P = .05) were significant independent prognostic factors for disease-free survival.

CONCLUSIONS

Among melanoma patients with clinically localized disease who have undergone a histologically negative SLN biopsy, presence of a detectable plasma level of IFN-gamma is an independent predictor of disease recurrence. Elevated levels of IFN-gamma may identify a group of early-stage melanoma patients who are more likely to have recurrence of disease and who may benefit from adjuvant therapies, including immunotherapies.

Classification and staging of melanoma

Although a standardized and uniformly accepted cancer staging system is an essential and fundamental requirement to enable meaningful comparisons across patient populations, the sometimes capricious biologic behavior of melanoma makes developing such a staging system particularly difficult. Since the earliest well-documented attempts at classifying patients with cutaneous melanoma were described more than 50 years ago, the identification of increasingly powerful prognostic factors has led to sequential modifications of the cutaneous melanoma staging system. The current AJCC staging system is based on relatively well-established prognostic factors; however, several recent reports have identified additional prognostic factors not included in the current system, and other studies support the re-evaluation of some of the currently employed staging criteria. Some of the more controversial areas include the relevance of level of invasion versus tumor thickness, optimal cutoffs for tumor thickness, importance of ulceration, the grouping of satellites with in-transit metastases, the inclusion of microsatellites and local recurrences as a separate staging criterion, the replacement of size of nodal mass with number of positive nodes, the importance of nodal metastases in more than one nodal basin, and the prognostic significance of distant metastases. Future modifications of the staging system are anticipated to better incorporate these observations. Stage-specific staging recommendations for the patient with melanoma provide the clinician with a framework to most efficiently assess extent of disease in an era of cost-conscious clinical practice. In the asymptomatic patient with primary melanoma (stage I or II), we recommend a chest roentgenogram and evaluation of alkaline phosphatase and LDH levels; extensive radiologic evaluations are not indicated, because the rate of detection in this population is extremely low. Additional staging information should also be obtained by the technique of lymphatic mapping and sentinel lymphadenectomy. For patients with local-regional disease (stage III, satellites, and local recurrence), a selective approach to imaging studies is warranted. For this patient population, we recommend complete blood count, liver function tests including alkaline phosphatase and LDH, a chest roentgenogram, and a CT scan of the abdomen. Although the yield of these tests, particularly CT of the abdomen, in detecting distant metastases in asymptomatic patients is low, they may identify false-positive abnormalities and provide an important baseline for future studies in this high-risk population. For patients with disease below the waist or in the head and neck region, we recommend CT of the pelvis and CT of the neck, respectively. Additional studies should be done only if clinically indicated. Finally, patients with known systemic disease (stage IV) should be more comprehensively evaluated, because the likelihood of detecting asymptomatic metastases is higher. Accordingly, in addition to the work-up outlined previously for stage III patients, we also perform a CT scan of the chest and MR imaging of the brain; other studies (e.g., bone scan, gastrointestinal series) are performed on the basis of symptoms.

How many lymph nodes are enough during sentinel lymphadenectomy for primary melanoma?

BACKGROUND

Sentinel lymph node (SLN) biopsy has been shown to reliably identify nodal metastases and the subsequent need for further surgical and adjuvant therapy in patients with cutaneous melanoma. Although SLN identification rates have improved with the addition of radioactive colloid to the blue dye technique, it remains unclear how many lymph nodes should be removed to accurately determine the histologic status of the nodal basin. The objective of this study was to determine the optimal extent of SLN biopsy in these patients.

METHODS

The records of 633 consecutive patients with melanoma (765 nodal basins) whose primary treatment included SLN biopsy with the use of a combination of blue dye and technetium Tc 99 labeled sulfur colloid were reviewed. SLN biopsy consisted of the removal of all of the blue-stained nodes and all nodes with radiotracer uptake activity of at least twice background.

RESULTS

SLN biopsy was successful in 765 of 772 basins (99%). A mean of 1.9 SLNs (median, 2 SLNs) per basin were excised. At least 3 SLNs were removed in 176 basins (23%). The overall histologic status of a basin was always established by the first or second SLN harvested (ie, in no patient was the third or subsequent SLN positive when 1 of the first 2 was not). Of the 124 basins containing lymphatic metastases, the SLN that contained the maximal radiotracer uptake (hottest) and/or stained blue was pathologically positive in 118 basins (95%). In only 6 of the 124 positive basins (5%) was the sole evidence of occult nodal metastases identified in an SLN that was neither blue-stained nor the hottest. All but 1 of these SLNs had counts that were at least 66% of the hottest node in the basin.

CONCLUSIONS

With a combined modality approach to SLN biopsy, removal of more than 2 SLNs did not provide information that upstaged any patient with primary melanoma. Removal of additional nonblue SLN(s) that contained radioactive counts of at least twice background but lower than two thirds of the SLNs with maximal radiotracer uptake affected patient management in less than 0.2% of all cases. These findings may be helpful in minimizing the extent of surgery and perhaps in reducing the costs and resource use associated with operating room time and pathologic examination.

Clinical classification and staging

The identification of increasingly powerful prognostic factors has led to sequential modifications of the cutaneous melanoma staging system. Changes in the staging system are anticipated as more refined prognostic factors are identified. This article provides an overview of the system, including a brief history and an introduction to recent advances in staging of patients with primary melanoma (i.e., sentinel lymphadenectomy). Practical recommendations for a stage-specific workup for the patient, which are especially important given the need for quality care in an increasingly cost-conscious environment, are provided.

Significance of multiple nodal basin drainage in truncal melanoma patients undergoing sentinel lymph node biopsy

BACKGROUND

Although previous studies have demonstrated that truncal site is associated with an adverse prognosis, explanations for such risk are lacking. In addition, the number of nodal basins as well as the number of lymph nodes containing regional metastases are important prognostic factors in these patients. Because the lymphatic drainage pattern of truncal melanoma often includes more than one basin, we designed a study to evaluate (1) whether patients with multiple nodal basin drainage (MNBD) were at an increased risk of lymph node metastases identified by sentinel lymph node (SLN) biopsy, and (2) whether the histological status of an individual basin reliably predicted the status of the other draining basins in patients with MNBD.

METHODS

The records of 295 consecutive truncal melanoma patients who were managed primarily with intraoperative lymphatic mapping and SLN biopsy, between 1991 and 1997, were reviewed. All patients underwent preoperative lymphoscintigraphy, which established the number and location of draining nodal basins. Univariate and multivariate analyses of relevant clinicopathological factors were performed to assess which factors may predict the presence of a pathologically positive SLN.

RESULTS

At least one SLN was identified in 281 patients. MNBD was present in 86 (31%) patients, and a pathologically positive SLN was found in 56 (20%) patients. By multivariate analysis, the presence of MNBD (relative risk = 1.9; P = .03), tumor thickness (P = .007), and tumor ulceration (relative risk = 2.4; P = .01) were significant independent risk factors for the presence of at least one pathologically positive SLN. SLN pathology in one basin did not predict the histology of other basins in 19 (22%) of 86 patients with MNBD.

CONCLUSIONS

MNBD is independently associated with an increased risk of nodal metastases in truncal melanoma patients. Because the histological status of an individual basin did not reliably predict the status of the other draining basins in patients with MNBD, it is important to adequately identify and completely assess all nodal basins at risk, as defined by lymphoscintigraphy, in truncal melanoma patients.

Regional nodal basin control is not compromised by previous sentinel lymph node biopsy in patients with melanoma

BACKGROUND

Regional nodal basin control is an important goal of lymphadenectomy in the management of melanoma patients with nodal disease. The purpose of this study was to determine if previous sentinel lymph node (SLN) biopsy compromises the ultimate regional nodal control achieved by subsequent therapeutic lymph node dissection in melanoma patients with microscopic lymph node metastases.

METHODS

A surgical melanoma database and hospital records were reviewed for 602 patients with primary cutaneous melanoma who underwent successful lymphatic mapping and SLN biopsy between 1991 and 1997.

RESULTS

A total of 105 (17%) of 602 patients had histologically positive SLNs and were offered therapeutic lymphadenectomy; 101 (96%) underwent this procedure. Thirty-six patients (36%) developed recurrent melanoma at one or more sites. The median follow-up period was 30 months. Recurrence in the previously dissected nodal basin was observed in 10 patients (10%); none had recurrence at only that site. Nodal basin disease appeared after local/in-transit (n = 6) or distant (n = 1) failure in seven patients and, as a component of the first site of failure, simultaneously with local/in-transit (n = 2) or distant (n = 1) recurrence in three patients.

CONCLUSIONS

Nodal basin failure after lymphadenectomy in patients who underwent previous biopsy of a histologically positive SLN is primarily a function of aggressive locoregional disease rather than of contamination from previous surgery. Because regional nodal control was comparable with that in other series, we conclude that SLN biopsy with selective lymphadenectomy does not compromise regional nodal basin control.

A new American Joint Committee on Cancer staging system for cutaneous melanoma

The Melanoma Staging Committee of the AJCC has proposed major revisions of the melanoma TNM and stage grouping criteria. The committee members represent most of the major cooperative groups and cancer centers worldwide with a special interest in melanoma; the committee also collectively has had clinical experience with over 40,000 patients. The new staging system better reflects independent prognostic factors that are used in clinical trials and in reporting the outcomes of various melanoma treatment modalities. Major revisions include 1) melanoma thickness and ulceration, but not level of invasion, to be used in the T classification; 2) the number of metastatic lymph nodes, rather than their gross dimensions, the delineation of microscopic versus macroscopic lymph node metastases, and presence of ulceration of the primary melanoma to be used in the N classification; 3) the site of distant metastases and the presence of elevated serum LDH, to be used in the M classification; 4) an upstaging of all patients with Stage I,II, and III disease when a primary melanoma is ulcerated; 5) a merging of satellite metastases around a primary melanoma and in-transit metastases into a single staging entity that is grouped into Stage III disease; and 6) a new convention for defining clinical and pathologic staging so as to take into account the new staging information gained from intraoperative lymphatic mapping and sentinel lymph node biopsy. The AJC Melanoma Staging Committee invites comments and suggestions regarding this proposed staging system before a final recommendation is made.

Role for lymphatic mapping and sentinel lymph node biopsy in patients with thick (> or = 4 mm) primary melanoma

BACKGROUND

Historically, patients with thick (> or =4 mm) primary melanoma have not been considered candidates for elective lymph node dissection, because their risk for occult distant disease is significant. Sentinel lymph node (SLN) biopsy offers an alternative approach to assess disease in the regional nodal basin, but no studies have specifically addressed the role for this technique in patients with thick melanoma. Although adjuvant therapy benefits patients who develop nodal metastases, data that supports its routine use in all patients with thick melanoma is both limited and controversial. This study was performed to determine whether pathological status of the SLN is an important risk factor in this heterogeneous group and, thus, provides a rationale for SLN biopsy.

METHODS

The records of 131 patients with primary cutaneous melanoma whose primary tumors were at least 4 mm thick and who underwent lymphatic mapping and SLN biopsy were reviewed. Several known prognostic factors, i.e., tumor thickness, ulceration, Clark level, location, sex, as well as SLN pathological status were analyzed with respect to disease-free and overall survival.

RESULTS

Lymphatic mapping and SLN biopsy was successful in 126 (96%) of 131 patients who underwent the procedure. In 49 patients (39%), the SLN biopsy was positive by conventional histology, although it was negative in 77 patients (61%). The median follow-up was 3 years. Although presence of ulceration and SLN status were independent prognostic factors with respect to disease-free and overall survival, SLN status was the most powerful predictor of overall survival by univariate and multivariate analyses.

CONCLUSIONS

Lymphatic mapping and SLN biopsy is a highly accurate method of staging lymph node basins at risk for regional metastases in patients with thick melanoma and identifies those patients who may benefit from earlier lymphadenectomy as well as patients with a more favorable prognosis. Pathological status of the SLN in these patients with clinically negative nodes is the most important prognostic factor for survival and is essential to establish stratification criteria for future adjuvant trials in this high-risk group.

Multi-institutional melanoma lymphatic mapping experience: the prognostic value of sentinel lymph node status in 612 stage I or II melanoma patients

PURPOSE

To compare the effect of pathologic sentinel lymph node (SLN) status with that of other known prognostic factors on recurrence and survival in patients with stage I or II cutaneous melanoma.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We reviewed the records of 612 patients with primary cutaneous melanoma who underwent lymphatic mapping and SLN biopsy between January 1991 and May 1995 to determine the effects of tumor thickness, ulceration, Clark level, location, sex, and SLN pathologic status on disease-free and disease-specific survival.

RESULTS

In the 580 patients in whom lymphatic mapping and SLN biopsy were successful, the SLN was positive by conventional histology in 85 patients (15%) but negative in 495 patients (85%). SLN status was the most significant prognostic factor with respect to disease-free and disease-specific survival by univariate and multiple covariate analyses. Although tumor thickness and ulceration influenced survival in SLN-negative patients, they provided no additional prognostic information in SLN-positive patients.

CONCLUSION

Lymphatic mapping and SLN biopsy is highly accurate in staging nodal basins at risk for regional metastases in primary melanoma patients and identifies those who may benefit from earlier lymphadenectomy. Furthermore, pathologic status of the SLN in these patients with clinically negative nodes is the most important prognostic factor for recurrence. The information from SLN biopsy is particularly helpful in establishing stratification criteria for future adjuvant trials.

Synchronous elective contralateral mastectomy and immediate bilateral breast reconstruction in women with early-stage breast cancer

BACKGROUND

The role of elective contralateral mastectomy (ECM) in women with early-stage breast cancer who elect or require an ipsilateral mastectomy and desire immediate bilateral breast reconstruction (IBR) is an intellectual and emotional dilemma for both patient and physician. In an attempt to clarify the rationale for this approach, we reviewed our experience with ECM and IBR and evaluated operative morbidity, the incidence of occult contralateral breast cancer, and patterns of recurrence.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed the records of 155 patients with primary unilateral breast cancer (stage 0, I, or II) and negative findings on physical and mammographic examinations of the contralateral breast who underwent ipsilateral mastectomy and simultaneous ECM with IBR between 1987 and 1995.

RESULTS

The median age of the patients was 46 years (range, 25 to 69 years). Clinical stage at diagnosis was stage 0, I, and II in 19.4%, 54.2%, and 26.4% of patients, respectively. Factors likely to influence the use of ECM were family history of breast cancer in first-degree relatives (30%), any family history of breast cancer (56%), difficulty anticipated in contralateral breast surveillance (48%), associated lobular carcinoma in situ (23%), multicentric primary tumor (28%), significant reconstructive issues (14%), and failure of mammographic identification of the primary tumor (16%). Skin-sparing mastectomies were performed in 81% of patients. Overall, 70% of patients underwent reconstruction using autogenous tissue transfer. Reoperations for suspected anastomotic thrombosis were performed in seven patients. Two patients experienced significant partial or complete flap loss. Histopathologic findings in the ECM specimen were as follows: benign, 80% of patients; atypical ductal hyperplasia, 12% of patients; lobular carcinoma in situ, 6.5% of patients; ductal carcinoma in situ, 2.7% of patients; and invasive carcinoma, 1.3% of patients. Eighteen patients (12%) had evidence of locoregional or distant recurrences, with a median follow-up of 3 years. In one patient (0.6%), invasive ductal carcinoma developed on the side of the elective mastectomy.

CONCLUSIONS

The use of ECM and IBR cannot be justified if the only oncologic criterion considered is the incidence of occult synchronous contralateral disease. However, in a highly selected population of young patients with a difficult clinical or mammographic examination and an increased lifetime risk of developing a second primary tumor, ECM and IBR is a safe approach.