Research on the child healthcare system in China from the perspective of equal health benefits: Beijing as the case study

BACKGROUND

With government's proposal of the Healthy China Strategy, universal health has become the focus of increasing attention in China. As a special group, children's health is the basis and start of the national health. The construction of children's healthcare system should be given the priority. This study applied the concept of health equal benefits and conducted a systematic and in-depth theoretical and empirical research on the children's healthcare system in Beijing, aiming at proposing relevant countermeasures and suggestions such as constructing the path of children's health care system in China.

METHODS

This study adopted the way of questionnaire on children's basic information, health status, health service demand, insured situation and system satisfaction and then analysed the children's health, healthcare, satisfaction influence factors and their healthcare needs based on a survey in Beijing China. Methods such as descriptive statistics, analysis of variance and logistic regression are adopted to analyse the correlation between factors affecting children's health.

RESULTS

The findings show that overall health of the children in Beijing was better. However, there are still problems such as insufficient resource coverage and incorrect cognition in some groups. Their mental health and support need to be put emphasis on. The popularization of medical insurance policies for urban and rural residents in Beijing needs to be further improved. The burden of seeing a doctor is slightly lower than before, and the contribution to protecting children's health is not strong enough.

CONCLUSIONS

Through the survey of children in Beijing, it can be seen that there are still some problems existing in the healthcare system of children in China from the perspective of equal benefit. This study draws policy attention to the issues of financing, service contents, targets, service level and the degree of social recognition.

Evaluation of Trends in Knee Arthroscopy from 2004 to 2019 in Ontario, Canada

Trends in Knee Arthroscopy in Ontario, CanadaThis study included 408,040 patients who underwent arthroscopy procedures in Ontario, Canada between 2004 and 2019. The number of procedures declined 8.9% from 24,070 in 2004/2005 to 21,930 in 2018/2019. Among patients with osteoarthritis, rates of progression to knee arthroplasty were 3.8%, 9.6% and 16.0% at 1, 2, and 5 years, respectively, compared with rates among patients with degenerative meniscal disorders, which were 1.6%, 4.1%, and 7.3%, at 1, 2 and 5 years, respectively.

Frailty is an important predictor of 30-day morbidity in patients treated for lumbar spondylolisthesis using a posterior surgical approach

BACKGROUND CONTEXT

Traditionally, a nonoperative approach has been favored for elderly patients with lumbar spondylolisthesis due to a perceived higher risk of morbidity with surgery. However, most studies have used an arbitrary age cut-off to define "elderly" and this research has yielded conflicting results.

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to investigate the impact of frailty on morbidity after surgery for degenerative lumbar spondylolisthesis treated with a posterior approach.

STUDY DESIGN

A retrospective cohort study was performed.

PATIENT SAMPLE

The American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (NSQIP) database, with years 2010 to 2018 included in this study. Patients who received posterior lumbar spine decompression with or without single level posterior instrumented fusion for degenerative lumbar spondylolisthesis were included. Patients who received anterior and/or lateral approaches were excluded.

OUTCOME MEASURES

The primary outcome was Clavien-Dindo grade IV complication. Secondary outcomes were readmission, reoperation, and discharge to location other than home.

METHODS

Patient demographics and comorbidities were extracted. Logistic regression analysis was performed to investigate the association between outcomes and the Modified Frailty Index-5, adjusting for age, gender, body mass index, smoking status, and surgical procedure performed. A sub-analysis was done to assess the effect of frailty in three different age groups (18-45 years, 46-65 years, and >65 years) for the two surgical cohorts.

RESULTS

There were 15,658 patients in this study. The mean age was 62.5 years. Approximately 70% of the patients received decompression with fusion. Frailty was significantly associated with an increased risk of major complication, unplanned readmission, reoperation, and non-home discharge. The risk increased with increasing frailty. For patients who received decompression, frailty was associated with a higher risk of readmission and non-home discharge in patients >65 years. For patients who received decompression and fusion, frailty was associated with a higher risk of complications, readmission, and non-home discharge in patients >65 years.

CONCLUSIONS

Frailty is independently associated with a higher risk of morbidity after posterior surgery in patients with lumbar spondylolisthesis, especially in patients older than 65. These data are of significance to clinicians in planning treatment for these patients.

The CREATE Method for Expressing Continuous Outcome Data in Absolute Terms for Use in Patient Treatment Decision Aids: A Validation Study

BACKGROUND

Patient decision aids (PtDAs) supplement advice from health care professionals by communicating the absolute risk or benefit of treatment options (i.e., X/100). As such, PtDAs have been amenable to binary outcomes only. We aimed to develop and test the validity of the Conversion to Risk Estimates through Application of Normal Theory (CREATE) method for estimating absolute risk based on continuous outcome data.

METHODS

CREATE is designed to derive an estimate of the proportion of those who experience a clinically relevant degree of change (CRDoC). We used a 2-stage validation process using real and simulated change score data, respectively. First, using raw data from published intervention trials, we calculated the proportion of patients with a CRDoC and compared that with our CREATE-derived estimate using chi-square tests of association. Second, 200,000 simulated distributions of change scores were generated with widely varying distribution characteristics. Actual and CREATE-derived estimates were compared for each simulated distribution, and relative differences were summarized graphically.

RESULTS

The absolute difference between the estimated and actual CRDoC did not exceed 5% for any of the samples based on real data. Applying the CREATE method to 200,000 simulated scenarios demonstrated that the CREATE method should be avoided for outcomes where the underlying distribution can be reasonably assumed to have high levels of skew or kurtosis.

CONCLUSION

Our results suggest that standard statistical theory can be used to estimate continuous outcomes in absolute terms with reasonable accuracy for use in PtDAs; caution is advised if outcome summary statistics are assumed to have been derived from highly skewed distributions.

The Effect of Mobile App Follow-up Care on the Number of In-person Visits Following Ambulatory Surgery: A Randomized Control Trial

Women's College Hospital (WCH) in Toronto offers specialized ambulatory surgical procedures. A feasibility study using a mobile appliciation (app) to supplement in-person follow-up care after surgery suggests that the mobile app adequately detects postoperative complications, eliminates the need for in-person follow-up care and is cost-effective. This is concordant with other postoperative telemedicine studies. The purpose of this study is to determine if we can avert in-person follow-up care through the use of mobile app compared to conventional, in-person follow-up care in the first month following surgery amongst breast reconstruction patients at WCH. This will be a pragmatic, single-centre, open, controlled, 2-arm parallel-group superiority randomized trial. Mobile app follow-up care is a novel approach to managing patients postoperatively with the potential to avert in-person follow-up and generate cost-savings for the healthcare system and patient.

Development of a patient decision aid for people with refractory angina: protocol for a three-phase pilot study

Background

Refractory angina is a severe chronic disease, defined as angina which cannot be controlled by usual treatments for heart disease. This disease is frightening, debilitating, and difficult to manage. Many people suffering refractory have inadequate pain relief, continually revisit emergency departments for help, undergo repeated cardiac investigations, and struggle with obtaining appropriate care. There is no clear framework to help people understand the risks and benefits of available treatment options in Canada. Some treatments for refractory angina are invasive, while others are not covered by provincial health insurance plans. Effective care for refractory angina sufferers in Canada is critically underdeveloped; it is important that healthcare professionals and refractory angina sufferers alike understand the treatment options and their implications. This proposal builds on the recent Canadian practice guidelines for the management of refractory angina. We propose to develop a decision support tool in order to help people suffering from refractory angina make well-informed decisions about their healthcare and reduce their uncertainty about treatment options.

Methods

This project will be conducted in three phases: a) development of the support tool with input from clinical experts, the Canadian refractory angina guidelines, and people living with refractory angina, b) pilot testing of the usability of the tool, and c) formal preliminary evaluation of the effectiveness of the support tool to help people make informed decisions about treatment options.

Discussion

A decision support tool for refractory angina is needed and the available data suggest that by developing such a tool, we may be able to help refractory angina sufferers better understand their condition and the effectiveness of available treatment options (in their respective clinical settings) as well as their implications (e.g. risks vs. benefits). By virtue of this tool, we may also be able to facilitate identification and inclusion of patients’ values and preferences in the decision making process. This is particularly important as refractory angina is an intractable condition, necessitating that the selected course of treatment be lifelong. This study will yield a much needed patient decision aid for people living with refractory angina and pilot data to support a subsequent effectiveness study.

Costs of prenatal detection of congenital heart disease

Little information is available about the transportation costs incurred from the missed prenatal diagnosis of congenital heart disease (CHD). The objectives of the present study were to analyze the costs of emergency transportation related to the postnatal diagnosis of major CHD and to perform a cost/benefit analysis of additional training for ultrasound technicians to study the implications of improved prenatal detection rates. The 1-year costs incurred for emergency transportation of pre- and postnatally diagnosed infants with CHD in Northern California and North Western Nevada were calculated and compared. The prenatal detection rate in our cohort (n = 147) was 30.6%. Infants postnatally diagnosed were 16.5 times more likely (p <0.001) to require emergency transport. The associated emergency transportation costs were US$542,143 in total for all patients with CHD. The mean cost per patient was $389.00 versus $5,143.51 for prenatally and postnatally diagnosed infants, respectively (p <0.001). Assuming an improvement in detection rates after 1-day training for ultrasound technicians, the investment in training cost can be recouped in 1 year if the detection rate increased by 2.4% to 33%. Savings of $6,543,476 would occur within 5 years if the detection rate increased to 50%. In conclusion, CHD diagnosed postnatally results in greater costs related to emergency transportation of ill infants. Improving the prenatal detection rates through improved ultrasound technician training could result in considerable cost savings.

Improving the management of waiting lists for long term care

Initially prepared for the South East Local Health Integration Network in Ontario, this literature review focuses on interventions to improve the management of waiting lists for admission to long-term care facilities. The review identified studies relating to four types of interventions: (1) different models for prioritizing patients, (2) ways to improve the accuracy of waiting lists, (3) the use of alternative care settings, and (4) altering the level of home care.

Randomized controlled trial of a psychoeducation program for the self-management of chronic cardiac pain

Cardiac pain arising from chronic stable angina (CSA) is a cardinal symptom of coronary artery disease and has a major negative impact on health-related quality of life (HRQL), including pain, poor general health status, and inability to self-manage. Current secondary prevention approaches lack adequate scope to address CSA as a multidimensional ischemic and persistent pain problem. This trial evaluated the impact of a low-cost six-week angina psychoeducation program, entitled The Chronic Angina Self-Management Program (CASMP), on HRQL, self-efficacy, and resourcefulness to self-manage anginal pain. One hundred thirty participants were randomized to the CASMP or three-month wait-list usual care; 117 completed the study. Measures were taken at baseline and three months. General HRQL was measured using the Medical Outcomes Study 36-Item Short Form and the disease-specific Seattle Angina Questionnaire (SAQ). Self-efficacy and resourcefulness were measured using the Self-Efficacy Scale and the Self-Control Schedule, respectively. The mean age of participants was 68 years, 80% were male. Analysis of variance of change scores yielded significant improvements in treatment group physical functioning [F=11.75(1,114), P<0.001] and general health [F=10.94(1,114), P=0.001] aspects of generic HRQL. Angina frequency [F=5.57(1,115), P=0.02], angina stability [F=7.37(1,115), P=0.001], and self-efficacy to manage disease [F=8.45(1,115), P=0.004] were also significantly improved at three months. The CASMP did not impact resourcefulness. These data indicate that the CASMP was effective for improving physical functioning, general health, anginal pain symptoms, and self-efficacy to manage pain at three months and provide a basis for long-term evaluation of the program.

``Not Everyone Who Needs One Is Going to Get One'': The Influence of Medical Brokering on Patient Candidacy for Total Joint Arthroplasty

Background. Many patients in Ontario, despite being appropriate candidates for total joint arthroplasty (TJA), are not offered surgery. To understand this discrepancy, the authors sought to explore the process by which physicians determine patient candidacy for TJA. Methods. Six focus groups (2 each of orthopedic surgeons, of rheumatologists, and of family physicians) and subsequent in-depth interviews were conducted with 50 practicing clinicians in Ontario. Results. Health care system constraints, including extensive waiting lists, lack of homecare and postoperative support, and, for surgeons, access to operating rooms and resources, are perceived by physicians to routinely influence the ultimate choice of candidates for TJA. Medical brokering, defined as strategies used by physicians in a constrained health system to prioritize patients and to negotiate relationships with other physicians, was an important factor in determining candidacy for TJA. Because individual physicians and surgeons appear to use their own criteria for making these decisions, and because these criteria are modified from time to time in response to specific institutional and system conditions, brokering results in varied decisions about candidacy regardless of patient suitability. Conclusions. Lack of consensus on the necessary patient characteristics for TJA candidacy does not in and of itself account for the discrepancy between the number of patients who are suitable candidates for TJA and those who receive the procedure. Until the process by which health care system constraints affect and complicate the decision-making process around TJA candidacy is more fully explored, patients may not receive appropriate and timely access to this procedure.

Economics of home vs. hospital breastfeeding support for newborns

AIM

This paper presents the findings of research comparing the incremental costs associated with the provision of home-based vs. hospital-based support for breastfeeding by nurse lactation consultants for term and near-term neonates during the first week of life.

BACKGROUND

A consequence of both consumer demands and increasing health resource constraints is that alternative care delivery models for safe, efficacious and cost-effective breastfeeding programmes have steadily evolved. To date, the economic impact of the setting (home or hospital) where lactation support is delivered has received little research attention.

METHODS

Mother-infant dyads were stratified by gestational age as term (>37 weeks gestational age; n = 101) or near term (35-37 weeks gestational age; n = 37) and randomized to standard hospital care and postpartum follow-up (standard care), or to standard hospital care plus home support from certified nurse lactation consultants (experimental). Data collection occurred at study entry, hospital discharge and at a seventh day postpartum follow-up session. Costs to the family (out-of-pocket and time costs) and to the healthcare system (during hospitalization and after hospital discharge) were measured. Total societal costs were defined as the sum of both family and healthcare system costs.

RESULTS

Compared with standard hospital-based care, home support by nurse lactation consultants showed no statistically significant differences in either time costs to the family or total societal costs. Term infants who received home support had statistically significantly greater postdischarge system costs (P < 0.0001), with a trend towards lower out-of-pocket expenses to their families (P = 0.12). There were no statistically significant differences between the two groups in overall combined family and healthcare system costs.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that the cost of home lactation support programmes were comparable with the costs of hospital-based standard care. Breastfeeding support at home by lactation consultants should be considered as an option as it was no more costly than support from lactation consultants in the hospital setting. The findings for near-term infants need to be interpreted with caution, given the small sample size.

Flexible client-driven in-home case management: an option to consider

Changes in health services and care needs have created high demand for case management of in-home services. To address this challenge, several models of case management have been used. Evaluations to date suggest that clients need different approaches for different circumstances at different times to optimize cost-effectiveness. Accordingly, one Canadian home care program adopted flexible client-driven case management engaging clients as partners in flexibly selecting either an integrated team, consumer-managed or brokerage model of case management in keeping with their preferences and abilities. Using an exploratory, multimeasure quasi-experimental design, a generic model of program evaluation, and both quantitative and qualitative methods, researchers identified challenges in implementing this intervention, policy impediments the clients characteristically in each of the three case management models, and client, provider, and caregiver outcomes of flexible, client-driven care. While further longitudinal investigation is needed findings suggest several important considerations for those interested in this option for care management. Alternative case management models do attract different client groups, and having a choice does not alter care costs or outcomes. Flexible client-driven case management may be experienced positively by case managers and other providers.

Treatments for paediatric femoral fractures: a randomised trial

BACKGROUND

Treatments for femoral fractures in children vary widely and have been investigated only in case series. We did a multicentre randomised trial to compare malunion rates after external fixation and after early application of a hip spica cast for paediatric femoral shaft fractures.

METHODS

All children aged 4-10 years with femoral fractures, admitted to four paediatric hospitals, were randomly assigned early application of hip spica or external fixation. The primary outcome was malunion at 2 years after the fracture. Secondary outcomes were scores on the RAND physical function child health questionnaire and the post-hospitalisation behavioural questionnaire, and parents' and children's ratings of overall satisfaction with treatment. Analysis was by intention to treat based on children who reached the 2 year evaluation.

FINDINGS

Of 60 children assigned to the hip-spica group, 56 reached the 2-year assessment; of them, six (11%) required other forms of treatment because of unacceptable loss of reduction. Of 48 children assigned external fixation, 45 reached the 2-year assessment; two (4%) had refractures and five (11%) required operative adjustment of the fixator. The rate of malunion was significantly higher in the hip-spica group than in the external-fixator group (25/56 [45%] vs 7/45 [16%]; 95% CI for difference 12-46%; p=0.002). The two groups had similar mean scores for the RAND physical function health questionnaire (0.34 vs 0.45; 95% CI for difference, -0.57 to 0.34; p=0.61), for the post-hospitalisation questionnaire (106.8 vs 106.3; -4.9 to 5.9; p=0.86), and for parents' satisfaction (4.3 vs 4.2; -0.3 to 0.6; p=0.5) and children's ratings of happiness with treatment (6.9 vs 7.7; -2.2 to 0.5; p=0.21).

INTERPRETATION

Early application of hip spica has a small role in the treatment of paediatric femoral fractures. Future trials need to compare external fixation with flexible intramedullary nails.

Registered nurses' experiences with an evidence-based home care pathway for myocardial infarction clients

OBJECTIVES

To obtain home health nurses' comments on an evidence-based care pathway for post myocardial infarction.

DESIGN

A qualitative design was used.

SETTING

Culturally diverse, lower income area of a large city.

PARTICIPANTS

All home health nurses from one nursing agency who participated in a comparative study on the impact of the evidence-based care pathway.

RESULTS

The largest number of comments made by the nurses were related to the beneficial impact of the pathway on the provision of quality nursing care and on increased job satisfaction. The home health nurses reported that the pathway increased clients' knowledge of medications and diet. In addition, they commented that they were able to use the pathway effectively because of the training they received from the inpatient cardiac nurses.

CONCLUSIONS

This qualitative study demonstrates the benefits of investing in the implementation of best practice guidelines by home health nurses. However, nursing associations, such as the Canadian Community Health Nurses Initiatives Group, will need to continue to champion for additional funds to support the additional expenses incurred.

Referral of children with otitis media. Do family physicians and pediatricians agree?

OBJECTIVE

To determine factors influencing family physicians' and pediatricians' decisions to refer children with recurrent acute otitis media (RAOM) and otitis media with effusion (OME) to otolaryngologists for an opinion about tympanostomy tube insertion.

DESIGN

Mailed survey.

SETTING

Physicians' practices in Ontario.

PARTICIPANTS

Random sample of 1459 family physicians and all 775 pediatricians in the province.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Physicians' reports of the influence of 17 factors on decisions to refer (more likely, no influence, less likely to refer) and number of episodes of otitis media, months with effusion, level of hearing loss, or months of continuous antibiotics without improvement prompting referral.

RESULTS

Physicians agreed (> 80% concordance) on six out of 17 factors as indications for referring children with RAOM or OME. Opinions about the importance of other factors varied widely. Family physicians would refer children with otitis media after fewer episodes of illness, fewer months of effusion, lower levels of hearing loss, and fewer months of prophylactic antibiotic therapy than pediatricians (all P < .001). Pediatricians would prescribe continuous antibiotics longer (11.8 weeks) than family physicians (8.9 weeks, P < .0001), which correlated with lower referral thresholds for family physicians.

CONCLUSION

Family physicians' and pediatricians' self-reported referral practices for surgical opinions on children with otitis media varied considerably. These observations raise questions about the consistency of care for children with otitis media and whether revised clinical guidelines would be helpful.

Health-related quality of life after knee replacement

A cross-sectional, community-based survey of a random sample of 1750 of 242,311 Medicare recipients was performed. The patients were at least sixty-five years old and had had a primary or revision knee replacement (either unilaterally or bilaterally) between 1985 and 1989. Three samples were surveyed separately: a national sample (to reflect the United States as a whole) and samples from Indiana and the western part of Pennsylvania (sites chosen for convenience to assess the validity of the findings for the national sample on a regional level). Each sample was stratified by race, age, residence (urban or rural), and the year of the procedure. Valid and reliable questionnaires were used to elicit the participants' assessments of pain, physical function, and satisfaction two to seven years after the knee replacement. Of the 1486 patients who were eligible for inclusion in the survey, 1193 (80.3 per cent) responded. The mean age of the respondents was 72.6 years. Eight hundred and forty-nine respondents (71.2 per cent) were white, and 849 (71.2 per cent) were women. The participants reported that they had little or no pain in the knee at the time of the survey, regardless of the age at the time of the knee replacement, the body-mass index, or the length of time since the knee replacement. After adjustment for potential confounding variables, predictors of better physical function after the replacement were an absence of problems with the contralateral knee, primary knee replacement (rather than revision) (Indiana sample only), and a lower body-mass index (Indiana and western Pennsylvania samples). Four hundred and fifteen (85.2 per cent) of the 487 patients in the national sample were satisfied with the result of the knee replacement. In what we believe to be the first community-based study of the outcome of knee replacement, patients reported having significant (p = 0.0001) and persistent relief of pain, improved physical function, and satisfaction with the result two to seven years postoperatively. The findings of the present study suggest that age and obesity do not have a negative impact on patient-relevant outcomes (pain and physical function). Dissemination of these findings has the potential to increase appropriate referrals for knee replacement and thereby reduce the pain and functional disability due to osteoarthrosis of the knee.

The relationship between variations in knee replacement utilization rates and the reported prevalence of arthritis in Ontario, Canada

OBJECTIVE

To determine the relationship between regional variations in knee replacement (KR) utilization rates in Ontario, Canada, and the reported prevalence of arthritis and rheumatism as a chronic health problem.

METHODS

Utilization data were acquired from the Canadian Institute for Health Information for KR procedures performed in Ontario between fiscal years 1984 and 1990. Census information was obtained from Statistics Canada. Disease prevalence data were derived from the 1990 Ontario Health Survey (OHS). Public Health Units (PHU) were used as the unit of analysis, with utilization rates defined as the number of KR performed on all PHU residents (irrespective of where these procedures were performed) divided by the population. Direct methods were used to standardize utilization for age, sex, and disease prevalence. The extremal quotient, the weighted coefficient of variation, and the systematic component of variation were used as measures of variation. The relationship between the number of KR performed in each age-sex-year strata and various demographic (age and sex), disease prevalence, and regional dummy variables was estimated using a Poisson regression model.

RESULTS

Regional variation in the standardized utilization of KR surgery was wide, but declined over the study period; the extremal quotient fell from 8.0 to 3.3, the weighted coefficient of variation fell from 0.49 to 0.30, and the systematic component of variation fell from 0.20 to 0.17. Variation in the provision of KR surgery remained even after controlling for the demographic composition of the population and disease prevalence. Moreover, while demographic, regional, and temporal covariates were significant (p < 0.0001) in accounting for over 90% of the variation in utilization, disease prevalence was not significant (p > 0.05).

CONCLUSION

This study merged population based reports of disease prevalence with administrative data to account for regional variations in utilization. While regional variations in KR surgery have fallen over time, variations remain even after adjusting for patient reported disease prevalence. The finding that demographic variables and the reported prevalence of disease were poorly correlated suggests that current area variation studies may not be adjusting fully for disease prevalence or severity.

Economic impact of cardiovascular disease in Canada

OBJECTIVE

To estimate the total cost of cardiovascular disease in Canada.

DESIGN

Prevalence-based study estimating disease-related costs generated by individuals with cardiovascular disease in 1994, from a societal viewpoint. The human capital approach was used to estimate the value of lost productivity due to illness.

SETTING

Canada.

OUTCOME MEASURES

First, direct costs, in terms of expenditures on hospital care, other institutions, physician services, other health professionals, drugs, research and other items; and second, indirect costs, in terms of lost productivity due to premature mortality or disability.

MAIN RESULTS

The total cost of cardiovascular disease was $18.0 billion in 1994, with direct and indirect cost components at $10.4 and $7.6 billion, respectively. Based on the sensitivity analysis, the lower and upper bounds were $14.1 and $20.4 billion, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

This study highlights the scope and magnitude of cardiovascular disease through its economic consequences. While the figures calculated herein do not give an indication of the appropriateness of current health expenditures on cardiovascular disease, they provide guidance in the setting of national priorities for research and prevention activities.

Demographic variation in the rate of knee replacement: a multi-year analysis

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study is to describe the practice variation of knee replacements (KRs) in the elderly ( > or = 65) over time from 1985-1990 in terms of the number of primary, bilateral, and revision KRs; the extent of large area variation in performance rates; and the degree to which demographic variables are the determinants of area rates.

DATA SOURCES/STUDY SETTING

Data analyzed are from every hospital in the United States that performed a KR on a Medicare patient during the study period. Data were obtained from the MEDPAR, HISKEW, and denominator files of the Medicare Statistical System.

STUDY DESIGN

This is a cohort study of all Medicare beneficiaries who received a KR between 1985 and 1990. The dependent variable in the analyses was the count of the KRs performed in each area.

DATA COLLECTION/EXTRACTION METHODS

This is a population-based sample of Medicare enrollees in the United States. All hospitalizations for Medicare-reimbursed KRs were included in the initial data set. Exclusion criteria were used to identify the Medicare covered population with a definite KR. These criteria resulted in 7.3 percent exclusions and a final set of 414,079 KR hospitalizations.

PRINCIPAL FINDINGS

The number of Medicare-funded KRs increased in each of the study years corresponding to an annual rate of increase of 18.45 percent. The likelihood of receiving a KR was a function of age, gender, and race. For each year, KRs were almost-twice as likely to be performed on women than on men. The odds of whites getting the surgery were over 1.5 times greater than for blacks. Even after adjusting for demographic factors, significant regional variation remained.

CONCLUSIONS

Much about area variation and the rate of growth in KR rates remains unexplained. For answers to emerge, better data and different types of studies are required.

Rates of tibial osteotomies in Canada and the United States

This study determined the temporal trends and factors associated with the rates of performance of tibial osteotomies from 1985 to 1990 in Ontario, Canada and the United States. The Health Care Financing Administration, Ontario Health Insurance Plan, and National Hospital Discharge Survey databases were used to determine the number of osteotomies from 1985 to 1990. Osteotomy rates decreased in both countries approximately by 11% to 14% per year in patients 65 years and older and by 3% to 4% per year in patients younger than 65 years. Men received twice as many osteotomies as women in both countries. In the United States, the average rate of tibial osteotomies was 2 to 3 times lower than in Ontario.

Comparison of a generic and a disease-specific measure of pain and physical function after knee replacement surgery

Generic and disease-specific health status instruments are commonly used to assess patients' outcomes. The hypothesis that they measure distinct but complementary aspects of patients' quality of life was tested using a sample of patients aged 67 to 99 years who had undergone knee replacement surgery 2 to 7 years previously. Patients' scores on a generic health-related quality-of-life (HRQOL) measure, the SF-36, were compared to those of the Western Ontario and McMaster Universities (WOMAC) Osteoarthritis Index; the WOMAC was developed specifically for patients with lower extremity arthritis, whereas the SF-36 is aimed at all conditions. A stratified sample of 1,750 Medicare beneficiaries was surveyed and an overall response rate of 80.3% achieved, resulting in 1,193 usable surveys (after adjustment for ineligible, incapacitated, and deceased individuals). The distribution of scores on the three dimensions common to both instruments (i.e., pain, physical function, and overall score) showed consistently higher scores on the WOMAC, on a scale of 0 (worst) to 100 (best), than on the SF-36, indicating less disability from arthritis than from other conditions after knee surgery in this elderly population. Statistically significant differences in the number of people with perfectly healthy scores were detected between the instruments; with regard to pain, 32.2% of the sample reported no pain due to arthritis on the WOMAC, compared with only 13.6% reporting no pain due to any conditions on the SF-36. The figures for physical function and overall score were 9.6% versus 1.4%, and 6.9% versus 0.2%, respectively. Examination for discriminant validity showed that the scores on the two scales followed hypothesized patterns: the WOMAC discriminated better among subjects with varying severity of knee problems, whereas the SF-36 discriminated better among subjects with varying levels of self-reported health status and comorbidity. The results of this study support the inclusion of both a generic and a disease-specific HRQOL measure to assess patient outcomes fully.

Variation in orthopedic surgeons' perceptions of the indications for and outcomes of knee replacement

OBJECTIVE

To determine the agreement among orthopedic surgeons' indications for knee replacement, their perceptions of the usefulness of various treatments for osteoarthritis of the knee and their expected outcomes of knee replacement, and to determine the relation between these opinions and the number of knee replacement procedures performed by individual surgeons.

DESIGN

Survey.

SETTING

Ontario.

PARTICIPANTS

All 392 orthopedic surgeons in the province. Of the 325 practising traceable surgeons 234 (72.0%) responded.

OUTCOME MEASURES

Indications for knee replacement, perceived usefulness of treatments for osteoarthritis, perceived outcomes of knee replacement and number of knee replacement procedures performed by individual surgeons.

RESULTS

The respondents disagreed on how 20 of 34 patient characteristics affected their decision to perform knee replacement surgery. They also disagreed on the usefulness of seven of eight treatments for arthritis of the knee. The respondents demonstrated variation in their expected outcomes of knee replacement. The surgeons who performed more procedures judged, on average, the outcomes to be better and to have fewer complications than the surgeons who performed fewer procedures.

CONCLUSIONS

Orthopedic surgeons demonstrated disagreement about some of the indications for knee replacement, the usefulness of treatments for arthritis of the knee and the perceived outcomes of knee replacement. The areas of greatest disagreement should be the focus of future research and the development of practice guidelines.