Studying Macromolecular Interactions of Cellular Machines by the Combined Use of Analytical Ultracentrifugation, Light Scattering, and Fluorescence Spectroscopy Methods

Cellular machines formed by the interaction and assembly of macromolecules are essential in many processes of the living cell. These assemblies involve homo- and hetero-associations, including protein-protein, protein-DNA, protein-RNA, and protein-polysaccharide associations, most of which are reversible. This chapter describes the use of analytical ultracentrifugation, light scattering, and fluorescence-based methods, well-established biophysical techniques, to characterize interactions leading to the formation of macromolecular complexes and their modulation in response to specific or unspecific factors. We also illustrate, with several examples taken from studies on bacterial processes, the advantages of the combined use of subsets of these techniques as orthogonal analytical methods to analyze protein oligomerization and polymerization, interactions with ligands, hetero-associations involving membrane proteins, and protein-nucleic acid complexes.

Benzodioxane-benzamides as promising inhibitors of Escherichia coli FtsZ

The conserved process of cell division in bacteria has been a long-standing target for antimicrobials, although there are few examples of potent broad-spectrum compounds that inhibit this process. Most currently available compounds acting on division are directed towards the FtsZ protein, a self-assembling GTPase that is a central element of the division machinery in most bacteria. Benzodioxane-benzamides are promising candidates, but poorly explored in Gram-negatives. We have tested a number of these compounds on E. coli FtsZ and found that many of them significantly stabilized the polymers against disassembly and reduced the GTPase activity. Reconstitution in crowded cell-like conditions showed that FtsZ bundles were also susceptible to these compounds, including some compounds that were inactive on protofilaments in dilute conditions. They efficiently killed E. coli cells defective in the AcrAB efflux pump. The activity of the compounds on cell growth and division generally showed a good correlation with their effect in vitro, and our experiments are consistent with FtsZ being the target in vivo. Our results uncover the detrimental effects of benzodioxane-benzamides on permeable E. coli cells via its central division protein, implying that lead compounds may be found within this class for the development of antibiotics against Gram-negative bacteria.

Bacterial division ring stabilizing ZapA versus destabilizing SlmA modulate FtsZ switching between biomolecular condensates and polymers

Cytokinesis is a fundamental process for bacterial survival and proliferation, involving the formation of a ring by filaments of the GTPase FtsZ, spatio-temporally regulated through the coordinated action of several factors. The mechanisms of this regulation remain largely unsolved, but the inhibition of FtsZ polymerization by the nucleoid occlusion factor SlmA and filament stabilization by the widely conserved cross-linking protein ZapA are known to play key roles. It was recently described that FtsZ, SlmA and its target DNA sequences (SlmA-binding sequence (SBS)) form phase-separated biomolecular condensates, a type of structure associated with cellular compartmentalization and resistance to stress. Using biochemical reconstitution and orthogonal biophysical approaches, we show that FtsZ-SlmA-SBS condensates captured ZapA in crowding conditions and when encapsulated inside cell-like microfluidics microdroplets. We found that, through non-competitive binding, the nucleotide-dependent FtsZ condensate/polymer interconversion was regulated by the ZapA/SlmA ratio. This suggests a highly concentration-responsive tuning of the interconversion that favours FtsZ polymer stabilization by ZapA under conditions mimicking intracellular crowding. These results highlight the importance of biomolecular condensates as concentration hubs for bacterial division factors, which can provide clues to their role in cell function and bacterial survival of stress conditions, such as those generated by antibiotic treatment.

Lipid Surfaces and Glutamate Anions Enhance Formation of Dynamic Biomolecular Condensates Containing Bacterial Cell Division Protein FtsZ and Its DNA-Bound Regulator SlmA

Dynamic biomolecular condensates formed by liquid-liquid phase separation can regulate the spatial and temporal organization of proteins, thus modulating their functional activity in cells. Previous studies showed that the cell division protein FtsZ from Escherichia coli formed dynamic phase-separated condensates with nucleoprotein complexes containing the FtsZ spatial regulator SlmA under crowding conditions, with potential implications for condensate-mediated spatiotemporal control of FtsZ activity in cell division. In the present study, we assessed formation of these condensates in the presence of lipid surfaces and glutamate ions to better approximate the E. coli intracellular environment. We found that potassium glutamate substantially promoted the formation of FtsZ-containing condensates when compared to potassium chloride in crowded solutions. These condensates accumulated on supported lipid bilayers and eventually fused, resulting in a time-dependent increase in the droplet size. Moreover, the accumulated condensates were dynamic, capturing protein from the external phase. FtsZ partitioned into the condensates at the lipid surface only in its guanosine diphosphate (GDP) form, regardless of whether it came from FtsZ polymer disassembly upon guanosine triphosphate (GTP) exhaustion. These results provide insights into the behavior of these GTP-responsive condensates in minimal membrane systems, which suggest how these membraneless assemblies may tune critical bacterial division events during the cell cycle.

Reversible Membrane Tethering by ZipA Determines FtsZ Polymerization in Two and Three Dimensions

In most bacteria, the early step of septum formation implies the association of soluble FtsZ polymers with the cytoplasmic membrane. ZipA, together with FtsA, provides membrane tethering to FtsZ in Escherichia coli, forming a dynamic proto-ring that serves as an assembly scaffold for the remaining elements of the divisome. Despite their importance for bacterial cell division, multivalent interactions between proto-ring elements at membrane surfaces remain poorly characterized in quantitative terms. We measured the binding of FtsZ to ZipA incorporated in supported lipid bilayers at controlled densities by using a combination of biophysical surface-sensitive techniques (quartz crystal microbalance and spectroscopic ellipsometry) and analyzed how ZipA density and FtsZ concentration control the state of assembly of FtsZ. We found that ZipA attachment enables FtsZ-GMPCPP (where GMPCPP is a GTP analogue with a reduced level of hydrolysis) to assemble in several distinct ways: (i) two-dimensional polymerization at the membrane and (ii) three-dimensional polymerization from the membrane into the solution phase where this may be associated with the formation of higher-order complexes. In these processes, ZipA is required to enrich FtsZ at the surface but the FtsZ bulk concentration defines which morphology is being formed. Moreover, we report a strong effect of the nucleotide (GDP vs GMPCPP/GTP) on the kinetics of ZipA association/dissociation of FtsZ. These results provide insights into the mode of interaction of proto-ring elements in minimal membrane systems and contribute to the completion of our understanding of the initial events of bacterial division.

Bacterial FtsZ protein forms phase-separated condensates with its nucleoid-associated inhibitor SlmA

Macromolecular condensation resulting from biologically regulated liquid-liquid phase separation is emerging as a mechanism to organize intracellular space in eukaryotes, with broad implications for cell physiology and pathology. Despite their small size, bacterial cells are also organized by proteins such as FtsZ, a tubulin homolog that assembles into a ring structure precisely at the cell midpoint and is required for cytokinesis. Here, we demonstrate that FtsZ can form crowding-induced condensates, reminiscent of those observed for eukaryotic proteins. Formation of these FtsZ-rich droplets occurs when FtsZ is bound to SlmA, a spatial regulator of FtsZ that antagonizes polymerization, while also binding to specific sites on chromosomal DNA. The resulting condensates are dynamic, allowing FtsZ to undergo GTP-driven assembly to form protein fibers. They are sensitive to compartmentalization and to the presence of a membrane boundary in cell mimetic systems. This is a novel example of a bacterial nucleoprotein complex exhibiting condensation into liquid droplets, suggesting that phase separation may also play a functional role in the spatiotemporal organization of essential bacterial processes.

Nucleotide and receptor density modulate binding of bacterial division FtsZ protein to ZipA containing lipid-coated microbeads

ZipA protein from Escherichia coli is one of the essential components of the division proto-ring that provides membrane tethering to the septation FtsZ protein. A sedimentation assay was used to measure the equilibrium binding of FtsZ-GDP and FtsZ-GTP to ZipA immobilized at controlled densities on the surface of microbeads coated with a phospholipid mixture resembling the composition of E. coli membrane. We found that for both nucleotide-bound species, the amount of bound FtsZ exceeds the monolayer capacity of the ZipA immobilized beads at high concentrations of free FtsZ. In the case of FtsZ-GDP, equilibrium binding does not appear to be saturable, whereas in the case of FtsZ-GTP equilibrium binding appears to be saturable. The difference between the two modes of binding is attributed to the difference between the composition of oligomers of free FtsZ-GDP and free FtsZ-GTP formed in solution.

Encapsulation of a compartmentalized cytoplasm mimic within a lipid membrane by microfluidics

Microdroplets in microfluidics and permeable GUVs encapsulating LLPS-systems provide improved platforms for analysing the impact of compartmentalization on biological processes.

Microenvironments created by liquid-liquid phase transition control the dynamic distribution of bacterial division FtsZ protein

The influence of membrane-free microcompartments resulting from crowding-induced liquid/liquid phase separation (LLPS) on the dynamic spatial organization of FtsZ, the main component of the bacterial division machinery, has been studied using several LLPS systems. The GTP-dependent assembly cycle of FtsZ is thought to be crucial for the formation of the septal ring, which is highly regulated in time and space. We found that FtsZ accumulates in one of the phases and/or at the interface, depending on the system composition and on the oligomerization state of the protein. These results were observed both in bulk LLPS and in lipid-stabilized, phase-separated aqueous microdroplets. The visualization of the droplets revealed that both the location and structural arrangement of FtsZ filaments is determined by the nature of the LLPS. Relocation upon depolymerization of the dynamic filaments suggests the protein may shift among microenvironments in response to changes in its association state. The existence of these dynamic compartments driven by phase transitions can alter the local composition and reactivity of FtsZ during its life cycle acting as a nonspecific modulating factor of cell function.