Referrals to palliative care for cardiovascular patients: a 10-year longitudinal retrospective study

Background

Patients with cardiovascular diseases have a significant symptom burden and often have a progressive course towards end-stage disease and ultimately, death. For this reason, consensus guidelines advocate early integration of palliative care into the care for cardiovascular patients, especially those with heart failure. However, palliative care involvement in the care of cardiovascular patients remains suboptimal, whereby only a small proportion of patients are referred to palliative care specialists, and often too late in the disease course. We aimed to examine the current situation and describe the profile, circumstances of death, and time of referral to palliative care of cardiovascular patients over a 10 year period in our unit.

Methods

This retrospective study included all patients with cardiovascular disease who were referred to the mobile palliative care team by the cardiology unit, in a single, large University Hospital in France between 2010 and 2020. All data were extracted from the medical hospital files. We recorded vital status, day of birth, time of referral to palliative care, day of death, and medical diagnoses. We noted whether patients had advance directives (AD).

Results

A total of 148 patients were identified; full data were available for 144 (97.3%). Of these, 136 (94.4%) died, while 8 (5.6%) were still alive in March 2022. The mean age at the time of death was 75±14 years. The median time between referral to palliative care and death was 9 days (interquartiles, 2, 41.5). We noted the following underlying diseases (patients could have more than one diagnosis): 111 (77%) had heart failure, 58 (40.2%) had ischemic heart disease, 55 (38.2%) had valvular heart disease, 39 (27%) had diabetes, 37 (25.7%) had chronic kidney disease, 30 (20.8%) had pulmonary hypertension, 17 (11.8%) had chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. In addition, 78 (54%) had at least one documented episode of atrial fibrillation, 27 (18.7%) had had a stroke. Place of death was available for 119 patients (82.6%) (Figure): The majority (73, 61.4%) died in the Cardiology department of our hospital; only 17 (14.3%) died at home (see Figure 1). Only 4 patients (2.7%) had documented AD.

Conclusion

This study suggests that palliative care is still widely under-used in cardiology patients, and is often initiated very close to the time of death, and mainly for heart failure patients. A large proportion of patients still die in the hospital setting. Further, prospective studies are warranted to investigate whether these dispositions corresponds to patients' wishes, and whether earlier initiation of palliative care could improve quality of life for cardiology patients with end-stage disease.

Funding Acknowledgement

Type of funding sources: None.

End-of-life and palliative care provision to adults with congenital heart disease: mortality follow-back study using administrative data

Background

Although many adults with congenital heart disease (CHD) still die prematurely, end-of-life care for these patients receives limited attention. There are indications that current care provision at the end of life is burdensome, expensive, and not in line with patients' needs and preferences. We sought to analyse end-of-life care in adult CHD patients to determine whether health services need to be optimized.

Purpose

This study aimed to describe patterns of healthcare consumption of adults with CHD who died in the last year of life.

Methods

This retrospective mortality follow-back study used data of the BELgian COngenital heart disease Database combining Administrative and Clinical data (BELCODAC), including individually linked healthcare claims, death certificates and clinical data from adults with CHD in Flanders (Belgium). For this study, adults with CHD who died between 2007 and 2016 from any cause except sudden death, accident or violence, were selected for inclusion. Accidental, violent, and sudden deaths were identified based on causes of death and healthcare use in the last 3 months of life. Healthcare consumption was based on nomenclature codes derived from healthcare claims data.

Results

A total of 327 eligible patients (median age: 58 y; 54% women; 43% mild CHD; 45% moderate CHD; 11% complex CHD; 49% cardiovascular cause of death) were identified. During the last year of life, healthcare use increased substantially (Fig. 1). During the last month of life, 54% of patients were hospitalised, 55% visited the emergency department, and 15% were admitted to an intensive care unit at least once (Fig. 2). A total of 8% and 5% of patients underwent heart surgery or catherization in the last month of life, respectively. Furthermore, 70% of patients had at least one encounter with a general practitioner and 11% with a CHD specialist in the last month of life. Specialist palliative care was provided to 13% of patients in the last month of life.

When looking at the subgroup of patients with CHD that died due to a cardiovascular cause, proportions of patients that were hospitalised or had visits at the emergency department or intensive care unit in the last month of life were similar (Fig. 2). However, these patients underwent more heart surgeries (11%) and catherizations (8%), had more encounters with CHD specialists (15%), and received remarkably less specialized palliative care (4%) in the last month of life.

Conclusion

Resource utilization increased substantially during the last year of life, resulting in high acute healthcare consumption in the last month of life. It is remarkable that only a minority of patients received palliative care, especially when looking at patients who died due to a cardiovascular cause. Our findings motivate the need to assess if and how end-of-life is planned for adults with CHD. Future studies using qualitative analyses and survey methodology are needed to optimize the management of end-of-life care.

Funding Acknowledgement

Type of funding sources: Public grant(s) – EU funding. Main funding source(s): Research Foundation Flanders, European Society of Cardiology, Koning Boudewijnstichting, National Foundation on Research in Pediatric Cardiology, Swedish Research Council for Health, Working Life and Welfare-FORTE

Healthcare use at the end of life of patients with congenital heart disease: does heart failure matter?

Funding Acknowledgements

Type of funding sources: Foundation. Main funding source(s): Research Foundation Flanders (to PM, EG, and LVB)

European Society of Cardiology (Nursing Training Grant to LVB)

Background

Heart failure (HF) is a common cause of morbidity and mortality in patients with congenital heart disease (CHD). Although limited in scope, previous studies suggest that patients with heart failure follow a specific end-of-life trajectory with episodes of serious complications, which may impact the patterns of care as death approaches.

Aims

The study aims to identify differences in characteristics and patterns of care in the last year of life in deceased CHD patients with and without HF.

Methods

This retrospective study used data of deceased adult patients included in the BELgian COngenital heart disease Database combining Administrative and Clinical data (BELCODAC). To describe patterns of care in the last year of life, we captured information about hospitalisations, emergency department visits, and visits to the general practitioner using nomenclature codes. Heart failure was identified as having HF as cause of death and/or at least one prescription of a loop diuretic in the last year of life. Sensitivity analyses with a stricter definition for HF (HF as cause of death or ≥ 1 prescription of a loop diuretic combined with a prescription of digoxin, dopamine, dobutamine, other non-glycoside stimulants, metoprolol, bisoprolol, carvedilol, aldosterone antagonists, ACE inhibitors or ARBs) were performed as well.

Results

During the period 2007–2016, 390 adults with CHD died, of which 170 patients with HF (44%). Patients with HF were older, died more often due to a cardiovascular cause of death, and had more complex heart lesions, compared to patients without HF (Table 1). While the number of emergency department visits and hospitalisations in the last year was similar, patients with HF had almost twice as much monthly visits at the general practitioner in their last year of life (Table 1). As shown in Figure 1, the mean number of hospitalisations and emergency department visits increased in a similar fashion throughout the last year of life, but the pattern of general practitioner visits was substantially different for patients with and without HF. The sensitivity analyses, in which a stricter definition for HF was used, yield very similar results. In these analyses, the difference in mean monthly hospitalisations was also significant between the two groups.

Conclusions

This study shows clinically important differences in characteristics and patterns of care of deceased patients with CHD with and without heart failure. Patients with HFhave different needs and should receive a tailored approach at the end of life. Future research is needed to understand these differences and investigate these patients' end-of-life care needs in more detail.

Funding acknowledgments: This work was supported by Research Foundation Flanders; European Society of Cardiology; the King Baudouin Foundation; the National Foundation on Research in Pediatric Cardiology; and the Swedish Research Council for Health, Working Life and Welfare-FORTE.

Provision of palliative care to adults with congenital heart disease at the end of life

Funding Acknowledgements

Type of funding sources: Public grant(s) – National budget only. Main funding source(s): This work was supported by Research Foundation Flanders [grant numbers G097516N to PM, 12E9816N to EG and 1154719N to LVB]; the King Baudouin Foundation (Fund Joseph Oscar Waldmann-Berteau & Fund Walckiers Van Dessel); the National Foundation on Research in Pediatric Cardiology; and the Swedish Research Council for Health, Working Life and Welfare -FORTE (grant number STYA-2018/0004).

OnBehalf

BELCODAC consortium

Background

Although recent position papers have discussed and advocated for the integration of palliative care in the treatment course of adults with congenital heart defects (CHD), empirical studies reporting to what extent palliative care is currently provided, are still lacking.

Purpose

(1) To explore the current provision of palliative care to adults with CHD in the last 6 months of their life; and (2) to describe the profile of patients who received palliative care.

Methods

In this retrospective study, data of deceased adult patients included in the BELgian COngenital heart disease Database combining Administrative and Clinical data (BELCODAC) were analysed. Palliative care provision (i.e., admission to palliative care ward, or palliative care at home) was identified using nomenclature codes. The level of anatomical complexity was based on the Bethesda classification. Descriptive analyses were performed.

Results

During the period 2006-2016, 480 adults with CHD died (mean age: 54.4y; 45% simple CHD, 43% moderate CHD, 12% complex CHD). We identified that 75 patients (16%) had at least one nomenclature code linked to palliative care in the last 6 months of their life. More specifically, 16 patients were admitted to an inpatient palliative care service and 67 patients received palliative care at home. Of the patients who received palliative care at home, 40 patients were cared for by a multidisciplinary team specialized in palliative care provision and 59 patients received care from nurses and/or general practitioners while being recognized as a palliative patient. A total of 8 patients received palliative care both at the inpatient palliative care service and at home.

Of the 75 patients receiving palliative care, 44 (59%) had a neoplasm as the primary cause of death and a cardiac cause of death was reported for 10 patients (13%) (see Figure 1). The mean age of patients receiving palliative care was 57.9 years. Most patients receiving palliative care had a simple CHD (n = 40; 53%), 29 patients (39%) had a moderate lesion, and 6 patients (8%) had a complex lesion. That means that, respectively, 19%, 14%, and 11% of all deceased patients with a simple, moderate, and complex heart lesion received palliative care.

Conclusions

This is the first exploratory study on palliative care in adults with CHD. About one in six patients who died received palliative care. Of those who received palliative care, the cause of death was in most cases of a non-cardiac nature. Further research is needed to investigate the care trajectories and care needs of adults with CHD in the last months of life.

Figure 1. Causes of death of adults with CHD who received palliative care in the last 6 months of life (n = 75).