Interventions to Improve Outcomes for High-Need, High-Cost Patients: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

BACKGROUND

Chronic disease patients who are the greatest users of healthcare services are often referred to as high-need, high-cost (HNHC). Payers, providers, and policymakers in the United States are interested in identifying interventions that can modify or reduce preventable healthcare use among these patients, without adversely impacting their quality of care and health. We systematically reviewed the evidence on the effectiveness of complex interventions designed to change the healthcare of HNHC patients, modifying cost and utilization, as well as clinical/functional, and social risk factor outcomes.

METHODS

We searched 8 electronic databases (January 2000 to March 2021) and selected non-profit organization and government agency websites for randomized controlled trials and observational studies with comparison groups that targeted HNHC patients. Two investigators independently screened each study and abstracted data into structured forms. Study quality was assessed using standard risk of bias tools. Random-effects meta-analysis was conducted for outcomes reported by at least 3 comparable samples.

RESULTS

Forty studies met our inclusion criteria. Interventions were heterogenous and classified into 7 categories, reflecting the predominant service location/modality (home, primary care, ambulatory intensive caring unit [aICU], emergency department [ED], community, telephonic/mail, and system-level). Home-, primary care-, and ED-based interventions resulted in reductions in high-cost healthcare services (ED and hospital use). ED-based interventions also resulted in greater use of primary care. Primary care- and ED-based interventions reduced costs. System-level transformation interventions did not reduce costs.

DISCUSSION

We found limited evidence of intervention effectiveness in relation to cost and use, and additional evidence is needed to strengthen our confidence in the findings. Few studies reported patient clinical/functional or social risk factor outcomes (e.g., homelessness) or sufficient details for determining why individual interventions work, for whom, and when. Future evaluations could provide additional insights, by including intermediate process outcomes and patients' experiences, in assessing the impact of these complex interventions.

PROSPERO REGISTRATION NUMBER

CRD42020161179.

Characteristics of High-Need, High-Cost Patients : A "Best-Fit" Framework Synthesis

BACKGROUND

Accurately identifying high-need, high-cost (HNHC) patients to reduce their preventable or modifiable health care use for their chronic conditions is a priority and a challenge for U.S. policymakers, health care delivery systems, and payers.

PURPOSE

To identify characteristics and criteria to distinguish HNHC patients.

DATA SOURCES

Searches of multiple databases and gray literature from 1 January 2000 to 22 January 2022.

STUDY SELECTION

English-language studies of characteristics and criteria to identify HNHC adult patients, defined as those with high use (emergency department, inpatient, or total services) or high cost.

DATA EXTRACTION

Independent, dual-review extraction and quality assessment.

DATA SYNTHESIS

The review included 64 studies comprising multivariate exposure studies (n = 47), cluster analyses (n = 11), and qualitative studies (n = 6). A National Academy of Medicine (NAM) taxonomy was an initial "best-fit" framework for organizing the synthesis of the findings. Patient characteristics associated with being HNHC included number and severity of comorbid conditions and having chronic clinical conditions, particularly heart disease, chronic kidney disease, chronic lung disease, diabetes, cancer, and hypertension. Patients' risk for being HNHC was often amplified by behavioral health conditions and social risk factors. The reviewers revised the NAM taxonomy to create a final framework, adding chronic pain and prior patterns of high health care use as characteristics associated with an increased risk for being HNHC.

LIMITATION

Little evidence distinguished potentially preventable or modifiable health care use from overall use.

CONCLUSION

A combination of characteristics can be useful for identifying HNHC patients. Because of the complexity of their conditions and circumstances, improving their quality of care will likely also require an individualized assessment of care needs and availability of support services.

PRIMARY FUNDING SOURCE

Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. (PROSPERO: CRD42020161179).

Development, Testing, and Dissemination of a Public-Facing Tool to Help Consumers Find Higher-Quality Addiction Treatment

OBJECTIVE

The authors aimed to describe the development and testing of quality measures included in a public-facing addiction treatment facility search engine.

METHODS

An addiction treatment facility survey was created that queried providers in six U.S. states about whether they offered the services and used the processes identified by federal agencies and nonprofit organizations as signs of higher-quality addiction treatment. Four insurance claims-based quality measures were created to capture the percentage of a provider's patients with opioid use disorder receiving opioid use disorder medications, who filled prescriptions for such medication for at least 180 days, who received follow-up care after treatment for substance use disorder in inpatient or residential settings, or who had a substance use disorder-related hospitalization or emergency department visit. A patient experience-of-care survey captured patients' perceptions of the quality of the addiction treatment. The project was undertaken from November 2018 through July 2020.

RESULTS

The authors tested the measures by using 1,245 facility surveys, 7,970 patients' experience-of-care surveys, and four claims-based measures submitted by 129, 136, 283, and 408 addiction treatment providers. Statistical testing demonstrated that the quality measures were reliable and valid. The quality measure scores varied among providers, capturing a wide performance range. A public website containing quality measures launched in July 2020 in the six states and has been accessed by thousands of consumers.

CONCLUSIONS

This study developed valid, reliable, and useful addiction treatment quality measures. Dissemination of these measures may help consumers select among providers and help providers, policy makers, and payers improve quality.

The POLARBEAR Fourier transform spectrometer calibrator and spectroscopic characterization of the POLARBEAR instrument

We describe the Fourier Transform Spectrometer (FTS) used for in-field testing of the POLARBEAR receiver, an experiment located in the Atacama Desert of Chile which measures the cosmic microwave background (CMB) polarization. The POLARBEAR-FTS (PB-FTS) is a Martin-Puplett interferometer designed to couple to the Huan Tran Telescope (HTT) on which the POLARBEAR receiver is installed. The PB-FTS measured the spectral response of the POLARBEAR receiver with signal-to-noise ratio >20 for ∼69% of the focal plane detectors due to three features: a high throughput of 15.1 sr cm², optimized optical coupling to the POLARBEAR optics using a custom designed output parabolic mirror, and a continuously modulated output polarizer. The PB-FTS parabolic mirror is designed to mimic the shape of the 2.5 m-diameter HTT primary reflector, which allows for optimum optical coupling to the POLARBEAR receiver, reducing aberrations and systematics. One polarizing grid is placed at the output of the PB-FTS and modulated via continuous rotation. This modulation allows for decomposition of the signal into different harmonics that can be used to probe potentially pernicious sources of systematic error in a polarization-sensitive instrument. The high throughput and continuous output polarizer modulation features are unique compared to other FTS calibrators used in the CMB field. In-field characterization of the POLARBEAR receiver was accomplished using the PB-FTS in April 2014. We discuss the design, construction, and operation of the PB-FTS and present the spectral characterization of the POLARBEAR receiver. We introduce future applications for the PB-FTS in the next-generation CMB experiment, the Simons Array.

Impact of State Psychiatric Hospital Waitlists on Monthly Admissions

OBJECTIVE

This study estimated the effects of a waitlist policy on the monthly number and case mix of admissions to state psychiatric hospitals (SPHs) in North Carolina (NC).

METHODS

Descriptive analyses compared pre/postwaitlist differences in the monthly number and case mix of nonforensic adult admissions (N=72,035) to NC's four SPHs by using data from the three years before and the three years after the waitlist announcement. Hospital-level fixed-effects regression models further evaluated the waitlist policy's impact on the number and case mix of admissions.

RESULTS

Regression results confirmed that the waitlist policy was associated with both fewer admissions and changes to the case mix of admissions, including a 4.2% decrease in the percentage of monthly admissions by patients with diagnoses of substance abuse disorders (p=.002) across all months postwaitlist (partially offset by an increase of patients with diagnoses of severe mental illness alone).

CONCLUSIONS

Waitlists led to reduced monthly admissions and altered case mix following implementation at NC SPHs.

Use of quality measures for Medicaid behavioral health services by state agencies: implications for health care reform

OBJECTIVE

The structure-process-outcome quality framework espoused by Donabedian provides a conceptual way to examine and prioritize behavioral health quality measures used by states. This report presents an environmental scan of the quality measures and satisfaction surveys that state Medicaid managed care and behavioral health agencies used prior to Medicaid expansion in 2014.

METHODS

Data were collected by reviewing online documents related to Medicaid managed care contracts for behavioral health, quality strategies, quality improvement plans, quality and performance indicators data, annual outcomes reports, performance measure specification manuals, legislative reports, and Medicaid waiver requests for proposals.

RESULTS

Information was publicly available for 29 states. Most states relied on process measures, along with some structure and outcome measures. Although all states reported on at least one process measure of behavioral health quality, 52% of states did not use any outcomes measures and 48% of states had no structure measures. A majority of the states (69%) used behavioral health measures from the National Committee for Quality Assurance's Healthcare Effectiveness Data and Information Set, and all but one state in the sample (97%) used consumer experience-of-care surveys. Many states supplemented these data with locally developed behavioral health indicators that rely on administrative and nonadministrative data.

CONCLUSIONS

State Medicaid agencies are using nationally recognized as well as local measures to assess quality of behavioral health care. Findings indicate a need for additional nationally endorsed measures in the area of substance use disorders and treatment outcomes.

TU-E-217BCD-03: Characterization of Anatomical Noise in Mammography, Tomosynthesis and Breast CT

PURPOSE

The role of breast density in cancer detection has been well characterized, and newer modalities such as breast tomosynthesis and breast CT (bCT) were developed to improve cancer detection in the dense breast by reducing anatomical complexity. Anatomical noise was characterized on a small cohort of patient images and compared across digital mammography, tomosynthesis, and bCT images.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

An IRB-approved and HIPPA-compliant clinical study was performed on women undergoing breast biopsy, and mammography, tomosynthesis, and bCT were performed on both breasts immediately prior to biopsy. A total of 23 women participated in this study, and the unaffected breast (no lesion) was evaluated. A total of 1000 regions of interest were sampled on each image data set, and the 2D noise power spectrum (NPS) was evaluated. This was radially averaged to produce a 1D NPS, and the NPS was fit to a power law: ln{NPS(f)} = alpha+betaxln(f), over an anatomically-relevant range of spatial frequencies. The slope, beta, was averaged across patients and compared between modalities and projections.

RESULTS

The value of beta was determined for bCT data sets, and they were 1.75 (0.424), 1.83 (0.352), and 1.79 (0.397), for the coronal, sagittal and axial views, respectively. For tomosynthesis, beta was 3.06 (0.361) and 3.10 (0.315) for the CC and MLO views, respectively. For mammography, these values were 3.17 (0.226) and 3.30 (0.236), for the CC and MLO views, respectively. The values of beta for breast CT were significantly different than those for tomosynthesis and mammography (p<0.001, all 12 comparisons).

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this investigation demonstrate that the anatomical complexity of the breast, as characterized by the parameter beta, is statistically similar between mammography and tomosynthesis, a somewhat surprising finding. The breast CT image data, however, demonstrate a statistically-significant reduction in beta across all projections. Funded in part by Hologic Corporation and by a grant from the National Institute of Biomedical Imaging and Bioengineering, EB002138.

Evidence for quark-hadron duality in the proton spin asymmetry A1

Spin-dependent lepton-nucleon scattering data have been used to investigate the validity of the concept of quark-hadron duality for the spin asymmetry A1. Longitudinally polarized positrons were scattered off a longitudinally polarized hydrogen target for values of Q2 between 1.2 and 12 GeV2 and values of W2 between 1 and 4 GeV2. The average double-spin asymmetry in the nucleon resonance region is found to agree with that measured in deep-inelastic scattering at the same values of the Bjorken scaling variable x. This finding implies that the description of A1 in terms of quark degrees of freedom is valid also in the nucleon resonance region for values of Q2 above 1.6 GeV2.

Q2 dependence of nuclear transparency for exclusive rho0 production

Exclusive coherent and incoherent electroproduction of the rho(0) meson from 1H and 14N targets has been studied at the HERMES experiment as a function of coherence length (l(c)), corresponding to the lifetime of hadronic fluctuations of the virtual photon, and squared four-momentum of the virtual photon (-Q2). The ratio of 14N to 1H cross sections per nucleon, called nuclear transparency, was found to increase (decrease) with increasing l(c) for coherent (incoherent) rho(0) electroproduction. For fixed l(c), a rise of nuclear transparency with Q2 is observed for both coherent and incoherent rho(0) production, which is in agreement with theoretical calculations of color transparency.

Evidence for a single-spin azimuthal asymmetry in semi-inclusive pion electroproduction

Single-spin asymmetries for semi-inclusive pion production in deep-inelastic scattering have been measured for the first time. A significant target-spin asymmetry of the distribution in the azimuthal angle straight phi of the pion relative to the lepton scattering plane was formed for pi(+) electroproduction on a longitudinally polarized hydrogen target. The corresponding analyzing power in the sinstraight phi moment of the cross section is 0.022+/-0.005+/-0.003. This result can be interpreted as the effect of terms in the cross section involving chiral-odd spin distribution functions in combination with a chiral-odd fragmentation function that is sensitive to the transverse polarization of the fragmenting quark.

Risk factors for bone mineral density loss in pediatric renal transplant patients

Bone mineral density (BMD) is decreased in both adult and pediatric renal transplant recipients. To investigate the risk factors associated with this decrease in BMD post-renal transplant, we studied 33 children, aged 7-22 yr, who had received a renal transplant from 0.3 to 10 yr prior to this study. BMD analysis of the total body, spine, and femur was carried out by using dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DEXA). Age, weight, Tanner stage, time on dialysis prior to transplantation, cumulative corticosteroid dosage, and cyclosporin A (CsA) dosage since transplantation, and use of corticosteroid therapy prior to transplantation, were recorded. Spine, femur, and total body BMD Z-scores were greater than two standard deviations (2 SD) below the mean in 45%, 42%, and 17% of patients, respectively. Age correlated inversely with total body and spine BMD Z-scores (p = 0.001 and p = 0.008); no child under 14 yr of age had a total body or spine BMD Z-score greater than 2 SD below the mean for age. Patients at a Tanner stage of 4 or 5 had lower total body and spine BMD Z-scores than did patients at Tanner stages 1-3 (p = 0.043). Time post-transplant correlated inversely with both spine and total body BMD Z-score (p = 0.013 and p = 0.023). Only total body BMD Z-score correlated inversely with cumulative corticosteroid dose (in g, p = 0.045). BMD did not correlate with cumulative CsA dose. Black patients tended to have decreased total body BMD compared with Caucasian patients. In pediatric renal transplant patients, decreases in BMD start in adolescence. Risk factors for BMD loss in these patients include increasing age, time post-transplant, increasing Tanner stage, and ethnicity. Longitudinal studies in these patients and strategies to improve BMD are needed.

Patient surveys and quality improvement

Patient satisfaction may be the ultimate measure of quality but it is only part of the quality measurement and improvement equation. Customers may be good at telling you what needs fixing but they cannot be expected to tell you how to fix the problem. It is important to let patient satisfaction measures guide the focus of your process improvement efforts, but these efforts must include the appropriate process measurement tools. A customer-focused survey will be valid only if it emphasizes key quality characteristics (KQCs), as defined by patients. You'll need to develop a sampling plan that will produce useable data. The design of the questionnaire and the reliability of the survey tool are critical to using patient surveys for quality improvement (QI). Surveys that don't meet standard criteria have a greater potential for error. Another challenge is the report format and analysis that are used to understand the patient responses. Having an external benchmark is critical to accurate measurement in patient surveys. Comparative data can also help prioritize QI projects. In summary, a well designed patient survey system can identify key quality characteristics, determine which KQCs have the most impact, help prioritize QI efforts, and measure patients' satisfaction in a reliable manner.

The utilization of rubber dam as a barrier membrane for the simultaneous treatment of multiple periodontal defects by the biologic principle of guided tissue regeneration: case reports

The principle of guided tissue regeneration has demonstrated a level of success in regenerating the periodontal attachment apparatus lost to periodontal disease. Several types of membrane barriers, each one with distinct properties, have been utilized to apply this principle in periodontal wound healing. A series of case reports introduces and discusses the attributes of rubber dam as a barrier membrane for the treatment of multiple periodontal osseous defects. Comparison of preoperative and postoperative clinical measurements as well as reentry procedures are utilized to highlight successful osseous regeneration.

Various methods of breast reconstruction after mastectomy: an economic comparison

This study is an economic comparison of various methods of breast reconstruction after mastectomy. The hospital bills of 287 patients undergoing breast reconstruction at three institutions from June of 1988 to March of 1991 were analyzed. The procedures examined included mastectomy, implant and tissue-expander reconstruction, and TRAM and latissimus pedicle flaps, as well as free TRAM and free gluteal flaps. These procedures were subdivided into those which were performed at the time of mastectomy and those performed at a later admission. In addition, auxiliary procedures (i.e., revision, nipple reconstruction, tissue-expander exchange, and contralateral mastopexy/reduction) also were examined. Where appropriate, these procedures were subdivided into those performed under general or local anesthesia and by inpatient or outpatient status. Data from the three institutions were converted to N.Y.U. Medical Center costs for standardization. A table is presented that summarizes the costs of each individual procedure with all the pertinent variations. In addition, a unique and novel method of analyzing the data was developed. This paper describes a menu system whereby other data regarding morbidity, mortality, and revision rates may be superimposed. With this information, the final cost of reconstruction can be extrapolated and the various methods of reconstruction can be compared. This method can be applied to almost any complex series of multiple procedures. The most salient points elucidated by this study are as follows: The savings generated by performing immediate reconstruction varies between $5092 (p < 0.05) for free gluteal flaps and $10,616 (p < 0.05) for pedicled TRAM flaps.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Efficiency of the bone scan for occult limping toddlers

Fifty consecutive occult limping toddlers were prospectively evaluated by acute triphase 99mTc MDP scintigraphy (TTS) at Arkansas Children's Hospital from 1984 through 1989. Only patients with a limp that could not be diagnosed by an orthopaedist were included. TTS proved essential in localizing the lesion in 27 patients (54%). With only two false negatives and one false positive, this test was shown to be highly sensitive, specific, efficient, and predictive, especially as compared with temperature, white blood cell (WBC) count, erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR), and plain radiography. Because no infections were missed by TTS, patients with a normal TTS could be safely observed as outpatients, saving thousands of health care dollars in this small series.

Localized ridge augmentation in dogs: a pilot study using membranes and hydroxyapatite

This study was designed to evaluate the potential to reconstruct localized ridge defects with bone by preventing non-osteogenic extraskelatal connective tissue from participating in the process of healing following experimental ridge augmentation treatment procedures. Following the elevation of buccal muco-periosteal flaps, buccal, interproximal, and interradicular bone was removed to the apical level of the second and third premolar teeth and the teeth were extracted to create bucco-lingual ridge defects that averaged 13 mm x 7 mm x 3.5 mm in each quadrant of two adult beagle dogs. The defects were permitted to heal for 90 days. The defects did not fill in with new bone. Subsequently, buccal muco-periosteal flaps were elevated and a membrane was placed over the defect and positioned so that it rested on bone that was exposed adjacent to the defect. In two quadrants test support materials were used to ensure that a space was maintained between the surface of the defect and the membrane. One quadrant was maintained as a sham-operated control site, three sites received membranes and no supporting implants and two sites received supporting implants and no membranes. The surgical schedule was designed to yield sacrifice times of 8 to 12 weeks. In the three quadrants available for study that were covered with membranes, bone and/or non-mineralized connective tissue was found to fill all of the space that had been provided by the membrane. Histologic examination confirmed that the space was filled with young, actively growing bone by 90 days. No new bone formation (bone fill) was observed in the sham-operated control site.

Clinical experience with the technetium-99 scan in children

A study of 86 bone scans in 79 patients was conducted to determine ways to enhance the usefulness of this test and learn what factors influence its results. While the overall value of the bone scan as we initially used it was not what we had hoped, it could be improved substantially by utilizing all initial clinical information when ordering as well as interpreting the scan. Its main value in suspected sepsis is to localize affected areas in and around the pelvis and spine. The scan is often unnecessary in the diagnosis of long-bone osteomyelitis and is seldom indicated when diagnosing cellulitis or synovitis. In occult trauma it is valuable for further investigation of specific areas with possible nondisplaced fractures. Needle aspiration of the bone or joint does not seem to alter the scan. We conclude that the bone scan is chiefly valuable in locating focal areas of skeletal pathophysiology.