Use of the pour plate technique in tuberculocidal efficacy testing according to EN 14348 - a comparative study

Effective disinfection strategies are essential to prevent the spread of Mycobacterium tuberculosis. Tuberculocidal efficacy of disinfectants can be demonstrated by testing disinfectants in in-vitro tests, such as the well-established quantitative suspension test EN 14348 using Mycobacterium terrae as a surrogate organism in European disinfectant testing. In other European standard tests, such as EN 13727 and EN 13624, use of the pour plate technique is well established; however, in EN 14348, the spread plate technique alone is considered. Comparative experiments according to EN 14348 with M. terrae were conducted using a peracetic-acid-based disinfectant. Either the pour plate technique or the spread plate technique was used for cultivation. Differences in colony size and morphology were observed when comparing the growth of M. terrae on pour plates compared with spread plates. However, no significant differences in biocidal efficacy data were obtained when applying either spread plates or pour plates in the quantitative suspension test described in EN 14348 under both clean and dirty conditions.

Investigation of the susceptibility of Candida auris and Candida albicans to chemical disinfectants using European Standards EN 13624 and EN 16615

BACKGROUND

Since the first appearance of Candida auris in 2009, this yeast has become a relevant pathogen in the clinical field. C. auris has been detected on various surfaces in health facilities, and is therefore a target for appropriate disinfection procedures. Preventive measures have to be implemented based on disinfectants with proven efficacy against C. auris.

AIM

The chemical tolerance of C. auris was compared with the surrogate test organism Candida albicans as established in the European standards (EN). In this way, conclusions will be drawn as to whether the disinfectants tested according to EN 13624 and EN 16615 are at least equally effective against C. auris.

METHODS

The chemical susceptibility of C. auris and C. albicans was investigated using standardized EN test protocols. EN 13624 and EN 16615 were used in this study to examine two commercially available surface disinfectants based on alcohol and quaternary ammonium compounds (QACs), respectively. In addition, the survival rates of the two yeast species were studied on a defined test surface simulating practical conditions.

FINDINGS

In comparison with C. albicans, C. auris was found to be significantly more susceptible to the alcohol- and QAC-based disinfectants used in this study. C. albicans was found to be more tolerant to drying on the test surface in EN 16615, yielding higher recovery rates.

CONCLUSION

C. albicans is a suitable surrogate test organism when targeting yeasticidal efficacy, which, based on EN 13624 and EN 16615, includes efficacy against the human pathogen C. auris.