The Society of Thoracic Surgeons Database Analysis: Comparing Sublobar Techniques in Stage IA Lung Cancer

BACKGROUND

This study compares sublobar resections-wedge resection and segmentectomy-in clinical stage IA lung cancers. It tests the hypothesis that overall survival after wedge resection is similar to segmentectomy.

METHODS

Adults undergoing wedge resection or segmentectomy for clinical stage IA lung cancer were identified from The Society of Thoracic Surgeons General Thoracic Surgery Database. Eligible patients were linked to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services database using a matching algorithm. The primary outcome was long-term overall survival. Propensity scores overlap weighting (PSOW) adjustment of wedge resection using validated covariates was used for group difference mitigation. Kaplan-Meier and Cox regression models analyzed survival. All-cause first readmission, and morbidity and mortality were examined using PSOW regression models.

RESULTS

Of 9756 patients, 6141 met inclusion criteria, comprising 2154 segmentectomies and 3987 wedge resections. PSOW reduced differences between the groups. Unadjusted perioperative mortality was comparable, but wedge resection showed lower major morbidity rates. Weighted regression analysis indicated reduced mortality and major morbidity risks in wedge resection. Kaplan-Meier analysis revealed no mortality difference between groups, which was confirmed by PSOW Cox regression models. The cumulative risk of readmission was also comparable for both groups, with Cox Fine-Gray models showing no difference in rehospitalization risks.

CONCLUSIONS

In clinical stage IA lung cancer, relative to segmentectomy, wedge resection has comparable overall survival and lower perioperative morbidity, suggesting it is an equally effective option for the broader population of patients with clinical stage IA lung cancer, not only those at highest risk of complications.

Risk Factors for Chronic Atrial Fibrillation Following Lung Lobectomy

INTRODUCTION

Postoperative atrial fibrillation (POAF) is a common complication following lung lobectomy and is associated with increased risk of stroke, mortality, and prolonged hospital length of stay. The purpose of this study was to define the risk factors for POAF after lobectomy, hypothesizing that operative approach would be associated with risk of chronic POAF.

METHODS

The TriNetX database was used to identify adult patients with no history of arrythmia receiving elective lung lobectomy for cancer from 7/6/2003-7/6/2023. Patients were categorized by approach: video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) or open. The outcome of interest was the presence of POAF occurring at 1-3 months ("early") and 12-24 months postop ("chronic"). Propensity matching was performed to reduce bias between cohorts.

RESULTS

We identified 22,998 patients: 8472 (36.8%) who received open and 14,526 (63.2%) VATS lobectomy. The rate of early POAF was 3.7% of VATS and 5.3% of open patients. The rate of chronic POAF was 5.5 % of VATS patients and 6.2% of open lobectomy patients. Propensity matching decreased bias between the approach groups, creating 7942 pairs for analysis. After matching, the risk of early POAF was greater in the open approach (5.5% open vs 3.4% VATS, risk ratio 1.607 (95% confidence interval 1.385-1.865), P < 0.001). Chronic POAF was (also) higher in the open approach (6.3% open vs 5.2% VATS, Risk Ratio 1.211 (95%CI 1.067-1.374), P = 0.003).

CONCLUSIONS

Postoperative atrial fibrillation (POAF) occurs more commonly after open lobectomy, both acutely and chronically. Providers should counsel patients about the risk of chronic arrythmia after lung resection.

Frailty is associated with 90-day mortality in urgent thoracic surgery conditions

Objective

In patients undergoing elective thoracic surgery, frailty is associated with worse outcomes. However, the magnitude by which frailty influences outcomes of urgent thoracic surgery (UTS) is unknown.

Methods

We identified patients admitted with a UTS condition from January to September 2017 in the National Readmissions Database. UTS conditions were classified as esophageal perforation, hemo/pneumothorax, rib fracture, and obstructed hiatal hernia. Outcome of interest was mortality within 90 days of index admission. Frailty score was calculated using a deficit accumulation method. Cox proportional hazard modeling was used to calculate a hazard ratio for each combination of UTS disease type and frailty score, adjusted for sex, insurance payor, hospital size, and hospital and patient location, and was compared with the effect of frailty on elective lung lobectomy.

Results

We identified 107,487 patients with a UTS condition. Among UTS conditions overall, increasing frailty elements were associated with increased mortality (hazard ratio, 2270; 95% CI, 1463-3523; P < .001). Compared with patients without frailty undergoing elective lobectomy, increasing frailty demonstrated trending toward increased mortality in all diagnoses. The magnitude of the effect of frailty on 90-day mortality differed depending on the disease and level of frailty.

Conclusions

The effect of frailty on 90-day mortality after admission for urgent thoracic surgery conditions varies by disease type and level of frailty. Among UTS disease types, increasing frailty was associated with a higher 90-day risk of mortality. These findings suggest a valuable role for frailty evaluation in both clinical settings and administrative data for risk assessment.

Uncovering Health-Care Disparities Through Patient Decisions in Lung Cancer Surgery

INTRODUCTION

Declining cancer surgery represents a conflict between patients' rights to autonomy and providers' perspectives of best practice. We hypothesize that, among patients with nonmetastatic lung cancer, patient demographics would be associated with different rates of declination of lung cancer surgery.

METHODS

Patients with nonmetastatic lung cancer from 2004 to 2018 in the National Cancer Database were identified. Patients were categorized into two groups based on surgical treatment: surgical resection and declined surgery. Patient characteristics were compared using bivariate and multivariate models to identify factors associated with surgical declination. Additionally, we performed subgroup analyses of cT1N0M0 patients with no comorbidities. Survival analysis done using multivariate cox analysis and Kaplan-Meier survival analysis.

RESULTS

478,757 patients were identified. In a multivariate model, declining surgery was associated with increased age (odds ratio 1.09, 1.09-1.10), non-Hispanic Black race (odds ratio 1.95, 1.73-2.21), nonprivate insurance, and lower Socioeconomic Status. In a subgroup of cT1N0M0 patients with no comorbidities, declining surgery was associated with increasing age, non-Hispanic Black race, nonprivate insurance, and socioeconomic status. Patient's that declined surgery demonstrated lower overall survival when compared to patients that underwent surgical resection (5 y overall survival: declined surgery 40% versus underwent resection 72%, P < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Although early-stage lung cancer is potentially curable, many patients decline guideline-based surgery, and have worse overall survival. There are social and economic factors associated with patients declining lung cancer surgery. Providers have an ethical responsibility to understand the basis of patient's decision to decline recommended surgery and address endemic disparities related to race and access to care.

National enrollment of lung cancer clinical trials is disproportionate based on race and health care access

OBJECTIVE

Despite declining lung cancer mortality in the United States, survival differences remain among racial and ethnic minorities in addition to those with limited health care access. Improvements in lung cancer treatment can be obtained through clinical trials, yet there are disparities in clinical trial enrollment of other cancer types. This study aims to evaluate disparities in lung cancer clinical trial enrollment to inform future enrollment initiatives.

METHODS

We analyzed patients with non-small cell lung cancer from the National Cancer Database (2004-2018), categorizing them as enrolled or not enrolled in clinical trials based on "rx_summ_other" data element. Clinical, demographic, and institutional factors associated with trial enrollment were assessed using bivariate and multivariate analysis, adjusting for institutional-level clustering.

RESULTS

A total of 1924 (0.12%) patients with lung cancer were enrolled in clinical trials. Enrolled patients were predominantly non-Hispanic White (82%), with greater socioeconomic status, treated at academic programs (67%), and had private insurance (42%) or Medicare (44%). They also traveled further for treatment compared with unenrolled patients (56 vs 27 miles, P < .001). After adjusting for demographic and clinical factors, lung cancer trial enrollment was significantly less likely among Black (odds ratio, 0.55; 95% confidence interval, 0.5-0.7, P < .001) and Hispanic (0.66; 95% confidence interval, 0.5-0.9, P = .01) patients. Patients with Medicaid or uninsured, in the lowest socioeconomic status group, and those treated at community-based cancer programs were the least likely to enroll.

CONCLUSIONS

Enrollment in lung cancer trials disproportionally excludes minority patients, those in the lowest socioeconomic status, community cancer programs, and the underinsured. These disparities in demographic and access for trial participation show a need for improved enrollment strategies.

Lung Cancer in Young Patients is Associated With More Advanced Disease but Better Overall Survival

INTRODUCTION

It is unclear whether nonsmall cell lung cancer (NSCLC) is associated with more aggressive disease and worse overall survival (OS) among younger patients. The aim of this study is to evaluate outcomes in young patients. We hypothesize that young age is associated with more advanced disease upon presentation, but better OS.

METHODS

We identified patients with NSCLC from 2004 to 2018 in the National Cancer Database. Patients were categorized in 3 groups: age≤50, 51-84, and ≥85 y. The outcomes were OS, stage IV NSCLC and clinical nodal metastasis. OS was analyzed using multivariate cox and Kaplan-Meier analysis accounting for stage, comorbidities, and other factors. The association of age, presentation with stage IV NSCLC and node positivity was analyzed using multivariate logistic regression.

RESULTS

In total 1,651,744 patients were identified: 92,506 (5.57%) age ≤50, 1,477,723 (88.90%) age 51-84, and 91,964 (5.53%) age ≥85. Multivariate model showed stage IV NSCLC was associated with age ≤50 (OR 1.17 (1.15-1.20) P < 0.001) and ≥85 (odds ratio (OR) 1.03 (1.02-1.04) P < 0.001). Clinical lymph node positivity was associated with age ≤50 (OR 1.27 (1.23-1.30) P < 0.001). Relative to patients 51-84, the ≤50 group was associated with better survival in Stage I (hazard ratio (HR) 0.61 versus 1.00), stage II (HR 1.12 versus 1.50), stage III (HR 2.12 versus 2.53), and stage IV (HR 6.65 versus 7.53).

CONCLUSIONS

Patients ≤50-y-old present with more advanced NSCLC, but better OS compared to patients 51-84. These findings suggest the need for increased awareness regarding NSCLC among age groups seen as low risk.

Evaluating the Optimal Time Between Diagnosis and Surgical Intervention for Early-Stage Lung Cancer

INTRODUCTION

There is no consensus on the optimal timing for lung cancer surgery. We aim to evaluate the impact of timing of surgical intervention. We hypothesize delay in intervention is associated with worse overall survival and higher pathologic upstaging in early-stage lung cancer.

METHODS

We identified patients with cT1/2N0M0 nonsmall cell lung cancer in the National Cancer Database from 2004 to 2018. Patients were categorized by time to surgery groups: early (<26 d), average (26-60 d), and delayed (61-365 d). Primary outcome was overall survival and secondary outcome was pathologic upstaging. Multivariate models and survival analyses were used to determine factors associated with time from diagnosis to surgery, pathologic upstaging, and overall survival.

RESULTS

In multivariate model, advanced age, non-Hispanic Black patients, nonprivate insurance, low median income and education, and treatment at low-volume facilities were less likely to undergo early intervention and compared to the average group were more likely to receive delayed intervention. Pathologic upstaging was more likely in the delayed group (odds ratio 1.11, 1.07-1.14) compared to early group (odds ratio 0.96, 0.93-0.99). Early intervention was associated with improved overall survival (hazard ratio 0.93, 0.91-0.95), while delayed intervention was associated with inferior survival (hazard ratio 1.11, 1.09-1.14).

CONCLUSIONS

Expeditious surgical intervention is associated with lower rates of pathologic upstaging and improved overall survival in early-stage lung cancer. Delays in surgery are associated with social and economic factors, suggesting disparities in access to surgery. Lung cancer surgery should be performed as quickly as possible to maximize oncologic outcomes.

Affordable Care Act Medicaid Expansion is Associated With Increased Utilization of Minimally Invasive Lung Resection for Early Stage Lung Cancer

OBJECTIVE

Minimally invasive lung resection (MILR) is underutilized in the United States. Under the Affordable Care Act (ACA), 39 states adopted Medicaid expansion, while 12 did not. Although Medicaid expansion has been associated with improved access to cancer care, its effect on utilization of MILR is unclear. We hypothesize that MILR would increase in Medicaid expansion states.

METHODS

The National Cancer Database was queried for adult patients from 2010 to 2018 with cT1/2N0M0 non-small cell lung cancer who received surgical resection by wedge, segmentectomy, or lobectomy. Patients were grouped by whether they received care in a state without Medicaid expansion vs expansion in January 2014. The outcome of interest was MILR (defined as video-assisted or robotic-assisted thoracoscopy) relative to open. Multivariable difference in differences (DID) cross-sectional analysis was used to estimate the average treatment effect (ATE) of Medicaid expansion.

RESULTS

There were 41,439 patients who met inclusion criteria: 20,446 (49.3%) in expansion states and 20,993 (50.7%) in non-expansion states. Multivariable DID analysis showed that Medicaid expansion was associated with an increase in Medicaid insurance type with an ATE of 7.4% (95% CI 7.1-7.7%, P = .002). Medicaid expansion was also associated with increased MILR utilization in unadjusted analysis (10,278/20,446 (50.3%) vs 9,953/20,993 (47.4%), p < .001) and in multivariable DID analysis (ATE 0.6%, 95% CI 0.3-0.8%, P = .008).

CONCLUSIONS

Although Medicaid expansion was associated with increased utilization of MILR for early stage lung cancer, the treatment effect was modest. This suggests that barriers in access to MILR are larger than simply access to care.

Motor Vehicle Protective Device Usage Associated with Decreased Rate of Flail Chest: A Retrospective Database Analysis

Background and Objectives: Protective equipment, including seatbelts and airbags, have dramatically reduced the morbidity and mortality rates associated with motor vehicle collisions (MVCs). While generally associated with a reduced rate of injury, the effect of motor vehicle protective equipment on patterns of chest wall trauma is unknown. We hypothesized that protective equipment would affect the rate of flail chest after an MVC. Materials and Methods: This study was a retrospective analysis of the 2019 iteration of the American College of Surgeons Trauma Quality Program (ACS-TQIP) database. Rib fracture types were categorized as non-flail chest rib fractures and flail chest using ICD-10 diagnosis coding. The primary outcome was the occurrence of flail chests after motor vehicle collisions. The protective equipment evaluated were seatbelts and airbags. We performed bivariate and multivariate logistic regression to determine the association of flail chest with the utilization of vehicle protective equipment. Results: We identified 25,101 patients with rib fractures after motor vehicle collisions. In bivariate analysis, the severity of the rib fractures was associated with seatbelt type, airbag status, smoking history, and history of cerebrovascular accident (CVA). In multivariate analysis, seatbelt use and airbag deployment (OR 0.76 CI 0.65-0.89) were independently associated with a decreased rate of flail chest. In an interaction analysis, flail chest was only reduced when a lap belt was used in combination with the deployed airbag (OR 0.59 CI 0.43-0.80) when a shoulder belt was used without airbag deployment (0.69 CI 0.49-0.97), or when a shoulder belt was used with airbag deployment (0.57 CI 0.46-0.70). Conclusions: Although motor vehicle protective equipment is associated with a decreased rate of flail chest after a motor vehicle collision, the benefit is only observed when lap belts and airbags are used simultaneously or when a shoulder belt is used. These data highlight the importance of occupant seatbelt compliance and suggest the effect of motor vehicle restraint systems in reducing severe chest wall injuries.

Is Sarcomatoid Lung Cancer Associated With Inferior Overall Survival? A National Cancer Database Analysis

INTRODUCTION

Sarcomatoid lung cancer has mainly been described in case series and single institution reviews. Although often associated with a poor prognosis, the overall survival compared to other forms of nonsmall cell lung cancer (NSCLC) is unknown. We hypothesize that sarcomatoid lung cancers have worse overall survival relative to other forms of NSCLC.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In this retrospective cohort study, we identified adult patients with nonmetastatic NSCLC from 2004 to 2018 in the National Cancer Database. Patients were categorized by histology as sarcomatoid, adenocarcinoma, or squamous cell carcinoma. We compared clinical and demographic characteristics between the groups. The primary outcome of overall survival was analyzed using Kaplan-Meier analysis. Multivariable Cox analysis was used to analyze factors associated with overall survival in sarcomatoid patients undergoing surgery.

RESULTS

Among 1,259,109 patients with lung cancer, there were 5223 (0.4%) sarcomatoid cancers. Sarcomatoid patients were more likely to be male, of Hispanic ethnicity, have fewer comorbidities, and receive treatment at an academic program. Despite higher cT- and M-stages, patients with sarcomatoid cancer were more likely to undergo surgical resection in multivariate analysis (odds ratio = 1.8 [confidence interval 1.60-2.11]; P < 0.001). Among nonmetastatic patients, overall survival was lower for sarcomatoid cancer relative to other histologies in Kaplan-Meier analysis (median survival sarcomatoid 17.6 mo versus nonsarcomatoid 31.5 mo, P < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

This National Cancer Database study confirms the findings of smaller studies that sarcomatoid cancer is associated with inferior overall survival compared to other NSCLCs. Given the inferior prognosis, further studies regarding optimal staging practices are appropriate.

Surgical subspecialization is associated with higher rate of rib fracture stabilization: a retrospective database analysis

Background

Surgical stabilization of rib fractures (SSRF) is performed on only a small subset of patients who meet guideline-recommended indications for surgery. Although previous studies show that provider specialization was associated with SSRF procedural competency, little is known about the impact of provider specialization on SSRF performance frequency. We hypothesize that provider specialization would impact performance of SSRF.

Methods

The Premier Hospital Database was used to identify adult patients with rib fractures from 2015 and 2019. The outcome of interest was performance of SSRF, defined using International Classification of Diseases—10th Revision Procedure Coding System coding. Patients were categorized as receiving their procedures from a thoracic, general surgeon, or orthopedic surgeon. Patients with missing or other provider types were excluded. Multivariate modeling was performed to evaluate the effect of surgical specialization on outcomes of SSRF. Given a priori assumptions that trauma centers may have different practice patterns, a subgroup analysis was performed excluding patients with ‘trauma center’ admissions.

Results

Among 39 733 patients admitted with rib fractures, 2865 (7.2%) received SSRF. Trauma center admission represented a minority (1034, 36%) of SSRF procedures relative to other admission types (1831, 64%, p=0.15). In a multivariable analysis, thoracic (OR 6.94, 95% CI 5.94–8.11) and orthopedic provider (OR 2.60, 95% CI 2.16–3.14) types were significantly more likely to perform SSRF. In further analyses of trauma center admissions versus non-trauma center admissions, this pattern of SSRF performance was found at non-trauma centers.

Conclusion

The majority of SSRF procedures in the USA are being performed by general surgeons and at non-trauma centers. ‘Subspecialty’ providers in orthopedics and thoracic surgery are performing fewer total SSRF interventions, but are more likely to perform SSRF, especially at non-trauma centers. Provider specialization as a barrier to SSRF may be related to competence in the SSRF procedures and requires further study.

Type

Therapeutic/care management.

Level of evidence

IV

Contemporary outcomes of esophageal and gastroesophageal junction neuroendocrine tumors

Adenocarcinoma and squamous cell esophageal cancers have been extensively studied in the literature. Esophageal neuroendocrine (NET)/carcinoid tumors are less commonly studied and have only been described in small series. The purpose of this study was to describe the demographics and natural history of esophageal NETs, as well as optimal treatments. We hypothesized that surgical resection would be the best treatment of esophageal NETs. The National Cancer Database was used to identify adult patients with esophageal or gastroesophageal junction (GEJ) cancer from 2004 to 2018. Patients were characterized as carcinoid/NET, adenocarcinoma, or squamous cell cancer. Clinical and demographic characteristics were compared between the histology groups. The primary outcome was overall survival, which was assessed by multivariable Cox analysis. Multivariable Cox analysis was also used to analyze factors associated with survival among NET patients who underwent surgery. Among 206,321 patients with esophageal cancer, 1,563 were NETs (<0.01%). Relative to the other two histologies, NETs were associated with younger age, female sex, and advanced clinical stage at diagnosis. Multivariate analysis suggested that NETs were less likely to be treated with surgical resection (OR 0.51, P < 0.001). Nonetheless, surgical resection was associated with improved survival (HR 0.64, P = 0.003). Among patients with NETs who received surgery, neoadjuvant therapy was associated with improved overall survival (HR 0.38, P = 0.013). NET of the esophagus presents with more advanced disease than other common histologies. Among patients with nonmetastatic cancer, surgical resection appears to be the best treatment. Neoadjuvant systemic therapy may offer survival benefit, but future studies are necessary.

Contemporary outcomes of surgical resection for chest wall chondrosarcoma

Objective

Chondrosarcoma is the most common primary malignant chest wall tumor and is historically associated with poor prognosis. Recommendations regarding surgical excision are on the basis of small, single-institution studies. We used a large national database to assess outcomes of surgery for chest wall chondrosarcoma (CWC) hypothesizing that surgical excision remains standard of care.

Methods

The National Cancer Databases for bone and soft tissue were merged to identify patients with chondrosarcoma from 2004 to 2018. Clinical and demographic characteristics of CWC were compared with chondrosarcoma from other sites. The primary outcome was overall survival described using Kaplan-Meier estimate. Univariable and multivariable Cox analysis was used to determine risk factors for poor survival among CWC patients who underwent surgery. Multivariable analysis of predictors of margin status was performed because of worse prognosis associated with positive margins.

Results

Among 11,925 patients with chondrosarcoma, 1934 (16.2%) had a CWC. Relative to other sites, CWC was associated with older age, male sex, White race, surgical resection, and care at a nonacademic institution. CWC was associated with 1-, 3-, 5-, and 10-year survival of 91.5%, 82.0%, 75.5%, and 62.7%, respectively. In univariable analysis, survival was associated with surgery (hazard ratio, 0.02; P < .001) and adversely affected by positive margins (hazard ratio, 2.66; P < .001). Multivariable analysis showed larger tumor size was independently associated with increased risk for positive margins (odds ratio, 1.04; 95% CI, 1.011-1.075).

Conclusions

CWC represents a different cohort of patients relative to chondrosarcoma from other sites. Surgical excision remains the optimal treatment, and positive margins are associated with poor prognosis.

Surgical Repair Versus Stent for Esophageal Perforation: A Multi-institutional Database Analysis

BACKGROUND

Endoscopic esophageal stenting is used as an alternative to surgical repair for esophageal perforation. Multi-institutional studies supporting stenting are lacking. The purpose of this study was to compare the outcomes of surgical repair and esophageal stenting in patients with esophageal perforation using a nationally representative database. We hypothesized that mortality between these approaches would not be different.

METHODS

The Premier Healthcare Database was used to compare adult inpatients with esophageal perforation receiving either surgical repair or esophageal stenting from 2009 to 2019. Patients receiving intervention ≤7 days of admission were included in the analysis. Patients receiving both stent and repair on the same day were excluded. The composite outcome of interest was death or discharge to hospice. Logistic regression was used to evaluate independent predictors of death or hospice, adjusting for comorbidities.

RESULTS

There were 2543 patients with esophageal perforation identified who received repair (1314 [51.7%]) or stenting (1229 [48.3%]). Stenting increased from 7.0% in 2009 to 78.1% in 2019. Patients receiving repair were more likely to be female and White and had fewer Elixhauser comorbidities. Death or discharge to hospice was more common after stent (134/1314 [10.2%] repair vs 199/1229 [16.2%] stent; P < .001); however, after adjustment for comorbidities, logistic regression suggested that death or hospice discharge was similar between approaches (stent vs repair: odds ratio, 1.074; 95% CI, 0.81-1.42; P = .622). Hospital length of stay was shorter after stenting (stent vs repair coefficient, -4.09; P < .001).

CONCLUSIONS

In patients with esophageal perforation, the odds for death or discharge to hospice were similar for esophageal stenting compared with surgical repair.

Spontaneous Chest Wall Herniation in Centrally Obese Patients: A Single-Center Experience of a Rare Problem

BACKGROUND

Spontaneous rib fractures, especially in association with chest wall herniation, represent an uncommon pathology. As such, there are little data analyzing approaches to treatment or regarding the success of intervention. The goal of this study was to analyze our cumulative experience with this unusual condition.

METHODS

A case series of 12 patients was gathered from a single institution based on outpatient visits between February 2015 and October 2018. Each chart was retrospectively reviewed with particular attention to age, gender, BMI, area of injury, and smoking history. Patients presented with complaints of dyspnea or pain related to rib fractures with or without intercostal neuralgia. Each of these patients was noted to have rib fractures with lung herniation either on imaging, outside hospital records, or physical exam. A thorough medical history was obtained with attempts to find common predisposing factors as well as data regarding any previous surgical intervention for their herniation.

RESULTS

Nine of the 12 patients reviewed had recent or prior surgical intervention. Every patient seen in the clinic with a spontaneous fracture and herniation incidentally had a BMI >30 and was therefore classified as obese. Additionally, every patient who had a recurrence after their first surgical attempt at repair had a BMI greater than or equal to 35. All 12 patients seen at our institution were males. The failure rate of operative intervention was 66%.

CONCLUSIONS

Obesity was a prevalent comorbidity in the patient population we reviewed. Given the role obesity plays in abdominal and hiatal hernia repair success rates, it should be considered that obesity is a significant contributor to chest wall herniation if rib fractures occur. With 66% chest wall repair failure, patient selection is critical in the success of surgical intervention. Perhaps additional patient optimization, especially weight loss, should be considered prior to surgery.