Skin dose in chest wall radiotherapy with bolus: a Monte Carlo study

Monte Carlo simulations are used to investigate skin dose resulting from chest wall radiotherapy with bolus. A simple model of a female thorax is developed, which includes a 2 mm-thick skin layer. Two representative 6 MV source models are considered: a tangents source model consisting of a parallel opposed pair of medial and lateral fields and subfields, and an arc source model. Tissue equivalent (TE) boluses (thicknesses of 3, 5 and 10 mm) and brass mesh bolus are considered. Skin dose distributions depend on incident photon obliquity: for tangents, radiation is incident more obliquely, resulting in longer path lengths through the bolus and higher skin dose compared to the arc source model in most cases. However, for thicker TE boluses, attenuation of oblique photons becomes apparent. Brass bolus and 3 mm TE bolus result in similar mean skin dose. This relatively simple computational model allows for consideration of different bolus thicknesses, materials and usage schedules based on desired skin dose and choice of either tangents or an arc beam technique. For example, using a 5 mm TE bolus every second treatment would result in mean skin doses of 89% and 85% for tangents and the arc source model, respectively. The hot spot metric D[Formula: see text] would be 103% and 99%, respectively.

In search of a one plan solution for VMAT post-mastectomy chest wall irradiation

PURPOSE

This study was designed to evaluate skin dose in both VMAT and tangent treatment deliveries for the purpose of identifying suitable bolus use protocols that should produce similar superficial doses.

METHODS

Phantom measurements were used to investigate skin dose in chest wall radiotherapy with and without bolus for 3D and rotational treatment techniques. Optically stimulated luminescence dosimeters (OSLDs) with and without housing and EBT3 film were used. Superflab (3, 5, and 10 mm) and brass mesh were considered. Measured doses were compared with predictions by the Eclipse treatment planning system. Patient measurements were also performed and the bolusing effect of hospital gowns and blankets were highlighted. The effect of flash for VMAT plans was considered experimentally by using 2 mm couch shifts.

RESULTS

For tangents, average skin doses without bolus were 0.64 (EBT3), 0.62 (bare OSLD), 0.77 (jacketed OSLD), and 0.68 (Eclipse) as a fraction of prescription. For VMAT, doses without bolus were 0.53 (EBT3), 0.53 (bare OSLD), 0.64 (jacketed OSLD), and 0.60 (Eclipse). For tangents, the average doses with different boluses as measured by EBT3 were 0.99 (brass mesh), 1.02 (3 mm), 1.03 (5 mm), and 1.07 (10 mm). For VMAT with bolus, average doses as measured by EBT3 were 0.83 (brass), 0.96 (3 mm), 1.03 (5 mm), and 1.04 (10 mm). Eclipse doses agreed with measurements to within 5% of measurements for all Superflab thicknesses and within 15% of measurements for no bolus. The presence of a hospital gown and blanket had a bolusing effect that increased the surface dose by approximately 10%.

CONCLUSIONS

Results of this work allow for consideration of different bolus thicknesses, materials, and usage schedules based on desired skin dose and choice of either tangents or an arc beam techniques.

Cavity theory applications for kilovoltage cellular dosimetry

Relationships between macroscopic (bulk tissue) and microscopic (cellular) dose descriptors are investigated using cavity theory and Monte Carlo (MC) simulations. Small, large, and multiple intermediate cavity theory (SCT, LCT, and ICT, respectively) approaches are considered for 20 to 370 keV incident photons; ICT is a sum of SCT and LCT contributions weighted by parameter d. Considering μm-sized cavities of water in bulk tissue phantoms, different cavity theory approaches are evaluated via comparison of [Formula: see text] (where D _w,m is dose-to-water-in-medium and D _m,m is dose-to-medium-in-medium) with MC results. The best overall agreement is achieved with an ICT approach in which [Formula: see text], where L is the mean chord length of the cavity and β is given by [Formula: see text] (R _CSDA is the continuous slowing down approximation range of an electron of energy equal to that of incident photons). Cell nucleus doses, D _nuc, computed with this ICT approach are compared with those from MC simulations involving multicellular soft tissue models considering a representative range of cell/nucleus sizes and elemental compositions. In [Formula: see text] of cases, ICT and MC predictions agree within [Formula: see text]; disagreement is at most 8.8%. These results suggest that cavity theory may be useful for linking doses from model-based dose calculation algorithms (MBDCAs) with energy deposition in cellular targets. Finally, based on the suggestion that clusters of water molecules associated with DNA are important radiobiological targets, two approaches for estimating dose-to-water by application of SCT to MC results for D _m,m or D _nuc are compared. Results for these two estimates differ by up to [Formula: see text], demonstrating the sensitivity of energy deposition within a small volume of water in nucleus to the geometry and composition of its surroundings. In terms of the debate over the dose specification medium for MBDCAs, these results do not support conversion of D _m,m to D _w,m using SCT.

A Monte Carlo study of macroscopic and microscopic dose descriptors for kilovoltage cellular dosimetry

This work investigates how doses to cellular targets depend on cell morphology, as well as relations between cellular doses and doses to bulk tissues and water. Multicellular models of five healthy and cancerous soft tissues are developed based on typical values of cell compartment sizes, elemental compositions and number densities found in the literature. Cells are modelled as two concentric spheres with nucleus and cytoplasm compartments. Monte Carlo simulations are used to calculate the absorbed dose to the nucleus and cytoplasm for incident photon energies of 20-370 keV, relevant for brachytherapy, diagnostic radiology, and out-of-field radiation in higher-energy external beam radiotherapy. Simulations involving cell clusters, single cells and single nuclear cavities are carried out for cell radii between 5 and [Formula: see text]m, and nuclear radii between 2 and [Formula: see text]m. Seven nucleus and cytoplasm elemental compositions representative of animal cells are considered. The presence of a cytoplasm, extracellular matrix and surrounding cells can affect the nuclear dose by up to [Formula: see text]. Differences in cell and nucleus size can affect dose to the nucleus (cytoplasm) of the central cell in a cluster of 13 cells by up to [Formula: see text] ([Formula: see text]). Furthermore, the results of this study demonstrate that neither water nor bulk tissue are reliable substitutes for subcellular targets for incident photon energies  <50 keV: nuclear (cytoplasm) doses differ from dose-to-medium by up to [Formula: see text] ([Formula: see text]), and from dose-to-water by up to [Formula: see text] ([Formula: see text]). The largest differences between dose descriptors are seen for the lowest incident photon energies; differences are less than [Formula: see text] for energies [Formula: see text]90 keV. The sensitivity of results with regard to the parameters of the microscopic tissue structure model and cell model geometry, and the importance of the nucleus and cytoplasm as targets for radiation-induced cell death emphasize the importance of accurate models for cellular dosimetry studies.